Binding of non-intercalating antibiotics to B-DNA: a theoretical study taking into account nucleic acid flexibility

A detailed theoretical study has been made for five antibiotics which all bind selectively to AT sequences in the minor groove of B-DNA: SN-18071, NSC-101327, distamycin-2, distamycin-3 and netropsin. The optimal complexes were found for systems in which the flexibility of DNA, as well as that of the antibiotics, was taken into account. Explicit, mobile counterions and a dielectric function modelling aqueous solution were also included. The binding geometries of the most strongly interacting antibiotics, distamycin-3 and netropsin, are compared in considerable detail and it is shown that notable differences exist between them. The results for netropsin are also discussed in the light of recent disagreements concerning its exact binding location within DNA.     

The solvation contribution to the binding energy of DNA with non-intercalating antibiotics.

The influence of the solvent on the binding energies to DNA of six non-intercalating antibiotics - netropsin, distamycin-3, distamycin-2, SN 18071, berenil and stilbamidine - is evaluated by combining the effect of the first hydration shell with that of bulk water. The first effect is computed by a methodology based on a spherical/point dipole model of water and limited to electrostatic interaction energies. Hydration shells are obtained which are energy optimized with respect to both water-solute and water-water interactions for the complexes and for the isolated DNA oligomers and ligands. The method allows even very large complexes to be studied in reasonable computation times. The second effect is introduced via a cavity treatment. It is shown that if the vacuum interaction energies already predict correctly the preference of the ligands for the minor groove of AT sequences of B-DNA, the introduction of the solvation effect is indispensable for reproducing the order of affinity of the ligands and for bringing the values of the complexation energies into close agreement with experimental data.     

Specific interaction of netropsin, distamycin-3 and analogs with LC duplexes: reversion towards the B form of the 2''-deoxy-.2''-deoxy-2''-fluoro-hybrid duplexes upon specific interaction with netropsin, distamycin-3 and analogs.

Binding of the B-form specific ligands netropsin and distamycin-3, -4 and -5 has been used to monitor the presence and/or the inducibility of a B-type structure in various poly-inosinic.poly-cytidilic double stranded polymers with deoxyribose, ribose or 2'-deoxy-2'-fluororibose as sugar on either strand. The efficiency of binding was followed by circular dichroism and further evaluated by the increase in melting temperature of the complexes. The efficient binding of netropsin and distamycins to the hybrid polymer (dIfl)n. (dC)n demonstrated that the fluorine carrying strand may undergo a A to B-type transition reflecting a change of the 2'-deoxy-2'-fluororibose from the 3'-endo to the 1'-exo or 2'-endo pucker. The less efficient binding of the same ligands to the reverse hybrid (dI)n.(dCfl)n showed that the geometry of the pyrimidine strand is the most critical for the specific interaction. Taking into account the recent findings about the regular hydration in the minor groove of the B-type dodecamer dCGCGAATTCGCG in solid-state, the different binding modes observed between the different polymers and antibiotics are explained by differences in their possibilities of hydration. Binding of netropsin to a double stranded deoxypolymer is interpreted as a local replacement of water molecules by netropsin in the minor groove hydration network which is typical of the B-form.     

Binding of Nonintercalative Antitumor Drugs to DNA-Polymers: Structural Effects of Bisquaternary Ammonium Heterocycles

Abstract

The binding of the antitumor agents SN-16814 nd SN-13232 to various DNA's in solution was monitored by CD and UV absorption measurements. In addition comparative studies with dA · dT containing duplex DNA of the related ligands SN-6136 and SN-6324 were included with respect to effects of structural variations. In general all four ligands show a dA · dT preference in their binding affinity to DNA.

Differences were observed for the reaction of SN-16814 which contains bicyclic ring system: it has a lower base pair selectivity, shows some affinity to poly(dG-dC) · poly(dG-dC), poly(rA) · poly(rU) and poly(rU). The binding mechanism of SN-16814 is associated with a significant time dependent binding effect in CD spectra and UV absorption in case of reaction with poly(dA) · poly(dT) and poly(dI) · poly(dC) indicating a slow kinetics.

The preferred binding to dA · dT base pairs in DNA decreases in the order from SN-61367 > SN-13232 > SN-6324, SN-16814 as judged from CD titration studies, salt dissociation and melting temperature data. Competitive binding experiments with netropsin (Nt) or distamycin-5 revealed that SN-16814 and SN-13232 are displaced from poly(dA-dT) · poly(dA-dT) suggesting that both ligands are less strongly bound than Nt and Dst-5 within the minor groove of B-DNA. These studies are consistent with results of the DNAase I cleavage of poly(dA-dT) · poly(dA-dT) which show the same relative order of inhibition of the cleavage reaction due to ligand binding. The results suggest that the variability of the DNAbinding and dA · dT sequence specificity may reside in the adaptability of benzamide-type ligands in the helical groove which is influenced by distinct structural modifications of the ligand conformation.     

Accessibility of the minor groove of DNA in chromatin to the binding of antibiotics netropsin and distamycin A

The interaction of the antibiotics distamycin A, distamycin analogue and netropsin with chromatin of calf thymus has been studied by circular dichroism measurements and by gel filtration. The minor groove of DNA in chromatin is accessible by 83–89% to the binding of these antibiotics as compared with that of free DNA. The present results combined with our data on the methylation of chromatin with dimethylsulphate [3] strongly suggest that the minor groove of DNA in chromatin is not occupied by chromatin proteins.Abbreviations DM distamycin A - DM₂ analogue of distamycin - Nt netropsin - CD spectra circular dichroism spectra     

Two Binding Modes of Netropsin are Involved in the Complex Formation with Poly(dA-dT)·Poly(dA-dT) and other Alternating DNA Duplex Polymers

Abstract

Using CD measurements we show that the interaction of netropsin to poly(dA-dT)·poly(dA-dT) involves two binding modes at low ionic strength. The first and second binding modes are distinguished by a defined shift of the CD maximum and the presence of characteristic isodichroic points in the long wavelength range from 313 nm to 325 nm. The first binding mode is independent of ionic strength and is primarily determined by specific interaction to dA·dT base pairs. Employing a netropsin derivative and different salt conditions it is demonstrated that ionic contacts are essential for the second binding mode. Other alternating duplexes and natural DNA also exhibit more or less a second step in the interaction with netropsin observable at high ratio of ligand per nucleotide. The second binding mode is absent for poly(dA)·poly(dT). The presence of a two-step binding mechanism is also demonstrated in the complex formation of poly(dA-dT)·poly(dA-dT) with the distamycin analog consisting of pentamethylpyrrolecarboxamide. While the binding mode I of netropsin is identical with its localization in the minor groove, for binding mode II we consider two alternative interpretations.     

Identification and separation of components of calf thymus DNA using a CsCl-netropsin density gradient

Calf thymus DNA containing satellite components of various densities was used as a model to study the effect of netropsin on the density of DNA in a CsCl gradient. The binding of netropsin resulted in a decrease in density which depended upon the quantity of netropsin added and on the average composition of the DNA. Differences in density of DNA components were higher in CsCl - netropsin gradients than in simple CsCl gradients. By use of netropsin a main band and four satellite bands could be differentiated in calf thymus DNA. Satellite DNA's were isolated using preparative CsCl - netropsin gradient centrifugation and were characterised by density and homogeneity in native and in reassociated state. Two of the satellite components, with densities of 1.722 and 1.714 g/cm³, are probably of homogenous sequence, the other two components of densities 1.709 and 1.705 g/cm³ appear to be heterogeneous.     

Structure and Dynamics of Netropsin-Poly(dA-dT)· Poly(dA-dT) Complex: 500 MHz 1H NMR Studies

Abstract

Antibiotic netropsin is known to bind specifically to A and T regions in DNA; the mode of binding being non-intercalative. Obviously, H-bonding between the proton donors of netropsin and acceptors N3 of A and 02 of T comes as a strong possibility which might render this specificity. In netropsin there could be 8 proton donors: four terminal amino groups and four internal imino groups. However, methylation of the terminal amino groups does not alter the binding affinity of netropsin to DNA—but the modification of the internal imino groups significantly lowers the binding affinity. Hence, the logical conclusion is that netropsin may specifically interact with A and T through H-bonding and in order to do so, it should approach the helix from the minor groove. The present paper provides experimental data which verify the conclusion mentioned above.

Using poly(dA-dT)? poly(dA-dT) as a model system it was observed following a thorough theoretical stereochemical analysis that netropsin could bind to -(T-A-T) sequence of the polymer in the B-form through the minor groove by forming specific B-bonding. Models could be either right or left-handed B-DNA with a mono or dinucleotide repeat.

By monitoring the ³¹P signals of free poly(dA-dT) ? poly(dA-dT) and netropsin-poly(dA-dT)? poly(dA-dT) complex we show that the drug changes the DNA structure from essentially a mononucleotide repeat to that of very dominant dinucleotide repeat; however the base- pairing in the DNA-drug complex remain to be Watson-Crick. Whether H-bonding is the specific mode of interaction was judged by monitoring the imino protons of netropsin in the presence of poly(dA-dT) ? poly(dA-dT). This experiment was conducted in 90% H₂O + 10% D₂O Using the time-shared long pulse. It was found that exchangeable imino protons of netropsin appear in the drug-DNA complex and disappear upon increasing the D₂O content; thus confirming that H-bonding is indeed the specific mode of interaction. From these and several NOE measurements, we propose a structure for poly(dA-dT)? poly(dA-dT(-netropsin complex.

In summary, experimental data indicate that netropsin binds to poly(dA-dT)? poly(dA-dT) by forming specific hydrogen bonds and that the binding interaction causes the structure to adopt a Watson-Crick paired dinucleotide repeat motif. The proposed hydrogen bonds can form only if the drug approaches the DNA from the minor groove. Within the NMR time scale the interaction between the ligand and DNA is a fast one. From the NOE experimental data, it appears that poly(dA-dT)? poly(dA-dT) in presence of netropsin exists as an equilibrium mixture of right- and left-handed B-DNA duplexes with a dinucleotide repeat—with a predominance of the left-handed form. The last conclusion is a soft one because it was very difficult to make sure the absence of spin diffusion. In a 400 base pairs long DNA duplex- drug complex (as used in this study), equilibrium between right and left-handed helices can also mean the existence of both helical domains in the same molecule with fast interchange between these domains or/and unhindered motion/propagation of these domains along the helix axis.     

Binding of Bis-linked Netropsin Derivatives in the Parallel-Stranded Hairpin Form to DNA

Abstract

Cis-diammine Pt(II)- bridged bis-netropsin and oligomethylene-bridged bis-netropsin in which two monomers are linked in a tail-to-tail manner bind to the DNA oligomer with the sequence 5′-CCTATATCC-3′ in a parallel-stranded hairpin form with a stoichiometry 1:1. The difference circular dichroism (CD) spectra characteristic of binding of these ligands in the hairpin form are similar. They differ from CD patterns obtained for binding to the same duplex of another bis-netropsin in which two netropsin moieties were linked in a head-to-tail manner. This reflects the fact that tail-to-tail and head-to-tail bis-netropsins use parallel and antiparallel side-by-side motifs, respectively, for binding to DNA in the hairpin forms. The binding affinity of cis -diammine Pt(II)- bridged bis-netropsin in the hairpin form to DNA oligomers with nucleotide sequences 5′-CCTATATCC-3′ (I), 5′-CCTTAATCC-3′ (II), 5′-CCTTATTCC-3′ (III), 5′-CCTTTTTCC-3′ (IV) and 5′-CCAATTTCC-3′ (V) decreases in the order I = II > III > IV> V. The binding of oligomethylene-bridged bis-netropsin in the hairpin form follows a similar hierarchy. An opposite order of sequence preferences is observed for partially bonded monodentate binding mode of the synthetic ligand.     

Chain length-dependent association of distamycin-type oligopeptides with A·T and G·C pairs in polydeoxynucleotide duplexes

Different binding affinities of various distamycin analogs including the deformylated derivative with poly(dA-dC)·poly(dG-dT) were investigated using CD measurements. The inhibitory effect of distamycins on the DNAase I cleavage activity of DNA duplexes strongly supports the binding data. The base specificity of the ligand interaction with duplex DNA depends on the chain length of distamycin analogs. Netropsin, distamycin-2 and the deformylated distamycin-3 show no binding to dG·dC containing sequences at moderate ionic strength and are classified as highly dA·dT specific. In contrast distamycin having three, four or five methylpyrrolecarboxamide groups also forms more or less stable complexes with dG·dC-containing duplexes. These ligands possess a lower basepair specificity. The correlation between binding behavior and oligopeptide structure shows that presence of the number of hydrogen acceptor and donor sites determines the basepair and sequence specificity. The additional interaction with dG·dC pairs becomes essential when the number of hydrogen acceptor sites exceeds n = 3.     

An Unexpected Major Groove Binding of Netropsin and Distamycin A to tRNAphe

Abstract

Crystalline complexes of yeast tRNA^phe and the oligopeptide antibiotics netropsin and distamycin A were prepared by diffusing drugs into crystals of tRNA. X-ray structure analyses of these complexes reveal a single common binding site for both drugs which is located in the major or deep groove of the tRNA T-stem. The netropsin-tRNA complex is stabilized by specific hydrogen bonds between the amide groups of the drug and the tRNA bases G51 0(6), U52 0(4) and G53 N(7) on one strand, and is further stabilized by electrostatic interactions between the positively charges guanidino side chain of the drug and the tRNA phosphate P53 on the same strand and the positively charged amidino propyl side chain and the phosphates P61, P62 and P63 on the opposite strand of the double helix. These results are in contrast to the implicated minor groove binding of these drugs to non-guanine sequences in DNA. The binding to the GUG sequence in tRNA implies that major groove binding to certain DNA sequences is possible.     

Quantitative Footprinting Analysis of the Netropsin-DNA Interaction

Abstract

The results of a series of quantitative footprinting experiments of the netropsin-DNA interaction as studied using two different DNA cleaving probes, the enzyme DNase I and a cationic manganese porphyrin complex, are described. Plots of the relative change in oligonucleotide concentration as a function of drug concentration, covering ～ 110 base pairs of a DNA restriction fragment, revealed netropsin induced changes in the cleavage rates of both probes. These appeared as inhibitions for the binding sites, enhancements where no binding took place, and enhancement/inhibitions for the weak binding sites. Determination of the concentration of drug necessary to reduce the amount of a particular oligomer to half of its initial value allowed a ranking of the affinities of the various binding sites on the fragment. In addition to uncovering the location of a number of overlapping netropsin binding sites, the data allowed additional insight on the manner in which both probes alter their DNA cleavage rates in the drug-footprinting experiment.     

Interaction of lambda cro repressor with synthetic operator OR3 studied by competition binding with minor groove binders.

In the present work, we employ a combination of CD spectroscopy and gel retardation technique to characterize thermodynamically the binding of lambda phage cro repressor to a 17 base pair operator OR3. We have found that three minor groove-binding antibiotics, distamycin A, netropsin and sibiromycin, compete effectively with the cro for binding to the operator OR3. Among these antibiotics, sibiromycin binds covalently to DNA in the minor groove at the NH2 of guanine, whereas distamycin A and netropsin interact preferentially with runs of AT base pairs and avoid DNA regions containing guanine bases in the two polynucleotide strands. Only subtle DNA conformation changes are known to take place upon binding of these antibiotics. Both the CD spectral profiles and the results of the gel retardation experiments indicate that distamycin A and netropsin can displace cro repressor from the operator OR3. The binding of cro repressor to the OR3 is accompanied by considerable changes in CD in the far-UV region which appear to be attributed to a DNA-dependent structural transition in the protein. Spectral changes are also induced in the wavelength region of 270-290 nm. The CD spectral profile of the cro-OR3 mixture in the presence of distamycin A can be represented as a sum of the CD spectrum of the repressor-operator complex and spectrum of distamycin-DNA complex at the appropriate molar ratio of the bound antibiotic to the operator DNA (r). When r tends to the saturation level of binding the CD spectrum in the region of 270-360 nm approaches a CD pattern typical of complexes of the antibiotic with the free DNA oligomer. This suggests that simultaneous binding of cro repressor and distamycin A to the same DNA oligomer is not possible and that distamycin A and netropsin can be used to determine the equilibrium affinity constant of cro repressor to the synthetic operator from competition-type experiments. The binding constant of cro repressor to the OR3 is found to be (6 +/- 1).10(6)M-1 at 20 degrees C in 10 mM sodium cacodylate buffer (pH 7.0) in the presence of 0.1 M NH4F.     

Netropsin Specifically Recognizes One of the Two Conformationally Equivalent Strands of Poly (dA)·Poly (dT). One Dimensional NMR Study at 500 MHz Involving NOE Transfer Between Netropsin and DNA Protons

Abstract

Recent observations that the heteronomous structural model for poly(dA)·poly(dT) is not found in solution and that in this DNA, the two strands are conformationally equivalent (J. Biomole. Str. Dyns. 2, 1057 (1985)), has added a new dimension to the structural dynamics of DNA-netropsin complex. Does the antibiotic somehow distinguish between the two strands and specifically interact with only one of the conformationally equivalent strands?

Model-building studies suggest that netropsin can either bind to the dA-strand in the minor groove such that H-bonds are formed between the imino protons N4-H, N6-H, N8-H of netropsin and N3 atoms of A or can bind to the dT-strand in the minor groove and form H-bonds between the imino-protons N4-H, N6-H, N8-H of netropsin and O2 atoms of T. If netropsin binds to the dA-strand, AH2 atoms of poly(dA)-poly(dT) would be in closer proximity to the imino protrons N4-H, N6-H, N8-H and pyrrole ring protons C5-H, Cll-H of netropsin than they would be, if netropsin binds to the dT-strand. In order to distinguish these possibilities experiments were conducted which involved NOE energy transfer between netropsin and DNA protons in the drug-DNA complex. Difference NOE spectra of netropsin·poly(dA)-poly(dT) complex in which AH2 was irradiated indicate that dominant NOEs were observed at the imino and pyrrole ring protons of netropsin. When the netropsin pyrrole ring protons were irradiated, the magnetization transfer was at AH2 of DNA. These observations suggest that netropsin binds to the dA-strand of poly(dA)-poly(dT) even though dA/dT strands are conformationally equivalent.     

DNA Sequence-Specific Ligands: XI.* The Synthesis and Binding to DNA of bis-Netropsins with the C-Ends of Their Netropsin Fragments Tethered by Tetra- or Pentamethylene Linkers

Bis-Netropsins with the C-ends of their netropsin fragments tethered via tetra- or pentamethylene linkers and with Gly or L-Lys-Gly residues on their N-ends were synthesized. The footprinting technique was used to study the specificity of bis-netropsin binding to the specially constructed DNA fragments containing various clusters of A · T pairs. It was found that the linker length affects the binding of bis-netropsins, with the tetramethylene linker providing better protection than the pentamethylene linker. It was shown that the newly synthesized bis-netropsins bind tighter to the 5"-A ₄ T ₄-3" sequence, whereas the bis-netropsin with a linker between the netropsin N-ends binds better to 5"-T ₄ A ₄-3" sequences.     

Antibiotic induced electrophoretic mobility shifts of DNA restriction fragments.

Several antibiotics, netropsin, distamycin A, actinomycin D, Hoechst 33258 and olivomycin, which demonstrate base specificity in their DNA binding properties have been found to alter the electrophoretic mobility of DNA restriction fragments in native polyacrylamide gels. The antibiotics mostly reduced the migration of larger DNA fragments, but netropsin and Hoechst 33258 were observed to increase the migration rate of several DNA fragments of intermediate size. DNA fragments of similar molecular weight which comigrate as a single gel band can at times be separated as the result of differential mobility shifts promoted by antibiotic DNA complex formations.     

Influence of Drug Binding on DNA Flexibility: A Normal Mode Analysis

Abstract

DNA-drug complexes are important because of their pharmacological interest but, in addition, they provide a useful model to study the essential aspects of DNA recognition processes. In order to investigate the influence of ligand binding on the dynamic properties of DNA we have carried out normal mode analysis for complexes with drugs of two types: a typical intercalator, 9-aminoacridine, and a typical groove binder, netropsin. Normal modes are analysed in terms of helicoidal parameter variations with special attention being paid to global deformations of the double helix. The results show that the influence of these two drugs is very different. Intercalation of 9-aminoacridine leads to an increase in the flexibility of the intercalated dinucleotide step, with notably larger vibrational amplitudes for both roll and twist parameters compared to free DNA. In contrast, the groove binding of netropsin induces a stiffening of the DNA segment which is in contact with the drug reflected by decreased vibrational amplitudes for backbone angles and inter base pair helicoidal parameters and an increase in vibrations for adjacent base pairs in terms of buckle and propeller twist.     

Conformation dependent binding of netropsin and distamycin to DNA and DNA model polymers

The binding of the antibiotics netropsin and distamycin A to DNA has been studied by thermal melting, CD and sedimentation analysis. Netropsin binds strongly at antibiotic/nucleotide ratios up to at least 0.05. CD spectra obtained using DNA model polymers reveal that netropsin binds tightly to poly (dA) · poly (dT), poly (dA-dT) · poly(dA-dT) and poly (dI-dC) · poly (dI-dC) but poorly, if at all, to poly (dG) · poly (dC). Binding curves obtained with calf thymus DNA reveal one netropsin-binding site per 6.0 nucleotides (K_a=2.9 · 10⁵ M⁻¹); corresponding values for distamycin A are one site per 6.1 nucleotides with K_a= 11.6 · 10⁵ M⁻¹. Binding sites apparently involve predominantly A·T-rich sequences whose specific conformation determines their high affinity for the two antibiotics. It is suggested that the binding is stabilized primarily by hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions probably in the narrow groove of the DNA helix, but without intercalation. Any local structural deformation of the helix does not involve unwinding greater than approximately 3° per bound antibiotic molecule.     

Selective Binding of Synthetic Polypeptides to DNA of Varying Composition and Sequence: Effect of Minor Groove Binding Drugs

Abstract

Repetitive basic polypeptides containing lysine or arginine as every third amino acid were shown to cause DNA condensation at physiological salt concentration connected with selective DNA binding with respect to DNA composition and sequence. This selectivity is very similar to that existing in the case of histone H1 and other basic proteins and does not depend on polypeptide chain conformation. The effect of the minor groove binding drugs netropsin and distamycin was tested to elucidate the origin of the binding selectivity. The results suggest that the binding preferences are due to the variations in the conformation in various types of B-DNA that depend on DNA composition and sequence. The most important factor affecting the selectivity is probably the value of the negative electrostatic potential in the minor groove.     

Z-DNA and other non-B-DNA structures are reversed to B-DNA by interaction with netropsin

The interaction between the B-form specific ligands netropsin (Nt) and distamycin-3 (Dst-3) and DNA duplexes has been studied under conditions of salt concentration and low water activity that modify the polymer conformation into a non-B DNA form, putatively a Z-like form. Three polymers with strict alternating purine-pyrimidine sequences and GC content from 100-0% have been tested: poly(dG-dC) . poly(dG-dC), poly(dA-dC) . poly(dG-dT) and poly(dA-dT) . poly(dA-dT). The titrations by Nt and Dst-3 were followed by circular dichroism. Although specific binding of Nt to the Z-form of poly(dG-dC) . poly(dG-dC) does not occur, Nt reverses this Z structure to the B-type conformation; Dst-3 is, however, totally inefficient. The presumed non-B or Z-like structure of poly(dA-dC) . poly(dG-dT) is reversed to the B-form upon interaction with Nt; Dst-3 also induces this reversal but at higher ligand ratios. The modified B-structure of poly(dA-dT) . poly(dA-dT) in low water activity is efficiently reversed to the B-form by interaction with both Nt and Dst-3.