Interaction of the nonintercalative antitumour drugs SN-6999 and SN-18071 with DNA: influence of ligand structure on the binding specificity

Binding to DNA's of the non-intercalative ligands SN-6999 and SN-18071 has been studied by means of circular dichroism, UV absorption, thermal melting and for SN-6999 by viscosity measurements. Both antitumour drugs show a preference for dA.dT rich DNA's, but the base pair selectivity of SN-18071 is lower as indicated by some affinity to dG.dC containing duplex DNA. The dA.dT base pair specificity of SN-6999 is comparable to that of netropsin. It forms very stable complexes with dA.dT containing duplex DNA and competes with netropsin binding on DNA. The ligands SN-18071 and pentamidine are totally released from their complexes with poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) by competitive netropsin binding. The results demonstrate that hydrogen bonding capacity of the ligand in addition to other factors strongly contribute to the base sequence specificity in the recognition process of the ligand with DNA. A binding model of SN-6999 with five dA.dT pairs in the minor groove of B-DNA is suggested.     

Molecular Modelling Study of the Netropsin Complexation With a Nucleic Acid Triple Helix

Abstract

A detailed molecular mechanical study has been made on the complexes of netropsin with the double stranded oligonucleotide (dA)₁₂.(dT)₁₂ and with the triple helix (dA)₁₂.(dT)₁₂.(dT)₁₂. The complexes were built using computer graphics and energy refined using JUMNA program. In agreement with circular dichroïsm experiments we have shown that 3 netropsins can bind the minor grooves of the triple helix and of the double helix. The groove geometry in the duplex and in the triplex is very similar. However a detailed analysis of the energetic terms shows, in agreement with thermal denaturation studies, that the affinity of netropsin toward the double helices is larger than towards triple helices.     

Berenil Complexation with a Nucleic Acid Triple Helix

Abstract

The interaction of berenii molecule, a minor groove binding drug, with T-A-T triple helix and A-T double helix was studied using circular dichroism spectroscopy and thermal denaturation. The triple helix was made by an oligonucleotide (dA)₁₂?x-(dT)₁₂?x-(dT)₁₂, where x is a hexaethylene glycol chain bridged between the 3′ phosphate of one strand and the 5′ phosphate of the following strand. This oligonucleotide is able to fold back on itself to form a very stable triplex. Circular dichroism spectroscopy demonstrates that berenil can bind to the triple helical structure. Spectral analysis shows that in the same ionic strength the drug bound to a double-stranded structure exhibits a conformation and an environment close to those observed in triple-stranded structure. The influence of the ionic strength on the interaction between the berenil molecule and the 36-mer is clearly demonstrated. We showed that when no NaCl salt is added in the buffer the triplex form of (dA)₁₂?x-(dT)₁2-x-(dT)₁₂ is stabilized by berenil whereas it is destabilized slightly by the dye when NaCl concentration is 1 M.     

Binding of netropsin to a DNA triple helix.

The interaction of netropsin, a minor groove binding drug, with T-A-T triple helix and A-T double helix was studied using circular dichroism spectroscopy and thermal denaturation. The triple helix was made by an oligonucleotide (dA)12-x-(dT)12-x-(dT)12, where x is a hexaethylene glycol chain bridged between the 3' phosphate of one strand and the 5' phosphate of the following strand. This oligonucleotide is able to fold back on itself to form a very stable triplex. Changing the conditions allows the same oligonucleotide in a duplex form with a (dT)12 dangling arm. Circular dichroism spectroscopy demonstrates that netropsin can bind to the triple helical structure. Spectral analysis shows that the bound drug exhibits a conformation and an environment similar in double-stranded and in triple-stranded structure. However, the binding constant to the triple-stranded structure is found smaller than the binding constant to the double-stranded one. Thermal denaturation experiments demonstrate that netropsin destabilizes the triplex whereas it stabilizes the duplex.     

Binding of ethidium bromide to a DNA triple helix. Evidence for intercalation

The interaction of ethidium, a DNA intercalator, with the poly(dA).poly(dT) duplex and the poly (dA).2poly(dT) triplex has been investigated by a variety of spectrophotometric and hydrodynamic techniques. The fluorescence of ethidium is increased when either the duplex or triplex form is present. Binding constants, determined from absorbance measurements, indicate that binding to the triple helical form is substantially stronger than to the duplex, with a larger binding site size (2.8 base triplets compared to 2.4 base pairs). Furthermore, while binding to poly(dA).poly(dT) shows strong positive cooperativity, binding to the triplex is noncooperative. Thermal denaturation experiments demonstrate that ethidium stabilizes the triple helix. Binding to either form induces a weak circular dichroism band in the visible wavelength region, while in the region around 310 nm, there is a band that is strongly dependent on the degree of saturation of the duplex, and which is positive for the duplex but negative for the triplex. Both fluorescence energy transfer and quenching studies provide evidence of intercalation of ethidium in both duplex and triplex complexes. Binding of ethidium leads to an initial decrease in viscosity for both the duplex and triplex structures, followed by an increase, which is greater for the duplex. Taken together, these results strongly suggest that ethidium binds to the poly (dA).2poly(dT) triple helix via an intercalative mechanism.     

Binding of Nonintercalative Antitumor Drugs to DNA-Polymers: Structural Effects of Bisquaternary Ammonium Heterocycles

Abstract

The binding of the antitumor agents SN-16814 nd SN-13232 to various DNA's in solution was monitored by CD and UV absorption measurements. In addition comparative studies with dA · dT containing duplex DNA of the related ligands SN-6136 and SN-6324 were included with respect to effects of structural variations. In general all four ligands show a dA · dT preference in their binding affinity to DNA.

Differences were observed for the reaction of SN-16814 which contains bicyclic ring system: it has a lower base pair selectivity, shows some affinity to poly(dG-dC) · poly(dG-dC), poly(rA) · poly(rU) and poly(rU). The binding mechanism of SN-16814 is associated with a significant time dependent binding effect in CD spectra and UV absorption in case of reaction with poly(dA) · poly(dT) and poly(dI) · poly(dC) indicating a slow kinetics.

The preferred binding to dA · dT base pairs in DNA decreases in the order from SN-61367 > SN-13232 > SN-6324, SN-16814 as judged from CD titration studies, salt dissociation and melting temperature data. Competitive binding experiments with netropsin (Nt) or distamycin-5 revealed that SN-16814 and SN-13232 are displaced from poly(dA-dT) · poly(dA-dT) suggesting that both ligands are less strongly bound than Nt and Dst-5 within the minor groove of B-DNA. These studies are consistent with results of the DNAase I cleavage of poly(dA-dT) · poly(dA-dT) which show the same relative order of inhibition of the cleavage reaction due to ligand binding. The results suggest that the variability of the DNAbinding and dA · dT sequence specificity may reside in the adaptability of benzamide-type ligands in the helical groove which is influenced by distinct structural modifications of the ligand conformation.     

Binding of nonintercalative antitumor drugs to DNA-polymers: structural effects of bisquaternary ammonium heterocycles

The binding of the antitumor agents SN-16814 nd SN-13232 to various DNA's in solution was monitored by CD and UV absorption measurements. In addition comparative studies with dA.dT containing duplex DNA of the related ligands SN-6136 and SN-6324 were included with respect to effects of structural variations. In general all four ligands show a dA.dT preference in their binding affinity to DNA. Differences were observed for the reaction of SN-16814 which contains bicyclic ring system: it has a lower base pair selectivity, shows some affinity to poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC), poly(rA).poly(rU) and poly(rU). The binding mechanism of SN-16814 is associated with a significant time dependent binding effect in CD spectra and UV absorption in case of reaction with poly(dA).poly(dT) and poly(dI).poly(dC) indicating a slow kinetics. The preferred binding to dA.dT base pairs in DNA decreases in the order from SN-61367 greater than SN-13232 greater than SN-6324,SN-16814 as judged from CD titration studies, salt dissociation and melting temperature data. Competitive binding experiments with netropsin (Nt) or distamycin-5 revealed that SN-16814 and SN-13232 are displaced from poly(dA.dT).poly(dA-dT) suggesting that both ligands are less strongly bound than Nt and Dst-5 within the minor groove of B-DNA. These studies are consistent with results of the DNAse I cleavage of poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) which show the same relative order of inhibition of the cleavage reaction due to ligand binding. The results suggest that the variability of the DNA binding and dA.dT sequence specificity may reside in the adaptability of benzamide-type ligands in the helical groove which is influenced by distinct structural modifications of the ligand conformation.     

A physico-chemical study of triple helix formation by an oligodeoxythymidylate with N3'--> P5' phosphoramidate linkages.

Non-denaturing gel retardation assay, DNA melting experiments and FTIR spectroscopy were used to characterize the triple helix formed by a 15mer 2'-deoxythymidylate with N3'-->P5'phosphoramidate linkages with its target sequence. The results indicate that: (i) the pentadecadeoxythymidylate with phosphoramidate linkages [dT15(np)] is highly potent to form a triple helix with a dT15*dA15target duplex through Hoogsteenbase-pairing; (ii) it forms a dT15(np)*dA15xdT15(np) triplex with the single-stranded oligo-2'-deoxyadenylate (dA15) without detectable double-helical intermediate; (iii) it does not only form a triple helix on the dT15*dA15target duplex, but also partially displaces the dT15 strand from the dT15*dA15duplex to form a dT15(np)*dA15xdT15(np) complex.     

Investigation of DNA Binding Modes for a Symmetrical Cyanine Dye Trication: Effect of DNA Sequence and Structure

Abstract

The DNA binding behavior of a tricationic cyanine dye (DiSC₃₊(5)) was studied using the [Poly(dA-dT)]₂, [Poly(dI-dC)]₂ and Poly(dA)?Poly(dT) duplex sequences and the Poly(dA) ?2Poly(dT) triplex. Optical spectroscopy and viscometry results indicate that the dye binds to the triplex structure by intercalation, to the nonalternating Poly(dA)?Poly(dT) duplex through minor groove binding and to the alternating [Poly(dA-dT)]₂ duplex by a combination of two binding modes: intercalation at low concentration and dimerization within the minor groove at higher concentration. Dimerization occurs at lower dye concentrations for the [Poly(dI-dC)]₂ sequence, consistent with our previous investigations on an analogous monocationic cyanine dye. [Seifert, J.L., et al. (1999) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121, 2987–2995] These studies illustrate the diversity of DNA binding modes that are available to a given ligand structure.     

Investigation of DNA binding modes for a symmetrical cyanine dye trication: effect of DNA sequence and structure.

The DNA binding behavior of a tricationic cyanine dye (DiSC3+(5)) was studied using the [Poly(dA-dT)]2, [Poly(dI-dC)]2 and Poly(dA) x Poly(dT) duplex sequences and the Poly(dA) x 2Poly(dT) triplex. Optical spectroscopy and viscometry results indicate that the dye binds to the triplex structure by intercalation, to the nonalternating Poly(dA) x Poly(dT) duplex through minor groove binding and to the alternating [Poly(dA-dT)]2 duplex by a combination of two binding modes: intercalation at low concentration and dimerization within the minor groove at higher concentration. Dimerization occurs at lower dye concentrations for the [Poly(dI-dC)]2 sequence, consistent with our previous investigations on an analogous monocationic cyanine dye. [Seifert, J.L., et al. (1999) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121, 2987-2995] These studies illustrate the diversity of DNA binding modes that are available to a given ligand structure.     

Structure of Poly(dA)·Poly(dT) is not Identical to the AT Rich Regions of the Single Crystal Structure of CGCGAATTBrCGCG. The Consequence of this to Netropsin Binding to Poly(dA)·Poly(dT)

Abstract

The basic assumption of Dickerson and Kopka (J. Biomole. Str. Dyns. 2, 423, 1985) that the conformation of poly(dA)·poly(dT) in solution is identical to the AT rich region of the single crystal structure of the Dickerson dodecamer is not supported by any experimental data. In poly(dA)·poly(dT), NOE and Raman studies indicate that the dA and dT units are conformationally equivalent and display the (anti-S-type sugar)-conformation; incorporation of this nucleotide geometry into a double helix leads to a conventional regular B-helix in which the width of the minor groove is 8A. The derived structure is consistent with all available experimental data on poly(dA)·poly(dT) obtained under solution conditions. In the crystal structure of the dodecamer, the dA and dT units have distinctly different conformations—dA residues adopt (anti, S-type sugar pucker), while dT residues belong to (low anti, N-type sugar pucker). These different conformations of the dA and dT units along with the large propeller twist can be accommodated in a double helix in which the minor groove is shrunk from 8A to less than 4A. In the conventional right handed B-form of poly(dA)·poly(dT) with the 8A wide minor groove, netropsin has to bind asymmetrically along the dA strand to account for the NOE and chemical shift data and to generate a stereochemically sound structure (Sarma et al, J. Biomole. Str. Dyns. 2, 1085, 1985).     

The width of the minor groove affects the binding of the bisquaternary heterocycle SN-6999 to duplex DNA.

A complex between d(GGGAAAAACGG).d(CCGTTTTTCCC) and the minor groove binding drug SN-6999 has been studied by 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The drug is found to bind in the d(A)5 tract, but with interactions extending one residue in the 3'-direction along each strand. Doubling of resonances in the complex indicates slow to intermediate exchange between two binding modes. An orientational preference (7:3) is found, the first such example in an SN-6999 complex. Furthermore, the upper limit of the lifetime for the major species is longer than was found for SN-6999 with other DNA duplexes. The preferred orientation of SN-6999 has the pyridinium ring near the 5'-end of the (+) strand; the minor binding mode has the reverse orientation. The orientational preference and slower exchange rate relative to other SN-6999 complexes is attributed to increased stabilization from van der Waals interactions due to better shape complementarity between the DNA duplex and ligand. The comparison of these results with studies of SN-6999 complexed to other DNA duplexes reveals the sensitivity of the binding properties to the delicate interplay between the molecular structure of the ligand and the specific characteristics of the DNA minor groove.     

Structure of poly(dA).poly(dT) is not identical to the AT rich regions of the single crystal structure of CGCGAATTBrCGCG. The consequence of this to netropsin binding to poly(dA).poly(dT)

The basic assumption of Dickerson and Kopka (J. Biomole. Str. Dyns. 2, 423, 1985) that the conformation of poly(dA).poly(dT) in solution is identical to the AT rich region of the single crystal structure of the Dickerson dodecamer is not supported by any experimental data. In poly(dA).poly(dT), NOE and Raman studies indicate that the dA and dT units are conformationally equivalent and display the (anti-S-type sugar)-conformation; incorporation of this nucleotide geometry into a double helix leads to a conventional regular B-helix in which the width of the minor groove is 8A. The derived structure is consistent with all available experimental data on poly(dA).poly(dT) obtained under solution conditions. In the crystal structure of the dodecamer, the dA and dT units have distinctly different conformations-dA residues adopt (anti, S-type sugar pucker), while dT residues belong to (low anti, N-type sugar pucker). These different conformations of the dA and dT units along with the large propeller twist can be accommodated in a double helix in which the minor groove is shrunk from 8A to less than 4A. In the conventional right handed B-form of poly(dA).poly(dT) with the 8A wide minor groove, netropsin has to bind asymmetrically along the dA strand to account for the NOE and chemical shift data and to generate a stereochemically sound structure (Sarma et al, J. Biomole. Str. Dyns. 2, 1085, 1985).     

Interaction of 9-O-(ω-amino) alkyl ether berberine analogs with poly(dT)·poly(dA)*poly(dT) triplex and poly(dA)·poly(dT) duplex: a comparative study

Isoquinoline alkaloids and their analogs represent an important class of molecules for their broad range of clinical and pharmacological utility. These compounds are of current interest owing to their low toxicity and excellent chemo preventive properties. These alkaloids can play important role in stabilising the nucleic acid triple helices. The present study has focused on the interaction of five 9-O-(ω-amino) alkyl ether berberine analogs with the DNA triplex poly(dT)·poly(dA)*poly(dT) and the parent duplex poly(dA)·poly(dT) studied using various biophysical techniques. Scatchard analysis of the spectral data indicated that the analogs bind both to the duplex and triplex in a non-cooperative manner in contrast to the cooperative binding of berberine to the DNA triplex. Strong intercalative binding to the DNA triplex structure was revealed from ferrocyanide quenching, fluorescence polarization and viscosity results. Thermal melting studies demonstrated higher stabilization of the Hoogsteen base paired third strand of the DNA triplex compared to the Watson–Crick strand. Circular dichroism studies suggested a stronger perturbation of the DNA triplex conformation by the alkaloid analogs compared to the duplex. The binding was entropy-driven in each case and the entropy contribution to free energy increased as the length of the alkyl side chain increased. The analogs exhibited stronger binding affinity to the triple helical structure compared to the parent double helical structure.     

Complete disproportionation of duplex poly(dT)*poly(dA) into triplex poly(dT)*poly(dA)*poly(dT) and poly(dA) by coralyne

Coralyne is a small crescent-shaped molecule known to intercalate duplex and triplex DNA. We report that coralyne can cause the complete and irreversible disproportionation of duplex poly(dT)·poly(dA). That is, coralyne causes the strands of duplex poly(dT)·poly(dA) to repartition into equal molar equivalents of triplex poly(dT)·poly(dA)·poly(dT) and poly(dA). Poly(dT)·poly(dA) will remain as a duplex for months after the addition of coralyne, if the sample is maintained at 4°C. However, disproportionation readily occurs upon heating above 35°C and is not reversed by subsequent cooling. A titration of poly(dT)·poly(dA) with coralyne reveals that disproportionation is favored by as little as one molar equivalent of coralyne per eight base pairs of initial duplex. We have also found that poly(dA) forms a self-structure in the presence of coralyne with a melting temperature of 47°C, for the conditions of our study. This poly(dA) self-structure binds coralyne with an affinity that is comparable with that of triplex poly(dT)·poly(dA)·poly(dT). A Job plot analysis reveals that the maximum level of poly(dA) self-structure intercalation is 0.25 coralyne molecules per adenine base. This conforms to the nearest neighbor exclusion principle for a poly(dA) duplex structure with A·A base pairs. We propose that duplex disproportionation by coralyne is promoted by both the triplex and the poly(dA) self-structure having binding constants for coralyne that are greater than that of duplex poly(dT)·poly(dA).     

Controlling nucleic acid secondary structure by intercalation: effects of DNA strand length on coralyne-driven duplex disproportionation

Small molecules that intercalate in DNA and RNA are powerful agents for controlling nucleic acid structural transitions. We recently demonstrated that coralyne, a small crescent-shaped molecule, can cause the complete and irreversible disproportionation of duplex poly(dA)·poly(dT) into triplex poly(dA)·poly(dT)·poly(dT) and a poly(dA) self- structure. Both DNA secondary structures that result from duplex disproportionation are stabilized by coralyne intercalation. In the present study, we show that the kinetics and thermodynamics of coralyne-driven duplex disproportionation strongly depend on oligonucleotide length. For example, disproportionation of duplex (dA)₁₆·(dT)₁₆ by coralyne reverts over the course of hours if the sample is maintained at 4°C. Coralyne-disproportioned (dA)₃₂· (dT)₃₂, on the other hand, only partially reverts to the duplex state over the course of days at the same temperature. Furthermore, the equilibrium state of a (dA)₁₆·(dT)₁₆ sample in the presence of coralyne at room temperature contains three different secondary structures [i.e. duplex, triplex and the (dA)₁₆ self-structure]. Even the well-studied process of triplex stabilization by coralyne binding is found to be a length-dependent phenomenon and more complicated than previously appreciated. Together these observations indicate that at least one secondary structure in our nucleic acid system [i.e. duplex, triplex or (dA)_n self-structure] binds coralyne in a length-dependent manner.     

DNA triple helix stabilization by aminoglycoside antibiotics

The stabilization of the poly(dA) x 2poly(dT) triple helix by neomycin is reported. Preliminary results indicate that neomycin stabilizes DNA triple helices and the double helical structures composed of poly(dA) x poly(dT) are virtually unaffected. This is the first report of the interaction of aminoglycoside antibiotics with DNA triple helices.     

A Model for Parallel Triple Helix Formation by Ree A: Single-Strand Association with a Homologous Duple via the Minor Groove

Abstract

The nucleoproteic filaments of RecA polymerized on single stranded DNA are able to integrate double stranded DNA in a coaxial arrangement (with DNA stretched by a factor 1.5), to recognize homologous sequences in the duplex and to perform strand exchange between the single stranded and double stranded molecules. While experimental results favor the hypothesis of an invasion of the minor groove of the duplex by the single strand, parallel minor groove triple helices have never been isolated or even modeled, the minor groove offering little space for a third strand to interact. Based on an internal coordinate modeling study, we show here that such a structure is perfectly conceivable when the two interacting oligomers are stretched by a factor 1.5, in order to open the minor groove of the duplex. The model helix presents characteristics that coincide with known experimental data on unwinding, base pair inclination and inter-proton distances. Moreover, we show that extension and unwinding stabilize the triple helix. New patterns of triplet interaction via the minor groove are presented.     

Minor groove binding of Co(III)meso-tetrakis(N-methylpyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin to various duplex and triplex polynucleotides

The binding site and the geometry of Co(III)meso-tetrakis(N-methylpyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin (CoTMPyP) complexed with double helical poly(dA).poly(dT) and poly(dG).poly(dC), and with triple helical poly(dA).[poly(dT)](2) and poly(dC).poly(dG).poly(dC)(+) were investigated by circular and linear dichroism (CD and LD). The appearance of monomeric positive CD at a low [porphyrin]/[DNA] ratio and bisignate CD at a high ratio of the CoTMPyP-poly(dA).poly(dT) complex is almost identical with its triplex counterpart. Similarity in the CD spectra was also observed for the CoTMPyP-poly(dG).poly(dC) and -poly(dC).poly(dG).poly(dC)(+) complex. This observation indicates that both monomeric binding and stacking of CoTMPyP to these polynucleotides occur at the minor groove. However, different binding geometry of CoTMPyP, when bind to AT- and GC-rich polynucleotide, was observed by LD spectrum. The difference in the binding geometry may be attributed to the difference in the interaction between polynucleotides and CoTMPyP: in the GC polynucleotide case, amine group protrude into the minor groove while it is not present in the AT polynucleotide.     

Probing the hydration of the minor groove of A.T synthetic DNA polymers by volume and heat changes

The minor-groove ligand netropsin provides a sensitive probe of the hydration difference between poly(dA).poly(dT) and poly[d(AT)].poly[d(AT)]. We have measured the volume change delta V accompanying binding of netropsin to these polymers, using an improved magnetic suspension densimeter. For poly(dA).poly(dT) we find delta V = +97 mL/mol of bound netropsin at pH 7.0 and 10 mM sodium phosphate buffer. For poly[d(AT)].poly[d(AT)] we find delta V = -16 mL/mol of bound netropsin. This striking differential effect suggests that the poly(dA).poly(dT) duplex compresses more water (or is more extensively hydrated). From our enthalpy and entropy results we estimate the approximately 10 water molecules, immobilized in the minor groove of this system, are displaced by each netropsin bound. The volume increase, however, is substantially larger than can be explained by a simple melting of these immobilized water molecules in the minor groove. A decompression of at least 40 water molecules must attend the complexation to the poly(dA).poly(dT) duplex. This suggests that the conformation change attending the binding of the drug to this polymer duplex causes a further dehydration, whereas no such change in dehydration and configuration for the heteropolymer system is indicated.