Comparison of cytogenetic response of human lymphocytes to in vivo and in vitro exposure to low-dose gamma rays. Translocations and dicentrics detected by the FISH technique

On peripheral lymphocytes of 5 cancer patients undergone wholebody therapeutic irradiation (at daily dose of 10 cGy up to total dose 50 cGy of 60Co gamma-rays) the dose response of unstable and stable chromosomal exchanges detected by FISH was compared with the dose response of the some aberrations in lymphocytes irradiated in vitro. The dose response fitted well to linear function. For dicentrics the lower slope of dose-response curve was found for in vivo irradiated lymphocytes as compared to the dose-response curve obtained for in vitro irradiated lymphocytes of the same patients. No difference between in vivo and in vitro irradiation of lymphocytes was found for translocations. The frequency of translocations increased faster with the dose than the frequency of dicentrics only in lymphocytes irradiated in vivo.     

Comparison of cytogenic response of human lymphocytes to in vivo and in vitro exposure to low doses of gamma-rays. Unstable chromosomal exchanges detected by FPG techniques

On peripheral lymphocytes of eight cancer patients undergone whole-body therapeutic irradiation (at daily dose of 10 cGy up to total dose of 50 cGy of 60Co gamma-rays) the dose-response of unstable chromosome exchanges (dicentrics and centric rings) was studied. This dose response fitted well linear function. The lower slope of dose-response curve was found for in vivo irradiated lymphocytes as compared to the dose response curve obtained for in vitro irradiated lymphocytes of the same patients. This finding seems to provide evidence that in case of protracted irradiation of individuals an absorbed dose could be underestimated if for biological dosimetry an in vitro dose response curve for unstable chromosome aberrations is used as referent one.     

Lymphocyte chromosomal aberrations and their complexity induced in vitro by plutonium-239 alpha-particles and detected by FISH.

G0 human lymphocytes were exposed in vitro to plutonium-239 alpha-particles, with doses ranging from 0 to 1.62 Gy, to provide a dose response curve and to compare complex rearrangements produced by high LET radiation with low LET data from previous work. Metaphase chromosomes 1 and 2 were painted using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) whole chromosome probes. All unstable and stable aberrations involving the painted chromosomes were scored. The whole genome corrected alpha-coefficient for dicentrics was 0.244 +/- 0.023 and for total translocations 0.346 +/- 0.032, when considering simple and complex exchanges. The ratio of bicoloured total translocations to bicoloured dicentrics was 1.21 +/- 0.15 and the ratio of 2-way to 1-way translocations was 1.73 +/- 0.27 for apparently simple exchanges only. A correlation was noted between the distributions of dicentrics and translocations and this applied even when the complex rearrangements were removed. 20% of the observed rearrangements were complex and this observation was independent of dose. Qualitatively, following irradiation with alpha-particles the complex rearrangements observed were of a greater complexity than seen after X- or gamma-rays. Using the Savage and Simpson system to classify the complex rearrangements, the higher order complexes were found to be the most common type observed. However the insertion type increased while the 2F + 2G types decreased when complex rearrangements induced by alpha-particles were compared to those formed after X- or gamma-irradiation.     

Stable and unstable chromosome aberrations in humans and other mammals in relation to the problems of biological dosimetry

Literature data of long-term cytogenetic follow-up of people exposed to radiation as a results of different radiation accidents are considered for the purpose of discussing of some problems of biological dosimetry. The results obtained for mammals are also presented. Of particular interest is a decrease in the level of dicentrics and symmetrical translocations in peripheral blood lymphocytes with the time after acute exposure depending on the dose of irradiation. The frequency of dicentrics decreases in accordance to the exponential law passing the fast and slow phases of elimination. In different radiation situations the values of the parameter which defines the half-life period of lymphocytes characterizing 50% reduction of cells with dicentrics markedly vary. However a general regularity is a decrease in the parameter value as the exposure dose increases. The level of stable translocations estimates by the EISH method remains relatively constant at doses below 1-2 Gy. At higher doses their level in peripheral blood lymphocytes declines with time due to which the retrospective dose appears to be underestimated. The reasons of such regularity, the role of various factors affecting the scoring of translocations, criteria of analysis of the given chromosome aberrations are discussed in the context of common agreements between leading European laboratories on the use of FISH for improving biological dosimetric estimates.     

The low dose and low dose rate cytogenetic effects induced by gamma-radiation in human blood lymphocytes in vitro. II. the results of cytogenetic study

The yield of chromosome aberrations induced by gamma-radiation of 60Co in human blood lymphocytes in vitro at low doses (30 divided by 600 mGy) and low dose rates (0.70, 5.05, 59.2 mGy/min) was investigated. It was found that the observed level of chromosomal aberrations induced by gamma-irradiation was unaffected by the value of the dose rate when using constant dose rate and obtaining different doses by altering the exposure time. However, a relatively enhanced level of chromatid aberrations was found at 5.05 and 59.2 mGy/min dose rates in the dose range less than 250 mGy. We have found that the observed level of the sum of chromosomal aberrations induced by gamma-irradiation at doses less than 250 mGy and a dose rate of 59.2 mGy/min was essentially larger compared with the level extrapolated from high doses (above 300 mGy) using a linear-quadratic dose curve. This complied with our previous finding in 1976, 1977 when the enhanced level of dicentrics was only found at a high dose rate approximately 500 mGy/min. Such a non-linear cytogenetic effect does not manifest itself statistically significantly at dose rates of 0.70 and 5.05 mGy/min for the sum of chromosomal aberrations and does not manifest itself at all for dicentrics at all the examined dose rates.     

Variation in the frequencies of spontaneous and in vitro induced chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes during natural and radiation-induced aging

The frequency of translocations detected by FISH in lymphocytes of control donors increases with age as a quadratic function. This process is faster in persons previously exposed to low doses of radiation. It means that translocation frequency can be used as a measure of biological age. Moreover, translocation frequency should be taken into account in biological reconstruction of absorbed doses. The frequencies of dicentrics detected by FIGH and FPG linearly increase with age in both groups, and this process occurs at equal rates during natural and radiation-induced aging. The age-dependent increase in the frequency of translocations exceeds the increase in dicentrics. The radiation sensitivity of lymphocytes estimated from the frequency of in vitro induced chromosomal aberrations tends to increase with age in the control group and decreases significantly in the group exposed to radiation; i.e., low-dose preexposure alters the pattern of the age dependence of radiation sensitivity in lymphocytes in vitro.     

A comparative study of the micronucleus test and chromosome aberrations in PHA-stimulated human lymphocytes

A dose dependence of the number of cells with chromosome aberrations was studied in PHA-stimulated donor's peripheral blood lymphocytes irradiated in vitro with doses of 10-400 cGy. In studying the number of chromosome aberrations and percentage of cells with micronuclei in parallel cultures no correlation was found between these indices within the groups exposed to a similar radiation dose.     

Retrospective dose estimation in remote period after exposure using different biological methods

Investigation of application of chromosome aberrations of lymphocytes in peripheral blood for biological dosimetry purposes in remote (up to 40 years) period after acute exposure to doses of 1 Gy and more was carried out. The comparative analysis of frequency of unstable and stable (using FISH and G-banding methods) aberrations was performed for 24 subjects accidentally exposed to radiation on nuclear submarines during 1961-1985. Statistically significant increasing of frequency of dicentrics and centric rings was determined in the exposed subjects in remote period after exposure to compare with controls. Their sum frequency in the exposed group varied depending on ARS heaviness from 0.1 to 1.0 aberrations per 100 cells. In control group it was from 0 to 0.2 correspondingly. Translocation frequency (complete + incomplete) fixed by FISH method (2, 4, and 12 chromosomes) varied within the limits of 0.2-16.0 for exposed subjects and 0.3-1.26 translocations per genome per 100 cells for controls. Some examined persons (5 subjects) exposed to accident in 1985 had results of analysis of unstable chromosome aberration in acute period after exposure that allow to estimate obtained doses by dicentrics frequency which having good correlation with ARS heaviness. Individual dosed using traslocation frequency were defined retrospectively in 11 from 21 exposed persons. They correlate with calculated physics doses and doses estimated by haematolotical parameters in acute period and also doses obtained by ESR spectroscopy of tooth enamel in remote period.     

Effect of age and radiation exposure on the frequency of translocations and dicentrics detected by FISH method in human lymphocytes

The frequencies of translocations and dicentrics detected by "chromosome painting" in lymphocytes were estimated in 115 healthy donors and in 273 people exposed to uncontrolled irradiation at low doses 1-4 years ago. Age responses of both types of exchanges at the age range from 3 to 85 years fit to quadratic model. The frequency of translocations grew faster with age than the frequency of dicentrics. The yields of stable exchanges in exposed people was significantly higher than those in control donors of corresponding ages.     

Relative biological effectiveness and dose rate effect of tritiated water on chromosomes in human lymphocytes and bone marrow cells

Tritriated water (HTO) is a major toxic effluent from the nuclear power industry, that is released into the environment in large quantities. The low dose radiation effect and dose rate effect of HTO on human lymphocytes and bone marrow cells have not been well studied. The present study was therefore undertaken to investigate the HTO dose-response relationship for chromosomal aberrations in human lymphocytes and bone marrow cells at low in vitro radiation doses ranging from 0.1 to 1 Gy. Lymphocytes (G₀ stage) and bone marrow cells were incubated for 10–150 min with HTO at a dose rate of 2cGy/min (555 MBq/ml). The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of HTO was calculated with respect to ₆₀Co γ-rays for the induction of dicentric and centric ring chromosomes at low radiation doses. The RBE value for HTO β-rays relative to ⁶⁰Co γ-rays was 2.7 for lymphocytes and 3.1 for chromatid aberrations in bone marrow cells. Lymphocytes were also chronically exposed to HTO for 6.7–80 h at dose rates of 0.5 cGy/min (138.5 MBq/ml) and 0.02 cGy/min (5.6 MBq/ml). There was a 71.5% decrease in the yield of dicentrics and centric rings at the dose rate of 0.02 cGy/min, indicating a clear dose rate effect of HTO. The RBE value for HTO relative to ¹³⁷Cs γ-rays was 2.0 at a dose rate of 0.02 cGy/min, suggesting that low HTO dose rates produce no increase of the RBE values and that the values may be constant between 2 and 3 within these dose rates. These results should prove useful in assessment of the health risk for humans exposed to low levels of HTO.     

The characterization and transmissibility of chromosome aberrations induced in peripheral blood lymphocytes by in vitro alpha-particle radiation

Peripheral blood lymphocytes were irradiated in vitro with (213)Bi alpha particles at doses of 0, 10, 20, 50, 100, 200 and 500 mGy. Chromosome analysis was performed on 47-h cultures using single-color fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) to paint chromosomes 1, 3 and 5. The whole genome was analyzed for unstable aberrations to derive aberration frequencies and determine cell stability. The dose response for dicentrics was 33.60 +/- 0.47 x 10(-2) per Gy. A more detailed analysis revealed that the majority of aberrations scored as dicentrics were part of complex/multiple aberrations, with the proportion of cells containing complexes increasing with dose. Cells containing aberrations involving painted chromosomes (FISH aberrations) were further classified according to cell stability and complexity. The majority of cells with FISH aberrations were unstable. The proportion of aberrant FISH cells with complex/multiple aberrations ranged from 56% at 10 mGy to 89% at 500 mGy. A linear dose response for genomic frequencies of translocations in stable cells fitted the data from 0 to 200 mGy with a dose response of 7.90 +/- 0.98 x 10(-2) per Gy, thus indicating that they are likely to be observed in peripheral blood lymphocytes from individuals with past or chronic exposure to high-LET radiation. Comparisons with the dose response for low-LET radiation suggest an RBE of 13.6 for dicentrics in all cells and 3.2 for translocations in stable cells. Since stochastic effects of radiation are attributable to genetic changes in viable cells, translocations in stable cells may be a better measure when considering the comparative risks of different qualities of radiation.     

A model for interphase chromosomes and evaluation of radiation-induced aberrations

We have developed a theoretical model for evaluating radiation-induced chromosomal exchanges by explicitly taking into account interphase (G(0)/G(1)) chromosome structure, nuclear organization of chromosomes, the production of double-strand breaks (DSBs), and the subsequent rejoinings in a faithful or unfaithful manner. Each of the 46 chromosomes for human lymphocytes (40 chromosomes for mouse lymphocytes) is modeled as a random polymer inside a spherical volume. The chromosome spheres are packed randomly inside a spherical nucleus with an allowed overlap controlled by a parameter Omega. The rejoining of DSBs is determined by a Monte Carlo procedure using a Gaussian proximity function with an interaction range parameter sigma. Values of Omega and sigma have been found which yield calculated results of interchromosomal aberration frequencies that agree with a wide range of experimental data. Our preferred solution is one with an interaction range of 0.5 microm coupled with a relatively small overlap parameter of 0.675 microm, which more or less confirms previous estimates. We have used our model with these parameter values and with resolution or detectability limits to calculate yields of translocations and dicentrics for human lymphocytes exposed to low-LET radiation that agree with experiments in the dose range 0.09 to 4 Gy. Five different experimental data sets have been compared with the theoretical results. Essentially all of the experimental data fall between theoretical curves corresponding to resolution limits of 1 Mbp and 20 Mbp, which may reflect the fact that different investigators use different limits for sensitivity or detectability. Translocation yields for mouse lymphocytes have also been calculated and are in good agreement with experimental data from 1 cGy to 10 cGy. There is also good agreement with recent data on complex aberrations. Our model is expected to be applicable to both low- and high-LET radiation, and we include a sample prediction of the yield of interchromosomal rejoining in the dose range 0.22 Gy to 2 Gy of 1000 MeV/nucleon iron particles. This dose range corresponds to average particle traversals per nucleus ranging from 1.0 to 9.12.     

Cytogenetic analysis of peripheral blood lymphocytes of occupational workers exposed to low levels of ionising radiation.

The incidence of chromosomal aberrations was analysed in peripheral blood lymphocytes of occupationally exposed people having cumulative doses of 500 mSv. The exposed individuals showed higher frequencies of dicentrics as well as acentrics than normal controls. Absorbed radiation dose was calculated by using in vitro dose response curve established for Cobalt-60 gamma rays. In the control constituting 17 healthy individuals, two dicentrics were detected among 3700 metaphases analysed. In the exposed group 27 dicentrics and one centric ring was detected among 8400 metaphases analysed. Due to small number of dicentrics scored in each individual, the dose estimate suffers from a large statistical uncertainty. The collective dose was found to be 1.89 Gy. This is in good agreement with the corrected physical doses, assuming a mean life of 10 years for the disappearance of lymphocytes. The physical doses accumulated during the last 10 years of occupation were also in good agreement with the biological dose estimate.     

The effect of low-dose irradiation and of age on the in vitro radiosensitivity of human lymphocytes

The effect of low-dose irradiation and of age on the radiosensitivity of human lymphocytes was studies in two groups: control (67 people) and exposed to uncontrolled low-dose irradiation in past (165 people). Radiosensitivity of lymphocytes was estimated by the level of chromosome aberrations induced in vitro by gamma-radiation Cs137 at the dose 1.5 Gy. In exposed children the frequency of induced chromosome aberrations was higher and in the exposed adults--lower in comparison to the coresponding controls. To investigate an age response of the number of chromosome aberrations three statistical approaches were used: the correlation analysis of individual data, the correlation analysis of means for 10-years intervals, the comparison of 3 age groups. In control group no significant alteration in the level of induced chromosome aberrations with age was found. However the significant negative correlation between these two parameters was revealed in exposed group, which likely is due to the opposite direction of differences in radiosensitivity of exposed children and adults from the corresponding controls.     

Chromosome aberrations produced in human lymphocytes by in vivo and in vitro irradiation

The production of chromosome aberrations in vivo has been studied in lymphocytes from a patient undergoing a wholebody treatment with gamma-radiation up to a cumulative dose of 1.4 Gy. These results were compared with the observations performed on whole blood samples irradiated in vitro with doses from 0.05 up to 2 Gy of gamma-rays. The frequency of chromosome aberrations, particularly the dicentrics, was found to be similar in vivo and in vitro. The yield of dicentrics could be best related to the dose by using a linear-quadratic model in both cases, the ratio of the coefficients a/b being of 0.56 and 0.69 Gy, respectively in vivo and in vitro. These observations confirm that in vitro dose response curves may be used to evaluate accurately an in vivo absorbed dose.     

Effect of high-level natural radiation on chromosomes of residents in southern China

To study the effect of low-dose (rate) radiation on human health, we analyzed chromosomes of peripheral lymphocytes of residents in a high background radiation area (HBRA) and compared the results with those obtained from residents in a control area (CA) in Guangdong Province, China. Unstable types of chromosome aberrations (dicentrics and rings) were studied in 22 members of eight families in HBRA and 17 members of five families in CA. Each family consists of three generations. On average 2,600 cells per subject were analyzed. 27 adults and six children in HBRA and 25 adults and eight children in CA were studied with respect to translocations. On average 4,741 cells per subject were examined. We found an increase of the frequency of dicentrics and rings in HBRA, where the natural radiation level is three to five times higher than in the control area. But the increase of translocations in HBRA was within the range of individual variation in the controls.     

Genotoxic effects of radiotherapy and chemotherapy on the circulating lymphocytes of breast cancer patients. I. Chromosome aberrations induced in vivo

Unstable chromosome aberrations were scored in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) serially collected from 21 breast cancer patients before and after radiotherapy (RT), chemotherapy (CT) and combined treatments. Local radiotherapy as treatment for mammary cancer induced unstable chromosome aberrations in peripheral blood lymphocytes. Only a fraction of these lymphocytes were exposed to irradiation during treatment and the chromosomal damage observed in PBL was equivalent to that induced by irradiation in vitro with 2 Gy at high dose rate, i.e., about 4% of the total dose delivered locally. Chemotherapy alone did not induce such anomalies. Apart from the observed interindividual variations in either the level or the fate of dicentrics with time, different features of chromosome damage were found when chemotherapy was given before or after local cobaltotherapy: secondary chemotherapy did not alter the frequency and the overdispersed distribution of dicentrics observed after first-line radiotherapy; in contrast, when CT was given before radiotherapy, a lower dicentric frequency was scored, the distribution of dicentrics was not always found to be overdispersed and there was a time-dependent decrease in dicentrics after in vivo exposure.     

Possibilities and limitations of fluorescence in situ hybridization technique in retrospective detection of low dose radiation exposure in post-chernobyl human cohorts

Cytogenetic analysis using the fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) technique was performed late time after the Chernobyl accident in groups of liquidators, evacuees from 30 km exclusive zone, residents of radioactively contaminated areas and control donors age-matched to exposed persons. Stable and unstable chromosome type exchanges were recorded using a hybrid conventional-PAINT nomenclature. The mean yield of stable chromosome exchanges in liquidators did not correlate with registered radiation doses but had a clear negative dependence on the duration of liquidators' staying in Chernobyl zone, that was in a good agreement with early data based on conventional dicentrics plus rings analysis. The overspontaneous excess for stable chromosome exchange level appeared to be higher in evacuees 16-40 years old than that of senior persons, whereas no age-dependent difference occurred for initially induced dicentrics plus rings yields in this cohort. The stable chromosome exchange yield, as well as combined yield of dicentrics plus rings and potentially unstable incomplete translocations in residents of radioactively contaminated areas showed a reasonable positive correlation with levels of 137Cs contamination. The observed yields of stable chromosome exchanges in all three exposed groups appeared to be somewhat lower than those of expected from unstable exchange-based doses which were referred to an in vitro dose response of stable exchanges outcome in human lymphocytes. Thus, FISH analysis can be successfully applied for qualitative cytogenetic indication of past and chronic radiation exposure to low doses but further refinement of FISH-based system for quantitative dose assessment is still required. Some practical approaches of solving this task are discussed.     

Alpha particles induce different F values in monocellular layers of settled and attached human lymphocytes

There is rapidly increasing information on the issue of three-dimensional nuclear architecture, according to which chromosomes are organized in localized territories and chromosome arms in exclusive domains within a given territory. The aim of the present study was to investigate the impact of different cell exposure conditions on cytogenetic damage induced by high-LET radiation. To this end the yield ratio of dicentrics to centric rings (F value) induced by (241)Am α particles was analyzed in monolayer cultures of human lymphocytes that were either settled or attached to foils, simulating a rounded or spread out cellular geometry, respectively. Monolayers were exposed in special irradiation chambers to 0.1 and 1.0 Gy and subsequently analyzed for chromosome aberrations. Independent of these different dose levels, significantly different F values of 10.07 ± 1.73 and 4.27 ± 0.44 have been determined in attached and settled lymphocytes, respectively. Since the diameter of nuclei vertically traversed by α particles in attached cells is about one-half that in settled cells, these F values support the postulate that proximity effects regarding the chromatin geometry in flattened or spherical human lymphocytes influence the formation of high-LET radiation-induced dicentrics and centric rings. A comparison with our earlier data sets obtained for both in vitro and in vivo exposure of human lymphocytes to α particles or (137)Cs γ rays supports the notion that the F value depends on the radiation quality when investigations are confined to spherical human lymphocytes. Thus the F value should not be ruled out as a practical chromosomal "fingerprint" for past exposure to high-LET radiation.     

In vitro transmission of chromosomal aberrations through mitosis in human lymphocytes

Stable and unstable chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes exposed to 2 and 4Gy of X-rays in G(0) were analyzed in M1 and M2 cells harvested at 72h to investigate how the scoring protocol influences the yields of aberrations transmitted through one mitosis. Metaphase chromosomes 2, 3, and 5 were painted using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) whole chromosome probes, together with a pan-centromeric probe and stained by the harlequin-FISH method, to allow the cell cycle status of each cell to be determined as it was scored. A strict scoring criterion was adopted so that each metaphase had to contain 46 centromeres and each dicentric/centric ring had to have an acentric present. In addition to scoring the painted material, unstable aberrations in the whole genome were also recorded. The yield of complete dicentrics decreased by more than a factor of 2 in going from M1 to M2. The decrease was greater at the lower dose. Two-way translocations appeared stable, but one-way translocations decreased. This suggests that if translocation yields are to be used for biological dosimetry purposes, then the two-way type should be used.