The relationship between region E1a and E1b of human adenoviruses in cell transformation

Baby rat kidney (BRK) cells were transfected either with intact region E1 DNA of adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) or with mixtures of DNA fragments containing the separated E1a and E1b regions. The results showed that mixtures of regions E1a and E1b transform with a similar efficiency as intact region E1. DNA fragments containing region E1b alone have no detectable transforming activity in primary BRK cells nor in established rat cell lines. When region E1a and Ad5 was combined with region E1b and Ad12 complete transformation was also obtained. Characterization of the cell lines transformed by separated E1a and E1b regions have led to the following conclusions: (1) Expression of region E1b is not dependent on specific linkage to region E1a as it occurs in the intact E1 region. (2) Region E1b is normally expressed into the corresponding major adenovirus T antigens (65,000 and 19,000 Mr with region E1b of Ad5; 60,000 and 19,000 Mr with E1b or AD12). (3) Region E1b of Ad12 can be activated by region E1a of Ad5 indicating that the Ela regions of both serotypes are functionally similar in transformation. (4) Cell lines containing region E1b of Ad5 are weakly oncogenic in nude mice whereas cells containing E1b of Ad12 are highly oncogenic in nude mice, indicating that the degree of oncogenicity is determined by region E1b.     

E1A 12S and 13S of the transformation-defective adenovirus type 12 strain CS-1 inactivate proteins of the RB family, permitting transactivation of the E2F-dependent promoter.

The transformation-defective Vero cell host range mutant CS-1 of the highly oncogenic adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) (Ad12-CS-1) has a 69-bp deletion in the early region 1A (E1A) gene that removes the carboxy-terminal half of conserved region 2 and the amino-terminal half of the Ad12-specific so-called spacer that seems to play a pivotal role in the oncogenicity of the virus. Despite its deficiency in immortalizing and transforming primary rodent cells, we found that the E1A 13S protein of Ad12-CS-1 retains the ability to bind p105-RB, p107, and p130 in nuclear extract binding assays with glutathione S-transferase-E1A fusion proteins and Western blot analysis. Like wild-type E1A, the mutant protein was able to dissociate E2F from retinoblastoma-related protein-containing complexes, as judged from gel shift experiments with purified 12S and 13S proteins from transfection experiments with an E1A expression vector or from infection with the respective virus. Moreover, in transient expression assays, the 12S and 13S products of wild-type Ad12 and Ad12-CS-1 were shown to transactivate the Ad12 E1A promoter containing E2F-1 and E2F-5-motifs, respectively, in a comparable manner. The same results were obtained from transfection assays with the E2F motif-dependent E2 promoter of adenovirus type 5 or the human dihydrofolate reductase promoter. These data suggest that efficient infection by Ad12 and the correlated virus-induced reprogramming of the infected cells, including the induction of cell cycle-relevant mechanisms (e.g. E2F activation), can be uncoupled from the transformation properties of the virus.     

Constructing chimeric type 12/type 5 adenovirus E1A genes and using them to identify an oncogenic determinant of adenovirus type 12.

The E1A gene of highly oncogenic type 12 adenovirus (Ad12) possesses a segment unique to this serotype and comprising 60 base pairs contiguous with and separating conserved regions 2 and 3 in the gene. A similar but slightly longer segment is also present in the E1A gene of highly oncogenic simian adenovirus type 7 (D. Kimelman, J. S. Miller, D. Porter, and B. E. Roberts, J. Virol. 53:399-409, 1985). This segment is missing entirely from the E1A gene of type 5 adenovirus, which is nononcogenic. To test the hypothesis that this unique separating or "spacer" region influences the oncogenicity of Ad12, we constructed ClaI and SmaI restriction sites on either side of it, which allowed reciprocal exchange between this and the equivalent cassette from type 5 adenovirus E1A, bounded by the same restriction sites intrinsic to that gene. The resultant Ad12-based chimeric viruses, ch702 and ch704, in which the spacer region is replaced with (in-frame) type 5 sequence, grow normally on human A549 cells and display wild-type transformation frequencies on baby rat and mouse kidney cells. In contrast, the oncogenic capacity of these chimeric viruses, as measured by tumor induction following virus inoculation in Hooded Lister rats, is greatly reduced. Likewise, cells transformed by ch702 and ch704 display reduced tumorigenicity compared with wild-type transformants in syngeneic rats. These results, coupled with recent preliminary tests using a mutant with a point mutation in this region, support the view that the unique spacer region of type 12 is an oncogenic determinant of this virus.     

Expression of the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase gene in human cells under the control of early adenovirus subgroup C promoters: effect of E1A gene products from other subgroups on gene expression

A hierarchy of dominance has been observed in HeLa cells co-infected with two serotypes of adenovirus belonging to different subgroups. DNA replication and late protein synthesis of one serotype are inhibited by those of the other. The degree of inhibitory effect has the following decreasing order: adenovirus type 3 (Ad3) and Ad7 (subgroup B), Ad9 (D), Ad4 (E), Ad12 (A), Ad2 and Ad5 (C) [Delsert and D'Halluin, Virus Res. 1 (1984) 365-380]. HeLa cells were first transfected with recombinant plasmids carrying Ad5 E2A or E3 promoters fused to the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase gene (cat), and then infected with human Ad belonging to different subgroups. All the serotypes tested were found to be able to stimulate both E2A and E3 promoters. When HeLa cells were co-transfected with either of the previous plasmids, plus a second plasmid carrying the Ad3 E1A region, the same stimulatory effect was observed. However, an inhibitory effect on Ad5 E2A and E3 promoters seemed to occur when both Ad2 E1A (subgroup C) and Ad3 E1A (subgroup B) genes were present together. To determine which one of the early products was responsible for the observed repression effect, and to assign the target on the genome of subgroup C Ad, a plasmid was constructed in which the sequences at the 5' end of the Ad2 E1A region were fused to the structural sequences of the cat gene. In HeLa cells transfected with this plasmid, CAT activity was significantly increased after co-transfection with a plasmid carrying the Ad2 E1A region, but decreased with a plasmid carrying the Ad3 E1A region.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Human adenovirus early region 4 open reading frame 1 genes encode growth-transforming proteins that may be distantly related to dUTP pyrophosphatase enzymes.

An essential oncogenic determinant of subgroup D human adenovirus type 9 (Ad9), which uniquely elicits estrogen-dependent mammary tumors in rats, is encoded by early region 4 open reading frame 1 (E4 ORF1). Whereas Ad9 E4 ORF1 efficiently induces transformed foci on the established rat embryo fibroblast cell line CREF, the related subgroup A Ad12 and subgroup C Ad5 E4 ORF1s do not (R. T. Javier, J. Virol. 68:3917-3924, 1994). In this study, we found that the lack of transforming activity associated with non-subgroup D adenovirus E4 ORF1s in CREF cells correlated with significantly reduced protein levels compared to Ad9 E4 ORF1 in these cells. In the human cell line TE85, however, the non-subgroup D adenovirus E4 ORF1s produced protein levels higher than those seen in CREF cells as well as transforming activities similar to that of Ad9 E4 ORF1, suggesting that all adenovirus E4 ORF1 polypeptides possess comparable cellular growth-transforming activities. In addition, searches for known proteins related to these novel viral transforming proteins revealed that the E4 ORF1 proteins had weak sequence similarity, over the entire length of the E4 ORF1 polypeptides, with a variety of organismal and viral dUTP pyrophosphatase (dUTPase) enzymes. Even though adenovirus E4 ORF1 proteins lacked conserved protein motifs of dUTPase enzymes or detectable enzymatic activity, E4 ORF1 and dUTPase proteins were predicted to possess strikingly similar secondary structure arrangements. It was also established that an avian adenovirus protein, encoded within a genomic location analogous to that of the human adenovirus E4 ORF1s, was a genuine dUTPase enzyme. Although no functional similarity was found for the E4 ORF1 and dUTPase proteins, we propose that human adenovirus E4 ORF1 genes have evolved from an ancestral adenovirus dUTPase and, from this structural framework, developed novel transforming properties.     

Several E4 region functions influence mammary tumorigenesis by human adenovirus type 9

Among oncogenic adenoviruses, human adenovirus type 9 (Ad9) is unique in eliciting exclusively estrogen-dependent mammary tumors in rats and in not requiring viral E1 region transforming genes for tumorigenicity. Instead, studies with hybrid viruses generated between Ad9 and the closely related nontumorigenic virus Ad26 have roughly localized an Ad9 oncogenic determinant(s) to a segment of the viral E4 region containing open reading frame 1 (E4-ORF1), E4-ORF2, and part of E4-ORF3. Although subsequent findings have shown that E4-ORF1 codes for an oncoprotein essential for tumorigenesis by Ad9, it is not known whether other E4 region functions may similarly play a role in this process. We report here that new results with Ad9/Ad26 hybrid viruses demonstrated that the minimal essential Ad9 E4-region DNA sequences include portions of both E4-ORF1 and E4-ORF2. Investigations with Ad9 mutant viruses additionally showed that the E4-ORF1 protein and certain E4-ORF2 DNA sequences are necessary for Ad9-induced tumorigenesis, whereas the E4-ORF2 and E4-ORF3 proteins are not. In fact, the E4-ORF3 protein was found to antagonize this process. Also pertinent was that certain crucial nucleotide differences between Ad9 and Ad26 within E4-ORF1 and E4-ORF2 were found to be silent with respect to the amino acid sequences of the corresponding proteins. Furthermore, supporting a prominent role for the E4-ORF1 oncoprotein in Ad9-induced tumorigenesis, an E1 region-deficient Ad5 vector that expresses the Ad9 but not the Ad26 E4-ORF1 protein was tumorigenic in rats and, like Ad9, promoted solely mammary tumors. These findings argue that the E4-ORF1 oncoprotein is the major oncogenic determinant of Ad9 and that an undefined regulatory element(s) within the E4 region represents a previously unidentified second function likewise necessary for tumorigenesis by this virus.     

Tumorigenicity of adenovirus-transformed cells: collagen interaction and cell surface laminin are controlled by the serotype origin of the E1A and E1B genes.

A library of cells transformed with recombinant adenoviruses was used to study tumorigenicity and interaction with extracellular matrix. Cells expressing the complete E1 region of highly oncogenic adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) are tumorigenic, adhere preferentially to type IV collagen, and express cell surface laminin. Weakly tumorigenic cells, which express the E1A oncogene of Ad12 and the E1B genes of Ad5, also attach preferentially to type IV collagen but do not contain laminin on their surface. Cells which express the E1A oncogene of Ad5 and the E1B genes of Ad12 are nontumorigenic and do not preferentially attach to type IV versus type I collagen but have laminin on their surface. There is no significant difference in the amounts of laminin secreted into the culture medium among cells expressing the E1B genes of Ad5 or Ad12. In vitro assays show that cells which express the E1B genes of Ad12, irrespective of the origin of the E1A genes, can bind three times more exogenously added laminin than cells expressing the E1B genes of nononcogenic Ad5. The interaction of adenovirus-transformed cells with collagen is controlled by the serotype origin of the E1A oncogene, whereas cell surface laminin is controlled by the serotype origin of the E1B genes.     

Different activities of the adenovirus types 5 and 12 E1A regions in transformation with the EJ Ha-ras oncogene.

We have compared the capacities of the E1A regions of nononcogenic adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) and highly oncogenic Ad12 to cooperate with the EJ bladder carcinoma Ha-ras-1 oncogene in the transformation of primary baby rat kidney cells. Both E1A regions, when cotransfected with the Ha-ras oncogene, transformed the primary cells with a low frequency. Ad5 E1A plus Ha-ras-transformed cells differed in phenotype from cells transformed by Ad12 E1A plus Ha-ras. The cells expressing Ad5 E1A appeared highly transformed and practically failed to adhere to plastic. This phenotype may be due to the virtually complete absence of fibronectin gene expression in these cells. In contrast, the cells expressing Ad12 E1A were flatter and adhered to plastic, whereas fibronectin gene expression was reduced but not absent. The oncogenic potential of the two types of E1A plus ras-transformed cells was tested by their injection into both athymic nude mice and weanling syngeneic rats. The Ad5 E1A plus ras-transformed cells were found to be highly oncogenic in both animal species, whereas the Ad12 E1A plus ras-transformed cells were only weakly oncogenic in both syngeneic rats and nude mice. The difference in oncogenic potential of the Ad5 E1A plus ras- and the Ad12 E1A plus ras-transformed cells is discussed in terms of the different capacities of the Ad5 and Ad12 E1A-encoded proteins to modulate cellular gene expression.     

Tumor induction by human adenovirus type 12 in hamsters: loss of the viral genome from adenovirus type 12-induced tumor cells is compatible with tumor formation.

The patterns of integration of adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) DNA in 39 virus-induced hamster tumors were determined. Both the amount of Ad12 DNA persisting and the apparent sites of insertion differed from tumor to tumor. In 30 tumors, the intact Ad12 genome persisted in colinear arrangement and in multiple copies. In nine tumors, only the left- or the left- and right-hand parts of the Ad12 genome persisted in the tumor cells. In three other cell lines the Ad12 genomes were lost completely during continuous passage in culture. A shift from epithelioid to fibroblastic morphology correlated with loss of Adl2 genomes. The cell line H1111(1) derived from an Ad12-induced tumor had lost all viral DNA by the thirteenth subpassage, but was still oncogenic when reinjected into animals. This finding raises the question, to what extent persistence of the Ad12 genome is essential for the oncogenic phenotype. Tumor cells could be detected histologically inside local lymphatic vessels. In those experiments in which Ad12 preparations were used which contained sizeable proportions of the symmetric recombinant between Ad12 and KB cellular DNA (Deuring et al., 1981), tumors were observed in the nuchal region of the animals.     

Adenovirus E1A gene induction of susceptibility to lysis by natural killer cells and activated macrophages in infected rodent cells.

Rodent cells immortalized by the E1A gene of nononcogenic adenoviruses are susceptible to lysis by natural killer (NK) cells and activated macrophages. This cytolysis-susceptible phenotype may contribute to the rejection of adenovirus-transformed cells by immunocompetent animals. Such increased cytolytic susceptibility has also been observed with infected rodent cells. This infection model provided a means to study the role of E1A gene products in induction of cytolytic susceptibility without cell selection during transformation. Deletion mutations outside of the E1A gene had no effect on adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) or Ad5 induction of cytolytic susceptibility in infected hamster cells, while E1A-minus mutant viruses could not induce this phenotype. E1A mutant viruses that induced expression of either E1A 12S or 13S mRNA in infected cells were competent to induce cytolytic susceptibility. Furthermore, there was a correlation between the accumulation of E1A gene products in Ad5-infected cells and the level of susceptibility of such target cells to lysis by NK cells. The results of coinfection studies indicated that the E1A gene products of highly oncogenic Ad12 could not complement the lack of induction of cytolytic susceptibility by E1A-minus Ad5 virus in infected cells and also could not block induction of this infected-cell phenotype by Ad5. These data suggest that expression of the E1A gene of nononcogenic adenoviruses may cause the elimination of infected cells by the immunologically nonspecific host inflammatory cell response prior to cellular transformation. The lack of induction of this cytolysis-susceptible phenotype by Ad12 E1A may result in an increased persistence of Ad12-infected cells in vivo and may lead to an increased Ad12-transformed cell burden for the host.     

Association between the cellular p53 and the adenovirus 5 E1B-55kd proteins reduces the oncogenicity of Ad-transformed cells.

The association of the cellular p53 protein with the E1B-55kd protein of adenovirus 5 (Ad5) is thought to result in inactivation of the p53 recessive oncogene product. Here we show that Ad5 E1-transformed 3Y1 rat cells which express low levels of the 55 kd E1B protein do not contain the p53-E1B 55kd complex. These cells have nuclearly located p53 and are highly oncogenic in nude mice. In 3Y1 cells expressing the E1B protein at a sufficiently high level, association between p53 and E1B-55kd occurs, resulting in an almost complete trapping of p53 into a discrete cytoplasmic body. These cells only form tumors after a very long latency period and in the tumors that eventually appear selection has occurred in favor of cells lacking the complex and containing free nuclear p53. Comparable results were found when highly oncogenic Ad12-transformed cells were supertransfected with the Ad5 E1B region. In none of the Ad-transformed mouse, rat and human cell lines examined, could we detect p53 of abnormal molecular weight or association with hsc70, neither could we immunoprecipitate p53 by the mutant specific antibody PAb240. These data suggest that a high level of nuclear p53 with a wild-type conformation contributes to the oncogenicity of Ad transformed cells.     

Mutations in the E1a gene of type 5 adenovirus result in oncogenic transformation of Fischer rat embryo cells

Transformation of a specific clone of Fischer rat embryo (CREF) cells with wild-type 5 adenovirus (Ad5) or the E1a plus E1b transforming gene regions of Ad5 results in epithelioid transformants that grow efficiently in agar but that do not induce tumors when inoculated into nude mice or syngeneic Fischer rats. In contrast, CREF cells transformed by a host-range Ad5 mutant, H5hrl, which contains a single base-pair deletion of nucleotide 1055 in E1a resulting in a 28-kd protein (calculated) in place of the wild-type 51-kd acidic protein, display a cold-sensitive transformation phenotype and an incomplete fibroblastic morphology but surprisingly do induce tumors in nude mice and syngeneic rats. Tumors develop in both types of animals following injection of CREF cells transformed by other cold-sensitive Ad5 E1a mutants (H5dl101 and H5in106), which contain alterations in their 13S mRNA and consequently truncated 289AA proteins. CREF cells transformed with only the E1a gene (0-4.5 m.u.) from H5hrl or H5dl101 also produce tumors in these animals. To directly determine the role of the 13S E1a encoded 289AA protein and the 12S E1a encoded 243AA protein in initiating an oncogenic phenotype in adenovirus-transformed CREF cells, we generated transformed cell lines following infection with the Ad2 mutant pm975, which synthesizes the 289AA E1a protein but not the 243AA protein, and the Ad5 mutant H5dl520 and the Ad2 mutant H2dl1500, which do not produce the 289AA E1a protein but synthesize the normal 243AA E1a protein. All three types of mutant adenovirus-transformed CREF cells induced tumors in nude mice and syngeneic rats. Tumor formation by these mutant adenovirus-transformed CREF cells was not associated with changes in the arrangement of integrated adenovirus DNA or in the expression of adenovirus early genes. These results indicate, therefore, that oncogenic transformation of CREF cells can occur in the presence of a wild-type 13S E1a protein or a wild-type 12S E1a protein when either protein is present alone, but does not occur when both wild-type E1a proteins are present.     

Adenovirus early region 1B 58,000-dalton tumor antigen is physically associated with an early region 4 25,000-dalton protein in productively infected cells.

In soluble protein extracts obtained from adenovirus productively infected cells, monoclonal antibodies directed against the early region 1B 58,000-dalton (E1B-58K) protein immunoprecipitated, in addition to this protein, a polypeptide of 25,000 molecular weight. An analysis of tryptic peptides derived from this 25K protein demonstrated that it was unrelated to the E1B-58K protein. The tryptic peptide maps of the 25K protein produced in adenovirus 5 (Ad5)-infected HeLa cells and BHK cells were identical, whereas Ad3-infected HeLa cells produced a different 25K protein. The viral origin of this 25K protein was confirmed by an amino acid sequence determination of five methionine residues in two Ad2 tryptic peptides derived from the 25K protein. The positions of these methionine residues in the 25K protein were compared with the nucleotide sequence of Ad2 and uniquely mapped the gene for this protein to early region 4, subregion 6 of the viral genome. A mutant of Ad5 was obtained (Ad5 dl342) which failed to produce detectable levels of the E1B-58K protein. In HeLa cells infected with this mutant, monoclonal antibodies directed against the E1B-58K protein failed to detect the associated 25K protein. In 293 cells infected with Ad5 dl342, which contain an E1B-58K protein encoded by the integrated adenovirus genome, the mutant produced an E4-25K protein which associated with the E1B-58K protein derived from the integrated genome. Extracts of labeled Ad5 dl342-infected HeLa cells (E1B-58K-) were mixed in vitro with extracts of unlabeled Ad5 wild type-infected HeLa cells or 293 cells (E1B-58K+). When the mixed extracts were incubated with the E1B-58K monoclonal antibody, a labeled E4-25K protein was coimmunoprecipitated. When extracts of Ad5 dl342-infected HeLa cells and uninfected HeLa cells (both E1B-58K-) were mixed, the E1B-58K monoclonal antibody failed to immunoselect the E4-25K protein. These data provide evidence that the E1B-58K antigen is physically associated with an E4-25K protein in productively infected cells. This is the same E1B-58K protein that was previously shown to be associated with the cellular p53 antigen in adenovirus-transformed cells.     

Adenovirus E1A-mediated regulation of class I MHC expression.

Expression of class I MHC transplantation antigens has been shown to be reduced in baby rat kidney (BRK) cells transformed by highly oncogenic adenovirus type 12 (Ad12), as compared with untransformed cells and cells transformed by non-oncogenic Ad5. Here we show that this reduction of class I expression also occurs in a variety of other primary cell cultures transformed by Ad12, and that reduction of class I gene expression occurs for all class I loci. Transfection of Ad5E1 into class I-negative Ad12-transformed BRK cells leads to complete restoration of class I expression. Introduction of Ad12E1 into most class I-positive established cell lines does not result in suppression of class I expression. However, transfection of the Ad12E1A region into a class I-positive cell line which was immortalized by a mutant Ad12E1A region resulted in suppression of class I gene expression, implying that the suppression of class I activity in Ad12-transformed cells is due to an active switching-off process.     

Adenovirus type 9 E4 open reading frame 1 encodes a transforming protein required for the production of mammary tumors in rats.

The E4 region of human adenovirus type 9 (Ad9) transforms established rat embryo fibroblasts and encodes an essential determinant for the production of estrogen-dependent mammary tumors in rats. Testing of the seven Ad9 E4 open reading frames (ORFs) individually for transformation of the established rat embryo fibroblast cell line CREF indicated that only Ad9 E4 ORF1 possessed a significant ability to generate transformed foci on these cells. In contrast, the E4 ORF1 sequences from human Ad5 and Ad12 lacked the transforming potential exhibited by Ad9 E4 ORF1. Cell lines derived from Ad9 E4 ORF1-transformed foci expressed the 14-kDa Ad9 E4 ORF1 protein and formed colonies in soft agar. In addition, the Ad9 E4 ORF1 protein was required for initiation of mammary oncogenesis in vivo, as E4 ORF1 mutant viruses failed while E4 ORF2 and ORF3 mutant viruses succeeded in eliciting mammary tumors in animals. A role for Ad9 E4 ORF1 in tumor maintenance was suggested by the fact that 100% of virus-induced mammary tumors expressed the E4 ORF1 protein. Taken together, the facts that the Ad9 E4 ORF1 protein exhibits transforming potential in culture and is required by Ad9 to produce mammary tumors in animals suggest that Ad9 E4 ORF1 is a new viral oncoprotein.