The uptake and utilization of Entodinium caudatum, bacteria, free amino acids and glucose by the rumen ciliate Entodinium bursa

C oleman , G.S. & H all , F.J. 1984. The uptake and utilization of Entodinium caudatum , bacteria, free amino acids and glucose by the rumen ciliate Entodinium bursa. Journal of Applied Bacteriology 56 , 283–294.
Washed suspensions of Entodinium bursa were incubated anaerobically with Entodinium caudatum , ten species of bacteria and a yeast. The rate of uptake and digestion of these micro-organisms was investigated. Protozoa grown in vivo did not engulf Proteus mirabilis or Klebsiella aerogenes but rapidly took up Bacillus mega-terium, Selenomonas ruminantium, Torulopsis glabrata and Streptococcus bouis , although only the last was digested with release of soluble material into the medium. Protozoa grown in vitro engulfed each of the bacteria tested, taking up Megasphaera elsdenii and i>Proteus mirabilis most rapidly. Individual bacterial species and mixed rumen bacteria were engulfed more rapidly (up to 20 times) by protozoa grown in vivo than those grown in vitro , although the latter digested over 80% of the B. megaterium, Escherichia coli and P. mirabilis taken up. Labelled Ent. caudatum was extensively digested after engulfment by Ent. bursa . Some of the digestion products were released into the medium but individual amino acids were transferred as such from Ent. caudatum protein to Ent. bursa protein. Engulfed bacteria and polysaccharide granules were transferred intact from one protozoon to the other. Free amino acids were also taken up intact from the medium into protozoal protein but there was little biosynthesis of amino acids from glucose. When available for engulfment Ent. caudatum was quantitatively a much more valuable source of amino acids for protein synthesis by Ent. bursa than free amino acids or bacteria.     

In vitro determination of generation times for Entodinium exiguum, Ophryoscolex purkynjei and Eudiplodinium maggii

ABSTRACT. Most previously reported generation times for rumen ciliate protozoa are longer than would be required to prevent their being flushed out of the rumen. In an earlier study from this lab, using a sequential transfer procedure, generation times between 12 and 13 h were determined for both Epidinium caudatum and Entodinium caudatum . This would permit these species to be maintained in a rumen with a fluid volume turnover rate as rapid as twice a day. In this study, generation times were estimated for Entodinium exiguum (13.2 h), Eudiplodinium maggii (26.8 h), and Ophryoscolex purkynjei (29 h), by sequential transfer at both 12 and 24 h time periods. The generation time for E. exiguum is lower than reported for this and other Entodinium species as determined by logarithmic growth from a small inoculum, but similar to that obtained for Ent. caudatum using sequential transfer. Eudiplodinium maggii and O. purkynjei generation times are similar to previous estimates of 24- and 24–48 h, respectively. However, it was observed that after an adaptation period of 36 to 48 h (generally 3–4 transfers) cell concentrations decreased and generation times were markedly decreased, i.e. 12.2 h for Ent. exiguum , 15.0 h for E. maggii and 12.8 h for O. purkynjei . In a separate study, varying both the concentration of Epidinium and the quantity of substrate fed per cell had no effect on generation time.     

The cultivation of the rumen ciliate Entodinium bursa in the presence of Entodinium caudatum.

The rumen ciliate protozoon Entodinium bursa has been grown in vitro in the presence of bacteria and Entodinium caudatum for over a year at population densities of 100 to 200 ml-1. The medium contained potassium phosphate, prepared fresh rumen fluid, cysteine, wholemeal flour (or rice starch), dried grass and a culture of the spineless form of Entodinium caudatum. Entodinium bursa has an obligate requirement for this protozoon and died within 48 h in its absence. During growth from a 2% inoculum, the mean generation time of E. bursa was 6 h. Entodinium bursa engulfed 1-5 to 2-5 E. caudatum organisms h-1, and when E. caudatum was in excess it developed caudal spines for the first time in 17 years; these spined forms were engulfed much less readily than the spineless organisms.     

The uptake and utilization of Entodinium caudatum, bacteria, free amino acids and glucose by the rumen ciliate Entodinium bursa

Washed suspensions of Entodinium bursa were incubated anaerobically with Entodinium caudatum, ten species of bacteria and a yeast. The rate of uptake and digestion of these micro-organisms was investigated. Protozoa grown in vivo did not engulf Proteus mirabilis or Klebsiella aerogenes but rapidly took up Bacillus megaterium. Selenomonas ruminantium, Torulopsis glabrata and Streptococcus bovis, although only the last was digested with release of soluble material into the medium. Protozoa grown in vitro engulfed each of the bacteria tested, taking up Megasphaera elsdenii and Proteus mirabilis most rapidly. Individual bacterial species and mixed rumen bacteria were engulfed more rapidly (up to 20 times) by protozoa grown in vivo than those grown in vitro, although the latter digested over 80% of the B. megaterium, Escherichia coli and P. mirabilis taken up. Labelled Ent. caudatum was extensively digested after engulfment by Ent. bursa. Some of the digestion products were released into the medium but individual amino acids were transferred as such from Ent. caudatum protein to Ent. bursa protein. Engulfed bacteria and polysaccharide granules were transferred intact from one protozoon to the other. Free amino acids were also taken up intact from the medium into protozoal protein but there was little biosynthesis of amino acids from glucose. When available for engulfment Ent. caudatum was quantitatively a much more valuable source of amino acids for protein synthesis by Ent. bursa than free amino acids or bacteria.     

Growth Factors of Bacterial Origin for the Culture of the Rumen Oligotrich Protozoon, Entodinium caudatum

Attempts were made to develop an artificial medium suitable for axenic culture of Entodinium caudatum. Agnotobiotic cultures of the protozoon were established as stock cultures for testing the suitability of various growth media. A cell-free extract of mixed bacteria isolated from the rumen was shown to contain one or more growth factors for the protozoon when supplied with activated charcoal as a carrier. The medium (CYSE medium), which supported the growth of the protozoon in the presence of 50 μg/ml each of penicillin and chloramphenicol, consisted of activated charcoal (20 mg), heat-treated yeast (Y) (80 mg), 13%β-sitosterol-coated rice starch (S) (120 mg), and cell-free extract of rumen bacteria (1 ml) in 40 ml buffer solution. When culturing the protozoon, the CYSE medium was supplemented daily with 20 mg each of Y and S and half of the medium was replaced with fresh medium once every 5 d. The possible use of this method to establish an axenic culture of E. caudatum is discussed.     

Methanogenesis in rumen ciliate cultures ofEntodinium caudatum andEpidinium ecaudatum after long-term cultivation in a chemically defined medium

The methanogenic activity in the presence of Entodinium caudatum and Epidinium ecaudatum was well preserved after long-term cultivation. Microscopic observation revealed that methane production in the presence of E. caudatum was probably caused by their intracellular methanogenic activity, while methane production in the presence of E. ecaudatum f caudatum et ecaudatum could be attributed to both the methanogenic bacterial fraction of their external surface and their intracellular activity. Methane production per protozoan cell of E. caudatum and E. ecaudatum was 2.1 nmol per cell per d and 6.0 nmol per cell per d, respectively. E. caudatum was responsible for almost the entire methane production in the culture. The activity of free methanogens constituted approximately 50% of the total methane production in the E. ecaudatum culture. Decrease of digestibility of substrates and differences in the fermentation end products accompanied the inhibition of methanogenesis in both cultures by penicillin G, streptomycin, chloramphenicol, 2-bromoethanesulfonate, and pyromellitic diimide. E. caudatum appeared to be more sensitive than E. ecaudatum to the compounds tested. Hydrogen recoveries based on both volatile fatty acids and methane production suggested that the methanogenic population appeared not to be fully able to consume hydrogen produced in the protozoan cultures. The culture conditions tested were found to be suitable for experiments on the relationship between rumen ciliates and rumen bacteria.     

Phylogeny of the Rumen Ciliates Entodinium, Epidinium and Polyplastron (Litostomatea: Entodiniomorphida) Inferred from Small Subunit Ribosomal RNA Sequences

ABSTRACT. Three complete 18S ribosomal RNA gene sequences from the rumen ciliates, Entodinium coudatum (1,639 bp), Epidinium caudarum (1,638 bp), and Polyplastron multivesiculatum (1,640 bp) were determined and confrimed in the opposite direction. Trees produced using maximum parsimony and distance-matrix methods (lest squares and neighbour-joining). with strong bootstrap support, depict the rumen ciliates as a monophyletic group, Entodinium caudatum is the earliest branching rumen ciliate. However, Entodiniwn simplex does not pair with En. caudatum , but rather with Polyplastron multivesiculatum. Signature sequences for these rumen ciliates reveal that the published SSrRNA gene sequence from En. simplex is in fact a Polyoplastron species. The free-living haptorian ciliates, Loxophyllum, Homalozoon and Spathidium (Subclass Hoptoria), are monophyletic and are the sister group to the rumen cilates. The litostomes (class Litostomatea), consisting of the haptorians and the rumen ciliates, are also a monophyletic group.     

The 3' untranslated region of messages in the rumen protozoan Entodinium caudatum

The 3' untranslated regions of a number of cDNAs from the rumen protozoal species Entodinium caudatum were studied with a view to characterising their preference for stop codons, general length, nucleotide composition and polyadenylation signals. Unlike a number of ciliates, Entodinium caudatum uses UAA as a stop codon, rather than as a codon for glutamine. In addition, the 3' untranslated region of the message is generally less than 100 nucleotides in length, extremely A+T rich, and does not appear to utilise any of the conventional polyadenylation signals described in other organisms.     

Bacterial Ingestion by the Rumen Ciliates Entodinium and Diplodinium

SYNOPSIS. In cattle fed a high-starch diet, species of Entodinium and Diplodinium ingested associated ruminal bacteria. Stained preparations of diluted rumen contents showed Entodinium caudatum, E. minimum, E. dubardi , (syn. E. simplex ), E. longinucleatum, E. bursa, E. nanellum, E. exiguum , and E. vorax contained gram-positive diplococci. Starch grains with adherent gram-positive diplococci were observed within Entodinium spp. Diplodinium ecaudatum forma ecaudatum, D. ecaudatum forma caudatum, D. neglectum and an unidentified species of Diplodinium also ingested ruminal diplococci. Bacteria were isolated from mixed species of Entodinium by washing and culturing the protozoa in a starch feed-extract agar medium. The strains isolated from the ciliates were gram-positive diplococci, 0.8 times 1–1.5 μm, which attached themselves to starch granules and were able to digest the starch. Conclusive evidence of bacterial ingestion by the oligotrichs was obtained by providing the bacterial cultures to Entodinium species ( E. dubardi and E. minimum ) which had been starved 24 hr. Gram-stained preparations showed the ciliates readily ingested the bacteria. The amylolytic cocci utilized by Entodinium spp. were identified as Streptococcus bovis.     

An NAD(+)-dependent glutamate dehydrogenase cloned from the ruminal ciliate protozoan, Entodinium caudatum

An NAD(+)-dependent glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH; EC 1.4.1.24) was cloned from the ruminal ciliate protozoan, Entodinium caudatum. The gene had high sequence similarity to GDH genes from the Bacteroides (class)--a class of bacteria which is highly represented in the rumen. When expressed in Escherichia coli the enzyme had a high affinity for ammonia and alpha-ketoglutarate (apparent K(m) of 2.33 and 0.71 mM, respectively) and a low affinity for glutamate (apparent K(m) of 98 mM). GDH activity and GDH mRNA concentration were increased by incubating washed E. caudatum cells with ammonia and antibiotics. These results suggest that the GDH is an anabolic enzyme catalysing the assimilation of ammonia by E. caudatum in the rumen and that the gene was probably acquired by lateral gene transfer from a ruminal bacterium.     

Preliminary study on the requirements of Entodinium exiguum and E. caudatum for live or dead bacteria when cultured in vitro

Whether live bacteria are required to culture the rumen protozoa Entodinium exiguum and E. caudatum in vitro was studied. Treatments were protozoa plus antibiotics (PA), PA plus autoclaved bacteria (PAB) or protozoa plus live bacteria (PLB). Generation times at 24 h were 22.8 and 31.0 h for E. exiguum and E. caudatum. Protozoal concentrations were unaffected by the absence of bacteria up to 48 h. After 72 h, E. exiguum, concentrations were higher in PLB than PA or PAB. With E. caudatum differences between PLB and PA were only observed at 96 h. Thus, a requirement for live bacteria appears to be manifested in culture periods longer than 48 (E. exiguum) and 72 (E. caudatum) h. Although differences between PLB and PAB indicate a metabolic dependence for bacteria or a long-term antibiotic effect, non-significant differences between PAB and PA suggest that the effect is also related to a nutritive bacterial contribution.     

Effect of nisin on two cultures of rumen ciliates

The effect of nisin (in the form of Nisaplin) was determined using two species of rumen ciliate protozoa in vitro, on their co-culture bacterial population, and volatile fatty acid concentration. Nisaplin did not affect the in vitro growth of Entodinium caudatum at concentrations of 50-400 mg/L during short-term treatment (5 d). Long-term application (30 d) of Nisaplin (100 mg/L) significantly decreased growth of the Epidinium ecaudatum forma caudatum et ecaudatum but not growth of E. caudatum. Nisaplin moderately supported the growth of E. caudatum after omission of wheat gluten (source of amino acids for protozoan growth). An inhibition of Gram-positive facultative anaerobic bacterial population in the protozoan cultures (lactobacilli, enterococci, staphylococci and amylolytic streptococci) was observed during long-term Nisaplin treatment. The concentration of volatile fatty acids significantly increased during the long-term Nisaplin treatment of both cultures. The propionate concentration in the mixture of volatile fatty acids was nearly twice higher on the account of the decreased concentration (from 74 to 63%) of acetate.     

Two-step freezing procedure for cryopreservation of rumen ciliates,an effective tool for creation of a frozen rumen protozoa bank

The present study aimed at the long-term storage of rumen protozoa as living cells in liquid nitrogen. The two-step or interrupted slow freezing procedure was used to cryopreserve six of the dominant species of rumen ciliates isolated from monofaunated animals, Dasytricha ruminantium, Entodinium caudatum, Epidinium ecaudatum caudatum, Eudiplodinium maggii, Isotricha prostoma, and Polyplastron multivesiculatum. We optimized the first step in the interrupted slow freezing procedure, from the extracellular ice nucleation temperature to the holding temperature, and studied the effects of the cooling rates on survival. In addition to the nature of the cryoprotectant (dimethyl sulfoxide), the equilibration temperature and equilibration time (25 degrees C and 5 min, respectively), and the holding time at subzero temperature (45 min) recommended previously (S. Kisidayová, J. Microbiol. Methods 22:185-192, 1995), we found that a holding temperature of -30 degrees C, a cooling rate from extracellular ice nucleation temperature to holding temperature of between 1.2 degrees C/min and 2.5 degrees C/min, depending on the ciliate, and rumen juice as the freezing and thawing medium markedly improved the survival rate. Survival rates determined after 2 weeks in liquid nitrogen were 100% for Isotricha, 98% for Dasytricha, 85% for Epidinium, 79% for Polyplastron, 63% for Eudiplodinium, and 60% for Entodinium. They were not significantly modified after a period of 1 year in liquid nitrogen. Four of the five ciliate species cryopreserved for 8 months in liquid nitrogen successfully colonized the rumen when inoculated into defaunated animals. These results have made it possible to set up a bank of cryopreserved rumen protozoa.     

Effect of insulin on in vitro fermentation activity of microrganism community of rumen ciliate Entodinium caudatum culture

The influence of insulin (17.4 nmol l-1) on total gas and methane production, the concentration of total and individual fatty acids and dry matter degradability was investigated in the rumen ciliate culture of Entodinium caudatum. The experimental groups consisted of control group (without insulin) and two groups with insulin application--single shot and long-term application (over 30 days). Fermentation activity of each experimental group was observed on two subgroups: whole protozoan culture (protozoa plus bacteria) and bacterial fraction (bacteria without protozoa). Long-term application of insulin significantly increased methane production and DM degradability in the whole protozoan culture. Total VFA concentration was significantly increased by long-term as well as single-dose application of insulin (by 255% and 158%, respectively). The growth of the protozoa was not influenced by insulin treatments. It can be concluded that the fermentation activity of the community of the rumen ciliate Entodinium caudatum culture was marked stimulated by application of insulin.     

Effect of the rumen ciliates Entodinium caudatum, Epidinium ecaudatum and Eudiplodinium maggii, and combinations thereof, on ruminal fermentation and total tract digestion in sheep

The quantitative importance of individual ciliate species and their interaction in the rumen is still unclear. The present study was performed to test whether there are species differences in the influence on ruminal fermentation in vivo and if combinations of ciliates act additive in that respect. Six adult wethers fed a hay-concentrate diet were defaunated, then refaunated either with Entodinium caudatum (EC), Epidinium ecaudatum (EE) or Eudiplodinium maggii (EM) alone, then progressively with all possible species combinations. Feed, faeces, urine, ruminal fluid and gas were sampled for eight days always after at least 21 days of adaptation. With a linear mixed model, accounting for the 2 x 2 x 2 full factorial study design, mean marginal effect sizes, i.e., the magnitude of change in variables as caused by the presence of each ciliate species or of combinations of them, were estimated. The apparent digestibility of organic matter and neutral detergent fibre remained unaffected. The apparent N digestibility increased by 0.054 with EM (0.716 with defaunation). Ruminal ammonia increased by 1.6, 4.0 and 8.7 mmol/l in the presence of EM, EC and EE, respectively, compared to defaunation (6.9 mmol/l). In the EM + EE combination, ruminal ammonia was lower than would have been expected from an additive effect. With EE, total short-chain fatty acids increased by 23 mmol/l (100 mmol/l with defaunation), but not when EE was combined with EM. The acetate-to-propionate ratio decreased by 0.73 units in the presence of EE (4.0 with defaunation), but only when EE was the sole ciliate species in the rumen. In the presence of any ciliate species, the 16S rDNA copies of total Bacteria and major fibrolytic species decreased to 0.52- and 0.22-fold values, respectively of that found without protozoa. Total Archaea were unaffected; however, Methanobacteriales copies increased 1.44-fold with EC. The CH4-to-CO2 ratio of ruminal gas decreased by 0.036 with EM and 0.051 with EE (0.454 with defaunation). In conclusion, individual ciliates affected ruminal fermentation differently and, when different species were combined, sometimes in a non-additive manner. From the ciliates investigated, EE affected ruminal fermentation most and might play a dominant role in mixed ciliate populations.     

The effect of sterols and haemin on the growth of the rumen ciliate Ophryoscolex caudatus and some other Entodiniomorphid protozoa

Seven isolates of Ophryoscolex caudatus have been cultured anaerobically in vitro (at a population density of 56/ml) for an average of 18 months each in the presence of bacteria on a reduced buffered salts medium containing prepared fresh rumen fluid with the daily addition of ground wheat and dried grass and with twice weekly dilution of the culture with an equal volume of fresh medium. The ground wheat and dried grass could be replaced by ground wheat coated with β-sitosterol, stigmasterol, ergosterol or α-spinasterol and with β-sitosterol the population density increased to 110/ml. Haemin further increased the population density obtained in the presence of sterol by 9–160%. The population density of cultures of Epidinium ecaudatum caudatum was also increased by sterols and haemin, that of Polyplastron multivesiculatum by sterols only, and some sterols and haemin, under certain conditions, increased that of Entodinium caudatum.     

The catabolism of phosphatidylethanolamine by the rumen protozoon Entodinium caudatum and its conversion into the N-(1-carboxyethyl) derivative

1. The N-(2-hydroxyethyl)alanine esterified to phosphatidic acid in anaerobic ciliate rumen protozoa has the l configuration. 2. Labelling experiments with Entodinium caudatum cultures using [(32)P]P(i) [2-(14)C]ethanolamine and (32)P- and (14)C-labelled phosphatidylethanolamine show that phosphatidylethanolamine is the direct lipid precursor of the N-(2-hydroxyethyl)alanine-containing phospholipid. 3. Labelling experiments with [(14)C]starch, [(14)C]lactate and [(14)C]pyruvate with E. caudatum cultures indicate that a three-carbon glycolytic intermediate is probably the precursor of the N-(1-carboxyethyl) grouping which substitutes on the amino group of phosphatidylethanolamine. 4. [(32)P]phosphatidylethanolamine is catabolized by E. caudatum forming initially glycerylphosphorylethanolamine and subsequently glycerophosphate and P(i). A little phosphorylethanolamine formed may possibly arise from bacterial enzymes ingested by the protozoa.     

Phospholipid biosynthesis in the anaerobic protozoon Entodinium caudatum.

1. The anaerobic rumen protozoon Entodinium caudatum was incubated either intact or with various radioactive precursors of phospholipids after ultrasonication. 2. Pulse-chase experiments showed a rapid turnover of phosphatidylinositol and much slower turnovers of phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylcholine. 3. E. caudatum imbibed choline very rapidly; this was immediately and exclusively converted into phosphatidylcholine which was shown by radioautography after 10 min to be distributed throughout the cell membranes. 4. Phosphatidylcholine was synthesized through a phosphorylcholine-CDP-choline pathway, the methylation or base-exchange pathways not being present. 5. Under suitable conditions [Me-14C]choline can be substantially (50-60%) converted into CDP-choline by sonicated E. caudatum and this provides an excellent method of preparing this biosynthetic intermediary. 6. [2-14C]Ethanolamine was taken up much less readily than choline. The former was incorporated into phosphatidylethanolamine by the CDP-ethanolamine pathway. 7. Doubly labelled [32P]phosphatidyl[2-3H]ethanolamine was converted into ceramide phosphorylethanolamine and N-(1-carboxyethyl)phosphatidyl-ethanolamine, without change in the isotopic ratio. Ceramide phosphoryl [2-14C]-ethanolamine was converted into phsophatidylethanolamine. 8. Palmitic acid, oleic acid and linoleic acid were taken by E. caudatum cells and incorporated into phospholipids. By contrast, although stearic acid was taken up it was hardly incorporated into phospholipids.     

A cryopreservation procedure for the rumen protozoon Entodinium caudatum: estimation of its viability by fluorescence microscopy

AIMS: To study the viability of a culture of the rumen protozoon Entodinium caudatum after a cryopreservation procedure by a fluorescence microscopy staining method. METHODS AND RESULTS: Fluorescence method is based on the different colour of cells depending on their membrane integrity. When the temperature effect was studied either by fluorescence or motility, the techniques were correlated (r = 0.727) and their slopes and intercepts were not different (P > 0.05). However, motility showed a higher variation coefficient (0.40 vs 0.12). There were no differences between cooling rates at cryopreservation (1 and 4 degrees C min-1) at 38, 15 or 5 degrees C, nor after thawing. CONCLUSIONS: Fluorescence staining is more accurate than motility for assessing protozoal viability. Viability after thawing was 0.50, and the number of viable cells per 250 microl straw was 320 and 420 for 1 and 4 degrees C min-1. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This cryopreservation procedure seems to ensure culture recovery for E. caudatum.     

Suitability of different media for in vitro cultivation of the ruminal protozoa species Entodinium caudatum, Eudiplodinium maggii, and Epidinium ecaudatum

Three protozoal cultivation media were tested to determine the medium which best facilitated growth and viability of key B-type ciliates isolated from the sheep rumen. Entodinium caudatum and Eudiplodinium maggii were grown anaerobically in 50-ml flasks for 32 days in Caudatum-type (C), Kisidayova (K) or Dehority (M) medium. On day 32, in media K and M, E. caudatum cell counts were high with 5.6 × 10³ and 7.8 × 10³ mL⁻¹, respectively, and the proportion of dead cells was low with 0.6 and 1.4%, respectively. E. maggii concentrations when grown in medium M and C were 2.7 × 10³ and 2.4 × 10³ mL⁻¹, respectively, with 3.9 and 14.1% dead cells. Medium M, which favoured growth of both protozoa species, was tested again and Epidinium ecaudatum was included. Protozoa were grown for a 4-month period and samples were taken in the last two months on days 1, 7, 35 and 57. Average cell concentrations were 10.0, 0.8 and 0.5 × 10³ mL⁻¹ for E. caudatum, E. maggii, and E. ecaudatum, respectively. In conclusion, medium M would appear to be the best choice for cultivating these three species in one medium.