Real-time detection of cruciform extrusion by single-molecule DNA nanomanipulation

During cruciform extrusion, a DNA inverted repeat unwinds and forms a four-way junction in which two of the branches consist of hairpin structures obtained by self-pairing of the inverted repeats. Here, we use single-molecule DNA nanomanipulation to monitor in real-time cruciform extrusion and rewinding. This allows us to determine the size of the cruciform to nearly base pair accuracy and its kinetics with second-scale time resolution. We present data obtained with two different inverted repeats, one perfect and one imperfect, and extend single-molecule force spectroscopy to measure the torque dependence of cruciform extrusion and rewinding kinetics. Using mutational analysis and a simple two-state model, we find that in the transition state intermediate only the B-DNA located between the inverted repeats (and corresponding to the unpaired apical loop) is unwound, implying that initial stabilization of the four-way (or Holliday) junction is rate-limiting. We thus find that cruciform extrusion is kinetically regulated by features of the hairpin loop, while rewinding is kinetically regulated by features of the stem. These results provide mechanistic insight into cruciform extrusion and help understand the structural features that determine the relative stability of the cruciform and B-form states.     

Comparison of physical and genetic properties of palindromic DNA sequences.

Some viable palindromic DNA sequences were found to cause an increase in the recovery of genetic recombinants. Although these palindromes contained no Chi sites, their presence in cis caused apparent recA+-dependent recombination to increase severalfold. This biological property did not correlate with the physical properties of the palindromes' extrusion of cruciform structures in vitro. Thus, two unrelated palindromes with similar effects on recombination in both Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas syringae displayed quite different kinetics of cruciform formation. In plasmids of native superhelical density, one palindrome underwent rapid cruciform formation at 55 degrees C, whereas the other did not form detectable cruciforms at any temperature. A shorter palindrome with similarly rapid kinetics of cruciform formation did not affect recombination detectably. The lack of a clear relationship between physical and genetic properties was also demonstrated in the case of longer, inviable palindromes. Here we found that the degree of asymmetry required in vivo to rescue a long palindrome from inviability far exceeded that required to kinetically prohibit cruciform extrusion in vitro.     

Effect of magnesium on cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA.

Recently, it was reported that Mg2+greatly facilitates cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes of supercoiled DNA, thereby allowing the formation of cruciform structures in vivo. Because of the potential biological importance of this phenomenon, we undertook a broader study of the effect of Mg2+on a cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA. The method of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to detect the cruciform extrusion both in the absence and in the presence of these ions. Our results show that Mg2+shifts the cruciform extrusion in the d(CCC(AT)16GGG) palindrome to a higher, rather than to a lower level of supercoiling. In order to study possible sequence-specific properties of the short palindromes for which the unusual cruciform extrusion in the presence Mg2+was reported, we constructed a plasmid with a longer palindromic region. This region bears the same sequences in the hairpin loops and four-arm junction as the short palindrome, except that the short stems of the hairpins are extended. The extension allowed us to overcome the limitation of our experimental approach which cannot be used for very short palindromes. Our results show that Mg2+also shifts the cruciform extrusion in this palindrome to a higher level of supercoiling. These data suggest that cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes at low supercoiling is highly improbable. We performed a thermodynamic analysis of the effect of Mg2+on cruciform extrusion. The treatment accounted for the effect of Mg2+on both free energy of supercoiling and the free energy of cruciform structure per se. Our analysis showed that although the level of supercoiling required for the cruciform extrusion is not reduced by Mg2+, the ions reduce the free energy of the cruciform structure.     

The Effects of Nucleotide Sequence Changes on DNA Secondary Structure Formation in Escherichia Coli Are Consistent with Cruciform Extrusion in Vivo

The construction in bacteriophage λ of a set of long DNA palindromes with paired changes in the central sequence is described. Identical palindrome centers were previously used by others to test the S-type model for cruciform extrusion in vitro. Long DNA palindromes prevent the propagation of carrier phage λ on a wild-type host, and the sbcC mutation is sufficient to almost fully alleviate this inviability. The plaque areas produced by the palindrome containing phages were compared on an Escherichia coli sbcC lawn. Central sequence changes had a greater effect upon the plaque area than peripheral changes, implying that the residual palindrome-mediated inviability in E. coli sbcC is center-dependent and could be due to the formation of a cruciform structure. The results argue strongly that intrastrand pairing within palindromes is critical in determining their effects in vivo. In addition, the same data suggests that DNA loops in vivo may sometimes contain two bases only.     

Stability and structure of three-way DNA junctions containing unpaired nucleotides.

Non-paired nucleotides stabilize the formation of three-way helical DNA junctions. Two or more unpaired nucleotides located in the junction region enable oligomers ten to fifteen nucleotides long to assemble, forming conformationally homogeneous junctions, as judged by native gel electrophoresis. The unpaired bases can be present on the same strand or on two different strands. Up to five extra bases on one strand have been tested and found to produce stable junctions. The formation of stable structures is favored by the presence of a divalent cation such as magnesium and by high monovalent salt concentration. The order-disorder transition of representative three-way junctions was monitored optically in the ultraviolet and analyzed to quantify thermodynamically the stabilization provided by unpaired bases in the junction region. We report the first measurements of the thermodynamics of adding an unpaired nucleotide to a nucleic acid three-way junction. We find that delta delta G degrees (37 degrees C) = +0.5 kcal/mol for increasing the number of unpaired adenosines from two to three. Three-way junctions having reporter arms 40 base-pairs long were also prepared. Each of the three reporter arms contained a unique restriction site 15 base-pairs from the junction. Asymmetric complexes produced by selectively cleaving each arm were analyzed on native gels. Cleavage of the double helical arm opposite the strand having the two extra adenosines resulted in a complex that migrated more slowly than complexes produced by cleavage at either of the other two arms. It is likely that the strand containing the unpaired adenosines is kinked at an acute angle, forming a Y-shaped, rather than a T-shaped junction.     

Influence of DNA sequence and supercoiling on the process of cruciform formation

We have studied some of the effects of DNA sequence and negative superhelicity on the rate of cruciform formation. Replacing the sequence AATT at the center of a perfect 68 base-pair palindromic sequence with the sequence CCCGGG decreases the rate of cruciform formation by a factor of at least 100. The logarithm of the rate constant of cruciform formation was found to increase linearly with linking difference. For the 68 base-pair perfect palindrome in a 4400 base-pair plasmid, each additional negative superhelical turn increased the rate of cruciform formation by a factor of 1.6. These results are consistent with a mechanism in which cruciform formation is initiated by the formation of a single-stranded bubble, 10 base-pairs in length, near the center of the palindromic sequence. In addition, we have examined the effect of introducing an asymmetric insertion into the palindromic sequence.     

Sequence and structural requirements of a herpes simplex viral DNA replication origin.

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) types 1 and 2 contain two classes of origins of DNA replication, oriS and oriL, which are closely related. A series of plasmids was constructed which contained specifically altered versions of the HSV type 2 oriS replication origin. Their ability to replicate in an in vivo replicon assay allowed a core origin of 75 base pairs (bp) to be defined. It included both arms of a 56-bp palindrome and from 13 to 20 bp of sequence leftward of the palindrome. The AT-rich sequence at the center of the palindrome was essential. Sequences on either side of the core origin enhanced replication. When additional copies of the -AT-dinucleotide were introduced progressively into the center of the palindrome, an oscillating effect on origin function was observed. These and other data implicate a linear rather than a cruciform conformation of the oriS palindrome in the initiation of HSV replication.     

Structures of bulged three-way DNA junctions.

We have studied a series of three-way DNA junctions containing unpaired bases on one strand at the branch-point of the junctions. The global conformation of the arms of the junctions has been analysed by means of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, as a function of conditions. We find that in the absence of added metal ions, all the results for all the junctions can be accounted for by extended structures, with the largest angle being that between the arms defined by the strand containing the extra bases. Upon addition of magnesium (II) or hexamine cobalt (III) ions, the electrophoretic patterns change markedly, indicative of ion-dependent folding transitions for some of the junctions. For the junction lacking the unpaired bases, the three inter-arm angles appear to be quite similar, suggesting an extended structure. However, the addition of unpaired bases permits the three-way junction to adopt a significantly different structure, in which one angle becomes smaller than the other two. These species also exhibit marked protection against osmium addition to thymine bases at the point of strand exchange. These results are consistent with a model in which two of the helical arms undergo coaxial stacking in the presence of magnesium ions, with the third arm defining an angle that depends upon the number of unpaired bases.     

Construction of a DNA four-way junction: Design and NMR spectroscopy

In 1964 Holliday postulated the formation of cruciform structures (four-way junctions) in duplex DNA as intermediate in genetic recombination. Since then, many biochemical and biophysical investigations were directed at solving questions concerning structural details of stable four-way junctions. Thus far, NMR spectroscopy played a minor part in these investigations on account of the minimum size of the molecule (expressed as the number of nucleotide residues) that was thought necessary to produce a stable cruciform structure. Indeed, the smallest four-way junction studied thus far by NMR methods was built from four separate DNA strands, each containing 16 nucleotides, a total of 64. Obviously, with such a large structure one runs into assignment problems. We considered the possibility of constructing a stable four-way junction from a single strand of DNA. The underlying idea was to make use of our detailed knowledge of the building principles of stable minihairpin loops. These loops, containing only two nucleotides to bridge the gap between antiparallel strands, are maximally stable in DNA sequences like 5-d(-C-TT-G-), where C and G form a normal Watson-Crick base pair and the two T residues cross the minor groove to form the minihairpin loop. Three of such miniloops could in principle cap three arms of the cruciform. The fourth arm would have an open end. The problem to be solved is to find the minimum length that is required to insure stability of the three closed arms and of the fourth open arm. We were successful with a structure that has three short stems (four base pairs each) and an open-end stem consisting of eight base pairs, a total of 46 residues. NMR experiments, carried out on this molecule in the presence of Mg²⁺, showed details of folding which have never been observed before.     

Tautomeric and microscopic protonation equilibria of some alpha-amino acids

Although there is a wealth of structural and theoretical data relating to palindromic sequences in genomes, the mechanisms of extrusion of cruciform structures during various biological processes in the presence of intercalating agents are still poorly understood. The current study addresses the effects of temperature and intercalator on cruciform extrusion from plasmids and also considers the effects of divalent metal ions on cruciform extrusion. It presents evidence that the cytotoxic effects of certain DNA binding drugs in vivo occur over concentration ranges corresponding to those that modulate cruciform extrusion in vitro. The results confirm earlier studies showing an inverse relationship between the effects of negative superhelicity and temperature on cruciform extrusion. By extrapolation, divalent metal ions facilitate cruciform extrusion by increasing superhelicity. The results allow the concentrations that preclude cruciform extrusion in DNA to be determined, and these are potentially informative about the relationships among temperature, DNA helical winding, cruciform formation, and intercalation. Overall, we provide new and interesting insights into the potential role of cruciform structures in biology and, by implication, cancer therapy.     

Cruciform extrusion in plasmids bearing the replicative intermediate configuration of a poxvirus telomere

The transition from lineform DNA to cruciform DNA (cruciformation) within the cloned telomere sequences of the Leporipoxvirus Shope fibroma virus (SFV) has been studied. The viral telomere sequences have been cloned in recombination-deficient Escherichia coli as a 322 base-pair, imperfect palindromic insert in pUC13. The inverted repeat configuration is equivalent to the arrangement of the telomere structures observed within viral DNA replicative intermediates. A major cruciform structure in the purified recombinant plasmid has been identified and mapped using, as probes, the enzymes AflII, nuclease S1 and bacteriophage T7 endonuclease I. It was extruded from the central axis of the cloned viral inverted repeat and, by unrestricted branch migration, attained a size commensurate with the superhelical density of the plasmid molecule at native superhelical densities. This major cruciform extrusion event was the only detectable duplex DNA perturbation, induced by negative superhelical torsion, in the insert viral sequences. No significant steady-state pool of extruded cruciform was identified in E. coli. However, the identification of a major deletion variant generated even in the recombination-deficient E. coli strain DB1256 (recA recBC sbcB) suggested that the cruciform may be extruded transiently in vivo. The lineform to cruciform transition has been further characterized in vitro using two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis. The transition was marked by a high energy of formation (delta Gf = 44 kcal/mol), and an apparently low activation energy that enabled facile transitions at physiological temperatures provided there was sufficient torsional energy. By comparing cruciformation in a series of related bidirectional central axis deletions of the telomeric insert, it has been concluded that the presence of extrahelical bases in the terminal hairpin structures contributes substantially to the high delta Gf value. Also, viral sequences flanking the extruded cruciform were shown to influence the measured delta Gf value. Several general features of poxvirus telomere structure that would be expected to influence the facility of cruciform extrusion are discussed along with the implications of the observed cruciform transition event on the replicative process of poxviruses in vivo.     

Nucleosome phasing on a DNA fragment from the replication origin of simian virus 40 and rephasing upon cruciform formation of the DNA.

Nucleosomes were reconstituted in vitro from a fragment of DNA spanning the simian virus 40 minimal replication origin. The fragment contains a 27-base-pair palindrome (perfect inverted repeat). DNA molecules with stable cruciform structures were generated by heteroduplexing this DNA fragment with mutants altered within the palindromic sequence (C. Nobile and R. G. Martin, Int. Virol., in press). Analyses of the structural features of the reconstituted nucleosomes by the DNase I footprint technique revealed two alternative DNA-histone arrangements, each one accurately phased with respect to the uniquely labeled DNA ends. As linear double-stranded DNA, a unique core particle was formed in which the histones strongly protected the regions to both sides of the palindrome. The cruciform structure seemed to be unable to associate with core histones and, therefore, an alternative phasing of the histone octamer along the DNA resulted. Thus, nucleosome positioning along a specific DNA sequence appears to be influenced in vitro by the secondary structure (linear or cruciform) of the 27-base-pair palindrome. The formation of cruciform structures in vivo, if they occur, might therefore represent a molecular mechanism by which nucleosomes are phased.     

Characterization of the binding specificity of two anticruciform DNA monoclonal antibodies

Two monoclonal antibodies (2D3 and 4B4) have been raised against a stable cruciform DNA structure containing the 27-base pair palindrome of the SV40 origin of replication on one strand and an unrelated 26-base pair palindrome on the complementary strand (pRGM 21 x pRGM 29) and have been shown to recognize conformational determinants specific to cruciform DNA structures (Frappier, L., Price, G.B., Martin, R. G., and Zannis-Hadjopoulos, M. (1987) J. Mol. Biol. 193, 751-758). To define the region(s) of the cruciform that is recognized by these antibodies, we examined the ability of 2D3 and 4B4 to protect the single-stranded tips of the loops or the four-way junctions at the base of the stem of stable cruciform molecules against cleavage by mung bean nuclease or T7 endonuclease 3, respectively. Both antibodies were found to protect two of the four elbow-like structures at the base of the cruciform from T7 endonuclease 3 cleavage, but not the tips of the cruciform arms from mung bean nuclease cleavage. Also, predigestion of the cruciform with mung bean nuclease did not affect the binding of either antibody. In addition, 2D3 bound to a cruciform and a T-shaped structure involving the palindromic sequence at the cloning site of pUC7, which is completely unrelated in sequence to the palindrome of pRGM 21 x pRGM 29, and protected the base of these stem-loop structures against cleavage by T4 endonuclease VII. These results indicate that 2D3 and 4B4 bind at or near the base of the cruciform molecules and that, at least for 2D3, binding is independent of DNA sequence.     

A 160-bp palindrome is a Rad50.Rad32-dependent mitotic recombination hotspot in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

Palindromic sequences can form hairpin and cruciform structures that pose a threat to genome integrity. We found that a 160-bp palindrome (an inverted repeat of 80 bp) conferred a mitotic recombination hotspot relative to a control nonpalindromic sequence when inserted into the ade6 gene of Schizosaccharomyces pombe. The hotspot activity of the palindrome, but not the basal level of recombination, was abolished by a rad50 deletion, by a rad50S "separation of function" mutation, or by a rad32-D25A mutation in the nuclease domain of the Rad32 protein, an Mre11 homolog. We propose that upon extrusion of the palindrome the Rad50.Rad32 nuclease complex recognizes and cleaves the secondary structure thus formed and generates a recombinogenic break in the DNA.     

The physical chemistry of cruciform structures in supercoiled DNA molecules

Inverted repeat DNA sequences extrude cruciform structures when present in negatively supercoiled molecules, stabilised by the release of torsional stress brought about by the negative twist change. We have revealed the presence of cruciform structures by means of enzyme and chemical probing experiments and topological band shift methods. The geometry of cruciform structures has been studied from two points of view. The unpairing of bases in the loop region has been investigated using bisulphite modification, with the result that the central four nucleotides have single-stranded character, and the next pair have only partially single-stranded nature. Gel electrophoretic studies of a pseudo-cruciform structure indicate that the cruciform junction introduces a pronounced bend into the molecule. The dependence of the formation of the ColE1 cruciform upon DNA supercoiling shows that it has a free energy of formation of 18.4 +/- 0.5 kcal mole-1. The kinetics of the extrusion process are complex. Most sequences extrude slowly with considerable temperature coefficients, but the detailed properties are strongly sequence-dependent. One synthetic inverted repeat sequence which we have studied in detail has an Arrhenius activation energy of 42.4 +/- 3.2 kcal mole-1. We discuss possible mechanistic pathways for the extrusion process.     

Intermediate range effects in DNA. I: Low pH/stress induced conformational changes in the vicinity of an extruded d(AT)n.d(AT) in cruciform.

A family of plasmids which contain d(AT)n cruciforms are sensitive to "single strand specific" (SS) endonucleases and a variety of chemical probes in a "random sequence" region centered 10-30 residues away from the cruciform junction. The SS nuclease sensitive structures are dependent on the presence of the extruded cruciform and exhibit a degree of sequence independence. Their appearance depends upon the combined effects of slightly lower than neutral pH and superhelical coiling above the minimum required to drive the extrusion of the d(AT)n cruciform arms. The nuclease sensitive structure is therefore underwound with respect to the B conformation and contains protonated bases.     

Influence of cation size and charge on the extrusion of a salt-dependent cruciform

We have made a comparative study of the kinetics of cruciform extrusion by a salt-dependent (S-type) cruciform in the presence of a variety of metal ions and related species. We find that the nature of the cation present has a marked effect on the observed kinetics, and that different cations differ greatly in the efficiency with which they promote the extrusion process. We can divide the ions into four classes according to the optimal ionic concentration required for maximal extrusion rate. Group Ia cations and tetramethyl ammonium are most effective in promoting extrusion at 50 to 60 mM. Group IIa and selected transition metal ions (notably manganese) are effective over a wide range, extending down to 200 microM. Hexaminecobalt(III) and the polyamines promote extrusion at concentrations as low as 15 to 40 microM. Most remaining ions examined, including trivalent ions such as Al(III) and many transition metal ions are totally ineffective. Within the first two groups, we observe a marked correlation between the rate of cruciform extrusion promoted and ionic radius, the larger ions giving faster extrusion rates. We interpret this to indicate specific ion binding occurring in the transition state of the extrusion process. We may rationalize all the data in terms of a model for salt-dependent cruciform extrusion, in which the transition state resembles a partially extruded protocruciform. This creates an anionic "cavity" with selective ion binding properties, and its stabilization is therefore ion size-dependent.     

Long-range structural effects in supercoiled DNA: statistical thermodynamics reveals a correlation between calculated cooperative melting and contextual influence on cruciform extrusion

We have previously described [K. M. Sullivan and D. M. J. Lilley (1986) Cell 47, 817-827] a set of sequences, called C-type inducing sequences, which cause cruciform extrusion by adjacent inverted repeats to occur by an abnormal kinetic pathway involving a large denatured region of DNA. In this paper we apply statistical thermodynamic DNA helix melting theory to these sequences. We find a marked correlation between the ability of sequences to confer C-type cruciform character experimentally and their calculated propensity to undergo cooperative melting, and no exceptions have been found. The correlations are both qualitative and quantitative. Thus the ColE1 flanking sequences behave as single melting units, while the DNA of the S-type plasmid pIRbke8 exhibits no propensity to melt in the region of the bke cruciform. The results of the calculations are also fully consistent with the following experimental observations: 1. the ability of the isolated colL and colR fragments of the ColE1 flanking sequences, as well as the short sequence col30, to confer C-type character; 2. C-type induction by an A + T rich Drosophila sequence; 3. low-temperature cruciform extrusion by an (AT)34 sequence; 4. the effect of changing sequences at a site 90 base pairs (bp) removed from the inverted repeat; 5. the effects of systematic deletion of the colL sequence; and 6. the effects of insertion of various sequences in between the colL sequence and the xke inverted repeat. These studies show that telestability effects on thermal denaturation as predicted from equilibrium helix melting theory of linear DNA molecules may explain all the features that are revealed by studying the extrusion of cruciforms in circular DNA molecules subjected to superhelical stress.     

Global structure of a DNA three-way junction by solution NMR: towards prediction of 3H fold

Three-way junctions (3H) are the simplest and most commonly occurring branched nucleic acids. They consist of three double helical arms (A to C), connected at the junction point, with or without a number of unpaired bases in one or more of the three different strands. Three-way junctions with two unpaired bases in one strand (3HS2) have a high tendency to adopt either of two alternative stacked conformations in which two of the three arms A, B and C are coaxially stacked, i.e. A/B-stacked or A/C-stacked. Empirical stacking rules, which successfully predict for DNA 3HS2 A/B-stacking preference from sequence, have been extended to A/C-stacked conformations. Three novel DNA 3HS2 sequences were designed to test the validity of these extended stacking rules and their conformational behavior was studied by solution NMR. All three show the predicted A/C-stacking preference even in the absence of multivalent cations. The stacking preference for both classes of DNA 3HS2 can thus be predicted from sequence. The high-resolution NMR solution structure for one of the stacked 3HS2 is also reported. It shows a well-defined local and global structure defined by an extensive set of classical NMR restraints and residual dipolar couplings. Analysis of its global conformation and that of other representatives of the 3H family, shows that the relative orientations of the stacked and non-stacked arms, are restricted to narrow regions of conformational space, which can be understood from geometric considerations. Together, these findings open up the possibility of full prediction of 3HS2 conformation (stacking and global fold) directly from sequence.