Multicolor luciferase assay system: one-step monitoring of multiple gene expressions with a single substrate

Reporter assays that use luciferase are widely employed for monitoring cellular events associated with gene expression. In general, firefly luciferase and Renilla luciferase are used for monitoring single gene expression. However, the expression of more than one gene cannot be monitored simultaneously by this system because one of the two reporting luciferases must be used as an internal control. We have developed a novel reporter assay system in which three luciferases that emit green, orange, and red light with a single substrate are used as reporter genes. The activities of the luciferases can be measured simultaneously and quantitatively with optical filters. This system enables us to simply and rapidly monitor multiple gene expressions in a one-step reaction.     

Improved Expression of Novel Red- and Green-emitting Luciferases of Phrixothrix Railroad Worms in Mammalian Cells

Luciferases are widely used for the quantitative monitoring of gene expression in a variety of organisms. We successfully expressed novel red- and green-emitting luciferases of Phrixothrix railroad worms in mammalian cells in combination with the Kozak sequence and the CAG promoter. The characteristic properties of these luciferases indicate that they are appropriate reporter genes for the simultaneous monitoring of two gene expressions.     

Bioluminescence and chemiluminescence literature—Luciferase reporter genes—Lux and Luc

The following references encompass a review of recent literature where the in vivo expression of eukaryotic and/or prokaryotic luciferases provide for sensitive reporters of cellular activity. The list is subdivided into prokaryotic and eukaryotic applications. We have included the uses of luciferases in elucidating the control of gene expression or for monitoring cell viability. We have not included papers cited by Stanley and Stewart (J Biolumin Chemilumin 1990; 5:141–52) nor have we included papers on the structure and regulation of luciferases as this now substantial literature will be the subject of a future review. References cited in both this review and previous ones are referred to by the number assigned to them in the earlier review.     

Simultaneous monitoring of independent gene expression patterns in two types of cocultured fibroblasts with different color-emitting luciferases

Background  

Luciferase assay systems enable the real-time monitoring of gene expression in living cells. We have developed a dual-color luciferase assay system in which the expression of multiple genes can be tracked simultaneously using green- and red-emitting beetle luciferases. We have applied the system to monitoring independent gene expressions in two types of cocultured fibroblasts in real time.     

Long-term ex vivo and in vivo monitoring of tumor progression by using dual luciferases

We propose a new concept of tumor progression monitoring using dual luciferases in living animals to reduce stress for small animals and the cost of luciferin. The secreted Cypridina luciferase (CLuc) was used as an ex vivo indicator to continuously monitor tumor progression. On the other hand, the non-secreted firefly luciferase was used as an in vivo indicator to analyze the spatial distribution of the tumor at suitable time points indicated by CLuc. Thus, the new monitoring systems that use dual luciferases are available, allowing long-term bioluminescence imaging under minimal stress for the experimental animals.     

An in vivo dual-reporter system of cyanobacteria using two railroad-worm luciferases with different color emissions

In vivo genetic reporter systems using luciferase enzymes enable the real-time monitoring of gene expression in living cells. We have challenged concurrent monitoring of two independent promoter activities within the same cells to precisely compare their characteristics in vivo. In this report, we describe a simple dual-reporter system capable of simultaneously monitoring two promoter activities in living cyanobacterial cells. Two railroad-worm luciferases catalyzing the bioluminescent emissions of different colors served as the dual reporters; each emission was successfully separated by interference filters to estimate the individual bioluminescence signals using photomultiplier tubes. Using this system, we clearly demonstrated the difference in the expression profiles between promoters in the same cells.     

Sensitive dual color in vivo bioluminescence imaging using a new red codon optimized firefly luciferase and a green click beetle luciferase

Background

Despite a plethora of bioluminescent reporter genes being cloned and used for cell assays and molecular imaging purposes, the simultaneous monitoring of multiple events in small animals is still challenging. This is partly attributable to the lack of optimization of cell reporter gene expression as well as too much spectral overlap of the color-coupled reporter genes. A new red emitting codon-optimized luciferase reporter gene mutant of Photinus pyralis, Ppy RE8, has been developed and used in combination with the green click beetle luciferase, CBG99.

Principal Findings

Human embryonic kidney cells (HEK293) were transfected with vectors that expressed red Ppy RE8 and green CBG99 luciferases. Populations of red and green emitting cells were mixed in different ratios. After addition of the shared single substrate, D-luciferin, bioluminescent (BL) signals were imaged with an ultrasensitive cooled CCD camera using a series of band pass filters (20 nm). Spectral unmixing algorithms were applied to the images where good separation of signals was observed. Furthermore, HEK293 cells that expressed the two luciferases were injected at different depth in the animals. Spectrally-separate images and quantification of the dual BL signals in a mixed population of cells was achieved when cells were either injected subcutaneously or directly into the prostate.

Significance

We report here the re-engineering of different luciferase genes for in vitro and in vivo dual color imaging applications to address the technical issues of using dual luciferases for imaging. In respect to previously used dual assays, our study demonstrated enhanced sensitivity combined with spatially separate BL spectral emissions using a suitable spectral unmixing algorithm. This new D-luciferin-dependent reporter gene couplet opens up the possibility in the future for more accurate quantitative gene expression studies in vivo by simultaneously monitoring two events in real time.     

Introduction to beetle luciferases and their applications

All beetle luciferases have evolved from a common ancestor: they all use ATP, O₂, and a common luciferin as substrates. The most studied of these luciferases is that derived from the firefly Photinus pyralis, a beetle in the superfamily of Cantharoidea. The sensitivity with which the activity of this enzyme can be assayed has made it useful in the measurement of minute concentrations of ATP. With the cloning of the cDNA coding this luciferase, it has also found wide application in molecular biology as a reporter gene. We have recently cloned other cDNAs that code for luciferases from the bioluminescent click beetle, Pyrophorus plagiophthalamus, in the superfamily Elateroidea. These newly acquired luciferases are of at least four different types, distinguishable by their ability to emit different colours of bioluminescence ranging from green to orange. Unique properties of these luciferases, especially their emission of multiple colours, may make them additionally useful in applications.     

Substrate cooperativity in marine luciferases

Marine luciferases are increasingly used as reporters to study gene regulation. These luciferases have utility in bioluminescent assay development, although little has been reported on their catalytic properties in response to substrate concentration. Here, we report that the two marine luciferases from the copepods, Gaussia princeps (GLuc) and Metridia longa (MLuc) were found, surprisingly, to produce light in a cooperative manner with respect to their luciferin substrate concentration; as the substrate concentration was decreased 10 fold the rate of light production decreased 1000 fold. This positive cooperative effect is likely a result of allostery between the two proposed catalytic domains found in Gaussia and Metridia. In contrast, the marine luciferases from Renilla reniformis (RLuc) and Cypridina noctiluca (CLuc) demonstrate a linear relationship between the concentration of their respective luciferin and the rate of light produced. The consequences of these enzyme responses are discussed.     

Trigger factor assists the refolding of heterodimeric but not monomeric luciferases

The refolding of thermally inactivated protein by ATP-independent trigger factor (TF) and ATP-dependent DnaKJE chaperones was comparatively analyzed. Heterodimeric (αβ) bacterial luciferases of Aliivibrio fischeri, Photobacterium leiognathi, and Vibrio harveyi as well as monomeric luciferases of Vibrio harveyi and Luciola mingrelica (firefly) were used as substrates. In the presence of TF, thermally inactivated heterodimeric bacterial luciferases refold, while monomeric luciferases do not refold. These observations were made both in vivo (Escherichia coli ΔdnaKJ containing plasmids with tig gene) and in vitro (purified TF). Unlike TF, the DnaKJE chaperone system refolds both monomeric and heterodimeric luciferases with equal efficiency.     

Bacterial luciferase reporters: the Swiss army knife of molecular biology

Bioluminescence is a process during which light in the visible spectrum is emitted as a consequence of an enzymatic reaction catalyzed by luciferases. Luciferases have been identified mainly in marine organisms and are used for several biological purposes include camouflage, repulsion, attraction, communication and illumination. Some of the currently known luciferases have become indispensible tools in modern molecular biology and are used for diverse applications such as autoinducer-1 activity assays, promoter test assays in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, imaging of bacterial infections in live animals, in vivo activity assays genes involved in host response and disease and monitoring of bacterial contaminations of food products. With the present review, the authors intend to give an overview on the currently used bacterial luciferase reporter systems, their methodologies and applications and compare them to other reporter systems.     

Thermostability of firefly luciferases affects efficiency of detection by in vivo bioluminescence

Luciferase from the North American firefly (Photinis pyralis) is a useful reporter gene in vivo, allowing noninvasive imaging of tumor growth, metastasis, gene transfer, drug treatment, and gene expression. Luciferase is heat labile with an in vitro halflife of approximately 3 min at 37 degrees C. We have characterized wild type and six thermostabilized mutant luciferases. In vitro, mutants showed half-lives between 2- and 25-fold higher than wild type. Luciferase transfected mammalian cells were used to determine in vivo half-lives following cycloheximide inhibition of de novo protein synthesis. This showed increased in vivo thermostability in both wild-type and mutant luciferases. This may be due to a variety of factors, including chaperone activity, as steady-state luciferase levels were reduced by geldanamycin, an Hsp90 inhibitor. Mice inoculated with tumor cells stably transfected with mutant or wild-type luciferases were imaged. Increased light production and sensitivity were observed in the tumors bearing thermostable luciferase. Thermostable proteins increase imaging sensitivity. Presumably, as more active protein accumulates, detection is possible from a smaller number of mutant transfected cells compared to wild-type transfected cells.     

The structural origin and biological function of pH-sensitivity in firefly luciferases.

Firefly luciferases are called pH-sensitive because their bioluminescence spectra display a typical red-shift at acidic pH, higher temperatures, and in the presence of heavy metal cations, whereas other beetle luciferases (click beetles and railroadworms) do not, and for this reason they are called pH-insensitive. Despite many studies on firefly luciferases, the origin of pH-sensitivity is far from being understood. This subject is revised in view of recent results. Some substitutions of amino-acid residues influencing pH-sensitivity in firefly luciferases have been identified. Sequence comparison, site-directed mutagenesis and modeling studies have shown a set of residues differing between pH-sensitive and pH-insensitive luciferases which affect bioluminescence colors. Some substitutions dramatically affecting bioluminescence colors in both groups of luciferases are clustered in the loop between residues 223-235 (Photinus pyralis sequence). A network of hydrogen bonds and salt bridges involving the residues N229-S284-E311-R337 was found to be important for affecting bioluminescence colors. It is suggested that these structural elements may affect the benzothiazolyl side of the luciferin-binding site affecting bioluminescence colors. Experimental evidence suggest that the residual red light emission in pH-sensitive luciferases could be a vestige that may have biological importance in some firefly species. Furthermore, the potential utility of pH-sensitivity for intracellular biosensing applications is considered.     

Orthologous gene of beetle luciferase in non-luminous click beetle, Agrypnus binodulus (Elateridae), encodes a fatty acyl-CoA synthetase

A homologous gene of beetle luciferase, AbLL (Agrypnus binodulusluciferase-like gene) was isolated from a Japanese non-luminous click beetle, A. binodulus, and its gene product was characterized. The identity of amino acid sequence deduced from AbLL with the click beetle luciferase from the Jamaican luminous click beetle, Pyrophorus plagiophthalmus, is 55%, which is higher than that between click beetle luciferase and firefly luciferase (approximately 48%). Phylogenetic analysis indicated that AbLL places in a clade of beetle luciferases, suggesting that AbLL is an orthologous gene of beetle luciferase. The gene product of AbLL (AbLL) has medium- and long-chain fatty acyl-CoA synthetase activity, but not luciferase activity. The fatty acyl-CoA synthetic activity was slightly inhibited in the presence of beetle luciferin, suggesting that AbLL has poor affinity for beetle luciferin. By comparing the amino acid residues of the catalytic domains in beetle luciferases with AbLL, the key substitutions for the luminescence activity in beetle luciferase will be proposed.     

Bioluminescence and chemiluminescence literature: 1987 literature,part III

In studying beetle bioluminescence in the early 1960s, Dr McElroy and his colleagues found that the Jamaican click beetle, Pyrophorus plagiophthalamus, was capable of emitting different colours of light. They further found that the luciferin substrate used by this beetle was the same as that in the firefly, demonstrating that the different colours of bioluminescence were due to differences in the structure of the luciferases. We have recently cloned cDNAs from this beetle species which code for at least four different luciferases. The luciferases are distinguishable by their different colours of bioluminescence when expressed in Escherichia coli. The sequence differences between these different luciferases are few, so the amino acids responsible for the different colours of emission must also be few. Through the construction of hybrid luciferases, by rearranging fragments of the original cDNA clones, we have identified some of these amino acid determinants of colour.     

The influence of insertion of a critical residue (Arg356) in structure and bioluminescence spectra of firefly luciferase

The firefly bioluminescence reaction, which uses luciferin, Mg-ATP, and molecular oxygen to yield an electronically excited oxyluciferin, is carried out by luciferase and visible light is emitted. The bioluminescence color of firefly luciferases is determined by the luciferase structure and assay conditions. Among different beetle luciferases, those from Phrixothrix railroad worm emit either yellow or red bioluminescence colors. Sequence alignment analysis shows that the red-emitter luciferase from Phrixothrix hirtus has an additional Arg residue at 353, which is absent in firefly luciferases. We report here the construction and purification of a mutant at residue Arg(356), which is not conserved in beetle luciferases. By insertion of an additional residue (Arg(356)) using site-specific insertion mutagenesis in a green-emitter luciferase (Lampyris turkestanicus) the color of emitted light was changed to red and the optimum temperature of activity was also increased. Insertion of this Arg in an important flexible loop showed changes of the bioluminescence color and the luciferase reaction took place with relatively retention of its basic kinetic properties such as Km and relative activity. Comparison of native and mutant luciferases using homology modeling reveals a significant conformational change of the flexible loop in the red mutant. Movement of flexible loop brought about a new ionic interaction concomitant with a change in polarity of the emitter site, thereby leading to red emission. It is worthwhile to note that the increased optimum temperature and emission of red light might make mutant luciferase a suitable reporter for the study of gene expression and bioluminescence imaging.     

Comparison of the thermostability of recombinant luciferases from Brazilian bioluminescent beetles: Relationship with kinetics and bioluminescence colours

Firefly luciferases have been used extensively as bioanalytical reagents and their cDNAs as reporter genes for biosensors and bioimaging, but they are in general unstable at temperatures above 30°C. In the past few years, efforts have been made to stabilize some firefly luciferases for better application as analytical reagents. Novel luciferases from different beetle families, displaying distinct bioluminescence colours and kinetics, may offer desirable alternatives to extend the range of applications. In the past years, our group has cloned the largest variety of luciferases from the three main families of bioluminescent beetles (Elateridae: P. termitilluminans, F. bruchi, P. angustus; Phengodidae: P. hirtus, P. vivianii; and Lampyridae: A. vivianii, C. distinctus and Macrolampis sp2) occurring in Brazilian biomes. We compared the thermostability of these recombinant luciferases and investigated their relationships with bioluminescence spectra and kinetics. The most thermostable luciferases were those of Pyrearinus termitilluminans larval click beetle (534 nm), Amydetes vivianii firefly (539 nm) and Phrixotrix vivianii railroad worm (546 nm), which are the most blue‐shifted examples in each family, confirming the trend that the most blue‐shifted emitting luciferases are also the most thermostable. Comparatively, commercial P. pyralis firefly luciferase was less thermostable than P. termitilluminans click beetle and A. vivianii firefly luciferases. The higher thermostability in these luciferases could be related to higher degree of hydrophobic packing and disulfide bond content (for firefly luciferases).     

The effect of Clp proteins on DnaK-dependent refolding of bacterial luciferases

A study was made of the refolding of bacterial luciferases of Vibrio fischeri, V. harveyi, Photobacterium phosphoreum, and Photorhabdus luminescens. By reaction rate, luciferases were divided into two groups. The reaction rate constants of fast luciferases of V. fischeri and Ph. phosphoreum were about tenfold higher than those of slow luciferases of Ph. luminescens and V. harveyi. The order of increasing luciferase thermostability was Ph. phosphoreum, V. fischeri, V. harveyi, and Ph. luminescens. The refolding of thermoinactivated luciferases completely depended on the active DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE chaperone system. Thermolabile fast luciferases of V. fischeri and Ph. phosphoreum showed highly efficient rapid refolding. Slower and less efficient refolding was characteristic of thermostable slow luciferases of V. harveyi and Ph. luminescens. Chaperones of the Clp family were tested for effect on the efficiency of DnaK-dependent refolding of bacterial luciferases in Escherichia coli cells. The rate and extent of refolding were considerably lower in the clpB mutant than in wild-type cells. In E. coli cells with mutant clpA, clpP, of clpX showed a substantially lower luciferase refolding after heat shock.     

A Highlights from MBoC Selection: Measuring fast gene dynamics in single cells with time-lapse luminescence microscopy

Time-lapse fluorescence microscopy is an important tool for measuring in vivo gene dynamics in single cells. However, fluorescent proteins are limited by slow chromophore maturation times and the cellular autofluorescence or phototoxicity that arises from light excitation. An alternative is luciferase, an enzyme that emits photons and is active upon folding. The photon flux per luciferase is significantly lower than that for fluorescent proteins. Thus time-lapse luminescence microscopy has been successfully used to track gene dynamics only in larger organisms and for slower processes, for which more total photons can be collected in one exposure. Here we tested green, yellow, and red beetle luciferases and optimized substrate conditions for in vivo luminescence. By combining time-lapse luminescence microscopy with a microfluidic device, we tracked the dynamics of cell cycle genes in single yeast with subminute exposure times over many generations. Our method was faster and in cells with much smaller volumes than previous work. Fluorescence of an optimized reporter (Venus) lagged luminescence by 15–20 min, which is consistent with its known rate of chromophore maturation in yeast. Our work demonstrates that luciferases are better than fluorescent proteins at faithfully tracking the underlying gene expression.     

Luc genes: Introduction of colour into bioluminescence assays

Luminescence assays are generally based on measurements of light intensity alone. Inclusion of colour as an additional parameter of the assay could increase the information content. Colour variation in luminescence is particularly prevalent among beetle luciferases. To study the relationship between enzyme structure and colour, luciferases from a Jamalcan click beetle were examined as a model system. These luciferases emit light ranging from green to orange, though their amino acid sequences differ by less than 5%. Through mutation of their respective cDNA clones, the amino acids responsible for the colour variation were identified. These specific amino acids are few, and they act upon colour independently with respect to the enzyme structure. Analysis of their effects indicates that the potential for colour variation among beetle luciferases is greater than is evident among the click beetle luciferase. Because of the subtle changes of enzyme structure that effect colour, luciferases that emit different colours may be useful as paired genetic reporters. They should interact equivalently with the intracellular environment of a host, but could be distinguished by colour in their assay. Such paired reporters could be used to observed simultaneous events, or to provide internal control for luminescence measurements.