Replacement or exclusion of the B-branch bacteriopheophytin in the purple bacterial reaction centre: The HB cofactor is not required for assembly or core function of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides complex

All of the membrane-embedded cofactors of the purple bacterial reaction centre have well-defined functional or structural roles, with the exception of the bacteriopheophytin (H_B) located approximately half-way across the membrane on the so-called inactive- or B-branch of cofactors. Sequence alignments indicate that this bacteriochlorin cofactor is a conserved feature of purple bacterial reaction centres, and a pheophytin is also found at this position in the Photosystem-II reaction centre. Possible structural or functional consequences of replacing the H_B bacteriopheophytin by bacteriochlorophyll were investigated in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centre through mutagenesis of residue Leu L185 to His (LL185H). Results from absorbance spectroscopy indicated that the LL185H mutant assembled with a bacteriochlorophyll at the H_B position, but this did not affect the capacity of the reaction centre to support photosynthetic growth, or change the kinetics of charge separation along the A-branch of cofactors. It was also found that mutation of residue Ala M149 to Trp (AM149W) caused the reaction centre to assemble without an H_B bacteriochlorin, demonstrating that this cofactor is not required for correct assembly of the reaction centre. The absence of a cofactor at this position did not affect the capacity of the reaction centre to support photosynthetic growth, or the kinetics of A-branch electron transfer. A combination of X-ray crystallography and FTIR difference spectroscopy confirmed that the H_B cofactor was absent in the AM149W mutant, and that this had not produced any significant disturbance of the adjacent ubiquinol reductase (Q_B) site. The data are discussed with respect to possible functional roles of the H_B bacteriopheophytin, and we conclude that the reason(s) for conservation of a bacteriopheophytin cofactor at this position in purple bacterial reaction centres are likely to be different from those underlying conservation of a pheophytin at the analogous position in Photosystem-II.     

Substitution of isoleucine L177 by histidine in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center results in the covalent binding of PA bacteriochlorophyll to the L subunit

In this work, we report the unique case of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) - protein covalent attachment in a photosynthetic membrane complex caused by a single mutation. The isoleucine L177 was substituted by histidine in the photosynthetic reaction center (RC) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Pigment analysis revealed that one BChl molecule was missing in the acetone-methanol extract of the I(L177)H RCs. SDS-PAGE demonstrated that this BChl molecule could not be extracted with organic solvents apparently because of its stable covalent attachment to the mutant RC L-subunit. Our data indicate that the attached bacteriochlorophyll is one of the special pair BChls, P(A). The chemical nature of this covalent interaction remains to be identified.     

Coupling of collective motions of the protein matrix to vibrations of the non-heme iron in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers

Non-heme iron is a conservative component of type II photosynthetic reaction centers of unknown function. We found that in the reaction center from Rba. sphaeroides it exists in two forms, high and low spin ferrous states, whereas in Rsp. rubrum mostly in a low spin state, in line with our earlier finding of its low spin state in the algal photosystem II reaction center (Burda et al., 2003). The temperature dependence of the non-heme iron displacement studied by Mössbauer spectroscopy shows that the surrounding of the high spin iron is more flexible (Debye temperature ~ 165 K) than that of the low spin atom (~ 207 K). Nuclear inelastic scattering measurements of the collective motions in the Rba. sphaeroides reaction center show that the density of vibrational states, originating from non-heme iron, has well-separated modes between lower (4-17 meV) and higher (17-25 meV) energies while in the one from Rsp. rubrum its distribution is more uniform with only little contribution of low energy (~ 6 meV) vibrations. It is the first experimental evidence that the fluctuations of the protein matrix in type II reaction center are correlated to the spin state of non-heme iron. We propose a simple mechanism in which the spin state of non-heme iron directly determines the strength of coupling between the two quinone acceptors (Q_A and Q_B) and fast collective motions of protein matrix that play a crucial role in activation and regulation of the electron and proton transfer between these two quinones. We suggest that hydrogen bond network on the acceptor side of reaction center is responsible for stabilization of non-heme iron in different spin states.     

Intermediate states between P* and Pf in bacterial reaction centers,as detected by the fluorescence kinetics

The fluorescence lifetimes of the reaction centers isolated from the wild-type Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides purple bacterium and those from the R26 mutant strain, lacking the carotenoid, were measured at low redox potential. In addition to the prompt fluorescence occurring directly from P* and the long delayed emission related to the radical pair state Pf, two other components are present. We suggest that they may come from intermediate states between P* and Pf, or reflect the stabilization of Pf itself.     

Structural and kinetic properties of Rhodobacter sphaeroides photosynthetic reaction centers containing exclusively Zn-coordinated bacteriochlorophyll as bacteriochlorin cofactors

The Zn-BChl-containing reaction center (RC) produced in a bchD (magnesium chelatase) mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides assembles with six Zn-bacteriochlorophylls (Zn-BChls) in place of four Mg-containing bacteriochlorophylls (BChls) and two bacteriopheophytins (BPhes). This protein presents unique opportunities for studying biological electron transfer, as Zn-containing chlorins can exist in 4-, 5-, and (theoretically) 6-coordinate states within the RC. In this paper, the electron transfer perturbations attributed exclusively to coordination state effects are separated from those attributed to the presence, absence, or type of metal in the bacteriochlorin at the H_A pocket of the RC. The presence of a 4-coordinate Zn^2 + ion in the H_A bacteriochlorin instead of BPhe results in a small decrease in the rates of the P* → P⁺H_A⁻ → P⁺Q_A⁻ electron transfer, and the charge separation yield is not greatly perturbed; however coordination of the Zn^2 + by a fifth ligand provided by a histidine residue results in a larger rate decrease and yield loss. We also report the first crystal structure of a Zn-BChl-containing RC, confirming that the H_A Zn-BChl was either 4- or 5-coordinate in the two types of Zn-BChl-containing RCs studied here. Interestingly, a large degree of disorder, in combination with a relatively weak anomalous difference electron density was found in the H_B pocket. These data, in combination with spectroscopic results, indicate partial occupancy of this binding pocket. These findings provide insights into the use of BPhe as the bacteriochlorin pigment of choice at H_A in both BChl- and Zn-BChl-containing RCs found in nature.     

Energy and electron transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center complex of Acidiphilium rubrum containing Zn-bacteriochlorophyll a studied by femtosecond up-conversion spectroscopy

A photosynthetic reaction center (RC) complex was isolated from a purple bacterium, Acidiphilium rubrum. The RC contains bacteriochlorophyll a containing Zn as a central metal (Zn-BChl a) and bacteriopheophytin a (BPhe a) but no Mg-BChl a. The absorption peaks of the Zn-BChl a dimer (P_Zn), the accessory Zn-BChl a (B_Zn), and BPhe a (H) at 4 K in the RC showed peaks at 875, 792, and 753 nm, respectively. These peaks were shorter than the corresponding peaks in Rhodobacter sphaeroides RC that has Mg-BChl a. The kinetics of fluorescence from P_Zn^*, measured by fluorescence up-conversion, showed the rise and the major decay with time constants of 0.16 and 3.3 ps, respectively. The former represents the energy transfer from B_Zn^* to P_Zn, and the latter, the electron transfer from P_Zn to H. The angle between the transition dipoles of B_Zn and P_Zn was estimated to be 36° based on the fluorescence anisotropy. The time constants and the angle are almost equal to those in the Rb. sphaeroides RC. The high efficiency of A. rubrum RC seems to be enabled by the chemical property of Zn-BChl a and by the L168HE modification of the RC protein that modifies P_Zn.     

Organization in photosynthetic membranes of purple bacteria in vivo: The role of carotenoids

Photosynthesis in purple bacteria is performed by pigment–protein complexes that are closely packed within specialized intracytoplasmic membranes. Here we report on the influence of carotenoid composition on the organization of RC–LH1 pigment–protein complexes in intact membranes and cells of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Mostly dimeric RC–LH1 complexes could be isolated from strains expressing native brown carotenoids when grown under illuminated/anaerobic conditions, or from strains expressing green carotenoids when grown under either illuminated/anaerobic or dark/semiaerobic conditions. However, mostly monomeric RC–LH1 complexes were isolated from strains expressing the native photoprotective red carotenoid spheroidenone, which is synthesized during phototrophic growth in the presence of oxygen. Despite this marked difference, linear dichroism (LD) and light-minus-dark LD spectra of oriented intact intracytoplasmic membranes indicated that RC–LH1 complexes are always assembled in ordered arrays, irrespective of variations in the relative amounts of isolated dimeric and monomeric RC–LH1 complexes. We propose that part of the photoprotective response to the presence of oxygen mediated by synthesis of spheroidenone may be a switch of the structure of the RC–LH1 complex from dimers to monomers, but that these monomers are still organized into the photosynthetic membrane in ordered arrays. When levels of the dimeric RC–LH1 complex were very high, and in the absence of LH2, LD and ?LD spectra from intact cells indicated an ordered arrangement of RC–LH1 complexes. Such a degree of ordering implies the presence of highly elongated, tubular membranes with dimensions requiring orientation along the length of the cell and in a proportion larger than previously observed.     

The local electric field within phospholipid membranes modulates the charge transfer reactions in reaction centres

Three different cholesterol derivatives and phloretin, known to affect the local electric field in phospholipid membranes, have been introduced into Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centre-containing phospholipid liposomes. We show that cholesterol and 6-ketocholestanol significantly slow down the interquinone first electron transfer (∼ 10 times), whereas phloretin and 5-cholesten-3β-ol-7-one leave the kinetics essentially unchanged. Interestingly, the two former compounds have been shown to increase the dipole potential, whereas the two latter decrease it. We also measured in isolated RCs the rates of the electron and proton transfers at the first flash. Over the pH range 7-10.5 both reactions display biphasic behaviors with nearly superimposable rates and amplitudes, suggesting that the gating process limiting the first electron transfer is indeed the coupled proton entry. We therefore interpret the effects of cholesterol and 6-ketocholestanol as due to dipole concentration producing an increased free energy barrier for protons to enter the protein perpendicular to the membrane. We also report for the first time in R. sphaeroides RCs, at room temperature, a biphasicity of the P⁺Q_A⁻ charge recombination, induced by the presence of cholesterol derivatives in proteoliposomes. We propose that these molecules decrease the equilibration time between two RC conformations, therefore revealing their presence.     

Fast oxidation of the primary electron acceptor under anaerobic conditions requires the organization of the photosynthetic chain of Rhodobacter sphaeroides in supercomplexes

The kinetics of reoxidation of the primary acceptor Q_a has been followed by measuring the changes in the fluorescence yield induced by a series of saturating flashes in intact cells of Rhodobacter sphaeroides in anaerobic conditions. At 0 °C, about half of Q_a⁻ is reoxidized in about 200 ms while reoxidation of the remaining fraction is completed in several seconds to minutes. The fast phase is associated with the transfer of ubiquinone formed at site Q_o of the cytochrome bc₁ complex while the slowest phase is associated with the diffusion of ubiquinone present in the membrane prior to the flash excitation. The biphasic kinetics of Q_a⁻ oxidation is interpreted assuming that the electron chain is organized in supercomplexes that associate two RCs and one cyt bc₁ complex, which allows a fast transfer of quinone formed at the level of cyt bc₁ complex to the RCs. In agreement with this model, the fast phase of Q_a⁻ reoxidation is inhibited by myxothiazol, a specific inhibitor of cyt bc₁. The PufX-deleted mutant displays only the slowest phase of Q_a⁻ oxidation; it is interpreted by the lack of supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic chain that leads to a larger average distance between cyt bc₁ and RCs.     

Circular dichroism of the peripheral chlorophylls in photosystem II reaction centers revealed by electrochemical oxidation

Visible absorption spectra and circular dichroism (CD) of the red absorption band of isolated photosystem II reaction centers were measured at room temperature during progressive bleaching by electrochemical oxidation, in comparison with aerobic photochemical destruction, and with anaerobic photooxidation in the presence of the artificial electron acceptor silicomolybdate. Initially, selective bleaching of peripheral chlorophylls absorbing at 672 nm was obtained by electrochemical oxidation at +0.9 V, whereas little selectivity was observed at higher potentials. Illumination in the presence of silicomolybdate did not cause a bleaching but a spectral broadening of the 672-nm band was observed, apparently in response to the oxidation of carotene. The 672-nm absorption band is shown to exhibit a positive CD, which accounts for the 674-nm shoulder in CD spectra at low temperature. The origin of this CD is discussed in view of the observation that all CD disappears with the 680-nm absorption band during aerobic photodestruction.     

Excitation transfer connectivity in different purple bacteria: A theoretical and experimental study

Photosynthetic membranes accommodate densely packed light-harvesting complexes which absorb light and convey excitation to the reaction center (RC). The relationship between the fluorescence yield (φ) and the fraction (x) of closed RCs is informative about the probability for an excitation reaching a closed RC to be redirected to another RC. In this work, we have examined in this respect membranes from various bacteria and searched for a correlation with the arrangement of the light-harvesting complexes as known from atomic force or electron microscopies. A first part of the paper is devoted to a theoretical study analyzing the φ(x) relationship in various models: monomeric or dimeric RC-LH1 core complexes, with or without the peripheral LH2 complexes. We show that the simple “homogeneous” kinetic treatment used here agrees well with more detailed master equation calculations. We also discuss the agreement between information derived from the present technique and from singlet annihilation experiments. The experimental results show that the enhancement of the cross section of open RCs due to excitation transfer from closed units varies from 1.5 to 3 depending on species. The ratio of the core to core transfer rate (including the indirect pathway via LH2) to the rate of trapping in open units is in the range of 0.5 to 4. It is about 1 in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and does not increase significantly in mutants lacking LH2—despite the more numerous contacts between the dimeric core complexes expected in this case. The connectivity in this bacterium is due in good part to the fast transfer between the two partners of the dimeric (RC-LH1-PufX)₂ complex. The connectivity is however increased in the carotenoidless and LH2-less strain R26, which we ascribe to an anomalous LH1. A relatively high connectivity was found in Rhodospirillum photometricum, although not as high as predicted in the calculations of Fassioli et al. (2010). This illustrates a more general discrepancy between the measured efficiency of core to core excitation transfer and theoretical estimates. We argue that the limited core to core connectivity found in purple bacteria may reflect a trade-off between light-harvesting efficiency and the hindrance to quinone diffusion that would result from too tightly packed LH complexes.     

Spectral dependence of energy transfer in wild-type peripheral light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria

The precise position of the upper exciton component and relevant vibronic transitions of the B850 ring in peripheral light-harvesting complexes from purple photosynthetic bacteria are important values for determining the exciton bandwidth and electronic structure of the B850 ring. To determine the presence of these components in wild-type LH2 complexes the pump-probe femtosecond transient spectra obtained with excitation into the 730-840 nm spectral range are analyzed. We show that at excitation wavelengths less than 780 nm B850 absorption bands are present and that, in accordance with exciton theory, these bands peak further in the blue when the lowest optically allowed transition is more red-shifted.     

A comparison of stigmatellin conformations, free and bound to the photosynthetic reaction center and the cytochrome bc1 complex

We describe in detail the conformations of the inhibitor stigmatellin in its free form and bound to the ubiquinone-reducing (Q(B)) site of the reaction center and to the ubiquinol-oxidizing (Q(o)) site of the cytochrome bc(1) complex. We present here the first structures of a stereochemically correct stigmatellin in complexes with a bacterial reaction center and the yeast cytochrome bc1 complex. The conformations of the inhibitor bound to the two enzymes are not the same. We focus on the orientations of the stigmatellin side-chain relative to the chromone head group, and on the interaction of the stigmatellin side-chain with these membrane protein complexes. The different conformations of stigmatellin found illustrate the structural variability of the Q sites, which are affected by the same inhibitor. The free rotation about the chi1 dihedral angle is an essential factor for allowing stigmatellin to bind in both the reaction center and the cytochrome bc1 pocket.     

Tuning electron transfer by ester-group of chlorophylls in bacterial photosynthetic reaction center

Accessory chlorophylls (B(A/B)) in bacterial photosynthetic reaction center play a key role in charge-separation. Although light-exposed and dark-adapted bRC crystal structures are virtually identical, the calculated B(A) redox potentials for one-electron reduction differ. This can be traced back to different orientations of the B(A) ester-group. This tuning ability of chlorophyll redox potentials modulates the electron transfer from SP* to B(A).     

Ubiquinone (coenzyme Q10) binding sites: low dielectric constant of the gate prevents the escape of the semiquinone

The photosynthetic reaction center (RC) from purple bacteria is frequently used as a model for the interaction of ubiquinones (coenzyme Q) with membrane proteins. Single-turnover flash activation of RC leads to formation of the semiquinone (SQ) of the secondary acceptor quinone after odd flashes and quinol after even flashes. The ubiquinol escapes the binding site in 1 ms, while the SQ does not leave the binding site for at least 5 min. Observed difference between these times suggests a large energetic barrier for the SQ. However, high apparent dielectric constant in the vicinity of the quinone ring (>or=25) results in a relatively small electrostatic energy of SQ stabilization. To resolve this apparent contradiction I suggest that a significant part of the kinetic stabilization of the SQ is achieved by the special topology of the binding site in which quinone can exit the binding site only by moving its headgroup toward the center of the membrane. The large energetic penalty of transferring the charged headgroup to the membrane dielectric can explain the observed kinetic stability of the SQ.     

Watching the components of photosynthetic bacterial membranes and their in situ organisation by atomic force microscopy

The atomic force microscope has developed into a powerful tool in structural biology allowing information to be acquired at submolecular resolution on the protruding structures of membrane proteins. It is now a complementary technique to X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy for structure determination of individual membrane proteins after extraction, purification and reconstitution into lipid bilayers. Moving on from the structures of individual components of biological membranes, atomic force microscopy has recently been demonstrated to be a unique tool to identify in situ the individual components of multi-protein assemblies and to study the supramolecular architecture of these components allowing the efficient performance of a complex biological function.Here, recent atomic force microscopy studies of native membranes of different photosynthetic bacteria with different polypeptide contents are reviewed. Technology, advantages, feasibilities, restrictions and limits of atomic force microscopy for the acquisition of highly resolved images of up to 10 Å lateral resolution under native conditions are discussed. From a biological point of view, the new insights contributed by the images are analysed and discussed in the context of the strongly debated organisation of the interconnected network of membrane-associated chlorophyll-protein complexes composing the photosynthetic apparatus in different species of purple bacteria.     

Direct quantification of the four individual S states in Photosystem II using EPR spectroscopy

EPR spectroscopy is very useful in studies of the oxygen evolving cycle in Photosystem II and EPR signals from the CaMn₄ cluster are known in all S states except S₄. Many signals are insufficiently understood and the S₀, S₁, and S₃ states have not yet been quantifiable through their EPR signals. Recently, split EPR signals, induced by illumination at liquid helium temperatures, have been reported in the S₀, S₁, and S₃ states. These split signals provide new spectral probes to the S state chemistry. We have studied the flash power dependence of the S state turnover in Photosystem II membranes by monitoring the split S₀, split S₁, split S₃ and S₂ state multiline EPR signals. We demonstrate that quantification of the S₁, S₃ and S₀ states, using the split EPR signals, is indeed possible in samples with mixed S state composition. The amplitudes of all three split EPR signals are linearly correlated to the concentration of the respective S state. We also show that the S₁ → S₂ transition proceeds without misses following a saturating flash at 1 °C, whilst substantial misses occur in the S₂ → S₃ transition following the second flash.     

High-resolution optical absorption-difference spectra of the triplet state of the primary donor in isolated reaction centers of the photosynthetic bacteria Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26 and Rhodopseudomonas viridis measured with optically detected magnetic resonance at 1.2 K

We have recorded triplet optical absorption-difference spectra of the reaction center triplet state of isolated reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26 and Rps. viridis with optical absorption-detected electron spin resonance in zero magnetic field (ADMR) at 1.2 K. This technique is one to two orders of magnitude more sensitive than conventional flash absorption spectroscopy, and consequently allows a much higher spectral resolution. Besides the relatively broad bleachings and appearances found previously (see, e.g., Shuvalov V.A. and Parson W.W. (1981) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 638, 50–59) we have found strong, sharp oscillations in the wavelength regions 790–830 nm (Rps. sphaeroides) and 810–890 nm (Rps. viridis). For Rps. viridis these features are resolved into two band shifts (a blue shift at about 830 nm and a red shift at about 855 nm) and a strong, narrow absorption band at 838 nm. For Rps. sphaeroides R-26 the features are resolved into a red shift at about 810 nm and a strong absorption band at 807 nm. We conclude that the appearance of the absorption bands at 807 and 838 nm, respectively, is due to monomeric bacteriochlorophyll. Apparently, the exciton interaction between the pigments constituting the primary donor is much weaker in the triplet state than in the singlet state, and at low temperature the triplet is localized on one of the bacteriochlorophylls on an optical time scale. The fact that for Rps. sphaeroides the strong band shift and the monomeric band found at 1.2 K are absent at 293 K and very weak at 77 K indicates that these features are strongly temperature dependent. It seems, therefore, premature to ascribe the temperature dependence between 293 and 77 K of the intensity of the triplet absorption-difference spectrum at 810 nm (solely) to a delocalization of the triplet state on one of the accessory bacteriochlorophyll pigments.     

Site-directed mutations at D1-His198 and D1-Thr179 of photosystem II in Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803: deciphering the spectral properties of the PSII reaction centre

Site-directed mutations were constructed in photosystem II of Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 in which the axial ligand, D1-His198, of special pair chlorophyll PD1 was replaced with Gln and where D1-Thr179, which overlies monomeric chlorophyll ChlD1, was replaced with His. The D1-His198Gln mutation produces a 3nm displacement to the blue of the bleaching minimum in the Soret and in the Qy region of the (P+QA--PQA) absorbance difference spectrum. To a first approximation, the bleaching can be assigned to the low-energy exciton transition of the special pair chlorophylls PD1/PD2. The D1-Thr179His mutation produces a 2nm displacement to the red of the bleaching minimum in the Qy region of the (3P-1P) absorbance difference spectrum. Analysis of the flash-induced (P+QA--PQA) and (3P-1P) absorbance difference spectra of both mutants compared with wild-type at 80K indicate that the cation of the oxidized donor P+ is predominantly localized on the chlorophyll PD1 of the special pair and that the reaction centre triplet state, produced upon charge recombination from 3[P+Pheo-], when the primary quinone electron acceptor QA is doubly reduced, is primarily localized on ChlD1.