Cytotoxicity and DNA binding properties of a chloro glycylhistidinate gold(III) complex (GHAu)

The chloro glycylhistidinate gold(III) complex (GHAu) is shown to be fairly cytotoxic towards the established A2780 ovarian carcinoma human cell line either sensitive or resistant to cisplatin. Remarkably, GHAu is far more cytotoxic than the corresponding zinc(II), palladium(II), platinum(II) and cobalt(II) complexes implying that cytotoxicity is essentially to be ascribed to the presence of a gold(III) center. Circular dichroism (CD) spectra, atomic absorption measurements and DNA melting profiles suggest that GHAu in vitro is able to bind DNA, the presumed target for several antitumor metal complexes, and to modify its conformation, even if the observed changes are generally small. Implications of these findings for the mechanism of action of cytotoxic gold(III) complexes are discussed.     

Chemistry, antiproliferative properties, tumor selectivity, and molecular mechanisms of novel gold(III) compounds for cancer treatment: a systematic study

Abstract  

The antiproliferative properties of a group of 13 structurally diverse gold(III) compounds, including six mononuclear gold(III) complexes, five dinuclear oxo-bridged gold(III) complexes, and two organogold(III) compounds, toward several human tumor cell lines were evaluated in vitro using a systematic screening strategy. Initially all compounds were tested against a panel of 12 human tumor cell lines, and the best performers were tested against a larger 36-cell-line panel. Very pronounced antiproliferative properties were highlighted in most cases, with cytotoxic potencies commonly falling in the low micromolar—and even nanomolar—range. Overall, good-to-excellent tumor selectivity was established for at least seven compounds, making them particularly attractive for further pharmacological evaluation. Compare analysis suggested that the observed antiproliferative effects are caused by a variety of molecular mechanisms, in most cases “DNA-independent,” and completely different from those of platinum drugs. Remarkably, some new biomolecular systems such as histone deacetylase, protein kinase C/staurosporine, mammalian target of rapamycin/rapamycin, and cyclin-dependent kinases were proposed for the first time as likely biochemical targets for the gold(III) species investigated. The results conclusively qualify gold(III) compounds as a promising class of cytotoxic agents, of outstanding interest for cancer treatment, while providing initial insight into their modes of action.     

Gold(III) compounds as anticancer agents: relevance of gold-protein interactions for their mechanism of action

Gold(III) compounds constitute an emerging class of biologically active substances, of special interest as potential anticancer agents. During the past decade a number of structurally diverse gold(III) complexes were reported to be acceptably stable under physiological-like conditions and to manifest very promising cytotoxic effects against selected human tumour cell lines, making them good candidates as anti-tumour drugs. Some representative examples will be described in detail. There is considerable interest in understanding the precise biochemical mechanisms of these novel cytotoxic agents. Based on experimental evidence collected so far we hypothesize that these metallodrugs, at variance with classical platinum(II) drugs, produce in most cases their growth inhibition effects through a variety of "DNA-independent" mechanisms. Notably, strong inhibition of the selenoenzyme thioredoxin reductase and associated disregulation of mitochondrial functions were clearly documented in some selected cases, thus providing a solid biochemical basis for the pronounced proapoptotic effects. These observations led us to investigate in detail the reactions of gold(III) compounds with a few model proteins in order to gain molecular-level information on the possible interaction modes with possible protein targets. Valuable insight on the formation and the nature of gold-protein adducts was gained through ESI MS (electrospray ionization mass spectrometry) and spectrophotometric studies of appropriate model systems as it is exemplified here by the reactions of two representative gold(III) compounds with cytochrome c and ubiquitin. The mechanistic relevance of gold(III)-induced oxidative protein damage and of direct gold coordination to protein sidechains is specifically assessed. Perspectives for the future of this topics are briefly outlined.     

Mechanistic studies on two dinuclear organogold(III) compounds showing appreciable antiproliferative properties and a high redox stability

Two dinuclear oxo-bridged organogold(III) compounds, namely [(N,N,C)(2)Au(2)(μ-O)][PF(6)](2) (with N,N,CH = 6-(1-methylbenzyl)-2,2'-bipyridine, Au(2)O1; or 6-(1,1-dimethylbenzyl)-2,2'-bipyridine, Au(2)O2), were previously prepared and characterised. Their solution chemistry under physiological-like conditions has been investigated here as well as their in vitro antiproliferative properties. Notably, these compounds reveal a marked redox stability even in the presence of effective biological reductants such as ascorbic acid and glutathione. The two dinuclear gold(iii) compounds were evaluated for cytotoxic actions against a representative panel of 12 human tumor cell lines, in comparison to respective mononuclear parent compounds [(N,N,C)AuOH][PF(6)], and appreciable biological activity could be highlighted. The reactions of Au(2)O1 and Au(2)O2 with a few model proteins were studied and the ability to form metallodrug-protein adducts monitored through ESI MS methods. Typical adducts were identified where the protein is associated to monometallic gold fragments; in these adducts gold remains in the oxidation state +3 and conserves its organic ligand. A direct comparison of the biological profiles of these binuclear organogold(III) compounds with those previously reported for a series of dinuclear oxo-bridged complexes [(N,N)(2)Au(2)(μ-O)(2)][PF(6)](2) (N,N = 6(6')-substituted 2,2'-bipyridines) named Auoxo's was carried out. It emerges that the greater cytotoxicity of the latter is mainly due to the greater oxidising power of their gold(III) centres and to propensity to generate gold(i) species; in contrast, the here described bimetallic organogold(III) complexes manifest a far higher redox stability in the biological milieu coupled to lower, but still significant, antiproliferative properties. Different molecular mechanisms are thus hypothesised for these two classes of dinuclear gold(III) agents.     

Proteomic characterization of the cytotoxic mechanism of gold (III) porphyrin 1a, a potential anticancer drug

There has been increasing interest in the potential applications of gold (III) complexes as anticancer drugs with higher cytotoxicity and fewer side effects than existing metal anticancer drugs. Our previous findings demonstrated that gold (III) porphyrin 1a preferentially induced apoptosis in a cancer cell line (SUNE1). In this study, we identified differentially expressed proteins related to the drug's cytotoxic action by comparing the protein alterations induced by gold (III) porphyrin 1a and cisplatin treatments. Several clusters of altered proteins were identified, including cellular structure and stress-related chaperone proteins, proteins involved in reactive oxygen species and enzyme proteins, translation factors, proteins that mediate cell proliferation or differentiation, and proteins participating in the internal degradation systems. Our results indicated that multiple factors leading to apoptosis were involved in drug cytotoxicity in SUNE1 cells. The balance between pro-apoptotic and anti-apoptotic signals determined the final fate of cancer cells.     

Interactions of selected gold(III) complexes with calf thymus DNA

DNA represents the primary target for platinum antitumor metal complexes and is the probable target for newly developed cytotoxic gold(III) complexes. To test this hypothesis the reactions with calf thymus DNA of five representative gold(III) complexes--namely [Au(en)(2)]Cl(3), [Au(dien)Cl]Cl(2), [Au(cyclam)](ClO(4))(2)Cl, [Au(terpy)Cl]Cl(2) and [Au(phen)Cl(2)]Cl--were analyzed in vitro through various physicochemical techniques including circular dichroism, absorption spectroscopy, DNA melting, and ultradialysis. It is shown that all tested complexes interact with DNA and modify significantly its solution behavior. The solution conformation of DNA is affected to variable extents by the individual complexes as shown by CD titration experiments. Notably, in all cases, the gold(III) chromophore is not largely perturbed by addition of calf thymus DNA ruling out occurrence of gold(III) reduction. Ultradialysis experiments point out that the binding affinity of the various complexes for the DNA double helix is relatively low; in most cases the gold(III)/DNA interaction is electrostatic in nature and reversible. The implications of these findings for the mechanism of action of antitumor gold(III) complexes are discussed.     

Synthesis,spectroscopic characterization,electrochemical behavior and computational analysis of mixed diamine ligand gold(III) complexes: antiproliferative and in vitro cytotoxic evaluations against human cancer cell lines

The gold(III) complexes of the type [(DACH)Au(en)]Cl₃, 1,2-Diaminocyclohexane ethylenediamine gold(III) chloride [where 1,2-DACH = cis-, trans-1,2- and S,S-1,2diaminocyclohexane and en = ethylenediamine] have been synthesized and characterized using various analytical and spectroscopic techniques including elemental analysis, UV–Vis and FTIR spectra; and solution as well as solid-state NMR measurements. The solid-state ¹³C NMR shows that 1,2-diaminocyclohexane (1,2-DACH) and ethylenediamine (en) are strongly bound to the gold(III) center via N donor atoms. The stability of the mixed diamine ligand gold(III) was determined by ¹H and ¹³C NMR spectra. Their electrochemical behavior was studied by cyclic voltammetry. The structural details and relative stabilities of the four possible isomers of the complexes were also reported at the B3LYP/LANL2DZ level of theory. The coordination sphere of these complexes around gold(III) center adopts distorted square planar geometry. The computational study also demonstrates that trans- conformations is slightly more stable than the cis-conformations. The antiproliferative effects and cytotoxic properties of the mixed diamine ligand gold(III) complexes were evaluated in vitro on human gastric SGC7901 and prostate PC3 cancer cells using MTT assay. The antiproliferative study of the gold(III) complexes on PC3 and SGC7901 cells indicate that complex 1 is the most effective antiproliferative agent among mixed ligand based gold(III) complexes 1–3. The IC₅₀ data reveal that the in vitro cytotoxicity of complexes 1 and 3 against SGC7901 cancer cells are fairly better than that of cisplatin.     

Gold complexes as prospective metal-based anticancer drugs

Medical and therapeutic value of gold has been recognized thousands of years ago, but its rational use in medicine has not begun until the early 1920s. Cisplatin is one of the first metal-containing compounds with anti-cancer activity discovered in the 1960s. Despite the fact that cisplatin treatment is efficient for several types of solid tumors, its effectiveness is limited by toxic side effects and tumor resistance that often leads to the occurrence of secondary malignancies. Since gold(III) is isoelectronic with platinum(II) and tetracoordinate gold(III) complexes have the same square-planar geometries as cisplatin, the anticancer activity of gold(III) compounds has been investigated. Previous studies suggested that, in contrast to cisplatin, gold complexes target proteins but not DNA. Recently, we have investigated gold(III) dithiocarbamates for their anticancer activity and showed that their primary target is the proteasome. Treatment of human breast tumor-bearing nude mice with a gold(III) dithiocarbamate complex resulted in significant inhibition of tumor growth, associated with proteasome inhibition and massive apoptosis induction in vivo. Better understanding of physiological processing of gold compounds will provide a rational basis for their further development into novel anticancer drugs.     

DNA binding properties of novel cytotoxic gold(III) complexes of terpyridine ligands: the impact of steric and electrostatic effects

Four gold(III) complexes of terpyridine derivatives 1–4 have been synthesized and characterized by spectroscopic methods. In vitro data demonstrated that all of them showed higher cytotoxicity than cisplatin against the human non-small-cell lung cancer cell line (A-549), the human stomach carcinoma cell line (SGC-7901), the human cervix carcinoma cell line (HELA), the human colon carcinoma cell line (HCT-116), the human liver carcinoma cell line (BEL-7402), the murine leukemia cell line (P-388) and the human acute promyelocytic leukemia cell line (HL-60). Complex 3 exhibits the highest activity, with growth inhibition rates of over 80% at 10⁻⁸ mol L⁻¹ against the A-549, HCT-116 and HELA tumor cell lines. Interestingly, ligands L1–L4 are also very cytotoxic against the cell lines tested. Complexes 1–4 are stable in aqueous solution for 2 days in the presence of the biological reducing agent glutathione. The inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry data showed that DNA isolated from cells treated with complexes 1 and 3 contained gold with gold-to-nucleotide ratios of approximately 1:6,400 and 1:4,900, respectively. Fluorescence titration, UV and circular dichroism analyses proved that the steric and electrostatic effects of the ligand remarkably influence the interactions of their gold(III) complexes with DNA. The DNA binding ability of the complexes has been correlated with their cytotoxicity, which could potentially provide a new rationale for the future design of terpyridine-based metal complexes with antitumor potential.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available to authorized users in the online version of this article at .     

The synthesis, chemical and biological properties of dichlorido(azpy)gold(III) chloride (azpy=2-(phenylazo)pyridine) and the gold-induced conversion of the azpy ligand to the chloride of the novel tricyclic pyrido[2,1-c][1,2,4]benzotriazin-11-ium cation

A new Au(III) coordination compound with the ligand 2-(phenylazo)pyridine has been synthesized and fully characterized by means of elemental analysis, IR, UV-visible, conductivity measurements, NMR, electrospray ionization (ESI-MS) and inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES). The chemical stability of the cation in this compound, [Au(azpy)Cl(2)](+) (abbreviated: Au-azpy), was analyzed by means of several physicochemical methods. While stable in the solid state, stability studies performed with the gold compound in solution showed an unexpected and unprecedented reactivity. A cationic organic derivative of 2-(phenylazo)pyridine, (abbreviated: pyrium), was produced from the solution and has been isolated as its chloride salt and characterized by crystal structure determination, elemental analysis, NMR, ESI-MS and conductivity studies in solution. This cyclization reaction is reported for the first time in the case of gold coordination compounds. The Au adduct and the pyrium cation were investigated as potential cytotoxic and anticancer agents, and both show moderate to high cytotoxic properties in cisplatin-sensitive and cisplatin-resistant ovarian carcinoma cell lines, A2780; and cisplatin-sensitive and cisplatin-resistant murine lymphocytic leukemia cell lines, L1210. Significant anticancer activity against the cisplatin resistant cell lines was found for the pyrium salt, ruling out the occurrence of cross resistance phenomena.     

Gold complexes inhibit mitochondrial thioredoxin reductase: consequences on mitochondrial functions

The effects of gold(I) complexes (auranofin, triethylphosphine gold and aurothiomalate), gold(III) complexes ([Au(2,2'-diethylendiamine)Cl]Cl(2), [(Au(2-(1,1-dimethylbenzyl)-pyridine) (CH(3)COO)(2)], [Au(6-(1,1-dimethylbenzyl)-2,2'-bipyridine)(OH)](PF(6)), [Au(bipy(dmb)-H)(2,6-xylidine)](PF(6))), metal ions (zinc and cadmium acetate) and metal complexes (cisplatin, zinc pyrithione and tributyltin) on mitochondrial thioredoxin reductase and mitochondrial functions have been examined. Both gold(I) and gold(III) complexes are extremely efficient inhibitors of thioredoxin reductase showing IC(50) ranging from 0.020 to 1.42 microM while metal ions and complexes not containing gold are less effective, exhibiting IC(50) going from 11.8 to 76.0 microM. At variance with thioredoxin reductase, auranofin is completely ineffective in inhibiting glutathione peroxidase and glutathione reductase, while gold(III) compounds show some effect on glutathione peroxidase. The mitochondrial respiratory chain is scarcely affected by gold compounds while the other metal complexes and metal ions, in particular zinc ion and zinc pyrithione, show a more marked inhibitory effect that is reflected on a rapid induction of membrane potential decrease that precedes swelling. Therefore, differently from gold compounds, the various metal ions and metal complexes exert their effect on different targets indicating a lower specificity. It is concluded that gold compounds are highly specific inhibitors of mitochondrial thioredoxin reductase and this action influences other functions such as membrane permeability properties. Metal ions and metal complexes markedly inhibit the activity of thioredoxin reductase although to an extent lower than that of gold compounds. They also inhibit mitochondrial respiration, decrease membrane potential and, finally, induce swelling.     

Synthesis,structure, spectroscopic and in vitro antitumour studies of a novel gallium(III) complex with 2-acetylpyridine (4)N-dimethylthiosemicarbazone

The reaction of 2-acetylpyridine 4N-dimethylthiosemicarbazone (HL) with GaCl(3) in absolute ethanol in 1:1 molar ratio yielded the complex [GaL(2)][GaCl(4)]. The crystal structure of the gallium(III) complex has been determined by X-ray diffraction methods. Infrared, electronic, ESI mass and (1)H, (13)C, (15)N and (71)Ga NMR spectra, as well as the thermal behaviour are reported. The cytotoxicity assay in several human cancer cell lines (SW480, SK-BR-3 and 41M) suggests that the gallium(III) complex might be endowed with promising antitumour properties. In vitro cytotoxic activity exceeds that of all other tested gallium(III) complexes and is slightly higher than that of HL.     

Structural and solution chemistry, protein binding and antiproliferative profiles of gold(I)/(III) complexes bearing the saccharinato ligand

A series of new gold(I) and gold(III) complexes based on the saccharinate (sac) ligand, namely M[Au(sac)₂] (with M being Na⁺, K⁺ or NH₄⁺), [(PTA)Au(sac)], K[Au(sac)₃Cl] and Na[Au(sac)₄], were synthesized and characterized, and some aspects of their biological profile investigated. Spectrophotometric analysis revealed that these gold compounds, upon dissolution in aqueous media, at physiological pH, manifest a rather favourable balance between stability and reactivity. Their reactions with the model proteins cytochrome c and lysozyme were monitored by mass spectrometry to predict their likely interactions with protein targets. In the case of disaccharinato gold(I) complexes, cytochrome c adducts bearing four coordinated gold(I) ions were preferentially formed in high yield. In contrast, [(PTA)Au(sac)] (PTA = 1,3,5-triaza-7-phosphaadamantane) turned out to be poorly effective, only producing a mono-metalated adduct in very low amount. In turn, the gold(III) saccharinate derivatives were less reactive than their gold(I) analogues: K[Au(sac)₃Cl] and Na[Au(sac)₄] caused moderate protein metalation, again with evidence of formation of tetragold adducts. Finally, the above mentioned gold compounds were challenged against the reference human tumor cell line A2780S and its cisplatin resistant subline A2780R and their respective cytotoxic profiles determined. [(PTA)Au(sac)] turned out to be highly cytotoxic whereas moderate cytotoxicities were observed for the gold(III) complexes and only modest activities for disaccharinato gold(I) complexes. The implications of these results are thoroughly discussed in the light of current knowledge on gold based drugs.     

Cytotoxic effects of metal complexes of biogenic polyamines. I. Platinum(II) spermidine compounds: prediction of their antitumour activity

Cytotoxicity and cell growth inhibition studies were performed for three distinct polynuclear platinum(II) complexes of spermidine, which showed to have significant cytotoxic and antiproliferative properties on the HeLa cancer cell line. The chemical environment of the metal centres in the drugs, as well as the coordination pattern of the ligand, were found to be strongly determinant of their cytotoxic ability. In the light of the results gathered, the most effective anticancer compound among the ones tested (IC50=5 microM) was found to be the one displaying three difunctional (PtCl2N2) moieties ((PtCl2)3(spd)2). Both the cytotoxic activity and the antiproliferative properties of the complexes studied showed to be irreversible for all the concentrations tested.     

Organogold(III) compounds as experimental anticancer agents: chemical and biological profiles

In the last few years gold(III) complexes have attracted growing attention in the medicinal chemistry community as candidate anticancer agents. In particular some organogold(III) compounds manifested quite attractive pharmacological behaviors in preclinical studies. Here we compare the chemical and biological properties of the novel organogold(III) complex [Au(bipy^dmb?H)(NH(CO)CH₃)][PF₆] (Aubipy^aa) with those of its parent compounds [Au(bipy^dmb?H)(OH)][PF₆] (Aubipy^c) and [Au₂(bipy^dmb?H)₂)(μ?O)][PF₆]₂ (Au2bipy^c), previously synthesized and characterized. The three study compounds were comparatively assessed for their antiproliferative actions against HCT-116 cancer cells, revealing moderate cytotoxic effects. Proapoptotic and cell cycle effects were also monitored. Afterward, to gain additional mechanistic insight, the three gold compounds were challenged against the model proteins HEWL, RNase A and cytochrome c and reactions investigated through UV–Vis and ESI–MS analysis. A peculiar and roughly invariant protein metalation profile emerges in the three cases consisting of protein binding of {Au(bipy^dmb?H)} moieties. The implications of these results are discussed in the frame of current knowledge on anticancer gold compounds.     

Reactions of gold(III) complexes with serum albumin.

The reactions of a few representative gold(III) complexes -[Au(ethylenediamine)2]Cl3, [Au(diethylentriamine)Cl]Cl2, [Au(1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclotetradecane)](ClO4)2Cl, [Au(2,2',2'-terpyridine)Cl]Cl2, [Au(2,2'-bipyridine)(OH)2][PF6] and the organometallic compound [Au(6-(1,1-dimethylbenzyl)-2,2'-bipyridine-H)(OH)][PF6]- with BSA were investigated by the joint use of various spectroscopic methods and separation techniques. Weak metal-protein interactions were revealed for the [Au(ethylenediamine)2]3+ and [Au(1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclotetradecane)]3+ species, whereas progressive reduction of the gold(III) centre was observed in the cases of [Au(2,2'-bipyridine)(OH)2]+ and [Au(2,2',2'-terpyridine)Cl]2+. In contrast, tight metal-protein adducts are formed when BSA is reacted with either [Au(diethylentriamine)Cl]2+ and [Au(6-(1,1-dimethylbenzyl)-2,2'-bipyridine-H)(OH)]+. Notably, binding of the latter complex to serum albumin results in the appearance of characteristic CD bands in the visible spectrum. It is suggested that adduct formation for both of these gold(III) complexes occurs through coordination at the level of surface histidines. Stability of these gold(III) complexes/serum albumin adducts was tested under physiologically relevant conditions and found to be appreciable. Metal binding to the protein is tight; complete detachment of the metal from the protein has been achieved only after the addition of excess potassium cyanide. The implications of the present results for the pharmacological activity of these novel cytotoxic agents are discussed.     

Synthesis, characterization and biological activity of lanthanum(III) complexes containing 2-methylene-1,10-phenanthroline units bridged by aliphatic diamines

Two novel lanthanum(III) complexes containing 2-methylene-1,10-phenanthroline units bridged by aliphatic diamines were synthesized and characterized by elemental analysis, IR, NMR, thermal analysis and conductance measurements. They have been assayed for anticancer activity in vitro against HL-60 (human leukocytoma) cells, PC-3MIE8 (human prostate carcinoma) cells, BGC-823 (human stomach carcinoma) cells, MDA-MB-435 (human galactophore carcinoma) cells, Bel-7402 (human liver carcinoma) cells, and Hela (human cervix carcinoma) cells. The results show that the two complexes exhibit good cytotoxic activities against different cell lines in general, especially more effective than cisplatin against Bel-7402, BGC-823 and MDA-MB-435 cell lines. DNA-binding studies indicate that, besides the intercalation, the complexes bind to DNA by the other interaction(s), which might be responsible for the production of more compact DNA, coinciding with more A-like feature of DNA as suggested by CD spectra.     

Synthesis, characterization and biological activity of complexes of lanthanum(III) with 2-(1'-phenyl- 2'-carboxyl-3'-aza-n-butyl)-1,10-phenanthroline and 2-(1'-p-phenol-2'-carboxyl-3'-aza-n-butyl)-1,10-phenanthroline

Two novel ligands 2-(1'-phenyl-2'-carboxyl-3'-aza-n-butyl)-1,10-phenanthroline (L1) and 2-(1'-p-phenol-2'-carboxyl-3'-aza-butyl)-1,10-phenanthroline (L2), and their La(III) complexes of La(III)L1, La(III)(L1)(2), La(III)L2, and La(III)(L2)(2), were synthesized and characterized by (1)H NMR, elemental analysis, IR, thermal analysis and conductance measurement. All complexes have been assayed for anticancer activity in vitro against HL-60 (human leukocytoma) cells, PC-3MIE8 (human prostate carcinoma) cells, BGC-823 (human stomach carcinoma) cells, MDA-MB-435 (human galactophore carcinoma) cells, Bel-7402 (human liver carcinoma) cells, and HeLa (human cervix carcinoma) cells. Results showed that the two complexes La(III)L1 and La(III)(L1)(2) exhibited good cytotoxic activity against different cell lines in general; and La(III)(L1)(2) is more effective than cisplatin against all six cell lines. DNA-binding studies indicated that, besides the intercalation, the complexes bind to DNA by the other interaction(s).