A very short peptide makes a voltage-dependent ion channel: the critical length of the channel domain of colicin E1

Cleavage of colicin E1 molecules with a variety of proteases or with cyanogen bromide (CNBr) generates COOH-terminal fragments which have channel-forming activity similar to that of intact colicin in planar lipid bilayer membranes. The smallest channel-forming fragment obtained by CNBr cleavage of the wild-type molecule consists of the C-terminal 152 amino acids. By the use of oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis, we have made nine mutants along this 152 amino acid peptide, in which an amino acid was replaced by methionine in order to create a new CNBr cleavage site. The smallest of the CNBr-cleaved C-terminal fragments with channel-forming activity, in planar bilayer membranes, was generated by cleavage at new Met position 428 and has 94 amino acids, whereas a 75 amino acid peptide produced by cleavage of a new Met at position 447 did not have channel activity. The NH2-terminus of the channel-forming domain of colicin E1 appears therefore to lie between residues 428 and 447. Since, however, the last six C-terminal residues of the colicin can be removed without changing activity, the number of amino acids necessary to form the channel is 88 or less. In addition, the unique Cys residue in colicin E1 was replaced by Gly, and nine mutants were then made with Cys placed at sequential locations along the peptide for eventual use as sulfhydryl attachment sites to determine the local environment of the replaced amino acid. In the course of making 21 mutants, eight charged residues have been replaced by uncharged Met or Cys without changing the biological activity of the intact molecule. It has been proposed previously that the conformation of the colicin E1 channel is a barrel formed from five or six alpha-helices, each having 20 amino acids spanning the membrane and two to four residues making the turn at the boundary of the membrane. Our finding that 88 amino acids can make an active channel, combined with recently reported stoichiometric evidence that the channel is a monomer excludes this model and adds significant constraints which can be used in building a molecular model of the channel.     

Membrane topography of ColE1 gene products: the hydrophobic anchor of the colicin E1 channel is a helical hairpin.

The paucity of crystallographic data on the structure of intrinsic membrane proteins necessitates the development of additional techniques to probe their structures. The colicin E1 ion channel domain contains one prominent hydrophobic region near its COOH terminus that has been proposed to be an anchor for the assembly of the channel. Saturation site-directed mutagenesis of the hydrophobic anchor region of the colicin E1 ion channel was used to probe whether it spanned the bilayer once or twice. A nonpolar amino acid was replaced by a charged residue in 29 mutations made at 26 positions in the channel domain. Substitution of the charged amino acid at all positions except those in the center of the hydrophobic region and the periphery of the hydrophobic region caused a large decrease in the cytotoxicity of the purified mutant colicin E1 protein. This result implies that the hydrophobic domain spans the membrane bilayer twice in a helical hairpin loop, with the center of this domain residing in an aqueous or polar phase. The lengths of the trans-membrane helices appear to be approximately 18 and 16 residues. The absence of significant changes in ion selectivity in five of nine mutants indicated that these mutations did not cause a large change in the channel structure. The ion selectivity changes in four mutants and those previously documented for the flanking Lys residues imply that the hydrophobic hairpin is part of the channel lumen. Water may "abhor" the hydrophobic side of the channel, explaining the small effects of residue charge changes on ion selectivity.     

Determination of membrane protein topology by red-edge excitation shift analysis: application to the membrane-bound colicin E1 channel peptide

A new approach for the determination of the bilayer location of Trp residues in proteins has been applied to the study of the membrane topology of the channel-forming bacteriocin, colicin E1. This method, red-edge excitation shift (REES) analysis, was initially applied to the study of 12 single Trp-containing channel peptides of colicin E1 in the soluble state in aqueous medium. Notably, REES was observed for most of the channel peptides in aqueous solution upon low pH activation. The extent of REES was subsequently characterized using a model membrane system composed of the tripeptide, Lys-Trp-Lys, bound to dimyristoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Subsequently, data accrued from the model peptide-lipid system was used to interpret information obtained on the channel peptides when bound to dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylcholine/dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylglycerol membrane vesicles. The single Trp mutant peptides were divided into three categories based on the change in the REES values observed for the Trp residues when the peptides were bound to liposomes as compared to the REES values measured for the soluble peptides. F-404 W, F-413 W, F-443 W, F-484 W, and W-495 peptides exhibited small and/or insignificant REES changes (Delta REES) whereas W-424, F-431 W, and Y-507 W channel peptides possessed modest REES changes (3 nm< or = Delta REES< or = 7 nm). In contrast, wild-type, Y-367 W, W-460, Y-478 W, and I-499 W channel peptides showed large Delta REES values upon membrane binding (7 nm< Delta REES< or =12 nm). The REES data for the membrane-bound structure of the colicin E1 channel peptide proved consistent with previous data for the topology of the closed channel state, which lends further credence to the currently proposed channel model. In conclusion, the REES method provides another source of topological data for assignment of the bilayer location for Trp residues within membrane-associated proteins; however, it also requires careful interpretation of spectral data in combination with structural information on the proteins being investigated.     

Determination of membrane protein topology by red-edge excitation shift analysis: application to the membrane-bound colicin E1 channel peptide

A new approach for the determination of the bilayer location of Trp residues in proteins has been applied to the study of the membrane topology of the channel-forming bacteriocin, colicin E1. This method, red-edge excitation shift (REES) analysis, was initially applied to the study of 12 single Trp-containing channel peptides of colicin E1 in the soluble state in aqueous medium. Notably, REES was observed for most of the channel peptides in aqueous solution upon low pH activation. The extent of REES was subsequently characterized using a model membrane system composed of the tripeptide, Lys-Trp-Lys, bound to dimyristoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Subsequently, data accrued from the model peptide-lipid system was used to interpret information obtained on the channel peptides when bound to dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylcholine/dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylglycerol membrane vesicles. The single Trp mutant peptides were divided into three categories based on the change in the REES values observed for the Trp residues when the peptides were bound to liposomes as compared to the REES values measured for the soluble peptides. F-404W, F-413W, F-443W, F-484W, and W-495 peptides exhibited small and/or insignificant REES changes (ΔREES) whereas W-424, F-431W, and Y-507W channel peptides possessed modest REES changes (3 nm≤ΔREES≤7 nm). In contrast, wild-type, Y-367W, W-460, Y-478W, and I-499W channel peptides showed large ΔREES values upon membrane binding (7 nm<ΔREES≤12 nm). The REES data for the membrane-bound structure of the colicin E1 channel peptide proved consistent with previous data for the topology of the closed channel state, which lends further credence to the currently proposed channel model. In conclusion, the REES method provides another source of topological data for assignment of the bilayer location for Trp residues within membrane-associated proteins; however, it also requires careful interpretation of spectral data in combination with structural information on the proteins being investigated.     

Membrane topology of the colicin E1 channel using genetically encoded fluorescence

The membrane topology of the colicin E1 channel domain was studied by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). The FRET involved a genetically encoded fluorescent amino acid (coumarin) as the donor and a selectively labeled cysteine residue tethered with DABMI (4-(dimethylamino)phenylazophenyl-4'-maleimide) as the FRET acceptor. The fluorescent coumarin residue was incorporated into the protein via an orthogonal tRNA/aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase pair that allowed selective incorporation into any site within the colicin channel domain. Each variant harbored a stop (TAG) mutation for coumarin incorporation and a cysteine (TGT) mutation for DABMI attachment. Six interhelical distances within helices 1-6 were determined using FRET analysis for both the soluble and membrane-bound states. The FRET data showed large changes in the interhelical distances among helices 3-6 upon membrane association providing new insight into the membrane-bound structure of the channel domain. In general, the coumarin-DABMI FRET interhelical efficiencies decreased upon membrane binding, building upon the umbrella model for the colicin channel. A tentative model for the closed state of the channel domain was developed based on current and previously published FRET data. The model suggests circular arrangement of helices 1-7 in a clockwise direction from the extracellular side and membrane interfacial association of helices 1, 6, 7, and 10 around the central transmembrane hairpin formed by helices 8 and 9.     

Localization of the immunity protein-reactive domain in unmodified and chemically modified COOH-terminal peptides of colicin E1.

The region of the colicin E1 polypeptide that interacts with immunity protein has been localized to a 168-residue COOH-terminal peptide. This is the length of a proteolytically generated peptide fragment of colicin E1 against which imm+ function can be demonstrated in osmotically shocked cells. The role of particular amino acids of the COOH-terminal peptide in the expression of the immune phenotype was studied. Chemical modification showed that the two histidine residues (His 427 and His 440) and the single cysteine residue (Cys 505) present in the COOH-terminal peptide were not necessary for the colicin-immunity protein interaction. The immunity protein was localized in the cytoplasmic membrane fraction, consistent with previous work of others on the colicin Ia immunity protein and the prediction from the immunity protein amino acid sequence that it is a hydrophobic protein. The distribution of hydrophobic residues along the immunity polypeptide was calculated.     

Adventures in membrane protein topology. A study of the membrane-bound state of colicin E1.

The molecular aggregate size of the closed state of the colicin E1 channel was determined by fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments involving a fluorescence donor (three tryptophans, wild-type protein) and a fluorescence acceptor (5-(((acetyl)amino)ethyl)aminonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (AEDANS), Trp-deficient protein). There was no evidence of energy transfer between the donor and acceptor species when bound to membrane large unilamellar vesicles. These experiments led to the conclusion that the colicin E1 channel is monomeric in the membrane-bound closed channel state. Experiments were also conducted to study the membrane topology of the closed colicin channel in membrane large unilamellar vesicles using acrylamide as the membrane-impermeant, nonionic quencher of tryptophan fluorescence in a battery of single tryptophan mutant proteins. Furthermore, additional fluorescence parameters, including fluorescence emission maximum, fluorescence quantum yield, and fluorescence decay times, were used to assist in mapping the topology of the closed channel. Results suggest that the closed channel comprises most of the polypeptide of the channel domain and that the hydrophobic anchor domain does not transverse the membrane bilayer but nonetheless is deeply embedded within the hydrocarbon core of the membrane. Finally, a model is proposed which features at least two states that are in rapid equilibrium with each other and in which one state is more heavily populated than the other.     

Solid-state NMR studies of the membrane-bound closed state of the colicin E1 channel domain in lipid bilayers.

The colicin E1 channel polypeptide was shown to be organized anisotropically in membranes by solid-state NMR analysis of samples of uniformly 15N-labeled protein in oriented planar phospholipid bilayers. The 190 residue C-terminal colicin E1 channel domain is the largest polypeptide to have been characterized by 15N solid-state NMR spectroscopy in oriented membrane bilayers. The 15N-NMR spectra of the colicin E1 show that: (1) the structure and dynamics are independent of anionic lipid content in both oriented and unoriented samples; (2) assuming the secondary structure of the polypeptide is helical, there are both trans-membrane and in-plane helical segments; (3) trans-membrane helices account for approximately 20-25% of the channel polypeptide, which is equivalent to 38-48 residues of the 190-residue polypeptide. The results of the two-dimensional PISEMA spectrum are interpreted in terms of a single trans-membrane helical hairpin inserted into the bilayer from each channel molecule. These data are also consistent with this helical hairpin being derived from the 38-residue hydrophobic segment near the C-terminus of the colicin E1 channel polypeptide.     

DNA sequence analysis of three missense mutations affecting colicin E3 bactericidal activity

Summary
We have determined the nucleotide sequence changes caused by three missense mutations leading to the production of inactive colicin E3 proteins. The ceaC1 mutation, affecting the transiocation of colicin E3 through bacterial membranes, is caused by a serine to phenylalanine change at position 37 within the glycine-rich region at the N-terminal part of colicin E3. This confirms previous results suggesting a role for this domain in colicin uptake by sensitive cells. The ceaC2 and ceaC3 mutations, abolishing colicin E3 RNase activity, affect the C-terminal enzymatic domain of the molecule, in the ceaC2 mutant, serine at position 529 was converted to leucine. The ceaC3 mutation replaced a glycine residue at position 524 with an aspartic acid residue. The two mutations ceaC2 and ceaC3 yieid information on the amino acid residues involved in the RNase activity of colicin E3.     

DNA sequence analysis of three missense mutations affecting colicin E3 bactericidal activity

We have determined the nucleotide sequence changes caused by three missense mutations leading to the production of inactive colicin E3 proteins. The ceaC1 mutation, affecting the translocation of colicin E3 through bacterial membranes, is caused by a serine to phenylalanine change at position 37 within the glycine-rich region at the N-terminal part of colicin E3. This confirms previous results suggesting a role for this domain in colicin uptake by sensitive cells. The ceaC2 and ceaC3 mutations, abolishing colicin E3 RNase activity, affect the C-terminal enzymatic domain of the molecule. In the ceaC2 mutant, serine at position 529 was converted to leucine. The ceaC3 mutation replaced a glycine residue at position 524 with an aspartic acid residue. The two mutations ceaC2 and ceaC3 yield information on the amino acid residues involved in the RNase activity of colicin E3.     

Structure and dynamics of the colicin E1 channel

The toxin-like and bactericidal colicin E1 molecule is of interest for problems of toxin action, polypeptide translocation across membranes, voltage-gated channels, and receptor function. Colicin E1 binds to a receptor in the outer membrane and is translocated across the cell envelope to the inner membrane. Import of the colicin channel-forming domain into the inner membrane involves a translocation-competent intermediate state and a membrane potential-dependent movement of one third to one half of the channel peptide into the membrane bilayer. The voltage-gated channel has a conductance sufficiently large to depolarize the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane. Amino acid residues that affect the channel ion selectivity have been identified by site-directed mutagenesis. The colicin E1 channel is one of a few membrane proteins whose secondary structures in the membrane, predominantly alpha-helix, have been determined by physico-chemical techniques. Hypothesis for the identity of the trans-membrane helices, and the mechanism of binding to the membrane, are influenced by the solved crystal structure of the soluble colicin A channel peptide. The protective action of immunity protein is a unique aspect of the colicin problem, and information has been obtained, by genetic techniques, about the probable membrane topography of the imm gene product.     

Effect of lipids with different spontaneous curvature on the channel activity of colicin E1: evidence in favor of a toroidal pore

The channel activity of colicin E1 was studied in planar lipid bilayers and liposomes. Colicin E1 pore-forming activity was found to depend on the curvature of the lipid bilayer, as judged by the effect on channel activity of curvature-modulating agents. In particular, the colicin-induced trans-membrane current was augmented by lysophosphatidylcholine and reduced by oleic acid, agents promoting positive and negative membrane curvature, respectively. The data obtained imply direct involvement of lipids in the formation of colicin E1-induced pore walls. It is inferred that the toroidal pore model previously validated for small antimicrobial peptides is applicable to colicin E1, a large protein that contains ten alpha-helices in its pore-forming domain.     

Nucleotide sequence of the colicin B activity gene cba: consensus pentapeptide among TonB-dependent colicins and receptors.

Colicin B formed by Escherichia coli kills sensitive bacteria by dissipating the membrane potential through channel formation. The nucleotide sequence of the structural gene (cba) which encodes colicin B and of the upstream region was determined. A polypeptide consisting of 511 amino acids was deduced from the open reading frame. The active colicin had a molecular weight of 54,742. The carboxy-terminal amino acid sequence showed striking homology to the corresponding channel-forming region of colicin A. Of 216 amino acids, 57% were identical and an additional 19% were homologous. In this part 66% of the nucleotides were identical in the colicin A and B genes. This region contained a sequence of 48 hydrophobic amino acids. Sequence homology to the other channel-forming colicins, E1 and I, was less pronounced. A homologous pentapeptide was detected in colicins B, M, and I whose uptake required TonB protein function. The same consensus sequence was found in all outer membrane proteins involved in the TonB-dependent uptake of iron siderophores and of vitamin B12. Upstream of cba a sequence comprising 294 nucleotides was identical to the sequence upstream of the structural gene of colicin E1, with the exception of 43 single-nucleotide replacements, additions, or deletions. Apparently, the region upstream of colicins B and E1 and the channel-forming sequences of colicins A and B have a common origin.     

Histidine 440 controls the opening of colicin E1 channels in a lipid-dependent manner

The in vitro activity of many pore-forming toxins, in particular, the rate of increase in the membrane conductance induced by the channel-forming domain (P178) of colicin E1 is maximum at an acidic pH. However, after P178 binding at acidic conditions, a subsequent pH shift from 4 to 6 on both sides of the planar bilayer lipid membrane caused a large increase in the trans-membrane current which was solely due to an increase in the number of open channels. This effect required the presence of anionic lipid. Replacing the His440 residue of P178 by alanine eliminated the pH-shift effect thereby showing that it is associated with deprotonation of this histidine residue. It was concluded that alkalinization-induced weakening of the electrostatic interactions between colicin and the membrane surface facilitates conformational changes required for the transition of membrane-bound colicin molecules to an active channel state.     

Transmembrane insertion of the Colicin Ia hydrophobic hairpin

Colicin Ia is a bactericidal protein that forms voltage-dependent, ion-conducting channels, both in the inner membrane of target bacteria and in planar bilayer membranes. Its amino acid sequence is rich in charged residues, except for a hydrophobic segment of 40 residues near the carboxyl terminus. In the crystal structure of colicin Ia and related colicins, this segment forms an α-helical hairpin. The hydrophobic segment is thought to be involved in the initial association of the colicin with the membrane and in the formation of the channel, but various orientations of the hairpin with respect to the membrane have been proposed. To address this issue, we attached biotin to a residue at the tip of the hydrophobic hairpin, and then probed its location with the biotin-binding protein streptavidin, added to one side or the other of a planar bilayer. Streptavidin added to the same side as the colicin prevented channel opening. Prior addition of streptavidin to the opposite side protected channels from this effect, and also increased the rate of channel opening; it produced these effects even before the first opening of the channels. These results suggest a model of membrane association in which the colicin first binds with the hydrophobic hairpin parallel to the membrane; next the hairpin inserts in a transmembrane orientation; and finally the channel opens. We also used streptavidin binding to obtain a stable population of colicin molecules in the membrane, suitable for the quantitative study of voltage-dependent gating. The effective gating charge thus determined is pH-independent and relatively small, compared with previous results for wild-type colicin Ia. Received: 12 November 1996/Revised: 23 January 1997     

Decrease of anion selectivity caused by mutation of Thr501 and Gly502 to Glu in the hydrophobic domain of the colicin E1 channel

Structure-function relations of the colicin E1 ion channel were studied through the effects of mutations in the 35-residue hydrophobic region of the channel polypeptide and neighboring residues in the channel domain. Mutation of neutral residues threonine 501 and glycine 502 to a more polar or charged glutamic acid generated a protein whose channel conductance properties in each case had a decreased selectivity for anions. There was no significant effect on ion selectivity caused by mutations that changed residue charge outside the hydrophobic domain at the neighboring aspartic acid 509 or at glycine 439. The Thr501----Glu and Gly502----Glu mutants possessed lower cytotoxic and in vitro activity. An altered thermolysin cleavage pattern and a greater binding to membrane vesicles at pH greater than 4.5 of the Gly502----Glu mutant indicated greater exposure of its COOH-terminal hydrophobic domain in solution. It is concluded that the hydrophobic nature of threonine 501 and glycine 502 is important in the structure of the channel lumen and the soluble colicin. Altering proline 462, a residue conserved in five sequenced channel-forming colicins, had no significant effect on channel properties. These conclusions are discussed in the context of sequence-structure-function concepts for channel proteins.     

Identification of a translocated gating charge in a voltage-dependent channel. Colicin E1 channels in planar phospholipid bilayer membranes.

The availability of primary sequences for ion-conducting channels permits the development of testable models for mechanisms of voltage gating. Previous work on planar phospholipid bilayers and lipid vesicles indicates that voltage gating of colicin E1 channels involves translocation of peptide segments of the molecule into and across the membrane. Here we identify histidine residue 440 as a gating charge associated with this translocation. Using site-directed mutagenesis to convert the positively charged His440 to a neutral cysteine, we find that the voltage dependence for turn-off of channels formed by this mutant at position 440 is less steep than that for wild-type channels; the magnitude of the change in voltage dependence is consistent with residue 440 moving from the trans to the cis side of the membrane in association with channel closure. The effect of trans pH changes on the ion selectivity of channels formed by the carboxymethylated derivative of the cysteine 440 mutant independently establishes that in the open channel state, residue 440 lies on the trans side of the membrane. On the basis of these results, we propose that the voltage-gated opening of colicin E1 channels is accompanied by the insertion into the bilayer of a helical hairpin loop extending from residue 420 to residue 459, and that voltage-gated closing is associated with the extrusion of this loop from the interior of the bilayer back to the cis side.     

Purification of a small receptor-binding peptide from the central region of the colicin E1 molecule

An Mr = 16,000 receptor-binding fragment of colicin E1 has been obtained by cyanogen bromide digestion of colicin E1. The purified 16-kDa fragment shows binding properties similar to those of an Mr = 38,000 colicin E1 receptor-binding fragment generated by thermolysin treatment. Treatment of the 38-kDa fragment with cyanogen bromide also yields the 16-kDa fragment. By comparing the NH2-terminal amino acid sequence of the 16-kDa fragment with the known colicin E1 sequence, the receptor-binding fragment can be shown to occupy the central region of the colicin molecule, extending from residue 231 to 370. It is inferred that the 16-kDa fragment binds efficiently to the colicin receptor because it is able to protect sensitive cells against the lethal effects of colicins E1 and E2 and, when pre-adsorbed to the cell, to physically displace colicin E1. Unlike the 38-kDa receptor-binding fragment, the 16-kDa fragment was found to be devoid of channel-forming ability previously shown to be associated with the COOH-terminal region of the colicin E1 polypeptide.     

Comparison of the macroscopic and single channel conductance properties of colicin E1 and its COOH-terminal tryptic peptide

A COOH-terminal tryptic fragment (Mr approximately equal to 20,000) of colicin E1 has been proposed to contain the membrane channel-forming domain of the colicin molecule. A comparison is made of the conductance properties of colicin E1 and its COOH-terminal fragment in planar bilayer membranes. The macroscopic and single channel properties of colicin E1 and its COOH-terminal tryptic fragment are very similar, if not indistinguishable, implying that the NH2-terminal, two-thirds of the colicin E1 molecule, does not significantly influence its channel properties. The channel-forming activity of both polypeptides is dependent upon the presence of a membrane potential, negative on the trans side of the membrane. The average single channel conductance of colicin E1 and the COOH-terminal fragment is 20.9 +/- 3.9 and 19.1 +/- 2.9 picosiemens, respectively. The rate at which both proteins form conducting channels increases as the pH is lowered from 7 to 5. Both molecules require negatively charged lipids for activity to be expressed, exhibit the same ion selectivity, and rectify the current to the same extent. Both polypeptides associate irreversibly with the membrane in the absence of voltage, but subsequent formation of conducting channels requires a negative membrane potential.     

Binding domains of colicins E1, E2 and E3 in the receptor protein btub ofEscherichia coli

Eight reagents specifically modifying amino acids were applied to cells of a standardEscherichia coli colicin indicator strain to followin vivo changes of its binding capacity for colicins E1–E3 and hence the binding domains (epitopes) for them in the outer membrane receptor protein BtuB. The effect of these reagents was also investigated in a mutant strain carrying an extensive BtuB deletion. The following differences of the binding epitopes could be ascertained.Colicin E1: Blockage of OH-groups, just as N-substitution of His and modification of Arg and Trp enhance binding of colicin E1. In the deleted receptor, also abolition of carboxylic anion bonds enhances its affinity for colicin E1. It follows that colicin E1 is bound, most of all, to the hydrophobic domain A (loops 1+2) of BtuB.Colicins E2 and E3: both exert rather analogous binding parameters. In contrast to E1, O-substitution of Ser and Thr dramatically decreases the E2 and E3 binding, similarly to modification of Lys. There is also a clear difference in the binding affinity of the domain for E2 and/or E3 and for E1 following modifications of their Arg and His. Colicins E2 and E3 are rather bound to the hydrophilic domain B (loops 5–7) of the receptor. In this respect, interactions of colicins E2 and E3 with deeper parts of A and B domains (Trp, several Arg, Lys and His residues) exhibited subtle differences. Acidic pH (4.5–6.0) shows a positive, while pH 7.0–8.5 a rather negative impact on the receptor-binding function for the colicins. It was clearly demonstrated that there is just a partial difference between the binding behavior of colicins E1, E2 and/or E3.