The value of tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests in preoperative blepharoplasty evaluation

The results of tear film breakup (BUT) and Schirmer's I and II tests were retrospectively analyzed on 146 patients undergoing elective blepharoplasty over a 41-month period. These tests were evaluated in conjunction with ocular history, orbital and periorbital anatomy, and Bell's phenomenon in order to determine their value, if any, in identifying patients at risk of developing a post-blepharoplasty dry eye complication. One-hundred and six patients (73 percent) had test results that were within normal limits, and two of these patients (1.9 percent) complained postoperatively of a transient gritty or burning sensation. Forty patients (27 percent) had abnormal results to one, two, or all three tests, and two of these patients (5 percent) also complained postoperatively of a transient gritty or burning sensation. These four symptomatic patients all had preoperative dry eye histories and abnormal orbital and periorbital anatomy. When analyzed alone, an abnormal tear film breakup (BUT) or Schirmer's test was not a good predictor of possible postblepharoplasty dry eye complications. An abnormal preoperative ocular history or abnormal orbital and periorbital anatomy proved to be the best predictor for the possible development of a postblepharoplasty dry eye complication.     

The value of tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests in preoperative blepharoplasty evaluation

The authors published their article on the value of tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests in preoperative blepharoplasty evaluation in 1989. The purpose of this update is to expand the original article in light of refinements and experiences in subsequent years. It was concluded in the 1989 article that the abnormal tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests were not good predictors of possible postblepharoplasty dry eye complications. It was concluded in the review that the anatomy and the history including scleral show, lagophtholmus, negative vector, snap test, previous surgery, increased blinking, dryness, grittiness and pain were more important predictors of postoperative dry eye problems than the ocular tests. The authors' opinion remains so, and they do less preoperative tear film testing and place more emphasis on the history and the anatomy as predictors of potential problems. In this follow-up to the 1989 article, the authors include a survey from several surgeons as to how they evaluate their patients for elective aesthetic blepharoplasty, which in large measure confirms the authors' practice.     

The prevention and treatment of lower lid ectropion following blepharoplasty

Ectropion and scleral show are the most common complications following lower lid blepharoplasty. Certain conditions predispose patients to ectropion, and these should be evaluated. In some cases, the addition of a wedge tarsectomy or tarsal strip procedure to a blepharoplasty in association with careful technique and postoperative measures is important in prevention of postblepharoplasty ectropion. Postoperative ectropion should initially be treated conservatively with massage. This may be effective up to 6 months postoperatively. If conservative measures fail, the etiology of the ectropion should be addressed. Laxity of the tarsus and canthal ligaments benefit from a horizontal lid-shortening procedure. Where there is vertical shortening from excessive skin resection or scarring of the orbital septum, there should be release and grafting of the deficiency.     

The crocodile tear syndrome.

Gusto-lacrimation, or "crocodile tear syndrome," is a rare complication, with 95 cases reported in the literature. Two patients are presented here, one after a facial fracture which apparently extended into the temporal bone proximal to the optic ganglion, and one after a Bell's palsy. The mechanism appears to be a misdirection of regenerating gustatory fibers destined for the salivary glands, so that they become secretory fibers to the lacrimal gland and cause homolateral tearing while the patient is eating. A simple procedure, involving subtotal resection of the palpebral lobe of the involved lacrimal gland, proved to be an effective corrective measure in these cases. Although it was not done in these cases, it would perhaps be advisable to do a Schirmer's test to assist in determining the amount of gland to be removed.     

Expanded applications for transconjunctival lower lid blepharoplasty.

There has been a recent upsurge in interest in the transconjunctival approach for lower lid blepharoplasty. Initial reports have focused on the young patient with isolated fat prominence. We describe our experience with transconjunctival lower lid blepharoplasty in 104 patients over the past 2 years. There have been no instances of prolonged lower lid retraction problems, presumably related to leaving the skin, orbicularis, and orbital septum intact. Our experience with expanding the indications for the transconjunctival approach to include patients with fine skin wrinkling as well as frank skin excess has been extremely favorable. We conclude that the skin excess is often more apparent than real, with the skin being necessary to recontour the lower eyelid after fat excision. Although skin excision may be required during the initial procedure or at a later stage, patients with apparent skin excess need not be excluded from consideration for transconjunctival lower lid blepharoplasty.     

Retro-orbicularis oculus fat (ROOF) resection in aesthetic blepharoplasty: a 6-year study in 63 patients

Sixty-three nonconsecutive patients have undergone resection of the retro-orbicularis oculus fat (ROOF) in conjunction with aesthetic blepharoplasty. In these patients, a consistent and useful ability to soften and flatten heaviness and bulkiness in the lateral upper orbital region was seen. Two patients developed postoperative hematoma, and two different patients had transient dry-eye symptoms following blepharoplasty. Twenty percent of patients had a transient degree of numbness in the lateral supraorbital nerve region, and all patients noted some transient numbness over the lateral upper brow region. No patient demonstrated significant paralysis of the orbicularis oculus or corrugator muscle. From this experience, retro-orbicularis oculus fat resection would appear to be a useful adjunct to standard blepharoplasty techniques in selected patients.     

Lower blepharoplasty using bony anatomical landmarks to identify and avoid injury to the inferior oblique muscle

In the resection of redundant orbital fat during lower blepharoplasty, selective excision is performed from the medial, central, and lateral compartments. During transcutaneous blepharoplasty, the inferior oblique muscle is susceptible to injury because of its intimate association between the medial and central compartments. When performing a transconjunctival approach, the inferior oblique muscle is even more susceptible to injury because it lies in the direct path of dissection for fat pad exposure. Injury to the inferior oblique muscle can result in symptoms ranging from transient diplopia to a more debilitating permanent strabismus. Fresh cadaver heads were used to identify bony anatomical landmarks that would help to more accurately define the origin and body of the inferior oblique muscle. The orbital rim, infraorbital foramen, and supraorbital notch were chosen as guideline landmarks. The origin of the inferior oblique muscle was designated with respect to the above structures, and the muscle course was delineated. The inferior oblique muscle originates on the orbital floor, 5.14 +/- 1.21 mm posterior to the inferior orbital rim, on a line extending from the infraorbital foramen to 10 +/- 0.9 mm inferior to the supraorbital notch along the supramedial orbital rim. The muscle belly extends from this origin to its insertion into the posterolateral globe in an oblique direction toward the lateral canthal area. Identification of the orbital rim, infraorbital foramen, and supraorbital notch more accurately localizes the origin and course of the inferior oblique muscle, which may facilitate fat resection during lower blepharoplasty by preventing morbidity associated with inferior oblique muscle injury.     

Retrobulbar hematoma and blepharoplasty

Retrobulbar hematoma leading to visual impairment is a rare but serious complication associated with elective blepharoplasty. A review of the literature addressing etiology, prevention, and management is presented. Removal of anterior orbital fat associated with traction and rupture of vessels within posterior orbital fat is currently most strongly supported as the cause of retrobulbar hematoma after blepharoplasty. Optic nerve ischemia is identified as the likely cause of visual impairment. Specific recommendations for avoidance and management of acute retrobulbar hematoma are offered. Recent background animal and human research is summarized.     

Two helpful technical aids in blepharoplasty

We describe two helpful technical aids in blepharoplasty. The first is a method of securely holding orbital fat without risk of excessive traction if the patient's head moves. The second involves use of a battery-powered cautery as a safe, convenient cutting instrument.     

Adipose compartments of the upper eyelid: anatomy applied to blepharoplasty

Many authors have indicated the presence of ectopic or accessory upper eyelid fat pads, but the effective rate of eyelid fat variations and the corresponding clinical features are still unclear. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the variability of upper lid fat and to define the anatomical landmarks of the adipose pockets of the upper lid. From January of 1998 to January of 2002, the authors investigated the upper eyelid fat compartments of 47 patients who underwent upper blepharoplasty. To support surgical findings, 11 fresh cadavers were also investigated; the anatomy of the intraorbital fat and of the upper eyelid fat compartments was reviewed. Ten patients (21.3 percent) showed an accessory fat pad in the upper lid, which was found on both sides in nine cases. In all patients, the third fat pad was situated lateral to the two classic compartments described by Castanares, behind the orbital septum. Surgical dissections demonstrated that this fat pad derived from the preaponeurotic fat. Anatomical dissections in three cadavers demonstrated an accessory fat compartment protruding under the inferior border of the lacrimal gland. This protruding fat derived from the preaponeurotic fat in all cases and might justify the clinical appearance of a bulge or fullness in the lateral third of the upper eyelid. In the authors' experience, the presence of an accessory upper eyelid fat pad was a frequent finding during blepharoplasty; it could be found and actually resected in about 21 percent of all cases. Surgical and experimental findings put this element as a lateral physiological extension of the preaponeurotic fat that can anteriorly protrude under the inferior border of the lacrimal gland toward the orbital septum. The clinical appearance may be a bulge or fullness in the upper eyelid, and its resection can better define the lateral one third of the supratarsal fold.     

Acquired strabismus following cosmetic blepharoplasty

The purpose of this study was to report on 12 patients with acquired strabismus following cosmetic blepharoplasty and to identify patterns of strabismus related to the surgical procedure. Clinical ophthalmologic examinations were performed to specifically clarify the type of strabismus. Operative reports of the blepharoplasty procedures were reviewed. Patients were followed for a minimum of 3 months after the blepharoplasty procedure before surgical intervention was considered. Operative findings at corrective strabismus surgery were noted and an attempt was made to correlate these findings with the clinical ophthalmologic examination and the blepharoplasty surgical procedure. Twelve cases of persistent vertical strabismus occurred following blepharoplasty procedures. Five patients had clinical findings consistent with the diagnosis of acquired superior oblique palsy; one of these five patients also showed signs of an acquired Brown syndrome. Seven patients developed an incomitant vertical deviation consistent with an inferior rectus paresis. Strabismus occurred after conventional lower lid, upper lid, and four-lid blepharoplasty with or without laser blepharoplasty. Acquired strabismus accompanied by persistent diplopia may occur as a complication of cosmetic blepharoplasty. Extraocular muscle damage resulting in either superior oblique muscle palsy or inferior rectus paresis was noted in these patients. In some cases, patients with inferior rectus paresis also showed mechanical restriction to upward rotation of the globe.     

Transconjunctival orbital fat repositioning: transposition of orbital fat pedicles into a subperiosteal pocket

Rejuvenation of the lower eyelid complex is based on the principle that the contour changes characterizing aging involve not only prolapse of orbital fat but also descent of the cheek tissues, resulting in accentuation of the orbital rim and tear trough groove. When a deep groove is present along the orbital rim in the area of the tear trough deformity, it is advantageous, rather than removing orbital fat, to reposition the fat over the orbital rim through the opened arcus marginalis onto the superior face of the maxilla. Orbital fat repositioning can be accomplished through a transconjunctival approach. The arcus marginalis is exposed and incised, and a subperiosteal pocket is created over the superior face of the maxilla. The subperiosteal pocket shape and location are customized based on the desired location of the orbital fat pedicle; often the origins of the levator superioris labialis and the levator alae nasi muscles are partially dissected. Medial and central fat pedicles are created and rotated over the orbital rim into the subperiosteal pocket. A 6-0 polypropylene externalized sutured is used to fixate the fat pedicle in position. The suture can be removed after 3 to 5 days. Twenty-four patients were followed clinically after orbital fat repositioning, with follow-up ranging from 6 to 30 months. Although the fat pedicle undergoes some variable resorption, the viability of the graft, the texture and contour of the repositioned fat after a healing period of 1 to 2 months, and the excellent patient acceptance are indicative of the viability of orbital fat repositioning.     

Transcoronal blepharoplasty.

Some of the patients requesting blepharoplasty have a combination of excessive eyelid fat and brow ptosis but little or no dermatochalasis. Coronal brow lift, combined with transcoronal fat removal, serves these patients well. The prelevator fat pocket is easily entered from above by incising the periosteum of the anterior orbital roof just inside the orbital rim. Since the orbital septum and anterior lamella of the eyelid rim remain undisturbed, the result appears natural. Contraindications to the procedure include significant medical pocket fat and hair patterns that would exclude a coronal or hairline incision. Two complications, unilateral ptosis and unilateral chemosis, were temporary and totally reversible. Minor changes in the procedure have prevented the recurrence of these problems.     

Primary and secondary orbit surgery: the transconjunctival approach

The transconjunctival approach to the orbit is underutilized because of concern regarding inadequate exposure and higher postoperative rates of lower eyelid shortening and ectropion. All patients who had a transconjunctival incision performed for orbital surgery over the last 6 years (1990 to 1996) were studied. Patients who had a transconjunctival blepharoplasty were excluded. A total of 35 patients, average age 32 years, had 45 transconjunctival incisions performed. Lateral canthotomy or cantholysis was not done. Operations fell into three categories: fracture plating alone, 10 (22 percent); split-calvarial bone graft placement with or without plating, 26 (58 percent); and orbital decompression, 9 (20 percent). The overall incidence of ectropion was 6.7 percent (3 of 45). One patient (2 percent) had transient ectropion, and two patients (4 percent) had persistent ectropion, which required surgical correction. Ectropion occurred only in those lower eyelids that had a previous transcutaneous incision (3 of 18 = 17 percent). None occurred in those eyelids that had no prior incision or only a previous transconjunctival incision. The transconjunctival approach without a lateral canthotomy provides safe access to the orbit in eyelids that have not had a previous transconjunctival incision.     

The tear "TROUF" procedure: transconjunctival repositioning of orbital unipedicled fat

Aging of the lower lid and cheek results in bulging of orbital fat and deepening of the orbital rim groove, known as the "tear trough." As an alternative to orbital fat excision, pedicles of fat can be spread in a submuscular plane to obliterate the groove of the tear trough. In a 1-year period, 25 patients had correction of their tear trough deformities through a transconjunctival approach. This technique included incision of the septum near the arcus marginalis, dissection of a suborbicularis pocket, and placement of medial and central fat pedicles over the orbital rim with buried 5-0 plain gut sutures. Clinically, after a follow-up of 17 to 31 months, there was leveling of the tear trough, smooth contour of the lower lid and cheek, minimal complications, and high patient satisfaction.     

Correction of sunken and/or multiply folded upper eyelid by fascia-fat graft

Sunken and/or multiply folded upper eyelid is one of the common, troublesome complications that can occur after Oriental blepharoplasty. In addition to orbital volume depletion, the traumatic surgical procedure of excessive fat removal might result in a varying degree of adhesion and injury to the orbital septum. Adhesiotomy followed by a restoration of volume is generally believed to be the logical way to correct such deformity. To restore volume and prevent re-adhesion, local tissues of the upper eyelid, free-fat graft, and dermis-fat graft have been used. However, local tissues are usually insufficient because of previous surgery, and the survival rate of grafted fat is often unpredictable. Moreover, the heaviness of the dermis-fat composite makes it a less than satisfactory choice. The authors value the use of free fascia-fat composite grafts for the treatment of such disfigurements. The fascia-fat composite is expected to have a better survival rate than free fat alone and to be lighter than a dermis-fat composite. In addition, the fascia-fat composite is abundant throughout the body and provides anatomical structure more similar to that of the repair site, namely, the damaged orbital septum and fat. The authors prefer the mons pubis, preauricular, and temporal areas for the donor site depending on the status of the damage. They treated 13 patients with sunken and/or multiply folded upper eyelids by fascia-fat composite grafts and obtained satisfactory results.     

Endoscopic brow lift: a personal review of 538 patients and comparison of fixation techniques

Since the introduction of endoscopic brow lifting in the mid-1990s, it has become widely accepted as a method for rejuvenation of the upper third of the face. Despite the multitude of brow fixation techniques, there are few long-term studies providing accurate analysis of outcome. The aims of this investigation were to evaluate the long-term objective results of endoscopic brow lifting and to establish whether the technique of fixation altered the longevity of aesthetic outcome. The outcome of endoscopic brow lifts carried out on 538 consecutive patients over a 6-year period was assessed. For each patient, midpupil-to-brow distance was measured preoperatively and at intervals postoperatively. Two different fixation methods were compared: fibrin glue (n = 189, group 1; 104 records available) and polydioxanone sutures tied through bone tunnels (n = 349, group 2; 220 records available). In 214 patients, an upper lid blepharoplasty was performed simultaneously (85 in group 1 and 129 in group 2). At 1 month postoperatively, each fixation technique had produced a significant change in mean pupil to brow height (5.93 mm in group 1 and 6.21 mm in group 2, with no significant difference between the two methods; p = 0.17). However, when measurements were compared more than 3 months postoperatively (mean, 9.4 months), there was a significant difference, with some relapse in the patients treated with fibrin glue (p < 0.01). However, in group 2 (tunnel fixation), measurements remained stable, with 6.21 mm at 1 month compared with 6.16 mm long term (no significant difference, p = 0.34). In contrast, in group 1 (fibrin glue), measurements showed significant reduction, with a 1-month result of 5.93 mm and a long-term outcome of 3.79 mm (p < 0.01). Upper lid blepharoplasty had no effect on the long-term outcome of either group (p > 0.3 in group 1, p > 0.4 in group 2). Complications were few in both groups. In group 1, there was one infection, two instances of significant alopecia (both temporary), and one reoperation for relapse. In group 2, four patients required minor surgical revision of a lateral port scar and three minor areas of temporal alopecia, which recovered in less than 3 months. One patient had a paresis of the frontal branch that had recovered after 4 months. The endoscopic brow lift is therefore a safe and effective technique for increasing mean pupil to brow height. Fixation with polydioxanone sutures tied through bone tunnels produces a significantly more stable result than fibrin glue, without greater risk. This lends weight to experimental evidence that periosteal fixation must be maintained for at least 6 weeks to be secure.     

Use of a muscle flap in lower blepharoplasty.

An adjunctive technique for lower lid blepharoplasty is presented. This operative procedure uses the principle of anchoring the upper margin of the lower lid by suturing a triangular muscle flap from it to the lateral-superior part of the orbital rim. This more effective support for the lower lid margin permits one to excise more redundant tissue without getting an ectropion.     

Mechanisms of global support and posttraumatic enophthalmos: I. The anatomy of the ligament sling and its relation to intramuscular cone orbital fat

The mechanisms of posttraumatic enophthalmos were evaluated to determine the interrelation between fat and ligaments in globe support. Anatomic studies demonstrate that the ligaments form an essential "sling" framework for the globe but are alone insufficient to maintain the globe's full forward position. Removal of extramuscular fat in cadavers and in patients undergoing blepharoplasty did not significantly change globe position. Loss of intramuscular cone fat (atrophy or displacement) in cadavers and patients produced enophthalmos. Fat atrophy is not a prominent feature in most patients with posttraumatic enophthalmos. Some loss of intramuscular cone fat from displacement outside the muscle cone is frequently present. The principal mechanism, however, of posttraumatic enophthalmos involves a displacement and change in the shape of orbital soft tissue. Loss of bone and ligament support permits posterior displacement and a reshaping of orbital soft tissue under the influence of gravity and the remodeling forces of fibrous scar contracture. The shape of the retrobulbar orbital contents changes from a modified cone to a sphere, and the globe sinks backward and downward. Given that the volume of orbital soft tissue is constant following trauma, procedures to restore the shape and position of the orbital soft tissue by mobilization and bone reconstruction will correct or significantly improve enophthalmos.     

Upper blepharoplasty with bony anatomical landmarks to avoid injury to trochlea and superior oblique muscle tendon with fat resection.

The trochlea and superior oblique muscle tendon separate the medial and central fat compartments in the upper lid. The purpose of this study was to determine anatomical landmarks to predict the location of and avoid injuring the trochlea and superior oblique muscle tendon with orbital fat resection during upper blepharoplasty. The trochlea and superior oblique muscle tendon were identified in 14 cadaver heads. Bony anatomical landmarks were identified to predict the oblique vector along which the trochlea and superior oblique tendon lie. The trochlea was measured in millimeters from the palpable superior orbital foramen. The oblique course of the superior oblique muscle tendon was measured from its medial location in the lateral direction in millimeters from the frontozygomatic suture. These measurements were obtained with 4.0-power loupe magnification. The trochlea was identified 10.0 +/- 0.9 mm inferior to the palpable superior orbital foramen. The superior oblique muscle tendon coursed laterally along an oblique vector to within 1 mm of the frontozygomatic suture for all 14 dissections. The vertical vector of the superior orbital foramen was measured 15.9 +/- 1.1 mm lateral to the medial canthus. The width of the bony orbit measured 42.2 +/- 1.6 mm. In two dissections, the superior orbital foramen could not be palpated, and the latter measurements were used to predict the superior orbital foramen. This anatomical study showed that when performing orbital fat resection with upper blepharoplasty, the trochlea and superior oblique muscle tendon can be identified and avoided with the above-described bony landmarks.