Body weight and tail length divergence in mice selected for rate of development

A series of mouse lines has been produced by 19 generations of restricted index selection for rate of development during early and late ontogeny. The selection program was based on an index with the following four replicated selection treatments: E(+) and E(-) were selected to alter birth to 10-day body weight gain while holding late gain for both selection lines constant; correspondingly, L(+) and L(-) were selected to alter 28- to 56-day body weight gain holding early gain for both lines constant. Herein, we characterize response to selection for growth rate by analyzing age-specific mouse body weight and tail lengths and for growth curves using a logistics model. Selection on developmental rate has resulted in divergence in both age-specific and growth curve traits. E(+) and L(+) lines reached identical weights during the late selection interval, then diverged to unique mature weights. E(-) and L(-) lines similarly achieved identical weights during late selection and diverged to unique mature weights. However, the shapes of early and late growth curves were significantly divergent, and at least two distinct growth patterns are shown to result from selection. Response in body weight gain was accompanied by similar, though less pronounced, change in tail length traits. Significant response during intervals of restricted growth was also found, especially in lines selected for late gain. The evolution of the growth trajectory under restricted index selection is discussed in terms of drift and available additive genetic variation and covariation.     

Growth and body composition of mice selected for high body weight

To elucidate the influence of high body weight selection on body compositional relationships, the accumulation of lipid, protein, and ash was investigated in two lines of mice selected for high 42-day body weight (H lines) and an unselected foundation population (FP). The two H lines differed in population size and were designated as the high-large (HL) and high-small (HS) lines. Logistic body growth curves revealed that HL mice exhibited an accelerated growth rate and reached a higher mature body weight than FP or HS mice. Over the range of body weights examined, HL mice had more lipid, less protein, and less ash than FP or HS mice of the same sex and body weight. However, HL lipid accumulation (relative to body weight increase) was not accelerated in comparison to that of FP mice. This study suggests that the existing model of selection-mediated compositional changes requires expansion to account for the ability of high-growth selection to direct an acceleration of body growth without a correlated enhancement of the relative rate of fat accumulation.     

Hepatic endopolyploidy as a cellular consequence of age-specific selection for rate of development in mice

Endopolyploidy is the generation of polyploid cells by DNA replication without subsequent cell division and is correlated with hypertrophic growth or growth via cell size. Thus, selection that alters growth may also change onset and frequency of endopolyploidy as a correlated response. We search for endopolyploidy in the liver in response to age-specific restricted index selection for the rate of development. Polyploidy changes over ontogeny are described in five mouse lines: two selected for divergence in early growth (0-10 days of age), two selected for divergence in late growth (28-56 days of age), and one randombred control. Polyploid cell frequency within each line increased as ontogeny continued, as expected from previous research. However, selection for altered growth clearly plays a role in the frequency and onset of polyploid cells. Lines selected for divergence in early growth have polyploidy differences after weaning that are not seen in adult mice. However, lines selected for divergence in late growth are divergent in frequency of polyploid cells, starting near sexual maturity and continuing into adulthood.     

Energy expenditure and locomotor activity in mice selected for food intake adjusted for body weight

Summary The aim of this study was to examine the differences in physical activity and their contribution to differences in energy utilization in mice, selected either high or low for food intake, adjusted for body weight, which show correlated responses in lean content and metabolic rate. Simultaneous measurements of fasting metabolic rate and activity were made in lines of mice selected at either: a young age, 4-to 6-week food intake corrected for 4-week body weight; or an older age, 8- to 10-week food intake corrected for mean weight at 8 and 10 weeks of age. Correlated response in metabolic rate was found to have been accompanied by changes in locomotor activity near the ages at selection in both sets of lines. Activity, however, accounted for only a small proportion of variation in fasting heat production, generally less than 5%, although a highly positive correlation (r=0.63) between the two traits was found. It was concluded that selection for food intake adjusted for body weight has led to correlated response in physical activity. In consequence, mice selected in the upward direction expend some of the excess energy intake rather than assimilating it as body mass and are, therefore, slightly leaner than their counterparts selected in the downward direction.     

Altering Developmental Trajectories in Mice by Restricted Index Selection

A restricted index selection experiment on mice was carried out for 14 generations on rate of early postnatal development (growth rate from birth to 10 days of age) vs. rate of development much later in ontogeny (growth rate from 28 to 56 days of age). Early rate of development (E) approximates hyperplasia (changes in cell number) and later rate (L) reflects hypertropy (changes in cell size). The selection criteria were as follows: E+L0 was selected to increase early body weight gain while holding late body weight gain constant; E-L0 was selected to decrease early body gain while holding late gain constant; E0L+ was selected to increase late gain holding early gain constant; and E0L- was selected to decrease late gain holding early gain constant. After 14 generations of selection, significant divergence among lines has occurred and the changes in the growth trajectories are very close to expectation. The genetic and developmental bases of complex traits are discussed as well as the concept of developmental homoplasy.     

Correlated Responses to Selection for Postweaning Gain in the Rat

Evidence for correlated responses to selection was investigated in lines of rats selected for 13 generations for high (U line) and low (D line) 3-9-week gain in comparison with random-bred control lines (R and C lines). The increase in 3-9-week gain in the U lines was shown to be due largely to an increase in 9-week weight, although 3-week weight also increased in these lines. In the D lines, where a marked decrease in 3-9-week gain was observed, this was found to be due to a large decrease in 9-week weight and no detectable change in 3-week weight. The average 2-week litter weight, a measure of the lactational performance of the dam, was significanly greater in the U lines than in the D lines. Selection for 3-9-week gain in these lines of rats led to changes of litter size at birth in the same direction as that of selection. This resulted in a significantly higher litter size in the U lines than in the D lines. The number of rats alive 2 and 9 weeks of age and the percentage of mated females pupping were similar in the U and D lines but lower in these lines than the random bred C lines, providing evidence for a reduction of "fitness" in the selected lines. Carcass composition was studied for all lines at the 11th generation of selection. Carcass composition, in terms of water, fat, ash and protein, was similar in the R and C lines. The U lines had more water and lesss fat than the R or C line. The D lines had similar carcass composition to the R and C lines. It is suggested that these selected and random-bred lines of rats are potentially useful animals to investigate further the developmental and physiological mechanisms which control growth.     

Uterine and postnatal maternal effects in mice selected for differential rate of early development.

A series of mouse lines was produced by long-term restricted index selection for divergent rate of growth during early and late postnatal development. The selection program was based on the following treatments: E(+) and E(-) lines were selected to alter birth to 10-day weight gain while holding late gain for both lines constant and a control line was established via random selection. Using embryo transfer and crossfostering methodology, we partitioned postnatal growth for E(+), E(-), and C lines into progeny genetic, uterine maternal, and nurse maternal components. Selection for differential early growth resulted in correlated response in uterine and nurse maternal effects on body weights, with significant genetic-by-environment interactions. Significant uterine effects were also observed in tail length measurements. Direct uterine effects on body weight were relatively small and resulted in growth rate differences early in development. Nurse effects were large, resulting in modification of progeny growth trajectory especially during early postnatal development. Genetic-by-uterine interactions were large and demonstrate progeny-specific effects of the prenatal uterine environment.     

Effect of selection for development rate on reproductive onset in female mice.

This research reports analyses of correlated response in reproductive onset in ICR mice after 23 generations of restricted index selection for divergent body weight gain, early (birth-10 days) or later (28-56 days) in life. Long-term selection altered growth trajectories and 56 day body weight of individuals under different selection regimes in this study. Mice in lines under early selection have the same percentage mature weight at vaginal opening as controls (63%). Vaginal opening is delayed in mice selected for slow early growth, which take longer to reach what appears to be a weight threshold. In contrast, individuals in lines selected for later slow growth undergo vaginal opening at the same age as controls, but at a lower weight and increased percentage mature weight. Pre-compensation or 'counter-balance growth' is observed in these lines, with mice selected for late enhanced growth reaching 52% of mature weight at vaginal opening while mice with late slow growth attain 71% of mature weight prior to vaginal opening. Only 42% of mice with late slow growth attain first oestrus by 56 days. We speculate this is a function of growth rate and fat/lean ratio. Mice with early slow growth show compensatory growth, reaching first oestrus at a similar time to controls. We conclude that selection for growth rate has asymmetrically affected reproductive onset, with lines selected for suppressed gains experiencing delays in the reproductive onset traits measured.     

Growth curves of body weight changes in laboratory-bred female African green monkeys (Cercopithecus aethiops)

Nonlinear growth models having three or four parameter family were applied to individual weight data of female African green monkeys for estimating their growth pattern. The body weight was measured continuously from birth to six years of age with five female laboratory-bred monkeys. A total of 95 weight data were collected from each monkey. The average body weight was 330 g with the standard deviation of +/- 15 g at birth, and 2.71 +/- 0.33 kg at four years of age. The body weight of female African green monkeys was judged to reach a plateau after about four years of age. Five growth models (Gompertz, Logistic, Richards, Bertalanffy, Brody) were applied to these weight to age data. The most suitable coefficient of determination between growth data and growth model was obtained by the application of Gompertz equation. Three parameters of Gompertz equation, mature size (A), rate of maturing (K) and inflexion point (e-1 A) were analyzed in relation to age of menarche. Strong correlations between age of menarche and maturing rate, as well as between age of menarche and inflexion point were observed.     

Effect of initial size on subsequent growth and carcass characteristics of divergently selected channel catfish

Summary Two experiments were conducted simultaneously to determine (1) if fast-growing fingerlings of channel catfish, Ictalurus punctatus, could be identified by simple visual selection of body size and (2) if initial size advantages influenced subsequent growth and carcass traits of divergently selected channel catfish. Exp. 1 included large (L), medium (M), and small (S) fingerling sizes from each of the control (C), selected upward (+) and selected downward (–) lines for body weight. Exp. 2 included all fmgerlings of the same size (25±5 g) from the 3 lines. Catfish from the L size-class, within each full-sib family in each line, were consistently heavier and longer than M and S size-classes throughout the 53-week experimental period. Fingerlings from the M size-class were also superior in growth to those from the S size-class. Catfish from the + line exceeded those from the C and –lines in body weight and total length at the conclusion of Exp. 1 but not in Exp. 2. This was attributed to the selection of equal size fmgerlings in Exp. 2 which may have excluded fingerlings with the best growth potential from the + body weight line. Results of the two experiments combined indicated that one generation of divergent selection has created genetic differences among lines of channel catfish.Supported by State and Hatch funds allocated to the Georgia Agricultural Experiment Station     

Correlated Responses in Male Reproductive Traits in Mice Selected for Litter Size and Body Weight

Correlated responses in male reproductive traits were determined at 4, 6 and 8 weeks of age in lines of mice selected for large litter size (L⁺), large 6-week body weight (W⁺), large litter size and small body weight (L⁺W^-) and small litter size and large body weight (L^-W⁺), and in an unselected control (K). Concentration of serum testosterone and weights of testes, seminal vesicles, epididymides and adrenal glands increased with age. Line differences in testosterone concentration were not detected. L⁺ and W⁺ males exhibited positive correlated responses in testes, epididymides and seminal vescile weights. Testis weight adjusted for body weight was significantly larger for L⁺ than controls and approached significance for W⁺. Realized genetic correlation betestis weight and litter size was 0.60 ± 0.04, and the realized partial genetic correlation holding body weight constant was 0.42. Therefore, pleiotropic loci, acting via the hypothalamic-pituitary axis, affect testis weight and litter size independently of body weight. Additionally, genes influencing overall growth have a pleiotropic effect on testis weight and litter size in mice; the realized genetic correlations of body weight with testis weight and with litter size were 0.60 ± 0.03 and 0.52 ± 0.10. Testis weight increased in both L⁺W^- and L^-W⁺ males. The positive correlated response in L⁺W^- may have resulted from changes in frequency of genes controlling reproductive processes; whereas, in L^-W⁺ it could have been the result of changes in the frequency of genes associated with body weight.     

Replicated selection for insulin-like growth factor-1 and body weight in mice

Summary Five generations of divergent selection for plasma concentration of insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) and for 12-week body weight were carried out in mice, including randomly selected control lines for each trait. All lines were replicated once (12 lines in total). Each replicate line consisted of eight male and eight female parents per generation. Litter size was standardized to eight pups at birth. Mass selection was applied in the selected lines and within-family random selection in the control lines. Blood was taken from the orbital sinus of individual mice at 12 weeks of age for IGF-1 assay. Realized heritabilities were 0.10±0.01 for IGF-1 and 0.41 ± 0.02 for 12-week weight. The realized genetic correlation between IGF-1 and 12-week weight was 0.58 ± 0.01, with a phenotypic correlation of 0.38. Although the genetic correlation between IGF-1 and body weight in mice is moderately positive, 12-week weight responded 3.5 times as fast to weight selection as to selection for IGF-1.     

Food Consumption, Feed Efficiency, Metabolic Rate and Utilization of Glucose in Lines of TRIBOLIUM CASTANEUM Selected for 21-Day Pupa Weight

Growth rate, body composition, cell number, cell size, and the activity of four dehydrogenase enzymes were studied from 10 to 25 days of age in one control (1C) and three lines (3, 9, 10) of Tribolium castaneum that had been subjected to long term selection for large 21-day pupae weight.—Selected lines were two- to three-fold larger in size than the control line throughout development. No major differences in percent of protein were detected among the lines but at any particular age, the selected lines were found to have a higher fat content than the control line. The differences in fat content were closely correlated with development such that all the lines reached very similar levels of percent of fat just prior to pupation. Water content showed an inverse relation to percent of fat.—Selection was observed to have caused major changes in the cellular response to growth. The selected lines had an average of from 17% to 48% larger cells (measured as protein/DNA) and were found to have from 37 to 62% more cells (measured as total DNA) than the control line at all ages from 10 to 19 days of age. In addition, the selected lines had a higher RNA content at all ages studied and higher RNA:DNA ratios at the young ages. In contrast the enzyme activities of ICDH and LDH were 60% lower. The results are interpreted as indicating that a more efficient metabolic machinery had evolved in the rapidly growing selected lines.     

Genetic variation in spontaneous ovulation rate and LH receptor induction in mice

Selection for litter size (Line S1) and for post-weaning body weight gain (Line G) increased spontaneous ovulation rate in mature females by 69 and 73%, respectively, over that of randomly bred control mice (Line C). Inbreeding from S1 mice with selection for litter size produced highly inbred lines with elevated ovulation rates. Inbreeding from Line C mice produced a 21% divergence among lines, but did not depress the mean ovulation rate. Crosses of these lines revealed little heterosis in ovulation rate. LH receptors were induced by treating females from 22 days of age with diethylstilboestrol for 4 days and FSH for 2 days. The in-vitro binding of 125I-labelled hCG per microgram DNA decreased 56% in response to selection for litter size and increased 57% in response to selection for body weight gain, indicating high susceptibility of this trait to genetic change. Inbreeding from Line C mice produced a 135% divergence amongst lines, but did not depress the mean LH receptor induction. Body weight had significant effects on ovulation rate and LH receptor induction. These results show that selection for litter size and for rapid post-weaning body weight gain increases ovulation rate, but we suggest that different mechanisms are involved in these responses.     

Growth Rate, Body Composition, Cellular Growth and Enzyme Activities in Lines of TRIBOLIUM CASTANEUM Selected for 21-Day Pupa Weight

Growth rate, body composition, cell number, cell size, and the activity of four dehydrogenase enzymes were studied from 10 to 25 days of age in one control (1C) and three lines (3, 9, 10) of Tribolium castaneum that had been subjected to long term selection for large 21-day pupae weight.-Selected lines were two- to three-fold larger in size than the control line throughout development. No major differences in percent of protein were detected among the lines but at any particular age, the selected lines were found to have a higher fat content than the control line. The differences in fat content were closely correlated with development such that all the lines reached very similar levels of percent of fat just prior to pupation. Water content showed an inverse relation to percent of fat.-Selection was observed to have caused major changes in the cellular response to growth. The selected lines had an average of from 17% to 48% larger cells (measured as protein/DNA) and were found to have from 37 to 62% more cells (measured as total DNA) than the control line at all ages from 10 to 19 days of age. In addition, the selected lines had a higher RNA content at all ages studied and higher RNA:DNA ratios at the young ages. In contrast the enzyme activities of ICDH and LDH were 60% lower. The results are interpreted as indicating that a more efficient metabolic machinery had evolved in the rapidly growing selected lines.     

Genetic-statistical analysis of growth in selected and unselected mouse lines

The growth of males sampled from two mouse lines long-term selected for over 86 generations on body weight (DU6) or on protein amount (DU6P) was analysed from birth till 120 days of age and compared to the growth of an unselected control line (DUKs). Animals from the selected lines are already approximately 40 to 50% heavier at birth than the controls. This divergence increases to about 210 to 240% at the 120 day of age. With birth weights of 2.2 and 2.4 g and weights of 78 and 89 g at the 120 day these selection lines are the heaviest known mouse lines.

The fit of three modified non-linear growth functions (Gompertz function, Logistic function, Richards function) was compared and the effect of three different data inputs elucidated. The modification was undertaken to use parameters having a direct biological meaning, for example: A: theoretical final body weight, B: maximum weight gain, C: age at maximum weight gain, D (only Richards function): determines the position of the inflection point in relation to the final weight. All three models fit the observed data very well (r² = 0.949–0.998), with a slight advantage for the Richards function. There were no substantial effects of the data input (averages, single values, fitting a curve for every animal with subsequent averaging the parameters).

The high growth of the selected mice is connected with very substantial changes in the final weight and in the maximum weight gain, whereas the changes of the age at the point of inflection were, although partially significant, relatively small and dependent on the model used.     

Influence of early pregnancy on reproductive rate in lines of mice selected for litter size

Summary The influence of male-induced early puberty on female reproductive rate was determined in three lines of mice differing in litter size and body weight. The lines originated from a single base population and had undergone 20 generations of selection for the following criteria: large litter size at birth (L⁺), large litter size and small 6-week body weight (L⁺W^–), or small litter size and large 6-week body weight (L^–W⁺). Females were paired with a mature intact male of the same line at 3, 5 or 7 weeks of age. Mean mating age, averaged over lines, was 26.5 ± .3, 38.3 ± .3 and 52.7 ± .3 days. Exposure to a mature male accelerated female sexual maturation in each line. When contrasted with their sibs mated at a later age, early-pregnant females from each line exhibited a decline in one or more component of reproductive performance, suggesting that the physiological state of the very young female was not optimum for normal pregnancy. In comparisons of early and later mating ages, all three lines showed a decreased littering rate at first mating, number born alive, and individual birth weight of progeny adjusted for litter size; L⁺ and L⁺W^– mice showed an increased perinatal mortality rate; L⁺ and L^–W⁺ had a reduction in litter size at birth. When the L⁺, L⁺W^– and L^–W⁺ lines were compared with an unselected strain and a line selected for high postweaning gain in similar experiments, a genotype by environment interaction was apparent since all lines did not respond in a similar manner to early mating. The line ranking for litter size at birth for each age at male-exposure was L⁺>L⁺W^–>L^–W⁺, despite the significant line by age interaction. When litter size was adjusted by covariance for body weight at mating, the significant effects of age at male-exposure and line by age interaction were eliminated. All fertile females were remated after they had weaned their first litter to obtain information on litter size in parity two. Line differences in litter size at birth and number born alive were uniform across parities. An age by parity interaction was evident since the decreased fecundity at younger ages of male exposure in the L⁺ and L^–W⁺ litters of parity one was not evident in parity two. Litter feed efficiency during first parity gestation was defined as litter birth weight divided by either cumulative feed intake of the dam from mating to parturition (GEI) or cumulative feed intake from weaning to parturition (GEII). The ranking of lines for GEI and GEH was L⁺> L⁺W^–>L^–W⁺, but when feed efficiency was adjusted for littering rate, L⁺W^– and L^–W⁺ were not significantly different. With regard to age at mating, the ranking for GEI (7 wk > 5 wk > 3 wk) was reversed from GEII (3 wk >5 wk > 7 wk) and these significant differences were maintained after adjustment for littering rate.Paper No. 6302 of the Journal Series of the North Carolina Agricultural Research Service, Raleigh. The use of trade names in this publication does not imply endorsement by the North Carolina Agricultural Research Service of the products named, nor criticism of similar ones not mentionedOn leave at the Institute of Animal Genetics, West Mains Road, Edinburgh EH9 3JN, Scotland. Supported, in part, by an Underwood Fund Fellowship, Agricultural Research Council, and an Edinburgh University Biological Fellowship in the Department of Genetics     

A Bayesian analysis of the effect of selection for growth rate on growth curves in rabbits

Gompertz growth curves were fitted to the data of 137 rabbits from control (C) and selected (S) lines. The animals came from a synthetic rabbit line selected for an increased growth rate. The embryos from generations 3 and 4 were frozen and thawed to be contemporary of rabbits born in generation 10. Group C was the offspring of generations 3 and 4, and group S was the contemporary offspring of generation 10. The animals were weighed individually twice a week during the first four weeks of life, and once a week thereafter, until 20 weeks of age. Subsequently, the males were weighed weekly until 40 weeks of age. The random samples of the posterior distributions of the growth curve parameters were drawn by using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods. As a consequence of selection, the selected animals were heavier than the C animals throughout the entire growth curve. Adult body weight, estimated as a parameter of the Gompertz curve, was 7% higher in the selected line. The other parameters of the Gompertz curve were scarcely affected by selection. When selected and control growth curves are represented in a metabolic scale, all differences disappear.     

LH receptor induction and ovulation rate in mice selected for litter size and body weight

Female mice from lines which had undergone long-term single trait and antagonistic index selection for litter size and body weight were analysed for ovulation rate and LH receptor induction. Compared to randomly selected controls, selection for large litter size increased ovulation rate (60%; P less than 0.001) and decreased LH receptor induction per microgram ovarian DNA (87%; P less than 0.01). Selection for large body weight increased ovulation rate (18%; P less than 0.001), but did not lead to a significant correlated response in LH receptor induction. Index selection for large litter size and small body weight increased ovulation rate (14%; P less than 0.01) and decreased LH receptor induction (72%; P less than 0.01), while index selection for small litter size and large body weight did not significantly alter either ovulation rate or LH receptor induction. LH receptor quantities in testes of males from the 5 lines did not exhibit the among-line profile which was observed in ovaries of females. These results confirm the role of ovulation rate in mediation of the positive genetic correlation between litter size and body weight in mice. Increased ovulation rate in mice selected for large litter size may be due to mechanisms associated with LH receptors as well as factors related to growth. In contrast, increased ovulation rate in mice selected for large body weight may be due exclusively to factors related to growth.