An imbalance in antioxidant defense affects cellular function: the pathophysiological consequences of a reduction in antioxidant defense in the glutathione peroxidase-1 (Gpx1) knockout mouse

Aerobic cells are subjected to damaging reactive oxygen species (ROS) as a consequence of oxidative metabolism and/or exposure to environmental toxins. Antioxidants limit this damage, yet peroxidative events occur when oxidant stress increases. This arises due to increased radical formation or decreased antioxidative defenses. The two-step enzymatic antioxidant pathway limits damage to important biomolecules by neutralising superoxides to water. However, an imbalance in this pathway (increased first-step antioxidants relative to second-step antioxidants) has been proposed as etiological in numerous pathologies. This review presents evidence that a shift in favor of hydrogen peroxide and/or lipid peroxides has pathophysiological consequences. The involvement of antioxidant genes in the regulation of redox status, and ultimately cellular homeostasis, is explored in murine transgenic and knockout models. The investigations of Sod1 transgenic cell-lines and mice, as well as Gpx1 knockout mice (both models favor H(2)O(2) accumulation), are presented. Although in most instances accumulation of H(2)O(2) affects cellular function and leads to exacerbated pathology, this is not always the case. This review highlights those instances where, for example, increased Sod1 levels are beneficial, and indicates a role for superoxide radicals in pathogenesis. Studies of Gpx1 knockout mice (an important second-step antioxidant) lead us to conclude that Gpx1 functions as the primary protection against acute oxidative stress, particularly in neuropathological situations such as stroke and cold-induced head trauma, where high levels of ROS occur during reperfusion or in response to injury. In summary, these studies clearly highlight the importance of limiting ROS-induced cellular damage by maintaining a balanced enzymatic antioxidant pathway.     

An imbalance in antioxidant defense affects cellular function: the pathophysiological consequences of a reduction in antioxidant defense in the glutathione peroxidase-1 (Gpx1) knockout mouse

Abstract

Aerobic cells are subjected to damaging reactive oxygen species (ROS) as a consequence of oxidative metabolism and/or exposure to environmental toxins. Antioxidants limit this damage, yet peroxidative events occur when oxidant stress increases. This arises due to increased radical formation or decreased antioxidative defenses. The two-step enzymatic antioxidant pathway limits damage to important biomolecules by neutralising superoxides to water. However, an imbalance in this pathway (increased first-step antioxidants relative to second-step antioxidants) has been proposed as etiological in numerous pathologies. This review presents evidence that a shift in favor of hydrogen peroxide and/or lipid peroxides has pathophysiological consequences. The involvement of antioxidant genes in the regulation of redox status, and ultimately cellular homeostasis, is explored in murine transgenic and knockout models. The investigations of Sod1 transgenic cell-lines and mice, as well as Gpx1 knockout mice (both models favor H₂O₂ accumulation), are presented. Although in most instances accumulation of H₂O₂ affects cellular function and leads to exacerbated pathology, this is not always the case. This review highlights those instances where, for example, increased Sod1 levels are beneficial, and indicates a role for superoxide radicals in pathogenesis. Studies of Gpx1 knockout mice (an important second-step antioxidant) lead us to conclude that Gpx1 functions as the primary protection against acute oxidative stress, particularly in neuropathological situations such as stroke and cold-induced head trauma, where high levels of ROS occur during reperfusion or in response to injury. In summary, these studies clearly highlight the importance of limiting ROS-induced cellular damage by maintaining a balanced enzymatic antioxidant pathway.     

Mitochondrial oxidative stress in mice lacking the glutathione peroxidase-1 gene

Oxidative stress resulting from mitochondrially derived reactive oxygen species (ROS) has been hypothesized to damage mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) and to be a factor in aging and degenerative disease. If this hypothesis is correct, then genetically inactivating potential mitochondrial antioxidant enzymes such as glutathione peroxidase-1 (Gpx1; EC 1.11.1.9) should increase mitochondrial ROS production and decrease OXPHOS function. To determine the expression pattern of Gpx1, isoform-specific antibodies were generated and mutant mice were prepared in which the Gpx1 protein was substituted for by beta-galactosidase, driven by the Gpx1 promoter. These experiments revealed that Gpx1 is highly expressed in both the mitochondria and the cytosol of the liver and kidney, but poorly expressed in heart and muscle. To determine the physiological importance of Gpx1, mice lacking Gpx1 were generated by targeted mutagenesis in mouse ES cells. Homozygous mutant Gpx1(tm1Mgr) mice have 20% less body weight than normal animals and increased levels of lipid peroxides in the liver. Moreover, the liver mitochondria were found to release markedly increased hydrogen peroxide, a Gpx1 substrate, and have decreased mitochondrial respiratory control ratio and power output index. Hence, genetic inactivation of Gpx1 resulted in growth retardation, presumably due in part to reduced mitochondrial energy production as a product of increased oxidative stress.     

Glutathione peroxidase-1 protects from CD95-induced apoptosis

Through the induction of apoptosis, CD95 plays a crucial role in the immune response and the elimination of cancer cells. Ligation of CD95 receptor activates a complex signaling network that appears to implicate the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). This study investigated the place of ROS production in CD95-mediated apoptosis and the role of the antioxidant enzyme glutathione peroxidase-1 (GPx1). Anti-CD95 antibodies triggered an early generation of ROS in human breast cancer T47D cells that was blocked by overexpression of GPx1 and inhibition of initiator caspase activation. Enforced expression of GPx1 also resulted in inhibition of CD95-induced effector caspase activation, DNA fragmentation, and apoptotic cell death. Resistance to CD95-mediated apoptosis was not due to an increased expression of anti-apoptotic molecules and could be reversed by glutathione-depleting agents. In addition, whereas the anti-apoptotic protein Bcl-xL prevented CD95-induced apoptosis in MCF-7 cells, it did not inhibit the early ROS production. Moreover, Bcl-xL but not GPx1 overexpression could suppress the staurosporine-induced late generation of ROS and subsequent cell death. Altogether, these findings suggest that GPx1 functions upstream of the mitochondrial events to inhibit the early ROS production and apoptosis induced by CD95 ligation. Finally, transgenic mice overexpressing GPx1 were partially protected from the lethal effect of anti-CD95, underlying the importance of peroxide formation (and GPx1) in CD95-triggered apoptosis.     

基因敲除小鼠技术的研究进展

基因敲除小鼠技术的建立和发展使得人们为研究基因的功能和寻找新的治疗人类疾病的靶点提供了强有力的支持。基因打靶和基因捕获是两种通过胚胎干细胞(Embryonicstemcell,ESC)构建基因敲除小鼠的技术。基因打靶通过同源重组替换内源基因从而敲除目的基因,而基因捕获则有启动子捕获和polyA捕获两种方法对目的基因进行敲除。近年来,有许多新的基因敲除技术不断被开发出来,包括Cre/loxP系统、CRISP/Cas9系统以及最新的ZFN技术和TAILEN技术,都有望取代传统基因敲除手段。文中简要阐述了如今新出现的几种基因敲除小鼠技术。     

Glutathione peroxidase-1 is required for self-renewal of murine embryonic stem cells

Embryonic stem (ES) cells are pluripotent cells that are capable of giving rise to any type of cells in the body and possess unlimited self-renewal potential. However, the exact regulatory mechanisms that govern the self-renewal ability of ES cells remain elusive. To understand the immediate early events during ES cell differentiation, we performed a proteomics study and analyzed the proteomic difference in murine ES cells before and after a 6-h spontaneous differentiation. We found that the expression level of glutathione peroxidase-1 (GPx-1), an antioxidant enzyme, is dramatically decreased upon the differentiation. Both knockdown of GPx-1 expression with shRNA and inhibiting GPx-1 activity by inhibitor led to the differentiation of ES cells. Furthermore, we showed that during early differentiation, the quick degradation of GPx-1 was mediated by proteasome. Thus, our data indicated that GPx-1 is a key regulator of self-renewal of murine embryonic stem cells.     

Synaptotagmin 1基因敲除对小鼠行为的影响*

目的: 研究Synaptotagmin 1基因敲除(Syt1^+/-)对小鼠情绪行为的影响并初步探讨其可能机制。方法: 选取8周龄雄性Syt1^+/-小鼠及同窝野生型(WT)小鼠各5只,采用免疫荧光染色方法观察小鼠前额叶皮层、海马、杏仁核、伏隔核、纹状体和腹侧被盖区等6个脑区中Syt1的表达;选用8周龄雄性Syt1^+/-小鼠9只,以及WT小鼠10只为对照,通过旷场实验、高架十字迷宫实验和强迫游泳实验检测比较成年Syt1^+/-小鼠和WT小鼠的焦虑样行为;另选用8周龄雄性Syt1^+/-小鼠及WT小鼠各5只,检测小鼠前额叶皮层、海马和杏仁核的谷氨酸含量。结果: 与WT小鼠相比,Syt1^+/-小鼠在前额叶皮层、海马、杏仁核、伏隔核、纹状体和腹侧被盖区Syt1阳性细胞数目显著减少(P＜0.01);Syt1^+/-小鼠在旷场中总移动距离显著减少(P＜0.01),并更偏爱在外周区域活动(P＜0.01),对中心区域的探索欲望显著下降(P＜0.01);Syt1^+/-小鼠更偏好待在封闭安全环境中(P＜0.01),开臂探索次数(P＜0.05)和在其中运动的时间显著减少(P＜0.01);Syt1^+/-小鼠在强迫游泳实验中不动时间明显增加(P＜0.01);同时,Syt1^+/-小鼠杏仁核中谷氨酸的含量显著增加(P＜0.01)。结论: Syt1基因敲除可以引起小鼠显著的焦虑样行为,推测与杏仁核中谷氨酸含量增加有关。     

Impacts of glutathione peroxidase-1 knockout on the protection by injected selenium against the pro-oxidant-induced liver aponecrosis and signaling in selenium-deficient mice

Previous research has suggested that repletion of cellular glutathione peroxidase (GPX1) activity by a single injection of Se was dissociated from the Se protection against the pro-oxidant-induced liver necrosis in Se-deficient rodents. Using the GPX1 knockout (GPX1-/-) mice, TUNEL assay, and apoptosis gene expression microarray, we have demonstrated strikingly different impacts of GPX1 knockout on hepatotoxicity and the related signaling induced by an intraperitoneal injection of 12.5 mg paraquat/kg body weight (b.wt.). In both Se-deficient GPX1-/- and wild-type (WT) mice, the paraquat did not induce typical liver necrosis, rather aponecrosis or necrapoptosis, a syncretic process of cell death sharing characteristics of both apoptosis and necrosis. The severity of liver aponecrosis and the associated mortality were reduced to a much greater extent by an injection of Se (ip, 50 microg/kg b.wt. as Na2SeO3) prior to paraquat stress in the WT mice, compared with the GPX1-/- mice. The induced liver aponecrosis seemed to be more apoptotic in the GPX1-/- mice but more necrotic in the WT mice. The paraquat-mediated gene or protein expression of proapoptotic Bax, Bcl-w, and Bcl-X(S), cell survival/death factors GADD45, MDM2, c-Myc, and caspase-3 was upregulated, but that of antiapoptotic Bcl-2 was downregulated in the GPX1-/- mice vs. the WT mice. Overall, these differences between the two groups of mice were related to a low level of liver GPX1 activity in the WT mice that represented < 4% of the normal physiological level. Therefore, the low level of GPX1 activity in the Se-deficient mice can exert a potent role in defending against liver aponecrosis induced by moderate oxidative stress.     

Glutathione peroxidase-1 deficiency augments proinflammatory cytokine-induced redox signaling and human endothelial cell activation

Glutathione peroxidase-1 (GPx-1) is a crucial antioxidant enzyme, the deficiency of which promotes atherogenesis. Accordingly, we examined the mechanisms by which GPx-1 deficiency enhances endothelial cell activation and inflammation. In human microvascular endothelial cells, we found that GPx-1 deficiency augments intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) and vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 (VCAM-1) expression by redox-dependent mechanisms that involve NFκB. Suppression of GPx-1 enhanced TNF-α-induced ROS production and ICAM-1 expression, whereas overexpression of GPx-1 attenuated these TNF-α-mediated responses. GPx-1 deficiency prolonged TNF-α-induced IκBα degradation and activation of ERK1/2 and JNK. JNK or NFκB inhibition attenuated TNF-α induction of ICAM-1 and VCAM-1 expression in GPx-1-deficient and control cells, whereas ERK1/2 inhibition attenuated only VCAM-1 expression. To analyze further signaling pathways involved in GPx-1-mediated protection from TNF-α-induced ROS, we performed microarray analysis of human microvascular endothelial cells treated with TNF-α in the presence and absence of GPx-1. Among the genes whose expression changed significantly, dual specificity phosphatase 4 (DUSP4), encoding an antagonist of MAPK signaling, was down-regulated by GPx-1 suppression. Targeted DUSP4 knockdown enhanced TNF-α-mediated ERK1/2 pathway activation and resulted in increased adhesion molecule expression, indicating that GPx-1 deficiency may augment TNF-α-mediated events, in part, by regulating DUSP4.     

Elevated body temperature during sleep in orexin knockout mice

Core body temperature (Tb) is influenced by many physiological factors, including behavioral state, locomotor activity, and biological rhythms. To determine the relative roles of these factors, we examined Tb in orexin knockout (KO) mice, which have a narcolepsy-like phenotype with severe sleep-wake fragmentation. Because orexin is released during wakefulness and is thought to promote heat production, we hypothesized that orexin KO mice would have lower Tb while awake. Surprisingly, Tb was the same in orexin KO mice and wild-type (WT) littermates during sustained wakefulness. Orexin KO mice had normal diurnal variations in Tb, but the ultradian rhythms of Tb, locomotor activity, and wakefulness were markedly reduced. During the first 15 min of spontaneous sleep, the Tb of WT mice decreased by 1.0 degrees C, but Tb in orexin KO mice decreased only 0.4 degrees C. Even during intense recovery sleep after 8 h of sleep deprivation, the Tb of orexin KO mice remained 0.7 degrees C higher than in WT mice. This blunted fall in Tb during sleep may be due to inadequate activation of heat loss mechanisms or sustained activity in heat-generating systems. These observations reveal an unexpected role for orexin in thermoregulation. In addition, because heat loss is an essential aspect of sleep, the blunted fall in Tb of orexin KO mice may provide an explanation for the fragmented sleep of narcolepsy.     

Lipopolysaccharide and interferon-gamma-induced nitric oxide production and protein oxidation in mouse peritoneal macrophages are affected by glutathione peroxidase-1 gene knockout

This study investigated the role of glutathione peroxidase-1 (GPX1) in protein oxidation in peritoneal macrophages. Macrophages isolated from both wild-type (WT) and GPX1 knockout (KO) mice were activated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS, 1 microg/ml) and interferon-gamma (IFN, 10 U/ml for 24 or 48 h in the presence or absence of 1 microM diquat (DQ), 250 microM aminoguanidine (AG, an inhibitor of inducible nitric oxide synthase), and (or) 100 microM diethyldithiocarbamate (DETC, an inhibitor of Cu,Zn-SOD). In the KO macrophages, there was no protein band detected by Western blot with anti-GPX1 antibody and 98% reduction in total GPX activity compared with WT cells. Nitric oxide (NO) synthesis was greatly enhanced after 24 h by GPX1 knockout and DQ, but inhibited by AG or DETC. Protein carbonyl formation in total cell extract was clearly associated with NO synthesis as higher levels of protein carbonyl were detected in activated KO than WT macrophages, and DQ enhanced slightly while AG or DETC virtually blocked its formation. A similarly marginal effect of GPX1 KO was observed on protein nitration. The LPS/IFN/DQ-induced DNA fragmentation was blocked by AG, but not by DETC. Cell viability at 48 h was decreased by the LPS/IFN activation and further reduced by the addition of DQ, but restored by AG. In conclusion, GPX1 affects the NO production in activated peritoneal macrophages and protects these cells against NO-associated protein oxidation.     

Heterozygous knockout of neuregulin-1 gene in mice exacerbates doxorubicin-induced heart failure

Neuregulins and their erbB receptors are essential for cardiac development and postulated to be cardioprotective in the presence of injury in the postnatal heart. We tested the hypothesis that the development of doxorubicin-induced cardiotoxicity in vivo is more severe in mice with heterozygous knockout of the neuregulin-1 gene (NRG-1(+/-)) compared with wild-type mice (WT). Three-month old NRG-1(+/-) and WT mice were injected with a single dose of doxorubicin (20 mg/kg ip). Survival was analyzed by the Kaplan-Meier approach. Left ventricular (LV) function and signaling pathways were analyzed 4 days after treatment. Fifteen days after treatment, survival was significantly lower in doxorubicin-treated NRG-1(+/-) mice (NRG-1(+/-)-Dox) compared with doxorubicin-treated WT mice (WT-Dox) (15% vs. 33%, P < 0.01). LV mass was significantly lower in NRG-1(+/-)-Dox but not in WT-Dox compared with nontreated animals. LV systolic pressure and LV midwall fractional shortening were significantly lower in NRG-1(+/-)-Dox compared with WT-Dox mice. LV protein levels of NRG-1, erbB2, and erbB4 receptors were similar in WT-Dox and NRG-1(+/-)-Dox mice. However, levels of phosphorylated erbB2, Akt, and ERK-1/2 were significantly decreased in NRG-1(+/-)-Dox compared with WT-Dox mice. A significant decrease in phosphorylated P70S6K levels was also observed in NRG-1(+/-)-Dox compared with nontreated NRG-1(+/-) mice. These results demonstrate that heterozygous knockout of the neuregulin-1 gene worsens survival and LV function in the presence of doxorubicin-induced cardiac injury in vivo. This is associated with the depression of activation of the erbB2 receptor as well as Akt, p70S6K, and ERK-1/2 pathways.     

Attenuated defense response and low basal blood pressure in orexin knockout mice

The perifornical area of the hypothalamus has been known as the center for the defense response, or "fight or flight" response, which is characterized by a concomitant rise in arterial blood pressure (AP), heart rate (HR), and respiratory frequency (Rf). We examined whether orexin, a recently identified hypothalamic neuropeptide, contributes to the defense response and basal cardiovascular regulation using orexin knockout mice. Microinjection of a GABA-A receptor antagonist, bicuculline methiodide (0.1-1 mM in 20 nl), to the perifornical area in urethane-anesthetized wild-type mice elicited dose-dependent increases in AP, HR, and Rf. Although similar changes were observed in orexin knockout mice, intensities were smaller and duration was shorter than those in wild-type mice. Moreover, in an awake and freely moving condition, telemeter-indwelling orexin knockout mice showed diminished cardiovascular and behavioral responses to emotional stress in the resident-intruder test. We also found that basal AP in orexin knockout mice was significantly lower in both anesthetized (117 +/- 8 mmHg in wild type and 92 +/- 3 in knockout) and conscious (125 +/- 6 mmHg in wild type and 109 +/- 2 in knockout) conditions. alpha-Adrenergic blockade with prazosin or ganglion blockade with hexamethonium canceled the difference in basal AP. HR and cardiac contractile parameters by echocardiography did not differ between the two strains of mice. These results indicate lower sympathetic vasoconstrictor tone in knockout mice. The present study suggests that orexin-containing neurons in the perifornical area play a role as one of the efferent pathways of defense response and also operate as a regulator of AP at basal condition by activating sympathetic outflow.     

Imbalance of antioxidant defense in mice lacking cellular prion protein

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative disorders resulting from conformational changes in the prion protein from its normal cellular isoform, PrPC, to the infectious scrapie isoform, PrP(Sc). In spite of many studies, the physiological function of PrPC remains unknown. Recent work shows that PrPC binds Cu2+, internalizing it into the cytoplasm. Since many antioxidant enzymes depend on Cu2+ (e.g., Cu/ZnSOD), their function could be affected in prion diseases. Here we investigate a possible relationship between PrP(C) and the cellular antioxidant systems in different structures isolated from PrPC knockout and wild-type mice by determining oxidative damage in protein and lipids and activity of antioxidant enzymes (CAT, SOD) and stress-adaptive enzymes (ODC). Our results show that, in the absence of PrPC, there is an increased oxidation of lipid and protein in all structures investigated. Decreased SOD activity and changes in CAT/ODC activities were also observed. Taking into account these results, we suggest that the physiological function of PrP(C) is related to cellular antioxidant defenses. Therefore, during development of prion diseases, the whole organism becomes more sensitive to ROS injury, leading to a progressive oxidative disruption of tissues and vital organs, especially the central nervous system.     

Nox1 causes ileocolitis in mice deficient in glutathione peroxidase-1 and -2

We previously reported that mice deficient in two Se-dependent glutathione peroxidases, GPx1 and GPx2, have spontaneous ileocolitis. Disease severity depends on mouse genetic background. Whereas C57BL/6J (B6) GPx1/2-double-knockout (DKO) mice have moderate ileitis and mild colitis, 129S1Svlm/J (1 2 9) DKO mice have severe ileocolitis. Because GPx’s are antioxidant enzymes, we hypothesized that elevated reactive oxygen species trigger inflammation in these DKO mice. To test whether NADPH oxidase 1 (Nox1) contributes to colitis, we generated B6 triple-KO (TKO) mice to study their phenotype. Because the Nox1 gene is X-linked, we analyzed the effects of Nox1 on male B6 TKO mice and female B6 DKO mice with the Nox1^+/− (het-TKO) genotype. We found that the male TKO and female het-TKO mice are virtually disease-free when monitored from 8 through 50 days of age. Male TKO and female het-TKO mice have nearly no signs of disease (e.g., lethargy and perianal alopecia) that are often exhibited in the DKO mice; further, the slower growth rate of DKO mice is almost completely eliminated in male TKO and female het-TKO mice. Male TKO and female het-TKO mice no longer have the shortened small intestine present in the DKO mice. Finally, the pathological characteristics of the DKO ileum, including the high level of crypt apoptosis (analyzed by apoptotic figures, TUNEL, and cleaved caspase-3 immunohistochemical staining), high numbers of Ki-67-positive crypt epithelium cells, and elevated levels of monocytes expressing myeloperoxidase, are all significantly decreased in male TKO mice. The attenuated ileal and colonic pathology is also evident in female het-DKO mice. Furthermore, the male DKO ileum has eightfold higher TNF cytokine levels than TKO ileum. Nox1 mRNA is highly elevated in both B6 and 129 DKO ileum compared to wild-type mouse ileum. Taking these results together, we propose that ileocolitis in the DKO mice is caused by Nox1, which is induced by TNF. The milder disease in female het-TKO intestine is probably due to random or imprinted X-chromosome inactivation, which produces mosaic Nox1 expression.     

Clustered gene expression changes flank targeted gene loci in knockout mice

Background

Gene expression profiling using microarrays is a powerful technology widely used to study regulatory networks. Profiling of mRNA levels in mutant organisms has the potential to identify genes regulated by the mutated protein.

Methodology/Principle Findings

Using tissues from multiple lines of knockout mice we have examined genome-wide changes in gene expression. We report that a significant proportion of changed genes were found near the targeted gene.

Conclusions/Significance

The apparent clustering of these genes was explained by the presence of flanking DNA from the parental ES cell. We provide recommendations for the analysis and reporting of microarray data from knockout mice     

Glutathione peroxidase-1 expression enhances recovery of human breast carcinoma cells from hyperoxic cell cycle arrest

We previously reported that hyperoxia (95% O(2)) induces an S-phase cell cycle arrest in glutathione peroxidase-deficient human carcinoma cells T47D-H3 (Exp. Cell Res. 256:347-357; 2000). Here, we investigated whether increasing the peroxide scavenging capacity via glutathione peroxidase-1 (GPx1) expression can prevent cell cycle alterations induced by oxidative stress. We show that GPx1-proficient T47D-GPx-2 transfectant cells, in which GPx1 concentration is most elevated in mitochondria (Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 272:416-422; 2000), are partially resistant to cell cycle inhibition induced by hyperoxia or menadione exposure. Transient cell growth resistance was observed at the level of cell cycle phase distribution, Cdk2 activity, and DNA synthesis after 40 h hyperoxia. This differential resistance was associated with an inhibition of ROS production and lipid peroxidation induced by hyperoxia. After 64 h hyperoxic exposure, cell growth was completely abolished in both cell lines, despite elevated glutathione levels. However, in contrast to the GPx1-deficient cells, T47D-GPx-2 cells showed an increased capacity to recover from a cell cycle arrest mediated by a 64 h hyperoxic stress. Differential recovery was also observed at the ultrastructural level between Gpx1-proficient and -deficient cells. These data indicate that GPx1 played an important role in the cell capacity to recover from hyperoxic insults. The limited protection conferred by GPx1 during hyperoxia suggests that the deleterious effects were partially mediated by peroxide-derived free radicals, but also involved the action of nonperoxide-derived reactive species.