Conserved Interactions of the Active Carboxyls in Pepsin-like Enzymes and Retroviral Proteases

In addition to previous studies, 30 crystal structures of retroviral proteases corresponding to the highest resolution were inspected to analyze the interactions of the active carboxyls with surroundings groups. The outer oxygens of the active carboxyls in retroviral enzymes form contacts only with the water molecule participating in catalysis. This is an important difference between retroviral proteases and pepsin-like enzymes, which form a net of hydrogen bonds of these outer oxygens with residues neighboring the catalytic site in 3D structures. At the same time, it was found that in all aspartic proteases the inner oxygens of the active carboxyls are also involved in the chain of interactions through peptide groups Thr–Gly adjacent to the active residues. Polarization of these peptide groups influences the donor–acceptor properties of the active carboxyls. The found chain of interactions is more extensive in retroviral than in pepsin-like proteases; however, its main part is conserved for the whole class of these enzymes. Some implications of the role of these interactions are discussed.     

Interdomain interactions in aspartic proteases of higher organisms and their analogs in retroviral enzymes

A continuous chain of hydrogen bonded groups, which forms cross-hands interaction between domains in molecules of pepsin-like enzymes, has been revealed. The chain contains a pair of 6 symmetrically related hydrogen bonds between main chain atoms and the two conserved water molecules. The peptide groups forming hydrogen bond with the inner oxygens of the active carboxyls are important elements of the chain. The so-called "fireman grip" hydrogen bonding, consisting of a pair of the two symmetrically related bonds, is an integral part of this system of interactions. One of the water molecules in this system has a zero accessibility and forms a very short hydrogen bond with the active site interacting peptide group. This chain connects tightly the two regions of domains which have a high correlation in conformational mobility. The retroviral enzymes have an abortive chain of the interdomain interaction in this region which is reduced to the "fireman grip" net.     

Analysis of crystal structures of aspartic proteinases: On the role of amino acid residues adjacent to the catalytic site of pepsin-like enzymes

To elucidate the role of amino acid residues adjacent to the catalytic site of pepsin-like enzymes, we analyzed and compared the crystal structures of these enzymes, their complexes with inhibitors, and zymogens in the active site area (a total of 82 structures). In addition to the water molecule (W1) located between the active carboxyls and playing a role of the nucleophile during catalytic reaction, another water molecule (W2) at the vicinity of the active groups was found to be completely conserved. This water molecule plays an essential role in formation of a chain of hydrogen-bonded residues between the active site flap and the active carboxyls on ligand binding. These data suggest a new approach to understanding the role of residues around the catalytic site, which can assist the development of the catalytic reaction. The influence of groups adjacent to the active carboxyls is manifested by pepsin activity at pH 1.0. Some features of pepsin-like enzymes and their mutants are discussed in the framework of the approach.     

Interdomain interactions in aspartic proteases of higher organisms and their analogs in retroviral enzymes

On recent evidence, the efficiency of catalysis and the specificity of aspartic proteases depend considerably on the dynamic properties of particular molecular regions and their correlations. Analysis of the three-dimensional structures of these enzymes showed the presence of a continuous chain of hydrogen-bonded groups, which connects regions with highly correlated dynamic parameters and provides for a “cross-hand” interaction between domains. This chain includes the inner oxygens of the active carboxyls and the conserved internal water molecules. The so-called “fireman grip” interdomain hydrogen bonding is part of this chain. Such networks are abortive in retroviral proteases. The role of these interactions in the functions of aspartic proteases is discussed.     

How the features of three-dimensional structure of aspartate proteinases determine their properties

There is given a brief account of the specific interactions of some amino acid residues in aspartic proteases of both higher organisms and retroviruses that determine their important properties: an anomalously low isoelectric point of pepsin and its stability at pH close to unity; the ability of one of the carboxyl groups in the active site of proteases of higher organisms to retain charged state at any pH value and protonated state of another carboxyl, which is necessary for their enzymatic activity. It is also explained how such states can be induced in retroviral proteases.     

Special Features of the Three-Dimensional Structure Defining Properties of Aspartic Proteases

A brief account is given of the specific interactions of some amino acid residues in aspartic proteases of both higher organisms and retroviruses that determine important protease properties: the anomalously low isoelectric point of pepsin and its stability at pH close to 1; the ability of one of the carboxyl groups in the active site of proteases of higher organisms to retain a charged state at any pH value; and the protonated state of another carboxyl, which is necessary for enzymatic activity. It is also explained how such states can be induced in retroviral proteases.     

Modeling of substrate and inhibitory complexes of histidine-aspartic protease

A three-dimensional structure of histo-aspartic protease (HAP), a pepsin-like enzyme from the causative agent of malaria Plasmodium falciparum, is suggested on the basis of homologous modeling followed by equilibration by the method of molecular dynamics. The presence of a His residue in the catalytic site instead of an Asp residue, which is characteristic of pepsin-like enzymes, and replacement of some other conserved residues in the active site make it possible for the enzyme to function by the covalent mechanism inherent in serine proteases. The detailed structures of HAP complexes with pepstatin, a noncovalent inhibitor of aspartic proteases, and phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride, a covalent inhibitor of serine proteases, as well as with a pentapeptide substrate are discussed.     

Modeling of substrate and inhibitory complexes of histidine-aspartic protease

A three-dimensional structure of histo-aspartic protease (HAP), a pepsin-like enzyme from the causative agent of malaria Plasmodium falciparum, is suggested on the basis of homologous modeling followed by equilibration by the method of molecular dynamics. The presence of a His residue in the catalytic site instead of an Asp residue, which is characteristic of pepsin-like enzymes, and replacement of some other conserved residues in the active site make it possible for the enzyme to function by the covalent mechanism inherent in serine proteases. The detailed structures of HAP complexes with pepstatin, a noncovalent inhibitor of aspartic proteases, and phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride, a covalent inhibitor of serine proteases, as well as with a pentapeptide substrate are discussed.     

Characterization of an active single polypeptide form of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease

The pepsin-like aspartyl proteases consist of a single polypeptide chain with topologically similar amino- and carboxyl-terminal domains, each of which contributes 1 aspartic acid residue to the active site. This structure has been proposed to have evolved by gene duplication and fusion from a dimeric enzyme composed of two identical polypeptide chains, such as the aspartyl protease (PRT) of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1). To determine if a single polypeptide form of the HIV-1 protease would be enzymatically active, two protease coding regions were linked to form a dimeric gene (pFGGP). Expression of this gene in Escherichia coli yielded a protein with the expected molecular mass of 22 kDa. The in vitro kinetic parameters of PRT and FGGP (where FGGP is the single polypeptide form of the HIV-1 protease with 2 glycine residues connecting the two subunits) for three peptide substrates are similar. Construction and analysis of a CheY-GAG-FGGP fusion protein demonstrated that FGGP is capable of precursor processing in vivo. Mutation of one or both of the active site aspartates to either asparagine or glutamate rendered the enzyme inactive, demonstrating that both active site aspartate residues are required for enzymatic activity.     

Evolution in the structure and function of carboxyl proteases

Summary A model for the structure and function of extracellular carboxyl (acid) proteases can be established from three amino acid sequences and four crystal structures of these enzymes. The carboxyl proteases from gastric and fungal origins are very homologous in both primary and tertiary structures. The molecules consist of about 320 residues organized with a secondary structure which is primarily comprised of -strands and very similar tertiary structures. An apparent binding cleft, which can accommodate a substrate with about eight amino acid residues, contains near its midpoint the active center residues Asp-215, Asp-32, and Ser-35. These three residues are hydrogen bonded to each other.An intracellular carboxyl protease, cathepsin D, is very homologous to the extracellular enzymes in N-terminal amino acid sequence and primary structure location of active center residues. The tertiary structure of cathepsin D is probably similar, as well. However, cathepsin D contains a unique hydrophobic tail made up of about 100 residues added on the C-terminal side. Cathepsin D precursor is over 100,000 daltons in molecular weights, as contrasted to the gastric carboxyl protease zymogens, which are about 40,000 daltons.     

Characterization of two hydrophobic methyl clusters in HIV-1 protease by NMR spin relaxation in solution

Nearly 50 % of the amino acid residues of HIV-1 protease contain methyl side-chains, most of which appear to be organized into two clusters: the inner cluster that nearly surrounds the active site and the outer cluster that contains the hydrophobic core which stabilizes the inhibitor-free protease structure. NMR relaxation experiments sensitive to motions of methyl groups on the sub-nanosecond and the milli-microsecond time-scales revealed flexible methyl groups in residues that link the two clusters, the methyl groups of L10, L23, V75, and L76. We hypothesize that flexibility at the junctions of these clusters allows the protease to minimize conformational changes upon drug-binding. The two-methyl cluster motif appears to be a common structural feature among retroviral proteases and may play a similar role throughout this family of enzymes.     

Closing of the flaps of HIV-1 protease induced by substrate binding: a model of a flap closing mechanism in retroviral aspartic proteases

The active site of aspartic proteases is covered by one or more flaps, which control access to the active site and play a significant role in the binding of the substrate. An extensive conformational change of the flaps takes place upon binding of substrate to the active site. A long molecular dynamics simulation was performed on the complex consisting of a peptide (CA-p2) from a natural substrate cleavage site of the gag/pol polyprotein placed in the active site of HIV-1 protease (PR) with an open flap conformation. During the simulation, the substrate induced the closing of the flaps into the closed conformation in an asymmetrical way through a hydrophobic intermediate state cluster. The nature of the residues of HIV-1 PR identified to be important in the flap closing mechanism is conserved across known structures of retroviral aspartic proteases family. The flap closing mechanism described in HIV-1 PR is proposed to be a general model for flap closing in retroviral aspartic proteases.     

Comparison of inhibitor binding in HIV-1 protease and in non-viral aspartic proteases: the role of the flap

The crystal structure of HIV-1 protease with an inhibitor has been compared with the structures of non-viral aspartic proteases complexed with inhibitors. In the dimeric HIV-1 protease, two 4-stranded beta-sheets are formed by half of the inhibitor, residues 27-29, and the flap from each monomer. In the monomeric non-viral enzyme the single flap does not form a beta-sheet with an inhibitor. The HIV-1 protease shows more interactions with a longer peptide inhibitor than are observed in non-viral aspartic protease-inhibitor complexes. This, and the large movement of the flaps, restricts the conformation of the protease cleavage sites in the retroviral polyprotein precursor.     

Crystal structure of the binary complex of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase and its product, 3-phospho-D-glycerate

The crystal structure of the binary complex of non-activated ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase from Rhodospirillum rubrum and its product 3-phospho-D-glycerate has been determined to 2.9-A resolution. This structure determination confirms the proposed location of the active site (Schneider, G., Lindqvist, Y., Br?ndén, C.-I., and Lorimer, G. (1986) EMBO J. 5, 3409-3415) at the carboxyl end of the beta-strands of the alpha/beta-barrel in the carboxyl-terminal domain. One molecule of 3-phosphoglycerate is bound per active site. All oxygen atoms of 3-phosphoglycerate form hydrogen bonds to groups of the enzyme. The phosphate group interacts with the sidechains of residues Arg-288, His-321, and Ser-368, which are conserved between enzymes from different species as well as with the main chain nitrogens from residues Thr-322 and Gly-323. These amino acid residues constitute one of the two phosphate binding sites of the active site. The carboxyl group interacts with the side chains of His-287, Lys-191, and Asn-111. Implications of the activation process for the binding of 3-phosphoglycerate are discussed.     

Active-site mobility in human immunodeficiency virus, type 1, protease as demonstrated by crystal structure of A28S mutant.

The mutation Ala28 to serine in human immunodeficiency virus, type 1, (HIV-1) protease introduces putative hydrogen bonds to each active-site carboxyl group. These hydrogen bonds are ubiquitous in pepsin-like eukaryotic aspartic proteases. In order to understand the significance of this difference between HIV-1 protease and homologous, eukaryotic aspartic proteases, we solved the three-dimensional structure of A28S mutant HIV-1 protease in complex with a peptidic inhibitor U-89360E. The structure has been determined to 2.0 A resolution with an R factor of 0.194. Comparison of the mutant enzyme structure with that of the wild-type HIV-1 protease bound to the same inhibitor (Hong L, Treharne A, Hartsuck JA, Foundling S, Tang J, 1996, Biochemistry 35:10627-10633) revealed double occupancy for the Ser28 hydroxyl group, which forms a hydrogen bond either to one of the oxygen atoms of the active-site carboxyl or to the carbonyl oxygen of Asp30. We also observed marked changes in orientation of the Asp25 catalytic carboxyl groups, presumably caused by the new hydrogen bonds. These observations suggest that catalytic aspartyl groups of HIV-1 protease have significant conformational flexibility unseen in eukaryotic aspartic proteases. This difference may provide an explanation for some unique catalytic properties of HIV-1 protease.     

Shewasin A, an active pepsin homolog from the bacterium Shewanella amazonensis

The view has been widely held that pepsin-like aspartic proteinases are found only in eukaryotes, and not in bacteria. However, a recent bioinformatics search [Rawlings ND & Bateman A (2009) BMC Genomics10, 437] revealed that, in seven of ～ 1000 completely sequenced bacterial genomes, genes were present encoding polypeptides that displayed the requisite hallmark sequence motifs of pepsin-like aspartic proteinases. The implications of this theoretical observation prompted us to generate biochemical data to validate this finding experimentally. The aspartic proteinase gene from one of the seven identified bacterial species, Shewanella amazonensis, was expressed in Escherichia coli. The recombinant protein, termed shewasin A, was produced in soluble form, purified to homogeneity, and shown to display properties remarkably similar to those of pepsin-like aspartic proteinases. Shewasin A was maximally active at acidic pH values, cleaving a substrate that has been widely used for assessment of the proteolytic activity of other aspartic proteinases, and displayed a clear preference for cleaving peptide bonds between hydrophobic residues in the P1*P1' positions of the substrate. It was completely inhibited by the general inhibitor of aspartic proteinases, pepstatin, and mutation of one of the catalytic Asp residues (in the Asp-Thr-Gly motif of the N-terminal domain) resulted in complete loss of enzymatic activity. It can thus be concluded unequivocally that this Shewanella gene encodes an active pepsin-like aspartic proteinase. It is now beyond doubt that pepsin-like aspartic proteinases are not confined to eukaryotes, but are encoded within some species of bacteria. The distinctions between the bacterial and eukaryotic polypeptides are discussed and their evolutionary relationships are outlined.     

Toward a universal inhibitor of retroviral proteases: comparative analysis of the interactions of LP-130 complexed with proteases from HIV-1, FIV, and EIAV.

One of the major problems encountered in antiviral therapy against AIDS is the emergence of viral variants that exhibit drug resistance. The sequences of proteases (PRs) from related retroviruses sometimes include, at structurally equivalent positions, amino acids identical to those found in drug-resistant forms of HIV-1 PR. The statine-based inhibitor LP-130 was found to be a universal, nanomolar-range inhibitor against all tested retroviral PRs. We solved the crystal structures of LP-130 in complex with retroviral PRs from HIV-1, feline immunodeficiency virus, and equine infectious anemia virus and compared the structures to determine the differences in the interactions between the inhibitor and the active-site residues of the enzymes. This comparison shows an extraordinary similarity in the binding modes of the inhibitor molecules. The only exceptions are the different conformations of naphthylalanine side chains at the P3/P3' positions, which might be responsible for the variation in the Ki values. These findings indicate that successful inhibition of different retroviral PRs by LP-130 is achieved because this compound can be accommodated without serious conformational differences, despite the variations in the type of residues forming the active-site region. Although strong, specific interactions between the ligand and the enzyme might improve the potency of the inhibitor, the absence of such interactions seems to favor the universality of the compound. Hence, the ability of potential anti-AIDS drugs to inhibit multiple retroviral PRs might indicate their likelihood of not eliciting drug resistance. These studies may also contribute to the development of a small-animal model for preclinical testing of antiviral compounds.     

Systematic mutational analysis of the active-site threonine of HIV-1 proteinase: rethinking the "fireman's grip" hypothesis

Aspartic proteinases share a conserved network of hydrogen bonds (termed "fireman's grip"), which involves the hydroxyl groups of two threonine residues in the active site Asp-Thr-Gly triplets (Thr26 in the case of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) PR). In the case of retroviral proteinases (PRs), which are active as symmetrical homodimers, these interactions occur at the dimer interface. For a systematic analysis of the "fireman's grip," Thr26 of HIV-1 PR was changed to either Ser, Cys, or Ala. The variant enzymes were tested for cleavage of HIV-1 derived peptide and polyprotein substrates. PR(T26S) and PR(T26C) showed similar or slightly reduced activity compared to wild-type HIV-1 PR, indicating that the sulfhydryl group of cysteine can substitute for the hydroxyl of the conserved threonine in this position. PR(T26A), which lacks the "fireman's grip" interaction, was virtually inactive and was monomeric in solution at conditions where wild-type PR exhibited a monomer-dimer equilibrium. All three mutations had little effect when introduced into only one chain of a linked dimer of HIV-1 PR. In this case, even changing both Thr residues to Ala yielded residual activity suggesting that the "fireman's grip" is not essential for activity but contributes significantly to dimer formation. Taken together, these results indicate that the "fireman's grip" is crucial for stabilization of the retroviral PR dimer and for overall stability of the enzyme.     

Synthetic "interface" peptides alter dimeric assembly of the HIV 1 and 2 proteases.

Retroviral proteases are obligate homodimers and play an essential role in the viral life cycle. Dissociation of dimers or prevention of their assembly may inactivate these enzymes and prevent viral maturation. A salient structural feature of these enzymes is an extended interface composed of interdigitating N- and C-terminal residues of both monomers, which form a four-stranded beta-sheet. Peptides mimicking one beta-strand (residues 95-99), or two beta-strands (residues 1-5 plus 95-99 or 95-99 plus 95-99) from the human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV1) interface were shown to inhibit the HIV1 and 2 proteases (PRs) with IC50's in the low micromolar range. These interface peptides show cognate enzyme preference and do not inhibit pepsin, renin, or the Rous sarcoma virus PR, indicating a degree of specificity for the HIV PRs. A tethered HIV1 PR dimer was not inhibited to the same extent as the wild-type enzymes by any of the interface peptides, suggesting that these peptides can only interact effectively with the interface of the two-subunit HIV PR. Measurements of relative dissociation constants by limit dilution of the enzyme show that the one-strand peptide causes a shift in the observed Kd for the HIV1 PR. Both one- and two-strand peptides alter the monomer/dimer equilibrium of both HIV1 and HIV2 PRs. This was shown by the reduced cross-linking of the HIV2 PR by disuccinimidyl suberate in the presence of the interface peptides. Refolding of the HIV1 and HIV2 PRs with the interface peptides shows that only the two-strand peptides prevent the assembly of active PR dimers. Although both one- and two-strand peptides seem to affect dimer dissociation, only the two-strand peptides appear to block assembly. The latter may prove to be more effective backbones for the design of inhibitors directed toward retroviral PR dimerization in vivo.     

Critical residues for structure and catalysis in short-chain dehydrogenases/reductases

Short-chain dehydrogenases/reductases form a large, evolutionarily old family of NAD(P)(H)-dependent enzymes with over 60 genes found in the human genome. Despite low levels of sequence identity (often 10-30%), the three-dimensional structures display a highly similar alpha/beta folding pattern. We have analyzed the role of several conserved residues regarding folding, stability, steady-state kinetics, and coenzyme binding using bacterial 3beta/17beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase and selected mutants. Structure determination of the wild-type enzyme at 1.2-A resolution by x-ray crystallography and docking analysis was used to interpret the biochemical data. Enzyme kinetic data from mutagenetic replacements emphasize the critical role of residues Thr-12, Asp-60, Asn-86, Asn-87, and Ala-88 in coenzyme binding and catalysis. The data also demonstrate essential interactions of Asn-111 with active site residues. A general role of its side chain interactions for maintenance of the active site configuration to build up a proton relay system is proposed. This extends the previously recognized catalytic triad of Ser-Tyr-Lys residues to form a tetrad of Asn-Ser-Tyr-Lys in the majority of characterized short-chain dehydrogenases/reductase enzymes.