Some observations on shell shape variation in Pacific Nucella

This paper considers the patterns of shell shape variation shown by Nucella canalicuata, N. emarginata and N. lamellosa from two areas of the Pacific Northwest: the shores near Friday Harbour on San Juan Island and near Bamfield on the west coast of Vancouver Island. No clear pattern of variation in association with changes in exposure was seen in either N. canaliculata or N. lamellosa . It appears that genetic influences are more important controls of shell shape than environmental selection in both these species. Nucella emarginata shows the nearest approximation to the pattern shown by the Atlantic species, N. lapillus , but only at the exposed end of the wave-action gradient. On those shores, enclaves from the most surf-washed open coast headlands have shells with proportionally larger apertures (and thus a shorter, squatter form) than their equivalents in local shelter. But, unlike in N. lapillus , the trend does not continue onto genuinely sheltered shores. Under these circumstances the species is generally rare and, where enclaves do occur, their shells are of much the same shape (although of a much larger size) as in more exposed situations.     

Extreme,continuous variation in an island snail: local diversification and association of shell form with the current environment

On Rosemary Island, a small continental island (11 km²) in the Dampier Archipelago, Western Australia, snails of the genus Rhagada have extremely diverse morphologies. Their shells vary remarkably in size and shape, with the latter ranging from globose to keeled‐flat, spanning the range of variation in the entire genus. Based primarily on variation in shell morphology, five distinct species are currently recognized. However, a study of 103 populations has revealed continuity of shell form within a very closely‐related group. A phylogenetic analysis of specimens from Rosemary Island, and other islands in the Dampier Archipelago, indicates that much of the morphological variation has evolved on the island, from within a monophyletic group. Within the island, snails with distinct shell morphologies could not be distinguished based on variation in mitochondrial DNA or their reproductive anatomy. The shell variation is geographically structured over a very fine scale, with clines linking the extreme forms over distances less than 200 m. Although there is no evidence that the different forms have evolved in isolation or as a consequence of drift, there is a strong association between keeled‐flat shells and rocky habitats, suggesting that shell shape may be of adaptive significance. © 2011 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2011, 104 , 756–769.     

Nonrandom variation of morphological traits across environmental gradients in a land snail

Morphological variation is often attributed to differential adaptations to diverse habitats, but adaptations to a similar environment do not necessarily result in similar phenotypes. Adaptations for water and heat budget are crucial for organisms living in arid habitats, and in snails, variation in shell morphology has been frequently attributed to selection by stressful environmental factors. However, their phenotypic divergence often is not accompanied by a relevant niche differentiation and consistent relationships with environmental correlates are lacking. In the pulmonate genus Albinaria, there is great size and shape variation between and within species, and there are two major shell sculpture morphotypes, ribbed and smooth. We used 62 populations of 28 Albinaria species, taking into account their phylogeny, to examine the variation of shell traits (sculpture, size, shape), their effect on water and heat budget, and their association with geographical and climatic gradients. We found unambiguous size and shape discrimination between the two morphotypes. Ribbed shells are lighter, taller, and slimmer and have a smaller aperture than the smooth ones. Moreover, significant correlations between shell traits and heat/moisture budget and climate/geography were revealed. Ribbed and taller shells retain more water on their shell surface, and on the other hand, smooth shells exhibit lower water permeability. Therefore, two strategies are being used to prevent water loss, active retention or resistance to loss. Consequently, different alternative solutions evolved and were retained as responses to the same stressful factor by the two distinct shell morphotypes. Larger shells occur in southern latitudes, mostly on islands, and at sites where there is a shortage of rainfall. Therefore, the variation of the examined traits is nonrandom with respect to location and to climate and their evolution can be attributed to selection by environmental factors, with water availability being the key driving agent of body-size variation.     

Appearance of morphological novelty in a hybrid zone between two species of land snail

On the small oceanic island of Chichijima, two endemic species of land snails, Mandarina mandarina and M. chichijimana, have discrete distributions separated by a hybrid zone. This study investigates the potential of hybridization as a source of morphological novelty in these snails. Mandarina mandarina possesses a shell with a higher whorl expansion rate and a smaller protoconch than M. chichijimana, relative to shell size. The number of whorls and shell size of M. mandarina do not differ from those of M. chichijimana, because the effect of higher expansion rate on number of whorls and size of the former is compensated for by its smaller protoconch. The whorl expansion rate and protoconch diameter of the individuals from the hybrid populations are intermediate or typical of either of the two species, and their average values show clinal changes along the hybrid zone. However, the hybrid populations include exceptionally high shells with many whorls and flat shells with few whorls, which are never found in the pure populations of either species. In addition, gradual increases in variance in shell height and number of whorls were found from the edges to the center of the hybrid zone. A combination of low expansion rate (typical of M. chichijimana) and a small protoconch (typical of M. mandarina) produces a shell with an extremely large number of whorls because of the geometry of shell coiling. However, the combination of high expansion rate and a large protoconch produces a shell with an extremely small number of whorls. Because of the correlation between the number of whorls and shell height, shells with an exceptional number of whorls possess an extraordinarily high or flat spire. Hybrids can inherit a mosaic of characters that, as they play out during growth, lead to novel adult morphologies. These findings emphasize the importance of hybridization as a source of morphological variation and evolutionary novelty in land snails.     

Geometric morphometric analysis reveals that the shells of male and female siphon whelks Penion chathamensis are the same size and shape

Secondary sexual dimorphism can make the discrimination of intra and interspecific variation difficult, causing the identification of evolutionary lineages and classification of species to be challenging, particularly in palaeontology. Yet sexual dimorphism is an understudied research topic in dioecious marine snails. We use landmark-based geometric morphometric analysis to investigate whether there is sexual dimorphism in the shell morphology of the siphon whelk Penion chathamensis. In contrast to studies of other snails, results strongly indicate that there is no difference in the shape or size of shells between the sexes. A comparison of P. chathamensis and a related species demonstrates that this result is unlikely to reflect a limitation of the method. The possibility that sexual dimorphism is not exhibited by at least some species of Penion is advantageous from a palaeontological perspective as there is a rich fossil record for the genus across the Southern Hemisphere.     

Constraint and the square snail: life at the limits of a covariance set. The normal teratology of Cerion disforme

Two major developmental constraints, identified and assessed by the covariance structure of ontogenetic measures, strongly influence the form and variation of Cerion in every study I have ever undertaken on this protean genus: the jigsaw constraint of large-and few vs small-and-many whorls for shells reaching a similar final size; and the compensatory constraint of later heights balancing juvenile widths to bring adult shells into a limited range of final proportions.
This study explores a set of taxa (the Cerion dimidiatum complex of eastern Cuba) growing at one extreme of the compensatory constraint–maximally flat juvenile shells followed by abrupt allometric transition to orthogonal adult whorls. I show that the most curious of all Cerion taxa, the teratologously uncoiling C. disforme , owes its unique and distinctive form to growth at an extreme of the compensatory constraint: the juvenile cross-section goes beyond mere flatness to actual concavity; and the adult shell, after maximally abrupt allometric transition to downward growth, loses contact with the juvenile whorls and begins to unwind in teratologic fashion. I present several categories of evidence to demonstrate that C. disforme is the extreme in a morphocline of taxa, whose correlated features express increasing discordance (and correlated sequelae of size and shape) under the compensatory constraint: C. geophilus – C. dimidiatum – C. alberli – C.disforme. I provide data for clines in morphology, in amount and character of variation, and in mode of growth. This genre of constraint–Darwin's old "correlations of growth"–must be given equal weight with immediate adaptation in a unified explanation of growth and form.     

Associations between shell morphology and land crab predation in the land snail Cerion

1. The land crab Gecarcinus lateralis is a significant predator of the abundant Bahamian land snails of the genus Cerion . The crabs typically 'scissor' the cylindrical shells in half or break the lip and peel back the shell to reach the animal which withdraws two or three whorls into the shell. Scars on shells of live adults at 73 sites in the Bahamas and Florida Keys show that about 8% (range: 0–44%) of the snails have survived attacks of this type.
2. An artificial crab claw was used to investigate the compressive force required to break Cerion shells of different morphotypes. Defining shell strength as the ability to withstand compressive forces, 10 morphotypes were found that exhibited mean relative strengths of between 30 and 300 newtons. Feeding trials with one adult crab showed that snails whose shells could withstand compressive forces of > 95 N were safe from this individual predator.
3. Multiple linear regression analyses showed that both shell size (length and width) and shell wall thickness were the ultimate determinants of shell strength. Ribs strengthen the shell by contributing to wall thickness and also by increasing overall shell width. The thickened adult shell lip and collabral ribs provide effective protection from attack by peeling.     

Variation in the genitalia of the land snail Heterostoma paupercula (Lowe, 1831) (Helicidae) in Madeira

The small helicid snail Heterostoma paupercula occurs in the Azores and Madeira. Previously regarded as a single species, it was split into two genera on the basis of variation in shell morphology and genital anatomy: Heterostoma having a toothed shell and being hemiphallic, while Steenbergia had a toothless shell and was euphallic. This division was first questioned when toothed shells {Heterostoma) in the Azores were found not to be hemiphallic. In this study the genitalia of 361 specimens from islands in the Madeira archipelago were examined. Four components of the genitalia were measured (penis/epiphallus, flagellum, bursa stalk and bursa) for 158 individuals. Hemiphally was found to be rare, occurring in only a proportion of the populations at two localities and it did not correspond with the expected shell morphology–the shells were untoothed (= Steenbergia) , which is the opposite of that previously described.
Variation in the genitalia was geographically based: Madeira and its nearest neighbour islands forming one group and the Porto Santo islands another. There is no evidence to suggest that the hemiphallic animals are more than an intraspecific form. It is suggested that the variation between the two island groups is reflective of allopatric differentiation. Without für ther evidence of divergence, H. paupercula should be regarded as the sole species throughout the range and the genus Steenbergia should be suppressed.     

Shell shape variation in the Nassariid Buccinanops globulosus in northern Patagonia

Morphological variation among natural populations is a phenomenon commonly observed in marine invertebrates and well studied, particularly, in shelled gastropods. The nassariid Buccinanops globulosus is interesting to study shell shape variation because it exhibits strong interpopulation differences in life history features, including maximum size, fecundity and growth rate. In this study, we examined the pattern of variation in size and shell shape among populations and between sexes of B. globulosus (Bahía San Antonio 40°29′S 63°01′W, Playa Villarino 40°45′S 64°40′W and Bahía Nueva 42°46′S 65°02′W). In particular, we used geometric morphometric techniques to test: (1) whether the two components of shell morphology (size and shape) are independent and (2) whether shape differences between sexes are consistently found among populations, regardless of their body sizes. Our results show shell shape variation between the populations of B. globulosus of northern Patagonia. Intra-specific shell shape variation is affected by body size, indicating allometry. Regardless of the size differences, individuals from Playa Villarino have high-spired shells, and shorter apertures and wider columellar area than individuals from the other populations. Also, sex-related shape differences were consistently found at each population, thus suggesting a common sexual dimorphism in shell morphology for this species. The functional significance of the variability found is discussed in terms of the flexibility of developmental programmes for morphology as well as the evolution of phenotypic plasticity.     

Differences in environmental predictability underlie divergent competitive abilities in three congeneric hydroids

Species in which individuals experience predictable and uniform environments should be most finely adapted to their environment. Many hydrozoan species in the genus Hydractinia simultaneously occupy similar microhabitats (gastropod shells inhabited by hermit crabs) but experience considerable differences in their immediate environment (size and species of shells and hosts). In the present study, hydroid species experience differences in environmental predictability and traits that mediate competitive ability (growth form and growth rate). The inferred competitive ability was directly proportional to the extent to which the gastropod environment promotes interactions between small, juvenile colonies, which always end in competitive elimination. Extensive intraspecific variation in competitive ability was explained primarily by crab host species or site. Dense host populations impose more severe disturbance regimes that favour competitively inferior, but disturbance-resistant, phenotypes. Interplay between different types of variation (gastropods and hermit crabs) provides a possible mechanism for the maintenance of intraspecific growth form variation.  © 2009 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2009, 96 , 322–338.     

Shell shape variation in dog-whelks (Nucella lapillus (L.)) from the West Coast of Scotland

European populations of the common dog-whelk, Nucella lapillus (L.), usually show a neat and precise pattern of shell shape variation with the exposure of their habitat to wave action. Whilst this is the case along much of the west coast of Scotland, there are a number of instances where unusually elongated shells occur, somewhat reminiscent of the form described for the Severn Estuary. There are no obvious environmental or geographical correlates to explain the occurrence of these forms and a genetical interpretation is sought.     

How does life adapt to a gravitational environment? The outline of the terrestrial gastropod shell

How do several characteristics adapt to gravity while mutually influencing each other? Our study addresses this issue by focusing on the terrestrial gastropod shell. The geometric relationship between the spire index (shell height/diameter) and outline (cylindricality) is theoretically estimated. When the shell grows isometrically, a high-spired shell becomes conical in shape and a low-spired shell becomes cylindrical in shape. A physical model shows that the lowest- and highest-spired shells are the most balanced. In addition, a cone shape is the most balanced for a low-spired shell, and a column shape is the most balanced for a high-spired shell. Spire index and cylindricality measured for freshwater gastropods follow the relationship estimated by the model, whereas those for terrestrial gastropods deviate from this relationship. This translates to a high shell being more cylindrical than a flat shell, except in the case of extremely high or low shells. This suggests that the shape of the most balanced shells (lowest and highest shell heights) is constrained by coiling geometry but that relatively unbalanced shells (intermediate shell heights) do not follow a coiling geometry, as a result of adaptation to enable the snail to carry its shell more effectively.     

COMPUTER-SIMULATED SHELL SIZE AND SHAPE VARIATION IN THE CARIBBEAN LAND SNAIL GENUS CERION: A TEST OF GEOMETRICAL CONSTRAINTS

A computer graphical model of gastropod shell form is used to test a hypothesis of geometric constraint proposed to explain the disjunct distribution of shell forms observed in Cerion, a species-rich and geometrically varied genus of terrestrial gastropods. The mapping of computer-simulated forms into a morphospace of Cerion shells produces a continuum of sizes and shapes. Therefore, the absence of particular shell forms is not explained by geometric constraints. Two proposed modes of shell morphogenesis at extreme ranges in size (“dwarfs” and “giants”) previously were thought to be exclusive routes to the construction of high-spired (“smokestack”) forms. The present study shows that there are, in fact, multiple routes of transformation. In addition, these routes are geometrically reversible and interconnect the members of the shell-form continuum. Thus, the possible pathways followed during the course of evolution within this genus cannot be determined until an adequate phylogenetic hypothesis has been proposed.     

Patterns of shell penetration by Chorus giganteus juveniles (Gastropoda: Muricidae) on the mussel Semimytilus algosus

Patterns are described for shell penetration by the sublittoral muricid snail Chorus giganteus during predatory attacks on the mussel Semimytilus algosus. Location, form and size of shell penetrations were observed in relation to the size of the predator. The results suggested that positions of the perforations on the mussel shells were related to size of the attacking snail. Smaller snails perforated areas near the shell ligament and in the central zone of the shell, while larger snails more frequently attacked shell borders, principally on the ventral side. These observations may be related to: (a) changes in the process of manipulation of the prey during development of the foot and the shell tooth of the predator, (b) changes in internal structure of the snails related to the shell perforation mechanism, or (c) learned behavior acquired experientially by the snails during early growth. Although in other studies of muricid penetration patterns larger boreholes made in shells of the prey were positively correlated with increasing predator size, this relation did not appear to hold with C. giganteus, as larger specimens often made relatively small shell perforations. Areas of boreholes made in the mussel shells by this snail varied from 0.01 to 1.1 mm(2), and were unusually variable in size and shape, especially when compared with literature results on bores characteristic of other muricid species.     

Associations with habitat versus geographic cohesiveness: size and shape of Bembicium vittatum Philippi (Gastropoda: Littorinidae) in the Houtman Abrolhos Islands

In the Houtman Abrolhos Islands, Western Australia, the direct-developing littorine snail Bembicium vittatum occupies a wide range of habitats, which are replicated across the three major groups of islands. Earlier studies showed that allozyme similarities followed patterns related to gene flow, independent of habitat, providing an excellent opportunity to test for associations with habitat for traits more likely to be adaptively important. As the first test for adaptive divergence, we examined variation in size and shape of shells among 131 populations in the Abrolhos Islands. Two-fold variations were found in width of adults, the allometric coefficient of height with width, and shell height scaled to a standard width. Quantification of habitat characteristics was summarized by principal components analysis. In contrast with the patterns of divergence for allozymes, shell height, adjusted for width, was strongly associated with habitat: flatter shells are found on exposed, vertical shores, while domed, more globose shells predominate in sheltered sites. This association was stronger for shape of adult-sized snails than for height scaled to an arbitrary size, highlighting the importance of using biologically relevant measures. Even highly isolated and allozymically less variable populations in tidal ponds conformed to this association. Because differences in shape are highly heritable in B. vittatum , this association of shape with habitat, independent of patterns of gene flow, indicates local adaptation. Shell size also varied with habitat, but because growth rate is highly plastic, variation in size cannot be interpreted simply in terms of adaptation. Nevertheless, the pattern of variation indicates that, within realized limits, larger size is generally favourable, but may be constrained by local conditions. Thus, variation in size signals the potential for adaptive divergence of life histories among the many, isolated populations of this species.     

Morphogenetic regulation in the shells of bivalves and brachiopods: evidence from the geometry of the spiral

Ackerly. S. C. 1992 07 15: Morphogenetic regulation in the shells of bivalves and brachiopods: evidence from the geometry of the spiral.
Analyses of the spiral geometry in shells of the mollusc Pecten maximus and the brachiopod Terebratulina retusa indicate a relative reduction in morphological variability within the population during growth. The spiral, as measured by a model of exponential radial expansion, tends to converge on a particular adult form, irrespective of irregularities during early growth phases. The recurrence of this pattern of variability in populations from two separate phyla (molluscs and brachiopods) suggests a common mechanism controlling shell form. Brachiopoda. Mollusca, coiling, spiral. morphogenetic regulation, growth .     

Some observations on shell-shape variation in North American populations of Nucella lapillus (L.)

This paper considers shell-shape variation in samples of the dog-whelk/dog-winkle, ucella lapillus , from the southern half of its North American range, between 41 and 46N, and compares it with the pattern seen in Europe. At the extreme southern limit of its American range, to the south of Cape Cod, the species exhibits features to be expected in an animal close to an environmental limit. It is generally rare and has a patchy distribution. There is little variation in the shell: almost all adult individuals have rather large, thick, white, elongated shells. This contrasts sharply with the situation in Portugal, at the southern limit in Europe, where the animals have small thin, coloured shells of intermediate shape.
Away from the marginal situation, north of Nahant (42^CN) in America, the species shows much the same range of variability in shell size, shape and colour on both sides of the Atlantic. Most populations appear to show the same pattern of shape variation in asociation with the exposure of their habitat to wave action. Animals from exposed sites tend to have shorter, squatter shells than their compatriots in shelter. However, in America as in some parts of Europe, there are occasional enclaves which do not fit the usual pattern. It is interesting to note that the form normally associated with extremely exposed shores from Brittany to Faroe in Europe is found in Atlantic Canada but is apparently absent from southern populations in both the U.S.A and the Iberian Peninsula.     

A new species of Gyraulus (Gastropoda: Planorbidae) from Ancient Lake Lugu,Yunnan-Guizhou Plateau,Southwest China

A new aberrant species of the planorbid genus Gyraulus, Gyraulus luguhuensis n. sp., is described from Lake Lugu (Lugu-hu, in Chinese), Southwest China. The generic assignment with Gyraulus is based on features of the genital anatomy that are characteristic for members of that genus, in particular the presence of a chitinized penial stylet. Gyraulus luguhuensis n. sp. differs from most other congeners by its large, thick shell with an elevated spire. Similarly, aberrant shells are known from congeners in other Ancient Lakes worldwide indicating a potentially convergent evolution of shell characteristics in exclusively lacustrine species. Gyraulus luguhuensis differs from other lacustrine Gyraulus species with similarly large shells in having a sub-terminal penis pore and an unkeeled shell.     

Geographical variation in shell shape of the pod razor shell Ensis siliqua (Bivalvia: Pharidae)

The present study assessed the existence of variation in the shell shape of the pod razor shell (Ensis siliqua) throughout its distributional range in the north-eastern Atlantic. Shells of E. siliqua caught at seven collecting sites (three in Portugal, three in Spain and one in Ireland) were studied by geometric morphometric methods, using both landmark- and contour-based methods. Both approaches (landmarks inside the valves and shell outline) discriminated the shells from Aveiro (centre of Portugal) and Strangford Lough (Ireland) from those caught in the nearby localities (remaining Portuguese and Spanish sites, maximum distance of 550 km by sea). Landmark analysis revealed that shells from Aveiro were more similar to shells from Ireland (~1,500 km far away). Contour analysis revealed that shells from Aveiro had a shape with a comparatively larger height-to-width ratio, whereas shells from Ireland showed a slightly more curved outline than in the remaining sites. Landmark- and contour-based methods provided coherent complementary information, confirming the usefulness of geometric morphometric analyses for discerning differences in shell shape among populations of E. siliqua. A brief review of previous applications of geometric morphometric methods to modern bivalve species is also provided.