Human papillomavirus infection in atrophic smears. A case report

BACKGROUND: Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection in atrophic smears can be misleading and may produce the diagnosis of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. CASE: A routine cervical smear in a 62-year-old female revealed an atrophic smear with nuclear changes suggestive of a high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL). An estrogen cream for topical vaginal use was prescribed. A new smear was collected seven days later and revealed koilocytosis but no evidence of HSIL. CONCLUSION: Koilocytosis is a cellular finding of mature epithelial cells. The use of estrogen produces maturation of HPV-infected basal cells, allowing a correct diagnosis of this disease in patients with atrophic smears.     

Goblet-like cells in atrophic vaginal smears and their histologic correlation. Possible confusion with endocervical cells.

The occurrence and origin of goblet-like cells seen between clusters of parabasal cells in atrophic vaginal smears were investigated. The goblet-like cells were cytologically identified in the vaginal smears from 23 (19.2%) of 120 patients whose smears showed an atrophic pattern, but without any inflammatory, dysplastic or malignant changes. Histologically, these cells were found in sections from 6 (18.8%) of 32 elderly women with atrophic vaginal epithelium. The goblet-like cells were situated among the squamous cells of the upper layer of the atrophic squamous epithelium from the vagina to the portio. These goblet-like cells in atrophic smears were initially misinterpreted as endocervical cells, which are regarded as a marker of smear adequacy in the cytologic screening for cancer of the uterine cervix. The correct interpretation of these goblet-like cells in smears from postmenopausal and elderly women is thus obviously important in assessing the adequacy of the sample for the detection of abnormal cells.     

Efficacy of Ki-67 antigen staining in Papanicolaou (Pap) smears in post-menopausal women with atypia—an audit

In cervical smears from post-menopausal women with mucosal atrophy it can be difficult to distinguish atrophic epithelial cell groups from neoplastic cell groups on cytomorphological criteria only. The consequence of post-menopausal atypia is that the woman is referred for a repeat smear after local oestrogen treatment or for colposcopy. We investigated whether immunocytochemical expression of Ki-67 (MIB-1) on the primary Papanicolaou-stained smear could be of any diagnostic help. Our data showed that negative Ki-67 expression is a very reliable indicator of a normal atrophic cell pattern, and by using this method on the original smear we were able to reduce the false-positive cytologic diagnoses by 86%.     

Atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance favor endometrial origin. Criteria for separating low grade endometrial adenocarcinoma from benign endometrial lesions

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate cytologic criteria for separating atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance favor endometrial origin (AGUS-EM), on Papanicolaou-stained (Pap) smears into favor benign and favor malignant categories. STUDY DESIGN: All patients who had a Pap smear diagnosis of AGUS-EM, not further qualified, followed by tissue follow-up were identified from the surgical pathology and cytopathology files from January 1992 through December 1996. The Pap smears were scored blindly for the presence or absence of 40 cytologic criteria, and univariate analysis was performed to determine which criteria were most indicative of malignancy by tissue follow-up. RESULTS: The presence of an atrophic smear, nuclear size greater than twice that of an intermediate cell nucleus and absence of clusters with irregular borders were highly indicative of adenocarcinoma, although other criteria were also helpful in identifying malignancy. CONCLUSION: There are no combinations of cytologic criteria that definitely separate AGUS-EM cases into those with benign or malignant findings on follow-up. However, some isolated criteria were useful in the differential diagnosis in a [table: see text] significant number of cases.     

Clinical value of repeat Pap smear at the time of colposcopy

OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical value of a repeat (second) Pap smear at the time of colposcopy in the management of patients with recent cytologic abnormalities. STUDY DESIGN: A study of paired Pap smears and their corresponding cervical biopsies during a two-year period, commencing in June 1996, was undertaken. Pap smears and cervical biopsies from 614 patients were evaluated in the Department of Pathology, Royal Darwin Hospital, Northern Territory, Australia. To maintain uniformity, the cytologic and histologic findings were assessed according to the Bethesda System. RESULTS: The original (first) Pap smears included 288 high grade and 326 low grade lesions. The second smears showed 200 high grade, 221 low grade, 167 normal and 26 unsatisfactory cases. Punch biopsies revealed 242 high grade, 300 low grade and 72 inflammatory/reactive lesions. The changes noted in the second Pap smears and in the punch biopsies in the group originally diagnosed as having high grade disease were generally less advanced. The second Pap smears and corresponding cervical punch biopsies showed more advanced changes in the group originally diagnosed as having low grade disease. Removal of part of the abnormal epithelium during the first Pap smear and the desire of the colposcopist not to damage the surface epithelium prior to performing a cervical biopsy may account for some of these findings. Sampling errors and morphological misinterpretation may explain some of the findings. CONCLUSION: In the second smears, new cases of high grade abnormality were discovered mainly in patients with low grade changes on the first smears. Therefore, a second Pap smear at the time of colposcopy is justifiable in the group with low grade changes on the first smear.     

Effects of tamoxifen on cervicovaginal smears from patients with breast cancer

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effect of tamoxifen on cervicovaginal epithelium and determine the value of cervicovaginal smears in identifying patients at risk for endometrial carcinoma. STUDY DESIGN: A group of 48 women with prior breast cancer were divided into three groups: A, tamoxifen-treated patients who developed endometrial carcinoma (n = 20); B, patients with endometrial cancer not treated with tamoxifen (n = 22); and C, tamoxifen-treated patients with no endometrial carcinoma (n = 16). A total of 114 cervicovaginal smears from these patients were evaluated for maturation index, histiocytes, benign and malignant endometrial cells, reactive cellular changes and microorganisms. All patients treated with tamoxifen had received doses of 10 mg twice daily. RESULTS: The maturation index was increased in tamoxifen-treated patients (A and C) versus nontreated patients (B) P < or = .001). The number of cases with endometrial cells was significantly higher in smears of treated patients who developed endometrial cancer (A) as compared to groups B and C (P = .01 and .02, respectively). Histiocytes were also significantly increased in the two groups that subsequently developed endometrial carcinoma (A and B) as compared to the group that did not (group C) (P = .02). There was no significant difference in the presence of reactive cellular changes between the three groups. CONCLUSION: Patients treated with tamoxifen exhibited a partial estrogenic effect in their smears regardless of whether they developed endometrial cancer. However, the presence of endometrial cells in the smears indicated a higher risk of endometrial adenocarcinoma.     

Relationship between the diagnosis of epithelial abnormalities and the composition of cervical smears

The significance of endocervical columnar cells as a high-quality parameter of cervical smears was studied. In a cohort of women with two successive screenings, the consistency of the cellular composition of the cervical smears and the relation between the cellular composition of the smears and the frequency of the diagnosis of abnormal epithelial changes was investigated. At the first screening, a significantly higher number of epithelial abnormalities was found in smears with endocervical columnar cells than in smears without endocervical columnar cells. A significantly higher number of abnormal epithelial changes was found on the second screening in smears from women whose smears from the first screening did not contain endocervical columnar cells than in smears from women whose smears from the first screening did contain endocervical columnar cells. The presence of endocervical cells should be considered a very important indicator of the quality of cervical smears. The chance of missing an abnormal epithelial change is increased in smears without endocervical columnar cells. When endocervical columnar cells are absent, the smear should be considered to be of unreliable quality and a repeat smear should be taken after a short interval, unless the absence of columnar cells can be satisfactorily explained.     

The influence of sample takers on the cellular composition of cervical smears

In a population-based cervical cancer screening program, the performances of five sample takers and their influence on the cellular composition of the smears and the numbers of epithelial abnormalities diagnosed were analyzed. As measured by the presence of endocervical columnar cells, there were remarkable variations in the quality of the smears between sample takers and between years of sampling. There was also a positive relationship between the presence of endocervical columnar cells in the smear and the number of epithelial abnormalities found. A lower quality of smear was reflected by a lower incidence of epithelial atypical changes found, both between sample takers and by a single sample taker over a period of time. These findings show that sample takers influence the cellular composition of smears and, therefore, the diagnostic outcome of smear screening. Their competence in executing their tasks must be frequently reviewed.     

Rapid review in cervical cytology: a retrospective review of cases detected on rapid review within a DGH cytology department and subsequent outcome

We retrospectively reviewed smears detected by rapid review within a district general hospital (DGH) laboratory over a period of 33 months and the subsequent histological or cytological outcome. Sixty-three cases had adequate follow-up data: 32 subsequently had two negative smears and 31 had a histological abnormality on subsequent biopsy. Twenty were high-grade lesions (CIN2, CIN3 or a glandular lesion) and eight of these were preceded by a low-grade smear abnormality. We reviewed and compared the pattern and distribution of smear abnormalities in these 63 cases. Abnormalities were often present within few cells (76%, n = 48 with 50 abnormal cells or less) or in micro-biopsies (27%, n = 17). There was no statistical difference in the pattern and distribution of smear abnormality between the rapid review-detected smears with a biopsy-proven abnormality and those with negative follow-up smears. Overall, the positive predictive value for high-grade CIN detected by rapid review (75%) was within NHSCSP achievable standards targets. This review of rapid review-detected abnormalities and the biopsy and cytological follow-up reiterates the importance of the method in cervical screening.     

A new,liquid-based cytology technique

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate a new liquid-based cytology technique, Papspin (Thermo Shandon, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, U.S.A.). STUDY DESIGN: Three thousand cervical samples were examined. Each cervix was sampled with a Cervex Brush (Roche, Oss, the Netherlands), used first for a Pap smear and afterwards for a Papspin. One cytospin was prepared from each vial. RESULTS: An identical rate of epithelial cell abnormalities (3.8%) was detected with the two methods. Diagnostic concordance was observed in 86% of the 114 cases. Differences in diagnoses occurred in 168 of 3,000 cases (5.6%) concerning fungal infection (22 cases), epithelial cell abnormalities (24 cases) and minimal differences within the nonneoplastic Bethesda category (122 cases). Endocervical cells were absent from 158 Papspins (5.3%) and 66 Pap smears (2.2%), while they were present in the respective Pap smear or Papspin. Seven Papspins were considered "satisfactory, but limited by ..." (SBLB) as compared to 33 Pap smears given the absence of endocervical cells. CONCLUSION: Discordances concerning epithelial cell abnormalities were observed in 24 of 3,000 cases (0.8%). Fungal infections were more easily diagnosed on Papspin. The absence of endocervical cells in 5.3% of Papspins is due to a bias of methodology. Quality improvement was evident on Papspin for SBLB specimens. HPV testing could be performed with good results.     

Atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance on cervical smears. A study with cytohistologic correlation.

OBJECTIVE: The incidence of endocervical adenocarcinoma has increased steadily over the past two decades. Since the Bethesda System was introduced, the diagnosis of atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance (AGUS) has also risen and now accounts for 0.46-1.83% of all cervical (Pap) smears. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the significance of a diagnosis of AGUS using cytohistologic correlation. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review of archival material from 1993 through 1996 identified 64 patients who had smears diagnosed as AGUS and had a subsequent surgical biopsy. The smears were reviewed and cytologic features analyzed and correlated with the histologic diagnosis. RESULTS: On biopsy, 3 (5%) of the 64 cases showed endocervical adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS) (1 case with invasive adenocarcinoma also), 14 (22%) had a benign glandular lesion (endocervical polyp, tubal metaplasia, microglandular hyperplasia, reactive changes), 35 (54%) had squamous intraepithelial lesion (SIL) (15 diagnosed on the original smear), and 12 (19%) had no abnormality. Among the cytologic criteria evaluated, feathering (P = .01), palisading (P < .001) and chromatin clearing (P = .002) were shown to have a significant association with the histopathologic diagnosis of AIS/adenocarcinoma. These features were also useful in distinguishing AIS/adenocarcinoma from SIL and benign glandular changes from AIS/adenocarcinoma but not benign/reactive glandular changes from SIL. CONCLUSION: A diagnosis of AGUS correlated with a clinically significant lesion in the majority of cases. Squamous dysplasia (SIL) was the most common lesion identified. The presence of feathering, nuclear palisading and chromatin clearing increased the likelihood of a histologic diagnosis of AIS/adenocarcinoma.     

Age- and hormone-related changes in vaginal smear patterns in the gray-tailed vole, Microtus canicaudus

Female voles, Microtus canicaudus, exhibited age-related changes in vaginal smear patterns when isolated from males after weaning. Between 30 and 50 days of age, nearly all females exhibited persistently leucocytic vaginal smears. By 90-120 days, most females showed vaginal cyclicity with alternating predominance of leucocytes, nucleated epithelial cells or cornified epithelial cells. Most females examined between 150 and 200 days of age exhibited persistent vaginal cornification. The vaginal cyclicity seen in females between 90 and 120 days was not a reflection of cyclic ovulatory changes; plasma progesterone concentrations remained constant, regardless of age or vaginal smear pattern, and corpora lutea were never seen in unmated females. Although progesterone concentrations did not differ among vaginal smear patterns of 120-day-old females, plasma oestrogen values were highest in females exhibiting vaginal cornification.     

Osteopenia and osteoporosis can be predicted from Pap test

OBJECTIVE: To determine sensitivity and specificity of Pap tests for osteopenia and osteoporosis using bone mineral density (BMD) with dual x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) as the reference standard. STUDY DESIGN: DXA measurement was performed on 136 routine Pap smears. Results of DXA measurement were expressed in T-scores, indicating degree of deviation compared to a young adult population of same age and gender. Smears were grouped into atrophic and mature cell patterns. Using a stereologic analysis, mean areas of squamous cells, their nuclei and their cytoplasm were estimated. RESULTS: There was significant positive correlation between cell area and T-score (p < 0.001), as well as between cytoplasm area and T-score (p < 0.001). There was no significant relationship between nucleus area and T-score (p > 0.05). Mean T-scores of patients with atrophic cells were significantly lower than mean T-scores of patients with mature cell patterns (p < 0.001). The group including patients with atrophic or mature cells had a sensitivity of 61.4% and specificity of 86.4%, with positive predictive value of 95.9% in detecting patients with osteopenia or osteoporosis. CONCLUSION: Women with atrophic smear pattern are susceptible to osteopenia or osteoporosis; many cases could be detected with routine Pap test without additional costs.     

Benign cellular changes in Pap smears. Causes and significance

OBJECTIVE: We reviewed consecutive cases classified as benign cellular changes (BCC) over a four-month period. STUDY DESIGN: Cases classified as BCC were retrieved from the cytology files. A search was carried out to identify the previous Pap smears and concomitant cervical biopsies. RESULTS: One thousand one hundred three cases (23% of our gynecologic smears) were classified as BCC. Ninety-two patients (8.3%) underwent concurrent cervical biopsies. Specific infections accounted for 8% of BCC cases; reactive changes accounted for 92%. Of the biopsy specimens, 8.3% had no significant pathologic change. The most common biopsy diagnoses were cervicitis (31.5%), immature squamous metaplasia (16.3%) and reserve cell hyperplasia (10.8%). Miscellaneous benign diagnoses accounted for 21.7%. Cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 1/human papillomavirus (HPV) was present in 14% of cases. All patients with biopsy diagnoses of CIN 1 had at least two previous abnormal Pap smears. Previous biopsy reports were available for review in 127 (12%) of the 1,103 patients. Of these 127 cases, 53.5% had a previous diagnosis of CIN/HPV; 9.4% had invasive carcinoma. A benign diagnosis was reported in 36.5%. CONCLUSION: The majority of BCC cases are due to reactive and inflammatory processes. In patients with a previous history of CIN, BCC may be of some significance. In patients with no significant prior cervical abnormalities, a Pap smear classified as BCC represents a reactive process.     

Cytohistologic correlation between AGUS and biopsy-detected lesions in postmenopausal women

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate histologic findings in patients aged 50 and older whose cervical smears revealed atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance (AGUS). STUDY DESIGN: Computerized records spanning a four-year period were retrospectively analyzed. Thirty patients over age 50 had cervical smears interpreted as AGUS and had follow-up biopsies within 12 months following the abnormal smear. The most important histologic diagnosis from the biopsy specimens was correlated with the subcategory of the cervical smear. RESULTS: Five smears interpreted as AGUS, favor reactive, revealed abnormal histology in four cases: three endometrial polyps and one squamous carcinoma. Two smears interpreted as AGUS, favor dysplasia, revealed squamous intraepithelial lesions on biopsy in both cases. Seventeen smears interpreted as AGUS, favor endometrial cells, revealed abnormal histology in 13 cases: 1 endocervical polyp, 6 endometrial polyps, 3 endometrial hyperplasias and 3 adenomyosis. Six patients with smears interpreted as AGUS, unclassifiable, revealed abnormal histology in five cases: two endocervical polyps, one endometrial polyp, one endometrial carcinoma and one ovarian carcinoma. CONCLUSION: The presence of AGUS in cervical smears from women over 50 was highly predictive of abnormal lesions detected by histologic examination. Although three cancers were detected on histologic follow-up, the most common lesions detected were endometrial polyps.     

Atypical glandular cells in cervical smears: histological correlation and a suggested plan of management based on age of the patient in a low-resource setting

Objectives:  To perform an audit of all smears reported as atypical glandular cells (AGC) using the Bethesda system (TBS) 2001.
Methods:  A total of 18 376 cervical smears were screened from January 2005 to June 2007, of which 65 cases were reported as AGC. Follow-up histology was available in 31 cases (47.7%), in whom a detailed cytological/histological correlation was carried out.
Results:  AGC constituted 0.35% of all Pap smears. Follow-up histology was normal or benign in 20 cases, whereas a squamous or glandular abnormality was seen in 11 cases. Squamous abnormalities included one case each of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN)1, CIN2 and CIN3 and five cases of squamous cell carcinoma. All glandular epithelial abnormalities were endometrial in origin and included two endometrial adenocarcinomas and one uterine serous carcinoma. Neither in situ nor invasive adenocarcinoma of the endocervix was observed. Review of smears and reclassification as AGC, not otherwise specified and favour neoplasia revealed a higher proportion of abnormality in the latter group, reaffirming the utility of subtyping. The median age of women with AGC was 41 years. The outcome was analysed with respect to the median age. In women aged equal or more than 40 years, AGC reflected a high-grade squamous or glandular epithelial abnormality in 50% of cases compared with none in those less than 40 years old ( P  = 0.010).
Conclusion:  The age of the woman as well as the subtype of atypical glandular cells influences outcome and hence must be taken into consideration while formulating an acceptable management strategy in these women in a low-resource setting.     

Vaginal intraepithelial neoplasia and the Pap smear

OBJECTIVE: To assess the sensitivity of the vaginal smear cytologic examination in detecting vaginal intraepithelial neoplasia (VAIN) and to evaluate the cytologic findings of cases of VAIN. STUDY DESIGN: Cases with a histologic diagnosis of VAIN were identified from the Barnes-Jewish Hospital South and North Campus over a period of five and nine years, respectively. Only posthysterectomy patients with a tissue biopsy diagnosis of VAIN and with a vaginal smear obtained within three months of the biopsy were included in the study. Pertinent clinical information was obtained by reviewing the medical records. Two pathologists reviewed the pathologic samples. RESULTS: Thirty-five vaginal smears from 31 posthysterectomy patients were included in the study. The mean age was 57 years (range, 29-84). The cytologic diagnoses of smears from patients with VAIN included: high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (19 cases), low grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (10 cases), atypical squamous cells of uncertain significance (5 cases) and negative for malignancy (1 case). CONCLUSION: The sensitivity of the vaginal smear cytologic examination in detecting VAIN is 83%. Obscuring inflammation contributed to false negative diagnoses in two cases.     

The effect of tamoxifen on cervical squamous maturation in Papanicolaou stained cervical smears of post-menopausal women

Using cervical smears obtained as part of routine gynaecological examinations, a retrospective study of the effects of the drug tamoxifen on squamous epithelial maturation of the cervix of post-menopausal women being treated for advanced breast cancer was made. The degree of squamous epithelial maturation was quantitated by using the Maturation Index and the Maturation Value. Although tamoxifen is a synthetic, non-steroidal compound classified as anti-oestrogenic, the findings indicate that this drug commonly produces a level of squamous maturation indicative of oestrogenic stimulation in Papanicolaou stained cervical smears from post-menopausal patients receiving this drug. Knowledge of the oestrogenic effect of tamoxifen in the cervix can obviate clinical concern about endometrial carcinoma.     

Benign glandular cells in posthysterectomy vaginal smears: the incidence is higher than expected

In this study, we have investigated the frequency and clinical significance of glandular cells in posthysterectomy vaginal smears. The slides of vaginal cuff smears of 290 patients were reviewed. The glandular cells were categorized into three groups: (1) squamous metaplastic-like cells; (2) columnar endocervical-like cells; and (3) small round cuboidal cells. Glandular cells were found in 39 (13%) of the 290 vaginal smears. Group 1 type cells were seen in 76% (n = 30), group 2 type cells in 38% (n = 15) and group 3 type cells in 47% (n = 19) of the smears. In 19 (48%) of the smears combination of two or three groups were seen. The presence of glandular cells showed a strong association with inflammation/repair as a background finding in the smears. No correlation could be found between the presence of atrophy and history of chemotherapy or radiotherapy. Apart from these there was a prominent increase in reporting benign glandular cells after the application of the current Bethesda 2001 reporting criteria in our laboratory. As a result our study showed that the finding of glandular cells in posthysterectomy vaginal smears is more frequent than expected and most of them could be related to inflammatory and regenerative processes in the absence of a clearly identified underlying cause.     

Regular audit of colposcopic biopsies from women with a mildly dyskaryotic or borderline cervical smear results in fewer cases of CINIII

Two years after introducing mandatory review of cases in which the cervical smear was discrepant with subsequent colposcopic or histological finding, the predictive accuracy of a first abnormal smear and the need for treatment were analysed. The results were compared with performance figures prior to this form of audit policy. Over 12 months 415 women referred for colposcopy were studied. Three per cent of patients with a single borderline smear and 6% with mild dyskaryosis had cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade III (CINIII) revealed in histopathological examinations after colposcopy. Only 25% with a borderline smear and 33% with mild dyskaryosis required treatment. Of women with moderate dyskaryosis, 18% had a biopsy showing CINIII and 46% were treated. Of women with severe dyskaryosis in their cervical smear, 61% were shown to have CINIII or invasive cancer on biopsy and 90% were treated. Regular audit improved cytological prediction of grade of epithelial abnormality found on biopsy, allowing accurate, safe surveillance for minor smear abnormalities.