Plant regeneration from seedling explants of green bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L) via organogenesis

Green bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) plants were regenerated from 3-day old seedling explants via organogenesis. The explants contained a cotyledon and a small portion (2–3 mm) of embryonic axis split in half. Explants were cultured on a defined medium containing glutamine as the sole nitrogen source. A ring of meristematic tissue was produced at the base of the axillary bud located at the cotyledonary node. The meristematic tissue was produced only if the axillary bud was present together with the cotyledon in the explant. Buds and shoots developed from the meristematic ring. Selected shoots produced roots when excised from the cluster of buds and transferred to root induction medium. Rooted shoots (plantlets) grew well and produced viable seeds when grown in the greenhouse. Histological studies revealed the origin of buds from the peripheral layers of the meristematic ring.Production of buds and shoots was a continuous process, so that new shoots could be removed from the explant for plantlet production every 10–14 days. With the cultivar Dark Red Kidney, an average of 49 buds and 8 shoots were regenerated per explant by 30 days after culture initiation. Sixty-seven percent of the shoots produced roots, and 90–95% of the plantlets survived greenhouse acclimatization to produce healthy plants.     

Thidiazuron-induced morphogenesis in tamarind seedlings

Summary Germination of tamarind seeds in medium containing thidiazuron (TDZ) resulted in induction of nodular protrusions in and around the cotyledonary node meristem. The structures developed radially in well-defined circles and subsequently spread towards the cotyledonary bridge and also in the proximal part of the hypocotyl. The structures developed into shoots on transfer to medium devoid of growth regulators. Histological studies revealed that the protrusions initiated from the nodal meristem and extended to the non-meristematic region between the two meristems and also in the proximal part of the hypocotyl in seedlings germinated in 9.08 μM TDZ. Newly formed cell layers and less-differentiated meristematic protrusions were also seen. With the increase in the distance from the meristem, the buds were less differentiated; in the proximal part of the hypocotyl only the multiple layers of meristematic cells were noted. With extension of the period of incubation, the TDZ-induced meristematic activity extended laterally in circles towards the neighboring region. The radial spread of the meristematic activity from the center of the nodal meristem was also evident at 18.16 μM TDZ. From the pattern of the morphogenic development and the histological studies it may be hypothesized that in tamarind, TDZ influences the existing meristems specifically. Subsequently de novo organogenesis is triggered in the neighboring cells.     

Rapid in vitro production of true-to-type plants of Pogostemon heyneaus through dedieferentiated axillary buds

Summary Rapid propagation of Pogostemon heyneanus Benth. (Lamiaceae) was accomplished through culture of node explants on Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium containing N ⁶-benzyladenine (BA). Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) and gas chromatographic (GC) analysis of in vitro-derived progenies were used to determine the true-to-type nature of in vitro-derived plantlets. At the optimum level of BA (2.22μM), the axillary buds underwent a degree of dedifferentiation to become small globular green masses from which a mean of 17.1 shoots were developed within 40d. Retaining the culture without subenlture enhanced the number of shoots (>30 shoots). Inereased callus proliferation was observed at higher concentrations of BA in concomitance with a reduction in number of shoots. However, prolonged culture without subculture (more than 60d) initiated 25–30 shoot buds from the callus. Culture of node segments excised from in vitro shoots on fresh medium with optimal BA (2.22μM) exhibited a similar response, but with an increase of shoots (mean of 26.3 shoots per node) within 40d. Subeulture of shoot clumps on half-strength MS basal medium resulted in elongation (more than 4cm) of most of the shoots along with the development of new shoots. Shoots developed were rooted most successfully on half-strength MS medium with 4.9 μM indole-3-butyric acid (IBA). Plantlets derived from the best rooting medium established in small cups exhibited 95% survival. Plantlets successfully established in field conditions exhibited morphological characteristies identical to the source plant. The RAPD profile of the in vitro-derived plants and source plant, using 10 random primers, was similar. The gas chromatogram of the extracted oils from in vitro-derived plants and the source plant showed similar patterns.     

Alginate encapsulation of axillary buds of Ocimum americanum L. (hoary basil), O. Basilicum L. (sweet basil), O. Gratissimum L. (shrubby basil), and O. Sanctum. L. (sacred basil)

Summary Propagation and conservation of four pharmaceutically important herbs, Ocimum americanum L. syn. O. canum Sims. (hoary basil); O basilicum L. (swett basil); O. gratissimum L. (shrubby basil); and O. sanctum L. (sacred basil) was attempted using synthetic seed technology. Synthetic seeds were produced by encapsulating axillary vegetative buds harvested from garden-grown plants of these four Ocimum species in calcium alginate gel. The gel contained Murashige and Skoog (MS) nutrients and 1.1-4.4 μM benzyladenine (BA). Shoots emerged from the encapsulated buds on all six planting media tested. However, the highest frequency shoot emergence and maximum number of shoots per bud were recorded on media containing BA. Of the six planting media tested, both shoot and root emergence from the encapsulated buds in a single step was recorded on growth regulator-free MS medium as well as on vermi-compost moistened with halfstrength MS medium. Rooted shoots were retrieved from the encapsulated buds of O. americanum, O. basilicum, and O. sanctum on these two media, whereas shoots of O. gratissimum failed to root. The encapsulated buds could be stored for 60 d at 4°C. Plants retrieved from the encapsulated buds were hardened off and established in soil.     

In vitro adventitious shoot formation from embryonic and cotyledonary tissues of Pinus brutia Ten.

Adventitious buds were induced when isolated whole embryos, and excised cotyledons from treated seeds of Calabrian pine (Pinus brutia Ten.) were cultured on a cytokinin-supplemented medium. The adventitious buds formed directly from the cotyledons. The highest number of bud primordia were formed, with both embryos and excised cotyledons, after 6 weeks on a BAP — supplemented Schenk and Hildebrandt medium under a 16 h photoperiod. The buds, when separated and maintained individually on a full-strength medium without growth regulators, developed into well-formed shoots within 4 weeks. The average number of harvested shoots obtained (>1 cm in height) per seed over 24 weeks was 55; however, a maximum number of 152 shoots was obtained from one individual over the same period. The shoot forming capacity of the meristematic tissue was not lost after seven harvests.     

Seasonal culture of dormant reproductive buds ofSalix tetrasperma: Analysis of the flowering process

The flowering process in a female tree ofSalix tetrasperma was analysed by culturing its reproductive buds at different developmental stages during the dormant period on a chemically defined medium and examining the nature of sprouts produced by them. Buds at the upper eight nodes of the actively growing shoots developing in an acropetal sequence were cultured in separate lots. While all the buds collected from the 1st and 2nd nodes of the branches from the top downwards were vegetative and produced shoots, a considerable number of those collected from the 3rd and 4th nodes were reproductively determined and produced catkins. All the buds obtained from the 5th node and below were reproductive. Reproductive buds were cultured at regular time intervals during the dormant period. Freshly formed buds cultured in March during the spring growth flush produced catkins and were therefore reproductively determined. However, such a determination was not tantamount to flowering, as the floral meristems present in the axils of catkin bracts remained quiescent. Floral meristems of the buds cultured during April to August developed into small vegetative shoots. This was followed by the crucial period during September to December when the hitherto vegetative sprouts of the floral meristems showed a gradual transition into ovaries (female flowers) resulting in fertile catkins. Catkins produced from buds cultured in January and February produced well-developed ovaries.     

Control of pattern of regenerant differentiation and plantlet production from leaflet segments of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Azadirachta indica</Emphasis> A. Juss. (neem)

A process with controlled pattern of regenerant differentiation from leaflet segments leading to production of cloned plants of a 40-year-old tree of Azadirachta indica was developed. A two-step procedure was adopted for containing intervening callusing during regenerant differentiation using modified Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium, where in the first step the explants were subjected to pulse treatments having higher concentration of 6-benzylaminopurine (BAP), while in the second step they were cultured in one-tenth of the initial concentrations of BAP. In the present case, simultaneous differentiation of two types of morphogenetic structures, that is, shoot buds and the meristematic nodules was observed. However, differentiation of higher number of desirable regenerants—the shoot buds and a few meristematic nodules, rather than vice-versa could be controlled by increasing both, the concentration of BAP in pulse treatment and the duration of pulse treatment. In the optimum treatment, where the explants were exposed to 8.88 μM BAP and 81.43 μM adenine hemisulphate for 5 days followed by their transfer to 0.88 μM BAP and 81.43 μM adenine hemisulphate, on an average, 17.4 shoot buds and only 1.6 meristematic nodules were formed from a leaflet. On subculturing, the shoot buds developed into shoots, whereas the meristematic nodules produced three kinds of organized structures that too in varied proportions. Multiplication of shoots was sustained in proliferation medium supplemented with 1.11 μM BAP, 1.43 μM indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and 135.72 μM adenine hemisulphate. The isolated shoots were rooted and complete plantlets were transferred to potted soil with 100% survival.     

Sugar cane buds as an efficient explant for plantlet regeneration

An efficient and reproducible protocol for regeneration of plantlets at a high frequency was developed by using sugar cane buds. Disinfected buds were firstly submerged in ethanol sodium hypochlorite solution with 0.1 % polyvinylpyrrolidone, 1.5 % ascorbic acid and 1.75 % citric acid as antioxidants and subsequently treated with solution of agrimicin:captan (1:1). The upper stalk segment was better to obtain bud in vitro culture compared to lower segments. The medium for induction of multiple shoots consisted of Murashige and Skoog basal medium (MS) supplemented with 2 mg dm⁻³ thidiazuron and 1 mg dm⁻³ naphthalene acetic acid. An average of 24 shoots per bud was obtained for cv. Mex 68-P23 within four weeks and 29 shoots for cv. MY 55-14 within six weeks. Indole-3-butyric acid induced more roots in both cultivars compared to the untreated plantlets. Plantlets transferred to soil showed normal growth with up to four axilliary buds in each node. It was concluded that the germplasm obtained through the above mentioned technique generated stalks with more buds in each node which would give farmers more vegetative material for plantations in field with 100 % germination.This research was funded by Fundacion Produce Chiapas A.C. (Mexico).     

Callus induction and plantlet regeneration inCichorium intybus L.: II. Effect of different hormonal treatments

Summary Expiants ofCichorium intybus L. storage roots were grownin vitro on a modified Heller's medium lacking auxins and cytokinins, or supplemented with auxins (either 2,4-D or NAA) alone or with a cytokinin (kinetin) or auxin and kinetin combinations in different concentrations. The morphogenetic responses of root explants varied with the different hormonal treatments. The best response for callus growth was obtained in presence of 2,4-D. On the contrary, kinetin alone was very effective for shoot induction, increasing the formation of adventitious buds (up to 100% of the explants) in respect to control (hormone-free medium). NAA induced either shoot differentiation (in a medium frequency) or root formation. Expiants excised from root zones near to apex, which showed on hormone-free medium a very low regenerative capacity (lower than proximal zones of the root), responded to kinetin by increasing significantly the number of shoots from adventitious buds.Cytological analyses in developing primary calli showed, in all media, high incidence of amitotic phenomena confirmed by DNA cytophotometry in calli at different growth stages. The histological analysis demonstrated the formation of meristematic growth centers on the organogenesis inducing media and the subsequent development of these meristemoids as shoot (or root) apices in the callus mass.The results are discussed in comparison with previous observations of the authors inCichorium intybus (Caffaro et al. 1982) and in relation to the action of hormonal treatments on callus formation and organogenesis. The cytological and histological results are also discussed in relation to the hormonal composition of the medium.     

Shoot bud regeneration from different explants of Bacopa monniera (L.) Wettst. by trimethoprim and bavistin

A mass in vitro propagation system devoid of growth regulators for Bacopa monniera (L.) Wettst., a traditional Indian medicinal plant, has been developed. Direct shoot bud regeneration was induced by culturing internode and leaf explants on Murashige and Skoog's (MS) medium supplemented with an antibiotic (trimethoprim) or a fungicide (bavistin). Bavistin showed a marked cytokinin-like activity, as evident from high number of shoot buds induced in node, internode and leaf explants. Optimum adventitious shoot buds induction occurred at 300 mg/l bavistin from internode explants. In vitro regenerated shoots were elongated and rooted before transferred to field with 85% survival. The regeneration protocol developed in this study illustrates the usefulness of additives for mass propagation and germplasm conservation of B. monniera.Authors Vaibhav Tiwari and Kavindra Nath Tiwari contributed equally to this work     

Optimization of in vitro multiple shoot clump induction and plantlet regeneration of Kentucky bluegrass (Poa pratensis)

An efficient protocol for Kentucky bluegrass (Poa pratensis L.) in vitro culture was established using shoot apices of seedlings as explants. The optimal procedure of this protocol for majority of the genotypes was that meristematic cell clumps and small calluses were firstly induced from the bases of explants on initial culture medium supplemented with 0.9 μM 2,4-d and 8.9 μM 6-BA for 20 d, then were separated and transferred to shoot clumps induction medium containing 8.9 μM 6-BA for the formation of multiple shoot clumps. The percentage of multiple shoot clumps and numbers of shoots per clump were deeply related with the combinations of different plant growth regulators, duration of initial culture, the intensity of illumination and genotypes. Histological observation of the induced explants revealed that the meristematic cell clumps were produced from repeated division of the cortical cells and original meristematic primodium cells of explants, and the multiple shoots were formed via organogenesis pathway in the meristematic cell regions of cultures on shoot clumps induction medium. In this study, plantlets were efficiently regenerated on large scale from seven cultivars of Kentucky bluegrass. Hence the meristematic cell clumps and small calluses in this protocol could be considered good targets for genetic transformation of Kentucky bluegrass.     

利用微嫁接技术促进麻疯树再生不定芽的生长

该研究以麻疯树种子实生苗的小芽和芽条为接穗,以带有胚根的实生苗下胚轴为砧木进行无菌微嫁接,试图建立新的有效微嫁接方法,解决农杆菌介导的麻疯树遗传转化体系中再生的转化不定芽难以顺利发育成完整植株的问题。结果表明:(1)抗生素对嫁接苗的生长有显著的抑制作用。(2)进行微嫁接所用砧木的苗龄以5d为宜。(3)进行微嫁接时适宜采用的砧木类型为带有部分胚根的下胚轴。(4)嫁接苗在0.3mg/L IBA+2mg/L谷氨酰胺+1/2MS培养基上的生长效果最好。(5)嫁接苗的移栽成活率最高可达76.40%。(6)以小芽或芽条为接穗的嫁接苗均可正常生长。该研究建立的麻疯树微嫁接体系,为解决麻疯树转化不定芽或芽条生长发育困难的问题提供了一条新的途径。     

Morphogenic response of the alginate-encapsulated axillary buds from in vitro shoot cultures of six mulberries

Axillary buds obtained from in vitro shoot cultures of six mulberries (Morus alba L., M. australis Poir., M. bombycis Koidz., M. cathyana Hemsl., M. latifolia Poir., and M. nigra L.) were encapsulated in calcium alginate hydrogel containing Murashige and Skoog (1962) nutrients (MS) and 4.4 μM benzyladenine (BA). Morphogenic response of encapsulated buds to various planting media such as MS medium + 4.4 μM BA, MS basal medium, soilrite mix + half-strength MS medium, garden soil + half-strength MS medium, soilrite mix + tap water and garden soil + tap water was evaluated. Encapsulated buds of M. alba, M. bombycis, M. latifolia and M. nigra exhibited shoot development in each of the six media tested whereas that of M. australis and M. cathyana responded only to the first four media. Analysis of variance revealed that the planting medium exhibited the greatest influence on shoot development. Of the six planting media evaluated, shoot development was highest in MS medium containing 4.4 μM BA and lowest in garden soil moistened with water. Of the six Morus species studied, one-step regeneration, i.e. both shoot and root formation, was recorded in M. alba, M. bombycis and M. latifolia. Rooted shoots were retrieved from encapsulated buds of these species on all planting media tested except the one that contained BA. Root development was significantly affected by the planting medium and the plant species with planting medium contributing the maximum amount (82%) of the total variation observed. Of the five planting media tested, the percentage of root development was highest in MS basal medium. Of the six Morus species studied, the best shoot and root development was observed in M. alba. Encapsulated buds of M. bombycis, M. latifolia and M. nigra stored for 90 days and those of M. alba, M. australis and M. cathyana for 60 days at 4 °C still regenerated shoots. Plants regenerated from the encapsulated buds were hardened off and transferred to soil. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Effects of the growth retardant paclobutrazol on large-scale micropropagation of daylily (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hemerocallis</Emphasis> spp.)

Summary Meristematic clusters were induced from daylily scape explants (pedicel-scape junction) in the presence of the growth retardant Paclobutrazol on semisolid agar medium. Liquid shake culture was used to proliferate meristematic clusters. Highly efficient regeneration of adventitious shoots occurred on clusters after subculture on a 0.8% agar strength semisolid medium with the addition of activated charcoal. Paclobutrazol and sucrose levels in the media were found to significantly affect starch accumulation, growth value, and dry weight percentage of liquid-cultured meristematic clusters. The use of liquid shake cultures for mass proliferation of meristematic clusters followed by regeneration of adventitious shoots on semisolid agar culture could be an efficient system for large-scale micropropagation of daylily.     

Simple bioreactors for mass propagation of plants

Bioreactors provide a rapid and efficient plant propagation system for many agricultural and forestry species, utilizing liquid media to avoid intensive manual handling. Large-scale liquid cultures have been used for micropropagation through organogenesis or somatic embryogenesis pathways. Various types of bioreactors with gas-sparged mixing are suitable for the production of clusters of buds, meristems or protocorms. A simple glass bubble-column bioreactor for the proliferation of ornamental and vegetable crop species resulted in biomass increase of 3 to 6-fold in 3–4 weeks. An internal loop bioreactor was used for asparagus, celery and cucumber embryogenic cultures. However, as the biomass increased, the mixing and circulation were not optimal and growth was reduced. A disposable pre-sterilized plastic bioreactor (2–5-l volume) was used for the proliferation of meristematic clusters of several ornamental, vegetable and woody plant species. The plastic bioreactor induced minimal shearing and foaming, resulting in an increase in biomass as compared to the glass bubble-column bioreactor. A major issue related to the use of liquid media in bioreactors is hyperhydricity, that is, morphogenic malformation. Liquid cultures impose stress signals that are expressed in developmental aberrations. Submerged tissues exhibit oxidative stress, with elevated concentrations of reactive oxygen species associated with a change in antioxidant enzyme activity. These changes affect the anatomy and physiology of the plants and their survival. Malformation was controlled by adding growth retardants to decrease rapid proliferation. Growth retardants ancymidol or paclobutrazol reduced water uptake during cell proliferation, decreased vacuolation and intercellular spaces, shortened the stems and inhibited leaf expansion, inducing the formation of clusters. Using a two-stage bioreactor process, the medium was changed in the second stage to a medium lacking growth retardants to induce development of the meristematic clusters into buds or somatic embryos. Cluster biomass increased 10–15-fold during a period of 25–30 days depending on the species. Potato bud clusters cultured in 1.5 1 of medium in a 2-l capacity bioreactor, increased during 10–30 days. Poplar in vitro roots regenerated buds in the presence of thidiazuron (TDZ); the biomass increased 12-fold in 30 days. Bioreactor-regenerated clusters were separated with a manual cutter, producing small propagule units that formed shoots and initiated roots. Clusters of buds or meristematic nodules with reduced shoots, as well as arrested leaf growth, had less distortion and were optimal for automated cutting and dispensing. In tuber-, bulb- and corm-producing plants, growth retardants and elevated sucrose concentrations in the media were found to enhance storage organ formation, providing a better propagule for transplanting or storage. Bioreactor-cultures have several advantages compared with agar-based cultures, with a better control of the contact of the plant tissue with the culture medium, and optimal nutrient and growth regulator supply, as well as aeration and medium circulation, the filtration of the medium and the scaling-up of the cultures. Micropropagation in bioreactors for optimal plant production will depend on a better understanding of plant responses to signals from the microenvironment and on specific culture manipulation to control the morphogenesis of plants in liquid cultures.     

Comparative studies of cytokinins on in vitro propagation of Bacopa monniera

A mass in vitro propagation system for Bacopa monniera (L.) Wettst. (Scrophulariaceae), a medicinally important plant, has been developed. A range of cytokinins have been investigated for multiple shoot induction with node, internode and leaf explants. Of the four cytokinins (6-benzyladenine, thidiazuron, kinetin and 2-isopentenyladenine) tested thidiazuron (6.8 μM) and 6-benzyladenine (8.9 μM) proved superior to other treatments. Optimum adventitious shoot buds induction occurred at 6.8 μM thidiazuron where an average of 93 shoot buds were produced in leaf explants after 7 weeks of incubation. However, subculture of leaf explants on medium containing 2.2 μM benzyladenine yielded a higher number (129.1) of adventitious shoot buds by the end of third subculture. The percentage shoot multiplication (100%) as well as the number of shoots per explant remained the high during the first 3 subculture cycles, facilitating their simultaneous harvest for rooting. In vitro derived shoots were elongated on growth regulator-free MS medium and exhibited better rooting response on medium containing 4.9 μM IBA. After a hardening phase of 3 weeks, there was an almost 100% transplantation success in the field. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Adventitious shoot formation in cultures of 30-year-old Larix decidua,L. leptolepis,L. eurolepis,and L. laricina trees

Primordial shoot explants excised from buds of one Larix decidua tree, about 30 years old, produced more adventitious buds, elongating into shoots, when grown on half strength Litvay medium than when grown on other basal media. Thidiazuron and N₆-benzyladenine (BA) were equally effective in adventitious bud induction. In a comparative study of 30-year-old L. decidua, L. leptolepis, L. eurolepis, and L. laricina trees, explants from L. eurolepis and L. decidua produced a high number of cultures with adventitious buds that elongated into shoots; those from L. leptolepis were less productive, and those from L. laricina failed to form adventitious buds. The highest response was obtained with material collected in August and September, and in March and April; the lowest response occurred in explants from the October collection.     

Direct shoot regeneration from node,internode, hypocotyl and embryo explants of Withania somnifera

In vitro studies were initiated with Withania somnifera (L.) Dun. for rapid micropropagation of selected chemotypes using nodes, internodes, hypocotyls and embryo explants. Direct regeneration of shoot buds was observed in MS basal medium supplemented with various concentrations of either benzyladenine (BA) or thidiazouron (TDZ) depending on the explant. Nodal explants formed multiple shoots both from pre-existing and de novo buds on Murashige and Skoog's medium (MS) containing 0.1–5.0 mg l⁻¹ BA and a ring of de novo shoot buds on MS medium containing 0.2 and 0.3 mg l⁻¹ TDZ. Internodal explants formed shoot buds on MS with 1.0 and 5.0 mg l⁻¹ BA while the hypocotyl explants gave rise to multiple shoots only on MS with 0.5 mg l⁻¹ BA. Isolated embryos gave rise to many shoot buds on MS with 0.2 and 0.3 mg l⁻¹ TDZ. The shoot buds elongated and rooted either on MS medium with 0.01 mg l⁻¹ BA or on half strength MS medium lacking growth regulators, which depended upon the growth regulator used in the shoot bud induction medium. Except for the embryo-derived plantlets, all other plantlets could be acclimatized with 100% success. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Floral induction and development in Phalaenopsis in vitro

Adventitious shoots formed from nodal sections of floral-stalks of Phalaenopsis Pink Leopard Petra that had been propagated on Hyponex medium with 6-benzyladenine (BA). After subculturing adventitious shoots on Vacin-Went medium with BA, more than 70% of the shoots formed floral buds, and 10% of the floral buds flowered in 9-month-old shoots. Floral buds were not formed on the adventitious shoots cultured on Vacin-Went medium lacking BA. A high concentration of total nitrogen inhibited the development of floral buds, and low-temperature treatments failed to induce the formation of floral buds in vitro.     

Regeneration and micrografting of lentil shoots

Summary A protocol for regeneration and micrografting of shoots of lentil (Lens culinaris Medik) was developed. Multiple shoots (4–5) were regenerated from cotyledonary node explants on Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium containing 8.8 μM 6-benzylaminopurine. In vitro regenerated shoots were micrografted on rootstocks with 96% efficiency. The successful grafts were transplanted to pots in Redi-earth^TM, hardened off and were grown to maturity with 100% success. The success of the micrografting was independent of the nature and concentration of growth regulator used in shoot initiation medium and the time period for induction of shoots. The protocol was successful with several cultivars of lentil. The advantages of micrografting over in vitro rooting are discussed.