A Mutation in the N Domain of Escherichia coli Lon Stabilizes Dodecamers and Selectively Alters Degradation of Model Substrates

Escherichia coli Lon, an ATP-dependent AAA⁺ protease, recognizes and degrades many different substrates, including the RcsA and SulA regulatory proteins. More than a decade ago, the E240K mutation in the N domain of Lon was shown to prevent degradation of RcsA but not SulA in vivo. Here, we characterize the biochemical properties of the E240K mutant in vitro and present evidence that the effects of this mutation are complex. For example, Lon^E240K exists almost exclusively as a dodecamer, whereas wild-type Lon equilibrates between hexamers and dodecamers. Moreover, Lon^E240K displays degradation defects in vitro that do not correlate in any simple fashion with degron identity, substrate stability, or dodecamer formation. The Lon sequence segment near residue 240 is known to undergo nucleotide-dependent conformational changes, and our results suggest that this region may be important for coupling substrate binding with allosteric activation of Lon protease and ATPase activity.     

Saturation and specificity of the Lon protease of Escherichia coli.

Lon is an ATP-dependent protease of Escherichia coli. The lon mutation has a pleiotropic phenotype: UV sensitivity, mucoidy, deficiency for lysogenization by bacteriophage lambda and P1, and lower efficiency in the degradation of abnormal proteins. All of these phenotypes are correlated with the loss of protease activity. Here we examine the effects of overproduction of one Lon substrate, SulA, and show that it protects two other substrates from degradation. To better understand this protection, we mutagenized the sulA gene and selected for mutants that have partially or totally lost their ability to saturate the Lon protease and thus can no longer protect another substrate. Some of the SulA mutants lost their ability to protect RcsA from degradation but could still protect the O thermosensitive mutant protein (Ots). All of the mutants retained their capacity to induce cell division inhibition. It was also found that deletion of the C-terminal end of SulA affected its activity but did not affect its susceptibility to Lon. We propose that Lon may have more than one specificity for peptide cleavage.     

Regulatory role of C-terminal residues of SulA in its degradation by Lon protease in Escherichia coli

The SulA protein is a cell division inhibitor in Escherichia coli, and is specifically degraded by Lon protease. To study the recognition site of SulA for Lon, we prepared a mutant SulA protein lacking the C-terminal 8 amino acid residues (SA8). This deletion protein was accumulated and stabilized more than native SulA in lon(+) cells in vivo. Moreover, the deletion SulA fused to maltose binding protein was not degraded by Lon protease, and did not stimulate the ATPase or peptidase activity of Lon in vitro, probably due to the much reduced interaction with Lon. A BIAcore study showed that SA8 directly interacts with Lon. These results suggest that SA8 of SulA was recognized by Lon protease. The SA8 peptide, KIHSNLYH, specifically inhibited the degradation of native SulA by Lon protease in vitro, but not that of casein. A mutant SA8, KAHSNLYH, KIASNLYH, or KIHSNAYH, also inhibited the degradation of SulA, while such peptides as KIHSNLYA did not. These results show that SulA has the specified rows of C-terminal 8 residues recognized by Lon, leading to facilitated binding and subsequent cleavage by Lon protease both in vivo and in vitro.     

ATP-dependent degradation of SulA, a cell division inhibitor, by the HslVU protease in Escherichia coli.

HslVU is an ATP-dependent protease consisting of two multimeric components, the HslU ATPase and the HslV peptidase. To gain an insight into the role of HslVU in regulation of cell division, the reconstituted enzyme was incubated with SulA, an inhibitor of cell division in Escherichia coli, or its fusion protein with maltose binding protein (MBP). HslVU degraded both proteins upon incubation with ATP but not with its nonhydrolyzable analog, ATPgammaS, indicating that the degradation of SulA requires ATP hydrolysis. The pulse-chase experiment using an antibody raised against MBP-SulA revealed that the stability of SulA increased in hsl mutants and further increased in lon/hsl double mutants, indicating that SulA is an in vivo substrate of HslVU as well as of protease La (Lon). These results suggest that HslVU in addition to Lon plays an important role in regulation of cell division through degradation of SulA.     

Functional dissection of a cell-division inhibitor, SulA, of Escherichia coli and its negative regulation by Lon

SulA is induced in Escherichia coli by the SOS response and inhibits cell division through interaction with FtsZ. To determine which region of SulA is essential for the inhibition of cell division, we constructed a series of N-terminal and C-terminal deletions of SulA and a series of alanine substitution mutants. Arginine at position 62, leucine at 67, tryptophan at 77 and lysine at 87, in the central region of SulA, were all essential for the inhibitory activity. Residues 3–27 and the C-terminal 21 residues were dispensable for the activity. The mutant protein lacking N-terminal residues 3–47 was inactive, as was that lacking the C-terminal 34 residues. C-terminal deletions of 8 and 21 residues increased the growth-inhibiting activity in lon ⁺ cells, but not in lon ^? cells. The wild-type and mutant SulA proteins were isolated in a form fused to E. coli maltose-binding protein, and tested in vitro for sensitivity to Lon protease. Lon degraded wild-type SulA and a deletion mutant lacking the N-terminal 93 amino acids, but did not degrade the derivative lacking 21 residues at the C-terminus. Futhermore, the wild-type SulA and the N-terminal deletion mutant formed a stable complex with Lon, while the C-terminal deletion did not. MBP fused to the C-terminal 20 residues of SulA formed a stable complex with, but was not degraded by Lon. When LacZ protein was fused at its C-terminus to 8 or 20 amino acid residues from the C-terminal region of SulA the protein was stable in lon ⁺ cells. These results indicate that the C-terminal 20 residues of SulA permit recognition by, and complex formation with, Lon, and are necessary, but not sufficient, for degradation by Lon.     

Functional dissection of a cell-division inhibitor, SulA, of Escherichia coli and its negative regulation by Lon

SulA is induced in Escherichia coli by the SOS response and inhibits cell division through interaction with FtsZ. To determine which region of SulA is essential for the inhibition of cell division, we constructed a series of N-terminal and C-terminal deletions of SulA and a series of alanine substitution mutants. Arginine at position 62, leucine at 67, tryptophan at 77 and lysine at 87, in the central region of SulA, were all essential for the inhibitory activity. Residues 3–27 and the C-terminal 21 residues were dispensable for the activity. The mutant protein lacking N-terminal residues 3–47 was inactive, as was that lacking the C-terminal 34 residues. C-terminal deletions of 8 and 21 residues increased the growth-inhibiting activity in lon ⁺ cells, but not in lon ⁻ cells. The wild-type and mutant SulA proteins were isolated in a form fused to E. coli maltose-binding protein, and tested in vitro for sensitivity to Lon protease. Lon degraded wild-type SulA and a deletion mutant lacking the N-terminal 93 amino acids, but did not degrade the derivative lacking 21 residues at the C-terminus. Futhermore, the wild-type SulA and the N-terminal deletion mutant formed a stable complex with Lon, while the C-terminal deletion did not. MBP fused to the C-terminal 20 residues of SulA formed a stable complex with, but was not degraded by Lon. When LacZ protein was fused at its C-terminus to 8 or 20 amino acid residues from the C-terminal region of SulA the protein was stable in lon ⁺ cells. These results indicate that the C-terminal 20 residues of SulA permit recognition by, and complex formation with, Lon, and are necessary, but not sufficient, for degradation by Lon. Received: 8 October 1996 / Accepted: 27 November 1996     

The ATP-Dependent HslVU/ClpQY Protease Participates in Turnover of Cell Division Inhibitor SulA in Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli mutants lacking activities of all known cytosolic ATP-dependent proteases (Lon, ClpAP, ClpXP, and HslVU), due to double deletions [DeltahslVU and Delta(clpPX-lon)], cannot grow at low (30 degrees C) or very high (45 degrees C) temperatures, unlike those carrying either of the deletions. Such growth defects were particularly marked when the deletions were introduced into strain MG1655 or W3110. To examine the functions of HslVU and other proteases further, revertants that can grow at 30 degrees C were isolated from the multiple-protease mutant and characterized. The revertants were found to carry a suppressor affecting either ftsZ (encoding a key cell division protein) or sulA (encoding the SulA inhibitor, which binds and inhibits FtsZ). Whereas the ftsZ mutations were identical to a mutation known to produce a protein refractory to SulA inhibition, the sulA mutations affected the promoter-operator region, reducing synthesis of SulA. These results suggested that the growth defect of the parental double-deletion mutant at a low temperature was due to the accumulation of excess SulA without DNA-damaging treatment. Consistent with these results, SulA in the double-deletion mutant was much more stable than that in the Delta(clpPX-lon) mutant, suggesting that SulA can be degraded by HslVU. As expected, purified HslVU protease degraded SulA (fused to the maltose-binding protein) efficiently in an ATP-dependent manner. These results suggest that HslVU as well as Lon participates in the in vivo turnover of SulA and that HslVU becomes essential for growth when the Lon (and Clp) protease level is reduced below a critical threshold.     

Analysis of the Escherichia coli Alp phenotype: heat shock induction in ssrA mutants

The major phenotypes of lon mutations, UV sensitivity and overproduction of capsule, are due to the stabilization of two substrates, SulA and RcsA. Inactivation of transfer mRNA (tmRNA) (encoded by ssrA), coupled with a multicopy kanamycin resistance determinant, suppressed both lon phenotypes and restored the rapid degradation of SulA. This novel protease activity was named Alp but was never identified further. We report here the identification, mapping, and characterization of a chromosomal mutation, faa (for function affecting Alp), that leads to full suppression of a Deltalon ssrA::cat host and thus bypasses the requirement for multicopy Kan(r); faa and ssrA mutants are additive in their ability to suppress lon mutants. The faa mutation was mapped to the C terminus of dnaJ(G232); dnaJ null mutants have similar effects. The identification of a lon suppressor in dnaJ suggested the possible involvement of heat shock. We find that ssrA mutants alone significantly induce the heat shock response. The suppression of UV sensitivity, both in the original Alp strain and in faa mutants, is reversed by mutations in clpY, encoding a subunit of the heat shock-induced ClpYQ protease that is known to degrade SulA. However, capsule synthesis is not restored by clpY mutants, probably because less RcsA accumulates in the Alp strain and because the RcsA that does accumulate is inactive. Both ssrA effects are partially relieved by ssrA derivatives encoding protease-resistant tags, implicating ribosome stalling as the primary defect. Thus, ssrA and faa each suppress two lon mutant phenotypes but by somewhat different mechanisms, with heat shock induction playing a major role.     

Proteolysis and modulation of the activity of the cell division inhibitor SulA in Escherichia coli lon mutants.

Intracellular accumulation of the inducible cell division inhibitor SulA is modulated by proteases that ensure its degradation, namely, the Lon protease and another ATP-dependent protease(s). Lon- cells are UV sensitive because SulA is stable. We asked whether these ATP-dependent proteases are more active when lon cells are grown at high temperature or in synthetic medium since these conditions decrease the UV sensitivity of lon cells. We found that these growth conditions have no direct effect on Lon-independent degradation of SulA. They may, instead, decrease the SulA-FtsZ interaction.     

Overproduction and purification of SulA fusion protein in Escherichia coli and its degradation by Lon protease in vitro

To overproduce extremely unstable SulA protein, which is the cell-division inhibitor of Escherichia coli, we fused the sulA gene to the maltose-binding protein (MBP) fusion vectors with or without the signal sequence (plasmids pMAL-p-SulA and pMAL-c-SulA respectively). The amount of the full-length fusion protein expressed from the plasmid pMAL-p-SulA (pre-MBP-SulA) in E. coli was much larger than that expressed from the plasmid pMAL-c-SulA (MBP-SulA). A major amount of the pre-MBP-SulA fusion protein was expressed in a soluble form and affinity-purified by amylose resin. Since site-specific cleavage of the fusion protein with factor Xa resulted in the precipitation of SulA protein, the pre-MBP-SulA fusion protein was used to study the degradation of SulA protein by E. coli Lon protease in vitro. It was found that only the SulA portion of the fusion protein was degraded by Lon protease in an ATP-dependent manner. This result provides direct evidence that Lon protease plays an important role in the rapid degradation of SulA protein in cells.     

An extraintestinal, pathogenic isolate of Escherichia coli (O4/K54/H5) can produce a group 1 capsule which is divergently regulated from its constitutively produced group 2, K54 capsular polysaccharide.

We are studying an O4/K54/H5 Escherichia coli bacteremic isolate (CP9) as a model pathogen for extraintestinal infection. Its group 2, K54 capsular polysaccharide is an important virulence determinant and confers serum resistance. In this study the effect of the group 1 capsule regulators, RcsA, RcsB, and Lon protease, on the regulation of CP9's capsular polysaccharides was assessed. It was established that in the presence of multicopy rcsA or with disruption of lon, CP9 can be induced to produce a group 1 capsule. RcsA, RcsB, and Lon are present in this K54 background and regulate group 1 capsule expression in a fashion similar to that described for K-12 strains. Two independent group 2 capsule gene protein fusions (cl1.29::TnphoA and cl1.137::TnphoA) were used to evaluate the effects of these regulators on group 2 K54 capsule production. Disruption of lon resulted in 1.9-fold (TR293 [cl1.29::TnphoA lon-146]) and 3.4-fold (TR1373 [cl1.137::TnphoA lon-146]) decreases in fusion activity at 28 degrees C, relative to the baseline level. However, decreases in fusion activity at 42 degrees C were only 1.2- and 1.4-fold, respectively. Inactivation of both lon and rcsA or lon and rcsB restored fusion activity to baseline levels at 28 degrees C, but only a partial restoration of activity was seen at higher temperatures. To assess whether these differences in fusion activity reflected a functional change in capsule production, the effects of 80% normal human serum (NHS) were tested against CP9 and TR93 (lon-146). Since the group 2 K54 capsule protects against the bactericidal activity of 80% NHS, a decrease in its production results in an increase in serum sensitivity. Viable counts of CP9 increased 10-fold in 80% NHS over 3 h at 28 degrees C, as expected. In contrast to CP9, TR93 (lon-146) incurred a 10-fold loss in viability under the same conditions. The levels of RcsA are increased in TR93 (lon 146) as consequence of lon disruption; therefore, these results in conjunction with the cl1::TnphoA protein fusion data establish RcsA as a negative regulator of the group 2 K54 capsular polysaccharide. Furthermore, these results also suggest existence of another Lon-sensitive negative regulator of group 2 K54 capsule production, which is active higher temperatures.     

Lon protease degrades transfer-messenger RNA-tagged proteins

Bacterial trans translation is activated when translating ribosomes are unable to elongate or terminate properly. Small protein B (SmpB) and transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA) are the two known factors required for and dedicated to trans translation. tmRNA, encoded by the ssrA gene, is a bifunctional molecule that acts both as a tRNA and as an mRNA during trans translation. The functions of tmRNA ensure that stalled ribosomes are rescued, the causative defective mRNAs are degraded, and the incomplete polypeptides are marked for targeted proteolysis. We present in vivo and in vitro evidence that demonstrates a direct role for the Lon ATP-dependent protease in the degradation of tmRNA-tagged proteins. In an endogenous protein tagging assay, lon mutants accumulated excessive levels of tmRNA-tagged proteins. In a reporter protein tagging assay with lambda-CI-N, the protein product of a nonstop mRNA construct designed to activate trans translation, lon mutant cells efficiently tagged the reporter protein, but the tagged protein exhibited increased stability. Similarly, a green fluorescent protein (GFP) construct containing a hard-coded C-terminal tmRNA tag (GFP-SsrA) exhibited increased stability in lon mutant cells. Most significantly, highly purified Lon preferentially degraded the tmRNA-tagged forms of proteins compared to the untagged forms. Based on these results, we conclude that Lon protease participates directly in the degradation of tmRNA-tagged proteins.     

Roles of the N domain of the AAA+ Lon protease in substrate recognition,allosteric regulation and chaperone activity

Degron binding regulates the activities of the AAA+ Lon protease in addition to targeting proteins for degradation. The sul20 degron from the cell‐division inhibitor SulA is shown here to bind to the N domain of Escherichia coli Lon, and the recognition site is identified by cross‐linking and scanning for mutations that prevent sul20‐peptide binding. These N‐domain mutations limit the rates of proteolysis of model sul20‐tagged substrates and ATP hydrolysis by an allosteric mechanism. Lon inactivation of SulA in vivo requires binding to the N domain and robust ATP hydrolysis but does not require degradation or translocation into the proteolytic chamber. Lon‐mediated relief of proteotoxic stress and protein aggregation in vivo can also occur without degradation but is not dependent on robust ATP hydrolysis. In combination, these results demonstrate that Lon can function as a protease or a chaperone and reveal that some of its ATP‐dependent biological activities do not require translocation.