Fluidity of phospholipid bilayers and membranes after exposure to osmium tetroxide and gluteraldehyde

The response of fluid bilayer regions to osmium tetroxide and glutaraldehyde fixation was examined in phospholipid multilayers and in nerve bundles from the walking legs of the lobster Homarus americanus. The samples were spinlabeled either with 5-doxylstearic acid (the 4′4′-dimethyloxazolidine-N-ozyl derivative of 5-ketostearic acid) or the maleimide spin label, 4-maleimido-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl. Osmium tetroxide fixation abolishes the characteristic orientation of the spin-labeled lipid bilayer regions and virtually eliminates motion on the electron spin resonance time scale. Glutaraldehyde treatment reduces the motion of maleimide spin labels covalently attached to proteins. However, in contrast to osmium tetroxide fixation, glutaraldehyde has essentially no effect on the orientation and mobility in the fluid bilayer regions, and hence probably does not restrict directly the potential for translational motion in membrane phospholipid bilayer regions.     

Azethoxyl nitroxide spin labels. ESR studies involving thiourea crystals, model membrane systems and chromatophores, and chemical reduction with ascorbate and dithiothreitol

Trans- and cis-azethoxyl nitroxides , , and can be trapped in the cavities of thiourea crystals. The presence of a single gauche conformation on either side of the pyrrolidine ring within the crystals was indicated by the ESR spectra. Rotation about the long molecular axis then corresponds approximately to y-axis motion of the nitroxide moiety. Proxyl nitroxides in which the nitroxide group is located on the penultimate carbon of long chain lipids can also be trapped and were shown to adopt the azethoxyl conformation in the thiourea crystals.The measured ΔA values (A_| − A) of oriented egg lecithin multilayers containing trans- and cis-azethoxyl nitroxides and were quite small, consistent with the unique orientation of the nitroxide principal axes with respect to the long axis of the molecule. The ΔA values for a series of lipids bearing a label near the terminus of the chain were very similar to that of , showing that the azethoxyl conformation is likely the predominant one in these labels in orienting systems.Computer simulations of the ESR spectra of and in egg lecithin vesicles provided values for molecular orientation and motion parameters consistent with those expected from a consideration of molecular models in the extended (all trans) conformation.Azethoxyl nitroxides have also proven useful in the investigation of motion restricted (boundary) lipid in a lipid-protein system. Thus, the values (69 ± 10%) for the amount of boundary lipid in the chromatophore membranes from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides as determined using trans- and cis- are in good agreement with values using 16-doxylstearic acid (64 ± 3%). The fact that all three labels show about the same fraction of boundary lipid in this system indicates that the lipid binding sites are relatively insensitive to the geometry of the lipid chain. Also, both and appear to be able to detect a third lipid environment not seen with the doxyl fatty acid. The apparent fluidity of this component lies between that of boundary and bilayer lipid. The unique orientation of the nitroxide principal axes with respect to the long molecular axis in azethoxyl nitroxides and allows detection of hindrance to rotation about the long molecular axis, in contrast to the analogous doxyl and proxyl fatty acids.Comparative reduction studies using ascorbate and dithiothreitol indicate that azethoxyl nitroxides are slightly more resistant toward reduction than proxyl nitroxides and much more resistant than doxyl nitroxides.     

Slow-motion ESR of cholestane spin labels in planar multibilayers of diacyldigalactosyldiglycerides

The orientation and restricted motion of the cholestane spin label (3-spiro-doxyl-5α-cholestane) incorporated into planar multibilayers of diacyldigalactosyldiglycerides extracted from the thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts from different plant leaves has been studied. The experimental ESR spectra were simulated in terms of the slow-tumbling ESR formalism of Freed and co-workers (Polnaszek, C.F., Bruno, G.V. and Freed, J.H. (1973) J. Chem. Phys. 58, 3185–3199). The analysis shows that the degree of orientational order is low. The spin label molecules undergo a faster reorientational motion about their long molecular axes than perpendicular to them. At room temperature the reorientational rate around the long molecular axis falls within the fast-motional limit, while the reorientation rate of the long axis itself corresponds to the slow-tumbling regime. The results indicate that the motion of the labels in bilayers of diacyldigalactosyldiglycerides is considerably slower than that of the same label incorporated into bilayers of saturated phosphatidylcholines above the main phase transition. Differences between bilayers of diacyldigalactosyldiglycerides extracted from different plant membranes have been observed.     

ESR spectral analysis of the molecular motion of spin labels in lipid bilayers and membranes based on a model in terms of two angular motional parameters and rotational correlation times

Electron spin resonance (ESR) spectral line shapes are calculated for a nitroxide spin-labeled molecule undergoing rapid restricted rotations (twisting) about its long molecular axis while simultaneously tumbling within a cone. Explicit expressions are derived for the hyperfine splittings and $\text{g-}\text{values}$, as well as for the secular contributions to the motionally modulated linewidths. The present model is useful for analyzing the restricted twisting and tumbling motions, and rotational correlation times, of spin-labeled molecules in bilayers. Simulated spectra compare well with experimental spectra of lecithin bilayers marked with cholestane spin label, over a wide temperature range.     

ESR spectral analysis of the molecular motion of spin labels in lipid bilayers and membranes based on a model in terms of two angular motional parameters and rotational correlation times.

Electron spin resonance (ESR) spectral line shapes are calculated for a nitroxide spin-labeled molecule undergoing rapid restricted rotations (twisting) about its long molecular axis while simultaneously tumbling within a cone. Explicit expressions are derived for the hyperfine splittings and g-values, as well as for the secular contributions to the motionally modulated linewidths. The present model is useful for analyzing the restricted twisting and tumbling motions, and rotational correlation times, of spin-labeled molecules in bilayers. Simulated spectra compare well with experimental spectra of lecithin bilayers marked with cholestane spin label, over a wide temperature range.     

Thermal effects on motion and orientation of the cholestane spin label in planar multibilayers of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine and dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine

A detailed picture of the orientation and restricted motion of the cholestane spin label (3-spiro-doxyl-5α-cholestane) in planar multibilayers of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine and dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine has been recorded by simultaneous simulation of ESR spectra obtained with the magnetic field parallel and perpendicular to the bilayers (Shimoyama, Y., Eriksson, L.E.G. and Ehrenberg, A. (1978) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 508, 213–235). The analysis has been made over the temperature range ?30°C to 60°C on samples containing 20 to 22% water. At low temperatures the cholestane spin label is tilted with respect to the lipid bilayer normal by an angle of approx. 30° which disappears at the pretransition. In this low temperature range the restricted twisting motion has an activation energy of 5.5 kJ·mol^?1. Above the main transition the twisting motion is unrestricted and has the activation energy 20 kJ·mol^?1. From below the pretransition to above the main transition the velocity of the twisting motion increases by an order of magnitude. The amplitude of the wobbling motion increases abruptly from 0° to 35° at the main transition.     

Azethoxyl nitroxide spin labels. ESR studies involving thiourea crystals, model membrane systems and chromatophores, and chemical reduction with ascorbate and dithiothreitol.

Trans- and cis-azethoxyl nitroxides 1, 2, 3 and 4 can be trapped in the cavities of thiourea crystals. The presence of a single gauche conformation on either side of the pyrrolidine ring within the crystals was indicated by the ESR spectra. Rotation about the long molecular axis then corresponds approximately to y-axis motion of the nitroxide moiety. Proxyl nitroxides in which the nitroxide group is located on the penultimate carbon of long chain lipids can also be trapped and were shown to adopt the azethoxyl conformation in the thiourea crystals. The measured deltaA values (A parallel to - A perpendicular) of oriented egg lecithin multilayers containing trans- and cis-azethoxyl nitroxides 1 and 2 were quite small, consistent with the unique orientation of the nitroxide principal axes with respect to the long axis of the molecule. The deltaA values for a series of lipids bearing a label near the terminus of the chain were very similar to that of 1, showing that the azethoxyl conformation is likely the predominant one in these labels in orienting systems. Computer simulations of the ESR spectra of 1 and 2 in egg lecithin vesicles provided values for molecular orientation and motion parameters consistent with those expected from a consideration of molecular models in the extended (all trans) conformation. Azethoxyl nitroxides have also proven useful in the investigation of motion restricted (boundary) lipid in a lipid-protein system. Thus, the values (69 +/- 10%) for the amount of boundary lipid in the chromatophore membranes from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides as determined using trans- 2 and cis- 2 are in good agreement with values using 16-doxylstearic acid (64 +/- 3%). The fact that all three labels show about the same fraction of boundary lipid in this system indicates that the lipid binding sites are relatively insensitive to the geometry of the lipid chain. Also, both 1 and 2 appear to be able to detect a third lipid environment not seen with the doxyl fatty acid. The apparent fluidity of this component lies between that of boundary and bilayer lipid. The unique orientation of the nitroxide principal axes with respect to the long molecular axis in azethoxyl nitroxides 1 and 2 allows detection of hindrance to rotation about the long molecular axis, in contrast to the analogous doxyl and proxyl fatty acids. Comparative reduction studies using ascorbate and dithiothreitol indicate that azethoxyl nitroxides are slightly more resistant toward reduction than proxyl nitroxides and much more resistant than doxyl nitroxides.     

Factors affecting molecular packing in mixed lipid monolayers and bilayers

The nature of the molecular interactions and the factors determining molecular packing in mixed phospholipid/glyceride monolayers and bilayers were investigated by monolayer and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques. Force-area curves were obtained at various temperatures for monolayers, at the air-water interface, of synthetic lecithins and a phosphatidyl ethanolamine mixed with di- and triglycerides in different molar ratios. The linewidths of peaks in the high resolution NMR spectra of lecithin/glyceride co-dispersions in excess water at different temperatures were used to obtain information about molecular mobilities.It was found that the molecular packing in mixed lipid monolayers and bilayers is determined by the following factors: (1) Whether lipid chains are above or below their melting point (T_C). (2) The difference between experimental temperature and T_C: the larger the difference, the smaller the effect of one component on the other. (3) The degree of similarity of the chains of the components; this influences the degree of cooperativity of chain motions and the degree of mixing of the components. (4) The nature, orientation, mutual interaction and degree of hydration of the polar groups.It is shown that mean molecular area does not always reflect the state of chain motions in lipid films, because of heterogeneity of motion and structure along the molecules. Cooperativity of motion may reduce steric requirements; other effects which are of particular importance for lecithins are interactions of zwitterions, and the influence of polar group hydration.     

Anisotropic and restricted molecular motion in lecithin bilayers

A treatment has been developed which accounts for the prominent features of the PMR spectra and proton relaxation data of unsonicated lecithin bilayers. The spin-lattice relaxation time T₁ and the spin-spin relaxation time T₂ of the protons of a methyl top undergoing anisotropic and restricted reorientation have been calculated employing the theory of Woessner, but modified to include the effects of orientational anisotropies on long time scales. Analysis of the nmr data in terms of this theory permitted determination of the mobility of the lecithin hydrocarbon chains in the bilayer phase. These results indicate that the hydrophobic core of an unsonicated bilayer is more appropriately described as a soft solid rather than as a highly mobile fluid, contrary to the suggestions of recent esr spin label studies.     

The fidelity of response by nitroxide spin probes to changes in membrane organization: The condensing effect of cholesterol

The response of doxyl fatty acid spin probes in egg lecithin bilayers to added cholesterol is compared with results from ²H-NMR. Large differences are found between the profiles of order parameter vs. label position and cholesterol concentration.At constant cholesterol content, the ESR spin probe order parameter decreases continuously as the label position is moved toward the terminal methyl region of the bilayer whereas an order parameter ‘plateau’ is observed for the upper region of the bilayer by ²H-NMR. In addition, the spin probe order parameters are smaller than those observed by ²H-NMR.Differences are also observed in the profiles of order parameter vs. cholesterol content for each label position. The spin probes detect a maximal response to added cholesterol for the central portion of the chains with much weaker responses near both ends of the chains. In contrast, the ²H-NMR results indicate a large, approximately constant response for the first ten positions in the chains with a decreasing response toward the terminal methyl group. For all the positions examined, the spin probes show a weaker response than that observed by ²H-NMR.A direct measure of the perturbing effect of a spin label is made by comparing the deuterium quadrupole splittings in egg lecithin-cholesterol bilayers for stearic acid with and without an attached doxyl moiety. The spin-labelled fatty acid has a much reduced quadrupole splitting and an opposite response to cholesterol addition.     

On the ordering of N-alkane and N-alcohol solutes in phospholipid bilayer model membrane systems

²H-NMR measurements of the ordering of several n-alkane and one n-alcohol solutes in lipid bilayers formed from dimyristoyl lecithin (DML) are reported. The results are consistent with orientation of the solutes between the lipid chains, the n-alkanes having a preference for the bilayer interior, while the n-octanol is anchored at the bilayer surface. Solubility of the short chain n-alkanes, n-hexane and n-octane as an ordered component in the L_α phase is more limited than that of n-dodecane. The NMR data are supported by low angle X-ray diffraction results which confirm that n-octanol has a more dramatic influence on bilayer area than the n-alkanes.     

Effect of various sterols on the 22Na permeability and fluidity of phospholipid bilayer membranes.

Sodium-22 efflux was measured in multilamellar liposomes composed of egg lecithin, dicetylphosphate, and various sterols. In a parallel series of experiments a spin labelled fatty acid ester was incorporated into similar vesicles and the molecular motion of the spin label monitored by electron spin resonance spectroscopy. Spin lable mobility was used as a measure of phospholipid hydrocarbon chain motion. There was a poor correlation between the effects of these sterols on sodium permeability and their effects on the motion of the lipid chains. It is postulated that sterols alter sodium transport not only through a reduction in the motional freedom of membrane lipids, but also through changes in the partitioning of sodium between membrane and aqueous phases.     

Molecular motion and order in oriented lipid multibilayer membranes evaluated by simulations of spin label ESR spectra. Effects of temperature, cholesterol and magnetic field.

A simulation method to interpret electron spin resonance (ESR) of spin labelled amphiphilic molecules in oriented phosphatidylcholine multibilayers in terms of a restricted motional model is presented. Order and motion of the cholestane spin label (3-spiro-doxyl-5alpha-cholestane) incorporated into egg yolk phosphatidylcholine, dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine and dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine, pure and in mixture with cholesterol, were studied at various temperatures. With egg yolk phosphatidylcholine identical sets of motional parameters were obtained from simulations of ESR spectra obtained at three microwave frequencies (X-, K- and Q-band). With dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine and dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine analyses of the spectra show that phase transitions occur in samples containing up to 30 mol % cholesterol. The activation energy for the motion of the spin label is about three times larger above than below the phase transition, indicating a more collective motion in the lipid crystalline state than in the gel state. In the liquid crystalline state the activation energy is larger in the pure phosphatidylcholines than with cholesterol added. Additions of cholesterol to egg phosphatidylcholine induces a higher molecular order but does not appreciably affect correlation times. This is in contrast to dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine where both order and correlation times are affected by the presence of cholesterol. The activation energies follow the same order as the transition temperatures: dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine greater than dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine greater than egg yokd phosphatidylcholine, suggesting a similar order of the cooperativity of the motion of the lipid molecules. Magnetic field-induced effects on egg phosphatidylcholine multibilayers were found at Q-band measurements above 40 degrees C. The cholestane spin label mimics order and motion of cholesterol molecule incorporated into the lipid bilayers. This reflects order and motion of the portions of the lipid molecules on the same depth of the bilayer as the rigid steroid portions of the intercalated molecules.     

A spin probe study of the influence of cholesterol on motion and orientation of phospholipids in oriented multibilayers and vesicles

Spin probes have been used to study at the molecular level the influence of cholesterol on bilayers of egg lecithin and dipalmitoyl lecithin. Distinct differences between the two lecithin systems were revealed. Increasing amounts of cholesterol result in extension of the fatty acid chains and decreased amplitude of motion of the long axes of the fatty acids in egg lecithin. In dipalmitoyl lecithin cholesterol causes an increase in the mobility and amplitude of motion of the fatty acid side chains, presumably due to alteration of the molecular interactions between phospholipids by relaxing the close packing of these molecules. These data provide an explanation for the condensing and fluidizing effects of cholesterol in water-containing phases and monolayers of egg lecithin and dipalmitoyl lecithin, respectively, and for the permeability behavior of egg lecithin and dipalmitoyl lecithin liposomes in the presence and absence of cholesterol. Differences are revealed between the spin bilayer environments in hydrated phospholipid films and vesicles.     

Distance measurements using paramagnetic ion-induced relaxation in the saturation transfer electron spin resonance of spin-labeled biomolecules: Application to phospholipid bilayers and interdigitated gel phases

The saturation transfer electron spin resonance (STESR) spectra of spin-labeled phosphatidylcholines in gel phase lipid bilayers are shown to be sensitive to dipolar spin-spin interactions with paramagnetic ions in the aqueous phase. The reciprocal integrated intensity of the STESR spectrum is linearly dependent on aqueous Ni²⁺ ion concentration, hence, confirming the expectation that the STESR intensity is directly proportional to the spin-lattice relaxation time of the spin label. The gradient of the relaxation rate with respect to Ni²⁺ ion concentration decreases strongly with the position of the nitroxide group down the sn-2 chain of the spin-labeled lipid and is consistent with a 1/R³ dependence on the distance, R, from the bilayer surface. The values derived for the dimensions of the bilayer and lipid molecules in the case of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) are in good agreement with those available from x-ray diffraction studies. Allowance for the multibilayer nature of the DPPC dispersions gives an estimate of the water layer thickness that is also consistent with results from x-ray diffraction. The profile of the paramagnetic ion-induced relaxation is drastically changed with DPPC dispersions in glycerol for which the lipid chains are known to be interdigitated in the gel phase. The terminal methyl groups of the lipid chains are located approximately in register with the C-3 atoms of the sn-2 chain of the oppositely oriented lipid molecules in the interdigitated phase. The thickness of the lipid layer and the effective thickness of the lipid polar group are reduced by ~40% in the interdigitated phase as compared with the bilayer phase. The calibrations of the distance dependence established by use of spin labels at defined chain positions should be applicable to STESR measurements on other biological systems.     

Theoretical study of aliphatic chain structure in mono- and bilayers

A model is proposed to explain the aliphatic chain structure in mono- and bilayers (monomolecular films, aqueous lipid dispersions and biologival membranes). The rotational isomerism around carbon-carbon bonds and chain interactions (dispersion forces) are taken into account. This model has been first used to calculate different conformational properties of normal hexan layers in terms of distance between chains (thickness, birefringence, melting entropy, order parameter S₃ introduced in spin label technique).     

Comparative 5-doxylstearoyllecithin and 3-doxylcholestane EPR spin labeling study of phospholipid bilayer perturbation by different oxidized lecithin species

A 3-doxylcholestane spin label was employed in addition to 5-doxylstearoyl lecithin for a more detailed study of the different effects exerted by variously oxidized lecithins on fatty acid alignment in phospholipid planar bilayers. Either spin label was enclosed in oriented PLPC planar samples also containing in turn a variety of conjugated-dienes lecithins and cleaved chain lecithins, in order to monitor EPR spectral angular dependence loss. Data obtained by use of arachidonoyl-hydroxystearoyl-PC and palmitoyl-hydroxylinoleoyl-PC confirm that the 5-DSPC nitroxide ring almost completely retains its orientation in CD-PCs-containing planar membranes, in contrast with angular dependence loss observed in the presence of the CC-PC molecular species palmitoyl-oxononanoyl-PC and palmitoyl-oxovaleroyl-PC, already seen with cleaved-chain palmitoyl-glutaroyl-PC and palmitoyl-azelaoyl-PC. However, the 3-DC nitroxide ring also loses its orientation with CD-PCs, in addition to being disoriented by cleaved chain-lecithins, similarly to 5DSPC. Joint information from the two spin labels will help to clarify whether OXPC-related disordering involved the whole bilayer structure or only the hydrophobic core. In addition, the propensity of different OXPCs to form bilayer vesicles in water suspension was also determined by Sepharose 4B gel-chromatography. The results suggest that CD-PCs might yield SPB bilayer structures with a disordered hydrophobic core, while pure CC-PC more probably forms non-bilayer disordered structures, possibly micelles or mixed micelle/bilayers.     

An ESR Spin label study of structural and dynamical properties of oriented lecithin-cholesterol multibilayers.

Oriented dipalmitoyllecithin-cholesterol multibilayers with 11% water have been studied with the cholestane spin label. From the ESR spectra the order parameters and the mobility of the spin label about its long axis have been calculated. The results on pure lecithin multibilayers indicate a transition from gel to liquid crystalline phase at 52 plus or minus 2 degrees C. In the gel phase the lecithin alkyl chains are highly ordered, but tilted with respect to the normal to the bilayers by about 25 degrees. Above 52 degrees C the tilt disappears and the mobility of the cholestane spin label increases, indicating an increase of mobility of the lecithin alkyl chains. When cholesterol is added, below about 52 degrees C a decrease of order is found. Furthermore, already small cholesterol contents (smaller than or equal to 10 mole %) remove the tilt. Above about 52 degrees C cholesterol improves the order by decreasing the amplitude of the librational motions. Cholesterol lowers the transition temperature of the system and reduces the mobility of the lecithin alkyl chains in the liquid crystalline phase. However an increase in mobility is found at cholesterol contents up to 10 mole %. A very broad phase transition is observed at 50 mole % cholesterol. In all systems an increase in temperature results in a reduction of order through an increase of the amplitude of the librational motions of the molecules. The librational motions are to some extent cooperative. The asymmetry of the order matrix is found to be a measure for the lateral ordering. Cholesterol increases the lateral ordering, indicating that the flat cholesterol molecules orient parallel to each other.     

Behavior of spin labels in a variety of interdigitated lipid bilayers

The behavior of a number of spin labels in several lipid bilayers, shown by X-ray diffraction to be interdigitated, has been compared in order to evaluate the ability of the spin label technique to detect and diagnose the structure of lipid bilayers. The main difference between interdigitated and non-interdigitated gel phase bilayers which can be exploited for determination of their structure using spin labels, is that the former have a much less steep fluidity gradient. Thus long chain spin labels with the nitroxide group near the terminal methyl of the chain, such as 16-doxylstearic acid, its methyl ester, or a phosphatidylglycerol spin label containing 16-doxylstearic acid (PG-SL), are more motionally restricted and/or ordered in the interdigitated bilayer than in the non-interdigitated bilayer. This difference is large enough to be of diagnostic value for all three spin labels in the interdigitated bilayers of dihexadecylphosphatidylcholine, dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine/ethanol, and 1,3-dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine. However, it is not large enough to be of diagnostic value at low temperatures. Use of probes with the nitroxide group closer to the apolar/polar interface reveals that these latter interdigitated bilayers are more disordered or less closely packed. As the temperature is increased, however, the motion of the PG-SL does not increase as much in these interdigitated bilayers as in non-interdigitated bilayers. The difference in the motion and/or order of PG-SL between interdigitated and non-interdigitated bilayers is large enough at higher temperatures to be of value in diagnosing the structure of the bilayers. Thus by choice of a suitable spin label and a suitable temperature, this technique should prove useful for detection and diagnosis of lipid bilayer structure with a good degree of reliability. Caution must, of course be exercised, as with any spectroscopic technique. Spin labels will also be invaluable for more detailed studies of known interdigitated bilayers, which would be time- and material-consuming, if carried out using X-ray diffraction solely.