Antimicrobial peptides in toroidal and cylindrical pores

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are small, usually cationic peptides, which permeabilize biological membranes. Their mechanism of action is still not well understood. Here we investigate the preference of alamethicin and melittin for pores of different shapes, using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the peptides in pre-formed toroidal and cylindrical pores. When an alamethicin hexamer is initially embedded in a cylindrical pore, at the end of the simulation the pore remains cylindrical or closes if glutamines in the N-termini are not located within the pore. On the other hand, when a melittin tetramer is embedded in toroidal pore or in a cylindrical pore, at the end of the simulation the pore is lined both with peptides and lipid headgroups, and, thus, can be classified as a toroidal pore. These observations agree with the prevailing views that alamethicin forms barrel-stave pores whereas melittin forms toroidal pores. Both alamethicin and melittin form amphiphilic helices in the presence of membranes, but their net charge differs; at pH ∼ 7, the net charge of alamethicin is − 1 whereas that of melittin is + 5. This gives rise to stronger electrostatic interactions of melittin with membranes than those of alamethicin. The melittin tetramer interacts more strongly with lipids in the toroidal pore than in the cylindrical one, due to more favorable electrostatic interactions.     

Investigation of toroidal pore and oligomerization by melittin using transmission electron microscopy

We studied the effects of melittin on various cell wall components and vesicles of various lipid compositions. To interact with the cytoplasmic membrane, melittin must traverse the cell wall, which is composed of oligosaccharides. Here, we found that melittin had a strong affinity for chitin, peptidoglycan, and lipopolysaccharide. We further examined the influence of lipid compositions on the lysis of the membranes by melittin. The result showed that melittin bound better to negatively charged than to zwitterionic lipid vesicles but was more potent at inducing leakage from zwitterionic lipid vesicles. Our studies further indicated that the oligomeric state of melittin varied between tetramers and octamers during the formation of toroidal pores. Dextran leakage experiments confirmed the formation and dimension of these toroidal pores. Finally, transmission electron microscopy revealed that melittin formed pores via peptide oligomerization by the toroidal pore-forming mechanism. The toroidal pores composed of 7-8 nm diameter rings that encircled 3.5-4.5 nm diameter cavities on zwitterionic lipid vesicles.     

Organizations of melittin peptides after spontaneous penetration into cell membranes

The antimicrobial peptide, melittin, is a potential next-generation antibiotic because melittin can spontaneously form pores in bacterial cell membranes and cause cytoplasm leakage. However, the organizations of melittin peptides in cell membranes remain elusive, which impedes the understanding of the poration mechanism. In this work, we use coarse-grained and all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the organizations of melittin peptides during and after spontaneous penetration into DPPC/POPG lipid bilayers. We find that the peptides in lipid bilayers adopt either a transmembrane conformation or a U-shaped conformation, which are referred to as T- and U-peptides, respectively. Several U-peptides and/or T-peptides aggregate to form stable pores. We analyze a T-pore consisting of four T-peptides and a U-pore consisting of three U-peptides and one T-peptide. In both pores, peptides are organized in a manner such that polar residues face inward and hydrophobic residues face outward, which stabilizes the pores and produces water channels. Compared with the U-pore, the T-pore has lower energy, larger pore diameter, and higher permeability. However, the T-pore occurs less frequently than the U-pore in our simulations, probably because the formation of the T-pore is kinetically slower than the U-pore. The stability and permeability of both pores are confirmed by 300 ns all-atom MD simulations. The peptide organizations obtained in this work should deepen the understanding of the stability, poration mechanism, and permeability of melittin, and facilitate the optimization of melittin to enhance the antibacterial ability.     

Effects of Peptide Charge,Orientation, and Concentration on Melittin Transmembrane Pores

Melittin is a short cationic peptide that exerts cytolytic effects on bacterial and eukaryotic cells. Experiments suggest that in zwitterionic membranes, melittin forms transmembrane toroidal pores supported by four to eight peptides. A recently constructed melittin variant with a reduced cationic charge, MelP5, is active at 10-fold lower concentrations. In previous work, we performed molecular dynamics simulations on the microsecond timescale to examine the supramolecular pore structure of a melittin tetramer in zwitterionic and partially anionic membranes. We now extend that study to include the effects of peptide charge, initial orientation, and number of monomers on the pore formation and stabilization processes. Our results show that parallel transmembrane orientations of melittin and MelP5 are more consistent with experimental data. Whereas a MelP5 parallel hexamer forms a large stable pore during the 5-μs simulation time, a melittin hexamer and an octamer are not fully stable, with several monomers dissociating during the simulation time. Interaction-energy analysis shows that this difference in behavior between melittin and MelP5 is not due to stronger electrostatic repulsion between neighboring melittin peptides but to peptide-lipid interactions that disfavor the isolated MelP5 transmembrane monomer. The ability of melittin monomers to diffuse freely in the 1,2-dimyristoyl-SN-glycero-3-phosphocholine membrane leads to dynamic pores with varying molecularity.     

Charge distribution and imperfect amphipathicity affect pore formation by antimicrobial peptides

Antimicrobial peptides often permeabilize biological membranes via a pore mechanism. Two pore types have been proposed: toroidal, where the pore is partly lined by lipid, and barrel-stave, where a cylindrical pore is completely lined by peptides. What drives the preference of antimicrobial peptides for a certain pore type is not yet fully understood. According to neutron scattering and oriented circular dichroism, melittin and MG-H2 induce toroidal pores whereas alamethicin forms barrel-stave pores. In previous work we found that indeed melittin seems to favor toroidal pores whereas alamethicin favors cylindrical pores. Here we designed mutants of these two peptides and the magainin analog MG-H2, aimed to probe how the distribution of charges along the helix and its imperfectly amphipathic structure influence pore formation. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the peptides in a pre-formed cylindrical pore have been performed. The duration of the simulations was 136ns to 216ns. We found that a melittin mutant with lysine 7 neutralized favors cylindrical pores whereas a MG-H2 mutant with lysines in the N-terminal half of these peptides neutralized and an alamethicin mutant with a positive charge at the position 7 form semitoroidal pores. These results suggest that charged residues within the N-terminal half are important for toroidal pore formation. Toroidal pores produced by MG-H2 are more disordered than the melittin pores, likely because of the charged residues located in the middle of the MG-H2 helix (K11 and K14). Imperfect amphipathicity of melittin seems to play a role in its preference for toroidal pores since the substitutions of charged residues located within the nonpolar face by hydrophobic residues suppress evolution of a toroidal pore. The mutations change the position of lysine 7 near the N-terminus, relative to the lower leaflet headgroups. The MD simulations also show that the melittin P14A mutant forms a toroidal pore, but its configuration diverges from that of melittin and it is probably metastable.     

On the mechanism of pore formation by melittin

The mechanism of pore formation of lytic peptides, such as melittin from bee venom, is thought to involve binding to the membrane surface, followed by insertion at threshold levels of bound peptide. We show that in membranes composed of zwitterionic lipids, i.e. phosphatidylcholine, melittin not only forms pores but also inhibits pore formation. We propose that these two modes of action are the result of two competing reactions: direct insertion into the membrane and binding parallel to the membrane surface. The direct insertion of melittin leads to pore formation, whereas the parallel conformation is inactive and prevents other melittin molecules from inserting, hence preventing pore formation.     

Antimicrobial peptides bind more strongly to membrane pores

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are small, usually cationic peptides, which permeabilize bacterial membranes. Understanding their mechanism of action might help design better antibiotics. Using an implicit membrane model, modified to include pores of different shapes, we show that four AMPs (alamethicin, melittin, a magainin analogue, MG-H2, and piscidin 1) bind more strongly to membrane pores, consistent with the idea that they stabilize them. The effective energy of alamethicin in cylindrical pores is similar to that in toroidal pores, whereas the effective energy of the other three peptides is lower in toroidal pores. Only alamethicin intercalates into the membrane core; MG-H2, melittin and piscidin are located exclusively at the hydrophobic/hydrophilic interface. In toroidal pores, the latter three peptides often bind at the edge of the pore, and are in an oblique orientation. The calculated binding energies of the peptides are correlated with their hemolytic activities. We hypothesize that one distinguishing feature of AMPs may be the fact that they are imperfectly amphipathic which allows them to bind more strongly to toroidal pores. An initial test on a melittin-based mutant seems to support this hypothesis.     

Melittin and a chemically modified trichotoxin form alamethicin-type multi-state pores

The bee venom constituent, melittin, is structurally and functionally related to alamethicin. By forming solvent-free planar bilayers of small area (approx. 100 microns 2) on the tip of fire-polished glass pipettes we could observe single melittin pores in these membranes. An increase in the applied voltage induced further non-integral conductance levels. This indicates that melittin forms multi-level pores similar to those formed by alamethicin. Trichotoxin A40, an antibiotic analogue of alamethicin, also induces a voltage-dependent bilayer conductivity, but no stable pore states are resolved. However, chemical modification of the C-terminal molecule part by introduction of a dansyl group leads to a steeper voltage-dependence and pore state stabilization. Comparing structure and activity of several natural and synthetic amphiphilic polypeptides, we conclude that a lipophilic, N-terminal alpha-helical part of adequate length (dipole moment) and a large enough hydrophilic, C-terminal region are sufficient prerequisites for voltage-dependent formation of multi-state pores.     

Voltage-dependent depolarization of bacterial membranes and artificial lipid bilayers by the peptide antibiotic nisin

The peptide antibiotic nisin is shown to disrupt valinomycin-induced potassium diffusion potentials imposed on intact cells of Staphylococcus cohnii 22. Membrane depolarization occurred rapidly at high diffusion potentials while at low potentials nisin-induced depolarization was slower suggesting that nisin requires a membrane potential for activity. This assumption was proven in experiments with planar lipid bilayers (black lipid membranes). Macroscopic conductivity measurements indicated a voltage-dependent action of nisin. The potential must have a trans-negative orientation with respect to the addition of nisin (added to the cis-side) and a sufficient magnitude (ca. -100 mV). With intact cells the threshold potential was lower (-50 to -80 mV at pH 7.5 and below -50 mV at pH 5.5). Single channel recordings resolved transient multistate pores, strongly resembling those introduced by melittin into artificial bilayers. The pores had diameters in the range of 0.2–1 nm, and lifetimes of few to several hundred milliseconds. The results indicate that nisin has to be regarded as a membrane-depolarizing agent which acts in a voltage-dependent fashion.Abbreviations BLM Black lipid membranes - CCCP carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone - DOPC dioleoyl phosphatidylcholine - PS phosphatidylserine - TPP⁺ tetraphenylphosphonium cation     

Effects of sphingomyelin on melittin pore formation

The effect of sphingomyelin (SM), one of the main lipids in the external monolayer of erythrocyte plasma membrane, on the ability of the hemolytic peptide melittin to permeabilize liposomes was investigated. The peptide induced contents efflux in large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) composed of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC)/SM (1:1 mole ratio), at lower (>1:10,000) peptide-to-lipid mole ratios than in pure POPC (>1:1000) or POPC/1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylglycerol (POPG) (1:1 mole ratio) (>1:300) vesicles. Analysis of the leakage data according to a kinetic model of pore formation showed a good fit for hexameric-octameric pores in SM-containing vesicles, whereas mediocre fits and lower surface aggregation constants were obtained in POPC and POPC/POPG vesicles. Disturbance of lateral separation into solid (s(o)) and liquid-disordered (l(d)) phases in POPC/SM mixtures increased the peptide-dose requirements for leakage. Inclusion of cholesterol (Chol) in POPC/SM mixtures under conditions inducing lateral separation of lipids into liquid-ordered (l(o)) and l(d) phases did not alter the number of melittin peptides required to permeabilize a single vesicle, but increased surface aggregation reversibility. Partitioning into liposomes or insertion into lipid monolayers was not affected by the presence of SM, suggesting that: (i) melittin accumulated at comparable doses in membranes with different SM content, and (ii) differences in leakage were due to promotion of melittin transmembrane pores under coexistence of s(o)-l(d) and l(o)-l(d) phases. Our results support the notion that SM may regulate the stability of size-defined melittin pores in natural membranes.     

What Makes a Good Pore Former: A Study of Synthetic Melittin Derivatives

Pore formation by membrane-active peptides, naturally encountered in innate immunity and infection, could have important medical and technological applications. Recently, the well-studied lytic peptide melittin has formed the basis for the development of combinatorial libraries from which potent pore-forming peptides have been derived, optimized to work under different conditions. We investigate three such peptides, macrolittin70, which is most active at neutral pH; pHD15, which is active only at low pH; and MelP5_Δ6, which was rationally designed to be active at low pH but formed only small pores. There are three, six, and six acidic residues in macrolittin70, pHD15, and MelP5_Δ6, respectively. We perform multi-microsecond simulations in 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) of hexamers of these peptides starting from transmembrane orientations at neutral pH (all residues at standard protonation), low pH (acidic residues and His protonated), and highly acidic environments in which C-termini are also protonated. Previous simulations of the parent peptides melittin and MelP5 in 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) are repeated in POPC. We find that the most potent pore-forming peptides exhibit strong interpeptide interactions, including salt bridges, H-bonds, and polar interactions. Protonation of the C-terminus promotes helicity and pore size. The proximity of the peptides allows fewer lipid headgroups to line the pores than in previous simulations, making the pores intermediate between barrel stave and toroidal. Based on these structures and geometrical arguments, we attempt to rationalize the factors that under different conditions can increase or decrease pore stability and propose mutations that could be tested experimentally.     

Effects of sphingomyelin on melittin pore formation

The effect of sphingomyelin (SM), one of the main lipids in the external monolayer of erythrocyte plasma membrane, on the ability of the hemolytic peptide melittin to permeabilize liposomes was investigated. The peptide induced contents efflux in large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) composed of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC)/SM (1:1 mole ratio), at lower (>1:10,000) peptide-to-lipid mole ratios than in pure POPC (>1:1000) or POPC/1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylglycerol (POPG) (1:1 mole ratio) (>1:300) vesicles. Analysis of the leakage data according to a kinetic model of pore formation showed a good fit for hexameric-octameric pores in SM-containing vesicles, whereas mediocre fits and lower surface aggregation constants were obtained in POPC and POPC/POPG vesicles. Disturbance of lateral separation into solid (s_o) and liquid-disordered (l_d) phases in POPC/SM mixtures increased the peptide-dose requirements for leakage. Inclusion of cholesterol (Chol) in POPC/SM mixtures under conditions inducing lateral separation of lipids into liquid-ordered (l_o) and l_d phases did not alter the number of melittin peptides required to permeabilize a single vesicle, but increased surface aggregation reversibility. Partitioning into liposomes or insertion into lipid monolayers was not affected by the presence of SM, suggesting that: (i) melittin accumulated at comparable doses in membranes with different SM content, and (ii) differences in leakage were due to promotion of melittin transmembrane pores under coexistence of s_o-l_d and l_o-l_d phases. Our results support the notion that SM may regulate the stability of size-defined melittin pores in natural membranes.     

The Structure of a Melittin-Stabilized Pore

Melittin has been reported to form toroidal pores under certain conditions, but the atomic-resolution structure of these pores is unknown. A 9-μs all-atom molecular-dynamics simulation starting from a closely packed transmembrane melittin tetramer in DMPC shows formation of a toroidal pore after 1 μs. The pore remains stable with a roughly constant radius for the rest of the simulation. Surprisingly, one or two melittin monomers frequently transition between transmembrane and surface states. All four peptides are largely helical. A simulation in a DMPC/DMPG membrane did not lead to a stable pore, consistent with the experimentally observed lower activity of melittin on anionic membranes. The picture that emerges from this work is rather close to the classical toroidal pore, but more dynamic with respect to the configuration of the peptides.     

Barrel-stave model or toroidal model? A case study on melittin pores

Transmembrane pores induced by amphiphilic peptides, including melittin, are often modeled with the barrel-stave model after the alamethicin pore. We examine this assumption on melittin by using two methods, oriented circular dichroism (OCD) for detecting the orientation of melittin helix and neutron scattering for detecting transmembrane pores. OCD spectra of melittin were systematically measured. Melittin can orient either perpendicularly or parallel to a lipid bilayer, depending on the physical condition and the composition of the bilayer. Transmembrane pores were detected when the helices oriented perpendicularly to the plane of the bilayers, not when the helices oriented parallel to the bilayers. The evidence that led to the barrel-stave model for alamethicin and that to the toroidal model for magainin were reviewed. The properties of melittin pores are closely similar to that of magainin but unlike that of alamethicin. We conclude that, among naturally produced peptides that we have investigated, only alamethicin conforms to the barrel-stave model. Other peptides, including magainins, melittin and protegrins, all appear to induce transmembrane pores that conform to the toroidal model in which the lipid monolayer bends continuously through the pore so that the water core is lined by both the peptides and the lipid headgroups.     

Interaction of melittin with membrane cholesterol: a fluorescence approach

We have monitored the organization and dynamics of the hemolytic peptide melittin in membranes containing cholesterol by utilizing the intrinsic fluorescence properties of its functionally important sole tryptophan residue and circular dichroism spectroscopy. The significance of this study is based on the fact that the natural target for melittin is the erythrocyte membrane, which contains high amounts of cholesterol. Our results show that the presence of cholesterol inhibits melittin-induced leakage of lipid vesicles and the extent of inhibition appears to be dependent on the concentration of membrane cholesterol. The presence of cholesterol is also shown to reduce binding of melittin to membranes. Our results show that fluorescence parameters such as intensity, emission maximum, and lifetime of membrane-bound melittin indicate a change in polarity in the immediate vicinity of the tryptophan residue probably due to increased water penetration in presence of cholesterol. This is supported by results from fluorescence quenching experiments using acrylamide as the quencher. Membrane penetration depth analysis by the parallax method shows that the melittin tryptophan is localized at a relatively shallow depth in membranes containing cholesterol. Analysis of energy transfer results using melittin tryptophan (donor) and dehydroergosterol (acceptor) indicates that dehydroergosterol is not randomly distributed and is preferentially localized around the tryptophan residue of membrane-bound melittin, even at the low concentrations used. Taken together, our results are relevant in understanding the interaction of melittin with membranes in general, and with cholesterol-containing membranes in particular, with possible relevance to its interaction with the erythrocyte membrane.     

Melittin-lipid bilayer interactions and the role of cholesterol

The membrane-destabilizing effect of the peptide melittin on phosphatidylcholine membranes is modulated by the presence of cholesterol. This investigation shows that inclusion of 40 mol % cholesterol in 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine or 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine liposomes reduces melittin's affinity for the membrane. It is significant that the presence of cholesterol does not increase the amount of membrane-associated melittin needed to cause maximum leakage from, or major structural rearrangements of, the liposomes. Furthermore, comparison of microscopy and leakage data suggests that melittin-induced leakage occurs via different mechanisms in the cholesterol-free and cholesterol-supplemented systems. In the absence of cholesterol, leakage of carboxyfluorescein takes place from intact liposomes in a manner compatible with the presence of small melittin-induced pores. In the presence of cholesterol, on the other hand, adsorption of the peptide causes complete membrane disruption and the formation of long-lived open-bilayer structures. Moreover, in the case of cholesterol-supplemented systems, melittin induces pronounced liposome aggregation. Cryotransmission electron microscopy was used, together with ellipsometry, circular dichroism, turbidity, and leakage measurements, to investigate the effects of melittin on phosphatidylcholine membranes in the absence and presence of cholesterol. The melittin partitioning behavior in the membrane systems was estimated by means of steady-state fluorescence spectroscopy measurements.     

Active,soluble recombinant melittin purified by extracting insoluble lysate of Escherichia coli without denaturation

Cell lytic peptides are a class of drugs that can be used to selectively kill invading organisms or diseased cells. Several of these peptides have been identified as potential therapeutics. Herein, we report a novel process for purifying recombinant melittin, a cell lytic peptide that inserts into the membranes of cells causing cell lysis, from Escherichia coli. The process involves surfactant and low pH to solubilize melittin fusion proteins from the insoluble fraction of bacterial lysates. We are able to significantly improve purity of the final product and confirm the activity of the peptide. The process yields recombinant melittin that is effective when used to treat U‐87 MG glioma cells and inhibits growth of the gram‐positive pathogenic bacterium Streptococcus pyogenes. We demonstrate a method of repeated extraction of the insoluble protein fraction with mild detergent at a low pH that is able to generate a yield of pure, soluble melittin of ～0.5–1 mg/L of E. coli culture. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:1150–1157, 2013     

Osmotic and pH transmembrane gradients control the lytic power of melittin.

Transmembrane osmotic gradients applied on large unilamellar 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine vesicles were used to modulate the potency of melittin to induce leakage. Melittin, an amphipathic peptide, changes the permeability of vesicles, as studied using the release of entrapped calcein, a fluorescent marker. A promotion of the ability of melittin to induce leakage was observed when a hyposomotic gradient (i.e., internal salt concentration higher than the external one) was imposed on the vesicles. It is proposed that structural perturbations caused by the osmotic pressure loosen the compactness of the outer leaflet, which facilitates the melittin-induced change in membrane permeability. Additionally, we have shown that this phenomenon is not due to enhanced binding of melittin to the vesicles using intrinsic fluorescence of the melittin tryptophan. Furthermore, we investigated the possibility of using a transmembrane pH gradient to control the lytic activity of melittin. The potency of melittin in inducing release is known to be inhibited by increased negative surface charge density. A transmembrane pH gradient causing an asymmetric distribution of unprotonated palmitic acid in the bilayer is shown to be an efficient way to modulate the lytic activity of melittin, without changing the overall lipid composition of the membrane. We demonstrate that the protective effect of negatively charged lipids is preserved for asymmetric membranes.     

Aggregation state of melittin in lipid vesicle membranes

We have performed time-resolved fluorescence energy transfer measurements using melittin as donor and a modified melittin as acceptor. The melittin molecules were bound to fluid vesicle membranes of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine. Analysis of the temporal decay of the energy transfer and of its variation with the donor and acceptor concentrations led to the conclusion that melittin in fluid membranes is usually monomeric. Only at the high melittin/lipid molar ratio of 1/200 and high ionic strength evidence for aggregation was obtained, the percentage of aggregated melittin molecules being of the order of 10%. The shortcomings of previous steady-state measurements of fluorescence energy transfer between melittin molecules are discussed.     

Electron microscopic observation of the aggregation of membrane proteins in human erythrocyte by melittin

Human erythrocytes and erythrocyte ghost membranes were treated with native and modified melittins, up to 250 nmol/mg membrane protein. Native melittin induced aggregation of intramembranous particles (IMPs, observed by freeze-fracture electron microscopy), and created large, smooth bilayer areas devoid of IMP. The degree of IMP aggregation increased with increasing concentration of melittin, corresponding to hemolysis results. Membrane ghosts were slightly more susceptible to IMP aggregation than membranes on intact cells. The potency of inducing IMP aggregation was ranked in the order of: native melittin greater than acetylated melittin greater than succinylated melittin = 0. The concentration range of melittin which caused IMP aggregation corresponded to that which caused the immobilization of band 3 proteins as detected by measurement of rotational mobility by transient dichroism (Dufton et al. (1984) Eur. J. Biophys. 11, 17-24). Because both IMP aggregation and band 3 protein immobilization decreased with decreasing positive charge of the melittins used, the nature of melittin-protein interaction is likely to be at least in part electrostatic in the case of human erythrocyte membranes. Possible roles of IMP aggregation and the consequent creation of 'exposed' bilayer areas in the cytotoxic reaction of melittins are discussed.