Electropermeabilization of mammalian cells. Quantitative analysis of the phenomenon.

Transient membrane permeabilization by application of high electric field intensity pulses on cells (electropermeabilization) depends on several physical parameters associated with the technique (pulse intensity, number, and duration). In the present study, electropermeabilization is studied in terms of flow of diffusing molecules between cells and external medium. Direct quantification of the phenomenon shows that electric field intensity is a critical parameter in the induction of permeabilization. Electric field intensity must be higher than a critical threshold to make the membrane permeable. This critical threshold depends on the cell size. Extent of permeabilization (i.e., the flow rate across the membrane) is then controlled by both pulse number and duration. Increasing electric field intensity above the critical threshold needed for permeabilization results in an increase membrane area able to be permeabilized but not due to an increase in the specific permeability of the field alterated area. The electroinduced permeabilization is transient and disappears progressively after the application of the electric field pulses. Its life time is under the control of the electric field parameters. The rate constant of the annealing phase is shown to be dependent on both pulse duration and number, but is independent of electric field intensity which creates the permeabilization. The phenomenon is described in terms of membrane organization transition between the natural impermeable state and the electro-induced permeable state, phenomenon only locally induced for electric field intensities above a critical threshold and expanding in relation to both pulse number and duration.     

An experimental evaluation of the critical potential difference inducing cell membrane electropermeabilization.

When applied on intact cell suspension, electric field pulses are known to induce membrane permeabilization (electropermeabilization) and fusion (electrofusion). These effects are triggered through a modulation of the membrane potential difference. Due to the vectorial character of the electric field effects, this modulation, which is superimposed on the resting membrane potential difference, is position-dependent on the cell surface. This explains the difference between the experimentally observed critical field strengths requested to trigger the processes of permeabilization and fusion. The critical membrane potential difference which induces membrane permeabilization can be calculated from these experimental observations. It is observed that its value is always about 200 mV for many different cell systems as we previously reported in the case of pure lipid vesicles. This is much less than assumed in most previous studies.     

Membrane permeabilization in relation to inactivation kinetics of Lactobacillus species due to pulsed electric fields.

Membrane permeabilization due to pulsed electric field (PEF) treatment of gram-positive Lactobacillus cells was investigated by using propidium iodide uptake and single-cell analysis with flow cytometry. Electric field strength, energy input, treatment time, and growth phase affected membrane permeabilization of Lactobacillus plantarum during PEF treatment. A correlation between PEF inactivation and membrane permeabilization of L. plantarum cells was demonstrated, whereas no relationship was observed between membrane permeabilization and heat inactivation. The same results were obtained with a Lactobacillus fermentum strain, but the latter organism was more PEF resistant and exhibited less membrane permeabilization, indicating that various bacteria have different responses to PEF treatment. While membrane permeabilization was the main factor involved in the mechanism of inactivation, the growth phase and the acidity of the environment also influenced inactivation. By using flow cytometry it was possible to sort cells in the L. plantarum population based on different cell sizes and shapes, and the results were confirmed by image analysis. An apparent effect of morphology on membrane permeabilization was observed, and larger cells were more easily permeabilized than smaller cells. In conclusion, our results indicate that the ability of PEF treatment to cause membrane permeabilization is an important factor in determining inactivation. This finding should have an effect on the final choice of the processing parameters used so that all microorganisms can be inactivated and, consequently, on the use of PEF treatment as an alternative method for preserving food products.     

Membrane Permeabilization in Relation to Inactivation Kinetics of Lactobacillus Species due to Pulsed Electric Fields

Membrane permeabilization due to pulsed electric field (PEF) treatment of gram-positive Lactobacillus cells was investigated by using propidium iodide uptake and single-cell analysis with flow cytometry. Electric field strength, energy input, treatment time, and growth phase affected membrane permeabilization of Lactobacillus plantarum during PEF treatment. A correlation between PEF inactivation and membrane permeabilization of L. plantarum cells was demonstrated, whereas no relationship was observed between membrane permeabilization and heat inactivation. The same results were obtained with a Lactobacillus fermentum strain, but the latter organism was more PEF resistant and exhibited less membrane permeabilization, indicating that various bacteria have different responses to PEF treatment. While membrane permeabilization was the main factor involved in the mechanism of inactivation, the growth phase and the acidity of the environment also influenced inactivation. By using flow cytometry it was possible to sort cells in the L. plantarum population based on different cell sizes and shapes, and the results were confirmed by image analysis. An apparent effect of morphology on membrane permeabilization was observed, and larger cells were more easily permeabilized than smaller cells. In conclusion, our results indicate that the ability of PEF treatment to cause membrane permeabilization is an important factor in determining inactivation. This finding should have an effect on the final choice of the processing parameters used so that all microorganisms can be inactivated and, consequently, on the use of PEF treatment as an alternative method for preserving food products.     

Aspects of plant plasmalemma charging induced by external electric field pulses

The charging of the plasmalemma is a necessary condition for permeabilization of the plasma membrane (electroporation) in response to external electric field exposure. Common theories explain this permeabilization by formation of pores in the lipid bilayer. Using pulsed laser fluorescence microscopy, we measured the charging process of the membrane during the application of an external electric field with a temporal resolution of 5 ns. Visualization of the charging process of protoplasts plasma membrane (Nicotiana tabacum Bright Yellow 2) was achieved by staining of the plasma membrane with the voltage-sensitive fluorescent dye ANNINE-6. Measurements on membranes exhibiting negligible membrane permeabilization confirm the sine-shaped azimuthal distribution of the membrane voltage predicted by the relation of Cole. At higher membrane voltages, enhanced pore formation allows for the exchange of charge carriers, leading to deviations from the sine-shaped curve progression, i.e., a saturation of the membrane voltage at membrane segments facing the electrodes. Additionally, measurements on protoplasts exposed to multiple successive pulses indicate that the recovery of the membrane seems to be a fast process, occurring within seconds after termination of the external electric field pulse.     

Cell synchronization effect on mammalian cell permeabilization and gene delivery by electric field

Electropermeabilization is a promising nonviral method for gene therapy. However, despite the fact that it is widely used to transfer genes into living cells, the steps that limit DNA transfer remain to be determined. Here, we report the effect of cell synchronization on membrane permeabilization and gene delivery by electric fields.Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were synchronized by aphidicolin or butyrate treatment. Electro-mediated transfection of these cells was evaluated under electric field conditions leading to the same level of membrane permeabilization.Aphidicolin cell synchronization in G2/M phase leads to a slight increase in plasma membrane permeabilization but to a three-fold increase in percentage of transfected cells and to an eight-fold increase in gene expression. This increase in cell transfection is specifically due to the G2/M synchronization process. Indeed, cell synchronization in G1 phase by sodium butyrate has no effect on cell permeabilization and transfection.Our results suggest that the enhanced transfection level in G2/M phase is not simply due to enhanced permeabilization, but reinforce the statement that the melting of the nuclear membrane facilitates direct access of plasmid DNA to the nucleus.     

Importance of association between permeabilization and electrophoretic forces for intramuscular DNA electrotransfer

Gene transfer using electrical pulses is a rapidly expanding field. Many studies have been performed in vitro to elucidate the mechanism of DNA electrotransfer. In vivo, the use of efficient procedures for DNA electrotransfer in tissues is recent, and the question of the implied mechanisms is largely open. We have evaluated the effects of various combinations of square wave electric pulses of variable field strength and duration, on cell permeabilization and on DNA transfection in the skeletal muscle in vivo. One high voltage pulse of 800 V/cm, 0.1 ms duration (short high pulse) or a series of four low voltage pulses of 80 V/cm, 83 ms duration (long low pulses) slightly amplified transfection efficacy, while no significant permeabilization was detected using the (51)Cr-EDTA uptake test. By contrast, the combination of one short high pulse followed by four long low pulses led to optimal gene transfer efficiency, while inducing muscle fibers permeabilization. These results are consistent with additive effects of electropermeabilization and DNA electrophoresis on electrotransfer efficiency. Finally, the described new combination, as compared to the previously reported use of repeated identical pulses of intermediate voltage, leads to similar gene transfer efficiency, while causing less permeabilization and thus being likely less deleterious. Thus, combination of pulses of various strengths and durations is a new procedure for skeletal muscle gene transfer that may represents a clear improvement in view of further clinical development.     

Electric Field Orientation for Gene Delivery Using High-Voltage and Low-Voltage Pulses

Electropermeabilization is a biological physical process in response to the presence of an applied electric field that is used for the transfer of hydrophilic molecules such as anticancer drugs or DNA across the plasma membranes of living cells. The molecular processes that support the transfer are poorly known. The aim of our study was to investigate the effect of high-voltage and low-voltage (HVLV) pulses in vitro with different orientations on cell permeabilization, viability and gene transfection. We monitored the permeabilization with unipolar and bipolar HVLV pulses with different train repetition pulses, showing that HVLV pulses increase cell permeabilization and cell viability. Gene transfer was also observed by measuring green fluorescent protein (GFP) expression. The expression was the same for HVLV pulses and electrogenotherapy pulses for in vitro experimentation. As the viability was better preserved for HVLV-pulsed cells, we managed to increase the number of GFP-expressing cells by up to 65?% under this condition. The use of bipolar HVLV train pulses increased gene expression to a higher extent, probably by affecting a larger part of the cell surface.     

Electro-permeabilization of cell membranes: effect of the resting membrane potential

Electric field induced permeabilization of cell membranes is an important technique for gene transfection and cell hybridization. Mechanistic studies of this process revealed that the uptake of fluorescent indicator by plant protoplasts occurs predominantly on the hemisphere facing the positive electrode, while in erythrocyte ghosts the probes exit through the hemisphere facing the negative electrode. To reconcile these observations symmetrical pore formation and a mechanism of molecular exchange by electroosmosis has been proposed. In light of these controversial observations, we conducted a systematic study of electroporation of NIH3T3 cells with varying electric field strength, waveform and frequency. Our data revealed that (i) symmetrical permeabilization of the cell membrane occurs only with bipolar a.c. fields. (ii) When a critical membrane breakdown potential, Vc, is applied using either an unipolar a.c. fields or a single d.c. square pulse, the cell membrane becomes permeabilized only at the hemisphere facing the positive electrode. (iii) When the pulse-induced membrane potential, Vm, is approximately equal to or larger than the intrinsic membrane potential (i.e. using d.c. or unipolar a.c. field), asymmetric permeabilization was observed with the hemisphere facing the positive electrode being most permeable. (iv) The rate of fluorescent indicator uptake is dependent on the concentration of the indicator. These results indicate that electro-permeabilization of cell membranes is affected by its resting potential and that electroosmosis is not the dominant mechanism for the cellular uptake of foreign molecules in electroporation.     

Electrooptics studies of Escherichia coli electropulsation: orientation, permeabilization, and gene transfer.

Fast optical transient signals are suitable approaches to the investigation of the behavior of bacteria during an electric pulse. In a previous work, by a dual approach taking advantage of a video method and a fast kinetic study of the light transmitted across a cell suspension, we showed that a field-induced orientation phenomenon was affecting the rod-shaped bacteria during the pulse (Eynard et al., 1992. Eur. J. Biochem. 209:431-436). In the present work, time courses of electro-induced responses of bacteria during a single square-wave pulse are analyzed. Observations of both the orientation step and the permeabilization process are relevant. These two steps are affected by the addition of DNA. They both obey to a first-order kinetic. The conclusion of this work is that Escherichia coli permeabilization and transformation are multistep processes: orientation (step 1) is followed by an envelope alteration (step 2), all steps being affected by plasmid addition. In the case of E. coli, a rod-shaped bacteria, the orientation process (step 1) brings the cell parallel to the field direction. The pulse duration must be longer than the orientation characteristic time (approximately 1 ms) to trigger an effective permeabilization and its associated events. The permeabilization process (step 2) is associated with a field-induced dipole effect.     

Permeabilization of transformed mouse fibroblasts by 3'-O-(4-benzoyl)benzoyl adenosine 5'-triphosphate and the desensitization of the process

A photoreactive analogue of ATP, 3'-O-(4-benzoyl)benzoyl adenosine 5'-triphosphate (BzATP) altered the plasma membrane permeability of transformed 3T6 mouse fibroblasts to normally impermeant molecules as previously reported for ATP, but at lower concentrations. BzATP-induced permeabilization was modulated by pH, temperature, and the ionic composition of the medium similar to the permeabilizing effects of ATP. Conditions known to enhance ATP-induced permeabilization, such as treatment with the mitochondrial uncoupler carbonyl cyanide-m-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP) or the Ca2+-calmodulin antagonist trifluoperazine also enhanced BzATP-induced permeabilization. Conditions inhibitory to ATP-induced permeabilization, including chloride replacement or treatment with furosemide or dithiothreitol (DTT), inhibited permeabilization induced by BzATP. The ionic strength of the medium modulated the responsiveness of the cells to ATP and BzATP; a decrease in the ionic strength below isotonicity increased the sensitivity of the cells to the nucleotides, whereas an increase in ionic strength above isotonicity inhibited permeabilization. Prolonged exposure to ATP under non-permeabilizing conditions caused the cells to become insensitive to ATP and BzATP. The densensitization phenomenon provides support for the theory that the permeabilization process is mediated by a receptor for ATP.     

In vivo electroporation of skeletal muscle: threshold, efficacy and relation to electric field distribution.

In vivo electroporation is increasingly being used to deliver small molecules as well as DNA to tissues. The aim of this study was to quantitatively investigate in vivo electroporation of skeletal muscle, and to determine the threshold for permeabilization. We designed a quantitative method to study in vivo electroporation, by measuring uptake of (51)Cr-EDTA. As electrode configuration influences electric field (E-field) distribution, we developed a method to calculate this. Electroporation of mouse muscle tissue was investigated using either external plate electrodes or internal needle electrodes placed 4 mm apart, and eight pulses of 99 micros duration at a frequency of 1 Hz. The applied voltage to electrode distance ratio was varied from 0 to 2.0 kV/cm. We found that: (1) the threshold for permeabilization of skeletal muscle tissue using short duration pulses was at an applied voltage to electrode distance ratio of 0.53 kV/cm (+/-0.03 kV/cm), corresponding to an E-field of 0.45 kV/cm; (2) there were two phases in the uptake of (51)Cr-EDTA, the first indicating increasing permeabilization and the second indicating beginning irreversible membrane damage; and (3) the calculated E-field distribution was more homogeneous for plate than for needle electrodes, which was reflected in the experimental results.     

Plant actin controls membrane permeability

The biological effects of electric pulses with low rise time, high field strength, and durations in the nanosecond range (nsPEFs) have attracted considerable biotechnological and medical interest. However, the cellular mechanisms causing membrane permeabilization by nanosecond pulsed electric fields are still far from being understood. We investigated the role of actin filaments for membrane permeability in plant cells using cell lines where different degrees of actin bundling had been introduced by genetic engineering. We demonstrate that stabilization of actin increases the stability of the plasma membrane against electric permeabilization recorded by penetration of Trypan Blue into the cytoplasm. By use of a cell line expressing the actin bundling WLIM domain under control of an inducible promotor we can activate membrane stabilization by the glucocorticoid analog dexamethasone. By total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy we can visualize a subset of the cytoskeleton that is directly adjacent to the plasma membrane. We conclude that this submembrane cytoskeleton stabilizes the plasma membrane against permeabilization through electric pulses.     

Effect of moderate electric field frequency and growth stage on the cell membrane permeability of Lactobacillus acidophilus

Changes in growth kinetics and metabolic activity of microorganisms under the presence of a moderate electric field (MEF) have been hypothesized as being due to temporary permeabilization of cell membranes. We investigated herein the effects of frequency and growth stage on cell membrane permeabilization of Lactobacillus acidophilus OSU 133 during MEF fermentation. Cells were stained with two fluorescent nucleic acid stains: the green, nonselective, cell membrane permeable SYTO 9, and the red, cell membrane impermeable propidium iodide (PI). Fluorescence exhibition post‐treatment was assessed using fluorescence microscopy. Total plate counting was done to determine whether or not the permeabilized population represented live cells. Fermentation treatments investigated were conventional (control) and MEF (2 V/cm, 45, 60, 1,000, 10,000 Hz) at 30°C. Studies were conducted at 45 Hz for lag, exponential, and stationary phases of growth. Low frequency MEF treated cells exhibited significantly greater numbers of red cell counts than conventional treatments; further, no significant differences existed in viable counts between MEF and conventional treatments, suggesting that the red counts represent permeabilized live cells. MEF treatments at the early stage of bacterial growth at 45 Hz exhibited the maximum permeabilization followed by treatments at 60 Hz. MEF treated samples at frequencies higher than 60 Hz did not exhibit red fluorescence. Cells at lag phase showed the greatest susceptibility to permeabilization followed by those at exponential phase. No evidence of electroporation was observed during the stationary phase. To our knowledge, these observations provide the first evidence that cell membrane permeabilization occurs under the presence of electric fields as low as those under MEF. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2009     

Assessment of electroporation by flow cytometry

BACKGROUND: Electroporation accomplishes transient permeabilization of cells and thus aids in the uptake of drugs. The method has been employed clinically in the treatment of dermatological tumors with bleomycin. The conditions of electroporation are still largely empirical and information is lacking as to the interrelationships among voltage pulse height, pulse number and toxicity, cell permeation, drug uptake, and effects on drug toxicity. We used propidium iodide (PI) and flow cytometry to define cell permeation into cytoplasmic and nuclear compartments to determine the improvements of drug toxicity that can be accomplished by electroporation. METHODS: Human squamous carcinoma cells of defined TP53 status and normal human epithelial cells were subjected to electroporation using a square wave pulse generator in the range of 0-5,000 V/cm. Flow cytometry served to establish entry of the drug reporter, PI, into the cytoplasm and nucleus. A dye staining method served to establish cell survival and to determine the toxicity of bleomycin alone, electroporation alone, and electroporation with bleomycin. RESULTS: The electric field intensity (EFI) required to produce 50% permeabilization (EP(50)) is cell type dependent. The EP(50) varied from 1,465 to 2,027 V/cm. An EFI below 900 V/cm is growth stimulatory whereas an EFI in excess of 1,000 V/cm is growth inhibitory. An EFI of 1,000 V/cm is sufficient to increase bleomycin toxicity by a factor of 2-3. A differential electroporation efficiency is observed between normal and tumor cells. CONCLUSIONS: Tumor cells can be targeted preferentially at electroporation voltages where normal cells are less permeable.     

Bax inhibition protects against free fatty acid-induced lysosomal permeabilization

Lysosomal permeabilization is a key feature of hepatocyte lipotoxicity, yet the mechanisms mediating this critical cellular event are unclear. This study examined the mechanisms involved in free fatty acid (FFA)-induced lysosomal permeabilization and the role of Bax, a Bcl-2 family member, in this event. Exposure of liver cells to palmitate induced Bax activation and translocation to lysosomes. Studies to suppress Bax activation either by pharmacological approaches or small interfering-RNA-mediated inhibition of Bax expression showed that lysosomal permeabilization is Bax dependent. In addition, palmitate treatment resulted in a significant decrease in Bcl-X(L), a Bax antagonist. Moreover, forced Bcl-X(L) expression blocked lysosomal permeabilization. Lysosomal permeabilization by FFA was ceramide and caspase independent. Finally, paradigms that inhibit lysosomal permeabilization also reduced apoptosis. In conclusion, these data strongly support a regulatory role for Bax in FFA-mediated lysosomal permeabilization and subsequent cell death.     

Specific detection of RNA molecules by fluorescent in situ hybridization in living cells

The antisense therapeutic strategy makes the assumption that sequence-specific hybridization of an oligonucleotide to its target can take place in living cells. The present work provides a new method for the detection of intracellular RNA molecules using in situ hybridization on living cells. The first step consisted in designing nonperturbant conditions for cell permeabilization using streptolysin O. In a second step, intracellular hybridization specificity was evaluated by incorporating various types of fluorescently labeled nucleic acid probes (plasmids, oligonucleotides). Due to its high expression level, the 28S ribosomal RNA was retained as a model. Results showed that: (1) no significant cell death was observed after permeabilization; (2) on living cells, 28S RNA specific probes provided bright nucleoli and low cytoplasmic signal; (3) control probes did not lead to significant fluorescent staining; and (4) comparison of signals obtained on living and fixed cells showed a colocalization of observed fluorescence. These results indicate the feasibility of specific hybridization of labeled nucleic acid probes under living conditions, after a simple and efficient permeabilization step. This new detection method is of interest for investigating the dynamics of distribution of various gene products in living cells, under normal or pathological conditions.Abbreviations PI propidium iodide - SLO streptolysin O     

Regulation of adenovirus membrane penetration by the cytoplasmic tail of integrin beta5

Adenovirus (Ad) cell entry involves sequential interactions with host cell receptors that mediate attachment (CAR), internalization (alphavbeta3 and alphavbeta5), and penetration (alphavbeta5) of the endosomal membrane. These events allow the virus to deliver its genome to the nucleus. While integrins alphavbeta3 and alphavbeta5 both promote Ad internalization into cells, integrin alphavbeta5 selectively facilitates Ad-mediated membrane permeabilization and endosome rupture. In the experiments reported herein, we demonstrate that the intracellular domain of the integrin beta5 subunit specifically regulates Ad-mediated membrane permeabilization and gene delivery. CS-1 melanoma cells expressing a truncated integrin beta5 or a chimeric (beta5-beta3) cytoplasmic tail (CT) supported normal levels of Ad endocytosis but had reduced Ad-mediated gene delivery and membrane permeabilization relative to cells expressing a wild-type integrin beta5. Thin-section electron microscopy revealed that virion particles were capable of being endocytosed into cells expressing a truncated beta5CT, but they failed to escape cytoplasmic vesicles and translocate to the nucleus. Site-specific mutagenesis studies suggest that a C-terminal TVD motif in the beta5CT plays a major role in Ad membrane penetration.     

Resistance of early stationary phase E. coli to membrane permeabilization by the antimicrobial peptide Cecropin A

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) cause bacterial membrane permeabilization and ultimately cell death at low μM concentrations. The membrane permeabilization action of a moth derived AMP Cecropin A on E. coli cells in exponential growth (mid-log phase) is well studied. At 1× MIC concentration, Cecropin A penetrates the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) barrier and causes outer membrane (OM) and cytoplasmic membrane (CM) permeabilization. For non-septating cells, permeabilization of both membranes begins at one pole. For septating cells, OM permeabilization begins at the septal region and CM permeabilization begins at one pole. However, in nature bacteria are frequently found in nutrient-starved conditions. Here we extend our single-cell microscopy assays to the attack of Cecropin A on E. coli cells in early stationary phase. Stationary phase E. coli is much more resistant to membrane permeabilization by Cecropin A than mid-log phase E. coli. A tenfold higher concentration of Cecropin A is required to observe CM permeabilization in the majority of stationary phase cells, and even then permeabilization proceeds more slowly. In addition, the spatial pattern of initial CM permeabilization changes from localized at one pole to global. Studies of lipid mutant strains suggest that a sufficient localized concentration of the anionic phospholipid phosphatidylglycerol (PG) guides the position of initial attack of the cationic AMP Cecropin A on the CM.     

Hepatitis B virus X protein induces size-selective membrane permeabilization through interaction with cardiolipin

Hepatitis B virus X protein (HBx) functions in a variety of cellular events during the HBV life cycle. In a previous study, we reported that the HBx protein is sufficient to induce mitochondrial membrane permeabilization; however, the exact mechanism of HBx-induced mitochondrial membrane permeabilization has been not proposed. In this study, we report that HBx specifically targets cardiolipin (CL) and induces membrane permeabilization depending on CL concentration in mitochondrial outer membrane–mimic artificial liposomes. Interestingly, HBx-induced membrane permeabilization was enhanced by liposomes containing phosphatidylethanolamine, which plays a crucial role in forming a negative curvature on the membrane. We also show that the 68-117 region of HBx, which interacts with mitochondria, is necessary for membrane permeabilization. We examined the size of the pores formed by HBx and found that HBx permeates fluorescent dyes depending on the hydrodynamic diameter with a pore size of approximately 10 nm. The results of this study suggest that CL is necessary for HBx-induced membrane permeabilization and provide important information that suggests a new strategy for anti-HBV therapy.