Influence of volume dependency and timing of airway occlusions on the Hering-Breuer reflex in infants

Bothend-inspiratory (EIO) and end-expiratory (EEO) airway occlusions areused to calculate the strength of the Hering-Breuer inflation reflex(HBIR) in infants. However, the influence of the timing of suchocclusions is unknown, as is the extent to which changes in volumewithin and above the tidal range affect this reflex. The purpose ofthis study was to compare both techniques and to evaluate the volumedependency of the HBIR in healthy, sleeping infants up to 1 yr of age.The strength of the HBIR was expressed as the ratio of expiratory orinspiratory time during EIO or EEO, respectively, to that recordedduring spontaneous breathing, i.e., as the "inhibitory ratio"(IR). Paired measurements of the EIO and EEO in 26 naturally sleepingnewborn and 15 lightly sedated infants at ~1 yr showed nostatistically significant differences in the IR according to technique:mean (95% CI) of the difference (EIO  EEO) being0.02 (0.17, 0.13) during the first week of life and 0.04 (0.14, 0.22) at 1 yr. During tidalbreathing, a volume threshold of ~4 ml/kg was required to evoke theHBIR. Marked volume and age dependency were observed. In newborninfants, occlusions at ~10 ml/kg during sighs always resulted in anIR > 4, whereas a similar response was only evoked at 25 ml/kg inolder infants. Age-related changes in the volume threshold may reflectmaturational changes in the control of breathing and respiratorymechanics throughout the first year of life.

     

Breathing pattern of anesthetized humans during pancuronium-induced partial paralysis

We investigated the breathing patterns of 17 subjects anesthetized with enflurane before and after partial muscle paralysis produced by pancuronium bromide. In the face of significant muscle weakness produced by pancuronium, breathing patterns are characterized by decreases in both tidal volume and respiratory frequency. The decreased tidal volume corresponded to the decrease in occlusion pressure, indicating that the decreased tidal volume results solely from a decreased contractile force of the respiratory muscles. The decreased respiratory frequency was due to prolongation of both inspiratory and expiratory time without changing the ratio of the inspiratory time to the total breath time. Withdrawal of phasic vagal influence by airway occlusion before partial muscle paralysis revealed that an active Breuer-Hering inflation reflex was operative in only 8 of all 17 subjects. Since the contribution of the Breuer-Hering inflation reflex alone does not seem to account for the consistent decrease in respiratory frequency, some other mechanisms modulating respiratory frequency might be involved in the characteristic breathing patterns during partial muscle paralysis under enflurane anesthesia.     

Persistence of the Hering-Breuer reflex beyond the neonatal period

There is conflicting evidence regarding the persistence of the Hering-Breuer reflex (HBR) beyond the 1st wk of life. This study was designed to assess the influence of postnatal age on the HBR. The airway occlusion technique was used to assess changes in respiratory timing during stimulation of the HBR in healthy full-term unsedated infants measured shortly after birth and at 6-8 wk of life. The strength of the HBR was assessed from the relative change in expiratory time (TE) after end-inspiratory occlusion compared with resting TE during spontaneous breathing. Paired studies were performed in 31 infants at approximately 2 days and 6 wk of age. There was a significant increase in TE during each occlusion in every infant irrespective of age at measurement. No maturational changes were observed. The increase in TE after end-inspiratory occlusion was 91.9 +/- 31.6% (SD) (range 38-158%) at approximately 2 days and 89.8 +/- 30.7% (range 44-175%) at approximately 6 wk. We conclude that the activity of the HBR during tidal breathing persists beyond the neonatal period and that there is no statistically significant change in its strength during the first 2 mo life in healthy infants during natural sleep.     

Expiratory pattern of newborn mammals

The passive mechanical time constant (tau pass) of the respiratory system is relatively similar among newborn mammalian species, approximately 0.15-0.2 s. However, breathing rate (f) is higher in smaller species than larger species in order to accommodate the relatively larger metabolic demands. Since tidal volume per kilogram is an interspecies constant, in the fastest breathing species the short expiratory time should determine a substantial dynamic elevation of the functional residual capacity (FRC). We examined the possibility of a difference in expiratory time constant between dynamic and passive conditions by analyzing the expiratory flow pattern of nine newborn unanesthetized species during resting breathing. In most newborns the late portion of the expiratory flow-volume curve was linear, suggesting muscle relaxation. The slope of the curve, which represents the dynamic expiratory time constant of the respiratory system (tau exp), varied considerably among animals (from 0.1 to 0.7 s), being directly related to the inspiratory time and inversely proportional to f. In relatively slow-breathing newborns, such as infants and piglets, tau exp is longer than tau pass most likely due to an increase in the expiratory laryngeal resistance and FRC is substantially elevated. On the contrary, in the fastest breathing newborns (such as rats and mice) tau exp is similar or even less than tau pass, because at these high rates dynamic lung compliance is lower than its passive value and the dynamic elevation of FRC is small. In dynamic conditions, therefore, the product of tau exp and f is maintained within narrow limits.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Decrease in functional residual capacity during inspiratory loading and the sensation of dyspnea.

The purposes of the present study were to determine the changes in functional residual capacity (FRC) during inspiratory loading and to examine their mechanisms. We studied seven normal subjects seated in a body plethysmograph. In both graded inspiratory elastic (35, 48, and 68 cmH2O/l) and resistive (21, 86, and 192 cmH2O.l-1.s) loading, FRC invariably decreased from control FRC and phasic expiratory activity increased. The reduction in FRC was greater with greater loads. A single inspiratory effort against an inspiratory occlusion at three different target mouth pressures (-25, -50, and -75 cmH2O) and durations (1, 2, and 5 s) also resulted in a decrease in FRC with an increase in expiratory electromyogram activity in the following expiration. The decrease in FRC was greater with greater target pressure and duration. This decrease in FRC is qualitatively similar to that during inspiratory loaded breathing, and we suspect that the same mechanisms are at work. Because neither vagal nor chemoreceptor reflex can account for these responses, we suspect conscious awareness of breathing or behavioral control to be responsible. In an additional study, the sensation of discomfort of breathing during elastic loading decreased with a decrease in FRC. These results suggest that the reduced FRC may be due to behavioral control of breathing to reduce the sensation of dyspnea during inspiratory loading.     

Mechanical role of expiratory muscles during breathing in upright dogs

To examine the mechanical effects of the abdominal and triangularis sterni expiratory recruitment that occurs when anesthetized dogs are tilted head up, we measured both before and after cervical vagotomy the end-expiratory length of the costal and crural diaphragmatic segments and the end-expiratory lung volume (FRC) in eight spontaneously breathing animals during postural changes from supine (0 degree) to 80 degrees head up. Tilting the animals from 0 degree to 80 degrees head up in both conditions was associated with a gradual decrease in end-expiratory costal and crural diaphragmatic length and with a progressive increase in FRC. All these changes, however, were considerably larger (P less than 0.005 or less) postvagotomy when the expiratory muscles were no longer recruited with tilting. Alterations in the elastic properties of the lung could not account for the effects of vagotomy on the postural changes. We conclude therefore that 1) by contracting during expiration, the canine expiratory muscles minimize the shortening of the diaphragm and the increase in FRC that the action of gravity would otherwise introduce, and 2) the end-expiratory diaphragmatic length and FRC in upright dogs are thus actively determined. The present data also indicate that by relaxing at end expiration, the expiratory muscles make a substantial contribution to tidal volume in upright dogs; in the 80 degrees head-up posture, this contribution would amount to approximately 60% of tidal volume.     

Effect of changes in lung volume on respiratory system compliance in newborn infants

Total respiratory system compliance (Crs) at volumes above the tidal volume (VT) was studied by use of the expiratory volume clamping (EVC) technique in 10 healthy sleeping unsedated newborn infants. Flow was measured with a pneumotachograph attached to a face mask and integrated to yield volume. Volume changes were confirmed by respiratory inductance plethysmography. Crs measured by EVC was compared with Crs during tidal breathing determined by the passive flow-volume (PFV) technique. Volume increases of approximately 75% VT were achieved with three to eight inspiratory efforts during expiratory occlusions. Crs above VT was consistently greater than during tidal breathing (P less than 0.0005). This increase in Crs likely reflects recruitment of lung units that are closed or atelectatic in the VT range. Within the VT range, Crs measured by PFV was compared with that obtained by the multiple-occlusion method (MO). PFV yielded greater values of Crs than MO (P less than 0.01). This may be due to braking of expiratory airflow after the release of an occlusion or nonlinearity of Crs. Thus both volume recruitment and airflow retardation may affect the measurement of Crs in unsedated newborn infants.     

Regulation of end-expiratory lung volume during sleep in premature infants

To investigate the regulation of end-expiratory lung volume (EEV) in premature infants, we recorded airflow, tidal volume, diaphragm electromyogram (EMG), and chest wall displacement during sleep. In quiet sleep, EEV during breathing was 10.8 +/- 3.6 (SD) ml greater than the minimum volume reached during unobstructed apneas. In active sleep, no decrease in EEV was observed during 28 of 35 unobstructed apneas. Breaths during quiet sleep had a variable extent of expiratory airflow retardation (braking), and inspiratory interruption occurred at substantial expiratory flow rates. During active sleep, the expiratory flow-volume curve was nearly linear, proceeding nearly to the volume axis at zero flow, and diaphragm EMG activity terminated near the peak of mechanical inspiration. Expiratory duration (TE) and inspiratory duration (TI) were significantly shortened in quiet sleep vs. active sleep although tidal volume was not significantly different. In quiet sleep, diaphragmatic braking activity and shortened TE combined to maintain EEV during breathing substantially above relaxation volume. In active sleep, reduced expiratory braking and prolongation of TE resulted in an EEV that was close to relaxation volume. We conclude that breathing strategy to regulate EEV in premature infants appears to be strongly influenced by sleep state.     

Lung Volume,Breathing Pattern and Ventilation Inhomogeneity in Preterm and Term Infants

Background

Morphological changes in preterm infants with bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD) have functional consequences on lung volume, ventilation inhomogeneity and respiratory mechanics. Although some studies have shown lower lung volumes and increased ventilation inhomogeneity in BPD infants, conflicting results exist possibly due to differences in sedation and measurement techniques.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We studied 127 infants with BPD, 58 preterm infants without BPD and 239 healthy term-born infants, at a matched post-conceptional age of 44 weeks during quiet natural sleep according to ATS/ERS standards. Lung function parameters measured were functional residual capacity (FRC) and ventilation inhomogeneity by multiple breath washout as well as tidal breathing parameters. Preterm infants with BPD had only marginally lower FRC (21.4 mL/kg) than preterm infants without BPD (23.4 mL/kg) and term-born infants (22.6 mL/kg), though there was no trend with disease severity. They also showed higher respiratory rates and lower ratios of time to peak expiratory flow and expiratory time (t _PTEF/t _E) than healthy preterm and term controls. These changes were related to disease severity. No differences were found for ventilation inhomogeneity.

Conclusions

Our results suggest that preterm infants with BPD have a high capacity to maintain functional lung volume during natural sleep. The alterations in breathing pattern with disease severity may reflect presence of adaptive mechanisms to cope with the disease process.     

The Hering-Breuer reflex in anesthetized infants: end-inspiratory vs. end-expiratory occlusion technique

Bothend-inspiratory (EIO) and end-expiratory (EEO) occlusions have beenused to measure the strength of the Hering-Breuer inflation reflex(HBIR) in infants. The purpose of this study was to compare bothtechniques in anesthetized infants. In each infant, HBIR activity wascalculated as the relative prolongation of expiratory and inspiratorytime during EIO and EEO, respectively. Respiratory drive was assessedfrom the change in airway pressure during inspiratory effort againstthe occlusion, both at a fixed time interval of 100 ms(P_0.1) and a fixed proportion(10%) of the occluded inspiratory time(P_10%). Twenty-two infants [age 14.3 ± 6.4 (SD) mo] were studied. No HBIR activitywas present during EIO [11.8 ± 15.9 (SD) %]. Bycontrast, there was significant, albeit weak, reflex activity duringEEO [HBIR: 27.2 ± 17.4%]. A strong HBIR (up to 310%)was elicited in six of seven infants in whom EIO was repeated afterlung inflation. P_0.1 was similar during both types of occlusions, whereas mean ± SDP_10% was lower during EEO thanduring EIO: 0.198 ± 0.09 vs. 0.367 ± 0.15 kPa, respectively(P < 0.01). These data suggest adifference in the central integration of stretch receptor activity ininfants during anesthesia compared with during sleep.

     

Influence of lung volume on oxygen cost of resistive breathing

We examined the relationship between the O2 cost of breathing (VO2 resp) and lung volume at constant load, ventilation, work rate, and pressure-time product in five trained normal subjects breathing through an inspiratory resistance at functional residual capacity (FRC) and when lung volume (VL) was increased to 37 +/- 2% (mean +/- SE) of inspiratory capacity (high VL). High VL was maintained using continuous positive airway pressure of 9 +/- 2 cmH2O and with the subjects coached to relax during expiration to minimize respiratory muscle activity. Six paired runs were performed in each subject at constant tidal volume (0.62 +/- 0.2 liters), frequency (23 +/- 1 breaths/min), inspiratory flow rate (0.45 +/- 0.1 l/s), and inspiratory muscle pressure (45 +/- 2% of maximum static pressure at FRC). VO2 resp increased from 109 +/- 15 ml/min at FRC by 41 +/- 11% at high VL (P less than 0.05). Thus the efficiency of breathing at high VL (3.9 +/- 0.2%) was less than that at FRC (5.2 +/- 0.3%, P less than 0.01). The decrease in inspiratory muscle efficiency at high VL may be due to changes in mechanical coupling, in the pattern of recruitment of the respiratory muscles, or in the intrinsic properties of the inspiratory muscles at shorter length. When the work of breathing at high VL was normalized for the decrease in maximum inspiratory muscle pressure with VL, efficiency at high VL (5.2 +/- 0.3%) did not differ from that at FRC (P less than 0.7), suggesting that the fall in efficiency may have been related to the fall in inspiratory muscle strength. During acute hyperinflation the decreased efficiency contributes to the increased O2 cost of breathing and may contribute to the diminished inspiratory muscle endurance.     

The ventilatory responses of the caecilian Typhlonectes natans to hypoxia and hypercapnia

Typhlonectes natans empty their lungs in a single extended exhalation and subsequently fill their lungs by using a series of 10-20 inspiratory buccal oscillations. These animals always use this breathing pattern, which effectively separates inspiratory and expiratory airflows, unlike most urodele and anuran amphibians that may use one to many buccal oscillations for lung inflation and typically mix expired and inspired gases. Aquatic hypoxia had no significant effect on the breathing pattern or mechanics in these animals. Aerial hypoxia stimulated ventilatory frequency and increased the number of inspiratory oscillations but had little effect on inspiratory and expiratory tidal volume. Aquatic hypercapnia elicited a large significant increase in air-breathing frequency and minute ventilation compared to the small stimulation of minute ventilation seen during aerial hypercapnia. Some animals responded to aquatic hypercapnia with a series of three or four closely spaced breaths separated by long nonventilatory periods. Overall, T. natans showed little capacity to modulate expiratory or inspiratory tidal volumes and depended heavily on changing air-breathing frequency to meet hypoxic and hypercapnic challenges. These responses are different from those of anurans or urodeles studied to date, which modulate both the number of ventilatory oscillations in lung-inflation cycles and the degree of lung inflation when challenged with peripheral or central chemoreceptor stimulation.     

Cough reflex in rabbits 24-h and 48-h after sulphur dioxide breathing

The cough reflex elicitability (CRE), cough reflex strength (CRS) and Hering-Breuer inflation reflex (HBIR) were studied in 51 anaesthetized (Pentobarbital Spofa, 30 mg/kg, i.v.) female rabbits 24-h and 48-h after SO2 breathing. To provoke cough, the interior of the trachea and carina were stroked with a polyethylene catheter. To elicit the HBIR, the lungs were inflated to 1.0 kPa intratracheal pressure. Intrapleural and systemic blood pressures were recorded. The CRE, CRS and HBIR obtained 24-h and 48-h after SO2 breathing were compared with correspondent values of control animals. It was found, that CRE and HBIR were fully recovered 24-h after SO2 breathing, but the CRS was still decreased, however, there were no significant differences in CRE, CRS and HBIR between animals 48-h after SO2 breathing and control animals. It can be concluded, that decrease of the CRS 24-h after SO2 breathing is not due to slowly adapting stretch receptors block of airways.     

Mechanical role of expiratory muscles during breathing in prone anesthetized dogs

The purpose of the present study was to assess the mechanical role of the expiratory muscles during spontaneous breathing in prone animals. The electromyographic (EMG) activity of the triangularis sterni, the rectus abdominis, the external oblique, and the transversus abdominis was studied in 10 dogs light anesthetized with pentobarbital sodium. EMGs were recorded during spontaneous steady-state breathing in supine and prone suspended animals both before and after cervical vagotomy. We also measured the end-expiratory lung volume [functional residual capacity (FRC)] in supine and prone positions to assess the mechanical role of expiratory muscle activation in prone dogs. Spontaneous breathing in the prone posture elicited a significant recruitment of the triangularis sterni, the external oblique, and the transversus abdominis (P less than 0.05). Bilateral cervical vagotomy eliminated the postural activation of the external oblique and the transversus abdominis but not the triangularis sterni. Changes in posture during control and after cervical vagotomy were associated with an increase in FRC. However, changes in FRC, on average, were 132.3 +/- 33.8 (SE) ml larger (P less than 0.01) postvagotomy. We conclude that spontaneous breathing in prone anesthetized dogs is associated with a marked phasic expiratory recruitment of rib cage and abdominal muscles. The present data also indicate that by relaxing at end expiration the expiratory muscles of the abdominal region are directly responsible for generating roughly 40% of the tidal volume.     

Identification of respiratory vagal feedback in awake normal subjects using pseudorandom unloading.

Evidence of the Hering-Breuer reflex has been found in humans during anesthesia and sleep but not during wakefulness. Cortical influences, present during wakefulness, may mask the effects of this reflex in awake humans. We hypothesized that, if lung volume were increased in awake subjects unaware of the stimulus, vagal feedback would modulate breathing on a breath-to-breath basis. To test this hypothesis, we employed proportional assist ventilation in a pseudorandom sequence to unload the respiratory system above and below the perceptual threshold in 17 normal subjects. Tidal volume, integrated respiratory muscle pressure per breath, and inspiratory time were recorded. Both sub- and suprathreshold stimulation evoked a significant increase in tidal volume and inspiratory flow rate, but a significant decrease in inspiratory time was present only during the application of a subthreshold stimulus. We conclude that vagal feedback modulates respiratory timing on a breath-by-breath basis in awake humans, as long as there is no awareness of the stimulus.     

Lung volumes, chest wall configuration, and pattern of breathing in microgravity

We studied the changes in functional residual capacity (FRC), thoracoabdominal volume (Vw), and chest wall configuration in five normal subjects seated in an aircraft flying parabolic trajectories resulting in 20-s periods of microgravity. We measured vital capacity (VC), inspiratory capacity, and tidal volume by integrating airflow at the mouth and changes in rib cage and abdominal volume (delta Vrc and delta Vab, respectively, where delta Vrc + delta Vab = delta Vw) using induction plethysmography. During microgravity (0 Gz) FRC decreased by 413 +/- 70 (SE) ml and VC by 0.37 liter. The decrease in Vw did not differ from that in FRC and was entirely the result of reduction of Vab, the Vrc showing no significant change. During tidal breathing the abdominal contribution (delta Vab/delta Vw) increased from 0.39 +/- 0.08 at 1 Gz to 0.57 +/- 0.08 at 0 Gz. During brief periods of hypergravity (approximately 1.8 Gz) all changes were opposite in sign and relatively smaller. Limited data during "roller coaster" flight patterns suggested that, in contrast to configurational changes, the temporal pattern of breathing was uninfluenced by changes in Gz. We conclude that at the onset of weightlessness there are substantial changes in lung volume and thoracoabdominal configuration. Abdominal contribution to tidal excursions increases but the temporal pattern of breathing is unchanged.     

Inspiratory and expiratory muscle function during continuous positive airway pressure in dogs

Continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) is known to produce activation of the expiratory muscles. Several factors may determine whether this activation can assist inspiration. In this study we asked how and to what extent expiratory muscle contraction can assist inspiration during CPAP. Respiratory muscle response to CPAP was studied in eight supine anesthetized dogs. Lung volume and diaphragmatic initial length were defended by recruitment of the expiratory muscles. At the maximum CPAP of 18 cmH2O, diaphragmatic initial lengths were longer than predicted by the passive relationship by 52 and 46% in the costal and crural diaphragmatic segments, respectively. During tidal breathing after cessation of expiratory muscle activity, a component of passive inspiration occurred before the onset of inspiratory diaphragmatic electromyogram (EMG). At CPAP of 18 cmH2O, passive inspiration represented 24% of the tidal volume (VT) and tidal breathing was within the relaxation characteristic. Diaphragmatic EMG decreased at CPAP of 18 cmH2O; however, VT and tidal shortening were unchanged. We identified passive and active components of inspiration. Passive inspiration was limited by the time between the cessation of expiratory activity and the onset of inspiratory activity. We conclude that increased expiratory activity during CPAP defends diaphragmatic initial length, assists inspiration, and preserves VT. Even though breathing appeared to be an expiratory act, there remained a significant component of active inspiratory diaphragmatic shortening, and the major portion of VT was produced during active inspiration.     

Bradykinin stimulates respiratory drive by activating pulmonary sympathetic afferents in the rabbit.

We recently identified a vagally mediated excitatory lung reflex by injecting hypertonic saline into the lung parenchyma (Yu J, Zhang JF, and Fletcher EC. J Appl Physiol 85: 1485-1492, 1998). This reflex increased amplitude and burst rate of phrenic (inspiratory) nerve activity and suppressed external oblique abdominal (expiratory) muscle activity. In the present study, we tested the hypothesis that bradykinin may activate extravagal pathways to stimulate breathing by assessing its reflex effects on respiratory drive. Bradykinin (1 microg/kg in 0.1 ml) was injected into the lung parenchyma of anesthetized, open-chest and artificially ventilated rabbits. In most cases, bradykinin increased phrenic amplitude, phrenic burst rate, and expiratory muscle activity. However, a variety of breathing patterns resulted, ranging from hyperpnea and tachypnea to rapid shallow breathing and apnea. Bradykinin acts like hypertonic saline in producing hyperpnea and tachypnea, yet the two agents clearly differ. Bradykinin produced a higher ratio of phrenic amplitude to inspiratory time and had longer latency than hypertonic saline. Although attenuated, bradykinin-induced respiratory responses persisted after vagotomy. We conclude that bradykinin activates multiple afferent pathways in the lung; portions of its respiratory reflexes are extravagal and arise from sympathetic afferents.     

Pressure-time product, flow, and oxygen cost of resistive breathing in humans

We examined the relationship between the pressure-time product (Pdt) of the inspiratory muscles and the O2 cost of breathing (VO2 resp) in five normal subjects breathing through an external inspiratory resistance with a tidal volume of 800 ml at a constant end-expiratory lung volume [functional residual capacity, (FRC)]. Each subject performed 30-40 runs, each of approximately 30 breaths, with inspiratory flow rates ranging from 0.26 +/- 0.01 to 0.89 +/- 0.04 l/s (means +/- SE) and inspiratory mouth pressures ranging from 10 +/- 1 to 68 +/- 4% of the maximum inspiratory pressure at FRC. In all subjects VO2 resp was linearly related to Pdt when mean inspiratory flow (VI) was constant, but the slope of this relationship increased with increasing VI. Therefore, Pdt is an accurate index of VO2 resp only when VI is constant. There was a linear relationship between the VO2 resp and the work rate across the external resistance (W) for all runs in each subject over the range of W 10 +/- 1 to 137 +/- 21 J/min. Thus, at a constant tidal volume the VO2 resp was related to the mean inspiratory pressure, independent of flow or inspiratory duration. If the VO2 resp were determined mainly during inspiration, then for a given rate of external work or O2 consumption, VI would be inversely related to mean inspiratory pressure. Efficiency (E) was 2.1 +/- 0.2% and constant over a large range of VI, pressure, work rate, or resistance and was not altered by the presence of a potentially fatiguing load. The constant E over such a wide range of conditions implies a complex integration of the recruitment, mechanical function, and energy consumption of the muscles utilized in breathing.     

O2 cost of inspiratory and expiratory resistive breathing in humans

In six normal male subjects we compared the O2 cost of resistive breathing (VO2 resp) between equivalent external inspiratory (IRL) and expiratory loads (ERL) studied separately. Each subject performed four pairs of runs matched for tidal volume, breathing frequency, flow rates, lung volume, pressure-time product, and work rate. Basal O2 uptake, measured before and after pairs of loaded runs, was subtracted from that measured during resistive breathing to obtain VO2 resp. For an equivalent load, the VO2 resp during ERL (184 +/- 17 ml O2/min) was nearly twice that obtained during IRL (97 +/- 9 ml O2/min). This twofold difference in efficiency between inspiratory and expiratory resistive breathing may reflect the relatively lower mechanical advantage of the expiratory muscles in overcoming respiratory loads. Variable recruitment of expiratory muscles may explain the large variation of results obtained in studies of respiratory muscle efficiency in normal subjects.