Evolution of the iron-responsive element

An RNA hairpin structure referred to as the iron-responsive element (IRE) and iron regulatory proteins (IRPs) are key players in the control of iron metabolism in animal cells. They regulate translation initiation or mRNA stability, and the IRE is found in a variety of mRNAs, such as those encoding ferritin, transferrin receptor (Tfr), erythroid aminolevulinic acid synthase (eALAS), mitochondrial aconitase (mACO), ferroportin, and divalent metal transporter 1 (DMT1). We have studied the evolution of the IRE by considering all mRNAs previously known to be associated with this structure and by computationally examining its occurrence in a large variety of eukaryotic organisms. More than 100 novel sequences together with approximately 50 IREs that were previously reported resulted in a comprehensive view of the phylogenetic distribution of this element. A comparison of the different mRNAs shows that the IREs of eALAS and mACO are found in chordates, those of ferroportin and Tfr1 are found in vertebrates, and the IRE of DMT1 is confined to mammals. In contrast, the IRE of ferritin occurs in a majority of metazoa including lower metazoa such as sponges and Nematostella (sea anemone). These findings suggest that the ferritin IRE represents the ancestral version of this type of translational control and that during the evolution of higher animals the IRE structure was adopted by other genes. On the basis of primary sequence comparison between different organisms, we suggest that some of these IREs developed by "convergent evolution" through stepwise changes in sequence, rather than by recombination events.     

Molecular characterization of the iron binding protein ferritin in Eisenia andrei earthworms

Ferritin is a storage protein that plays a key role in iron metabolism. In this study, we report on the sequence characterization of a ferritin-coding cDNA in Eisenia andrei earthworms isolated by RT-PCR using degenerated primers, and we suggest the presence of a putative IRE in the 5′-UTR of ferritin mRNA. The obtained ferritin sequence was compared with those of other animals showing sequence and structure homology in consensus sites, including the iron-responsive element (IRE) and ferroxidase centers. Despite the sequence homology in the E. andrei mRNA of ferritin with the sequences of other animals in consensus IRE sites, the presented cytosine in the IRE of E. andrei ferritin in the expected position does not form a conventional bulge. The presence of ferritin in the coelomic fluid of E. andrei was proven by iron staining assay. Moreover, aconitase activity in the coelomic fluid was assessed by aconitase assay, suggesting the presence of an iron regulatory protein. Quantitative analysis revealed changes in the gene expression levels of ferritin in coelomocytes in response to bacterial challenge, reaching the maximum level 8 h after the stimulation with both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria.     

Regulation of ferritin and transferrin receptor mRNAs

Iron regulates the synthesis of two proteins critical for iron metabolism, ferritin and the transferrin receptor, through novel mRNA/protein interactions. The mRNA regulatory sequence (iron-responsive element (IRE)) occurs in the 5'-untranslated region of all ferritin mRNAs and is repeated as five variations in the 3'-untranslated region of transferrin receptor mRNA. When iron is in excess, ferritin synthesis and iron storage increase. At the same time, transferrin receptor synthesis and iron uptake decrease. Location of the common IRE regulatory sequence in different noncoding regions of the two mRNAs may explain how iron can have opposite metabolic effects; when the IRE is in the 5'-untranslated region of ferritin mRNA, translation is enhanced by excess iron whereas the presence of the IREs in the 3'-untranslated region of the transferrin receptor mRNA leads to iron-dependent degradation. How and where iron actually acts is not yet known. A soluble 90-kDa regulatory protein which has been recently purified to homogeneity from liver and red cells specifically blocks translation of ferritin mRNA and binds IRE sequences but does not appear to be an iron-binding protein. The protein is the first specific eukaryotic mRNA regulator identified and confirms predictions 20 years old. Concerted regulation by iron of ferritin and transferrin receptor mRNAs may also define a more general strategy for using common mRNA sequences to coordinate the synthesis of metabolically related proteins.     

Ferritin gene organization: Differences between plants and animals suggest possible kingdom-specific selective constraints

Ferritin, a protein widespread in nature, concentrates iron ∼10¹¹–10¹²-fold above the solubility within a spherical shell of 24 subunits; it derives in plants and animals from a common ancestor (based on sequence) but displays a cytoplasmic location in animals compared to the plastid in contemporary plants. Ferritin gene regulation in plants and animals is altered by development, hormones, and excess iron; iron signals target DNA in plants but mRNA in animals. Evolution has thus conserved the two end points of ferritin gene expression, the physiological signals and the protein structure, while allowing some divergence of the genetic mechanisms. Comparison of ferritin gene organization in plants and animals, made possible by the cloning of a dicot (soybean) ferritin gene presented here and the recent cloning of two monocot (maize) ferritin genes, shows evolutionary divergence in ferritin gene organization between plants and animals but conservation among plants or among animals; divergence in the genetic mechanism for iron regulation is reflected by the absence in all three plant genes of the IRE, a highly conserved, noncoding sequence in vertebrate animal ferritin mRNA. In plant ferritin genes, the number of introns (n= 7) is higher than in animals (n= 3). Second, no intron positions are conserved when ferritin genes of plants and animals are compared, although all ferritin gene introns are in the coding region; within kingdoms, the intron positions in ferritin genes are conserved. Finally, secondary protein structure has no apparent relationship to intron/exon boundaries in plant ferritin genes, whereas in animal ferritin genes the correspondence is high. The structural differences in introns/exons among phylogenetically related ferritin coding sequences and the high conservation of the gene structure within plant or animal kingdoms suggest that kingdom-specific functional constraints may exist to maintain a particular intron/exon pattern within ferritin genes. In the case of plants, where ferritin gene intron placement is unrelated to triplet codons or protein structure, and where ferritin is targeted to the plastid, the selection pressure on gene organization may relate to RNA function and plastid/nuclear signaling. Received: 25 July 1995 / Accepted: 3 October 1995     

An mRNA loop/bulge in the ferritin iron-responsive element forms in vivo and Was detected by radical probing with Cu-1,10-phenantholine and iron regulatory protein footprinting.

Messenger RNA (mRNA) regulatory elements often form helices specifically distorted by loops or bulges, which control protein synthesis rates in vitro. Do such three-dimensional RNA structures form in vivo? We now observe formation of the internal loop/bulge (IL/B structure) in the IRE (iron-responsive element) of ferritin mRNA expressed in HeLa cells, using radical cleavage with Cu-phen (Cu-1,10-phenantholine), and protection of the loop/bulge by the regulatory protein (IRP), expressed by cotransfection. Cu-phen, a metal coordination complex (MC) selected because of binding and cleavage at the IL/B in solution, recognized the same site in mRNA in HeLa cells. Endogenous reductants apparently substituted for the sulfhydryl activation of Cu-phen cleavage in solution. Selective RNA IL/B recognition by Cu-phen in vivo is emphasized by resistance to cleavage of a mutated, IL/B IRE in ferritin mRNA. Development of small MCs even more selective than Cu-phen can exploit three-dimensional mRNA or viral RNA structures in vivo to manipulate RNA function. Formation in vivo of the IL/B in the ferritin IRE, which is associated in vitro with greater repression than single IRE structures in other mRNAs, likely contributes to larger derepression of ferritin synthesis in vivo triggered by signals for the IRE/IRP system.     

Alterations in the interaction between iron regulatory proteins and their iron responsive element in normal and Alzheimer's diseased brains.

Iron regulatory proteins (IRPs) are cytoplasmic mRNA binding proteins involved in intracellular regulation of iron homeostasis. IRPs regulate expression of ferritin and transferrin receptor at the mRNA level by interacting with a conserved RNA structure termed the iron-responsive element (IRE). This concordant regulation of transferrin receptors and ferritin is designed so a cell can obtain iron when it is needed, and sequester iron when it is in excess. However, we have reported that iron accumulates in the brain in Alzheimer's disease without a concomitant increase in ferritin. An increase in iron without proper sequestration can increase the vulnerability of cells to oxidative stress. Oxidative stress is a component of many neurological diseases including Alzheimer's. We hypothesized that alterations in the IRP/IRE interaction could be the site at which iron mismanagement occurs in the Alzheimer's brains. In this report we demonstrate that in normal human brain extracts, the IRP is detected as a double IRE/IRP complex by RNA band shift assay, but in 2 of 6 Alzheimer's brain (AD) extracts examined a single IRE/IRP complex was obtained. Furthermore, the mobility of the single IRE/IRP complex in Alzheimer's brain extracts is decreased relative to the double IRE/IRP complex. Western blot and RNA band super shift assay demonstrate that IRP1 is involved in the formation of the single IRE/IRP complex. In vitro analyses suggest that the stability of the doublet complex and single AD complex are different. The single complex from the AD brain are more stable. A more stable IRE/IRP complex in the AD brain could increase stability of the transferrin receptor mRNA and inhibit ferritin synthesis. At the cellular level, the outcome of this alteration in the molecular regulatory mechanism would be increased iron accumulation without an increase in ferritin; identical to the observation we reported in AD brains. The appearance of the single IRE/IRP complex in Alzheimer's brain extracts is associated with relatively high endogenous ribonuclease activity. We propose that elevated RNase activity is one mechanism by which the iron regulatory system becomes dysfunctional.     

The iron-responsive element is the single element responsible for iron-dependent translational regulation of ferritin biosynthesis. Evidence for function as the binding site for a translational repressor

Ferritin, a cytoplasmic protein critical in iron metabolism, displays iron-dependent regulation of its biosynthetic rate with no corresponding changes in mRNA levels. An iron-responsive element (IRE) has been identified in the 5'-untranslated region (UTR) of the human ferritin heavy chain mRNA which, when placed in the 5'-UTR of heterologous reporter genes, confers iron-dependent translational regulation to the hybrid mRNAs. However, whereas the biosynthetic rate of ferritin in response to changes in iron status exhibits a 30-80-fold range, the apparent ranges observed for reporter gene constructs utilizing chloramphenicol acetyltransferase assays or human growth hormone radioimmunoassays have been much less. A deletion and reconstitution study was undertaken to address the possibility that regions of the ferritin gene and mRNA other than the IRE may be necessary for the production of the full range of iron regulation. Data are presented that demonstrate that the IRE alone is capable of conferring iron-dependent translational regulation of biosynthesis to downstream encoded proteins that is both qualitatively and quantitatively similar to that observed with expression of ferritin itself. Thus, the complete range of iron-dependent translational regulation conferred by the IRE occurs independently of the presence of the ferritin promoter, other regions of the ferritin 5'-UTR, the ferritin coding region, and the ferritin 3'-UTR. Additionally, experiments addressing the translatability in vivo of various ferritin construct mRNAs support the theory that the IRE functions as the binding site for a translational repressor.     

Role of RNA secondary structure of the iron-responsive element in translational regulation of ferritin synthesis.

Iron regulates synthesis of the iron storage protein ferritin at the translational level through interaction between a stem-loop structure, the iron-responsive element (IRE), located in the 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR) of ferritin mRNAs, and a protein, the iron regulatory protein (IRP). The role of IRE secondary structure in translational regulation of ferritin synthesis was explored by introducing ferritin constructs containing mutations in the IRE into Rat-2 fibroblasts. Our in vivo studies demonstrate that size and sequence of the loop within the IRE and the distance and/or spatial relationship of this loop to the bulged nucleotide region closest to the loop must be preserved in order to observe iron-dependent translation of ferritin mRNA. In contrast, changes in nucleotide sequence of the upper stem can be introduced without affecting translational regulation in vivo, as long as a stem can be formed. Our in vivo results suggest that only a very small variation in the affinity of interaction of IRP with IRE can be tolerated in order to maintain iron-dependent regulation of translation.     

Structure of the 5'' untranslated regulatory region of ferritin mRNA studied in solution.

Ferritin mRNAs are the first eukaryotic mRNAs for which a conserved, translational regulatory sequence has been identified. The sequence of twenty-eight nucleotides, called the IRE (iron regulatory element), is found in the 5'-noncoding region and is required for enhanced translation of ferritin mRNA by excess cellular iron; regulation occurs at initiation. The prediction of secondary structure in the IRE is a hairpin loop. We now report an analysis of the IRE structure in solution studied in natural ferritin mRNAs [H and H'(M) subunits] by primer extension, after modification or cleavage by dimethyl sulfate, RNAases T1 and V1, and the chemical nuclease 1, 10-phenanthroline-copper (OPCu) which cleaves single-stranded and bulged regions of RNA. Overall, the structure in solution of the ferritin mRNA regulatory region is a hairpin loop, with magnesium-sensitive features, in which half the stem is provided by the IRE and half by flanking regions; only secondary structure is conserved in the flanking regions. Predicted bulges or internal loops along the stem were clearly detected by OPCu but were missed by the more bulky probe RNAase T1, indicating the efficacy of OPCu in probing subtle features of RNA structure. Magnesium-dependent deviations from the predicted structure were observed in the stem between the hairpin loop and the bulge at C6. The location of the IRE in relation to the initiator AUG or the cap is variable in different ferritin mRNAs. However, the number of nucleotides in the base-paired flanking regions of known ferritin mRNAs is proportional to the distance of the IRE from the cap and places the secondary/tertiary structure 8-10 nucleotides from the cap where interference with initiation is likely.