Influence of decorin on the mechanical, compositional, and structural properties of the mouse patellar tendon

The interactions of small leucine-rich proteoglycans (SLRPs) with collagen fibrils, their association with water, and their role in fibrillogenesis suggests that SLRPs may play an important role in tendon mechanics. Some studies have assessed the role of SLRPs in the mechanical response of the tendon, but the relationships between sophisticated mechanics, assembly of collagen, and SLRPs have not been well characterized. Decorin content was varied in a dose dependent manner using decorin null, decorin heterozygote, and wild type mice. Quantitative measures of mechanical (tension and compression), compositional, and structural changes of the mouse patellar tendon were evaluated. Viscoelastic, tensile dynamic modulus was increased in the decorin heterozygous tendons compared to wild type. These tendons also had a significant decrease in total collagen and no structural changes compared to wild type. Decorin null tendons did not have any mechanical changes; however, a significant decrease in the average fibril diameter was found. No differences were seen between genotypes in elastic or compressive properties, and all tendons demonstrated viscoelastic mechanical dependence on strain rate and frequency. These results suggest that decorin, a member of the SLRP family, plays a role in tendon viscoelasticity that cannot be completely explained by its role in collagen fibrillogenesis. In addition, reductions in decorin do not cause large changes in indentation compressive properties, suggesting that other factors contribute to these properties. Understanding these relationships may ultimately help guide development of tissue engineered constructs or treatment modalities.     

Influence of decorin and biglycan on mechanical properties of multiple tendons in knockout mice

Evaluations of tendon mechanical behavior based on biochemical and structural arrangement have implications for designing tendon specific treatment modalities or replacement strategies. In addition to the well studied type I collagen, other important constituents of tendon are the small proteoglycans (PGs). PGs have been shown to vary in concentration within differently loaded areas of tendon, implicating them in specific tendon function. This study measured the mechanical properties of multiple tendon tissues from normal mice and from mice with knock-outs of the PGs decorin or biglycan. Tail tendon fascicles, patellar tendons (PT), and flexor digitorum longus tendons (FDL), three tissues representing different in vivo loading environments, were characterized from the three groups of mice. It was hypothesized that the absence of decorin or biglycan would have individual effects on each type of tendon tissue. Surprisingly, no change in mechanical properties was observed for the tail tendon fascicles due to the PG knockouts. The loss of decorin affected the PT causing an increase in modulus and stress relaxation, but had little effect on the FDL. Conversely, the loss of biglycan did not significantly affect the PT, but caused a reduction in both the maximum stress and modulus of the FDL. These results give mechanical support to previous biochemical data that tendons likely are uniquely tailored to their specific location and function. Variances such as those presented here need to be further characterized and taken into account when designing therapies or replacements for any one particular tendon.     

The mechanical properties of tail tendon fascicles from lubricin knockout, wild type and heterozygous mice

The purpose of this study was to analyze the effects of lubricin on tendon stiffness and viscoelasticity.A total of 36 mice were tested with 12 mice in each of the following groups: lubricin knock-out (−/−), heterozygous (+/−) and wild-type (+/+). A ramp test was used to determine the elastic modulus by pulling the fascicles to 2.5% strain amplitude at a rate of 0.05 mm/s. Then, followed by a relaxation test that pulled the fascicles to 5% strain amplitude at a rate of 2 mm/s. The fascicles were allowed to relax for 2 min at the maximum strain and a single-cycle relaxation ratio was used to characterize viscoelastic properties.There was no significant difference in the Young’s modulus between the three groups (p > 0.05), but the knockout mice had a significantly (p < 0.05) lower relaxation ratio than the wild type mice.Based on these data, we concluded that lubricin expression has an effect on the viscoelastic properties of tendon fascicles. The clinical significance of this finding, if any, remains to be demonstrated.     

Tendon tissue microdamage and the limits of intrinsic repair

The transmission of mechanical muscle force to bone for musculoskeletal stability and movement is one of the most important functions of tendon. The load-bearing tendon core is composed of highly aligned collagen-rich fascicles interspersed with stromal cells (tenocytes). Despite being built to bear very high mechanical stresses, supra-physiological/repetitive mechanical overloading leads to tendon microdamage in fascicles, and potentially to tendon disease and rupture. To date, it is unclear to what extent intrinsic healing mechanisms of the tendon core compartment can repair microdamage. In the present study, we investigated the healing capacity of the tendon core compartment in an ex vivo tissue explant model. To do so, we isolated rat tail tendon fascicles, damaged them by applying a single stretch to various degrees of sub-rupture damage and longitudinally assessed downstream functional and structural changes over a period of several days. Functional damage was assessed by changes in the elastic modulus of the material stress-strain curves, and biological viability of the resident tenocytes. Structural damage was quantified using a fluorescent collagen hybridizing peptide (CHP) to label mechanically disrupted collagen structures. While we observed functional mechanical damage for strains above 2% of the initial fascicle length, structural collagen damage was only detectable for 6% strain and beyond. Minimally loaded/damaged fascicles (2–4% strain) progressively lost elastic modulus over the course of tissue culture, despite their collagen structures remaining intact with high degree of maintained cell viability. In contrast, more severely overloaded fascicles (6–8% strain) with damage at the molecular/collagen level showed no further loss of the elastic modulus but markedly decreased cell viability. Surprisingly, in these heavily damaged fascicles the elastic modulus partially recovered, an effect also seen in further experiments on devitalized fascicles, implying the possibility of a non-cellular but matrix-driven mechanism of molecular repair. Overall, our findings indicate that the tendon core has very little capacity for self-repair of microdamage. We conclude that stromal tenocytes likely do not play a major role in anabolic repair of tendon matrix microdamage, but rather mediate catabolic matrix breakdown and communication with extrinsic cells that are able to effect tissue repair.     

A quantitative investigation of structure-function relationships in a tendon fascicle model

These studies sought to investigate quantitative relationships between the complex composite structure and mechanical properties of tendon. The isolated mouse tail tendon fascicle was chosen as an appropriate model for these so-called "structure-function" investigations. Specifically, collagen fibril diameters and mechanical properties were measured in fascicles from immature (3 week) control, adult (8 week) control, and adult (8 week) MovI3 transgenic mice. Results demonstrated a moderate correlation between mean fibril diameter and fascicle stiffness (r = 0.73, p = 0.001) and maximum load (r = 0.75, p < 0.001), whereas a weak correlation with fascicle modulus (r = 0.39, p = 0.11) and maximum stress (r = 0.48, p = 0.04). An analysis of pooled within-group correlations revealed no strong structure-function trends evidenced at the local or group level, indicating that correlations observed in the general structure-function analyses were due primarily to having three different experimental groups, rather than significant correlations of parameters within the groups.     

Mechanical properties of collagen fascicles from the rabbit patellar tendon

Tensile and viscoelastic properties of collagen fascicles of approximately 300 microns in diameter, which were obtained from rabbit patellar tendons, were studied using a newly designed micro-tensile tester. Their cross-sectional areas were determined with a video dimension analyzer combined with a CCD camera and a low magnification microscope. There were no statistically significant differences in tensile properties among the fascicles obtained from six medial-to-lateral locations of the patellar tendon. Tangent modulus, tensile strength, and strain at failure of the fascicles determined at about 1.5 percent/s strain rate were 216 +/- 68 MPa, 17.2 +/- 4.1 MPa, and 10.9 +/- 1.6 percent (mean +/- S.D.), respectively. These properties were much different from those of bulk patellar tendons; for example, the tensile strength and strain at failure of these fascicles were 42 percent and 179 percent of those of bulk tendons, respectively. Tangent modulus and tensile strength of collagen fascicles determined at 1 percent/s strain rate were 35 percent larger than those at 0.01 percent/s. The strain at failure was independent of strain rate. Relaxation tests showed that the reduction of stress was approximately 25 percent at 300 seconds. These stress relaxation behavior and strain rate effects of collagen fascicles differed greatly from those of bulk tendons. The differences in tensile and viscoelastic properties between fascicles and bulk tendons may be attributable to ground substances, mechanical interaction between fascicles, and the difference of crimp structure of collagen fibrils.     

Specimen dimensions influence the measurement of material properties in tendon fascicles

Stress, strain and modulus are regularly used to characterize material properties of tissue samples. However, when comparing results from different studies it is evident the reported material properties, particularly failure strains, vary hugely. The aim of our study was to characterize how and why specimen length and cross-sectional area (CSA) appear to influence failure stress, strain and modulus in fascicles from two functionally different tendons. Fascicles were dissected from five rat tails and five bovine foot extensors, their diameters determined by a laser micrometer, and loaded to failure at a range of grip-to-grip lengths. Strain to failure significantly decreased with increasing in specimen length in both rat and bovine fascicles, while modulus increased. Specimen length did not influence failure stress in rat tail fascicles, although in bovine fascicles it was significantly lower in the longer 40 mm specimens compared to 5 and 10 mm specimens. The variations in failure strain and modulus with sample length could be predominantly explained by end-effects. However, it was also evident that strain fields along the sample length were highly variable and notably larger towards the ends of the sample than the mid-section even at distances in excess of 5 mm from the gripping points. Failure strain, stress and modulus correlated significantly with CSA at certain specimen lengths. Our findings have implications for the mechanical testing of tendon tissue: while it is not always possible to control for fascicle length and/or CSA, these parameters have to be taken into account when comparing samples of different dimensions.     

In situ cell–matrix mechanics in tendon fascicles and seeded collagen gels: implications for the multiscale design of biomaterials

Designing biomaterials to mimic and function within the complex mechanobiological conditions of connective tissues requires a detailed understanding of the micromechanical environment of the cell. The objective of our study was to measure the in situ cell–matrix strains from applied tension in both tendon fascicles and cell-seeded type I collagen scaffolds using laser scanning confocal microscopy techniques. Tendon fascicles and collagen gels were fluorescently labelled to simultaneously visualise the extracellular matrix and cell nuclei under applied tensile strains of 5%. There were significant differences observed in the micromechanics at the cell–matrix scale suggesting that the type I collagen scaffold did not replicate the pattern of native tendon strains. In particular, although the overall in situ tensile strains in the matrix were quite similar (～2.5%) between the tendon fascicles and the collagen scaffolds, there were significant differences at the cell–matrix boundary with visible shear across cell nuclei of >1 μm measured in native tendon which was not observed at all in the collagen scaffolds. Similarly, there was significant non-uniformity of intercellular strains with relative sliding observed between cell rows in tendon which again was not observed in the collagen scaffolds where the strain environment was much more uniform. If the native micromechanical environment is not replicated in biomaterial scaffolds, then the cells may receive incorrect or mixed mechanical signals which could affect their biosynthetic response to mechanical load in tissue engineering applications. This study highlights the importance of considering the microscale mechanics in the design of biomaterial scaffolds and the need to incorporate such features in computational models of connective tissues.     

Evidence against proteoglycan mediated collagen fibril load transmission and dynamic viscoelasticity in tendon

The glycosaminoglycan (GAG) dermatan sulfate and chondroitin sulfate side-chains of small leucine-rich proteoglycans have been increasingly posited to act as molecular cross links between adjacent collagen fibrils and to directly contribute to tendon elasticity. GAGs have also been implicated in tendon viscoelasticity, supposedly affecting frictional loss during elongation or fluid flow through the extra cellular matrix. The current study sought to systematically test these theories of tendon structure–function by investigating the mechanical repercussions of enzymatic depletion of GAG complexes by chondroitinase ABC in a reproducible tendon structure–function model (rat tail tendon fascicles). The extent of GAG removal (at least 93%) was verified by relevant spectrophotometric assays and transmission electron microscopy. Dynamic viscoelastic tensile tests on GAG depleted rat tail tendon fascicle were not mechanically different from controls in storage modulus (elastic behavior) over a wide range of strain-rates (0.05, 0.5, and 5% change in length per second) in either the linear or nonlinear regions of the material curve. Loss modulus (viscoelastic behavior) was only affected in the nonlinear region at the highest strain-rate, and even this effect was marginal (19% increased loss modulus, p = 0.035). Thus glycosaminoglycan chains of small leucine-rich proteoglycans do not appear to mediate dynamic elastic behavior nor do they appear to regulate the dynamic viscoelastic properties in rat tail tendon fascicles.     

The effect of a lathyritic diet on the sensitivity of tendon to strain rate

While the tensile failure properties of rat-tail tendon depend on strain rate, the sensitivity to strain rate decreases with age, especially during sexual maturation. The object of this study was to determine the effect of an experimental model of chronic lathyrism on age-dependent changes in the sensitivity of developing tendon strength to strain rate. Tensile failure experiments were conducted at high and low strain rate on tendons excised from test and control animals aged 1 to 6 mo. The tensile "yield" response of tendon was significantly affected by the diet resulting in a reduced tensile strength and failure strain. While the sensitivity of tendon failure to strain rate was slightly elevated by the experimental diet, age-dependent changes compared with controls. Since the diet supplement is thought to inhibit covalent crosslinking of collagen in the developing tendon, other factors are likely responsible for decrease in the sensitivity of tendon strength to strain rate during maturation.     

Self-assembly of collagen fibers. Influence of fibrillar alignment and decorin on mechanical properties.

Collagen is the primary structural element in extracellular matrices. In the form of fibers it acts to transmit forces, dissipate energy, and prevent premature mechanical failure in normal tissues. Deformation of collagen fibers involves molecular stretching and slippage, fibrillar slippage, and, ultimately, defibrillation. Our laboratory has developed a process for self-assembly of macroscopic collagen fibers that have structures and mechanical properties similar to rat tail tendon fibers. The purpose of this study is to determine the effects of subfibrillar orientation and decorin incorporation on the mechanical properties of collagen fibers. Self-assembled collagen fibers were stretched 0-50% before cross-linking and then characterized by microscopy and mechanical testing. Results of these studies indicate that fibrillar orientation, packing, and ultimate tensile strength can be increased by stretching. In addition, it is shown that decorin incorporation increases ultimate tensile strength of uncross-linked fibers. Based on the observed results it is hypothesized that decorin facilitates fibrillar slippage during deformation and thereby improves the tensile properties of collagen fibers.     

A novel microstructural approach in tendon viscoelastic modelling at the fibrillar level

Novel applications in rehabilitation, surgery and tissue engineering require the knowledge of the mechanical behaviour of the tissues at microstructural level. The aim of this work is to investigate the viscoelastic properties of the tendon from the interaction of its biological constituents in the fibrillar network. Traction, relaxation and creep in-vitro tests have been performed on porcine flexor digital tendons. A viscoelastic constitutive equation at finite deformation is presented. The fibrillar deformation modes are described through a network of adaptive links between collagen type I and decorin. The theoretical predictions fit accurately the experimental data. The results of the model demonstrate the mechanical importance of glycosaminoglycan chains of decorin for the differential recruitment and the activation of fibrillar collagen.     

Effects of static stress on the mechanical properties of cultured collagen fascicles from the rabbit patellar tendon

In-vitro tissue culture experiments were performed to study the effects of static stress on the mechanical properties of collagen fascicles obtained from the rabbit patellar tendon. After collagen fascicles having the diameter of approximately 300 microm were cultured for 1 and 2 wk under static stress between 0 and 3 MPa, their mechanical properties and crimp morphology were determined using a micro-tensile tester and a light microscope, respectively. The tensile strength and tangent modulus of the fascicles were significantly decreased by culture under no load compared to control fascicles. A statistically significant correlation, which was described by a quadratic curve, was observed between applied stress and tensile strength. The maximum tensile strength (16.7 MPa) was obtained at the applied stress of 1.2 MPa; the strength was within a range of control values. There was a similar correlation between applied stress and tangent modulus, and the modulus was maintained at control level under 1.3 MPa stress. The stress of 1.2 to 1.3 MPa is equivalent to approximately 50 percent of the peak stress developed in the intact rabbit patellar tendon by running. Strain at failure of cultured collagen fascicles was negatively correlated with applied stress, and that at 1.2 to 1.3 MPa stress was almost the same as the control value. Crimp morphology in the fascicles cultured under about 1.2 MPa stress was similar to that in control fascicles. These results indicate that cultured collagen fascicles change the mechanical properties and structure in response to static tensile stress. In addition, their mechanical properties and structure are maintained at control level if the static stress of 50 percent of in-vivo peak stress is applied.     

The role of viscoelasticity of collagen fibers in articular cartilage: theory and numerical formulation

The relative importance of fluid-dependent and fluid-independent transient mechanical behavior in articular cartilage was examined for tensile and unconfined compression testing using a fibril reinforced model. The collagen matrix of articular cartilage was modeled as viscoelastic using a quasi-linear viscoelastic formulation with strain-dependent elastic modulus, while the proteoglycan matrix was considered as linearly elastic. The collagen viscoelastic properties were obtained by fitting experimental data from a tensile test. These properties were used to investigate unconfined compression testing, and the sensitivity of the properties was also explored. It was predicted that the stress relaxation observed in tensile tests was not caused by fluid pressurization at the macroscopic level. A multi-step tensile stress relaxation test could be approximated using a hereditary integral in which the elastic fibrillar modulus was taken to be a linear function of the fibrillar strain. Applying the same formulation to the radial fibers in unconfined compression, stress relaxation could not be simulated if fluid pressurization were absent. Collagen viscoelasticity was found to slightly weaken fluid pressurization in unconfined compression, and this effect was relatively more significant at moderate strain rates. Therefore, collagen viscoelasticity appears to play an import role in articular cartilage in tensile testing, while fluid pressurization dominates the transient mechanical behavior in compression. Collagen viscoelasticity plays a minor role in the mechanical response of cartilage in unconfined compression if significant fluid flow is present.     

Effects of decorin proteoglycan on fibrillogenesis,ultrastructure, and mechanics of type I collagen gels

The proteoglycan decorin is known to affect both the fibrillogenesis and the resulting ultrastructure of in vitro polymerized collagen gels. However, little is known about its effects on mechanical properties. In this study, 3D collagen gels were polymerized into tensile test specimens in the presence of decorin proteoglycan, decorin core protein, or dermatan sulfate (DS). Collagen fibrillogenesis, ultrastructure, and mechanical properties were then quantified using a turbidity assay, 2 forms of microscopy (SEM and confocal), and tensile testing. The presence of decorin proteoglycan or core protein decreased the rate and ultimate turbidity during fibrillogenesis and decreased the number of fibril aggregates (fibers) compared to control gels. The addition of decorin and core protein increased the linear modulus by a factor of 2 compared to controls, while the addition of DS reduced the linear modulus by a factor of 3. Adding decorin after fibrillogenesis had no effect, suggesting that decorin must be present during fibrillogenesis to increase the mechanical properties of the resulting gels. These results show that the inclusion of decorin proteoglycan during fibrillogenesis of type I collagen increases the modulus and tensile strength of resulting collagen gels. The increase in mechanical properties when polymerization occurs in the presence of the decorin proteoglycan is due to a reduction in the aggregation of fibrils into larger order structures such as fibers and fiber bundles.     

The development of structural and mechanical anisotropy in fibroblast populated collagen gels

An in vitro model system was developed to study structure-function relationships and the development of structural and mechanical anisotropy in collagenous tissues. Fibroblast-populated collagen gels were constrained either biaxially or uniaxially. Gel remodeling, biaxial mechanical properties, and collagen orientation were determined after 72 h of culture. Collagen gels contracted spontaneously in the unconstrained direction, uniaxial mechanical constraints produced structural anisotropy, and this structural anisotropy was associated with mechanical anisotropy. Cardiac and tendon fibroblasts were compared to test the hypothesis that tendon fibroblasts should generate greater anisotropy in vitro. However, no differences were seen in either structure or mechanics of collagen gels populated with these two cell types, or between fibroblast populated gels and acellular gels. This study demonstrates our ability to control and measure the development of structural and mechanical anisotropy due to imposed mechanical constraints in a fibroblast-populated collagen gel model system. While imposed constraints were required for the development of anisotropy in this system, active remodeling of the gel by fibroblasts was not. This model system will provide a basis for investigating structure-function relationships in engineered constructs and for studying mechanisms underlying the development of anisotropy in collagenous tissues.     

Recruitment of tendon crimp with applied tensile strain

The tensile stress-strain behavior of ligaments and tendons begins with a toe region that is believed to result from the straightening of crimped collagen fibrils. The in situ mechanical function is mostly confined to this toe region and changes in crimp morphology are believed to be associated with pathological conditions. A relatively new imaging technique, optical coherence tomography (OCT), provides a comparatively inexpensive method for nondestructive investigation of tissue ultrastructure with resolution on the order of 15 microm and the potential for use in a clinical setting. The objectives of this work were to assess the utility of OCT for visualizing crimp period, and to use OCT to determine how crimp period changed as a function of applied tensile strain in rat tail tendon fascicles. Fascicles from rat tail tendons were subjected to 0.5 percent strain increments up to 5 percent and imaged at each increment using OCT. A comparison between OCT images and optical microscopy images taken between crossed polarizing lenses showed a visual correspondence between features indicative of crimp pattern. Crimp pattern always disappeared completely before 3 percent axial strain was reached. Average crimp period increased as strain increased, but both elongation and shortening occurred within single crimp periods during the application of increasing strain to the fascicle.     

Region-specific mechanical properties of the human patella tendon.

The present study investigated the mechanical properties of tendon fascicles from the anterior and posterior human patellar tendon. Collagen fascicles from the anterior and posterior human patellar tendon in healthy young men (mean +/- SD, 29.0 +/- 4.6 yr, n = 6) were tested in a mechanical rig. A stereoscopic microscope equipped with a digital camera recorded elongation. The fascicles were preconditioned five cycles before the failure test based on pilot data on rat tendon fascicle. Human fascicle length increased with repeated cycles (P < 0.05); cycle 5 differed from cycle 1 (P < 0.05), but not cycles 2-4. Peak stress and yield stress were greater for anterior (76.0 +/- 9.5 and 56.6 +/- 10.4 MPa, respectively) than posterior fascicles (38.5 +/- 3.9 and 31.6 +/- 2.9 MPa, respectively), P < 0.05, while yield strain was similar (anterior 6.8 +/- 1.0%, posterior 8.7 +/- 1.4%). Tangent modulus was greater for the anterior (1,231 +/- 188 MPa) than the posterior (583 +/- 122 MPa) fascicles, P < 0.05. In conclusion, tendon fascicles from the anterior portion of the human patellar tendon in young men displayed considerably greater peak and yield stress and tangent modulus compared with the posterior portion of the tendon, indicating region-specific material properties.     

Tensile properties of human collagen fibrils and fascicles are insensitive to environmental salts

To carry out realistic in vitro mechanical testing on anatomical tissue, a choice has to be made regarding the buffering environment. Therefore, it is important to understand how the environment may influence the measurement to ensure the highest level of accuracy. The most physiologically relevant loading direction of tendon is along its longitudinal axis. Thus, in this study, we focus on the tensile mechanical properties of two hierarchical levels from human patellar tendon, namely: individual collagen fibrils and fascicles. Investigations on collagen fibrils and fascicles were made at pH 7.4 in solutions of phosphate-buffered saline at three different concentrations as well as two HEPES buffered solutions containing NaCl or NaCl + CaCl₂. An atomic force microscope technique was used for tensile testing of individual collagen fibrils. Only a slight increase in relative energy dissipation was observed at the highest phosphate-buffered saline concentration for both the fibrils and fascicles, indicating a stabilizing effect of ionic screening, but changes were much less than reported for radial compression. Due to the small magnitude of the effects, the tensile mechanical properties of collagen fibrils and fascicles from the patellar tendon of mature humans are essentially insensitive to environmental salt concentration and composition at physiological pH.     

Assembly of type I collagen: fusion of fibril subunits and the influence of fibril diameter on mechanical properties.

Structural stability of the extracellular matrix is primarily a consequence of fibrillar collagen and the extent of cross-linking. The relationship between collagen self-assembly, consequent fibrillar shape and mechanical properties remains unclear. Our laboratory developed a model system for the preparation of self-assembled type I collagen fibers with fibrillar substructure mimicking the hierarchical structures of tendon. The present study evaluates the effects of pH and temperature during self-assembly on fibrillar structure, and relates the structural effects of these treatments on the uniaxial tensile mechanical properties of self-assembled collagen fibers. Results of the analysis of fibril diameter distributions and mechanical properties of the fibers formed under the different incubation conditions indicate that fibril diameters grow via the lateral fusion of discrete approximately 4 nm subunits, and that fibril diameter correlates positively with the low strain modulus. Fibril diameter did not correlate with either the ultimate tensile strength or the high strain elastic modulus, which suggests that lateral aggregation and consequently fibril diameter influences mechanical properties during small strain mechanical deformation. We hypothesize that self-assembly is mediated by the formation of fibrillar subunits that laterally and linearly fuse resulting in fibrillar growth. Lateral fusion appears important in generating resistance to deformation at low strain, while linear fusion leading to longer fibrils appears important in the ultimate mechanical properties at high strain.