Contribution of circadian physiology and sleep homeostasis to age-related changes in human sleep

The circadian pacemaker and sleep homeostasis play pivotal roles in vigilance state control. It has been hypothesized that age-related changes in the human circadian pacemaker, as well as sleep homeostatic mechanisms, contribute to the hallmarks of age-related changes in sleep, that is, earlier wake time and reduced sleep consolidation. Assessments of circadian parameters in healthy young (∼20-30 years old) and older people (∼65-75 years old)—in the absence of the confounding effects of sleep, changes in posture, and light exposure—have demonstrated that an earlier wake time in older people is accompanied by about a 1h advance of the rhythms of core body temperature and melatonin. In addition, older people wake up at an earlier circadian phase of the body temperature and plasma melatonin rhythm. The amplitude of the endogenous circadian component of the core body temperature rhythm assessed during constant routine and forced desynchrony protocols is reduced by 20-30% in older people. Recent assessments of the intrinsic period of the human circadian pacemaker in the absence of the confounding effects of light revealed no age-related reduction of this parameter in both sighted and blind individuals. Wake maintenance and sleep initiation are not markedly affected by age except that sleep latencies are longer in older people when sleep initiation is attempted in the early morning. In contrast, major age-related reductions in the consolidation and duration of sleep occur at all circadian phases. Sleep of older people is particularly disrupted when scheduled on the rising limb of the temperature rhythm, indicating that the sleep of older people is more susceptible to arousal signals genernpated by the circadian pacemaker. Sleep-homeostatic mechanisms, as assayed by the sleep-deprivation-induced increase of EEG slow-wave activity (SWA), are operative in older people, although during both baseline sleep and recovery sleep SWA in older people remains at lower levels. The internal circadian phase advance of awakening, as well as the age-related reduction in sleep consolidation, appears related to an age-related reduction in the promotion of sleep by the circadian pacemaker during the biological night in combination with a reduced homeostatic pressure for sleep. Early morning light exposure associated with this advance of awakening in older people could reinforce the advanced circadian phase. Quantification of the interaction between sleep homeostasis and circadian rhythmicity contributes to understanding age-related changes in sleep timing and quality. (Chronobiology International, 17(3), 285-311, 2000)     

The Effect of Activity on the Waking Temperature Rhythm in Humans

Nine healthy female subjects were studied when exposed to the natural light-dark cycle, but living for 17 “days” on a 27h day (9h sleep, 18h wake). Since the circadian endogenous oscillator cannot entrain to this imposed period, forced desynchronization between the sleep/activity cycle and the endogenous circadian temperature rhythm took place. This enabled the effects of activity on core temperature to be assessed at different endogenous circadian phases and at different stages of the sleep/activity cycle. Rectal temperature was measured at 6-minute intervals, and the activity of the nondominant wrist was summed at 1-minute intervals. Each waking span was divided into overlapping 3h sections, and each section was submitted to linear regression analysis between the rectal temperatures and the total activity in the previous 30 minutes. From this analysis were obtained the gradient (of the change in rectal temperature produced by a unit change in activity) and the intercept (the rectal temperature predicted when activity was zero). The gradients were subjected to a two-factor analysis of variance (ANOVA) (circadian phase/ time awake). There was no significant effect of time awake, but circadian phase was highly significant statistically. Post hoc tests (Newman-Keuls) indicated that gradients around the temperature peak were significantly less than those around its trough. The intercepts formed a sinusoid that, for the group, showed a mesor (±SE) of 36.97 (±0.12) and amplitude (95% confidence interval) of 0.22°C (0.12°C, 0.32°C). We conclude that this is a further method for removing masking effects from circadian temperature rhythm data in order to assess its endogenous component, a method that can be used when subjects are able to live normally. We suggest also that the decreased effect of activity on temperature when the endogenous circadian rhythm and activity are at their peak will reduce the possibility of hyperthermia.     

CONTRIBUTION OF CIRCADIAN PHYSIOLOGY AND SLEEP HOMEOSTASIS TO AGE-RELATED CHANGES IN HUMAN SLEEP

The circadian pacemaker and sleep homeostasis play pivotal roles in vigilance state control. It has been hypothesized that age-related changes in the human circadian pacemaker, as well as sleep homeostatic mechanisms, contribute to the hallmarks of age-related changes in sleep, that is, earlier wake time and reduced sleep consolidation. Assessments of circadian parameters in healthy young (～20–30 years old) and older people (～65–75 years old)—in the absence of the confounding effects of sleep, changes in posture, and light exposure—have demonstrated that an earlier wake time in older people is accompanied by about a 1h advance of the rhythms of core body temperature and melatonin. In addition, older people wake up at an earlier circadian phase of the body temperature and plasma melatonin rhythm. The amplitude of the endogenous circadian component of the core body temperature rhythm assessed during constant routine and forced desynchrony protocols is reduced by 20–30% in older people. Recent assessments of the intrinsic period of the human circadian pacemaker in the absence of the confounding effects of light revealed no age-related reduction of this parameter in both sighted and blind individuals. Wake maintenance and sleep initiation are not markedly affected by age except that sleep latencies are longer in older people when sleep initiation is attempted in the early morning. In contrast, major age-related reductions in the consolidation and duration of sleep occur at all circadian phases. Sleep of older people is particularly disrupted when scheduled on the rising limb of the temperature rhythm, indicating that the sleep of older people is more susceptible to arousal signals genernpated by the circadian pacemaker. Sleep-homeostatic mechanisms, as assayed by the sleep-deprivation–induced increase of EEG slow-wave activity (SWA), are operative in older people, although during both baseline sleep and recovery sleep SWA in older people remains at lower levels. The internal circadian phase advance of awakening, as well as the age-related reduction in sleep consolidation, appears related to an age-related reduction in the promotion of sleep by the circadian pacemaker during the biological night in combination with a reduced homeostatic pressure for sleep. Early morning light exposure associated with this advance of awakening in older people could reinforce the advanced circadian phase. Quantification of the interaction between sleep homeostasis and circadian rhythmicity contributes to understanding age-related changes in sleep timing and quality. (Chronobiology International, 17(3), 285–311, 2000)     

The Effect of Old Age on the Free-Running Period of Circadian Rhythms in Rat

The free-running period is regarded to be an exclusive feature of the endogenous circadian clock. Changes during aging in the free-running period may therefore reflect age-related changes in the internal organization of this clock. However, the literature on alterations in the free-running period in aging is not unequivocal. In the present study, with various confounding factors kept to a minimum, it was found that the free-running periods for active wakefulness, body temperature, and drinking behavior were significantly shorter (by 12-17 min) in old than in young rats. In addition, it was found that the day-to-day stability of the different sleep states was reduced in old rats, whereas that of the drinking rhythm was enhanced. Transient cycles were not observed, nor were there any age-related differences in daily totals of the various sleep-wake states. The amplitudes of the circadian rhythms of active wakefulness, quiet sleep, and temperature were reduced, whereas those of paradoxical sleep and quiet wakefulness remained unchanged.     

Pineal Gland and Circadian Locomotor Activity Rhythm in the Lacertid Gallotia galloti eisentrauti: Pinealectomy Induces Arrhythmicity

In order to contribute to a comparative view on lacertids, the effect of pinealectomy on the freerunning activity displayed under constant darkness and temperature (27.5°C ± 0.5) has been studied in the lizard Gallotia galloti eisentrauti . Animals showed an entrained motor activity rhythm under an initial light-dark (12:12 hours) routine and freerunning circadian periods ranging between 24.1 and 25.5 h during constant darkness (periodograms obtained by Sokolove & Bushell's method). After pinealectomy, most animals showed no significant circadian rhythm, their locomotor activity becoming diffuse throughout the whole 24 h period. Thus, the pineal gland seems to play an important role as a main pacemaker regulating the endogenous activity rhythm under constant conditions. This result contrasts with that found in Podarcis sicula where after pinealectomy only changes in length of the freerunning period were found.     

Effect of ambient temperature on the circadian activity rhythm in common marmosets, Callithrix j. jacchus (primates)

Whereas the (zeitgeber) effect of ambient temperature T_a and temperature cycles TaC's on circadian rhythmicity has been well documented for heterofhermic mammals, inconsistent results have been obtained for strictly homeothermic species. Hence, it might be inferred that the susceptibility of the mammalian circadian timing system (CTS) to Ta and TaC's depends on the range of the animals' core and/or brain temperature rhythm. This hypothesis was tested in the common marmoset (Callithrix j. jacchus, n=12), a small diurnal primate with an amplitude in body temperature rhythm that is larger than for other homeothermic primates studied so far. Within the range 20-30°C, no systematic effects of constant Ta on most parameters of the marmosets' light-dark (LD)-entrained and free-running circadian activity rhythm (CAR) were found. Significant differences could be established in the average amount of activity per circadian cycle. It was highest at Ta 25°C (LD) and 20°C (light-light, LL) and most probably reflected a temperature-induced masking effect. A 24h trapezoidal TaC of 20:30°C entrained the free-running CAR in two of six marmosets and produced relative coordination in all others. Accordingly, in all animals tested, it had an effect on the CTS. In marmosets free running in LL at a Ta of 20°C or 30°C, 3h warm and cold pulses of 30°C and 20°C, respectively, produced neither systematic phase responses nor period responses of the CAR. So, there is no evidence of a phase-response mechanism underlying circadian entrainment. The results show that large-amplitude TaC's function as a weak zeitgeber for the marmosets' CTS. Since this zeitgeber effect is significantly larger than that found in owl monkeys, the results are consistent with the starting hypothesis that the zeitgeber effect of a given T,C on the mammalian CTS may be related to the amplitude of the species' core and/or brain temperature cycle.     

Forced Desynchrony of Orcadian Rhythms of Body Temperature and Activity in Rats

The daily rhythm in body temperature is thought to be the result of the direct effects of activity and the effects of an endogenous circadian clock. Forced desynchrony (FD) is a tool used in human circadian rhythm research to disentangle endogenous and activity-related effects on daily rhythms. In the present study, we applied an FD protocol to rats. We subjected 8 rats for 5 days to a 20h forced activity cycle consisting of lOh of forced wakefulness and lOh for rest and sleep. The procedure aimed to introduce a lOh sleep/ lOh wake cycle, which period was different from the endogenous circadian (about 24h) rhythm. Of the variation in the raw body temperature data, 68-77% could be explained by a summation of estimated endogenous circadian cycle and forced activity cycle components of body temperature. Free-running circadian periods of body temperature during FD were similar to free-running periods measured in constant conditions. The applied forced activity cycle reduced clock-related circadian modulation of activity. This reduction of circadian modulation of activity did not affect body temperature. Also, the effects of the forced activity on body temperature were remarkably small.     

Lack of evidence that feedback from lifestyle alters the amplitude of the circadian pacemaker in humans

Two groups of healthy subjects were studied indoors, first while living normally for 8 days (control section) and then for 18 × 27h “days” (experimental section). This schedule forces the endogenous (body clock-driven) and exogenous (lifestyle-driven) components of circadian rhythms to run independently. Rectal temperature and wrist movement were measured throughout and used as markers of the amplitude of the circadian rhythm, with the rectal temperature also “purified” by means of the activity record to give information about the endogenous oscillator. Results showed that, during the experimental days, there were changes in the amplitude of the overt temperature rhythm and in the relative amounts of out-of-bed and in-bed activity, both of which indicated an interaction between endogenous and exogenous components of the rhythm. However, the amplitude and the amount of overlap were not significantly different on the control days (when endogenous and exogenous components remained synchronized) and those experimental days when endogenous and exogenous components were only transiently synchronized; also, the amplitudes of purified temperature rhythms did not change significantly during the experimental days in spite of changes in the relationship between the endogenous and exogenous components. Neither result offers support for the view that the exogenous rhythm alters the amplitude of oscillation of the endogenous circadian oscillator in humans.     

Dueling Hypotheses: Circatidal Versus Circalunidian Battle Basics–Second Engagement

The daily rhythm in body temperature is thought to be the result of the direct effects of activity and the effects of an endogenous circadian clock. Forced desynchrony (FD) is a tool used in human circadian rhythm research to disentangle endogenous and activity-related effects on daily rhythms. In the present study, we applied an FD protocol to rats. We subjected 8 rats for 5 days to a 20h forced activity cycle consisting of lOh of forced wakefulness and lOh for rest and sleep. The procedure aimed to introduce a lOh sleep/ lOh wake cycle, which period was different from the endogenous circadian (about 24h) rhythm. Of the variation in the raw body temperature data, 68–77% could be explained by a summation of estimated endogenous circadian cycle and forced activity cycle components of body temperature. Free-running circadian periods of body temperature during FD were similar to free-running periods measured in constant conditions. The applied forced activity cycle reduced clock-related circadian modulation of activity. This reduction of circadian modulation of activity did not affect body temperature. Also, the effects of the forced activity on body temperature were remarkably small.     

Circadian Rhythms and time Measurement in Locomotor Activity of the Scorpion Leiurus Quinquestriatus (Buthidae)

The circadian rhythms of locomotor activity of the scorpion Leiurus quinqueslriatus were examined under different light-dark cycles and in free-running conditions. The circadian rhythm is bimodal in LD 12:12 with alternating cycles of temperature (35°-25°C) with high intensity (1300 lux) or in LD 12: 12 with constant temperature 35° C with 300 lux. In LD 12:12 (1300 lux), in long or in short light spans with constant temperature, the bimodal pattern is slightly changed with the appearance of a third minor peak of activity. In free-running conditions, the bimodal rhythm of locomotor activity persists in DD with T about 24 hr, but in LL the rhythm becomes unimodal with T about 24 hr. Cosinor and power spectrum analysis showed the presence of more than one periodic component. It seems that there is a correlation between the range of light regimens, temperature, light intensity and the coincidence of these components. These components are independently entrained by the environmental light cycle. The mechanism of entrainment of components is discussed.     

A Nonlinear Interrelationship Between Period Length and the Amount of Activity - Age-Dependent changes

The circadian activity rhythm undergoes changes in the course of postnatal development. Experiments without external time cues were performed to characterize the endogenous component and to investigate any age-dependent changes. Female laboratory mice were used. At the beginning of the experiment they were 3 (juvenile), 23 (adult) or 72 (senile) weeks old. Animals were kept in climatic chambers (constant darkness, food and water ad libitum, temperature: 22±2°C, rel. humidity: 55±5%). Locomotor activity was recorded continuously using infrared detectors. The data were stored and analysed by means of the “Chronobiology Kit” (Stanford University). The mean period lengths were not statistically different between age groups. The stability of the spontaneous activity rhythms was highest in adult mice, however. The mean activity/day decreased from juvenile to senile mice. A nonlinear interrelationship between period length and amount of activity was obtained. At lower activity levels the period length became shorter with increasing activity; at higher levels it became longer again. The general shape of the curve was similar in all age groups. With respect to the nonlinear curve, one could not establish a general age dependency of period length. At similar ranges of activity the period length would be shortest in senile animals. Taking into account, however, the decline with age of the amount of activity the period of old mice could be shorter than, equal to or longer than that of adult mice. The results show that the endogenous component of the circadian activity rhythm, including feedback loops, matures and stabilizes from the juvenile to the adult. An expected loss of stability in senile mice was not demonstrated, probably due to a high variance of the animals' biological age. These age-dependent changes contribute to the changes of circadian activity rhythms obtained under entrained conditions.     

Different Behavior of the Circadian Rhythms of Activity and Body Temperature During Resynchronization Following an Advance of the LD Cycle

Spontaneous activity and the body temperature of laboratory mice were recorded telemetrically using implantable transmitters. Following ten control days (L : D = 12 : 12; light from 07:00 to 19:00), the LD cycle was phase-advanced by shortening the light time by 8 h. Recordings were continued for a further 3 weeks. The raw temperature data were unmasked or 'purified' — that is, the temperature changes due to locomotor activity were removed, so revealing the endogenous component of the rhythm — using a regression method previously developed by us. The circadian rhythms of activity and measured body temperature resynchronized on average after 8 days. During resynchronization, both rhythms tended to show two components, one adjusting by a phase advance and the other by a phase delay. However, after purification of the body temperature rhythm, only the advancing component remained. These results indicate that the delaying component of the measured temperature rhythm was caused by masking due to activity, and that the endogenous component of this rhythm did not divide into two components during the resynchronization process. Also, the endogenous component of the circadian rhythm of body temperature and one component of the activity rhythm seemed to be controlled by the same oscillator. It remains uncertain how the other component of the activity rhythm is regulated.     

The Circadian Rhythm of Body Temperature of the Horse

Rectal temperature of 10 female adult horses was recorded every 2 h for 10 consecutive days under a natural winter photoperiod (9 h of light and 15 h of darkness per day). A robust daily rhythm of body temperature was observed in all animals. The rhythm had a mean level of 38.3°C and a range of excursion of 1.0°C. Temperature started its daily ascent at dawn each day and reached a maximum 14 hours later. Body temperature of 5 of the horses was studied for 10 more days under constant illumination. The rhythm persisted under this condition, although with a slightly longer period of 24.2 h, which confirms the endogenous nature of the rhythm. Despite the fact that the body size of the horse is several orders of magnitude greater than that of rodents, the various parameters of the body temperature rhythm of the horse are similar to those of several species of rodents previously studied.     

Different Behavior of the Circadian Rhythms of Activity and Body Temperature During Resynchronization Following an Advance of the LD Cycle

Spontaneous activity and the body temperature of laboratory mice were recorded telemetrically using implantable transmitters. Following ten control days (L : D = 12 : 12; light from 07:00 to 19:00), the LD cycle was phase-advanced by shortening the light time by 8 h. Recordings were continued for a further 3 weeks. The raw temperature data were unmasked or ‘purified’ — that is, the temperature changes due to locomotor activity were removed, so revealing the endogenous component of the rhythm — using a regression method previously developed by us. The circadian rhythms of activity and measured body temperature resynchronized on average after 8 days. During resynchronization, both rhythms tended to show two components, one adjusting by a phase advance and the other by a phase delay. However, after purification of the body temperature rhythm, only the advancing component remained. These results indicate that the delaying component of the measured temperature rhythm was caused by masking due to activity, and that the endogenous component of this rhythm did not divide into two components during the resynchronization process. Also, the endogenous component of the circadian rhythm of body temperature and one component of the activity rhythm seemed to be controlled by the same oscillator. It remains uncertain how the other component of the activity rhythm is regulated.     

Effect of the Ageing on the Circadian Activity in Selected Japanese Quail

Our aim was to study the age-related changes of the rhythm of feeding activity in sexually inactive Japanese quail, Coturnix japonica . For that, we recorded the feeding activity of 16 birds maintained in constant darkness during a fortnight, when they were 1 month old, and when they were 19 ± 3 months old. We used birds from selected lines in order to test individuals of rhythmic and arrhythmic phenotypes. Three parameters were studied: the period, the clarity of the rhythm and the level of activity. All the birds kept the same circadian phenotype during the both recordings. For the rhythmic birds, the circadian period of feeding activity weakly lengthened, but this increase was not statistically significant. For all the birds, the clarity of the circadian rhythm and the level of activity per cycle decreased significantly with ageing. We found a positive relation between the ratios of the correlation coefficients of circadian activity, expressing the clarity of the rhythm, when the birds were young and older. So, it seems that a basic decrease of clarity as well as of level of activity, though these two parameters are not directly linked, take place with ageing. The results are discussed in terms of causal and functional aspects of circadian rhythm of feeding activity.     

Suprachiasmatic nucleus and circadian core temperature rhythm in the rat

Core temperature was telemetered from 26 singly-housed adult male inbred Fischer rats standardized in an ambient temperature of 24 ± 1°C, in light from 0600–1800 alternating with darkness (L:D 12:12), with food and water freely available. The rats were operated upon first for bilateral electrolytic lesioning of the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) or by a sham-operation, which consisted of an inserted electrode which neither penetrated into the SCN area nor was activated to produce a lesion. Next, a temperature sensor was implanted intraperitoneally. The telemetered data obtained at 10-min intervals from each rat were analyzed by the least-squares fit of certain trial periods (cosinor methods). A circadian population rhythm persisted in the SCN-lesioned rats which sustained destruction of both SCN (P < 0.01). The amplitude of the circadian temperature rhythm was attenuated(P < 0.01) and the rhythm's acrophase advanced (P < 0.05) from mid-dark to a time near the transition from light to darkness. Unilateral lesions of the suprachiasmatic nuclei altered the circadain amplitude but not the phasing.     

Effect of light during lactation on the phasic and tonic responses of the rat pacemaker

The circadian system in mammals generates endogenous circadian rhythms and entrains them to external cycles. Here, we examine whether the lighting conditions under which rats are reared affect the properties of the circadian pacemaker. We maintained three groups of rats under constant darkness (DD-rats), constant bright light (LL-rats) or light-dark cycles of 24 hours (LD-rats) during lactation. We then studied motor activity rhythm under constant light of four intensities, and under seven light-dark cycles with periods ranging between 22 and 27 hours. Results show that neither the tau nor the phase angle to the external cycle differed between groups. Differences were found in the amplitude of the circadian rhythm and in the number of rats that became arrhythmic under LL. We conclude that the light received during lactation affects the strength of the circadian pacemaker and its sensitivity to light.     

Circadian modulation of starvation-induced hypothermia in sheep and goats

Prolonged food deprivation is known to cause a fall in the core body temperature of homeotherms. In various species of small birds and mammals (body mass up to 2-3 kg), it has been shown that starvation-induced hypothermia is modulated by the circadian system, in the sense that hypothermia is observed primarily during the inactive phase of the daily activity cycle (i.e., during the night for diurnal animals and during the day for nocturnal animals), whereas relatively normal temperatures are recorded during the active phase. To investigate whether this modulation occurs also in larger animals, we investigated the effects of 4d food deprivation on the body temperature rhythm of goats and sheep (body mass 30-40 kg). In goats, the body temperature rhythm was found to have a mean level of 39.0°C with a mean daily range of excursion of 0.42°C. The daily oscillation in body temperature persisted during the first day of fasting, but the rhythm was drastically damped, if not eliminated, over the next 3 d as body temperature descended from the baseline level of 39.0 to 38.2°C. In sheep, the rhythm was found to have a mean level of 39.3°C with a mean daily range of excursion of 0.34°C. The daily oscillation in body temperature persisted through the 4 d of food deprivation, even though the mean level of body temperature gradually fell. Temperature fell more during the third and fourth nights than during the third and fourth days. Thus, circadian modulation of starvation-induced hypothermia was observed in sheep but not in goats.     

Internal desynchronization of the circadian activity and feeding rhythm in an owl monkey (Aotus lemurinus griseimembra): a case study

In the free-running circadian locomotor activity rhythm of a 7-year-old male owl monkey (Aotus lemurinus griseimembra) kept under constant light and climatic conditions (LL 0.2 lux, 25°C ± 1°C, 60 ± 5% relative humidity [RH]), a second rhythm component developed that showed strong relative coordination with the free-running activity rhythm of 24.4h and a 24h rhythm. The simultaneously recorded feeding activity rhythm strongly resembled this rhythm component. Therefore, it seems justified to infer that there was an internal desynchronization between the two behavioral rhythms or their circadian pacemakers, that is, between the light-entrainable oscillator located in the suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN) and a food-entrainable oscillator located outside the SCN. This internal desynchronization may have been induced and/or maintained by a zeitgeber effect of the (irregular) 24h feeding schedule on the food-entrainable oscillator. The weak relative coordination shown by the activity rhythm indicates a much weaker coupling of the light-entrainable oscillator to the food-entrainable oscillator than vice versa. (Chronobiology International, 17(2), 147-153, 2000)     

Period and phase control in a multioscillatory circadian system (Iguana iguana)

The circadian system of the lizard Iguana iguana is composed of several independent pacemakers that work in concert: the pineal gland, retinae of the lateral eyes, and a fourth oscillator presumed to be located in the hypothalamus. These pacemakers govern the circadian expression of multiple behaviors and physiological processes, including rhythms in locomotor activity, endogenous body temperature, electroretinogram, and melatonin synthesis. The numerous, easily measurable rhythmic outputs make the iguana an ideal organism for examining the contributions of individual oscillators and their interactions in governing the expression of overt circadian rhythms. The authors have examined the effects of pinealectomy and enucleation on the endogenous body temperature rhythm (BTR) and locomotor activity rhythm (LAR) of juvenile iguanas at constant temperature both in LD cycles and in constant darkness (DD). They measured the periods (tau) of the circadian rhythms of LAR and BTR, the phase relationships between them in DD (psiAT), and the phase relationship between each rhythm and the light cycle (psiRL). Pinealectomy lengthened tau of locomotor activity in all animals tested and abolished the BTR in two-thirds of the animals. In those animals in which the BTR did persist following pinealectomy, tau lengthened to the same extent as that of locomotor activity. Pinealectomy also delayed the onset of activity with respect to its normal phase relationship with body temperature in DD. Enucleation alone had no significant effect on tau of LAR or BTR; however, after enucleation, BTR became 180 degrees out of phase from LAR in DD. After both pinealectomy and enucleation, 4 of 16 animals became arrhythmic in both activity and body temperature. Their data suggest that rhythmicity, period, and phase of overt circadian behaviors are regulated through the combined output of multiple endogenous circadian oscillators.