Influence of nearest neighbor sequence on the stability of base pair mismatches in long DNA; determination by temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis.

Temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) was employed to determine the thermal stabilities of 48 DNA fragments that differ by single base pair mismatches. The approach provides a rapid way for studying how specific base mismatches effect the stability of a long DNA fragment. Homologous 373 bp DNA fragments differing by single base pair substitutions in their first melting domain were employed. Heteroduplexes were formed by melting and reannealing pairs of DNAs, one of which was 32P-labeled on its 5'-end. Product DNAs were separated based on their thermal stability by parallel and perpendicular temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis. The order of stability was determined for all common base pairs and mismatched bases in four different nearest neighbor environments; d(GXT).d(AYC), d(GXG).d(CYC), d(CXA).d(TYG), and d(TXT).d(AYA) with X,Y = A, T, C, or G. DNA fragments containing a single mismatch were destabilized by 1 to 5 degrees C with respect to homologous DNAs with complete Watson-Crick base pairing. Both the bases at the mismatch site and neighboring stacking interactions influence the destabilization caused by a mismatch. G.T, G.G and G.A mismatches were always among the most stable mismatches for all nearest neighbor environments examined. Purine.purine mismatches were generally more stable than pyrimidine.pyrimidine mispairs. Our results are in very good agreement with data where available from solution studies of short DNA oligomers.     

Thermodynamics-structure relationship of single mismatches in RNA/DNA duplexes

Thermodynamics of 66 RNA/DNA duplexes containing single mismatches were measured by UV melting methods. Stability enhancements for rG. dT mismatches were the largest of all mismatches examined here, while rU.dG mismatches were not as stable. The methyl group on C5 of thymine enhanced the stability by 0.12 approximately 0.53 kcal mol(-)(1) depending on the identity of adjacent Watson-Crick base pairs, whereas the 2'-hydroxyl group in ribouridine stabilized the duplex by approximately 0.6 kcal mol(-)(1) regardless of the adjacent base pairs. Stabilities induced by the methyl group in thymine, the 2'-hydroxyl group of ribouridine, and an nucleotide exchange at rG.dT and rU.dG mismatches were found to be independent of each other. The order for the mismatch stabilities is rG.dT > rU. dG approximately rG.dG > rA.dG approximately rG.dA approximately rA. dC > rA.dA approximately rU.dT approximately rU.dC > rC.dA approximately rC.dT, although the identity of the adjacent base pairs slightly altered the order. The pH dependence stability and structural changes were suggested for the rA.dG but not for rG.dA mismatches. Comparisons of trinucleotide stabilities for G.T and G.U pairs in RNA, DNA, and RNA/DNA duplexes indicate that stable RNA/DNA mismatches exhibit a stability similar to RNA mismatches while unstable RNA/DNA mismatches show a stability similar to that of DNA mismatches. These results would be useful for the design of antisense oligonucleotides.     

Thermodynamics of DNA duplexes with adjacent G.A mismatches.

The sequence 5'-d(ATGAGCGAAT) forms a very stable self-complementary duplex with four G.A mismatch base pairs (underlined) out of ten total base pairs [Li et al. (1991) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 88, 26-30]. The conformation is in the general B-family and is stabilized by base-pair hydrogen bonding of an unusual type, by favorable base dipole orientations, and by extensive purine-purine stacking at the mismatched sites. We have synthesized 13 decamers with systematic variations in the sequence above to determine how the flanking sequences, the number of G.A mismatches, and the mismatch sequence order (5'-GA-3' or 5'-AG-3') affect the duplex stability. Changing A.T to G.C base pairs in sequences flanking the mismatches stabilizes the duplexes, but only to the extent observed with B-form DNA. The sequence 5'-pyrimidine-GA-purine-3', however, is considerably more stable than 5'-purine-GA-pyrimidine-3'. The most stable sequences with two pairs of adjacent G.A mismatches have thermodynamic parameters for duplex formation that are comparable to those for fully Watson-Crick base-paired duplexes. Similar sequences with single G.A pairs are much less stable than sequences with adjacent G.A mismatches. Reversing the mismatch order from 5'-GA-3' to 5'-AG-3' results in an oligomer that does not form a duplex. These results agree with predictions from the model derived from NMR and molecular mechanics and indicate that the sequence 5'-pyrimidine-GA-purine-3' forms a stable conformational unit that fits quite well into a B-form double helix.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Factors affecting the thermodynamic stability of small asymmetric internal loops in RNA

Optical melting experiments were used to determine the thermodynamic parameters for oligoribonucleotides containing small asymmetric internal loops. The results show a broad range of thermodynamic stabilities, which depend on loop size, asymmetry, sequence, closing base pairs, and length of helix stems. Imino proton NMR experiments provide evidence for possible hydrogen bonding in GA and UU mismatches in some asymmetric loops. The stabilizing effects of GA, GG, and UU mismatches on the thermodynamic stability of internal loops vary depending on the size and asymmetry of the loop. The dependence of loop stability on Watson-Crick closing base pairs may be explained by an account of hydrogen bonds. Models are presented for approximating the free energy increments of 2 x 3 and 1 x 3 internal loops.     

Structural Features and Hydration of d(C-G-C-G-A-A-T-T-A-G-C-G); a Double Helix Containing Two G.A Mispairs

Abstract

Single crystal X-ray diffraction techniques have been used to characterise the molecular structure of the title compound to 2.5Å resolution. The structure consists of ten standard Watson-Crick base pairs and two G.A mismatched base pairs. The purine-purine mismatches have guanine in the usual anti orientation with respect to the sugar and adenine in syn orientation. There are two hydrogen bonds formed between the mismatch bases, N-l and 0–6 of guanine with N-7 and N-6 of adenine respectively. The bulky purine-purine mismatches are accommodated with minor perturbation of the sugar-phosphate backbone. There is a slight improvement in base pair overlap at the mismatch sites. Details of the backbone conformation, base stacking interactions and hydration are presented and compared with those of the parent compound d(C-G-C-G-A-A-T-T-C-G-C-G).     

Structure, dynamics, and thermodynamics of mismatched DNA oligonucleotide duplexes d(CCCAGGG)2 and d(CCCTGGG)2

The structures and hydrogen exchange properties of the mismatched DNA oligonucleotide duplexes d(CCCAGGG)2 and d(CCCTGGG)2 have been studied by high-resolution nuclear magnetic resonance. Both the adenine-adenine and thymine-thymine mismatches are intercalated in the duplexes. The structures of these self-complementary duplexes are symmetric, with the two strands in equivalent positions. The evidence indicates that these mismatches are not stably hydrogen bonded. The mismatched bases in both duplexes are in the anti conformation. The mismatched thymine nucleotide in d(CCCTGGG)2 is intercalated in the duplex with very little distortion of the bases or sugar-phosphate backbone. In contrast, the bases of the adenine-adenine mismatch in d(CCCAGGG)2 must tilt and push apart to reduce the overlap of the amino groups. The thermodynamic data show that the T-T mismatch is less destabilizing than the A-A mismatch when flanked by C-G base pairs in this sequence, in contrast to their approximately equal stabilities when flanked by A-T base pairs in the sequence d(CAAAXAAAG.CTTTYTTTG) where X and Y = A, C, G, and T [Aboul-ela, F., Koh, D., & Tinoco, I., Jr. (1985) Nucleic Acids Res. 13, 4811]. Although the mechanism cannot be determined conclusively from the limited data obtained, exchange of the imino protons with solvent in these destabilized heteroduplexes appears to occur by a cooperative mechanism in which half the helix dissociates.     

Base pairing geometry in GA mismatches depends entirely on the neighboring sequence.

We have synthesized nine self-complementary DNA oligomers containing different flanking sequences adjacent to a pair of contiguous GA mismatches, and have used high resolution nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) to investigate the GpA phosphodiester backbone conformation and mismatch pairing schemes in these duplexes. We found dramatic effects of the flanking base pair on the hydrogen bonding and backbone conformation, which appear to be coupled. Thus the Ganti-Aanti base pairing scheme in a NAGATN sequence switches to a more stable sheared GA base pairing scheme in a NCGAGN or NTGAAN context, while no duplex is formed (or only GA bulges occur) when NAGATN is changed to NGGACN. Furthermore, the more stable sheared GA pairing in NPyGAPuN sequences is associated with a BII rather than BI backbone conformation for the phosphodiester between the adjacent mismatched GA pairs. The overall stability of these adjacent GA mismatches as measured by imino proton n.m.r. studies is Py-GA-Pu > A-GA-T > G-GA-C.     

Structural features and hydration of d(C-G-C-G-A-A-T-T-A-G-C-G); a double helix containing two G.A mispairs

Single crystal X-ray diffraction techniques have been used to characterise the molecular structure of the title compound to 2.5A resolution. The structure consists of ten standard Watson-Crick base pairs and two G.A mismatched base pairs. The purine-purine mismatches have guanine in the usual anti orientation with respect to the sugar and adenine in syn orientation. There are two hydrogen bonds formed between the mismatch bases, N-1 and O-6 of guanine with N-7 and N-6 of adenine respectively. The bulky purine-purine mismatches are accommodated with minor perturbation of the sugar-phosphate backbone. There is a slight improvement in base pair overlap at the mismatch sites. Details of the backbone conformation, base stacking interactions and hydration are presented and compared with those of the parent compound d(C-G-C-G-A-A-T-T-C-G-C-G).     

Thermodynamic and spectroscopic study of bulge loops in oligoribonucleotides

Thermodynamic parameters for bulge loops of one to three nucleotides in oligoribonucleotide duplexes have been measured by optical melting. The results indicate bulges Bn of An and Un have similar stabilities in the duplexes, GCGBmGCG + CGCCGC. The stability increment for a bulge depends on more than its adjacent base pairs. For example, the stability increment for a bulge is affected more than 1 kcal/mol by changing two nonadjacent base pairs or by adding terminal unpaired nucleotides (dangling ends) three base pairs away. Thus a nearest-neighbor approximation for helixes with bulges is oversimplified. Many of the non-self-complementary strands used in this study were observed to form homoduplexes. Such duplexes with GA mismatches were particularly stable.     

G . T base-pairs in a DNA helix: the crystal structure of d(G-G-G-G-T-C-C-C)

The synthetic deoxyoctanucleotide d(G-G-G-G-T-C-C-C) crystallizes as an A-type DNA double helix containing two adjacent G . T base-pair mismatches. The structure has been refined to an R-factor of 14% at 2.1 A resolution with 104 solvent molecules located. The two G . T mismatches adopt the "wobble" form of base-pairing. The mismatched bases are linked by a network of water molecules interacting with the exposed functional groups in both the major and minor grooves. The presence of two mispaired bases in the octamer has surprisingly little effect on the global structure of the helix or the backbone and glycosidic torsional angles. Base stacking around the mismatch is perturbed, but the central G-T step shows particularly good base overlap, which may contribute to the relatively high stability of this oligomer.     

Molecular-Mechanical studies of the mismatched base analogs of d(CGCGAATTCGCG)2:d(CGTGAATTCGCG)2, d(CGAGAATTCGCG)2, d(CGCGAATTCACG)2, d(CGCGAATTCTCG)2, and d(CGCAGAATTCGCG)·d(CGCGAATTCGCG)

Molecular-mechanical simulations have been carried out on “mismatched base” analogs of the DNA double-helical structure d(CGCGAATTCGCG)₂, in which the base pairs CG at the 3 and 10 positions have been replaced by CA, AG, TC, and TG base pairs, as well as an insertion analog in which an extra adenine has been incorporated into one strand of the above structure between bases 3 and 4. The results of these simulations (calculated relative stabilities, structures, and nmr ring-current shifts) have been compared with calorimetric and nmr data. The calculated relative stabilities of the double-helical parent dodecamer and the various “wobble” base pairs qualitatively correlate with the experimental melting temperatures. The base-pairing structure for the GT wobble pair is in agreement with that previously determined from nmr experiments. For the GA base pair, the structure with both bases anti has a slightly more favorable energy from base pairing and stacking than a structure with non-Watson-Crick H-bonding with adenine syn, in agreement with nmr experiments. The CA wobble base is calculated to favor an adenine 6NH₂ …? cytosine N3 H-bond over cytosine 4NH₂ …? adenine N1, again, in agreement with nmr experiments. There is no definitive experimental data on the TC base pair, but the existence of (somewhat long and weak) H-bonds involving cytosine 4NH₂ …? thymine 4CO and cytosine N3 …? thymine HN3 seems reasonable. We find a structure in which the extra adenine base of the insertion analogs sits “inside” the double helix.     

Relative specificities in binding of Watson-Crick base pairs by third strand residues in a DNA pyrimidine triplex motif.

The specificity of binding of Watson-Crick base pairs by third strand nucleic acid residues via triple helix formation was investigated in a DNA pyrimidine triplex motif by thermal melting experiments. The host duplex was of the type A10-X-A10: T10-Y-T10, and the third strand T10-Z-T10, giving rise to 16 possible triplexes with Z:XY inserts, 4 duplexes with the Watson-Crick base pairs (XY) and 12 duplexes with mismatch pairs (XZ), all of whose stabilities were compared. Two Z:XY combinations confirm the primary binding of AT and GC target pairs in homopurine.homopyrimidine sequences by T and C residues, respectively. All other Z:XY combinations in the T:AT environment result in triplex destabilization. While some related observations have been reported, the present experiments differ importantly in that they were performed in a T:AT nearest neighbor environment and at physiological ionic strength and pH, all of which were previously untested. The conclusions now drawn also differ substantially from those in previous studies. Thus, by evaluating the depression in Tm due to base triplet mismatches strictly in terms of third strand residue affinity and specificity for the target base pair, it is shown that none of the triplet combinations that destabilize qualify for inclusion in the third strand binding code for the pyrimidine triplex motif. Hence, none of the mismatch triplets afford a general way of circumventing the requirement for homopurine.homopyrimidine targets when third strands are predominated by pyrimidines, as others have suggested. At the same time, the applicability of third strand binding is emphasized by the finding that triplexes are equally or much more sensitive to base triplet mismatches than are Watson-Crick duplexes to base pair mismatches.     

Kinetics and thermodynamics of double-helix formation of self-complementary deoxyribooctanucleotides d(TCTATAGA) and d(TAGATCTA).

Double-helix formation of self-complementary deoxyribooctanucleotides, d(TCTATAGA) and d(TAGATCTA), with identical nearest neighbor base pairs has been studied by means of UV melting and temperature-jump techniques. The self-complementary duplexes of both octanucleotides with identical nearest neighbors had similar stabilities: The stabilization energies of the octanucleotides at 25 degrees C were 5.8 kcal mol-1 for d(TCTATAGA) and 6.7 kcal mol-1 for d(TAGATCTA). On the kinetic curve the melting reactions finished within 20 ms for d(TCTATAGA) and 40 ms for d(TAGATCTA) at 20 degrees C. For both octanucleotides the rate constants of dissociation increased and the rate constants of association decreased with increasing temperature.     

Design of LNA probes that improve mismatch discrimination

Locked nucleic acids (LNA) show remarkable affinity and specificity against native DNA targets. Effects of LNA modifications on mismatch discrimination were studied as a function of sequence context and identity of the mismatch using ultraviolet (UV) melting experiments. A triplet of LNA residues centered on the mismatch was generally found to have the largest discriminatory power. An exception was observed for G–T mismatches, where discrimination decreased when the guanine nucleotide at the mismatch site or even the flanking nucleotides were modified. Fluorescence experiments using 2-aminopurine suggest that LNA modifications enhance base stacking of perfectly matched base pairs and decrease stabilizing stacking interactions of mismatched base pairs. LNAs do not change the amount of counterions (Na⁺) that are released when duplexes denature. New guidelines are suggested for design of LNA probes, which significantly improve mismatch discrimination in comparison with unmodified DNA probes.     

Comparative Studies of the Thermodynamic Stabilities Between Sheared A:G and Watson-Crick A:U(T) Base Pairs in RNA and DNA

Abstract

Thermodynamic parameters for duplex formation were determined from CD melting curves for r(GGACGAGUCC)₂ and d(GGACGAGTCC)₂, both of which form two consecutive ‘sheared’ A:G base pairs at the center [Katahira et al. (1993) Nucleic Acids Res. 21, 5418–5424; Katahira et al., (1994) Nucleic Acids Res. 22, 2752–27591. The parameters were determined also for r(GGACUAGUCC)₂ and d(GGACTAGTCC)₂, where the A:G mismatches are replaced by Watson-Crick A:U(T) base pairs. Thermodynamic properties for duplex formation are compared between the sheared and the Watson-Crick base pairs, and between RNA and DNA. Difference in the thermodynamic stability is analyzed and discussed in terms of enthalpy and entropy changes. The characteristic features in CD spectra of RNA and DNA containing the sheared A:G base pairs are also reported.

     

Recognition of GT mismatches by Vsr mismatch endonuclease

The Vsr mismatch endonuclease recognises the sequence CTWGG (W = A or T) in which the underlined thymine is paired with guanine and nicks the DNA backbone on the 5'-side of the mispaired thymine. By using base analogues of G and T we have explored the functional groups on the mismatch pair which are recognised by the enzyme. Removal of the thymine 5-methyl group causes a 60% reduction in activity, while removing the 2-amino group of guanine reduces cleavage by 90%. Placing 2-amino-purine or nebularine opposite T generates mis-matches which are cut at a much lower rate (0.1%). When either base is removed, generating a pseudoabasic site (1', 2'-dideoxyribose), the enzyme still produces site-specific cleavage, but at only 1% of the original rate. Although TT and CT mismatches at this position are cleaved at a low rate (approximately 1%), mismatches with other bases (such as GA and AC) and Watson-Crick base pairs are not cleaved by the enzyme. There is also no cleavage when the mismatched T is replaced with difluorotoluene.     

Development of polymer latex particles for selective cleavage of mismatched DNA and their application for DNA diagnosis

We developed functional polymer latex particles that can catch and cleave mismatched DNA selectively and propose a new mismatch detection system using the functional particles. The aimed particles possess two functional units composed of mismatch binding protein (MutS) and an anthraquinone derivative (AQ), a light-activated agent that photocleaves dsDNA. Use of the functional particles made it possible to discriminate complementary and mismatched DNAs and photocleave mismatched DNA selectively. The efficiency of photocleavage of mismatched DNA by the functional particles increased with UV irradiation time. It was also found that the functional particles were reusable and had dissociation constants (K(d)) of 1000 and 68.5 nM for G/C homoduplex and G/T heteroduplex, respectively. Using the functional particles and a dsDNA-binding fluorescent dye, SYBR-Gold, we could construct the system for detection of mismatched DNA that was 40 base pairs. The functional particles prepared in this study will be an absolutely new tool for mismatch detection in DNA diagnosis.     

Homopurine and homopyrimidine strands complementary in parallel orientation form an antiparallel duplex at neutral pH with A-C,G-T,and T-C mismatched base pairs

DNA sequences d-TGAGGAAAGAAGGT (a 14-mer) and d-CTCCTTTCTTCC (a 12-mer) are complementary in parallel orientation forming either Donahue (reverse Watson-Crick) base pairing at neutral pH or Hoogsteen base pairing at slightly acidic pH. The structure of the complex formed by dissolving the two strands in equimolar ratio in water has been investigated by nmr. At neutral pH, the system forms an ordered antiparallel duplex with five A : T and four G : C Watson-Crick base pairs and three mismatches, namely G-T, A-C, and T-C. The nuclear Overhauser effect cross-peak pattern suggests an overall B-DNA conformation with major structural perturbations near the mismatches. The duplex has a low melting point and dissociates directly into single strands with a broad melting profile. The hydrogen-bonding schemes in the mismatched base pairs have been investigated. It has been shown earlier that in acidic pH, the system prefers a triple-stranded structure with two pyrimidine strands and one purine strand. One of the pyrimidine strands has protonated cytosines, forms Hoogsteen base pairing, and is aligned parallel to the purine strand; the other has nonprotonated cytosines and has base-pairing scheme similar to the one discussed in this paper. The parallel duplex is therefore less stable than either the antiparallel duplex or the triplex, in spite of its perfect complementarity. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biopoly 41: 773–784, 1997     

Interaction between the Z-type DNA duplex and 1,3-propanediamine: crystal structure of d(CACGTG)2 at 1.2 A resolution

The crystal structure of a hexamer duplex d(CACGTG)(2) has been determined and refined to an R-factor of 18.3% using X-ray data up to 1.2 A resolution. The sequence crystallizes as a left-handed Z-form double helix with Watson-Crick base pairing. There is one hexamer duplex, a spermine molecule, 71 water molecules, and an unexpected diamine (Z-5, 1,3-propanediamine, C(3)H(10)N(2)) in the asymmetric unit. This is the high-resolution non-disordered structure of a Z-DNA hexamer containing two AT base pairs in the interior of a duplex with no modifications such as bromination or methylation on cytosine bases. This structure does not possess multivalent cations such as cobalt hexaammine that are known to stabilize Z-DNA. The overall duplex structure and its crystal interactions are similar to those of the pure-spermine form of the d(CGCGCG)(2) structure. The spine of hydration in the minor groove is intact except in the vicinity of the T5A8 base pair. The binding of the Z-5 molecule in the minor grove of the d(CACGTG)(2) duplex appears to have a profound effect in conferring stability to a Z-DNA conformation via electrostatic complementarity and hydrogen bonding interactions. The successive base stacking geometry in d(CACGTG)(2) is similar to the corresponding steps in d(CG)(3). These results suggest that specific polyamines such as Z-5 could serve as powerful inducers of Z-type conformation in unmodified DNA sequences with AT base pairs. This structure provides a molecular basis for stabilizing AT base pairs incorporated into an alternating d(CG) sequence.     

Thermodynamic comparison of the base pairs formed by the carcinogenic lesion O6-methylguanine with reference both to Watson-Crick pairs and to mismatched pairs

A set of 10 non-self-complementary nonadeoxyribonucleoside octaphosphates, d(GGTTXTTGG) and d(CCAAYAACC), where X and Y are A, C, G, T, or O6MeG, has been synthesized by a large-scale, automated, phosphoramidite procedure. Purification was effected by reversed-phase HPLC, and the base composition was verified by analytical HPLC after enzymatic degradation to the constituent deoxynucleosides. This set of molecules was designed to allow evaluation of the nearest-neighbor dependence of each base pair. The thermal stability, expressed as Tmax, of each duplex containing one of the O6MeG base pairs, a Watson-Crick pair, or one of the mismatches possible with this set of molecules was determined over a concentration range of 5.7-200 microM. From these data the delta H degree, delta S degree, and delta G degree of each combination were calculated. In general, the relative thermal stabilities observed for the O6-methylguanine combinations confirm our previous findings that the most stable base pair is formed with cytosine rather than thymine and that all O6MeG pairs are much weaker than Watson-Crick base pairs [Kuzmich, S., Marky, L. A., & Jones, R. A. (1983) Nucleic Acids Res. 11, 3393-3404; Gaffney, B. L., Marky, L. A., & Jones, R. A. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 5686-5691]. Moreover, the nine combinations containing O6-methylguanine are all of similar thermal stability, cover a much smaller range in Tmax than do the mismatches, and show little sequence dependence.