Suppression of reaginic antibody formation. III. Relationship between immunogenecity and tolerogenicity of hapten-carrier conjugates.

From the study of the effect of epitope density on the immunogenicity of haptenated ovalbumin (DNP-OA) it was concluded that the lightly haptenated conjugate, DNP0-5-OA, induced, on the one hand, only low titers of anti-DNP hemagglutinating antibody and no reaginic antibodies to the hapten and, on the other, high reaginic and high hemagglutinating antibody responses to the carrier. The conjugate with a slightly higher degree of haptenation, i.e., DNP2.3-OA, induced both reaginic and hemagglutinating antibodies to both the hapten and the carrier. By contrast, the heavily haptenated conjugate, DNP20-OA, elicited reaginic and hemagglutinating antibodies only against the hapten but not against the carrier. Specific suppression of anti-hapten reaginic antibody formation had been achieved by treatment of mice with a tolerogen consisting of the hapten (DNP) conjugated covalently to isologous gamma globulins (MgammaG). The epitope density of the DNPx-MgammaG conjugates was shown to play a dominant role in determining whether or not the conjugate was tolerogenic. Thus, lightly haptenated conjugates (DNP0.5-MgammaG, DNP1.3-MgammaG or DNP1.9-MgammaG) were not tolerogenic, moderately haptenated conjugates (DNP4.2-MgammaG, DNP8-MgammaG, and DNP 14-MgammaG) were tolerogenic, and heavily haptenated conjugates (DNP32-MgammaG and DNP53-MgammaG) were immunogenic, being capable of priming the recipients for the DNP hapten. Further evidence for the nonimmunogenicity of DNP 8-MgammaG conjugate was inferred from its rate of clearance in tolerized and normal mice. Thus, the half-life of 125I-labeled DNP8-MgammaG in circulation was not significantly different for normal and tolerized mice; it was 3.7 and 3.5 days, respectively, which is within the range of data reported for clearance of normal MgammaG. These results suggest that DNP8-MgammaG was catabolized at a rate similar to that of nonconjugated, isologous MgammaG. Moreover, there was no significant difference in the localization of DNP8-MgammaG in identical difference in the localization of DNP8-MgammaG in identical organs (spleen, thymus, kidney, and liver) of normal and tolerized mice. All the multivalent DNPx-MgammaG conjugates were shown to be able to elicit passive cutaneous anaphylaxis (PCA) reaction on i.v. challenge of rats which had been pre-sensitized i.d. with anti-DNP reaginic antibodies.     

Ascaris suum: suppression of reaginic and hemagglutinating antibody responses in the mouse by crude extract and maintenance fluid.

Intraperitoneal administration in mice of crude extract (CE) or maintenance fluid (MF) of Ascaris suum in Freund's incomplete adjuvant (FICA) in doses of 200 and 2 (CE) and 4 μg (MF) on Days ?4, 0, and +4 relative to the day of the immunization with 10 μg of hen egg white lysozyme (HL) resulted in the suppression of anti-HL reaginic antibody responses at varying degrees depending on the dose and their time of administration. Hemagglutinating antibody responses were also affected but in a different manner. Treatment with CE on Day ?4 resulted in complete suppression of reaginic antibody responses and some degree of suppression of hemagglutinating antibody responses depending on the size of the CE dose. In mice pretreated with MF, transient suppression was found only for reaginic antibody responses. In mice receiving the treatment of CE on Day 0, 200 μg of CE caused complete suppression of reaginic antibody responses, while 2 μg was less effective. Hemagglutinating antibody responses were also suppressed in proportion to the dose. Simultaneous treatment with MF did not cause any suppression of either reaginic or hemagglutinating antibody responses. In mice treated with CE on Day +4, reaginic antibody responses were not markedly suppressed and hemagglutinating antibody responses were also not altered. In contrast, treatment with MF on Day +4 resulted in suppression of reaginic antibody responses during the whole course of the primary response, but had no effect on hemagglutinating antibody responses. When MF was administered 7 days after the priming, no suppressive effect on the antibody responses was demonstrated. On the other hand, if a lower dose (1 μg of HL) was used for the priming, the effect of MF treatment with Day +4 was more pronounced in the primary reaginic antibody response and the secondary response was also affected. A comparable suppression of hemagglutinating antibody responses also was observed.     

Suppression of the in vitro secondary antibody response of rabbit lymphoid cells by Concanavalin A.

The effect of various concentrations of concanavalin A (Con A) on the in vitro secondary antibody response of rabbit lymph node and spleen cells to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) was studied. Complete suppression of the IgM plaque-forming cell (PFC) response of both lymph node and spleen cultures was observed when 10 mug/ml of Con A was added at the time of initiation of the cultures whereas only partial suppression was observed when 1 mug/ml of Con A was added. Moreover, marked suppression of the immune responses of both spleen and lymph node cultures was observed when 10 mug/ml of Con A was added at 24 hr after antigenic challenge and to a lesser extent when added at 48 hr. Suppression of the IgM PFC response was also detected when spleen cultures were exposed to 10 mug/ml of Con A for as little as 2 hr after antigenic challenge. However, substantial increases in DNA synthesis were observed only in those cultures which were in contact with Con A for at least 24 hr. Finally evidence is presented that the Con A-induced suppression is mediated by a soluble substance(s).     

Reaginic antibody formation in the mouse. VI. Suppression of IgE and IgG antibody responses to ovalbumin following the administration of high dose urea-denatured antigen.

The major antigenic determinants in ovalbumin molecules (OA) were lost following denaturation in 8 M urea. The urea-denatured antigen (UD-OA) failed to combine with anti-OA antibody, but was capable of priming mouse T cells specific for OA. BDF₁ mice primed with alum-precipitated OA were given three intravenous injections of 100 μg UD-OA at 3, 5, and 7 days after the primary immunization. The treatment with UD-OA suppressed both IgE and IgG antibody responses to OA. The same treatment of OA-primed animals with intravenous injections of OA resulted in suppression of IgE antibody response but enhanced IgG antibody response. Intravenous injections of either OA or UD-OA suppressed both IgE and IgG anti-DNP antibody responses of DNP-OA-primed animals but failed to suppress anti-hapten antibody responses to DNP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin. The effect of the treatment on helper T cells and B memory cells in OA-primed animals was studied by adoptive transfer experiments. The results showed that the OA-treatment as well as UD-OA-treatment suppressed the development of both helper function of T cells and B memory cells in the spleen, but the UD-OA treatment was more effective than OA-treatment for the suppression of B cell development. Possible mechanisms for the suppression of the development of immunocompetent cells were discussed.     

Modulation of help and suppression in a hapten-carrier system.

Provision of beta-galactosidase (GZ) under defined conditions of dose and time can either help or suppress a subsequent response to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-GZ in CBA/J mice. The optimal helper effect occurs when 10(7) spleen cells from mice primed 9 or more days previously with 10 mug GZ are adoptively transferred to irradiated recipients which are than challenged with 10 mug TNP50GZ. Optimum suppression results from the transfer of spleen cells from mice primed 3 days previously with 100 mug GZ and challenge of recipients with TMP150GZ. Both help and suppression are carrier-specific and mediated by T cells. In experiments where helper or suppressor cells were mixed with normal cells, the anti-TNP response was proportional to the number of primed cells transferred. The results point to a wave of suppression as the initial event after immunization, which is succeeded by period in which the helper effect dominates.     

Immunoregulatory function of specific IgG. I. Results in nonatopic subjects

Nonatopic subjects immunized with short ragweed developed both reaginic IgE and blocking IgG antibodies to the antigen. Administration of 250 microgram-specific ragweed IgG antibodies 1 week before, simultaneously, or up to 2 weeks after start of immunization with ragweed extract abrogated the production of anti-ragweed reaginic antibodies which was measured by skin reactivity. Formation of specific ragweed IgG antibodies was unaffected by IgG treatment. These results indicate selective regulation of an immune response in humans by IgG.     

Specific suppression of anti-hapten reaginic antibody titers with hapten-coated liposomes

Reaginic antibodies to DNP and ovalbumin (OA) were induced in B6D2F1 mice by a single i.p. injection of 1 microgram of DNP3-OA suspended with 1 mg of A1(OH)3 in 0.5 ml of saline. The anti-DNP reaginic antibody titers were markedly depressed by treatment of mice with DNP-coated liposomes. This treatment, however, did not affect the level of antibody formation to OA.     

Suppression and contrasuppression in the induction of contact sensitivity by the administration of cellbound antigen-antibody complexes

The tolerogenic signal produced by the i.v. injection of haptenated peritoneal exudate cells can be converted to an immunogenic signal by treating the cells with antibody to the hapten before administration. We examined this phenomenon and found that immunity induced by antigen-antibody complexes, as opposed to skin sensitization, is resistant to suppressor T cell influences. This resistance to suppression is due to the activation of an I-J+, Ly-1 T cell population which adheres to the Vicia villosa lectin, all characteristics of contrasuppressor T cells. Because haptenated cells can induce immunity if injected subcutaneously or into cyclophosphamide-pretreated recipients (thereby avoiding the induction of suppressor cells), we suggest that the activation of contrasuppressor cells by antigen-antibody complexes overrides suppressive influences in the host, allowing immunity to become dominant. The possible roles of suppression and contrasuppression in channeling the effector arm of the immune response (e.g., contact sensitivity vs humoral immunity) are discussed.     

Effect of Isomeric cis-Octadecenoic Acids on the Growth of Leptospira interrogans Serotype patoc

Leptospira interrogans serotype patoc exhibited an increasing growth response when cultivated in media containing from 50 to 250 mug of sodium oleate per ml. Leptospiral growth in the presence of 250 mug of sodium oleate per ml was as good as that in the basal medium which contained 700 mug of oleic acid (in Tween 80) per ml. When positional isomers of oleic acid (9-octadecenoic acid) were present at a concentration of 200 mug/ml, the 2- and 8-isomers were not readily utilized, whereas the 3-, 4-, 6-, 11-, 15-, and 16-isomers gave a growth response equivalent to that of oleic acid, i.e., the 9-isomer. The 5-, 7-, 10-, 12-, 13-, 14-, and 17-isomers of octadecenoic acid induced growth responses which differed in magnitude but were intermediate to those of 2-18:1 and 3-18:1. When 200 mug of either 2- or 3-octadecenoic acid per ml was added in addition to 200 mug of 9-18:1 alone; 400 mug of 9-18:1 alone per ml inhibited growth of this organism. The growth response of leptospira to octadecenoic acids differed from that of mammalian cells, suggesting the presence of different enzymes in the two systems for the utilization of these substrates.     

Suppression of cytotoxic T lymphocyte activation by L-ornithine

The effect of L-ornithine on several types of immune reactions was analyzed. L-ornithine was found to suppress the activation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vivo and in vitro. This suppressive effect was not observed with the structural analogues D-ornithine, L-lysine, or putrescine or with the amino acids L-histidine or L-alanine. The concentration of 9 X 10(-3) M L-ornithine was found to mediate a practically complete suppression of the cytotoxic response in vitro if applied on day 0 or day 1 of the culture, but a comparably weak suppression if applied on day 3. The same concentration of L-ornithine had no effect on the production of the lymphokines interleukin 2 (IL 2) and gamma-interferon (IFN-gamma). This concentration of ornithine had also no substantial effect on several types of proliferative responses, including the allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction, the concanavalin A-activated IL 2-dependent proliferation of thymocytes, and IL 2-dependent proliferation of the T cell clone W-2. These observations suggest that L-ornithine inhibits selectively the differentiation of CTL effector cells. By the criteria tested, the immunosuppressive effect of L-ornithine is more selective than that of cyclosporine A, which was previously found to suppress not only the activation of cytotoxic activity but also proliferative responses and the production of the lymphokines IL 2 and IFN-gamma.     

Ascaris suum: homocytotropic antibody responses in mice.

Homocytotropic antibodies in the sera of CD-1 and DBA/1 mice infected with larval A. suum were titered by PCA reactions. IgG₁ and reaginic antibody responses were similar in both strains of mice. With a dose of 8000 to 10,000 embryonated eggs, reaginic antibody was detected during the second week and IgG₁ antibody during the third week of infection. Doses of 1500 to 5000 eggs gave delayed antibody responses or did not induce a detectable response, although an anamnestic response followed a challenge inoculation even when no detectable antibody was observed in initial infection. Larval A. suum infections in two strains of mice did not potentiate a reaginic response to ovalbumin.     

Role of self carriers in the immune response and tolerance. III. B cell tolerance induced by hapten-modified-self involves both active T cell-mediated suppression and direct blockade.

The induction of B cell unresponsiveness with hapten-modified syngeneic murine lymphoid cells (hapten-modified self, HMS) can be achieved in vivo and in vitro. Tolerance in vivo in mice required a latent period of 3 to 4 days. Moreover, B cell unresponsiveness could not be induced by HMS in athymic nude mice, although their nu/+ littermates were rendered hyporesponsive by HMS. Pretreatment of normal mice with cyclophosphamide (cyclo) prevented their susceptibility to tolerance induction by haptenated lymphoid cells. Nude mice became sensitive to HMS-induced suppression if they were first reconstituted with spleen cells from normal (but not cyclo-treated) donors.Interestingly, labeling of H-2 antigens was not necessary for tolerance induction by HMS since haptenated teratoma cells (lacking H-2) were tolerogenic in normal recipients.In contrast, suppression of the in vitro response to haptenated flagellin occurred equally well with nude, nu/+ and anti-Ly 2 + C-treated spleen cells. These data suggest that cyclo-sensitive modified self-reactive (T) cells may regulate the immune response and mediate tolerance to HMS in vivo. However, the in vitro “blockade” of B cell reactivity may be directly mediated on hapten-specific PFC precursors.     

Multivalent poly(ethylene glycol)-containing conjugates for in vivo antibody suppression

Poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) was incorporated into multivalent conjugates of the N-terminal domain of beta(2)GPI (domain 1). PEG was incorporated to reduce the rate of elimination of the conjugates from plasma and to putatively improve their efficacy as toleragens for the suppression of anti-beta(2)GPI antibodies and the treatment of antiphospholipid syndrome (APS). Three structurally distinct types of multivalent platforms were constructed by incorporating PEG into the platform structures in different ways. The amount of PEG incorporated ranged from about 5000 g per mole to about 30000 g per mole. The platforms were functionalized with either four or eight aminooxy groups. The conjugates were prepared by forming oxime linkages between the aminooxy groups and N-terminally glyoxylated domain 1 polypeptide. The plasma half-life of each conjugate, labeled with (125)I, was measured in both mice and rats. The half-lives of the conjugates ranged from less than 10 min to about 1 h in mice, and from less than 3 h to about 19 h in rats. The ability of five tetravalent conjugates to suppress anti-domain 1 antibodies in immunized rats was also measured. Incorporation of PEG in the conjugates significantly reduced the doses required for suppression, and the amount of reduction correlated with the amount of PEG incorporated.     

Suppression of islet allogeneic immune response by indoleamine 2,3 dioxygenase-expressing fibroblasts

Success of transplantation of pancreatic islets which is a promising way for restoring efficient insulin regulation in type 1 diabetes depends on lifelong use of immunosuppressive drugs. To eliminate the use of systemic immunosuppressive drugs for islet transplantation, we examined the potential use of a local immunosuppressive factor, indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO). Thus, the aim of this study was to determine whether local expression of IDO in bystander syngeneic fibroblasts could prevent islet allogeneic immune response in vitro. C57BL/6 (B6) mouse fibroblasts were induced to express IDO by either IFN-gamma treatment or transduction with an adenoviral vector and were co-cultured with B6 mouse lymphocytes and BALB/c mouse pancreatic islets in the presence or absence of an IDO inhibitor. Proliferation of lymphocytes were then assessed using [(3)H]-thymidine incorporation assay. IDO-expression by co-cultured syngeneic fibroblasts resulted in a five-fold decrease in lymphocyte proliferation rate upon stimulation of lymphocytes by allogeneic mouse pancreatic islets (21.9% +/- 5.3 and 22.1% +/- 4.9 in the preparations with IFN-gamma treated and genetically modified IDO-expressing fibroblasts, respectively vs. 100% in control groups, P < 0.01). Allogeneic response was restored when IDO inhibitor was added to the culture indicating that suppression was due to IDO. In conclusion, this study shows that local expression of IDO by syngeneic bystander fibroblasts can suppress in vitro proliferation of lymphocytes in response to stimulation with allogeneic pancreatic islets. This local immunosuppressive function of IDO may be employed for development of a novel alternative strategy for preventing allogeneic islet graft rejection.     

The suppression of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in Lewis rats by treatment with myelin basic protein-cell conjugates

Pretreatment of Lewis rats with guinea pig (GP) myelin basic protein (MBP) coupled to syngeneic spleen leukocytes (SL) suppressed the subsequent induction of experimental allegic encephalomyelitis (EAE) with GP-MBP in Freund's complete adjuvant. The degree of suppression correlated positively with the amount of antigen coupled to the SL. GP-MBP coupled to syngeneic red blood cells (RBC) also resulted in suppression of EAE and the extent of the suppression was related to the dose of cells. These regimens of pretreatment also resulted in a decrease in the in vitro lymphocyte proliferative response to GP-MBP and in the extent of perivascular cuffing in the spinal cord. No decrease in the anti-MBP antibody response was detected in rats pretreated with either GP-MBP-SL or GP-MBP-RBC conjugates. Transfer of lymph node cells from rats pretreated with GP-MBP-RBC resulted in a decrease in disease severity in recipients. It is concluded that prior administration of MBP-cell conjugates is an effective way of suppressing the symptoms of EAE.     

Regulation of the murine IgE antibody response. I. Characterization of suppressor cells regulating both persistent and transient responses and their sensitivity to low doses of X-irradiation.

Anti-ovalbumin (OA) IgE antibody responses were measured in B6D2F1 mice as a function of time and antigen dose. One hundred to 200 microgram of OA in Al(OH)3 elicited transient responses, whereas 1 to 10 microgram of OA in Al(OH)3 elicited persistent anti-OA IgE responses of high titer. T cells isolated from the spleens of mice mounting either a persistent or a transient response strongly suppressed primary anti-DNP IgE responses in unirradiated recipient mice that were immunized with DNP-OA in Al(OH)3; it was, therefore, concluded that suppressor T cells (Ts cells) were activated during both the persistent and transient IgE responses. Nevertheless, in the present study it was not possible to completely rule out the contention that IgG antibodies may also have been suppressing the IgE response. With a modified adoptive transfer system, it was shown that these Ts cells were sensitive to low doses (250 R) of x-irradiation. The suppressive activity of long-term OA primed cells was also shown to be markedly enhanced when cultured for 24 hr with soluble OA; this finding was interpreted to indicate the presence of memory suppressor cells.     

Trichinella spiralis: anaphylactic antibody formation and susceptibility in strains of inbred mice.

The anaphylactic antibody response of various strains of inbred mice of different H-2 specificities was investigated using the passive cutaneous anaphylactic technique (PCA) for the detection of the antibody response. Neither IgC₁ nor reaginic antibody were detected in serum samples obtained at the end of the first week of infection with Trichinella spiralis. Subsequently, all animals had detectable IgG₁ antibodies, although in some strains the titers were very low. Reaginic antibody was detected in relatively high titers in C57L, A, and DBA/1 mice. Two other strains were very poor responders (SJL and AKR). In most strains, reagin and IgG₁ remained detectable for 14 wk or longer. The pattern of response of all strains was very reproducible, indicating genetic control of the anaphylactic antibody production to the infection. In F₁ hybrids obtained from crosses between good and poor anaphylactic antibody responders, intermediate levels of both antibody classes were detected.Adult worm recovery rates were established at various points during the intestinal phase of infection, and no correlation between worm numbers and reaginic antibody titers in the various strains of mice could be demonstrated. There were noticeable differences in larval yields obtained after muscle digestion of mice belonging to the different inbred strains. In fact, we generally observed an inverse relationship between the number of larvae recovered from a given strain and their reaginic antibody titer.The intravenous injection of newborn larvae (NBL), obtained upon in vitro incubation of adult worms, produced detectable antibodies only in mice of the DBA/1 strain. These antibodies were consistently of low titer and became detectable only after the administration of two additional injections of NBL. This contrasted with the results observed after “per os” infection of DBA/1 mice, where high titers of these antibodies were always obtained, in spite of comparable ratios of muscle larval yield.     

Suppression of the immune response to ovalbumin in vivo using anti-idiotypic antibodies

The effect of anti-idiotype antibodies (a-IdpI) on primary immune response to ovalbumin (OVA) was studied. A-IdpI against OVA antibodies were obtained with pI 6.2-6.7 from BALB/c mice. About 30-40% of IgG plaque cell formation (PCF) was inhibited if a-IdpI antiserum was added in situ, which served as a test for the evaluation of idiotype-positive (Id+) PCF. Up to 70% of common PCF and 70-80% of Id+ PCF were suppressed in mice that were injected with a-IdpI antibodies prior to immunization. This suppression was antigen- and allo-specific and depended upon the time of a-IdpI injection. If a-IdpI antibodies were disaggregated (DA) the Id+ suppression increased. A-IdpI antibodies also decreased IgE response to OVA, the suppression being most pronounced with the use of DA samples.     

Stimulation of humoral immune responses to a thymic-independent antigen in mice immunosuppressed by a graft-versus-host reaction.

The immunosuppressive effect of the graft-versus-host (GVH) reaction was studied in CBA × A F₁ (CAF₁) mice which had been rendered immunologically unresponsive by the injection of parental A-strain lymphoid cells (GVH mice). When challenged with a single injection of either sheep red blood cells or Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS), GVH mice failed to produce a significant number of plaque-forming cells (PFC) or a significant level of antibody against either the thymic-dependent or the thymic-independent antigen. Multiple challenges with SRBC also failed to stimulate a significant humoral immune response to the thymic-dependent antigen. Multiple challenges with LPS, however, resulted in the production of a significant number of LPS-specific PFC and a high titer of anti-LPS hemagglutinating antibodies. These results suggest that GVH-induced suppression of humoral immune responses is directed partly at B-cell activity and partly at the activity of helper T cells.     

Selective cytotoxicity of antibody-ricin-A-chain conjugate for human tumor B cells. II. Comparison of activity of immunotoxins conjugated with poly- and monoclonal antibodies

The A-chain of a plant toxin ricin has been coupled to poly- and monoclonal antibodies specific to the L-chains of human IgG. The inhibitory effect of the conjugates has been compared with the ability of the antibodies to bind to target cells. Cytotoxicity of the conjugates has been monitored following incorporation of 14C-leucine radioactivity into Burkitt lymphoma cells with surface Ig. The 50% inhibition of protein synthesis is observed 18 h after treatment of cells with immunotoxins, when the concentration of the conjugates with poly- and monoclonal antibodies is 1.2.10(-9) M and 0.7.10(-9) M, respectively. The data take into account that only part of the polyclonal antibodies molecules is able to react with target cells. The control conjugates containing either monoclonal antibodies that do not react with the lymphoma cells surface L-chains or nonimmune serum IgG proved to have no effect on target cells even at the level of 10(-7) M. The immunotoxins with poly- and monoclonal antibodies produce almost the same kinetics of protein synthesis inhibition, when incubated with lymphoma cells for 60 min. However, a 30 min treatment reveals a considerably higher cytotoxicity of the conjugate with monoclonal antibodies.