Diverse mutants of HIV RRE IIB recognize wild‐type Rev ARM or Rev ARM R35G‐N40V

The binding of human immunodeficiency virus Rev protein via its arginine‐rich motif (ARM) to an internal loop in the Rev‐response element region IIB (RRE IIB) is necessary for viral replication. Many variant RNAs and ARMs that bind Rev and RRE IIB have been found. Despite the essential role of Rev asparagine 40 in recognition, the Rev ARM double‐mutant R35G‐N40V functions well in a Rev–RRE IIB reporter assay, indicating R35G‐N40V uses a distinct recognition strategy. To examine how RRE IIB may evolve specificity to wild‐type Rev ARM and R35G‐N40V, 10 RRE IIB libraries, each completely randomized in overlapping regions, were screened with wild‐type Rev ARM and R35G‐N40V using a reporter system based on bacteriophage λ N antitermination. Consistent with previous studies, a core element of RRE IIB did not vary, and substitutions occurred at conserved residues only in the presence of other substitutions. Notably, the groove‐widening, non‐canonical base‐pair G48:G71 was mutable to U48:G71 without strong loss of binding to wild‐type Rev ARM, suggesting U48:G71 performs the same role by adopting the nearly isosteric, reverse wobble base pair. Originating from RRE IIB, as few as one or two substitutions are sufficient to confer specificity to wild‐type Rev or Rev R35G‐N40. The diversity of RRE IIB mutants that maintain binding to wild‐type Rev ARM and R35G‐N40V supports neutral theories of evolution and illustrates paths by which viral RNA–protein interactions can evolve new specificities. Rev–RRE offers an excellent model with which to study the fine structure of how specificity evolves. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Altered‐specificity mutants of the HIV Rev arginine‐rich motif‐RRE IIB interaction

Arginine‐rich motifs (ARMs) bind RNA structures with high affinity and specificity, and the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) exploits ARM‐RNA interactions to regulate its lifecycle. The expression of HIV structural genes relies on recognition between the ARM of its Rev protein and its primary binding site, an internal loop in the viral RNA, the Rev‐response element region IIB (IIB). Many functional variants of the Rev ARM‐IIB interaction have been discovered, yet how easily it can evolve new specificities is poorly explored. A double mutant of Rev ARM, R35G‐N40 V, uses an unknown strategy to recognize IIB. Here, isothermal titration calorimetry and gel shift assays show that the R35G‐N40V‐IIB interaction has high affinity and specificity in vitro and a larger unfavorable entropy change upon binding than that of wild‐type Rev ARM‐IIB. In stark contrast with the critical dependence of wild‐type Rev on Arg35, Arg39, Asn40, and Arg44, mutational profiling shows R35G‐N40V is highly mutable at positions 40 and 44 and dependent on Gly35, Arg38, Arg39, Arg42, and Arg43. Affinity measurements in vitro and reporter assay measurements in vivo are consistent with the wild‐type Rev ARM and R35G‐N40V maintaining their recognition strategies when binding IIB mutants specific to wild‐type Rev ARM and R35G‐N40V, respectively. Some single amino acid mutants of wild‐type Rev ARM and R35G‐N40V have enhanced specificity, recognizing mutant IIBs yet not wild‐type IIB. These results provide another example of viral ARM‐RNA interactions evolving new specificities with few mutations, consistent with neutral theories of evolution.     

Cooperative dimerization of a stably folded protein directed by a flexible RNA in the assembly of the HIV Rev dimer–RRE stem II complex

The binding of the HIV‐1 Rev protein as an oligomer to a viral RNA element, the Rev‐response element (RRE), mediates nuclear export of genomic RNA. Assembly of the Rev–RRE ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex is nucleated by the binding of the first Rev molecule to stem IIB of the RRE. This is followed by stepwise addition of a total of ~six Rev molecules along the RRE through a combination of RNA–protein and protein–protein interactions. RRE stem II, which forms a three‐way junction consisting of stems IIA, IIB and IIC, has been shown to bind to two Rev molecules in a cooperative manner, with the second Rev molecule binding to the junction region of stem II. The results of base substitutions at the stem II junction, and characterization of stem II junction variants selected from a randomized library showed that an “open” flexible structure is preferred for binding of the second Rev molecule, and that binding of the second Rev molecule to the junction region is not sequence‐specific. Alanine substitutions of a number of Rev amino acid residues implicated to be important for Rev folding in previous structural studies were found to result in a dramatic decrease in the binding of the second Rev molecule. These results support the model that proper folding of Rev is critical in ensuring that the flexible RRE is able to correctly position Rev molecules for specific RNP assembly, and suggests that targeting Rev folding may be effective in the inhibition of Rev function. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Arginine side-chain dynamics in the HIV-1 rev-RRE complex

The binding of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Rev protein to its viral RNA target, stem-loop IIB (SLIIB) within the Rev Response element (RRE), mediates the export of singly-spliced and unspliced viral mRNA from the nucleus to the cytoplasm of infected cells; this Rev-mediated transport of viral RNA is absolutely required for the replication of infectious virus. To identify important features that influence the binding affinity and specificity of this Rev-RRE interaction, we have characterized the arginine side-chain dynamics of the Rev arginine-rich motif (ARM) while bound to a 34 nt RNA oligomer that corresponds to SLIIB. As the specificity of the Rev-RRE interaction varies with salt concentration, arginine side-chain dynamics were characterized at two different salt conditions. Following NMR measurements of (15)N spin relaxation parameters for the arginine (15)N(epsilon) nuclei, the dynamics of the corresponding N(epsilon)-H(epsilon) bond vectors were interpreted in terms of Lipari-Szabo model-free parameters using anisotropic expressions for the spectral density functions. Results from these analyses indicate that a number of arginine side-chains display a surprising degree of conformational freedom when bound to RNA, and that arginine residues having known importance for specific RRE recognition show striking differences in side-chain mobility. The (15)N relaxation measurements at different salt conditions suggest that the previously reported increase in Rev-RRE specificity at elevated salt concentrations is likely due to reduced affinity of non-specific Rev-RNA interactions. The observed dynamical behavior of the arginine side-chains at this protein-RNA interface likely plays an important role in the specificity and affinity of Rev-SLIIB complex formation.     

Fluorescence-based methods for evaluating the RNA affinity and specificity of HIV-1 Rev-RRE inhibitors

RNA plays a pivotal role in the replication of all organisms, including viral and bacterial pathogens. The development of small molecules that selectively interfere with undesired RNA activity is a promising new direction for drug design. Currently, there are no anti-HIV treatments that target nucleic acids. This article presents the HIV-1 Rev response element (RRE) as an important focus for the development of antiviral agents that target RNA. The Rev binding site on the RRE is highly conserved, even between different groups of HIV-1 isolates. Compounds that inhibit HIV replication by binding to the RRE and displacing Rev are therefore expected to retain activity across groups of genetically diverse HIV infections. Systematic evaluations of both the RRE affinity and specificity of numerous small molecule inhibitors are essential for deciphering the parameters that govern effective RRE recognition. This article discusses fluorescence-based techniques that are useful for probing a small molecule's RRE affinity and its ability to inhibit Rev-RRE binding. Rev displacement experiments can be conducted by observing the fluorescence anisotropy of a fluorescein-labeled Rev peptide, or by quantifying its displacement from a solid-phase immobilized RRE. Experiments conducted in the presence of competing nucleic acids are useful for evaluating the RRE specificity of Rev-RRE inhibitors. The discovery and characterization of new RRE ligands are described. Eilatin is a polycyclic aromatic heterocycle that has at least one binding site on the RRE (apparent Kd is approximately 0.13 microM), but it does not displace Rev upon binding the RRE (IC50 > 3 microM). In contrast, ethidium bromide and two eilatin-containing metal complexes show better consistency between their RRE affinity and their ability to displace a fluorescent Rev peptide from the RRE. These results highlight the importance of conducting orthogonal binding assays that establish both the RNA affinity of a small molecule and its ability to inhibit the function of the RNA target. Some Rev-RRE inhibitors, including ethidium bromide, Lambda-[Ru(bpy)(2)eilatin]2+, and Delta-[Ru(bpy)(2)eilatin]2+ also inhibit HIV-1 gene expression in cell cultures (IC50 = 0.2-3 microM). These (and similar) results should facilitate the future discovery and implementation of anti-HIV drugs that are targeted to viral RNA sites. In addition, a deeper general understanding of RNA-small molecule recognition will assist in the effective targeting of other therapeutically important RNA sites.     

Specific RNA binding by a single C2H2 zinc finger

Zinc finger proteins with high affinity for human immunodeficiency virus Rev responsive element stem loop IIB (RRE-IIB) were previously isolated from a phage display zinc finger library. Zinc fingers from one of these proteins, RR1, were expressed individually and assayed for RRE-IIB affinity. The C-terminal zinc finger retained much of the binding affinity of the two-finger parent and was disrupted by mutations predicted to narrow the RRE-IIB major groove and which disrupt Rev binding. In contrast, the N-terminal zinc finger has a calculated affinity at least 1000-fold lower. Despite the high affinity and specificity of RR1 for RRE-IIB, binding affinity for a 234-nucleotide human immunodeficiency virus Rev responsive element (RRE234) was significantly lower. Therefore, zinc finger proteins that bind specifically to RRE234 were constructed using an in vitro selection and recombination approach. These zinc fingers bound RRE234 with subnanomolar dissociation constants and bound the isolated RRE-IIB stem loop with an affinity 2 orders of magnitude lower but similar to the affinity of an arginine-rich peptide derived from Rev. These data show that single C2H2 zinc fingers can bind RNA specifically and suggest that their binding to stem loop IIB is similar to that of Rev peptide. However, binding to RRE234 is either different from stem loop IIB binding or the tertiary structure of stem loop IIB is changed within the Rev responsive element.     

Molecular recognition of a branched peptide with HIV-1 Rev Response Element (RRE) RNA

Interaction of HIV-1 rev response element (RRE) RNA with its cognate protein, Rev, is critical for HIV-1 replication. Understanding the mode of interaction between RRE RNA and ligands at the binding site can facilitate RNA molecular recognition as well as provide a strategy for developing anti-HIV therapeutics. Our approach utilizes branched peptides as a scaffold for multivalent binding to RRE IIB (high affinity rev binding site) with incorporation of unnatural amino acids to increase affinity via non-canonical interactions with the RNA. Previous high throughput screening of a 46,656-member library revealed several hits that bound RRE IIB RNA in the sub-micromolar range. In particular, the lead compound, 4B3, displayed a K_d value of 410?nM and demonstrated selectivity towards RRE. A ribonuclease protection assay revealed that 4B3 binds to the stem-loop structure of RRE IIB RNA, which was confirmed by SHAPE analysis with 234 nt long NL4-3 RRE RNA. Our studies further indicated interaction of 4B3 with both primary and secondary Rev binding sites.     

Water, Shape Recognition, Salt Bridges, and Cation-Pi Interactions Differentiate Peptide Recognition of the HIV Rev-Responsive Element

Recognition of the human immunodeficiency virus Rev-responsive element (RRE) RNA by the Rev protein is an essential step in the viral life cycle. Formation of the Rev-RRE complex signals nucleocytoplasmic export of unspliced and partially spliced viral RNA. Essential components of the complex have been localized to a minimal arginine-rich Rev peptide and stem IIB of RRE. In vitro selection studies have identified a synthetic peptide known as RSG 1.2 that binds with better specificity and affinity to RRE than the Rev peptide. NMR structures of both peptide-RNA complexes of Rev and RSG 1.2 bound to RRE stem IIB have been solved and reveal gross structural differences between the two bound complexes. Molecular dynamics simulations of the Rev and RSG 1.2 peptides in complex with RRE stem IIB have been simulated to better understand on an atomic level how two arginine-rich peptides of similar length recognize the same sequence of RNA with such different structural motifs. While the Rev peptide employs some base-specific hydrogen bonding for recognition of RRE, shape recognition, through contact with the sugar-phosphate backbone, and cation-pi interactions are also important. Molecular dynamics simulations suggest that RSG 1.2 binds more tightly to the RRE sequence than Rev by forming more base-specific contacts, using water to mediate peptide-RNA contacts, and is held in place by a strong salt bridge network spanning the major groove of the RNA.     

Construction of HIV Rev peptides containing peptide nucleic acid that bind HIV RRE IIB RNA

Peptides containing peptide nucleic acid (PNA) have been designed and synthesized to construct molecules recognizing a bulge or a loop structure of RNA. Such peptides were here designed from the HIV Rev protein that can bind the stem-loop IIB of the Rev responsive element (RRE) RNA. Variations of PNA modulated the binding affinities of the peptides to RRE IIB RNA.     

Stereospecificity of short Rev-derived peptide interactions with RRE IIB RNA

The essential HIV-1 regulatory protein Rev binds to the Rev responsive element (RRE) of the HIV-1 mRNA. A short alpha-helical peptide derived from Rev (Rev 34-50) and a truncated form of the RRE sequence (RRE IIB) provide a useful in vitro system to study the interactions between Rev and RRE. The current studies focus on evaluating the specificity of the binding interactions between Rev 34-50 and RRE IIB. The binding of L- and D-Rev peptides to natural and enantiomeric RRE IIB RNA was studied by fluorescence spectroscopy. D-Rev and L-Rev peptides bind to RRE IIB with similar affinities. CD measurements are consistent with a nonhelical, probably beta-hairpin, conformation for D-Rev in the complex. The binding affinities of D/L Rev peptides to L-RRE IIB RNA are also similar to those with natural D-RRE IIB. Furthermore, the conformations of L- and D-peptides when bound to L-RRE are reciprocal to the conformations of these peptides in complex with D-RRE. RNA footprinting studies show that L- and D-Rev peptides bind to the same site on RRE IIB. Our results demonstrate lack of stereospecificity in RRE RNA-Rev peptide interactions. However, it is quite possible that the interactions between full-length Rev protein and RRE are highly specific.     

Assignment and modeling of the Rev Response Element RNA bound to a Rev peptide using 13C-heteronuclear NMR

Summary The Rev Response Element (RRE) RNA-Rev protein interaction is important for regulation of gene expression in the human immunodeficiency virus. A model system for this interaction, which includes stem IIB of the RRE RNA and an arginine-rich peptide from the RNA-binding domain of Rev, was studied using multidimensional heteronuclear NMR. Assignment of the RNA when bound to the peptide was obtained from NMR experiments utilizing uniformly and specifically ¹³C-labeled RNA. Isotopic filtering experiments on the specifically labeled RNA enabled unambiguous assignment of unusual nonsequential NOE patterns present in the internal loop of the RRE. A three-dimensional model of the RNA in the complex was obtained using restrained molecular dynamics calculations. The internal loop contains two purine-purine base pairs, which are stacked to form one continuous helix flanked by two A-form regions. The formation of a G-G base pair in the internal loop requires an unusual structure of the phosphate backbone. This structural feature is consistent with mutational data as being important for the binding of Rev to the RRE. The G-G base pair may play an important role in opening the normally narrow major groove of A-form RNA to permit binding of the Rev basic domain.     

Amino acid requirement for the high affinity binding of a selected arginine-rich peptide with the HIV Rev-response element RNA.

The arginine-rich motif is a class of short arginine-rich peptides that bind to specific RNA structures that has been found to be a versatile framework for the design and selection of RNA-binding peptides. We previously identified novel peptides that bind to the Rev-response element (RRE) RNA of the HIV from an arginine-rich polypeptide library (ARPL) consisting of a polyarginine (15 mer) randomized at the N-terminal 10 positions. The selected peptides bound more strongly to the RRE than the natural binding partner, Rev, and contained glutamine residues that were assumed to be important for recognition of the G-A base pair. In addition, the peptides were predicted to bind to the RRE in an alpha-helical conformation. In this study, in order to understand the mechanism of the interaction between the RRE and the putative alpha-helical glutamine-containing peptides, the amino acid requirements for high affinity binding were analyzed by a combinatorial approach using a bacterial system for detecting RNA-peptide interactions. A consensus peptide, the DLA peptide, was elucidated, which consists of a single glutamine residue within a polyarginine context with the glutamine residue flanked at specific positions by three nonarginine residues, two of which appear to be important for alpha-helix stabilization. In addition, the DLA peptide was found to bind extremely tightly to the RRE with an affinity 50-fold higher than that of the Rev peptide as determined by a gel shift assay. A working model for the interaction of the DLA peptide to the RRE is proposed, which should aid in the development of peptide-based drugs that inhibit HIV replication, as well as in our understanding of polypeptide-RNA interactions. Copyright (c) 2008 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Chimeric RNase H-competent oligonucleotides directed to the HIV-1 Rev response element

Chimeric oligo-2'-O-methylribonucleotides containing centrally located patches of contiguous 2'-deoxyribonucleotides and terminating in a nuclease resistant 3'-methylphosphonate internucleotide linkage were prepared. The oligonucleotides were targeted to the 3'-side of HIV Rev response element (RRE) stem-loop IIB RNA, which is adjacent to the high affinity Rev protein binding site and is critical to virus function. Thermal denaturation experiments showed that chimeric oligonucleotides form very stable duplexes with a complementary single-stranded RNA, and gel electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA) showed that they bind with high affinity and specificity to RRE stem-loop II RNA (K(D) approximately 200 nM). The chimeric oligonucleotides promote RNase H-mediated hydrolysis of RRE stem-loop II RNA and have half-lives exceeding 24h when incubated in cell culture medium containing 10% fetal calf serum. One of the chimeric oligonucleotides inhibited RRE mediated expression of chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) approximately 60% at a concentration of 300 nM in HEK 293T cells co-transfected with p-RRE/CAT and p-Rev mammalian expression vectors.     

Exchange of the basic domain of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Rev for a polyarginine stretch expands the RNA binding specificity, and a minimal arginine cluster is required for optimal RRE RNA binding affinity, nuclear accumulation, and trans-activation

The Rev regulatory protein of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) facilitates the nuclear export of unspliced and partially spliced HIV RNAs. Using a Rev:MS2 phage coat protein fusion that could be targeted to bind and activate the Rev-responsive element (RRE) RNA or heterologous MS2 phage operator RNA, we analyzed the role(s) of the arginine-rich RNA binding domain in RNA binding and transactivation. The arginine-rich domain could be functionally replaced by a stretch of nine arginines. However, polyarginine substitutions expanded the RNA binding specificity of the resultant mutant Rev protein. Polyarginine insertions in place of residues 24 to 60 that excised the RNA binding and oligomerization domains of Rev preserved the activation for MS2 RNA, but not for the RRE. A nine-arginine insertion outside of the natural context of the Rev nuclear localization signal domain was incompatible with activation of either RNA target. Insertions of fewer than eight arginines impaired RRE activation. Interrupted lysine clusters and disruption of the arginine stretch with lysine or neutral residues resulted in a similar phenotype. Some of these mutants with a null phenotype for RRE activated the heterologous MS2 RNA target. Under steady-state conditions, mutants that preserved the Rev response for RRE RNA localized to the nuclei; those with poor or no Rev response accumulated mostly in the cytoplasm. Many of the cytoplasmically resident derivatives became nuclear when leptomycin B (LMB) treatment inhibited nuclear export of nuclear export signal-containing proteins. Mutants that had a null activation potential for either RNA target were particularly resistant to LMB treatment. Abbreviated nuclear residence times and differences in RRE binding affinity may have compromised their activation potential for RRE. High-affinity binding to MS2 RNA through the intact coat protein was sufficient to overcome the short nuclear residence times and to facilitate MS2 activation by some derivatives.     

Analysis of the EIAV Rev-responsive element (RRE) reveals a conserved RNA motif required for high affinity Rev binding in both HIV-1 and EIAV

A cis-acting RNA regulatory element, the Rev-responsive element (RRE), has essential roles in replication of lentiviruses, including human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) and equine infection anemia virus (EIAV). The RRE binds the viral trans-acting regulatory protein, Rev, to mediate nucleocytoplasmic transport of incompletely spliced mRNAs encoding viral structural genes and genomic RNA. Because of its potential as a clinical target, RRE-Rev interactions have been well studied in HIV-1; however, detailed molecular structures of Rev-RRE complexes in other lentiviruses are still lacking. In this study, we investigate the secondary structure of the EIAV RRE and interrogate regulatory protein-RNA interactions in EIAV Rev-RRE complexes. Computational prediction and detailed chemical probing and footprinting experiments were used to determine the RNA secondary structure of EIAV RRE-1, a 555 nt region that provides RRE function in vivo. Chemical probing experiments confirmed the presence of several predicted loop and stem-loop structures, which are conserved among 140 EIAV sequence variants. Footprinting experiments revealed that Rev binding induces significant structural rearrangement in two conserved domains characterized by stable stem-loop structures. Rev binding region-1 (RBR-1) corresponds to a genetically-defined Rev binding region that overlaps exon 1 of the EIAV rev gene and contains an exonic splicing enhancer (ESE). RBR-2, characterized for the first time in this study, is required for high affinity binding of EIAV Rev to the RRE. RBR-2 contains an RNA structural motif that is also found within the high affinity Rev binding site in HIV-1 (stem-loop IIB), and within or near mapped RRE regions of four additional lentiviruses. The powerful integration of computational and experimental approaches in this study has generated a validated RNA secondary structure for the EIAV RRE and provided provocative evidence that high affinity Rev binding sites of HIV-1 and EIAV share a conserved RNA structural motif. The presence of this motif in phylogenetically divergent lentiviruses suggests that it may play a role in highly conserved interactions that could be targeted in novel anti-lentiviral therapies.     

Computational investigation of the HIV-1 Rev multimerization using molecular dynamics simulations and binding free energy calculations

The HIV Rev protein mediates the nuclear export of viral mRNA, and is thereby essential for the production of late viral proteins in the replication cycle. Rev forms a large organized multimeric protein-protein complex for proper functioning. Recently, the three-dimensional structures of a Rev dimer and tetramer have been resolved and provide the basis for a thorough structural analysis of the binding interaction. Here, molecular dynamics (MD) and binding free energy calculations were performed to elucidate the forces thriving dimerization and higher order multimerization of the Rev protein. It is found that despite the structural differences between each crystal structure, both display a similar behavior according to our calculations. Our analysis based on a molecular mechanics-generalized Born surface area (MM/GBSA) and a configurational entropy approach demonstrates that the higher order multimerization site is much weaker than the dimerization site. In addition, a quantitative hot spot analysis combined with a mutational analysis reveals the most contributing amino acid residues for protein interactions in agreement with experimental results. Additional residues were found in each interface, which are important for the protein interaction. The investigation of the thermodynamics of the Rev multimerization interactions performed here could be a further step in the development of novel antiretrovirals using structure based drug design. Moreover, the variability of the angle between each Rev monomer as measured during the MD simulations suggests a role of the Rev protein in allowing flexibility of the arginine rich domain (ARM) to accommodate RNA binding.