Correlation between cell killing and massive second-round superinfection by members of some subgroups of avian leukosis virus.

Avian leukosis viruses of subgroups B, D, and F are cytopathic for chicken cells, whereas viruses of subgroups A, C, and E are not. The amounts of unintegrated linear viral DNA in cells at different times after infection with cytopathic or noncytopathic viruses were determined by hybridization and transfection assays. Shortly after infection, there is a transient accumulation of unintegrated linear viral DNA in cells infected with cytopathic avian leukosis viruses. By 10 days after infection, the majority of this unintegrated viral DNA is not present in the infected cells. The transient cytopathic effect seen in these infected cells also disappears by this time. Low amounts of unintegrated linear viral DNA persist in these cells. Cells infected with noncytopathic viruses do not show this transient accumulation of unintegrated viral DNA. Cells infected with cytopathic viruses and subsequently grown in the presence of neutralizing antibody do not show the transient accumulation of unintegrated viral DNA or cytopathic effects. These results demonstrate a correlation between envelope subgroup, transient accumulation of unintegrated linear viral DNA, and transient cell killing by avian leukosis viruses. The cell killing appears to be the result of massive second-round superinfection by the cytopathic avian leukosis viruses.     

Specificity of avian leukosis virus-induced hyperlipidemia

Rous-associated virus 7 (RAV-7) is a subgroup C avian leukosis virus which does not transform cells in vitro or carry an oncogene. When injected into 1-day-old hatched chicks, RAV-7 causes a low incidence of lymphoid leukosis after a latent period of several months. In contrast, infection of 10-day-old chicken embryos with RAV-7 leads to a disease syndrome characterized by stunting, obesity, atrophy of the bursa and the thymus, high triglyceride and cholesterol levels, reduced thyroxine levels, and increased insulin levels (Carter et al., Infect. Immun. 39:410-422, 1983; J.K. Carter and R.E. Smith, Infect. Immun. 40:795-805, 1983). Histopathological examination of tissues from affected chicks revealed an accumulation of lipid in the liver and an extensive infiltration of the thyroid and pancreas by lymphoblastoid cells. In the present investigation, the subgroup specificity of this syndrome was investigated. Other subgroup C avian leukosis viruses (transformation-defective B77, transformation-defective Prague C strain of Rous sarcoma virus, and RAV-49) caused stunting, infiltration of the thyroid and pancreas, increased liver weights, decreased thyroxine levels, and increased insulin levels, but they did not cause a uniform, profound increase in triglyceride and cholesterol levels. Avian leukosis viruses of subgroup A [myeloblastosis-associated virus 1 causing osteopetrosis [MAV-1(O)] and RAV-1], subgroup B [MAV-2(O), MAV-2 causing nephroblastoma [MAV-2(N)], and RAV-2], subgroup D (RAV-50), and subgroup F (ring-necked pheasant virus and RAV-61) did not cause a syndrome identical to that induced by RAV-7. All of the viruses examined induced some stunting and a reduction in thyroxine levels which correlated with the stunting. The two subgroup F viruses caused an infiltration of the thyroid which may have been secondary to severe lung involvement. We conclude that the RAV-7 syndrome is unique, particularly in the induction of a hyperlipidemia.     

Component of Strain MC29 Avian Leukosis Virus with the Property of Defectiveness

Three clones of morphologically altered cells (L(-)MC29) of singular properties were isolated from MC29 (subgroup A) leukosis virus-infected chick embryo cells. Supernatant fluids from cultures of the cloned cells produced no transforming or interfering activity on chick embryo cells susceptible to known avian leukosis-sarcoma viruses. No virus associated with the cells was demonstrable by fluorescent-antibody staining or by electron microscopy. All L(-)MC29 clone cells were activated, however, by four strains of Rous-associated viruses (RAV) representative of A, B, C, and D subgroup avian leukosis viruses and by two strains of MC29 virus. Virus L(-)MC29 cells activated by superinfection with RAV-1 and RAV-2 was characterized by helper-dependent and helper-independent properties. These findings suggest that the strain MC29 leukosis virus, or a component thereof, possesses properties of defectiveness similar to those of the Bryan high-titer Rous sarcoma virus.     

The avian retrovirus env gene family: molecular analysis of host range and antigenic variants.

The nucleotide sequence of the env gp85-coding domain from two avian sarcoma and leukosis retrovirus isolates was determined to identify host range and antigenic determinants. The predicted amino acid sequence of gp85 from a subgroup D virus isolate of the Schmidt-Ruppin strain of Rous sarcoma virus was compared with the previously reported sequences of subgroup A, B, C, and E avian sarcoma and leukosis retroviruses. Subgroup D viruses are closely related to the subgroup B viruses but have an extended host range that includes the ability to penetrate certain mammalian cells. There are 27 amino acid differences shared between the subgroup D sequence and three subgroup B sequences. At 16 of these sites, the subgroup D sequence is identical to the sequence of one or more of the other subgroup viruses (A, C, and E). The remaining 11 sites are specific to subgroup D and show some clustering in the two large variable regions that are thought to be major determinants of host range. Biological analysis of recombinant viruses containing a dominant selectable marker confirmed the role of the gp85-coding domain in determining the host range of the subgroup D virus in the infection of mammalian cells. We also compared the sequence of the gp85-coding domain from two subgroup A viruses, Rous-associated virus type 1 and a subgroup A virus of the Schmidt-Ruppin strain of Rous sarcoma virus. The comparison revealed 24 nonconservative amino acid changes, of which 6 result in changes in potential glycosylation sites. The positions of 10 amino acid differences are coincident with the positions of 10 differences found between two subgroup B virus env gene sequences. These 10 sites identify seven domains in the sequence which may constitute determinants of type-specific antigenicity. Using a molecular recombinant, we demonstrated that type-specific neutralization of two subgroup A viruses was associated with the gp85-coding domain of the virus.     

Cell killing by avian leukosis viruses.

Infection of chicken cells with a cytopathic avian leukosis virus resulted in the detachment of killed cells from the culture dish. The detached, dead cells contained more unintegrated viral DNA than the attached cells. These results confirm the hypothesis that cell killing after infection with a cytopathic avian leukosis virus is associated with accumulation of large amounts of unintegrated viral DNA. No accumulation of large amounts of integrated viral DNA was found in cells infected with cytopathic avian leukosis viruses.     

Artificial insertion of a dominant gene for resistance to avian leukosis virus into the germ line of the chicken

Summary This report describes the unique biological properties of a transgenic chicken line that contains a defective avian leukosis virus (ALV) proviral insert that we call alv6. Chick embryo fibroblasts (CEF) containing this insert express subgroup A envelope glycoprotein since they yield focus-forming pseudotype virus when co-cultivated with transformed quail cells expressing envelope-defective Bryan high-liter Rous sarcoma virus (RSV). In addition, these cells display high interference to subgroup A RSV but not to subgroup B RSV infection. Chickens containing this insert are highly resistant to pathogenic subgroup A ALV infection, but show little immunological tolerance to subgroup B ALV infection. Thus we have artificially inserted a dominant gene for resistance to avian leukosis infection into the chicken germ line.     

Rapid death of duck cells infected with influenza: a potential mechanism for host resistance to H5N1

Aquatic birds are the natural reservoir for most subtypes of influenza A, and a source of novel viruses with the potential to cause human pandemics, fatal zoonotic disease or devastating epizootics in poultry. It is well recognised that waterfowl typically show few clinical signs following influenza A infection, in contrast, terrestrial poultry such as chickens may develop severe disease with rapid death following infection with highly pathogenic avian influenza. This study examined the cellular response to influenza infection in primary cells derived from resistant (duck) and susceptible (chicken) avian hosts. Paradoxically, we observed that duck cells underwent rapid cell death following infection with low pathogenic avian H2N3, classical swine H1N1 and 'classical' highly pathogenic H5N1 viruses. Dying cells showed morphological features of apoptosis, increased DNA fragmentation and activation of caspase 3/7. Following infection of chicken cells, cell death occurred less rapidly, accompanied by reduced DNA fragmentation and caspase activation. Duck cells produced similar levels of viral RNA but less infectious virus, in comparison with chicken cells. Such rapid cell death was not observed in duck cells infected with a contemporary Eurasian lineage H5N1 fatal to ducks. The induction of rapid death in duck cells may be part of a mechanism of host resistance to influenza A, with the loss of this response leading to increased susceptibility to emergent strains of H5N1. These studies provide novel insights that should help resolve the long-standing enigma of host-pathogen relationships for highly pathogenic and zoonotic avian influenza.     

Replication of the Reticuloendotheliosis Virus (Strain T) in Chicken Embryo Cell Culture

Investigations were conducted on the in vitro replication of the reticuloendotheliosis (RE) virus (strain T) in specific-pathogen-free chicken embryo fibroblast (CEF) cultures. Active virus production was detected in the tissue culture fluid 24 hr after infection. When injected into chickens, samples taken 42 hr after infection of the cell cultures killed approximately 50% of the birds at a 1:100 dilution. The RE virus titer remained at this level for 5 days before declining. Cell-free virus preparations from tissue cultures rarely resulted in 100% mortality of the assay birds. The level of cell-associated virus was very low. Evidence that the reticuloendotheliosis was not induced by a mycoplasma was indicated by failure to isolate an organism on PPLO Agar (Difco) and failure of kanamycin or amphotericin B to inhibit multiplication of RE virus in vitro. RE virus appeared to be unrelated to members of the avian leukosis and sarcoma complex. It did not induce resistance in CEF cultures to sarcoma viruses of the A or B subgroup of this complex. Similarly, preinfection of cell cultures with leukosis viruses of the A or B subgroup did not inhibit or reduce the replication of RE virus.     

Infection of human airway epithelium by human and avian strains of influenza a virus

We describe the characterization of influenza A virus infection of an established in vitro model of human pseudostratified mucociliary airway epithelium (HAE). Sialic acid receptors for both human and avian viruses, alpha-2,6- and alpha-2,3-linked sialic acids, respectively, were detected on the HAE cell surface, and their distribution accurately reflected that in human tracheobronchial tissue. Nonciliated cells present a higher proportion of alpha-2,6-linked sialic acid, while ciliated cells possess both sialic acid linkages. Although we found that human influenza viruses infected both ciliated and nonciliated cell types in the first round of infection, recent human H3N2 viruses infected a higher proportion of nonciliated cells in HAE than a 1968 pandemic-era human virus, which infected proportionally more ciliated cells. In contrast, avian influenza viruses exclusively infected ciliated cells. Although a broad-range neuraminidase abolished infection of HAE by human parainfluenza virus type 3, this treatment did not significantly affect infection by influenza viruses. All human viruses replicated efficiently in HAE, leading to accumulation of nascent virus released from the apical surface between 6 and 24 h postinfection with a low multiplicity of infection. Avian influenza A viruses also infected HAE, but spread was limited compared to that of human viruses. The nonciliated cell tropism of recent human H3N2 viruses reflects a preference for the sialic acid linkages displayed on these cell types and suggests a drift in the receptor binding phenotype of the H3 hemagglutinin protein as it evolves in humans away from its avian virus precursor.     

Assay of noninfectious fragments of DNA of avian leukosis virus-infected cells by marker rescue.

A marker rescue assay of noninfectious fragments of avian leukosis virus DNAs is describe. DNA fragments were prepared either by sonication of EcoRI-digestion of DNAs of chicken cells infected with wild-type Rous sarcoma virus, with a nontransforming avian leukosis virus, and with a mutant of Rous sarcoma virus temperature sensitive for transformation. Recipient cultures of chicken embryo fibroblasts were treated with noninfectious DNA fragments and infected with temperature-sensitive mutants of Rous sarcoma virus defective in DNA polymerase or in an internal virion structural protein. Wild-type progeny viruses which replicated at the nonpermissive temperature were isolated. Some of the wild-type progeny acquired both the wild-type DNA polymerase and the subgroup specificity of the Rous sarcona virus strain used for preparation of sonicated or EcoRI-digested DNA fragments. Therefore the genetic markers for DNA polymerase and envelope were linked and appeared to be located on the same EcoRi fragment of the DNA of Rous sarcoma virus-infected cells.     

Modifications in the binding domain of avian retrovirus envelope protein to redirect the host range of retroviral vectors.

On the basis of theoretical structural and comparative studies of various avian leukosis virus SU (surface) envelope proteins, we have identified four small regions (I, II, III, and IV) in their receptor-binding domains that could potentially be involved in binding to receptors. From the envelope gene of an avian leukosis virus of subgroup A, we have constructed a set of SU mutants in which these regions were replaced by the coding sequence of FLA16, a 16-amino-acid RGD-containing peptide known to be the target for several cellular integrin receptors. Helper-free retroviral particles carrying a neo-lacZ retroviral vector were produced with the mutant envelopes. SU mutants in which regions III and IV were substituted yielded normal levels of envelope precursors but were not detectably processed or incorporated in viral particles. In contrast, substitutions in regions I and II did not affect the processing and the viral incorporation of SU mutants. When FLA16 was inserted in region II, it could be detected with antibodies against FLA16 synthetic peptide, but only when viral particles were deglycosylated. Viral particles with envelopes mutated in region I or II were able to infect avian cells through the subgroup A receptor at levels similar to those of the wild type. When viruses with envelopes containing FLA16 peptide in region II were applied to plastic dishes, they were found to promote binding of mammalian cells resistant to infection by subgroup A avian leukosis viruses but expressing the integrins recognized by FLA16. Deglycosylated helper-free viruses obtained by mild treatment with N-glycosidase F have been used to infect these mammalian cells, and infections have been monitored by neomycin selection. No neomycin-resistant clones could be obtained after infection by viruses with wild-type envelopes. Conversely, colonies were obtained after infection by viruses with envelopes bearing FLA16 in region II, and the genome of the retroviral vector was found correctly integrated in cell DNA of these colonies. By using a blocking peptide containing the minimal adhesive RGD sequence contained in FLA16, we have shown that preincubation of target cells could specifically inhibit infection by viruses with FLA16.     

Cross-reactive, cell-mediated immunity and protection of chickens from lethal H5N1 influenza virus infection in Hong Kong poultry markets

In 1997, avian H5N1 influenza virus transmitted from chickens to humans resulted in 18 confirmed infections. Despite harboring lethal H5N1 influenza viruses, most chickens in the Hong Kong poultry markets showed no disease signs. At this time, H9N2 influenza viruses were cocirculating in the markets. We investigated the role of H9N2 influenza viruses in protecting chickens from lethal H5N1 influenza virus infections. Sera from chickens infected with an H9N2 influenza virus did not cross-react with an H5N1 influenza virus in neutralization or hemagglutination inhibition assays. Most chickens primed with an H9N2 influenza virus 3 to 70 days earlier survived the lethal challenge of an H5N1 influenza virus, but infected birds shed H5N1 influenza virus in their feces. Adoptive transfer of T lymphocytes or CD8(+) T cells from inbred chickens (B(2)/B(2)) infected with an H9N2 influenza virus to naive inbred chickens (B(2)/B(2)) protected them from lethal H5N1 influenza virus. In vitro cytotoxicity assays showed that T lymphocytes or CD8(+) T cells from chickens infected with an H9N2 influenza virus recognized target cells infected with either an H5N1 or H9N2 influenza virus in a dose-dependent manner. Our findings indicate that cross-reactive cellular immunity induced by H9N2 influenza viruses protected chickens from lethal infection with H5N1 influenza viruses in the Hong Kong markets in 1997 but permitted virus shedding in the feces. Our findings are the first to suggest that cross-reactive cellular immunity can change the outcome of avian influenza virus infection in birds in live markets and create a situation for the perpetuation of H5N1 influenza viruses.     

Establishment and characterization of chicken embryo fibroblast clone LSCC-H32

Cell line CEC-32 and clone LSCC-H32 were established from primary chicken embryo cells spontaneously but not experimentally transformed at 32 degrees C. The lines consisted of fibroblastoid and polygonal cells and had a subtetraploid karyotype of 2N = 130 to 140. The cells showed increased plating efficiency and metabolic activities as demonstrated by hexose uptake and plasminogen activator assay. The established cells produced avian lymphoid leukosis viruses of subgroups A and B. The virus released from LSCC-H32 cells induced lymphoid leukosis in inoculated chickens 18 to 22 wk post infection (PI). The cells have been carried in continuous culture for 285 passages and they appeared to grow indefinitely. They were efficiently used to propagate several animal viruses and to titrate chicken interferon.     

Analysis of the subgroup A avian sarcoma and leukosis virus receptor: the 40-residue, cysteine-rich, low-density lipoprotein receptor repeat motif of Tva is sufficient to mediate viral entry.

The genes encoding the receptor for subgroup A Rous sarcoma viruses (tva) were recently cloned from both chicken and quail cells (P. Bates, J. A. T. Young, and H. E. Varmus, Cell 74:1043-1051, 1993; J. A. T. Young, P. Bates, and H. E. Varmus, J. Virol. 67:1811-1816, 1993). Previous work suggested that only the extracellular domain of Tva interacts with the virus (P. Bates, J. A. T. Young, and H. E. Varmus, Cell 74:1043-1051, 1993). Tva is a small membrane-associated protein containing in its extracellular domain a 40-amino-acid region which is closely related to the low-density lipoprotein receptor (LDLR) repeat motif. To determine the region of the Tva extracellular domain responsible for viral receptor function, we created chimeric proteins containing various regions of the Tva extracellular domain fused with a murine CD8 membrane anchor. Analysis of these proteins demonstrates that any chimera containing the Tva LDLR repeat motif can specifically bind the envelope protein of subgroup A avian sarcoma and leukosis viruses. Furthermore, NIH 3T3 cell lines expressing these chimeric proteins were efficiently infected by subgroup A avian sarcoma and leukosis virus vectors. Our results demonstrate that the 40-residue-long LDLR repeat motif of Tva is responsible for viral receptor function.     

Two Loci Controlling Genetic Cellular Resistance to Avian Leukosis-Sarcoma Viruses

Female chickens known to be heterozygous for resistance to subgroups A and B of the avian leukosis-sarcoma viruses were mated to males known to be homozygously resistant to both. The progeny were assayed both on the chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) and in tissue culture for resistance to representative viruses of the A, B, and tentatively defined C subgroups. Segregation ratios of resistance to A and B subgroup viruses agreed with the previously suggested hypothesis of single-autosomal-recessive genes controlling resistance to each subgroup. Mixed infection on the CAM and replicate plate infection in tissue culture with subgroup A and B viruses showed that resistance to the A and B subgroups was inherited independently. Assays with viruses tentatively classified as subgroup C indicated that they were largely composed of a mixture of subgroup A and B viruses or of particles possessing the host range specificity of both. However, virus stocks of the subgroup C category, as well as some stocks classified as subgroup B, produced small numbers of pocks or foci on individuals known to be resistant to subgroup A and B viruses. It is suggested that these Rous sarcoma virus stocks carry between 1 and 10% of a true subgroup C virus.     

Isolation of a chicken gene that confers susceptibility to infection by subgroup A avian leukosis and sarcoma viruses.

We used a genetic strategy to isolate the chicken gene believed to encode the receptor for subgroup A avian leukosis and sarcoma viruses (ALSV-A). Chicken genomic DNA was transfected into monkey COS-7 cells, and two independent primary transfectants susceptible to ALSV-A infection were identified by using ALSV-A vectors containing a hygromycin B resistance gene. A second round of transfection and selection in mouse BALB/3T3 fibroblasts again led to isolation of a transfectant susceptible to infection by ALSV-A. Plasmid DNA sequences linked to chicken DNA during the primary transfection segregated with chicken DNA in the secondary transfectant and served as a molecular tag to clone the gene conferring susceptibility. Expression of the cloned gene in mouse BALB/3T3 cells conferred susceptibility to infection by ALSV-A but not by ALSV-B. Therefore the cloned gene most probably represents the tv-a locus, the genetically defined receptor gene for ALSV-A.     

Packaging cells for avian leukosis virus-based vectors with various host ranges.

Using our previously described Haydée semipackaging cell line (F. L. Cosset, C. Legras, Y. Chebloune, P. Savatier, P. Thoraval, J. L. Thomas, J. Samarut, V. M. Nigon, and G. Verdier, J. Virol. 64:1070-1078, 1990) which produces avian leukosis virus gag and pol proteins, we have constructed packaging cells with subgroups B, C, and E envelope specificities. This allows us to produce helper-free avian leukosis virus particles carrying the lacZ reporter gene and the A, B, C, or E subgroup specificities. Titers of the recombinant lacZ virus are shown to be dependent upon the type of the env subgroup and the target avian cell.     

Genetic analysis of the Rous sarcoma virus subgroup D env gene: mammal tropism correlates with temperature sensitivity of gp85.

Subgroup D avian sarcoma and leukosis viruses can penetrate a variety of mammalian cells in addition to cells from their natural host, chickens. Sequences derived from the gp85-coding domain within the env gene of a mammal-tropic subgroup D virus (Schmidt-Ruppin D strain of Rous sarcoma virus [SR-D RSV]) and a non-mammal-tropic subgroup B virus (Rous-associated virus type 2) were recombined to map genetic determinants that allow penetration of mammalian cells. The following conclusions were based on host range analysis of the recombinant viruses. (i) The determinants of gp85 that result in the mammal tropism phenotype of SR-D RSV are encoded within the 160 codons that lie 3' of codon 121 from the corresponding amino terminus of the gp85 protein. (ii) Small linear domains of the SR-D RSV gp85-coding domain placed in the subgroup B background did not yield viruses with titers equal to that of the subgroup D virus in a human cell line. (iii) Recombinant viruses that contained subgroup D sequences within the hr1 variable domain of gp85 showed modest-to-significant increases in infectivity on human cells relative to chicken cells. A recombinant virus that contained three fortuitous amino acid substitutions in the gp85-coding domain was found to penetrate the human cell line and give a titer similar to that of the subgroup D virus. In addition, we found that the subgroup D virus, the mutant virus, and recombinant viruses with an increased mammal tropism phenotype were unstable at 42 degrees C. These results suggest that the mammal tropism of the SR-D strain is not related to altered receptor specificity but rather to an unstable and fusogenic viral glycoprotein. A temperature sensitivity phenotype for infectivity of mammalian cells was also observed for another mammal-tropic avian retrovirus, the Bratislava 77 strain of RSV, a subgroup C virus, but was not seen for any other avian retrovirus tested, strengthening the correlation between mammal tropism and temperature sensitivity.     

Genetic determinants of neoplastic diseases induced by a subgroup F avian leukosis virus.

Two subgroup F avian leukosis viruses, ring-necked pheasant virus (RPV) and RAV-61, were previously shown to induce a high incidence of a fatal proliferative disorder in the lungs of infected chickens. These lung lesions, termed angiosarcomas, appear rapidly (4 to 5 weeks after infection), show no evidence of proto-oncogene activation by proviral integration, and are not induced by avian leukosis viruses belonging to other subgroups. To identify the viral sequences responsible for induction of these tumors, we constructed recombinant viruses by exchanging genomic segments of molecularly cloned RPV with those of a subgroup A leukosis virus, UR2AV. The ability to induce rapid lung tumors segregated only with the env sequences of RPV; the long terminal repeat of RPV was not required. However, recombinants carrying both env and long terminal repeat sequences of RPV induced lung tumors with a shorter latency. In several cases, recombinant viruses exhibited pathogenic properties differing from those of either parental virus. Recombinants carrying the gag-pol region of RPV and the env gene of UR2AV induced a high incidence of a muscle lesion termed infiltrative intramuscular fibromatosis. One recombinant, EU-8, which carries the gag-pol and LTR sequences of RPV, and the env gene of UR2AV, induced lymphoid leukosis after an unusually short latent period. The median time of death from lymphoid leukosis was 6 to 7 weeks after infection with EU-8 compared with approximately 5 months for UR2AV.     

Activation of type I and III interferon signalling pathways occurs in lung epithelial cells infected with low pathogenic avian influenza viruses

The host response to the low pathogenic avian influenza (LPAI) H5N2, H5N3 and H9N2 viruses were examined in A549, MDCK, and CEF cells using a systems-based approach. The H5N2 and H5N3 viruses replicated efficiently in A549 and MDCK cells, while the H9N2 virus replicated least efficiently in these cell types. However, all LPAI viruses exhibited similar and higher replication efficiencies in CEF cells. A comparison of the host responses of these viruses and the H1N1/WSN virus and low passage pH1N1 clinical isolates was performed in A549 cells. The H9N2 and H5N2 virus subtypes exhibited a robust induction of Type I and Type III interferon (IFN) expression, sustained STAT1 activation from between 3 and 6 hpi, which correlated with large increases in IFN-stimulated gene (ISG) expression by 10 hpi. In contrast, cells infected with the pH1N1 or H1N1/WSN virus showed only small increases in Type III IFN signalling, low levels of ISG expression, and down-regulated expression of the IFN type I receptor. JNK activation and increased expression of the pro-apoptotic XAF1 protein was observed in A549 cells infected with all viruses except the H1N1/WSN virus, while MAPK p38 activation was only observed in cells infected with the pH1N1 and the H5 virus subtypes. No IFN expression and low ISG expression levels were generally observed in CEF cells infected with either AIV, while increased IFN and ISG expression was observed in response to the H1N1/WSN infection. These data suggest differences in the replication characteristics and antivirus signalling responses both among the different LPAI viruses, and between these viruses and the H1N1 viruses examined. These virus-specific differences in host cell signalling highlight the importance of examining the host response to avian influenza viruses that have not been extensively adapted to mammalian tissue culture.