Selection for tolerance to copper during pollen formation in Mimulus guttatus Fischer ex DC

In Mimulus guttatus, copper tolerance is determined largely by a single gene and is expressed in both the sporophyte and microgametophyte. This study explores the extent to which selection during pollen formation affects copper tolerance in the sporophytic generation. Two sets of plants heterozygous for copper tolerance, produced by reciprocal crosses between different copper-tolerant or sensitive families, and the plant on which the original observations were based, were cloned and grown in control or copper-supplemented solutions. Pollen viability and the number of tolerant progeny produced in backcrosses to sensitive plants were compared. In addition, the effect of copper treatment on pollen viability in vitro was compared for plants tolerant, sensitive and heterozygous for copper tolerance. The extent to which in vitro pollen viability decreased in response to copper treatment corresponded to the copper tolerance of the pollen source. When grown with added copper, four of the five plants showed significant reductions in pollen viability, ranging from 18% to 48% of control values. The reductions in pollen viability were correlated with an increase in tolerant progeny (r= 0.679, p=0.004). Increases in tolerant progeny could be large, ranging from 119% to 170% of that of controls, but were usually smaller than was predicted from the reductions in viable pollen. In addition, plants derived from reciprocal crosses differed significantly in the extent to which pollen viability was decreased and sporophytic tolerance increased. Thus, while selection during pollen formation could increase sporophytic tolerance, sporophytic factors, perhaps including cytoplasmic or epigenetic ones, moderated the effectiveness of pollen selection for copper tolerance.     

DIFFERENTIAL SEED PRODUCTION IN MIMULUS GUTTATUS IN RESPONSE TO INCREASING CONCENTRATIONS OF COPPER IN THE PISTIL BY POLLEN FROM COPPER TOLERANT AND SENSITIVE SOURCES

Selection can occur in the pistil, during a series of stages that include both pre-zygotic (pollen germination, pollen tube growth, and fertilization) and post-zygotic events. This study explores the extent to which selection, at this level, could be due to the environmental conditions under which the maternal parent is growing. Five plants of Mimulus guttatus, tolerant to copper, were vegetatively cloned and each clone was grown in control and in solutions to which copper was added. The maternal plants received pollen from plants either tolerant or sensitive to copper. Seeds and ovules were counted to estimate the number of seeds/capsule, the seed/ovule ratio, the percent fertilization, and the proportion of zygotes aborting for each clone, treatment and pollen source combination. There were large differences among the pollen recipients for each of the measurements. However, there was a consistent pattern to seed production depending on the pollen source and copper treatment. The seed/ovule ratio was unaffected if pollen came from tolerant sources but was reduced by an average of 24% for both copper supplemented treatments if pollen came from copper sensitive sources. Thus, the data indicated that selection due to environmental factors could occur within the pistil. Differences in percent fertilization were not statistically significant, but the seed/zygote ratio showed a pattern that was similar to seed production suggesting that abortion of immature seeds was responsible for most of the difference in seed production.     

Sporophytic response to pollen selection for Alachlor tolerance in maize

In order to assess the efficiency of male gametophytic selection (MGS) for crop improvement, pollen selection for tolerance to herbicide was applied in maize. The experiment was designed to test the parallel reactivity to Alachlor of pollen and plants grown in controlled conditions or in the field, the response to pollen selection in the sporophytic progeny, the response to a second cycle of MGS, and the transmission of the selected trait to the following generations. The results demonstrated that pollen assay can be used to predict Alachlor tolerance under field conditions and to monitor the response to selection. A positive response to selection applied to pollen in the sporophytic progeny was obtained in diverse genetic backgrounds, indicating that the technique can be generally included in standard breeding programs; the analysis of the data produced in a second selection cycle indicated that the selected trait is maintained in the next generation.     

POLLEN TUBE COMPETITION AND SELECTION FOR METAL TOLERANCE IN SILENE DIOICA (CARYOPHYLLACEAE) AND MIMULUS GUTTATUS (SCROPHULARIACEAE)

An experiment was conducted to test whether metal tolerance expressed in pollen would provide a competitive advantage during pollen tube growth and fertilization. Copper or zinc was introduced into the pistil by growing metal tolerant plants of Silene dioica or Mimulus guttatus in a nutrient solution to which metals were added. Flowers from treated and control plants were pollinated with either metal tolerant or metal sensitive pollen. The rate of pollen tube growth, the number of seeds set, and the number of viable seeds produced were measured. In general, no effects were found on the rates of pollen tube growth. However, the number of fertilizations and viable seeds were affected. When toxic metals were present, the relative success of pollen from the nontolerant parent was reduced.     

THE EFFECTS OF SELECTION IN THE GAMETOPHYTE STAGE ON MUTATIONAL LOAD

We have studied a multilocus selection model of a plant population in which mutations to deleterious alleles occur that may affect not only the diploid sporophyte stage, but also the haploid pollen stage before zygote formation. We investigated the reduction in inbreeding depression (as measured in the sporophyte) caused by the lowering of mutant allele frequencies due to selection in the pollen. This is important for a full understanding of the role of inbreeding depression in the maintenance of outcrossing in seed plants. We also studied the theoretically expected relationship between the pollen fitnesses of different pollen donor genotypes and the fitnesses of the diploid progeny that they sire. This relationship can be compared with the results of experiments in which pollen was subjected to selection, and improved progeny quality was observed. We found that on the mutational load model there is, as expected intuitively, a positive covariance between the pollen and zygote fitnesses, but that it is likely to be small. Subjecting pollen to an episode of strong selection is usually expected to increase sporophyte fitness only slightly.     

Haplo-diploid gene expression and pollen selection for tolerance to acetochlor in maize

The objectives of this research were to determine if genes controlling the reaction to the herbicide acetochlor in maize (Zea mays L.) are active during both the haploid and the diploid phases of the life cycle and if pollen selection can be utilized for improving sporophytic resistance. Pollen of eight inbred lines, previously characterized through sporophytic analysis for the level of tolerance to acetochlor, showed a differential reaction to the herbicide forin vitro tube length; moreover, such pollen reactions proved to be significantly correlated (r =0.786^*,df=6) with those of the sporophytes producing the pollen. Pollen analysis of two inbred lines (i.e. Mo17, tolerant, and B79, susceptible) and their single cross showed that thein vitro pollen-tube length reaction of the hybrid was intermediate between those of two parents. An experiment on pollen selection was then performed by growing tassels of Mo17xB79 in the presence of the herbicide. Pollen obtained from treated tassels showed a greater tolerance to acetochlor, assessed asin vitro tube length reaction, than pollen obtained from control tassels. Moreover, the backcross [B79 (Mo17xB79)] sporophytic population obtained using pollen from the treated tassels was more tolerant (as indicated by the fresh weight of plants grown in the presence of the herbicide) than was the control backcross population. The two populations did not differ when grown without the herbicide. These findings indicate that genes controlling the reaction to acetochlor in maize have haplodiploid expression; consequently, pollen selection can be applied for improving plant tolerance.     

Production of sodium-chloride-tolerant Brassica juncea plants by in vitro selection at the somatic embryo level

Summary Somatic embryos, developed from hypocotyl segments of light-grown seedlings of Brassica juncea cv RLM198, were subjected to selection at varying concentrations of sodium chloride (NaCl). Plants were developed from proliferated somatic embryos selected on NaCl-containing medium. The selections were characterized for salt tolerance, esterase isozyme pattern, and proline accumulation. It has been found that: (i) selected tolerant lines showed better root growth, shoot growth, and fresh weight accumulation on salt-containing medium when compared to the control; (ii) salt tolerance was transmitted to the next generation in seed progeny of tolerant plants grown in the absence of exposure to salt; (iii) both the starting material and the tolerant selections accumulated proline, even when grown in salt-free medium. On salt-containing medium, however, the differences in accumulated proline between the control and tolerant lines became more pronounced, and (iv) the patterns of esterase isozymes of two tolerant selections were similar but distinctly different from that of the parental control.     

Herbicide-tolerant corn by pollen selection

Summary Maize pollen was exposed to the herbicide Chlorsulfuron (CS), and segregation for tolerance was observed. The resulting plant generation exhibited significantly greater tolerance to CS than other (control) progeny. Since the increase in tolerance occurred after only one generation of pollen exposure, this result demonstrates that pollen selection can be used to develop herbicide-resistant crop species, even when the species are not amenable to cell culture. It also suggests a possible mechanism for the rapid evolution of herbicide tolerance in weeds.     

EVOLUTION OF DOMINANCE IN SPOROPHYTIC SELF-INCOMPATIBILITY SYSTEMS: I. GENETIC LOAD AND COEVOLUTION OF LEVELS OF DOMINANCE IN POLLEN AND PISTIL

Recent theoretical advances have suggested that various forms of balancing selection may promote the evolution of dominance through an increase of the proportion of heterozygote genotypes. We test whether dominance can evolve in the sporophytic self-incompatibility (SSI) system in plants. SSI prevents mating between individuals expressing identical SI phenotypes by recognition of pollen by pistils, which avoids selfing and inbreeding depression. SI phenotypes depend on a complex network of dominance relationships between alleles at the self-incompatibility locus ( S -locus). Empirical studies suggest that these relationships are not random, but the exact evolutionary processes shaping these relationships remain unclear. We investigate the expected patterns of dominance under the hypothesis that dominance is a direct target of natural selection. We follow the fate of a mutant allele at the S -locus whose dominance relationships are changed but whose specificity remains unaltered. We show that strict codominance is not evolutionarily stable in SSI, and that inbreeding depression due to deleterious mutations linked or unlinked to the S -locus exerts strong constraints on changes in relative levels of dominance in pollen and pistil. Our results provide a general adaptive explanation for most patterns of dominance relationships empirically observed in natural plant populations.     

INTER- AND INTRASPECIFIC VARIATION OF MOSSES IN TOLERANCE TO COPPER AND ZINC

Bryophytes are often viewed as slowly evolving with little genetic variation within and among populations. A study of heavy-metal tolerance was initiated to test the capacity of bryophytes to undergo genetic differentiation in response to natural selection. Tolerance of Funaria hygrometrica to copper and zinc was greater in populations that originated on soil with high concentrations of these metals. Protonemal growth was more inhibited by the metals than was germination, and copper was more toxic than zinc. Zinc and copper tolerances were correlated, but so were the zinc and copper concentrations of native substrates. The pattern of population differentiation for heavy-metal tolerance in this species is much like that of flowering plants. Five populations of Physcomitrium pyriforme, which does not occur on metal-contaminated soil, were all highly tolerant of zinc but extremely intolerant of copper. This species seems to have an inherent tolerance to the former. Significant variation in tolerance to copper and zinc occurred among populations, but tolerance did not correlate with metal contents in native substrates. This pattern differs from that of flowering plants. Normal populations of species that colonize contaminated sites tended to be more tolerant than populations of species that do not colonize such sites. The extensive population differentiation in Funaria hygrometrica augments the evidence from electrophoretic data that there is genetic variation among populations of mosses and liverworts.     

Correlation in the tolerance to ozone between sporophytes and male gametophytes of several fruit and nut tree species (Rosaceae)

We analyzed relative sensitivities to ozone partial pressure for male gametophytes (pollen and pollen tubes) of five tree-crop species in the family Rosaceae (almond, apple, apricot, nectarine/peach, pear) and of four cultivars of almond. Relative sensitivities to ozone partial pressure were previously described using field-based, whole-plant, physiological measurements for the sporophytes of each of the species and cultivars used in this study. Our objective was to determine the extent of correlation between sporophyte and gametophyte responses to ozone among and within these tree species. If the relative sensitivities prove to be similar for the two generations, two research strategies become possible for breeders interested in developing new cultivars with improved tolerance to atmospheric ozone: First, because screening large numbers of sporophytes for their responses to ozone partial pressure is a formidable task, exploiting the much more easily manipulated male gametophyte generation for large-scale screening of individuals for ozone tolerance could greatly facilitate identification and selection of tolerant genotypes. Second, it opens the possibility of applying selection pressure to the gametophyte generation (as during pollen germination or pollen tube growth) to favor production of ozonetolerant progeny. Results indicate that, among and within species, relative responses of pollen tube growth to ozone partial pressure are highly correlated with that of the sporophytes. Pollen germination was inhibited by ozone treatments for all but one species (pear), but differences among and within species were neither significant nor (with the exception of pear) did they correlate with relative sporophyte sensitivities.     

Crop/weed microgametophyte competition in Cucurbita pepo (Cucurbitaceae)

Prior studies of crop/weed gene flow in Cucurbita pepo have demonstrated that pollinators can deposit mixed pollen loads. The fate of microgametophytes emerging from these pollen mixtures is unknown. In an effort to define the relationship between pollen mixture composition and progeny composition, experimental plants representing a zucchini cultivar and a cross-compatible free-living type were genotyped with an isozyme marker and grown under greenhouse conditions. Weighed mixtures of weed/crop pollen were applied to stigmas of both types in differing ratios. Subsequent fertilizations were tracked by an electrophoretic screen of over 1,600 progeny from 39 fruits. Equal mixtures of weed/crop pollen do not produce a corresponding suite of progeny. Pollen of the pistillate parent is favored, and this advantage increases as the proportion of pollen from the pistillate parent increases. However, increasing the proportion of zucchini pollen does not produce a corresponding increase in fertilization success when the free-living type is used as pistillate parent. These results indicate that microgametophyte competition in both domesticated and free-living Cucurbita gynoecia could be a significant component of gene flow dynamics. The nature of this competition can only be defined by experiments that control numerous variables, both paternal and maternal, that might be involved. The tendency for crop/weed hybrids to occur at different portions of the ovary suggests that interactions involving two factors—microgametophyte growth rate and gynoecium structure—might play a significant role.     

The characterization of herbicide tolerant plants in Brassica napus L. after in vitro selection of microspores and protoplasts

Brassica napus L.(cv Topas) plants tolerant to chlorsulfuron (CS) were isolated after selection experiments utilizing microspores and haploid protoplasts. The first microspore-derived plant (M-37,) was CS tolerant, haploid and sterile. Normal plant morphology and fertility was restored after colchicine doubling. A CS tolerant plant was also selected from protoplasts (P-26) isolated from microspore-derived embryo tissue and grown on medium containing CS. P-26 was aneuploid, CS tolerant and had very low fertility. The two selected lines produced selfed progeny which were tolerant to from 10–100 times the CS levels of the corresponding Topas plants. Microspores and protoplasts derived from the selfed plants were also CS tolerant. The segregation pattern for CS tolerance from reciprocally crossed progeny of M-37 and Topas was consistent with a semi-dominant nuclear mode of inheritance. Biochemical analysis of the two mutants indicated that the microspore-derived mutant and F1 crosses contained an altered acetohydroxyacid synthase (AHAS) enzyme, while the AHAS activity of the protoplast mutant was similar to Topas. Selfed seed from the M-37 plants have provided tolerance to CS in both greenhouse and field tests. S1 plants from a second microspore selected mutant (M-42) have tolerated 30 g/ha of CS in greenhouse tests. The two single-celled selection systems are discussed and the microspore selection system highlighted as a new method for in vitro selection.     

The evolutionary dynamics of self-incompatibility systems

Self-incompatible flowering plants reject pollen that expresses the same mating specificity as the pistil (female reproductive tract). In most plant families, pollen and pistil mating specificities segregate as a single locus, the S locus. In at least two self-incompatibility systems, distinct pollen and pistil specificity genes are embedded in an extensive nonrecombining tract. To facilitate consideration of how new S locus specificities arise in systems with distinct pollen and pistil genes, we present a graphical model for the generation of hypotheses. It incorporates the evolutionary principle that nonreciprocal siring success (cross-pollinations between two plants produce seeds in only one direction) tends to favor the rejecting partner. This model suggests that selection within S-allele specificity classes could accelerate the rate of nonsynonymous (amino acid-changing) substitutions, with periodic selective sweeps removing segregating variation within classes. Accelerated substitution within specificity classes could also promote the origin of new S-allele specificities.     

INBREEDING DEPRESSION IN ANDRODIOECIOUS POPULATIONS OF DATISCA GLOMERATA (DATISCACEAE)

Several workers have suggested that the rarity of androdioecy (the presence of males and hermaphrodites in a breeding population) in nature is due to the large fitness gain required by male plants in order to be maintained by selection. As part of an ongoing investigation of this hypothesis, we tested the effects of selfing on fitness in functionally androdioecious populations of Datisca glomerata. We compared progeny from self-fertilizations, cross-fertilizations with pollen from male plants only, cross-fertilizations with pollen from hermaphrodite plants only, and open-pollinated flowers for several measures of progeny fitness including seed weight, germination rate, and seedling weight. Significant inbreeding depression was observed for androdioecious populations of D. glomerata for both seed and seedling weights. However, no significant differences were observed across treatments for seed germination percentages. The observation of significant levels of inbreeding depression in this study, combined with prior evidence of threefold greater pollen production by males, may at least partially account for the large fitness increase required by males to be maintained by selection.     

ECOLOGICAL GENETICS OF SERPENTINE TOLERANCE IN THE MOSS,FUNARIA FLAVICANS: VARIATION WITHIN AND AMONG HAPLOID SIB FAMILIES

Many mosses occur both on and off serpentine soils, but experiments designed to test whether serpentine populations of widespread species display genetic adaptations for growth on serpentines have not been reported. Toward that end, two populations of the moss, Funaria flavicans, were grown on nutrient media varying in nickel and chromium concentration and in the ratio of magnesium to calcium. Three haploid siblings from each of five sporophytic families from the two populations were grown on five experimental media. There was no evidence that serpentine plants were more tolerant of nickel, chromium, high magnesium/calcium, or high nickel combined with high magnesium/calcium. In fact, plants from the nonserpentine population produced more protonemal growth than the serpentine plants on every medium except the control, on which plants from the two populations were indistinguishable. Large differences in nickel tolerance among haploid sib families (families of meiotic progeny derived from the same sporophyte) from the nonserpentine site provided evidence of genetic polymorphism in that population.     

The effect of pollen competition on maintenance of variation in fertilisation ability

Pollen competition in the pistil does not only give flowering plants the possibility to reduce inbreeding but also provides an opportunity for selection of pollen traits that increase male reproductive success. An objection to the existence of selection on pollen competitive ability is that individual variation should quickly vanish if selection is strong. A balance between selection for local adaptation of sporophytes within sites and pollen flow between sites could maintain variation in pollen competitive ability. A prerequisite is that variation in male competitive ability is condition dependent, i.e., influenced by sporophytic adaptation to a patch. This further means that selection on pollen competitive ability can occur both directly on the gamethophytic level and indirectly on the sporophytic level. Our dynamic model shows that maintenance of variation in male competitive ability is more probable when differences in pollen competitive ability influence male fitness, i.e., in cases with pollen competition, than when differences in this trait only is a side effect of selection for more viable individuals. Since there is a connection between the gamethophytic and sporophytic life-phases, the incidence of pollen competition between donors should make it more probable that variability also in sporophyte fitness is preserved.     

Plantacyanin plays a role in reproduction in Arabidopsis

Plantacyanins belong to the phytocyanin family of blue copper proteins. In the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) genome, only one gene encodes plantacyanin. The T-DNA-tagged mutant is a knockdown mutant that shows no visible phenotype. We used both promoter-beta-glucuronidase transgenic plants and immunolocalization to show that Arabidopsis plantacyanin is expressed most highly in the inflorescence and, specifically, in the transmitting tract of the pistil. Protein levels show a steep gradient in expression from the stigma into the style and ovary. Overexpression plants were generated using cauliflower mosaic virus 35S, and protein levels in the pistil were examined as well as the pollination process. Seed set in these plants is highly reduced mainly due to a lack of anther dehiscence, which is caused by degeneration of the endothecium. Callose deposits occur on the pollen walls in plants that overexpress plantacyanin, and a small percentage of these pollen grains germinate in the closed anthers. When wild-type pollen was used on the overexpression stigma, seed set was still decreased compared to the control pollinations. We detected an increase in plantacyanin levels in the overexpression pistil, including the transmitting tract. Guidance of the wild-type pollen tube on the overexpression stigma is disrupted as evidenced by the growth behavior of pollen tubes after they penetrate the papillar cell. Normally, pollen tubes travel down the papilla cell and into the style. Wild-type pollen tubes on the overexpression stigma made numerous turns around the papilla cell before growing toward the style. In some rare cases, pollen tubes circled up the papilla cell away from the style and were arrested there. We propose that when plantacyanin levels in the stigma are increased, pollen tube guidance into the style is disrupted.