Phylogeny of Medusozoa and the evolution of cnidarian life cycles

To investigate the evolution of cnidarian life cycles, data from the small subunit of the ribosome are used to derive a phylogenetic hypothesis for Medusozoa. These data indicate that Cnidaria is monophyletic and composed of Anthozoa and Medusozoa. While Cubozoa and Hydrozoa are well supported clades, Scyphozoa appears to be paraphyletic. Stauromedusae is possibly the sister group of either Cubozoa or all other medusozoans. The phylogenetic results suggest that: the polyp probably preceded the medusa in the evolution of Cnidaria; within Hydrozoa, medusa development involving the entocodon is ancestral; within Trachylina, the polyp was lost and subsequently regained in the parasitic narcomedusans; within Siphonophorae, the float originated prior to swimming bells; stauromedusans are not likely to be descended from ancestors that produced medusae by strobilation; and cubozoan polyps are simplified from those of their ancestors, which possessed polyps with gastric septa and four mesogleal muscle bands and peristomial pits.     

Cladistic analysis of Medusozoa and cnidarian evolution

Abstract. A cladistic analysis of 87 morphological and life history characters of medusozoan cnidarians, rooted with Anthozoa, results in the phylogenetic hypothesis (Anthozoa (Hydrozoa (Scyphozoa (Staurozoa, Cubozoa)))). Staurozoa is a new class of Cnidaria consisting of Stauromedusae and the fossil group Conulatae. Scyphozoa is redefined as including those medusozoans characterized by strobilation and ephyrae (Coronatae, Semaeostomeae, and Rhizostomeae). Within Hydrozoa, Limnomedusae is identified as either the earliest diverging hydrozoan lineage or as the basal group of either Trachylina (Actinulida (Trachymedusae (Narcomedusae, Laingiomedusae))) or Hydroidolina (Leptothecata (Siphonophorae, Anthoathecata)). Cladistic results are highly congruent with recently published phylogenetic analyses based on 18S molecular characters. We propose a phylogenetic classification of Medusozoa that is consistent with phylogenetic hypotheses based on our cladistic results, as well as those derived from 18S analyses. Optimization of the characters presented in this analysis are used to discuss evolutionary scenarios. The ancestral cnidarian probably had a sessile biradial polyp as an adult form. The medusa is inferred to be a synapomorphy of Medusozoa. However, the ancestral process (metamorphosis of the apical region of the polyp or lateral budding involving an entocodon) could not be inferred unequivocally. Similarly, character states for sense organs and nervous systems could not be inferred for the ancestral medusoid of Medusozoa.     

Monophyly of Anthozoa (Cnidaria): why do nuclear and mitochondrial phylogenies disagree?

The phylum Cnidaria is usually divided into five classes: Anthozoa, Cubozoa, Hydrozoa, Scyphozoa and Staurozoa. The class Anthozoa is subdivided into two subclasses: Hexacorallia and Octocorallia. Morphological and molecular studies based on nuclear rDNA and recent phylogenomic studies support the monophyly of Anthozoa. On the other hand, molecular studies based on mitochondrial markers, including two recent studies based on mitogenomic data, supported the paraphyly of Anthozoa, and positioned Octocorallia as sister group to Medusozoa (the monophyletic group of Cubozoa, Hydrozoa and Scyphozoa). On the basis of 51 nuclear orthologs from four hexacorallians, four octocorallians, two hydrozoans and one scyphozoan (with poriferans and Homo sapiens as out‐groups), we built a multilocus alignment of 9 873 amino acids, which aimed at minimizing missing data and hidden paralogy, in order to understand the discrepancy between nuclear and mitochondrial phylogenies. Our phylogenetic analyses strongly supported the monophyly of Anthozoa. We compared the level of substitution saturation between our data set, the data sets of two recent phylogenomic studies and one of a mitogenomic study. We found that mitochondrial DNA is more saturated than nuclear DNA at all the phylogenetic levels studied. Our results emphasize the need for a good evaluation of phylogenetic signal.     

Medusozoan phylogeny and character evolution clarified by new large and small subunit rDNA data and an assessment of the utility of phylogenetic mixture models

A newly compiled data set of nearly complete sequences of the large subunit of the nuclear ribosome (LSU or 28S) sampled from 31 diverse medusozoans greatly clarifies the phylogenetic history of Cnidaria. These data have substantial power to discern among many of the competing hypotheses of relationship derived from prior work. Moreover, LSU data provide strong support at key nodes that were equivocal based on other molecular markers. Combining LSU sequences with those of the small subunit of the nuclear ribosome (SSU or 18S), we present a detailed working hypothesis of medusozoan relationships and discuss character evolution within this diverse clade. Stauromedusae, comprising the benthic, so-called stalked jellyfish, appears to be the sister group of all other medusozoans, implying that the free-swimming medusa stage, the motor nerve net, and statocysts of ecto-endodermal origin are features derived within Medusozoa. Cubozoans, which have had uncertain phylogenetic affinities since the elucidation of their life cycles, form a clade-named Acraspeda-with the scyphozoan groups Coronatae, Rhizostomeae, and Semaeostomeae. The polyps of both cubozoans and hydrozoans appear to be secondarily simplified. Hydrozoa is comprised by two well-supported clades, Trachylina and Hydroidolina. The position of Limnomedusae within Trachylina indicates that the ancestral hydrozoan had a biphasic life cycle and that the medusa was formed via an entocodon. Recently hypothesized homologies between the entocodon and bilaterian mesoderm are therefore suspect. Laingiomedusae, which has often been viewed as a close ally of the trachyline group Narcomedusae, is instead shown to be unambiguously a member of Hydroidolina. The important model organisms of the Hydra species complex are part of a clade, Aplanulata, with other hydrozoans possessing direct development not involving a ciliated planula stage. Finally, applying phylogenetic mixture models to our data proved to be of little additional value over a more traditional phylogenetic approach involving explicit hypothesis testing and bootstrap analyses under multiple optimality criteria. [18S; 28S; Cubozoa; Hydrozoa; medusa; molecular systematics; polyp; Scyphozoa; Staurozoa.].     

Bau und Lebensgeschichte des Polypen vonTripedalia cystophora (Cubozoa,class. nov., Carybdeidae) und seine Bedeutung für die Evolution der Cnidaria

FollowingHaeckel (1880), most zoologists have grouped the Cubomedusae with the class Scyphozoa. However, the actual systematic position and evolution of the Cubomedusae remained unclear because essential phenomena of the life cycle, i. e. life history and structure of the polyp generation and the process of medusa formation were unknown. Successful cultivation of the Carribean larviparousTripedalia cystophora Conant, 1898 elucidated for the first time the complete life cycle of a cubomedusa. Primary polyps could be raised from planulae which were transferred by air mail from La Parguera, Puerto Rico. The sessile polyp is solitary. Its morphology, anatomy, and behaviour are described. The body (length 0.6–1.0 mm) is radially constructed without any trace of tetramerous structures. 6 to 11 solid capitate tentacles insert in one circle, above which the body ends in a long contractile snout-like mouth cone (proboscis). The body is sac-like without gastric septa or gastric pockets; its base is enveloped by a small cup of thin, structureless periderm. Asexual reproduction by which the stock is enlarged quickly envolves lateral budding of small secondary polyps. After detachment these small polyps go through a creeping phase. The fully grown polyp shows a remarkable behavioural plasticity as it can migrate and change into an inactive encysted stage. The whole polyp metamorphoses into a single medusa. All externally visible metamorphosis phases are described. First, the polyp's body becomes tetramerous due to 4 longitudinal folds. The tentacles congregate into 4 groups, each in one quadrant. While the distal parts of the tentacles are resorbed, their bases develop into 4 perradial sensory organs (rhopalia). Interradially, 4 new tentacles are formed and become the primary tentacles of the medusa. Simultaneously, the complete body of the polyp transforms into the bell of the medusa. At the end of the metamorphosis which takes 5 to 6 days at 25 to 27° C, the young medusa begins to pulsate quickly and swims away leaving behind the empty peridermal cup. The morphology of the young medusa is described.T. cystophora has a tricnidom of basitrich haplonemes, holotrich haplonemes, and heterotrich microbasic euryteles. The ecology of both, polyp and medusa generation, is briefly outlined. A critical comparison between the polyp and medusa ofT. cystophora and the Scyphozoa and Hydrozoa reveals important differences. Consequently, a new class, Cubozoa, must be established and given the evolutionary position between Scyphozoa and Hydrozoa. Diagnoses are presented for the polyp ofT. cystophora and the class Cubozoa.     

Slow Mitochondrial COI Sequence Evolution at the Base of the Metazoan Tree and Its Implications for DNA Barcoding

The evolution rates of mtDNA in early metazoans hold important implications for DNA barcoding. Here, we present a comprehensive analysis of intra- and interspecific COI variabilities in Porifera and Cnidaria (separately as Anthozoa, Hydrozoa, and Scyphozoa) using a data set of 619 sequences from 224 species. We found variation within and between species to be much lower in Porifera and Anthozoa compared to Medusozoa (Hydrozoa and Scyphozoa), which has divergences similar to typical metazoans. Given that recent evidence has shown that fungi also exhibit limited COI divergence, slow-evolving mtDNA is likely to be plesiomorphic for the Metazoa. Higher rates of evolution could have originated independently in Medusozoa and Bilateria or been acquired in the Cnidaria + Bilateria clade and lost in the Anthozoa. Low identification success and substantial overlap between intra- and interspecific COI distances render the Anthozoa unsuitable for DNA barcoding. Caution is also advised for Porifera and Hydrozoa because of relatively low identification success rates as even threshold divergence that maximizes the “barcoding gap” does not improve identification success. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Dead-end evolution of the Cnidaria as deduced from 5S ribosomal RNA sequences

Using nucleotide sequences of 5S ribosomal RNAs from 2 hydrozoan jellyfishes, 3 scyphozoan jellyfishes and 2 sea anemones, a phylogenetic tree of Cnidaria has been constructed to elucidate the evolutionary relationships of radial and bilateral symmetries. The 3 classes of Cnidaria examined herein belong to one branch, which does not include other metazoan phyla such as the Platyhelminthes. The Hydrozoa (having radial symmetry without septa) and the Scyphozoa (having radial symmetry with septa) are more closely related to each other than to the Anthozoa (having bilateral symmetry with septa). In classical taxonomy, multicellular animals are considered to have evolved through organisms with radial symmetry (e.g., Cnidaria) to bilateral symmetry. Our results, however, indicate that the emergence of the Bilateria was earlier than that of the Radiata, suggesting (in opposition to Haeckel's view) that the radial symmetry of Cnidaria is an evolutionary dead end.     

Phylogenetics and evolution of Capitata (Cnidaria: Hydrozoa), and the systematics of Corynidae

Nawrocki, A. M., Schuchert, P. & Cartwright, P. (2009). Phylogenetics and evolution of Capitata (Cnidaria: Hydrozoa), and the systematics of Corynidae.—Zoologica Scripta, 39, 290–304. Generic‐ and family level classifications in Hydrozoa have been historically problematic due to limited morphological characters for phylogenetic analyses and thus taxonomy, as well as disagreement over the relative importance of polyp vs. medusa characters. Within the recently redefined suborder Capitata (Cnidaria: Hydrozoa: Hydroidolina), which includes 15 families and almost 200 valid species, family level relationships based on morphology alone have proven elusive, and there exist numerous conflicting proposals for the relationships of component species. Relationships within the speciose capitate family Corynidae also remain uncertain, for similar reasons. Here, we combine mitochondrial 16S, and nuclear 18S and 28S sequences from capitate hydrozoans representing 12 of the 15 valid capitate families, to examine family level relationships within Capitata. We further sample densely within Corynidae to investigate the validity of several generic‐level classification schemes that rely heavily on the presence/absence of a medusa, a character that has been questioned for its utility in generic‐level classification. We recover largely congruent tree topologies from all three markers, with 28S and the combined dataset providing the most resolution. Our study confirms the monophyly of the redefined Capitata, and provides resolution for family level relationships of most sampled families within the suborder. These analyses reveal Corynidae as paraphyletic and suggest that the limits of the family have been underestimated. Our results contradict all available generic‐level classification schemes for Corynidae. As classification schemes for this family have been largely based on reproductive characters such as the presence/absence of a medusa, our results suggest that these are not valid generic‐level characters for the clade. We suggest a new taxonomic structure for the lineage that includes all members of the newly redefined Corynidae, based on molecular and morphological synapomorphies for recovered clades within the group.     

Evolutionary origin of rhopalia: insights from cellular‐level analyses of Otx and POU expression patterns in the developing rhopalial nervous system

SUMMARY In Cnidaria, the medusae of Scyphozoa and its sister‐group Cubozoa uniquely possess rhopalia at their bell margin. These sensory centers coordinate behavior and development. We used fluorescent in situ hybridization and confocal microscopy to examine mRNA expression patterns in Aurelia sp.1 (Cnidaria, Scyphozoa) during early medusa formation, while simultaneously visualizing the developing nervous system by immunofluorescence. The genes investigated include AurOtx1, and the POU genes, AurPit1, and AurBrn3, homologs of genes known to function in cephalar neural organization and sensory cell differentiation across Bilateria. Our results show that AurOtx1 expression defines the major part of the oral neuroectodermal domain of the rhopalium, within which distinct populations of AurBrn3‐ and AurPit1‐expressing sensory cells develop. Thus, despite the unique attributes of rhopalial evolution, we suggest that the rhopalial nervous system of scyphozoan medusae involves similar patterns of differential expression of genes that function in bilaterian cephalic structure and neuroendocrine system development. We propose that rhopalia evolved from preexisting sensory structures that developed distinct populations of sensory cells differentially expressing POU genes within Otx oral‐neuroectodermal domains. This implies some commonality of developmental genetic functions involving these genes in the still poorly constrained common ancestor of bilaterians and cnidarians.     

Placozoa are not derived cnidarians: evidence from molecular morphology

The phylum Placozoa is represented by a single known species, Trichoplax adhaerens, a tiny marine organism that represents the most simple metazoan bauplan. Because of the latter, placozoans were originally considered the most basal metazoan phylum. A misinterpretation of the life cycle at the turn of the century and some more recent molecular phylogenetic analyses have placed Trichoplax as a derived species within the Cnidaria. The latter hypothesis assumes that the primitive organization of the Placozoa is the result of secondary reduction. Here we compare the molecular morphology of the predicted 16S rDNA structure and the mitochondrial genome between Trichoplax and representatives of all four cnidarian classes. Trichoplax shares a circular mtDNA molecule as a plesiomorphy with all other metazoans except for the derived cnidarian classes Hydrozoa, Scyphozoa, and Cubozoa. The predicted secondary structure of the 16S rRNA molecule differs substantially between Trichoplax and cnidarians, particularly with respect to the number and length of stem and loop regions. The new molecular morphological characters provide compelling evidence that Trichoplax is not a derived (medusozoan) cnidarian. Furthermore, it was found that the mitochondrial genome in Cubozoa consists of four linear molecules instead of a single circular molecule or two linear molecules, suggesting that the cubozoans may represent the most derived cnidarian group.     

The HOX-like gene Cnox2-Pc is expressed at the anterior region in all life cycle stages of the jellyfish Podocoryne carnea

The marine jellyfish Podocoryne carnea (Cnidaria, Hydrozoa) has a metagenic life cycle consisting of a larva, a colonial polyp and a free-swimming jellyfish (medusa). To study the function of HOX genes in primitive diploblastic animals we screened a library of P. carnea cDNA using PCR primers derived from the most conserved regions in helix 1 and helix 3 of the homeobox. A novel gene, Cnox2-Pc, has been isolated and characterized. Cnox2-Pc is a HOX cluster-like gene, and its homeodomain shows similarity to the Deformed subfamily of HOM-C/HOX genes. In situ hybridization revealed that Cnox2-Pc is expressed in the anterior region of the larva, the polyp head, and the most apical ectoderm of the differentiating bud during medusa development. In adult medusa expression is restricted to the gastrovascular entoderm. The results suggest that Cnox2-Pc is involved in establishment of an anterior-posterior axis during development in primitive metazoans. Received: 23 February 1999 / Accepted: 27 July 1999     

Replacement of nucleosomal histones by histone H1-like proteins during spermiogenesis in Cnidaria: Evolutionary implications

We have analyzed the chromosomal protein composition of the sperm from several species belonging to three different classes (Hydrozoa, Scyphozoa, Anthozoa) of the phylum Cnidaria. In every instance, the sperm nuclear basic proteins (SNBPs) were found to consist of one to two major protein fractions that belong to the histone H1 family, as can be deduced from their amino acid composition and solubility in dilute perchloric acid, and the presence of a trypsin-resistant core. In those species where mature spawned sperm could be obtained, we were able to show that these proteins completely replace the somatic histones from the stem cells that are present at the onset of spermatogenesis. The presence of a highly specialized histone H1 molecule in the sperm of this phylum provides support for the idea that the protamine-like proteins (PL) from higher groups in the phylogenetic tree (and possibly protamines as well) may all have evolved from a primitive histone H1 ancestor.     

Phospholipase A2 in cnidaria

Phospholipase A2 (PLA2) is an enzyme present in snake and other venoms and body fluids. We measured PLA2 catalytic activity in tissue homogenates of 22 species representing the classes Anthozoa, Hydrozoa, Scyphozoa and Cubozoa of the phylum Cnidaria. High PLA2 levels were found in the hydrozoan fire coral Millepora sp. (median 735 U/g protein) and the stony coral Pocillopora damicornis (693 U/g) that cause skin irritation upon contact. High levels of PLA2 activity were also found in the acontia of the sea anemone Adamsia carciniopados (293 U/g). Acontia are long threads containing nematocysts and are used in defense and aggression by the animal. Tentacles of scyphozoan and cubozoan species had high PLA2 activity levels: those of the multitentacled box jellyfish Chironex fleckeri contained 184 U/g PLA2 activity. The functions of cnidarian PLA2 may include roles in the capture and digestion of prey and defense of the animal. The current observations support the idea that cnidarian PLA2 may participate in the sting site irritation and systemic envenomation syndrome resulting from contact with cnidarians.     

Character evolution in Hydrozoa (phylum Cnidaria)

The diversity of hydrozoan life cycles, as manifested in the wide range of polyp, colony, and medusa morphologies, has been appreciated for centuries. Unraveling the complex history of characters involved in this diversity is critical for understanding the processes driving hydrozoan evolution. In this study, we use a phylogenetic approach to investigate the evolution of morphological characters in Hydrozoa. A molecular phylogeny is reconstructed using ribosomal DNA sequence data. Several characters involving polyp, colony, and medusa morphology are coded in the terminal taxa. These characters are mapped onto the phylogeny and then the ancestral character states are reconstructed. This study confirms the complex evolutionary history of hydrozoan morphological characters. Many of the characters involving polyp, colony, and medusa morphology appear as synapomorphies for major hydrozoan clades, yet homoplasy is commonplace.     

Potential of MALDI-TOF MS-based proteomic fingerprinting for species identification of Cnidaria across classes,species, regions and developmental stages

Morphological identification of cnidarian species can be difficult throughout all life stages due to the lack of distinct morphological characters. Moreover, in some cnidarian taxa genetic markers are not fully informative, and in these cases combinations of different markers or additional morphological verifications may be required. Proteomic fingerprinting based on MALDI-TOF mass spectra was previously shown to provide reliable species identification in different metazoans including some cnidarian taxa. For the first time, we tested the method across four cnidarian classes (Staurozoa, Scyphozoa, Anthozoa, Hydrozoa) and included different scyphozoan life-history stages (polyp, ephyra, medusa) in our dataset. Our results revealed reliable species identification based on MALDI-TOF mass spectra across all taxa with species-specific clusters for all 23 analysed species. In addition, proteomic fingerprinting was successful for distinguishing developmental stages, still by retaining a species specific signal. Furthermore, we identified the impact of different salinities in different regions (North Sea and Baltic Sea) on proteomic fingerprints to be negligible. In conclusion, the effects of environmental factors and developmental stages on proteomic fingerprints seem to be low in cnidarians. This would allow using reference libraries built up entirely of adult or cultured cnidarian specimens for the identification of their juvenile stages or specimens from different geographic regions in future biodiversity assessment studies.