Reduced oxygen tension results in reduced human T cell proliferation and increased intracellular oxidative damage and susceptibility to apoptosis upon activation

Cell culture and in vitro models are the basis for much biological research, especially in human immunology. Ex vivo studies of T cell physiology employ conditions attempting to mimic the in vivo situation as closely as possible. Despite improvements in controlling the cellular milieu in vitro, most of what is known about T cell behavior in vitro is derived from experiments on T cells exposed to much higher oxygen levels than are normal in vivo. In this study, we report a reduced proliferative response and increased apoptosis susceptibility after T cell activation at 2% oxygen compared to in air. To explain this observation, we tested the hypothesis of an impaired efficacy of intracellular protective mechanisms including antioxidant levels, oxidized protein repair (methionine sulfoxide reductases), and degradation (proteasome) activities. Indeed, after activation, there was a significant accumulation of intracellular oxidized proteins at more physiological oxygen levels concomitant with a reduced GSH:GSSG ratio. Proteasome and methionine sulfoxide reductase activities were also reduced. These data may explain the increased apoptotic rate observed at more physiological oxygen levels. Altogether, this study highlights the importance of controlling oxygen levels in culture when investigating oxygen-dependent phenomena such as oxidative stress.     

Hypoxia in the thymus: role of oxygen tension in thymocyte survival

Our previous studies using oxygen microelectrodes showed that the thymus is grossly hypoxic under normal physiological conditions. We now have investigated how oxygen tension affects the thymus at the cellular and molecular level. Adducts of the hypoxia marker drug pimonidazole accumulated in foci within the cortex and medulla and at the corticomedullary junction, consistent with the presence of widespread cellular hypoxia in the normal thymus. Hypoxia-associated pimonidazole accumulation was decreased but not abrogated by oxygen administration. Genes previously reported to be induced by hypoxia were expressed at baseline levels in the normal thymus, indicating that physiological adaptation to hypoxia occurred. Despite changes in thymus size and cellularity, thymic PO(2) did not change with age. Combined assays for hypoxia and cell death showed that hypoxia achieved using either hypoxic gas mixtures or high-density culture in normoxia decreased spontaneous thymocyte apoptosis in vitro. Taken together, these data suggest that regulatory mechanisms exist to maintain thymic cellular hypoxia in vivo and that oxygen tension may regulate thymocyte survival both in vitro and in vivo.     

Effects of hypoxia on human mesenchymal stem cell expansion and plasticity in 3D constructs

Low oxygen tension is thought to be an integral component of the human mesenchymal stem cell (hMSC) native bone marrow microenvironment. HMSC were cultured under physiologically relevant oxygen environments (2% O2) in three-dimensional (3D) constructs for up to 1 month in order to investigate the combined effects of chronic hypoxia and 3D architecture on hMSC tissue-development patterns. Hypoxic hMSC exhibited an extended lag phase in order to acclimatize to culture conditions. However, they subsequently proliferated continuously throughout the culture period, while maintaining significantly higher colony-forming unit capabilities and expressing higher levels of stem cell genes than hMSC cultured at 20% O2 (normoxic) conditions. Upon induction, hypoxic hMSC also expressed higher levels of osteoblastic and adipocytic differentiation markers than normoxic controls. Hypoxia induced increased total protein levels in hMSC throughout the culture period, as well as significantly different fibronectin expression patterns suggesting that oxygen levels can significantly affect tissue-development patterns. Importantly, hMSC maintained the ability to thrive in prolonged hypoxic conditions suggesting that hypoxia may be an essential element of the in vivo hMSC niche. Further studies are required to determine how variations in cellular characteristics and ECM expression impact on the physiological properties of the engineered tissue, yet these results strongly indicate that oxygen tension is a key parameter that influences the in vitro characteristics of hMSC and their development into tissues.     

Effect of culture PO2 on macrophage (RAW 264.7) nitric oxide production

Macrophages are commonly cultured at a PO2 of 149 Torr, but tissue macrophages in vivo live in an environment of much lower oxygen tension. Despite the many potential mechanisms for changes in oxygen tension to influence nitric oxide (NO) synthesis, there have been few reports investigating the effect of PO2 on macrophage NO production. With the use of a culture chamber designed to rigorously control oxygen tension, we investigated the effects of culture PO2 on macrophage NO production, inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) activity, iNOS protein, and tumor necrosis factor production. NO production and iNOS activity were linearly related in the range of 39.4 to 677 Torr, but not in the range of 1.03 to 39.4 Torr. Therefore, results obtained in vitro for the high oxygen tensions commonly used in cell culture were quantitatively and qualitatively different from results obtained in cells cultured at the lower oxygen tensions that more accurately reflect the in vivo environment. The influence of oxygen tension on NO production has implications for cell culture methodology and for the relationship between microcirculatory dysfunction and inflammatory responses in rodent models of sepsis.     

Effects of oxygen transport on 3-d human mesenchymal stem cell metabolic activity in perfusion and static cultures: experiments and mathematical model

Human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) have unique potential to develop into functional tissue constructs to replace a wide range of tissues damaged by disease or injury. While recent studies have highlighted the necessity for 3-D culture systems to facilitate the proper biological, physiological, and developmental processes of the cells, the effects of the physiological environment on the intrinsic tissue development characteristics in the 3-D scaffolds have not been fully investigated. In this study, experimental results from a 3-D perfusion bioreactor system and the static culture are combined with a mathematical model to assess the effects of oxygen transport on hMSC metabolism and proliferation in 3-D constructs grown in static and perfusion conditions. Cells grown in the perfusion culture had order of magnitude higher metabolic rates, and the perfusion culture supports higher cell density at the end of cultivation. The specific oxygen consumption rate for the constructs in the perfusion bioreactor was found to decrease from 0.012 to 0.0017 micromol/10(6) cells/h as cell density increases, suggesting intrinsic physiological change at high cell density. BrdU staining revealed the noneven spatial distribution of the proliferating cells in the constructs grown under static culture conditions compared to the cells that were grown in the perfusion system. The hypothesis that the constructs in static culture grow under oxygen limitation is supported by higher Y(L/G) in static culture. Modeling results show that the oxygen tension in the static culture is lower than that of the perfusion unit, where the cell density was 4 times higher. The experimental and modeling results show the dependence of cell metabolism and spatial growth patterns on the culture environment and highlight the need to optimize the culture parameters in hMSC tissue engineering.     

Adverse effects of reduced oxygen tension on the proliferative capacity of rat kidney and insulin-secreting cell lines involve DNA damage and stress responses

Standard cell culture conditions do not reflect the physiological environment in terms of oxygen tension (20% vs 3%). The effects of lowering oxygen tension on cell proliferation in culture can be beneficial as well as detrimental depending on the cell line studied, but the molecular mechanism underlying such effects is not fully understood. We observed that the proliferative capacity of the rat cell lines NRK and INS-1 was inhibited when cultured under 3% oxygen as compared to 20% oxygen. Suppression of proliferation in NRK cells was accompanied by induction of DNA double strand breaks whereas in INS-1 cells it was accompanied by up-regulation of p53 and p27. Although Sirt1 was up-regulated in both cell lines by 3% oxygen the effects on antioxidant enzymes (MnSOD, CuZnSOD and catalase) were cell line specific. Marked up-regulation of heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) was detected in both NRK and INS-1 cells when cultured in 3% oxygen. HO-1 expression can be readily induced by exposure to hydrogen peroxide in culture. These results suggest that reduced oxygen tension suppresses the proliferative capacity of these two cell lines through a stress response that is similar to an oxidative stress response but the molecular events that lead to the reduced cell proliferation are cell line specific.     

Modeling spatial distribution of oxygen in 3d culture of islet beta‐cells

Three‐dimensional (3D) scaffold culture of pancreatic β‐cell has been proven to be able to better mimic physiological conditions in the body. However, one critical issue with culturing pancreatic β‐cells is that β‐cells consume large amounts of oxygen, and hence insufficient oxygen supply in the culture leads to loss of β‐cell mass and functions. This becomes more significant when cells are cultured in a 3D scaffold. In this study, in order to understand the effect of oxygen tension inside a cell‐laden collagen culture on β‐cell proliferation, a culture model with encapsulation of an oxygen‐generator was established. The oxygen‐generator was made by embedding hydrogen peroxide into nontoxic polydimethylsiloxane to avoid the toxicity of a chemical reaction in the β‐cell culture. To examine the effectiveness of the oxygenation enabled 3D culture, the spatial‐temporal distribution of oxygen tension inside a scaffold was evaluated by a mathematical modeling approach. Our simulation results indicated that an oxygenation‐aided 3D culture would augment the oxygen supply required for the β‐cells. Furthermore, we identified that cell seeding density and the capacity of the oxygenator are two critical parameters in the optimization of the culture. Notably, cell‐laden scaffold cultures with an in situ oxygen supply significantly improved the β‐cells' biological function. These β‐cells possess high insulin secretion capacity. The results obtained in this work would provide valuable information for optimizing and encouraging functional β‐cell cultures. © 2016 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 33:221–228, 2017     

Oxygen concentration modulates the differentiation of muscle stem cells toward myogenic and adipogenic fates

The physiological oxygen concentration of many tissues is far lower than that in which cells are typically cultured in vitro and this may inadvertently influence the proliferation and differentiation potential of many cell types. Muscle derived stem cells, known as satellite cells are responsible for the maintenance and repair of muscle tissue post-natally and in vivo would be exposed to oxygen concentrations of ～2-5%. Relatively few studies describe the function of these cells in large animal models and here we investigate the influence oxygen concentration has on modulating porcine muscle derived stem cell fate. We compared cells derived from two metabolically distinct muscles, the diaphragm and the hind limb semi-membranosus (SM) muscle. The two sub-populations responded differently to culture at atmospheric (～20%) and physiological (～5%) oxygen concentration. While myogenesis was enhanced in both populations at low oxygen, noticeably diaphragm derived cells exhibited greater myotube formation, than those from SM. The trans-differentiation of cells derived from these two sources was similarly affected, with considerable differences seen in adipogenic and neuronal tendencies. In addition to the effect of oxygen on cell phenotype, the expression of key signalling proteins varied between the two sub-populations during early time-points of induced differentiation, suggesting altered regulation of muscle specific stem cells under these conditions. While differences in muscle stem cell potential requires further investigation, the culture of cells in physiological oxygen concentration appears as fundamental to recreating the micro-environmental niche as routinely used factors such as cytokines, substrata and matrices.     

Physiological intestinal oxygen modulates the Caco-2 cell model and increases sensitivity to the phytocannabinoid cannabidiol

The Caco-2 cell model is widely used as a model of colon cancer and small intestinal epithelium but, like most cell models, is cultured in atmospheric oxygen conditions (～21%). This does not reflect the physiological oxygen range found in the colon. In this study, we investigated the effect of adapting the Caco-2 cell line to routine culturing in a physiological oxygen (5%) environment. Under these conditions, cells maintain a number of key characteristics of the Caco-2 model, such as increased formation of tight junctions and alkaline phosphatase expression over the differentiation period and maintenance of barrier function. However, these cells exhibit differential oxidative metabolism, proliferate less and become larger during differentiation. In addition, these cells were more sensitive to cannabidiol-induced antiproliferative actions through changes in cellular energetics: from a drop of oxygen consumption rate and loss of mitochondrial membrane integrity in cells treated under atmospheric conditions to an increase in reactive oxygen species in intact mitochondria in cells treated under low-oxygen conditions. Inclusion of an additional physiological parameter, sodium butyrate, into the medium revealed a cannabidiol-induced proliferative response at low doses. These effects could impact on its development as an anticancer therapeutic, but overall, the data supports the principle that culturing cells in microenvironments that more closely mimic the in vivo conditions is important for drug screening and mechanism of action studies.     

Effects of establishing cell cultures and cell culture conditions on the proliferative life span of human fibroblasts isolated from different tissues and donors of different ages

It is well known that normal human cells placed in a culture environment exhibit a limited proliferative capacity. The extent to which the culture environment influences proliferative life span is not understood. This study evaluated the effects of the standard procedures used to establish and maintain cultures on the proliferative life spans of different types of human fibroblast cells established from fetal and adult skin and lung. The results of this study demonstrate that procedures to establish cell cultures use only one of several subpopulations of cells present in biopsy pieces and that the culture conditions routinely employed by most laboratories can exert significant effects on proliferative life-span determinations. The maximum proliferative life span differed significantly when obtained by growing the cells in two commonly used commercial media. Proliferative life span was inversely related to ambient oxygen tension and directly related to seeding density in all of the lines examined although lines established from adult skin were much more resistant to toxicity. Enzymatic antioxidant defense levels of fetal skin fibroblasts were much lower than those observed in adult skin fibroblasts, but the effects of oxygen on their life spans were similar. Hyperoxia induced larger increases in glutathione concentration in cell lines with low antioxidant enzyme levels.     

Effects of antioxidants and reduced oxygen tension on rat mammary epithelial cells in culture

Summary Free radical damage has the potential to significantly affect the behavior of cells in culture. In this study the effects of antioxidants (superoxide dismutase, catalase, and vitamin E) and lowered oxygen tension (1% oxygen) on primary culture of rat mammary epithelial cells were examined. Rat mammary epithelial cells were dissociated in collagenase with or without the addition of antioxidants and low oxygen tension, then cultured for 10 d in rat-tail collagen gel matrix and fed with Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’sF12 medium supplemented with various hormones and growth factors. Growth potential of the mammary cells was enhanced when antioxidants and low oxygen tension were used, alone or in combination, during the cell dissociation period. Using antioxidants and low oxygen tension during the culture period failed to improve growth potential regardless whether cells were dissociated in standard conditions or with antioxidants and low oxygen tension. The use of antioxidants and low oxygen tension during the cell dissociation period also reduced the degree of keratinization of the cells after 10 d of culture. Using antioxidants and low oxygen tension during the cell culture period did not further reduce keratinization if antioxidants and low oxygen tension were used during the dissociation period, but were effective in reducing keratinization if cells were dissociated in standard condition. In this system, antioxidants and low oxygen tension reduced lipid peroxidation during the cell dissociation period. An iron chelator, desferal, can also reduce lipid peroxidation and enhance growth when used during cell dissociation, suggesting the enhanced growth potential by the addition of antioxidants and low oxygen to be due to the reduction of lipid peroxidation. This study is supported by grants CA05388 and GM11903 to Y. K. H. from the Public Health Service, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, DC.     

Hypoxia and neural stem cells: from invertebrates to brain cancer stem cells

Oxygen is a fundamental element for all living organisms, and modifications in its concentration influence several physiological and pathological events such as embryogenesis, development and also aging. Regulation of oxygen levels is an important factor in neural stem cell biology (e.g. differentiation, growth and the capacity to generate more differentiated cells). Studies on neural stem cells in culture have deepened our knowledge of their survival, proliferation and differentiation pathways. However, traditional cell culture for neural stem cells is performed employing environmental oxygen levels of 20%, while the effective oxygen concentration in the developing and adult brain is significantly lower; this results in an important alteration of the in vivo conditions. Several data indicate that a so called "physiologic hypoxic condition" could strongly influence the growth of neural stem cells and their differentiation mechanisms both in vivo and in vitro. The present overview deals with the different mechanisms utilized by invertebrate and vertebrate organisms to respond to hypoxic conditions. It highlights how the adaptations and responses to different oxygen concentrations have changed along the developmental route and underlines the importance of oxygen concentration in neural physiology and differentiation, with a final hint to the involvement of hypoxia in brain cancer stem cells.     

Limitations of alginate gels as a culture model for the study of the effects of UVA radiation on human dermal fibroblasts

Several studies were undertaken to develop three-dimensional (3-D) cell culture models that allow conditions closer to the in vivo situation. To this end, alginate gels were tested as a 3-D cell culture model that might be useful in the study of the effects of UVA on human dermal fibroblasts. Cell culture in alginate gels and the irradiation conditions were optimized. Results showed that optimized cultures in alginate gels experienced considerable cell death on UVA irradiation compared to the classical monolayer cell culture. Viability tests (cell counting and neutral red assay) were performed to show that only UVA-irradiated alginate gels were responsible for this cytotoxicity. The implication of oxygen species in the phototoxicity induced by ultraviolet light has already been described; for this reason we investigated whether oxygen species were involved in the cytotoxicity induced by alginate upon UVA irradiation. It appeared that superoxide anion is not implicated     

Hypoxia or in situ normoxia: The stem cell paradigm

Although O₂ concentrations are considerably lowered in vivo, depending on the tissue and cell population in question (some cells need almost anoxic environment for their maintenance) the cell and tissue cultures are usually performed at atmospheric O₂ concentration (20–21%). As an instructive example, the relationship between stem cells and micro‐environmental/culture oxygenation has been recapitulated. The basic principle of stem cell biology, “the generation‐age hypothesis,” and hypoxic metabolic properties of stem cells are considered in the context of the oxygen‐dependent evolution of life and its transposition to ontogenesis and development. A hypothesis relating the self‐renewal with the anaerobic and hypoxic metabolic properties of stem cells and the actual O₂ availability is elaborated (“oxygen stem cell paradigm”). Many examples demonstrated that the cellular response is substantially different at atmospheric O₂ concentration when compared to lower O₂ concentrations which better approximate the physiologic situation. These lower O₂ concentrations, traditionally called “hypoxia” represent, in fact, an in situ normoxia, and should be used in experimentation to get an insight of the real cell/cytokine physiology. The revision of our knowledge on cell/cytokine physiology, which has been acquired ex vivo at non physiological atmospheric (20–21%) O₂ concentrations representing a hyperoxic state for most primate cells, has thus become imperious. J. Cell. Physiol. 219: 271–275, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Developmental responses of 2-cell embryos to oxygen tension and bovine serum albumin in Wistar rats.

To improve rat embryo culture conditions, responses of Wistar 2-cell embryos from 2 breeders to oxygen tension (5 vs 20%) and bovine serum albumin (BSA) (0 vs 3 mg/ml) were examined using rat 1-cell embryo culture medium (mR1ECM). Supplementation of 3 mg/ml BSA significantly stimulated and accelerated development to the blastocyst and expanded blastocyst stages during 72 and 96 h culture, while reduced oxygen tension stimulated cell division. Fetus development after transfer of blastocysts obtained from 72 h culture under 5% O2 with BSA was significantly higher than those cultured under atmospheric oxygen without BSA. However, the nuclear numbers of in vitro cultured blastocysts and fetus development after embryo transfer were still significantly lower than in vivo developed blastocysts, indicating the current culture condition is still suboptimal.     

Effect of oxygen levels on the physiology of dendritic cells: implications for adoptive cell therapy

Dendritic cell (DC)-based adoptive tumor immunotherapy approaches have shown promising results, but the incidence of tumor regression is low and there is an evident call for identifying culture conditions that produce DCs with a more potent Th1 potential. Routinely, DCs are differentiated in CO(2) incubators under atmospheric oxygen conditions (21% O(2)), which differ from physiological oxygen levels of only 3-5% in tissue, where most DCs reside. We investigated whether differentiation and maturation of DCs under physiological oxygen levels could produce more potent T-cell stimulatory DCs for use in adoptive immunotherapy. We found that immature DCs differentiated under physiological oxygen levels showed a small but significant reduction in their endocytic capacity. The different oxygen levels did not influence their stimuli-induced upregulation of cluster of differentiation 54 (CD54), CD40, CD83, CD86, C-C chemokine receptor type 7 (CCR7), C-X-C chemokine receptor type 4 (CXCR4) and human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DR or the secretion of interleukin (IL)-6, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α and IL-10 in response to lipopolysaccharide (LPS) or a cytokine cocktail. However, DCs differentiated under physiological oxygen level secreted higher levels of IL-12(p70) after exposure to LPS or CD40 ligand. Immature DCs differentiated at physiological oxygen levels caused increased T-cell proliferation, but no differences were observed for mature DCs with regard to T-cell activation. In conclusion, we show that although DCs generated under atmospheric or physiological oxygen conditions are mostly similar in function and phenotype, DCs differentiated under physiological oxygen secrete larger amounts of IL-12(p70). This result could have implications for the use of ex vivo-generated DCs for clinical studies, since DCs differentiated at physiological oxygen could induce increased Th1 responses in vivo.     

Establishment of new mouse embryonic stem cell lines is improved by physiological glucose and oxygen

Embryonic stem cell lines are routinely selected and cultured in glucose and oxygen concentrations that are well above those of the intrauterine environment. Supraphysiological glucose and hyperoxia each increase oxidative stress, which could be detrimental to survival in vitro by inhibiting proliferation and/or inducing cell death. The aim of this study was to test whether isolation of new embryonic stem cell lines from murine blastocysts is improved by culture in physiological (5%) oxygen instead of approximately 20%, the concentration of oxygen in room air, or in media containing physiological (100 mg/dL) instead of 450 mg/dL glucose. We found that culturing in either physiological oxygen or physiological glucose improved the success of establishing new murine embryonic stem cell lines, and that culture when concentrations of both oxygen and glucose were physiological improved the success of establishing new lines more than culture in either alone. Physiological oxygen and glucose reduce oxidative stress, as determined by 2',7'-dichloro-dihydrofluorescein fluorescence. BrdU incorporation suggests that physiological oxygen and glucose increase the pool of proliferating cells. Cells isolated in physiological oxygen and glucose are capable of self-renewal and differentiation into all three germ layers in vitro. However, none of the culture conditions prevents cytogenetic instability with prolonged passage. These results suggest that culture of cells derived from murine blastocysts in physiological oxygen and glucose reduces oxidant stress, which increases the success of establishing new embryonic stem cell lines.     

A review of bioreactor protocols for human neural precursor cell expansion in preparation for clinical trials

Tissue-specific human neural precursor cells (hNPCs) can be isolated from various regions of the developing or adult central nervous system and may serve as a viable source of cells in cell replacement therapies for the treatment of neurodegenerative disorders. However, in order for cell replacement strategies to become a routine therapeutic option for the treatment of neurodegenerative disorders, hNPCs should be generated under standardized and controlled conditions. Studies over the last two decades have focused on developing cell growth media and cell handling protocols for expansion and differentiation of hNPCs in culture. Key studies have reported the development of serum-free growth media and large-scale computer-controlled suspension bioreactors that can support high cell proliferation rates (doubling times < 3 days), multipotentiality, and potential neurogenic differentiation (more than 60% neurons). Moreover, bioengineering studies have focused on controlling culture conditions in suspension bioreactors including inoculation, hydrodynamics of culture, oxygen and nutrients transfer to the cells, monitoring in situ physiological parameters using process control techniques, and expansion for extended periods of time. In addition, in vitro and in vivo characterization of hNPCs have been performed, providing information on stem/progenitor cell characteristics, cell surface analysis, and appropriate type of cells to use in transplantation studies.