Studies on the degradation pathway of iron-sulfur centers during unfolding of a hyperstable ferredoxin: cluster dissociation,iron release and protein stability

The ferredoxin from the thermoacidophile Acidianus ambivalens is a representative of the archaeal family of di-cluster [3Fe-4S][4Fe-4S] ferredoxins. Previous studies have shown that these ferredoxins are intrinsically very stable and led to the suggestion that upon protein unfolding the iron-sulfur clusters degraded via linear three-iron sulfur center species, with 610 and 520 nm absorption bands, resembling those observed in purple aconitase. In this work, a kinetic and spectroscopic investigation on the alkaline chemical denaturation of the protein was performed in an attempt to elucidate the degradation pathway of the iron-sulfur centers in respect to protein unfolding events. For this purpose we investigated cluster dissociation, iron release and protein unfolding by complementary biophysical techniques. We found that shortly after initial protein unfolding, iron release proceeds monophasically at a rate comparable to that of cluster degradation, and that no typical EPR features of linear three-iron sulfur centers are observed. Further, it was observed that EDTA prevents formation of the transient bands and that sulfide significantly enhances its intensity and lifetime, even after protein unfolding. Altogether, our data suggest that iron sulfides, which are formed from the release of iron and sulfide resulting from cluster degradation during protein unfolding in alkaline conditions, are in fact responsible for the observed intermediate spectral species, thus disproving the hypothesis suggesting the presence of a linear three-iron center intermediate. Kinetic studies monitored by visible, fluorescence and UV second-derivative spectroscopies have elicited that upon initial perturbation of the tertiary structure the iron-sulfur centers start decomposing and that the presence of EDTA accelerates the process. Also, the presence of EDTA lowers the observed melting temperature in thermal ramp experiments and the midpoint denaturant concentration in equilibrium chemical unfolding experiments, further suggesting that the clusters also play a structural role in the maintenance of the conformation of the folded state.     

High thermal and chemical stability of Thermus thermophilus seven-iron ferredoxin. Linear clusters form at high pH on polypeptide unfolding.

To probe the stability of the seven-iron ferredoxin from Thermus thermophilus (FdTt), we investigated its chemical and thermal denaturation processes in solution. As predicted from the crystal structure, FdTt is extremely resistant to perturbation. The guanidine hydrochloride-induced unfolding transition shows a midpoint at 6.5 m (pH 7, 20 degrees C), and the thermal midpoint is above boiling, at 114 degrees C. The stability of FdTt is much lower at acidic pH, suggesting that electrostatic interactions are important for the high stability at higher pH. On FdTt unfolding at alkaline pH, new absorption bands at 520 nm and 610 nm appear transiently, resulting from rearrangement of the cubic clusters into linear three-iron species. A range of iron-sulfur proteins has been found to accommodate these novel clusters in vitro, although no biological function has yet been assigned.     

Stability and folding of the ferredoxin from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Acidianus ambivalens

The ferredoxin from the thermophilic archaeon Acidianus ambivalens is a small monomeric protein containing two iron-sulfur centres, one [3Fe-4S](1+/0) and one [4Fe-4S](2+/1+). It is an intrinsically hyperstable protein, being expressed at the organism's extreme optimal growth temperature: 80 degrees C. Using spectroscopic methods we have investigated the unfolding reaction of the Acidianus ambivalens ferredoxin. No unfolding of the oxidised ferredoxin was observed at pH 7.0, even in the presence of 8 M GuHCl. Upon increasing the pH to 10.0, the unfolding transition showed a midpoint at 6.3 M GuHCl and an unfolding-free energy of 70 kJ mol(-1) in buffer (pH 10) was estimated. Kinetic-unfolding experiments showed that the polypeptide unfolding correlated with rearrangement of the iron-sulfur centres to new ones which had strong absorption maxima at 520 and 610 nm. These new, possibly linear three-iron, clusters were coordinated to the unfolded protein but degraded slowly. From thermal experiments in the presence of GuHCl we estimated the melting temperature for the Acidianus ambivalens ferredoxin in buffer (at pH 7) to be 122 degrees C. Possible structural properties that contribute to the large thermal stability of the Acidianus ambivalens ferredoxin are discussed using a three-dimensional protein model.     

High stability of a ferredoxin from the hyperthermophilic archaeon A. ambivalens: involvement of electrostatic interactions and cofactors

The ferredoxin from the thermophilic archaeon Acidianus ambivalens is a small monomeric seven-iron protein with a thermal midpoint (T(m)) of 122 degrees C (pH 7). To gain insight into the basis of its thermostability, we have characterized unfolding reactions induced chemically and thermally at various pHs. Thermal unfolding of this ferredoxin, in the presence of various guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) concentrations, yields a linear correlation between unfolding enthalpies (DeltaH[T(m)]) and T(m) from which an upper limit for the heat capacity of unfolding (DeltaC(P)) was determined to be 3.15 +/- 0.1 kJ/(mole * K). Only by the use of the stronger denaturant guanidine thiocyanate (GuSCN) is unfolding of A. ambivalens ferredoxin at pH 7 (20 degrees C) observed ([GuSCN](1/2) = 3.1 M; DeltaG(U)[H(2)O] = 79 +/- 8 kJ/mole). The protein is, however, less stable at low pH: At pH 2.5, T(m) is 64 +/- 1 degrees C, and GuHCl-induced unfolding shows a midpoint at 2.3 M (DeltaG(U)[H(2)O] = 20 +/- 1 kJ/mole). These results support that electrostatic interactions contribute significantly to the stability. Analysis of the three-dimensional molecular model of the protein shows that there are several possible ion pairs on the surface. In addition, ferredoxin incorporates two iron-sulfur clusters and a zinc ion that all coordinate deprotonated side chains. The zinc remains bound in the unfolded state whereas the iron-sulfur clusters transiently form linear three-iron species (in pH range 2.5 to 10), which are associated with the unfolded polypeptide, before their complete degradation.     

Antioxidant activity of sugar-lysine Maillard reaction products in cell free and cell culture systems

The presence of a linear [3Fe-4S] cluster in a protein was first observed in beef-heart aconitase. Here, we report the formation of linear [3Fe-4S] clusters upon guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl)-induced unfolding of Aquifex aeolicus [2Fe-2S] ferredoxins (Fd) (AaeFd1, AaeFd4, and AaeFd5) at alkaline conditions (pH 10, 20 degrees C). We find the mechanism of linear [3Fe-4S] cluster formation to depend critically on the speed of polypeptide unfolding. In similarity to seven-iron Fds, polypeptide unfolding determines the rate by which linear [3Fe-4S] clusters form in AaeFd4 and AaeFd5. In contrast, in a disulfide-lacking variant of AaeFd1, which unfolds faster than AaeFd4 and AaeFd5, the polypeptides unfold first and the majority of clusters decompose. Next, unfolded polypeptides retaining intact clusters scavenge iron and sulfur to form linear [3Fe-4S] clusters in a bimolecular reaction. Wild-type AaeFd1 unfolds slower than the speed of linear-cluster decomposition, and the linear species is never populated. Linear [3Fe-4S] clusters may be intermediates during folding of iron-sulfur proteins.     

Exceptional stability of a [2Fe-2S] ferredoxin from hyperthermophilic bacterium Aquifex aeolicus

Aquifex aeolicus is the only hyperthermophile that is known to contain a plant- and mammalian-type [2Fe-2S] ferredoxin (Aae Fd1). This unique protein contains two cysteines, in addition to the four that act as ligands of the [2Fe-2S] cluster, which form a disulfide bridge. We have investigated the stability of Aae Fd1 with (wild-type) and without (C87A variant) the disulfide bond, with respect to pH, thermal and chemical perturbation, and compared the results to those for the mesophilic [2Fe-2S] ferredoxin from spinach. Unfolding reactions of all three proteins are irreversible due to cluster decomposition in the unfolded state. Wild-type and C87A Aae Fd1 proteins are extremely stable: unfolding at 20 degrees C requires high concentrations of the chemical denaturant and long incubation times. Moreover, their thermal-unfolding midpoints are 40-50 degrees higher than that for spinach ferredoxin (pH 7). The stability of the Aae Fd1 protein is significantly lower at pH 2.5 than pH 7 and 10, suggesting that ionic interactions play a role in structural integrity. Interestingly, the iron-sulfur cluster in C87A Aae Fd1 rearranges into a transient species with absorption bands at 520 and 610 nm, presumably a linear three-iron cluster, in the high-pH unfolded state.     

Formation of a linear [3Fe-4S] cluster in a seven-iron ferredoxin triggered by polypeptide unfolding

Cubic iron-sulfur ([Fe-S]) clusters are common inorganic cofactors in proteins. The presence of a linear [3Fe-4S] cluster in a protein was first observed in beef-heart aconitase at high pH, where the protein structure was perturbed. Not long ago, the same linear cluster was discovered upon unfolding of a thermophilic di-cluster seven-iron ferredoxin, suggesting a more general relevance for this type of linear clusters in Nature. Since structure-induced cluster rearrangements may be important regulatory, on-going processes in living systems, we decided to further characterize the formation of the linear iron-sulfur cluster observed upon ferredoxin unfolding. Here we present a kinetic investigation of parameters that affect the linear-cluster formation and disassembly in the Sulfolobus acidocaldarius seven-iron ferredoxin. We find the linear cluster to be an intermediate on the protein-mediated cluster-degradation pathway under a wide range of pH and denaturant conditions. The linear species forms in parallel with secondary-structure disappearance. In contrast, the disassembly rate constant for the linear cluster is independent of denaturant concentration but depends strongly on solution pH. At high pH, the disassembly rate is slower and the linear iron-sulfur species has a longer lifetime, than at low pH.     

Interplay of IscA and IscU in biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters

Increasing evidence suggests that sulfur in ubiquitous iron-sulfur clusters is derived from L-cysteine via cysteine desulfurases. In Escherichia coli, the major cysteine desulfurase activity for biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters has been attributed to IscS. The gene that encodes IscS is a member of an operon iscSUA, which also encodes two highly conserved proteins: IscU and IscA. Previous studies suggested that both IscU and IscA may act as the iron-sulfur cluster assembly scaffold proteins. However, recent evidence indicated that IscA is an iron-binding protein that can provide iron for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly in IscU (Ding, H., Harrison, K., and Lu, J. (2005) J. Biol. Chem. 280, 30432-30437). To further elucidate the function of IscA in biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters, we evaluate the iron-sulfur cluster binding activity of IscA and IscU under physiologically relevant conditions. When equal amounts of IscA and IscU are incubated with an equivalent amount of ferrous iron in the presence of IscS, L-cysteine and dithiothreitol, iron-sulfur clusters are assembled in IscU, but not in IscA, suggesting that IscU is a preferred iron-sulfur cluster assembly scaffold protein. In contrast, when equal amounts of IscA and IscU are incubated with an equivalent amount of ferrous iron in the presence of IscS and dithiothreitol but without L-cysteine, nearly all iron is bound to IscA. The iron binding in IscA appears to prevent the formation of the biologically inaccessible ferric hydroxide under aerobic conditions. Subsequent addition of L-cysteine efficiently mobilizes the iron center in IscA and transfers the iron for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly in IscU. The results suggest an intriguing interplay between IscA and IscU in which IscA acts as an iron chaperon that recruits "free" iron and delivers the iron for biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters in IscU under aerobic conditions.     

Sequential unfolding of the two-domain protein Pseudomonas stutzeri cytochrome c(4)

P. stutzeri cytochrome c(4) is a di-haem protein, composed of two globular domains each with His-Met coordinated haem, and a hydrogen bond network between the domains. The domain foldings are highly symmetric but with specific differences including structural differences of ligand coordination, and different spin states of the oxidised haem groups. We have studied unfolding of oxidised P. stutzeri cyt c(4) induced thermally and by chemical denaturants. Horse heart cyt c was a reference molecule. Isothermal unfolding induced by guanidinium chloride and acid was followed by Soret, alpha/beta, and 701-nm band absorption, and by far-UV circular dichroism spectroscopy. Multifarious patterns emerge, but the two domains clearly unfold sequentially. One phase, assigned to unfolding of the N-terminal domain, proceeds at guanidinium concentrations up to approximately 1.0 M. This is followed by two overlapping phases at higher concentrations. The intermediate state maintains Fe-Met coordination, assigned to the C-terminal domain. Interdomain interaction is reflected in decreasing values of the cooperativity parameters. Differential scanning calorimetry shows a single peak, but two peaks appear when guanidinium chloride up to 0.4 M is present. This reflects different chemical action in chemical and thermal unfolding. Acid-induced unfolding kinetics was addressed by pH jumps using diode array stopped-flow techniques. Three kinetic phases in the 701 nm Fe-Met marker band, and four phases in the Soret and alpha/beta bands, spanning 4-1000 ms could be distinguished on pH jumps from 7.5 to the range 2.5-3.5. In this range of time and pH cyt c appears to unfold in no more than two phases. Spectral properties of the kinetic intermediates could be identified. Sequential domain unfolding, formation of high-spin states, and an intermediate state with Fe-Met coordination to a single haem group are features of the unfolding kinetics.     

Iron-sulfur proteins are the major source of protein-bound dinitrosyl iron complexes formed in Escherichia coli cells under nitric oxide stress

Protein-bound dinitrosyl iron complexes (DNICs) have been observed in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells under nitric oxide (NO) stress. The identity of proteins that bind DNICs, however, still remains elusive. Here we demonstrate that iron-sulfur proteins are the major source of protein-bound DNICs formed in Escherichia coli cells under NO stress. Expression of recombinant iron-sulfur proteins, but not proteins without iron-sulfur clusters, almost doubles the amount of protein-bound DNICs formed in E. coli cells after NO exposure. Purification of recombinant proteins from the NO-exposed E. coli cells further confirms that iron-sulfur proteins, but not proteins without iron-sulfur clusters, are modified, forming protein-bound DNICs. Deletion of the iron-sulfur cluster assembly proteins IscA and SufA to block the [4Fe-4S] cluster biogenesis in E. coli cells largely eliminates the NO-mediated formation of protein-bound DNICs, suggesting that iron-sulfur clusters are mainly responsible for the NO-mediated formation of protein-bound DNICs in cells. Furthermore, depletion of the "chelatable iron pool" in wild-type E. coli cells effectively removes iron-sulfur clusters from proteins and concomitantly diminishes the NO-mediated formation of protein-bound DNICs, indicating that iron-sulfur clusters in proteins constitute at least part of the chelatable iron pool in cells.     

IscA mediates iron delivery for assembly of iron-sulfur clusters in IscU under the limited accessible free iron conditions

Increasing evidence suggests that IscS, a cysteine desulfurase, provides sulfur for assembly of transient iron-sulfur clusters in IscU. IscU appears to act as a scaffold and eventually transfers the assembled clusters to target proteins. However, the iron donor for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly largely remains elusive. Here we find that Escherichia coli IscU fails to assemble iron-sulfur clusters when the accessible "free" iron in solution is limited by an iron chelator sodium citrate. Remarkably, IscA, an iron-sulfur cluster assembly protein with an iron association constant of 3.0 x 10(19) m(-1), is able to overcome the iron limitation due to sodium citrate and deliver iron for the IscS-mediated iron-sulfur cluster assembly in IscU. Substitution of the invariant cysteine residues Cys-99 or Cys-101 in IscA with serine completely abolishes the iron binding activity of the protein. The IscA mutants that fail to bind iron are unable to mediate iron delivery for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly in IscU under the limited accessible "free" iron conditions. The results suggest that IscA is capable of recruiting intracellular iron and providing iron for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly in IscU in cells in which the accessible "free" iron content is probably restricted.     

Insights into properties and energetics of iron-sulfur proteins from simple clusters to nitrogenase

Some of the principal physical features of iron-sulfur clusters in proteins are analyzed, including metal-ligand covalency, spin polarization, spin coupling, valence delocalization, valence interchange and small reorganization energies, with emphasis on recent spectroscopic and theoretical work. The current state of structural, spectroscopic, and computational knowledge for the iron-sulfur clusters in the nitrogenase iron and iron-molybdenum proteins is examined by comparison and contrast to 'simpler' ironclusters. The differing interactions of the nitrogenase iron and iron-molybdenum clusters compared with those of other iron-sulfur clusters with the protein and solvent environment are also explored.     

Stepwise unfolding of a β barrel protein by the AAA+ ClpXP protease

In the AAA+ ClpXP protease, ClpX uses the energy of ATP binding and hydrolysis to unfold proteins before translocating them into ClpP for degradation. For proteins with C-terminal ssrA tags, ClpXP pulls on the tag to initiate unfolding and subsequent degradation. Here, we demonstrate that an initial step in ClpXP unfolding of the 11-stranded β barrel of superfolder GFP-ssrA involves extraction of the C-terminal β strand. The resulting 10-stranded intermediate is populated at low ATP concentrations, which stall ClpXP unfolding, and at high ATP concentrations, which support robust degradation. To determine if stable unfolding intermediates cause low-ATP stalling, we designed and characterized circularly permuted GFP variants. Notably, stalling was observed for a variant that formed a stable 10-stranded intermediate but not for one in which this intermediate was unstable. A stepwise degradation model in which the rates of terminal-strand extraction, strand refolding or recapture, and unfolding of the 10-stranded intermediate all depend on the rate of ATP hydrolysis by ClpXP accounts for the observed changes in degradation kinetics over a broad range of ATP concentrations. Our results suggest that the presence or absence of unfolding intermediates will play important roles in determining whether forced enzymatic unfolding requires a minimum rate of ATP hydrolysis.     

Swapping core residues in homologous proteins swaps folding mechanism

Rat intestinal fatty acid binding protein (IFABP) displays an intermediate with little if any secondary structure during unfolding, while the structurally homologous rat ileal lipid binding protein (ILBP) displays an intermediate during unfolding with nativelike secondary structure. Double-jump experiments indicate that these intermediates are on the folding path for each protein. To test the hypothesis that differences in the number of buried hydrophobic atoms in a folding initiating site are responsible for the different types of intermediates observed for these proteins, two mutations (F68C-IFABP and C69F-ILBP) were made that swapped a more hydrophobic residue for a more hydrophilic residue in the respective cores of these two proteins. F68C-IFABP followed an unfolding path identical to that of WT-ILBP with an intermediate that showed nativelike secondary structure, whereas C69F-ILBP followed an unfolding path that was identical to that of WT-IFABP with an intermediate that lacked secondary structure. Further, a hydrophilic residue was introduced at an identical hydrophobic structural position in both proteins (F93S-IFABP and F94S-ILBP). Replacement of phenylalanine with serine at this site led to the appearance of an intermediate during refolding that lacked secondary structure for both proteins that was not detected for either parental protein. Altering the chemical characteristics and/or size of residues within an initiating core of hydrophobic interactions is critical to the types of intermediates that are observed during the folding of these proteins.     

Heterotrifunctional Chemical Cross-Linking Mass Spectrometry Confirms Physical Interaction between Human Frataxin and ISU

The progressive neurodegenerative disease Friedreich's ataxia is caused by a decreased level of expression of frataxin, a putative iron chaperone. Frataxin is thought to transiently interact with ISU, the scaffold protein onto which iron-sulfur clusters are assembled, to deliver ferrous iron. Photoreactive heterotrifunctional chemical cross-linking confirmed the interaction between frataxin and ISU in the presence of iron and validated that transient interactions can be covalently trapped with this method. Because frataxin may participate in transient interactions with other mitochondrial proteins, this cross-linking approach may reveal new protein partners and pathways in which it interacts and help deduce direct, downstream consequences of its deficiency.     

Formation of iron-sulfur clusters in bacteria: an emerging field in bioinorganic chemistry

Biological iron-sulfur clusters are chemically versatile inorganic structures that are attached to many proteins. These clusters are intimately involved in the functions of their partner proteins and they are required to sustain life on earth. Recent work has demonstrated that, in spite of their simple structures, the assembly and insertion of iron-sulfur clusters into their protein partners is a complex biological process. This complexity is probably related to the cellular toxicity of iron and sulfur in their free forms.     

The coordination sphere of iron-sulfur clusters: lessons from site-directed mutagenesis experiments

 Cysteine is the ubiquitous ligand of iron-sulfur clusters in proteins, although chemical models have indicated that functional groups other than thiolates can coordinate iron in iron-sulfur compounds. Only a small number of naturally occurring examples of hydroxyl, histidinyl or carboxyl coordination have been clearly established but many others are suspected. Quite a few site-directed mutagenesis experiments have been aimed at replacing the cysteine ligands of iron-sulfur centers by other amino acids in various systems. The available data set shows that substituting one ligand, even by another functional residue, is very often destabilizing enough to impair cluster assembly; in some cases, the apoprotein cannot even be detected. One for one replacements have been demonstrated, but they have been so far almost exclusively confined to clusters with no more than one or two iron atoms. In contrast, changes of the cluster nuclearity or recruitment of free cysteine residues seem preferred ways for proteins containing larger clusters to cope with removal of a ligand, rather than using coordinating amino acids bearing different chemical functions. Furthermore, the possibility of replacing cysteines by other residues as ligands in iron-sulfur proteins does not uniquely depend on the ability of the cluster to accept other kinds of coordination than cysteinate; other factors such as the local flexibility of the polypeptide chain, the accessibility of the solvent and the electronic distribution on the active centers may also play a prominent role.     

Characterization of iron-sulfur cluster assembly protein isca from Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans

IscA is a key member of the iron-sulfur cluster assembly machinery found in bacteria and eukaryotes, but the mechanism of its function in the biogenesis of iron-sulfur cluster remains elusive. In this paper, we demonstrate that Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans IscA is a [4Fe-4S] cluster binding protein, and it can bind iron in the presence of DTT with an apparent iron association constant of 4·10²⁰ M^?1. The iron binding in IscA can be promoted by oxygen through oxidizing ferrous iron to ferric iron. Furthermore, we show that the iron bound form of IscA can be converted to iron-sulfur cluster bound form in the presence of IscS and L-cysteine in vitro. Substitution of the invariant cysteine residues Cys35, Cys99, or Cys101 in IscA abolishes the iron binding activity of the protein; the IscA mutants that fail to bind iron are unable to assemble the iron-sulfur clusters. Further studies indicate that the iron-loaded IscA could act as an iron donor for the assembly of iron-sulfur clusters in the scaffold protein IscU in vitro. Taken together, these findings suggest that A. ferrooxidans IscA is not only an iron-sulfur protein, but also an iron binding protein that can act as an iron donor for biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters.     

Expression, Purification, and Characterization of an Iron Chaperon Protein CyaY from Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans

CyaY is the bacterial homolog of frataxin, proposed to be involved in the assembly of iron-sulfur clusters. While, the physiological iron donor for the iron-sulfur clusters assembly remains controversial. In this study, the gene of CyaY from Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli, the protein was purified by one-step affinity chromatography to homogeneity. The CyaY protein can bind ferric iron and serve as an iron donor for the biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters on the scaffold protein IscU in the presence of IscS and L-cysteine in vitro.     

Coming into view: eukaryotic iron chaperones and intracellular iron delivery

Eukaryotic cells contain hundreds of metalloproteins, and ensuring that each protein receives the correct metal ion is a critical task for cells. Recent work in budding yeast and mammalian cells has uncovered a system of iron delivery operating in the cytosolic compartment that involves monothiol glutaredoxins, which bind iron in the form of iron-sulfur clusters, and poly(rC)-binding proteins, which bind Fe(II) directly. In yeast cells, cytosolic monothiol glutaredoxins are required for the formation of heme and iron-sulfur clusters and the metallation of some non-heme iron enzymes. Poly(rC)-binding proteins can act as iron chaperones, delivering iron to target non-heme enzymes through direct protein-protein interactions. Although the molecular details have yet to be explored, these proteins, acting independently or together, may represent the basic cellular machinery for intracellular iron delivery.