Phage λ Cro Protein and Ci Repressor Use Two Different Patterns of Specific Protein-DNA Interactions to Achieve Sequence Specificity in Vivo

By assaying the binding of wild-type Cro to a set of 40 mutant lambda operators in vivo, we have determined that the 14 outermost base pairs of the 17 base pair, consensus lambda operator are critical for Cro binding. Cro protein recognizes 4 base pairs in a lambda operator half-site in different ways than cI repressor. The sequence determinants of Cro binding at these critical positions in vivo are nearly perfectly consistent with the model proposed by W. F. ANDERSON, D. H. OHLENDORF, Y. TAKEDA and B. W. MATTHEWS and modified by Y. TAKEDA, A. SARAI and V. M. RIVERA for the specific interactions between Cro and its operator, and explain the relative order of affinities of the six natural lambda operators for Cro. Our data call into question the idea that lambda repressor and Cro protein recognize the consensus lambda operator by nearly identical patterns of specific interactions.     

1H NMR study of the interaction of bacteriophage lambda Cro protein with the OR3 operator. Evidence for a change of the conformation of the OR3 operator on binding.

The specific complex between the lambda phage OR3 operator and the Cro protein has been studied by proton NMR spectroscopy at 500 MHz. The DNA imino proton resonances of this complex have been assigned to specific base pairs using the known assignments of these resonances for the free operator. Increase of the protein/DNA ratio to complete saturation of the OR3 operator with the Cro protein made it possible to follow the shift changes of the resonances. Ambiguities were resolved by nuclear Overhauser effect measurements on the complex. The shifts of the imino proton resonance positions provide information on the changes induced in the conformation of the operator upon complex formation with a dimer of the Cro protein. The most striking shift occurs for the central (GC 9) base pair, which is known to have no direct contacts with the Cro protein. This shift may be induced by a bend in the OR3 operator DNA at the GC 9 base pair to accommodate the operator for the binding of the Cro protein dimer. The imino proton resonances of two additional base pairs can be observed in the complex, demonstrating an overall stabilization of the DNA structure by the binding of the Cro protein.     

DNA recognition by the helix-turn-helix motif: investigation by laser Raman spectroscopy of the phage lambda repressor and its interaction with operator sites OL1 and OR3.

The lambda repressor provides a model system for biophysical studies of DNA recognition by the helix-turn-helix motif. We describe laser Raman studies of the lambda operator sites OL1 and OR3 and their interaction with the DNA-binding domain of lambda repressor (residues 1-102). Raman spectra of the two DNA sites exhibit significant differences attributable to interstrand purine-purine steps that differ in the two oligonucleotides. Remarkably, the conformation of each operator is significantly and specifically altered by repressor binding. Protein recognition, which involves hydrogen-bond formation and hydrophobic contacts in the major groove, induces subtle changes in DNA Raman bands of interacting groups. These include (i) site-specific perturbations to backbone phosphodiester geometry at AT-rich domains, (ii) hydrophobic interaction at thymine 5CH3 groups, (iii) hydrogen bonding to guanine 7N and 6C = O acceptors, and (iv) alterations in sugar pucker within the C2'-endo (B-DNA) family. These perturbations differ between aqueous OL1 and OR3 complexes of repressor, indicating that protein binding in solution determines the precise DNA conformation. The overall structure of the lambda domain is not greatly perturbed by binding to either OL1 or OR3, in accord with X-ray studies of other complexes. However, Raman markers indicate a change in hydrogen bonding of the OH group of tyrosine-22, which is a hydrogen-bond acceptor in the absence of DNA but a combined donor and acceptor in the OL1 complex; yet, Y22 hydrogen bonding is not altered in forming the OR3 complex. The present results demonstrate qualitatively different and distinguishable modes of interaction of the lambda repressor DNA-binding domain with operators OL1 and OR3 in solution. This application of laser Raman spectroscopy to a well-characterized system provides a prototype for future Raman studies of other DNA-binding motifs under physiological conditions.     

Nucleotide sequence of the operators of lambda ultravirulent mutants.

The nucleotide sequence of the operators of ultravirulent mutants of lambda, able to grow on host cells with elevated repressor levels, was determined. It appears that ultravirulence in lambda requires multiple mutational events at the operator sequences. OL1, OL2, and OL3 operator sites are the target of mutational changes in ultravirulent phages indicating that these sites participate in vivo in repression of the PL promoter. No changes were found in the OR3 sequence, in contrast there is a mutation in OR2 and two mutations in OR1, in both lambda 668 and lambda 2668 phages. This mutated operator structure accounts for the constitutive expression of their PR promoter either in cells overproducing the lambda repressor or in cells overproducing the cro gene product. A model of the structure of the lambda operator site is proposed. The nucleotide sequence in each site can be divided into two functionally different subsets, one of which is recognized by the repressor while the other stabilizes the repressor-operator interaction.     

Proton-linked contributions to site-specific interactions of lambda cI repressor and OR

The effects of proton activity on the site-specific interactions of cI repressors with operator sites OR were studied by using DNase I footprint titration. Individual-site binding isotherms were obtained for the binding of repressor to each site of wild-type OR and of mutant operators in which binding to some sites is eliminated. The Gibbs energies for binding and for cooperativity (in every operator configuration) were determined at each pH (range 5-8). The proton-linked effects clearly account for a significant fraction of the difference in affinities for the three operator sites. The most dramatic effects on the repressor-operator binding interactions are at acid pH, and therefore do not involve the basic groups in the repressor N-terminal arm known to contact the DNA. Also, the proton-linked effects are different at the three operator sites as indicated by significantly different derivative relationships, partial derivative of ln k versus partial derivative of ln aH = net proton absorption (delta nu bar(H)). These results implicate ionizable repressor groups which may not contact the DNA and conformational differences between the three repressor-operator site complexes as being important components to the mechanism of site specificity. The extensive data base generated by these studies was also used to reevaluate the traditional models used to describe cooperativity in this system. The results confirm the lack of significant cooperative interaction between OR1 and OR3 at all conditions. However, the data for some experimental conditions are clearly inconsistent with the (selection) rule, that cooperative interaction between OR2 and OR3 is eliminated by ligation at OR1.     

Interaction of lambda cro repressor with synthetic operator OR3 studied by competition binding with minor groove binders.

In the present work, we employ a combination of CD spectroscopy and gel retardation technique to characterize thermodynamically the binding of lambda phage cro repressor to a 17 base pair operator OR3. We have found that three minor groove-binding antibiotics, distamycin A, netropsin and sibiromycin, compete effectively with the cro for binding to the operator OR3. Among these antibiotics, sibiromycin binds covalently to DNA in the minor groove at the NH2 of guanine, whereas distamycin A and netropsin interact preferentially with runs of AT base pairs and avoid DNA regions containing guanine bases in the two polynucleotide strands. Only subtle DNA conformation changes are known to take place upon binding of these antibiotics. Both the CD spectral profiles and the results of the gel retardation experiments indicate that distamycin A and netropsin can displace cro repressor from the operator OR3. The binding of cro repressor to the OR3 is accompanied by considerable changes in CD in the far-UV region which appear to be attributed to a DNA-dependent structural transition in the protein. Spectral changes are also induced in the wavelength region of 270-290 nm. The CD spectral profile of the cro-OR3 mixture in the presence of distamycin A can be represented as a sum of the CD spectrum of the repressor-operator complex and spectrum of distamycin-DNA complex at the appropriate molar ratio of the bound antibiotic to the operator DNA (r). When r tends to the saturation level of binding the CD spectrum in the region of 270-360 nm approaches a CD pattern typical of complexes of the antibiotic with the free DNA oligomer. This suggests that simultaneous binding of cro repressor and distamycin A to the same DNA oligomer is not possible and that distamycin A and netropsin can be used to determine the equilibrium affinity constant of cro repressor to the synthetic operator from competition-type experiments. The binding constant of cro repressor to the OR3 is found to be (6 +/- 1).10(6)M-1 at 20 degrees C in 10 mM sodium cacodylate buffer (pH 7.0) in the presence of 0.1 M NH4F.     

Lac repressor with the helix-turn-helix motif of lambda cro binds to lac operator.

Lac repressor, lambda cro protein and their operator complexes are structurally, biochemically and genetically well analysed. Both proteins contain a helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif which they use to bind specifically to their operators. The DNA sequences 5'-GTGA-3' and 5'-TCAC-3' recognized in palindromic lac operator are the same as in lambda operator but their order is inverted form head to head to tail to tail. Different modes of aggregation of the monomers of the two proteins determine the different arrangements of the HTH motifs. Here we show that the HTH motif of lambda cro protein can replace the HTH motif of Lac repressor without changing its specificity. Such hybrid Lac repressor is unstable. It binds in vitro more weakly than Lac repressor but with the same specificity to ideal lac operator. It does not bind to consensus lambda operator.     

Study of the structure of phage lambda operator OR1 using two-dimensional 1H-NMR-spectroscopy

NOESY spectroscopy at 500 HMz was employed to assign resonances of nonexchangeable protons in the 1H NMR spectrum of the synthesized 17 base pair duplex of deoxyribonucleotides comprising the OR1 operator, one of the specific binding sites for the bacteriophage lambda cro repressor. A pure absorption spectrum that was obtained by the phase sensitive detection technique allowed to perform a resonance assignment of base and deoxyribose protons, excepting H-5'- and H-5"-protons, on the basis of a single NOESY experiment, mixing time 200 ms. The sequential assignment strategy for 2D NMR spectra of oligonucleotides was used for this purpose. The data obtained and the previous results on OR3 are discussed in the view of the conformation of operators in solution. It is shown that both duplexes exist in the DNA B-form with its intrinsic anti conformation of the nucleotides. Conformation of DNA segments with identical primary structures are similar, and local deviations from the classical B-form are determined by a nucleotide sequence.     

Specificity of the interaction between lambda cro repressor protein and operator DNA fragments

Cro repressor protein is known to interact with specific sites in the operator DNA. The cro protein of lambda phage was isolated and the mode of its interaction with three different DNA fragment, lambda-OR3 17mer, phi 80-OR2 19mer and CAP binding site 22-mer, were examined by the use of proton NMR. Some of the imino proton resonances of lambda-OR3 shifted and were broadened remarkably on addition of lambda-cro protein, which indicated the induction of conformational change with complexation. In the spectrum of phi 80-OR2 which has a six base pair sequence common to lambda-OR3 the signals of the common base pairs revealed slight shifts on addition of lambda-cro protein. The imino proton signals of the CAP site DNA, however, did not show any change at all on mixing with lambda-cro. Combining the data of photo CIDNP of lambda-cro, we could postulate the mode of interaction between lambda-cro repressor and operator DNA.     

Imino proton assignments in the proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of the lambda phage OR3 deoxyribonucleic acid fragment

The 17 base pair duplex d(TATCACCGCAAGGGATAp) . d(TATCCCTTGCGGTGATAp) corresponding to the OR3 operator site of lambda phage has been synthesized and studied by 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy at 470 MHz. The 13 imino proton resonances observed at 20 degrees C have been assigned to specific base pairs at positions 3-15 on the basis of nuclear Overhauser effect measurements and studies of the temperature dependence of peak intensities. Resonances from the A-T base pairs at positions 1, 2, 16, and 17 are assumed to be absent from the spectrum because of terminal fraying. Resonance from many of the base pairs suggested by Ohlendorf et al. [Ohlendorf, D. H., Anderson, W. F., Fisher, R. G., Takeda, Y., & Matthews, B. W. (1982) Nature (London) 298, 718-723] to be involved in specific binding of the lambda phage cro repressor are well resolved.     

100ps molecular dynamic simulation of d(TATCACC)2.

A heptanucleotide sequence d(TATCACC)2 from OR3 region of bacteriophage lambda is considered sufficient for the recognition of Cro protein. We present here results on molecular dynamic simulations on this sequence for 100 ps in 0.02 ps interval. The simulations are done using computer program GROMOS. The conformational results are averaged over each ps. The IUPAC torsional parameters for 100 conformations are illustrated using a wheal and a dial systems. Several other stereochemical parameters such as H-bonding lengths and angles, sugar puckers, helix twist and roll angles as also distances between opposite strand phosphorus are depicted graphically. We find that there is rupture of terminal H-bonds. The bases are tilted and shifted away from the helix axis giving rise to bifurcated H-bonds. H-bonds are seen even in between different base pairs. The role of these dynamic structural changes in the recognition of OR3 operator by Cro protein is discussed in the paper.     

Kinetic studies on Cro repressor-operator DNA interaction

The six operators of phage lambda and their consensus sequence were synthesized as 21 base-pair DNAs and their interactions with Cro repressor were studied using a filter binding assay. The measured equilibrium dissociation constants suggest that Cro has the highest affinity to the consensus operator (KD = 1.2 X 10(-12) M) and then the OR3 operator (KD = 2.0 X 10(-12) M), after that the affinity becomes lower in the following order: OR1, OL1, OL2, OL3, OR2. The competition experiments show that Cro forms the most stable complex with the consensus operator (t1/2 = 150 min), which is followed by the complex with OR3 (t1/2 = 70 min), OR1, OL1, OL2, OL3 and OR2. The association rate constants (ka) were also measured. They are approximately the same (2 X 10(8) to 4 X 10(8) m-1 s-1) for the consensus, OR3, OR2 and OR1 operators. These experiments have thus shown that the sequence difference in the operator affects the dissociation (KD and kd) but not the association (ka) process. The operators' binding strengths relative to OR1 are 14 (for consensus operator), 7.6 (OR3), 0.73 (OL1), 0.42 (OL2), 0.16 (OL3) and 0.1 (OR2). Seven different lengths of OR-containing DNA fragments were prepared. Measurement of kinetic parameters shows that the affinity of Cro to operator DNA (measured by KD) is essentially constant and independent of the DNA length, while the association and dissociation rate constants increase as the DNA length increases. This is consistent with the idea that Cro locates and leaves its operator via a two-step mechanism. It appears that Cro binds first at an arbitrary site on DNA, then is transferred to its operator site by a facilitated mechanism. The process is reversed when Cro dissociates from the operator. Most of our data fit to the theoretical expression formulated by Berg, Winter & von Hippel for the sliding mechanism. We conclude that Cro slides along the DNA to locate and leave the operator.     

Site-specific enthalpic regulation of DNA transcription at bacteriophage lambda OR.

Binding of cI repressor to DNA fragments containing the three specific binding sites of the right operator (OR) of bacteriophage lambda was studied in vitro over the temperature range 5-37 degrees C by quantitative footprint titration. The individual-site isotherms, obtained for binding repressor dimers to each site of wild-type OR and to appropriate mutant operator templates, were analyzed for the Gibbs energies of intrinsic binding and pairwise cooperative interactions. It is found that dimer affinity for each of the three sites varies inversely with temperature, i.e., the binding reactions are enthalpy driven, unlike many protein-DNA reactions. By contrast, the magnitude of the pairwise cooperativity terms describing interaction between adjacently site-bound repressor dimers is quite small. This result in combination with the recent finding that repressor monomer-dimer assembly is highly enthalpy driven (with delta H degrees = -16 kcal mol-1) [Koblan, K. S., & Ackers, G. K. (1991) Biochemistry 30, 7817-7821] indicates that the associative contacts between site-bound repressors that mediate cooperativity are unlikely to be the same as those responsible for dimerization. The intrinsic binding enthalpies for all three sites are negative (exothermic) and nearly temperature-invariant, indicating no heat capacity changes on the scale of those inferred in other protein-DNA systems. However, the three operator sites are affected differentially by temperature: the intrinsic binding free energies for sites OR1 and OR3 change in parallel over the entire range, delta H0OR1 = -23.3 +/- 4.0 kcal mol-1 and delta H0OR3 = -22.7 +/- 1.2 kcal mol-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Sites of contact between lambda operators and lambda repressor.

DNA bearing lambda operator sequences was methylated by dimethyl sulfate (DMS) in the presence or absence of lambda repressor. Under the experimental conditions, DMS methylates only the purine residues. The presence of lambda repressor affects only the methylation of certain G residues in the operators. Repressor blocks the methylation of certain G's and enhances the methylation of other G's. Since the reactive ring-nitrogen of G lies in the major groove of double-stranded DNA, and the reactive ring-nitrogen of A lies in the minor groove, the above results imply that the repressor makes contacts in the major groove of the helix. The repressor effect on G-methylation is sharply confined to the three 17 base pair units within each lambda operator previously proposed as the repressor-binding sites.     

Flanking DNA-sequences contribute to the specific binding of cI-repressor and OR1.

The binding of cI-repressor to a series of mutant operators containing OR1 of the right operator of bacteriophage lambda was investigated. Sites OR2 and/or OR3 were inactivated by either point or deletion mutations. The free energy of binding repressor to OR1 in the wildtype operator, delta G1, is -13.7 +/- 0.3 kcal/mol. delta G1 determined for an OR2- operator created by a single point mutation in OR2 is -13.6 +/- 0.2 kcal/mol. In contrast, delta G1 for the binding of repressor to a cloned synthetic OR1 operator containing only 24 bp of lambda sequence is -12.2 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol. When sequence 5' to OR1 is present, the binding affinity increases to -13.0 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol. In addition, the proximity of OR1 to a fragment-end decreases delta G1 from -13.7 to -12.3 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol. These results suggest that the DNA sequence outside the 17 bp OR1 binding-site contributes to the specific binding of cI-repressor.     

Comparison of the structures of operator DNA free and in complex with lambda repressor

The structures of operator DNA unbound and in complex with lambda repressor protein are compared. The conformation of the left 10 base pairs of a lambda right regulatory operator DNA sequence has been previously determined in solution using nuclear magnetic resonance techniques and the structure of a homologous left regulatory operator DNA bound to lambda repressor N-terminal domain had been previously solved using X-ray crystallography. The DNA adopts an overall linear B-form DNA both in the absence and presence of lambda repressor. Superimpositioning of the DNA structures reveals small differences between them that are due to the binding of protein and not to the different techniques used for their determination.