Structural framework for the mechanism of archaeal exosomes in RNA processing

Exosomes emerge as central 3'-->5' RNA processing and degradation machineries in eukaryotes and archaea. We determined crystal structures of two 230 kDa nine subunit archaeal exosome isoforms. Both exosome isoforms contain a hexameric ring of RNase phosphorolytic (PH) domain subunits with a central chamber. Tungstate soaks identified three phosphorolytic active sites in this processing chamber. A trimer of Csl4 or Rrp4 subunits forms a multidomain macromolecular interaction surface on the RNase-PH domain ring with central S1 domains and peripheral KH and zinc-ribbon domains. Structural and mutational analyses suggest that the S1 domains and a subsequent neck in the RNase-PH domain ring form an RNA entry pore to the processing chamber that only allows access of unstructured RNA. This structural framework can mechanistically unify observed features of exosomes, including processive degradation of unstructured RNA, the requirement for regulatory factors to degrade structured RNA, and left-over tails in rRNA trimming.     

Characterization of native and reconstituted exosome complexes from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus

The eukaryotic exosome is a protein complex with essential functions in processing and degradation of RNA. Exosome-like complexes were recently found in Archaea. Here we characterize the exosome of Sulfolobus solfataricus. Two exosome fractions can be discriminated by density gradient centrifugation. We show that the Cdc48 protein is associated with the exosome from the 30S-50S fraction but not with the exosome of the 11.3S fraction. While only some complexes contain Cdc48, the archaeal DnaG-like protein was found to be a core exosome subunit in addition to Rrp4, Rrp41, Rrp42 and Csl4. Assays with depleted extracts revealed that the exosome is responsible for major ribonucleolytic activity in S. solfataricus. Various complexes consisting of the Rrp41-Rrp42 hexameric ring and Rrp4, Csl4 and DnaG were reconstituted. Dependent on their composition, different complexes showed variations in RNase activity indicating functional interdependence of the subunits. The catalytic activity of these complexes and of the native exosome can be ascribed to the Rrp41-Rrp42 ring, which degrades RNA phosphorolytically. Rrp4 and Csl4 do not exhibit any hydrolytic RNase activity, either when assayed alone or in context of the complex, but influence the activity of the archaeal exosome.     

An exosome-like complex in Sulfolobus solfataricus

We present the first experimental evidence for the existence of an exosome-like protein complex in Archaea. In Eukarya, the exosome is essential for many pathways of RNA processing and degradation. Co-immunoprecipitation with antibodies directed against the previously predicted Sulfolobus solfataricus orthologue of the exosome subunit ribosomal-RNA-processing protein 41 (Rrp41) led to the purification of a 250-kDa protein complex from S. solfataricus. Approximately half of the complex cosediments with ribosomal subunits. It comprises four previously predicted orthologues of the core exosome subunits from yeast (Rrp41, Rrp42, Rrp4 and Csl4 (cep1 synthetic lethality 4; an RNA-binding protein and exosome subunit)), whereas other predicted subunits were not found. Surprisingly, the archaeal homologue of the bacterial DNA primase DnaG was tightly associated with the complex. This suggests an RNA-related function for the archaeal DnaG-like proteins. Comparison of experimental data from different organisms shows that the minimal core of the exosome consists of at least one phosphate-dependent ribonuclease PH homologue, and of Rrp4 and Csl4. Such a protein complex was probably present in the last common ancestor of Archaea and Eukarya.     

The RNA exosome complex central channel controls both exonuclease and endonuclease Dis3 activities in vivo and in vitro

The RNA exosome is an essential ribonuclease complex involved in RNA processing and decay. It consists of a 9-subunit catalytically inert ring composed of six RNase PH-like proteins forming a central channel and three cap subunits with KH/S1 domains located at the top. The yeast exosome catalytic activity is supplied by the Dis3 (also known as Rrp44) protein, which has both endo- and exoribonucleolytic activities and the nucleus-specific exonuclease Rrp6. In vitro studies suggest that substrates reach the Dis3 exonucleolytic active site following passage through the ring channel, but in vivo support is lacking. Here, we constructed an Rrp41 ring subunit mutant with a partially blocked channel that led to thermosensitivity and synthetic lethality with Rrp6 deletion. Rrp41 mutation caused accumulation of nuclear and cytoplasmic exosome substrates including the non-stop decay reporter, for which degradation is dependent on either endonucleolytic or exonucleolytic Dis3 activities. This suggests that the central channel also controls endonucleolytic activity. In vitro experiments performed using Chaetomium thermophilum exosomes reconstituted from recombinant subunits confirmed this notion. Finally, we analysed the impact of a lethal mutation of conserved basic residues in Rrp4 cap subunit and found that it inhibits digestion of single-stranded and structured RNA substrates.     

Structure of the active subunit of the yeast exosome core, Rrp44: diverse modes of substrate recruitment in the RNase II nuclease family

The eukaryotic exosome is a macromolecular complex essential for RNA processing and decay. It has recently been shown that the RNase activity of the yeast exosome core can be mapped to a single subunit, Rrp44, which processively degrades single-stranded RNAs as well as RNAs containing secondary structures. Here we present the 2.3 A resolution crystal structure of S. cerevisiae Rrp44 in complex with single-stranded RNA. Although Rrp44 has a linear domain organization similar to bacterial RNase II, in three dimensions the domains have a different arrangement. The three domains of the classical nucleic-acid-binding OB fold are positioned on the catalytic domain such that the RNA-binding path observed in RNase II is occluded. Instead, RNA is threaded to the catalytic site via an alternative route suggesting a mechanism for RNA-duplex unwinding. The structure provides a molecular rationale for the observed biochemical properties of the RNase R family of nucleases.     

The archaeal exosome core is a hexameric ring structure with three catalytic subunits

The exosome is a 3' --> 5' exoribonuclease complex involved in RNA processing. We report the crystal structure of the RNase PH core complex of the Sulfolobus solfataricus exosome determined at a resolution of 2.8 A. The structure reveals a hexameric ring-like arrangement of three Rrp41-Rrp42 heterodimers, where both subunits adopt the RNase PH fold common to phosphorolytic exoribonucleases. Structure-guided mutagenesis reveals that the activity of the complex resides within the active sites of the Rrp41 subunits, all three of which face the same side of the hexameric structure. The Rrp42 subunit is inactive but contributes to the structuring of the Rrp41 active site. The high sequence similarity of this archaeal exosome to eukaryotic exosomes and its high structural similarity to the bacterial mRNA-degrading PNPase support a common basis for RNA-degrading machineries in all three domains of life.     

Genetic interactions suggest multiple distinct roles of the arch and core helicase domains of Mtr4 in Rrp6 and exosome function

The RNA exosome is responsible for a wide variety of RNA processing and degradation reactions. The activity and specificity of the RNA exosome is thought to be controlled by a number of cofactors. Mtr4 is an essential RNA-dependent adenosine triphosphatase that is required for all of the nuclear functions of the RNA exosome. The crystal structure of Mtr4 uncovered a domain that is conserved in the RNA exosome cofactors Mtr4 and Ski2 but not in other helicases, suggesting it has an important role related to exosome activation. Rrp6 provides the nuclear exosome with one of its three nuclease activities, and previous findings suggested that the arch domain is specifically required for Rrp6 functions. Here, we report that the genetic interactions between the arch domain of Mtr4 and Rrp6 cannot be explained by the arch domain solely acting in Rrp6-dependent processing reactions. Specifically, we show that the arch domain is not required for all Rrp6 functions, and that the arch domain also functions independently of Rrp6. Finally, we show that the arch domain of Ski2, the cytoplasmic counterpart of Mtr4, is required for Ski2’s function, thereby confirming that the arch domains of these cofactors function independently of Rrp6.     

Structural insights into the interaction of the Nip7 PUA domain with polyuridine RNA

The conserved protein Nip7 is involved in ribosome biogenesis, being required for proper 27S pre-rRNA processing and 60S ribosome subunit assembly in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Yeast Nip7p interacts with nucleolar proteins and with the exosome subunit Rrp43p, but its molecular function remains to be determined. Solution of the Pyrococcus abyssi Nip7 (PaNip7) crystal structure revealed a monomeric protein composed by two alpha-beta domains. The N-terminal domain is formed by a five-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet surrounded by three alpha-helices and a 310 helix while the C-terminal, a mixed beta-sheet domain composed by strands beta8 to beta12, one alpha-helix, and a 310 helix, corresponds to the conserved PUA domain (after Pseudo-Uridine synthases and Archaeosine-specific transglycosylases). By combining structural analyses and RNA interaction assays, we assessed the ability of both yeast and archaeal Nip7 orthologues to interact with RNA. Structural alignment of the PaNip7 PUA domain with the RNA-interacting surface of the ArcTGT (archaeosine tRNA-guanine transglycosylase) PUA domain indicated that in the archaeal PUA domain positively charged residues (R151, R152, K155, and K158) are involved in RNA interaction. However, equivalent positions are occupied by mostly hydrophobic residues (A/G160, I161, F164, and A167) in eukaryotic Nip7 orthologues. Both proteins can bind specifically to polyuridine, and RNA interaction requires specific residues of the PUA domain as determined by site-directed mutagenesis. This work provides experimental verification that the PUA domain mediates Nip7 interaction with RNA and reveals that the preference for interaction with polyuridine sequences is conserved in Archaea and eukaryotic Nip7 proteins.     

Quantitative analysis of processive RNA degradation by the archaeal RNA exosome

RNA exosomes are large multisubunit assemblies involved in controlled RNA processing. The archaeal exosome possesses a heterohexameric processing chamber with three RNase-PH-like active sites, capped by Rrp4- or Csl4-type subunits containing RNA-binding domains. RNA degradation by RNA exosomes has not been studied in a quantitative manner because of the complex kinetics involved, and exosome features contributing to efficient RNA degradation remain unclear. Here we derive a quantitative kinetic model for degradation of a model substrate by the archaeal exosome. Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods for parameter estimation allow for the comparison of reaction kinetics between different exosome variants and substrates. We show that long substrates are degraded in a processive and short RNA in a more distributive manner and that the cap proteins influence degradation speed. Our results, supported by small angle X-ray scattering, suggest that the Rrp4-type cap efficiently recruits RNA but prevents fast RNA degradation of longer RNAs by molecular friction, likely by RNA contacts to its unique KH-domain. We also show that formation of the RNase-PH like ring with entrapped RNA is not required for high catalytic efficiency, suggesting that the exosome chamber evolved for controlled processivity, rather than for catalytic chemistry in RNA decay.     

The roles of S1 RNA-binding domains in Rrp5's interactions with pre-rRNA

RNA-binding proteins mediate the function of all RNAs. Since few distinct RNA-binding domains (RBDs) exist, with most RBDs contacting only a few nucleotides, RNA-binding proteins often combine multiple RNA-binding motifs to achieve a higher affinity and selectivity for their targets. Rrp5, a ribosome assembly factor essential for both 40S and 60S ribosome maturation, is an extreme example as it contains 12 tandem S1 RNA-binding domains. In this study, we use a combination of RNA binding and DMS probing experiments to probe interactions of Rrp5 with pre-rRNA mimics. Our data localize Rrp5's binding site to three distinct regions within internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1), the sequence between 18S and 5.8S rRNAs. One of these regions is directly adjacent to a recently uncovered helical structure, which prevents premature cleavage at the 3'-end of 18S rRNA. This finding, together with previous results, suggests a role for Rrp5 in regulating the above-mentioned helical element. Furthermore, we have produced two truncated forms of the protein, Rrp5N and Rrp5C, which together encompass the entire protein and fully restore growth. Quantitative analysis of the RNA affinity of these Rrp5 fragments indicates that the first nine S1 motifs contribute much of Rrp5's RNA affinity, while the last three domains alone provide its specificity for the pre-rRNA. This surprising division of labor is unique, as it suggests that S1 domains can bind RNA both specifically as well as nonspecifically with high affinity; this has important implications for the molecular details of the Rrp5?pre-rRNA complex.     

Poring over exosome structure

The authors analyse the eukaryotic exosome structure, published in EMBO reports, in light of the known archaeal and prokaryotic exosomes, and discuss its striking flexibility and the conservation of the RNA channelling mechanism.EMBO Rep (2010) advance online publication. doi: 10.1038/embor.2010.164Almost all RNA molecules are processed by RNases to form mature RNAs. In addition, many RNAs are degraded, either because they are no longer needed or because they are aberrant. All of these functions—RNA processing, normal RNA degradation and RNA quality control—are carried out by the eukaryotic RNA exosome complex. In this issue of EMBO reports, the Lorentzen group provide structural insight into the eukaryotic exosome and the mechanism by which it degrades RNA from 3′ to 5′ (Malet et al, 2010).The crystal structures of overlapping parts of the eukaryotic exosome (Liu et al, 2006; Bonneau et al, 2009) and the related bacterial PNPase (Symmons et al, 2000) and archaeal exosome (Lorentzen et al, 2007) have been solved, and show that these RNA-degrading machines from the three domains of life have a similar structure (Fig 1). They are all composed of a ring of six RNase PH domains, one side of which has a cap that contains putative RNA-binding domains. Although this overall structure is conserved, the way that it is formed is not. Bacterial PNPase is a homotrimer of which each monomer contains two RNase PH domains, an S1 domain and a KH domain. The archaeal PH ring consists of three copies of two proteins and the cap is made of three copies of either one of two proteins. Finally, the eukaryotic exosome core is composed of nine proteins: six with one RNase PH domain each and three cap proteins.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Exosome structures. The bacterial PNPase (left), the archaeal exosome (middle) and eukaryotic core exosome (right) have a common overall structure. The top panels are schematic views from above, showing the cap proteins. The bottom panels show a view from the side, with one-third of the exosome cut away to reveal the RNA in the central channel.In PNPase and the archaeal exosome, substrates enter the PH ring from the cap-side. The putative RNA-binding domains of the cap are therefore probably important for controlling entry to the PH ring. In both archaea and bacteria, the active sites are on the inner side of the PH ring and thus the ribonucleic catalysis occurs inside the central channel. However, in humans and yeast each of the RNase PH domains have point mutations that make the exosome ring catalytically inactive (Dziembowski et al, 2007). Instead, catalysis is carried out by a tenth subunit—Rrp44/Dis3—which binds to the PH ring on the opposite side to the cap proteins (Bonneau et al, 2009; Wang et al, 2007). This organization made it unclear whether RNA also enters the central channel of the exosome in eukaryotes (Fig 1), or whether substrate RNAs directly access the catalytic subunit.Malet and colleagues now provide structural information that resolves this by reconstituting the ten-subunit yeast exosome and analysing its structure with electron microscopy, in the presence and absence of RNA. This analysis suggests that the RNase PH ring of the exosome is stable, but that the cap and catalytic subunits are more flexible than previously appreciated. It is the first structural evidence that in eukaryotes RNA is threaded through the central channel before being degraded by Rrp44.     

Evidence for core exosome independent function of the nuclear exoribonuclease Rrp6p

The RNA exosome processes and degrades RNAs in archaeal and eukaryotic cells. Exosomes from yeast and humans contain two active exoribonuclease components, Rrp6p and Dis3p/Rrp44p. Rrp6p is concentrated in the nucleus and the dependence of its function on the nine-subunit core exosome and Dis3p remains unclear. We found that cells lacking Rrp6p accumulate poly(A)+ rRNA degradation intermediates distinct from those found in cells depleted of Dis3p, or the core exosome component Rrp43p. Depletion of Dis3p in the absence of Rrp6p causes a synergistic increase in the levels of degradation substrates common to the core exosome and Rrp6p, but has no effect on Rrp6p-specific substrates. Rrp6p lacking a portion of its C-terminal domain no longer co-purifies with the core exosome, but continues to carry out RNA 3′-end processing of 5.8S rRNA and snoRNAs, as well as the degradation of certain truncated Rrp6-specific rRNA intermediates. However, disruption of Rrp6p–core exosome interaction results in the inability of the cell to efficiently degrade certain poly(A)+ rRNA processing products that require the combined activities of Dis3p and Rrp6p. These findings indicate that Rrp6p may carry out some of its critical functions without physical association with the core exosome.     

The evolutionarily conserved subunits Rrp4 and Csl4 confer different substrate specificities to the archaeal exosome

We studied the substrate specificity of the exosome of Sulfolobus solfataricus using the catalytically active Rrp41-Rrp42-hexamer and complexes containing the RNA-binding subunits Rrp4 or Csl4. The conservation of both Rrp4 and Csl4 in archaeal and eukaryotic exosomes suggests specific functions for each of them. We found that they confer different specificities to the exosome: RNA with an A-poor 3′-end is degraded with higher efficiency by the Csl4-exosome, while the Rrp4-exosome strongly prefers poly(A)-RNA. High C-content and polyuridylation negatively influence RNA processing by all complexes, and, in contrast to the hexamer, the Rrp4-exosome prefers longer substrates.     

Arabidopsis thaliana exosome subunit AtRrp4p is a hydrolytic 3′→5′ exonuclease containing S1 and KH RNA-binding domains

The exosome, an evolutionarily conserved complex of multiple 3′→5′ exoribonucleases, is responsible for a variety of RNA processing and degradation events in eukaryotes. In this report Arabidopsis thaliana AtRrp4p is shown to be an active 3′→5′ exonuclease that requires a free 3′-hydroxyl and degrades RNA hydrolytically and distributively, releasing nucleoside 5′-monophosphate products. AtRrp4p behaves as an ~500 kDa species during sedimentation through a 10–30% glycerol gradient, co-migrating with AtRrp41p, another exosome subunit, and it interacts in vitro with AtRrp41p, suggesting that it is also present in the plant cell as a subunit of the exosome. We found that, in addition to a previously reported S1-type RNA-binding domain, members of the Rrp4p family of proteins contain a KH-type RNA-binding domain in the C-terminal half and show that either domain alone can bind RNA. However, only the full-length protein is capable of degrading RNA and interacting with AtRrp41p.     

The exosome‐binding factors Rrp6 and Rrp47 form a composite surface for recruiting the Mtr4 helicase

The exosome is a conserved multi‐subunit ribonuclease complex that functions in 3′ end processing, turnover and surveillance of nuclear and cytoplasmic RNAs. In the yeast nucleus, the 10‐subunit core complex of the exosome (Exo‐10) physically and functionally interacts with the Rrp6 exoribonuclease and its associated cofactor Rrp47, the helicase Mtr4 and Mpp6. Here, we show that binding of Mtr4 to Exo‐10 in vitro is dependent upon both Rrp6 and Rrp47, whereas Mpp6 binds directly and independently of other cofactors. Crystallographic analyses reveal that the N‐terminal domains of Rrp6 and Rrp47 form a highly intertwined structural unit. Rrp6 and Rrp47 synergize to create a composite and conserved surface groove that binds the N‐terminus of Mtr4. Mutation of conserved residues within Rrp6 and Mtr4 at the structural interface disrupts their interaction and inhibits growth of strains expressing a C‐terminal GFP fusion of Mtr4. These studies provide detailed structural insight into the interaction between the Rrp6–Rrp47 complex and Mtr4, revealing an important link between Mtr4 and the core exosome.     

Surveillance of nuclear-restricted pre-ribosomes within a subnucleolar region of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We previously hypothesized that HEAT-repeat (Huntington, elongation A subunit, TOR) ribosome synthesis factors function in ribosome export. We report that the HEAT-repeat protein Sda1p is a component of late 60S pre-ribosomes and is required for nuclear export of both ribosomal subunits. In strains carrying the ts-lethal sda1-2 mutation, pre-60S particles were rapidly degraded following transfer to 37 degrees C. Polyadenylated forms of the 27S pre-rRNA and the 25S rRNA were detected, suggesting the involvement of the Trf4p/Air/Mtr4p polyadenylation complex (TRAMP). The absence of Trf4p suppressed polyadenylation and stabilized the pre-rRNA and rRNA. The absence of the nuclear exosome component Rrp6p also conferred RNA stabilization, with some hyperadenylation. We conclude that the nuclear-restricted pre-ribosomes are polyadenylated by TRAMP and degraded by the exosome. In sda1-2 strains at 37 degrees C, pre-40S and pre-60S ribosomes initially accumulated in the nucleoplasm, but then strongly concentrated in a subnucleolar focus, together with exosome and TRAMP components. Localization of pre-ribosomes to this focus was lost in sda1-2 strains lacking Trf4p or Rrp6p. We designate this nucleolar focus the No-body and propose that it represents a site of pre-ribosome surveillance.     

The CR3 motif of Rrp44p is important for interaction with the core exosome and exosome function

The 10-subunit RNA exosome is involved in a large number of diverse RNA processing and degradation events in eukaryotes. These reactions are carried out by the single catalytic subunit, Rrp44p/Dis3p, which is composed of three parts that are conserved throughout eukaryotes. The exosome is named for the 3′ to 5′ exoribonuclease activity provided by a large C-terminal region of the Rrp44p subunit that resembles other exoribonucleases. Rrp44p also contains an endoribonuclease domain. Finally, the very N-terminus of Rrp44p contains three Cys residues (CR3 motif) that are conserved in many eukaryotes but have no known function. These three conserved Cys residues cluster with a previously unrecognized conserved His residue in what resembles a metal-ion-binding site. Genetic and biochemical data show that this CR3 motif affects both endo- and exonuclease activity in vivo and both the nuclear and cytoplasmic exosome, as well as the ability of Rrp44p to associate with the other exosome subunits. These data provide the first direct evidence that the exosome-Rrp44p interaction is functionally important and also provides a molecular explanation for the functional defects when the conserved Cys residues are mutated.     

Dis3‐like 1: a novel exoribonuclease associated with the human exosome

The exosome is an exoribonuclease complex involved in the degradation and maturation of a wide variety of RNAs. The nine‐subunit core of the eukaryotic exosome is catalytically inactive and may have an architectural function and mediate substrate binding. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the associated Dis3 and Rrp6 provide the exoribonucleolytic activity. The human exosome‐associated Rrp6 counterpart contributes to its activity, whereas the human Dis3 protein is not detectably associated with the exosome. Here, a proteomic analysis of immunoaffinity‐purified human exosome complexes identified a novel exosome‐associated exoribonuclease, human Dis3‐like exonuclease 1 (hDis3L1), which was confirmed to associate with the exosome core by co‐immunoprecipitation. In contrast to the nuclear localization of Dis3, hDis3L1 exclusively localized to the cytoplasm. The hDis3L1 isolated from transfected cells degraded RNA in an exoribonucleolytic manner, and its RNB domain seemed to mediate this activity. The siRNA‐mediated knockdown of hDis3L1 in HeLa cells resulted in elevated levels of poly(A)‐tailed 28S rRNA degradation intermediates, indicating the involvement of hDis3L1 in cytoplasmic RNA decay. Taken together, these data indicate that hDis3L1 is a novel exosome‐associated exoribonuclease in the cytoplasm of human cells.