Chromosome scaffold and structural integrity of mitotic chromosomes

Chromosome scaffold represents a continuous protein substructure revealed in isolated metaphase chromosomes after harsh extraction. According to postulates of the widespread radial loop model the scaffold plays an important role in the formation and maintenance of structural integrity of the mitotic chromosomes. Here, the data concerning the structure and major components of the chromosome scaffold are presented. The experiments suggesting that the scaffold represents a system of discrete linker proteins and the data about high mobility of scaffolding proteins are discussed. Furthermore, the data about higher-level chromatin structures (elementary chromonema and 200–250 nm fibers) and behavior of scaffolding proteins are compared. The results presented agree with the idea that at the present stage it is possible to discriminate chromatin complexes, whose structural integrity is not maintained by the chromosome scaffold.     

A search for protein cores in chromosomes: Is the scaffold an artifact?

A protein chromosome scaffold structure has been proposed that acts as a structural framework for attachment of chromosomal DNA. There are several troubling aspects of this concept: (1) such structures have not been seen in many previous thin-section and whole-mount electron microscopy studies of metaphase chromosomes, while they are readily seen in leptotene and zygotene chromosomes; (2) such a structure poses problems for sister chromatid exchanges; and (3) the published photographs show a marked variation in the amount of scaffold in different whole-mount preparations. An alternative explanation is that the scaffold in whole-mount preparations represents incomplete dispersion of the high concentration of chromatin in the center of chromosomes, and when the histones are removed and the DNA dispersed, the remaining nonhistone proteins (NHPs) aggregate to form a chromosome-shaped structure. Two studies were done to determine if the scaffold is real or an artifact: (1) Chinese hamster mitotic cells and isolated chromosomes were examined using two protein stains -EDTA-regressive staining and phosphotungstic acid (PTA) stain. The EDTA-regressive stain showed ribonucleoprotein particles at the periphery of the chromosomes but nothing at the center of the chromosomes. The PTA stain showed the kinetochore plates but no central structures; and (2) isolated chromosomes were partially dispersed to decrease the high concentration of chromatin in the center of the chromosome, then treated with 4 M ammonium acetate or 2 M NaCl to dehistonize them and disperse the DNA. Under these circumstances, no chromosome scaffold was seen. We conclude that the scaffold structure is an artifact resulting from incomplete dispersion of central chromatin and aggregation of NHPs in dehistonized chromosomes.     

The integrity of the histone-DNA complex in chromatin fibres is not necessary for the maintenance of the shape of mitotic chromosomes

In this study we addressed the question of whether scaffold structures produced from purified mitotic chromosomes are an artefact of dehistonization, and whether the integrity of the chromatin fibres is necessary for the maintenance of the well-known shape of mitotic chromosomes. Purified mitotic chromosomes from Friend erythroleukemia cells were treated either with increasing NaCl concentrations up to 500 mM, or with 6 M urea in the presence or absence of 10 mM 2-mercaptoethanol. The main criterion for the intactness of the overall chromosome shape as seen by electron microscopy was the characteristic X-or U-like appearance with clearly discernable chromatid axes. Histone H1 is known to be essential for the integrity of chromatin fibres. Its removal in sucrose gradients containing 500 mM NaCl did not lead to loss of the overall chromosome shape. However, treatment of chromosomes in sucrose gradients containing 10 mM 2-mercaptoethanol and 6 M urea led to loss of the structure probably due to dissociation (or denaturation) of shape-determining (scaffolding) components. Under these conditions most of the histones remained bound to the chromosomes, and the fibres in this chromatin material, after removal of excess urea and 2-mercaptoethanol, still showed condensation of the nucleosome filaments into the characteristic fibre structures upon increasing ionic strength. Our observations are compatible with the model that specific non-histone components, independently of histone-DNA interactions, organize or stabilize the structure of metaphase chromosomes.     

Metaphase chromosome structure. Involvement of topoisomerase II

SCI is a prominent, 170,000 Mr, non-histone protein of HeLa metaphase chromosomes. This protein binds DNA and was previously identified as one of the major structural components of the residual scaffold structure obtained by differential protein extraction from isolated chromosomes. The metaphase scaffold maintains chromosomal DNA in an organized, looped conformation. We have prepared a polyclonal antibody against the SC1 protein. Immunolocalization studies by both fluorescence and electron microscopy allowed identification of the scaffold structure in gently expanded chromosomes. The micrographs show an immunopositive reaction going through the kinetochore along a central, axial region that extends the length of each chromatid. Some micrographs of histone-depleted chromosomes provide evidence of the substructural organization of the scaffold; the scaffold appears to consist of an assembly of foci, which in places form a zig-zag or coiled arrangement. We present several lines of evidence that establish the identity of SC1 as topoisomerase II. Considering the enzymic nature of this protein, it is remarkable that it represents 1% to 2% of the total mitotic chromosomal protein. About 60% to 80% of topoisomerase II partitions into the scaffold structure as prepared from isolated chromosomes, and we find approximately three copies per average 70,000-base loop. This supports the proposed structural role of the scaffold in the organization of the mitotic chromosome. The dual enzymic and apparent structural function of topoisomerase II (SC1) and its location at or near the base of chromatin loops allows speculation as to its involvement in the long-range control of chromatin structure.     

Could condensin scaffold the mitotic chromosome?

One of the most remarkable and yet poorly understood events during the cell cycle is how dispersed chromatin fragments are transformed into chromosomes every time cells undergo mitosis. It has been postulated that mitotic chromosomes might contain an axial scaffold that is involved in condensation but its molecules and structure have remained elusive. Recent data suggests that the condensin complex might indeed be an essential part of the scaffold that provides a platform for other proteins to localize and promote different aspects of chromosome condensation.     

Could Condensin Scaffold the Mitotic Chromosome?

One of the most remarkable and yet poorly understood events during the cell cycle is how dispersed chromatin fragments are transformed into chromosomes every time cells undergo mitosis. It has been postulated that mitotic chromosomes might contain an axial scaffold that is involved in condensation but its molecules and structure have remained elusive. Recent data suggests that the condensin complex might indeed be an essential part of the scaffold that provides a platform for other proteins to localize and promote different aspects of chromosome condensation.     

Architecture of metaphase chromosomes and chromosome scaffolds

We have developed procedures for depositing intact mitotic chromosomes and isolated residual scaffolds on electron microscope grids at controlled and reproducible levels of compaction. The chromosomes were isolated using a recently developed aqueous method. Our study has addressed two different aspects of chromosome structure. First, we present a method for improved visualization of radial chromatin loops in undisrupted mitotic chromosomes. Second, we have visualized a nonhistone protein residual scaffold isolated from nuclease-digested chromosomes under conditions of low salt protein extraction. These scaffolds, which have an extremely simple protein composition, are the size of chromosomes, are fibrous in nature, and are found to retain differentiated regions that appear to derive from the kinetochores and the chromatid axis. When our standard preparation conditions were used, the scaffold appearance was found to be very reproducible. If the ionic conditions were varied, however, the scaffold appearance underwent dramatic changes. In the presence of millimolar concentrations of Mg++ or high concentrations of NaCl, the fibrous scaffold protein network was observed to undergo a lateral aggregation or assembly into a coarse meshlike structure. The alteration of scaffold structure was apparently reversible. This observation is consistent with a model in which the scaffolding network plays a dynamic role in chromosome condensation at mitosis.     

Proteome analysis of human metaphase chromosomes

DNA is packaged as chromatin in the interphase nucleus. During mitosis, chromatin fibers are highly condensed to form metaphase chromosomes, which ensure equal segregation of replicated chromosomal DNA into the daughter cells. Despite >1 century of research on metaphase chromosomes, information regarding the higher order structure of metaphase chromosomes is limited, and it is still not clear which proteins are involved in further folding of the chromatin fiber into metaphase chromosomes. To obtain a global view of the chromosomal proteins, we performed proteome analyses on three types of isolated human metaphase chromosomes. We first show the results from comparative proteome analyses of two types of isolated human metaphase chromosomes that have been frequently used in biochemical and morphological analyses. 209 proteins were quantitatively identified and classified into six groups on the basis of their known interphase localization. Furthermore, a list of 107 proteins was obtained from the proteome analyses of highly purified metaphase chromosomes, the majority of which are essential for chromosome structure and function. Based on the information obtained on these proteins and on their localizations during mitosis as assessed by immunostaining, we present a four-layer model of metaphase chromosomes. According to this model, the chromosomal proteins have been newly classified into each of four groups: chromosome coating proteins, chromosome peripheral proteins, chromosome structural proteins, and chromosome fibrous proteins. This analysis represents the first compositional view of human metaphase chromosomes and provides a protein framework for future research on this topic.     

Condensin is required for nonhistone protein assembly and structural integrity of vertebrate mitotic chromosomes

The dramatic condensation of chromosomes that occurs during mitosis is widely thought to be largely controlled by a protein complex termed condensin. Here, we describe a conditional knockout of the condensin subunit ScII/SMC2 in chicken DT40 cells. In cells lacking this condensin subunit, chromosome condensation is delayed, but ultimately reaches near-normal levels. However, these chromosomes are structurally compromised. Kinetochores appear normal, but the localization of nonhistone proteins such as topoisomerase II and INCENP is aberrant. Both proteins also fail to partition into the chromosome scaffold fraction, which appears to be largely missing in the absence of condensin. Furthermore, the chromosomes lack structural integrity, as defined by an assay that tests the stability of the chromosomal higher-order structure. Thus, a major function of condensin is to promote the correct association of nonhistone proteins with mitotic chromosomes, and this is essential for establishment of a robust chromosome structure.     

Packaging the genome: the structure of mitotic chromosomes

Mitotic chromosomes are essential structures for the faithful transmission of duplicated genomic DNA into two daughter cells during cell division. Although more than 100 years have passed since chromosomes were first observed, it remains unclear how a long string of genomic DNA is packaged into compact mitotic chromosomes. Although the classical view is that human chromosomes consist of radial 30 nm chromatin loops that are somehow tethered centrally by scaffold proteins, called condensins, cryo-electron microscopy observation of frozen hydrated native chromosomes reveals a homogeneous, grainy texture and neither higher-order nor periodic structures including 30 nm chromatin fibres were observed. As a compromise to fill this huge gap, we propose a model in which the radial chromatin loop structures in the classic view are folded irregularly toward the chromosome centre with the increase in intracellular cations during mitosis. Consequently, compact native chromosomes are made up primarily of irregular chromatin networks cross-linked by self-assembled condensins forming the chromosome scaffold.     

The metaphase scaffold is helically folded: sister chromatids have predominantly opposite helical handedness

We have studied the three-dimensional folding of the scaffolding in histone H1-depleted chromosomes by immunofluorescence with an antibody specific for topoisomerase II. Two different types of decondensed chromosomes are observed. The majority of the chromosomes are expanded, and the central fluorescence signal is surrounded by a large halo of chromatin. A much smaller number of chromosomes are more compact in length; they contain a smaller halo of chromatin and their scaffolds are not extended but folded into a genuine, quite regular helical coil. This conclusion is based on a three-dimensional structural analysis by optical sectioning. The number of helical coils is related to chromosome length. Surprisingly, sister chromatids have predominantly opposite helical handedness; that is, they are related by mirror symmetry.     

Visualization of early chromosome condensation: a hierarchical folding, axial glue model of chromosome structure

Current models of mitotic chromosome structure are based largely on the examination of maximally condensed metaphase chromosomes. Here, we test these models by correlating the distribution of two scaffold components with the appearance of prophase chromosome folding intermediates. We confirm an axial distribution of topoisomerase IIalpha and the condensin subunit, structural maintenance of chromosomes 2 (SMC2), in unextracted metaphase chromosomes, with SMC2 localizing to a 150-200-nm-diameter central core. In contrast to predictions of radial loop/scaffold models, this axial distribution does not appear until late prophase, after formation of uniformly condensed middle prophase chromosomes. Instead, SMC2 associates throughout early and middle prophase chromatids, frequently forming foci over the chromosome exterior. Early prophase condensation occurs through folding of large-scale chromatin fibers into condensed masses. These resolve into linear, 200-300-nm-diameter middle prophase chromatids that double in diameter by late prophase. We propose a unified model of chromosome structure in which hierarchical levels of chromatin folding are stabilized late in mitosis by an axial "glue."     

The structure of histone-depleted metaphase chromosomes

We have previously shown that histone-depleted metaphase chromosomes can be isolated by treating purified HeLa chromosomes with dextran sulfate and heparin (Adolph, Cheng and Laemmli, 1977a). The chromosomes form fast-sedimenting complexes which are held together by a few nonhistone proteins.In this paper, we have studied the histone-depleted chromosomes in the electron microscope. Our results show that: the histone-depleted chromosomes consist of a scaffold or core, which has the shape characteristic of a metaphase chromosome, surrounded by a halo of DNA; the halo consists of many loops of DNA, each anchored in the scaffold at its base; most of the DNA exists in loops at least 10–30 μm long (30–90 kilobases).We also show that the same results can be obtained when the histones are removed from the chromosomes with 2 M NaCl instead of dextran sulfate. Moreover, the histone-depleted chromosomes are extraordinarily stable in 2 M NaCI, providing further evidence that they are held together by nonhistone proteins.These results suggest a scaffolding model for metaphase chromosome structure in which a backbone of nonhistone proteins is responsible for the basic shape of metaphase chromosomes, and the scaffold organizes the DNA into loops along its length.     

Differential distribution and association of repeat DNA sequences in the lateral element of the synaptonemal complex in rat spermatocytes

The synaptonemal complex (SC) is an evolutionarily conserved structure that mediates synapsis of homologous chromosomes during meiotic prophase I. Previous studies have established that the chromatin of homologous chromosomes is organized in loops that are attached to the lateral elements (LEs) of the SC. The characterization of the genomic sequences associated with LEs of the SC represents an important step toward understanding meiotic chromosome organization and function. To isolate these genomic sequences, we performed chromatin immunoprecipitation assays in rat spermatocytes using an antibody against SYCP3, a major structural component of the LEs of the SC. Our results demonstrated the reproducible and exclusive isolation of repeat deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) sequences, in particular long interspersed elements, short interspersed elements, long terminal direct repeats, satellite, and simple repeats. The association of these repeat sequences to the LEs of the SC was confirmed by in situ hybridization of meiotic nuclei shown by both light and electron microscopy. Signals were also detected over the chromatin surrounding SCs and in small loops protruding from the lateral elements into the SC central region. We propose that genomic repeat DNA sequences play a key role in anchoring the chromosome to the protein scaffold of the SC. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

The condensin I subunit Barren/CAP-H is essential for the structural integrity of centromeric heterochromatin during mitosis

During cell division, chromatin undergoes structural changes essential to ensure faithful segregation of the genome. Condensins, abundant components of mitotic chromosomes, are known to form two different complexes, condensins I and II. To further examine the role of condensin I in chromosome structure and in particular in centromere organization, we depleted from S2 cells the Drosophila CAP-H homologue Barren, a subunit exclusively associated with condensin I. In the absence of Barren/CAP-H the condensin core subunits DmSMC4/2 still associate with chromatin, while the other condensin I non-structural maintenance of chromosomes family proteins do not. Immunofluorescence and in vivo analysis of Barren/CAP-H-depleted cells showed that mitotic chromosomes are able to condense but fail to resolve sister chromatids. Additionally, Barren/CAP-H-depleted cells show chromosome congression defects that do not appear to be due to abnormal kinetochore-microtubule interaction. Instead, the centromeric and pericentromeric heterochromatin of Barren/CAP-H-depleted chromosomes shows structural problems. After bipolar attachment, the centromeric heterochromatin organized in the absence of Barren/CAP-H cannot withstand the forces exerted by the mitotic spindle and undergoes irreversible distortion. Taken together, our data suggest that the condensin I complex is required not only to promote sister chromatid resolution but also to maintain the structural integrity of centromeric heterochromatin during mitosis.     

A two-step scaffolding model for mitotic chromosome assembly

Topoisomerase IIalpha (topoIIalpha) and 13S condensin are both required for mitotic chromosome assembly. Here we show that they constitute the two main components of the chromosomal scaffold on histone-depleted chromosomes. The structural stability and chromosomal shape of the scaffolding toward harsh extraction procedures are shown to be mediated by ATP or its nonhydrolyzable analogs, but not ADP. TopoIIalpha and 13S condensin components immunolocalize to a radially restricted, longitudinal scaffolding in native-like chromosomes. Double staining for topoIIalpha and condensin generates a barber pole appearance of the scaffolding, where topoIIalpha- and condensin-enriched "beads" alternate; this structure appears to be generated by two juxtaposed, or coiled, chains. Cell cycle studies establish that 13S condensin appears not to be involved in the assembly of prophase chromatids; they lack this complex but contain a topoIIalpha-defined (-mediated?) scaffolding. Condensin associates only during the pro- to metaphase transition. This two-step assembly process is proposed to generate the barber pole appearance of the native-like scaffolding.     

Plant chromatin -- epigenetics linked to ATP-dependent remodeling and architectural proteins

Studies in organisms belonging to different eukaryotic kingdoms have revealed that the structural state of chromatin is controlled by interactions of DNA, small RNAs and specific proteins, linked to a self-reinforcing complex network of biochemical activities involving histone and DNA modifications and ATP-dependent nucleosome remodeling. However, these findings must now be reinterpreted in light of the recent discovery of the highly dynamic character of interphase chromosomes exemplified by the constant flux of enzymatic and structural proteins through both eu- and heterochromatin and by short- and long-range chromosome movements in the nucleus. The available data on chromosome organization in Arabidopsis thaliana and links between proteins influencing chromatin structure and DNA and histone modifications documented in this model plant provide strong supportive evidence for the dynamic nature of chromosomes.     

Distinct roles of the Drosophila ninaC kinase and myosin domains revealed by systematic mutagenesis

We have investigated the role of topoisomerase II (topo II) in mitotic chromosome assembly and organization in vitro using Xenopus egg extracts. When sperm chromatin was incubated with mitotic extracts, the highly compact chromatin rapidly swelled and concomitantly underwent local condensation. Further incubation induced the formation of entangled thin chromatin fibers that eventually resolved into highly condensed individual chromosomes. This in vitro system made it possible to manipulate mitotic chromosomes in their assembly condition without any isolation or stabilization steps. Two complementary approaches, immunodepletion and antibody blocking, demonstrated that topo II activity is required for chromosome assembly and condensation. Once condensation was completed, however, blocking of topo II activity had little effect on the chromosome morphology. Immunofluorescent studies showed that topo II was uniformly distributed throughout the condensed chromosomes and was not restricted to the chromosomal axis. Surprisingly, all detectable topo II molecules were easily extracted from the chromosomes under mild conditions where the shape of chromosomes was well preserved. Our results show that topo II is essential for mitotic chromosome assembly, but does not play a scaffolding role in the structural maintenance of chromosomes assembled in vitro. We also present evidence that changes of DNA topology affect the distribution of topo II in mitotic chromosomes in our system.     

Structural Maintenance of Chromosome (SMC) Proteins Link Microtubule Stability to Genome Integrity

Structural maintenance of chromosome (SMC) proteins are key organizers of chromosome architecture and are essential for genome integrity. They act by binding to chromatin and connecting distinct parts of chromosomes together. Interestingly, their potential role in providing connections between chromatin and the mitotic spindle has not been explored. Here, we show that yeast SMC proteins bind directly to microtubules and can provide a functional link between microtubules and DNA. We mapped the microtubule-binding region of Smc5 and generated a mutant with impaired microtubule binding activity. This mutant is viable in yeast but exhibited a cold-specific conditional lethality associated with mitotic arrest, aberrant spindle structures, and chromosome segregation defects. In an in vitro reconstitution assay, this Smc5 mutant also showed a compromised ability to protect microtubules from cold-induced depolymerization. Collectively, these findings demonstrate that SMC proteins can bind to and stabilize microtubules and that SMC-microtubule interactions are essential to establish a robust system to maintain genome integrity.     

Micromechanics of chromatin and chromosomes.

The enzymes that transcribe, recombine, package, and duplicate the eukaryotic genome all are highly processive and capable of generating large forces. Understanding chromosome function therefore will require analysis of mechanics as well as biochemistry. Here we review development of new biophysical-biochemical techniques for studying the mechanical properties of isolated chromatin fibers and chromosomes. We also discuss microscopy-based experiments on cells that visualize chromosome structure and dynamics. Experiments on chromatin tell us about its flexibility and fluctuation, as well as quantifying the forces generated during chromatin assembly. Experiments on whole chromosomes provide insight into the higher-order organization of chromatin; for example, recent experiments have shown that the mitotic chromosome is held together by isolated chromatin-chromatin links and not a large, mechanically contiguous non-DNA "scaffold".