Deep supercooling enabled by surface impregnation with lipophilic substances explains the survival of overwintering buds at extreme freezing

The frost survival mechanism of vegetative buds of angiosperms was suggested to be extracellular freezing causing dehydration, elevated osmotic potential to prevent freezing. However, extreme dehydration would be needed to avoid freezing at the temperatures down to ?45°C encountered by many trees. Buds of Alnus alnobetula, in common with other frost hardy angiosperms, excrete a lipophilic substance, whose functional role remains unclear. Freezing of buds was studied by infrared thermography, psychrometry, and cryomicroscopy. Buds of A. alnobetula did not survive by extracellular ice tolerance but by deep supercooling, down to ?45°C. An internal ice barrier prevented ice penetration from the frozen stem into the bud. Cryomicroscopy revealed a new freezing mechanism. Until now, supercooled buds lost water towards ice masses that form in the subtending stem and/or bud scales. In A. alnobetula, ice forms harmlessly inside the bud between the supercooled leaves. This would immediately trigger intracellular freezing and kill the supercooled bud in other species. In A. alnobetula, lipophilic substances (triterpenoids and flavonoid aglycones) impregnate the surface of bud leaves. These prevent extrinsic ice nucleation so allowing supercooling. This suggests a means to protect forestry and agricultural crops from extrinsic ice nucleation allowing transient supercooling during night frosts.     

Ice crystallization by Pseudomonas syringae

Several bacterial species can serve as biological ice nuclei. The best characterized of these is Pseudomonas syringae, a widely distributed bacterial epiphyte of plants. These biological ice nuclei find various applications in different fields, but an optimized production method was required in order to obtain the highly active cells which may be exploited as ice nucleators. The results presented here show that P. syringae cells reduce supercooling of liquid or solid media and enhance ice crystal formation at sub-zero temperatures, thus leading to a remarkable control of the crystallization phenomenon and a potential for energy savings. Our discussion focuses on recent and future applications of these ice nucleators in freezing operations, spray-ice technology and biotechnological processes. Received: 21 December 1999 / Received revision: 29 February 2000 / Accepted: 6 March 2000     

Diel Variation in Population Size and Ice Nucleation Activity of Pseudomonas syringae on Snap Bean Leaflets

The extent to which diel changes in the physical environment affect changes in population size and ice nucleation activity of Pseudomonas syringae on snap bean leaflets was determined under field conditions. To estimate bacterial population size and ice nucleation activity, bean leaflets were harvested at 2-h intervals during each of three 26-h periods. A tube nucleation test was used to assay individual leaflets for ice nuclei. Population sizes of P. syringae were determined by dilution plating of leaflet homogenates. The overall diel changes in P. syringae population sizes differed during each of the 26-h periods. In one 26-h period, there was a continuous increase in the logarithm of P. syringae population size despite intense solar radiation, absence of free moisture on leaf surfaces, and low relative humidity during the day. A mean doubling time of approximately 4.9 h was estimated for the 28-fold increase in P. syringae population size that occurred from 0900 to 0900 h during the 26-h period. However, doubling times of 3.3 and 1.9 h occurred briefly during this period from 1700 to 2300 h and from 0100 to 0700 h, respectively. Thus, growth rates of P. syringae in association with leaves in the field were of the same order of magnitude as optimal rates measured in the laboratory. The frequency with which leaflets bore ice nuclei active at −2.0, −2.2, and −2.5°C varied greatly within each 26-h period. These large diel changes were inversely correlated primarily with the diel changes in air temperature and reflected changes in nucleation frequency rather than changes in population size of P. syringae. Thus, the response of bacterial ice nucleation activity to the physical environment was distinct from the changes in population size of ice nucleation-active P. syringae.     

Supercooling characteristics of isolated peach flower bud primordia

The amount of unfrozen water in dormant peach (Prunus persica [L.] Batsch, cv Redhaven) flower buds, isolated primordia, and bud axes was determined during freezing using pulse nuclear magnetic resonance methods. Differential thermal analysis studies were conducted on whole buds and isolated primordia in the presence of ice nucleation. The results showed that some of the water in isolated primordia remained supercooled in the presence of ice nucleation. Although most tissue water froze (57.5%) following ice nucleation at −2.5°C, a considerable amount of water was found to supercool. In the presence of ice nucleation, increased hydration of isolated primordia resulted in the elimination of the supercooling characteristic. The structural integrity of isolated primordia appeared to be essential for supercooling.     

Effect of Plant Species and Environmental Conditions on Ice Nucleation Activity of Pseudomonas syringae on Leaves

Selected plant species and environmental conditions were investigated for their influences on expression of ice nucleation activity by 15 Pseudomonas syringae strains grown on plants in constant-temperature growth chamber studies. Ice nucleation frequencies (INFs), the fraction of cells that expressed ice nucleation at −5 or −9°C, of individual strains varied greatly, both on plants and in culture. This suggests that the probability of frost injury, which is proportional to the number of ice nuclei on leaf surfaces, is strongly determined by the particular bacterial strains that are present on a leaf surface. The INFs of strains were generally higher when they were grown on plants than when they were grown in culture. In addition, INFs in culture did not correlate closely with INFs on plants, suggesting that frost injury prediction should be based on INF measurements of cells grown on plants rather than in culture. The relative INFs of individual strains varied with plant host and environment. However, none of seven plant species tested optimized the INFs of all 15 strains. Similarly, incubation for 48 h at near 100% relative humidity with short photoperiods did not always decrease the INF when compared with a 72 h, 40% relative humidity, long-photoperiod incubation. Pathogenic strains on susceptible hosts were not associated with higher or lower INFs relative to their INFs on nonsusceptible plant species. The ice nucleation activity of individual bacterial strains on plants therefore appears to be controlled by complex and interacting factors such as strain genotype, environment, and host plant species.     

Frost Injury as a Possible Inciting Factor in Bud and Shoot Necroses of Fraxinus excelsior L.

Large numbers of European ash have died in Poland in all age classes during the last ten years. The characteristic symptom occurring on shoots of planted and self‐sown seedlings was bark necroses starting from the shoot apex, necrotic buds, or leaf and twig scars. The results showed that in the bud tissue of cold acclimated European ash extracellular and intracellular ice formation occurred at approximately ?9 and ?32°C, respectively. In deacclimated plants in spring water supercooling is limited by the heterogenous ice nucleation temperature and consequently the cold tolerance is ?9 to ?4°C for bud tissues and ?13 to ?9°C for shoots. Isolations of fungi were performed from dead buds and from necroses occurring on the main stem. Alternaria alternata, Fusarium lateritium and Phomopsis scobina were among the fungi occurring in both these organs at frequencies of more than 7%. Cylindrocarpon heteronemum, Diplodia mutila and Tubercularia vulgaris from necroses were only isolated in frequencies; 3.3, 1.2 and 5.4%, respectively. It seems likely that freezing injury is the inciting factor, which combined with fungal colonization manifests itself as fatal damage to European ash buds and shoots.     

Expression of a bacterial ice nucleation gene in plants

We have introduced an ice nucleation gene (inaZ) from Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae into Nicotiana tabacum, a freezing-sensitive species, and Solanum commersonii, a freezing-tolerant species. Transformants of both species showed increased ice nucleation activity over untransformed controls. The concentration of ice nuclei detected at −10.5°C in 15 different primary transformants of S. commersonii varied by over 1000-fold, and the most active transformant contained over 100 ice nuclei/mg of tissue. The temperature of the warmest freezing event in plant samples of small mass was increased from approximately −12°C in the untransformed controls to −4°C in inaZ-expressing transformants. The threshold nucleation temperature of samples from transformed plants did not increase appreciably with the mass of the sample. The most abundant protein detected in transgenic plants using immunological probes specific to the inaZ protein exhibited a higher mobility on sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gels than the inaZ protein from bacterial sources. However, some protein with a similar mobility to the inaZ protein could be detected. Although the warmest ice nucleation temperature detected in transgenic plants is lower than that conferred by this gene in P. syringae (−2°C), our results demonstrate that the ice nucleation gene of P. syringae can be expressed in plant cells to produce functional ice nuclei.     

Identification and expression of the Pseudomonas syringae pv. aptata hrpZPsa gene which encodes an harpin elicitor

A sequence homologous to an internal fragment 0.75 kb BstXI of the Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae hrpZ gene was identified in Pseudomonas syringae pv. aptata NCPPB 2664, the causal agent of bacterial blight in sugar beet, lettuce and other plants, and in E. coli DH10B (pCCP1069) containing the P. syringae pv. aptata hrp gene cluster. PCR with oligonucleotides, based on the hrpZ_Pss gene and used as primers with the total genomic DNA of P. syringae pv. aptata, amplified a 1 kb fragment that hybridized with the probe in highly stringent conditions. The amplicon was cloned into the pGEM-T® plasmid vector, amplified in E. coli DH5 and sequenced. The sequence showed 95%, 83% and 61% identity with those of hrpZ_Pss, hrpZ_Psg and hrpZ_Pst genes encoding the harpins of the P. syringae pv. syringae, glycinea and tomato, respectively. The amplicon was cloned into the pMAL® expression system. The expressed protein, fused with maltose-binding protein, was cleaved with a specific protease factor Xa, and purified using affinity chromatography. On the basis of the amino acid sequence and its ability to induce HR in tobacco leaves, it was identified as a P. syringae pv. aptata harpin.     

An investigation of the frost hardiness of grapevine (Vitis vinifera) during bud break

The aim of this investigation was to assess ice nucleation and frost resistance of two varieties of grapevine (Siegrebbe and Madeleine Angevine) during bud burst under radiative freezing conditions analogous to those during Spring in the UK. During bud burst, grapevines were almost entirely resistant to freezing during frosts of less than -3°C by virtue of their ability to supercool. The risk of frost damage increased significantly as bud development progressed, and once buds had passed growth stage DS3 they became more sensitive to freezing and freezing damage was more extensive. The two varieties did not differ in frost resistance but, because of its earlier developing habit, variety Siegrebbe could be more prone to frost damage in the field. Buds were more prone to damage after freezing once bud burst had commenced and the damage could not be reversed by acclimating plants for periods of 7 to 21 days at 4°C in an 8 h photoperiod. Such acclimation appeared to predispose frozen buds to more extensive damage.     

Epidemiology of Pseudomonas syringae Pathovars Associated with Decline of Plum Trees in the Southwest of Germany

Plum decline was associated with Pseudomonas syringae pathovars syringae and morsprunorum in Baden‐Württemberg. The trunks of affected plum trees (Prunus domestica) were girdled by bacterial cankers resulting in sudden death of infected trees. Copper compounds that were applied extensively during leaf fall and bud burst, were not effective. A minority of P. syringae strains isolated from cankers on plum trees were moderately resistant, while most strains were sensitive to cupric ions. Invasions through blossoms, leaves and wounds during the vegetation period were limited to the infection sites and plum trees coped effectively with both P. syringae pathovars eliminating them eventually. Infections after dormancy including very rare leaf scar infections did not induce cankers on the trunk. However, infections of dormant trees through frost injuries, (pruning) wounds or non‐injurious ingress by freezing and thawing were serious, because they led to cankers girdling the trunk. Control strategies to manage plum decline have to be adapted to the disease cycle. They should concentrate on the dormant period beginning with early frosts in autumn and ending with bud burst.     

Early detection of bean infection by Pseudomonas syringae in asymptomatic leaf areas using chlorophyll fluorescence imaging

Chlorophyll fluorescence imaging has been used to analyse the response elicited in Phaseolus vulgaris after inoculation with Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola 1448A (compatible interaction) and P. syringae pv. tomato DC3000 (incompatible interaction). With the aim of modulating timing of symptom development, different cell densities were used to inoculate bean plants and the population dynamics of both bacterial strains was followed within the leaf tissue. Fluorescence quenching analysis was carried out and images of the different chlorophyll fluorescence parameters were obtained for infected as well as control plants at different timepoints post-infection. Among the different parameters analysed, we observed that non-photochemical quenching maximised the differences between the compatible and the incompatible interaction before the appearance of visual symptom. A decrease in non-photochemical quenching, evident in both infiltrated and non-infiltrated leaf areas, was observed in P. syringae pv. phaseolicola-infected plants as compared with corresponding values from controls and P. syringae pv. tomato-infected plants. No photoinhibitory damage was detected, as the maximum photosystem II quantum yield remained stable during the infection period analysed.     

Pathogenicity and identification of the lilac pathogen, Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae van Hall 1902

Comparative in planta studies with Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae have established optimum conditions for disease expression in lilac in terms of inoculum concentration, host age and post-inoculation conditions (temperature and day-length). Reproducible disease reactions required an inoculum concentration exceeding the ED⁵⁰, 5 × 10⁶ cfu/ml, and a temperature for post-inoculation incubation not exceeding 19°C. A revised host range of P. syringae pv. syringae, proposed on the basis of confirmation of pathogenicity of strains to lilac, comprises 44 species from monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous plants. Nine new hosts Abelmoschus esculentus, Bromus willdenowii, Camellia sinensis, Centrosema pubescens, Citrullus lanatus, Cotoneaster sp., Cucumis melo, Populus×euramericana and Triticum aestivum, are recorded. A comparative laboratory study was made of strains of P. syringae pv. syringae using more than 30 selected biochemical and nutritional tests. The pathovar could be characterised on the basis of 11 of these which may prove to be useful determinative tests.     

Development, distribution, and characteristics of intrinsic, nonbacterial ice nuclei in prunus wood

Ice nuclei active at approximately −2°C and intrinsic to woody tissues of Prunus spp. were shown to have properties distinct from bacterial ice nuclei. Soaking 5-centimeter peach stem sections in water for 4 hours lowered the mean ice nucleation temperature to below −4°C, nearly 2°C lower than stems inoculated with ice nucleation-active Pseudomonas syringae strain B301D. Ice nucleation activity in peach was fully restored by air-drying woody stem sections for a few hours. The ice nuclei in woody tissue were inactivated between 40 and 50°C, but unaffected by treatment with bacterial ice nucleation inhibitors (i.e. NaOCl, tartaric acid, Triton XQS-20), sulfhydryl reagents (i.e. p-hydroxymercuribenzoate and iodine) and Pronase. Ice nuclei could not be dislodged from stems by sonication and were shown to be equally distributed in peach bud and internodal stem tissue on a per unit mass basis; outer and inner stem tissues were also indistinguishable in ice nucleation activity. Development of ice nuclei in immature peach and sweet cherry stems did not occur until midsummer and their formation was essentially complete by late August. Once formed the ice nuclei intrinsic to woody stems were stable and unaffected by seasonal changes in growth. The apparent physiological function of the ice nuclei is discussed in relation to supercooling and mechanisms of cold hardiness in Prunus spp.     

Branch development in Lupinus angustifolius L.#I. Not all branches have the same potential growth rate

Although the basal and uppermost lateral branches of Lupinus angustifolius L. frequently grow and contribute to yield, buds formed in the axils of leaves 6-12 (referred to as middle buds) rarely grow. This may be due to an inherent limitation of these buds, or some form of apical dominance or competition imposed by the plant. The hypothesis that middle buds have the full capacity to grow, but remain suppressed on intact plants was tested. The main stem apex and buds from the axils of leaves 1 and 8 (bud 1 and bud 8) were excised and cultured on sterile agar. The buds were removed from culture and weighed every 2-3 d for 21 d. The growth rate of apices from the main stem was approximately 5.8 mg d^-1, compared to 2.4 mg d^-1 for bud 1 and 0.9 mg d^-1 for bud 8. Buds in the axils of leaves 6-10 on intact plants were painted six times with a synthetic cytokinin, benzylaminopurine, from 40 d after sowing. This promoted rapid elongation and thickening of these buds, visible as early as 5 d after painting began. The rapid growth of these branches was associated with a reduction in the length of the remaining branches on the plant. However, excision of lower branches did not increase the growth of the middle buds. It is concluded that buds 6-12 of Lupinus angustifolius L. have a partial potential to grow. This potential appears to be limited by innate factors in the bud, and may be structural and/or hormonal. The limitation appears to develop very early in the plant, and potential growth is not modified by subsequent nutrition of the plant.     

Factors Influencing the Distribution of Growth Between Stem and Axillary Buds in Decapitated Bean Plants

Phaseolus multiflorus plants at three stages of developmentwere decapitated either immediately below the apical bud orlower down at a point 1 cm above the insertion of the primaryleaves. Growth regulators in lanolin were applied to the cutstem surface. IAA always inhibited axillary bud elongation anddry-matter accumulation, and enhanced internode dry weight butnot elongation. GA₃ applied below the apical bud greatly increasedinternode elongation and dry weight, but simultaneously reducedbud elongation and dry-weight increase. Application of GA₃ 1cm above the buds had no effect on bud elongation in the youngestplants, but enhanced their elongation in the two older groups.IAA always antagonized GA₃-enhancement of internode extensiongrowth, whereas its effects on GA₃-enhanced dry-matter accumulationdepended on the stage of internode development. Bud elongationwas greater in plants treated with GA₃+IAA than in plants treatedonly with IAA, except in the youngest plants decapitated immediatelybelow the apical bud, where GA₃ caused a slight increase inIAA-induced bud inhibition. GA₃ increased inhibition of buddry weight by IAA in the two youngest groups of plants, butslightly reduced it in the oldest plants. No simple compensatorygrowth relationship existed between internode and buds. It wasconcluded that, (1) auxin appears to be the principal growthhormone concerned in correlative inhibition, and (2) availabilityof gibberellin to internode and buds is of importance as a modifyingfactor in auxin-regulated apical dominance by virtue of itslocal effects on growth in the internode and in the buds.     

A Comparative Analysis of the Ice Nucleation Activity of Pseudomonad Cells and Lipopolysaccharides

The paper deals with the study of the ice nucleation activity of the cells, extracellular lipopolysaccharides (ELPSs), lipopolysaccharides (LPSs), and LPS structural components (lipid A, core oligosaccharide, and O-specific polysaccharide) of Pseudomonas fluorescens, P. syringae, P. fragi, and P. pseudoalcaligenes. Aqueous suspensions of intact cells of P. syringae IMV 1951 and IMV 185 began to freeze at –1 and –4°C, respectively. This suggests that these cells possess ice nucleation activity. Aqueous cell suspensions of two other strains, P. fluorescens IMV 1433 and IMV 2125, began to freeze at lower temperatures than did distilled water (–9°C), which suggests that the cells of these strains possess antifreeze activity. The ice nucleation activity of the bacterial strains studied did not show any correlation with their taxonomic status. The ice nucleation activity of ELPSs depended little on their concentration (within a concentration range of 0.2–0.4%). In most cases, the ice nucleation activity of ELPSs, LPSs, and LPS structural components differed from that of the intact cells from which these biopolymers were obtained. This may indicate that the biopolymers under study play a role in ice nucleation but this role is not crucial. The relationship between the structure of LPSs and their effect on ice nucleation is discussed.     

Exogenous N‐acyl‐homoserine lactones enhance the expression of flagella of Pseudomonas syringae and activate defence responses in plants

In order to cope with pathogens, plants have evolved sophisticated mechanisms to sense pathogenic attacks and to induce defence responses. The N‐acyl‐homoserine lactone (AHL)‐mediated quorum sensing in bacteria regulates diverse physiological processes, including those involved in pathogenicity. In this work, we study the interactions between AHL‐producing transgenic tobacco plants and Pseudomonas syringae pv. tabaci 11528 (P. syringae 11528). Both a reduced incidence of disease and decrease in the growth of P. syringae 11528 were observed in AHL‐producing plants compared with wild‐type plants. The present data indicate that plant‐produced AHLs enhance disease resistance against this pathogen. Subsequent RNA‐sequencing analysis showed that the exogenous addition of AHLs up‐regulated the expression of P. syringae 11528 genes for flagella production. Expression levels of plant defence genes in AHL‐producing and wild‐type plants were determined by quantitative real‐time polymerase chain reaction. These data showed that plant‐produced AHLs activated a wide spectrum of defence responses in plants following inoculation, including the oxidative burst, hypersensitive response, cell wall strengthening, and the production of certain metabolites. These results demonstrate that exogenous AHLs alter the gene expression patterns of pathogens, and plant‐produced AHLs either directly or indirectly enhance plant local immunity during the early stage of plant infection.     

Anti-ice nucleation activity in xylem extracts from trees that contain deep supercooling xylem parenchyma cells

Boreal hardwood species, including Japanese white birch (Betula platyphylla Sukat. var. japonica Hara), Japanese chestnut (Castanea crenata Sieb. et Zucc.), katsura tree (Cercidiphyllum japonicum Sieb. et Zucc.), Siebold’s beech (Fagus crenata Blume), mulberry (Morus bombycis Koidz.), and Japanese rowan (Sorbus commixta Hedl.), had xylem parenchyma cells (XPCs) that adapt to subfreezing temperatures by deep supercooling. Crude extracts from xylem in all these trees were found to have anti-ice nucleation activity that promoted supercooling capability of water as measured by a droplet freezing assay. The magnitude of increase in supercooling capability of water droplets in the presence of ice-nucleation bacteria, Erwinia ananas, was higher in the ranges from 0.1 to 1.7 °C on addition of crude xylem extracts than freezing temperature of water droplets on addition of glucose in the same concentration (100 mosmol/kg). Crude xylem extracts from C. japonicum provided the highest supercooling capability of water droplets. Our additional examination showed that crude xylem extracts from C. japonicum exhibited anti-ice nucleation activity toward water droplets containing a variety of heterogeneous ice nucleators, including ice-nucleation bacteria, not only E. ananas but also Pseudomonas syringae (NBRC3310) or Xanthomonas campestris, silver iodide or airborne impurities. However, crude xylem extracts from C. japonicum did not affect homogeneous ice nucleation temperature as analyzed by emulsified micro-water droplets. The possible role of such anti-ice nucleation activity in crude xylem extracts in deep supercooling of XPCs is discussed.     

Culture of Shoot Apices of Theobroma cacao

Surface sterilized buds of young cocoa plants (Theobroma cacao L.) taken at particular stages of the flush cycle were placed in Linsmaier and Skoog agar medium supplemented with a range of growth regulators. Only buds taken at the 1–2 (dormant) stage of the flush cycle and treated with gibberellic acid (GA₃) alone and GA₃plus kinetin (KN) supplement showed bud opening. In liquid Linsmaier and Skoog medium buds isolated at the 1–2 stage also responded to GA₃ and KN. In this case addition of KN caused bud opening, while GA₃ either initiated bud opening only or opening followed by leaf expansion depending on the concentration of GA₃ supplied. Bud development was inhibited when ABA was included in the medium hut this was overcome by the presence of GA₃ but not KN. Since a hormonal supplement was required for any response from the excised buds, it is suggested that the intermittent growth of the shoot apex in the intact plant may be determined by hormonal stimuli derived from other parts of the plant. The findings also indicate that the bud apices could be maintained in culture for long periods which may provide a basis for the development of a micropropagation procedure for cocoa.     

Pseudomonas syringae isolated in lichens for the first time: Unveiling Peltigera genus as the exclusive host

Pseudomonas syringae is a bacterial complex that is widespread through a range of environments, typically associated with plants where it can be pathogenic, but also found in non-plant environments such as clouds, precipitation, and surface waters. Understanding its distribution within the environment, and the habitats it occupies, is important for examining its evolution and understanding behaviours. After a recent study found P. syringae living among a range of vascular plant species in Iceland, we questioned whether lichens could harbour P. syringae. Sixteen different species of lichens were sampled all over Iceland, but only one lichen genus, Peltigera, was found to consistently harbour P. syringae. Phylogenetic analyses of P. syringae from 10 sampling points where lichen, tracheophyte, and/or moss were simultaneously collected showed significant differences between sampling points, but not between different plants and lichens from the same point. Furthermore, while there were similarities in the P. syringae population in tracheophytes and Peltigera, the densities in Peltigera thalli were lower than in moss and tracheophyte samples. This discovery suggests P. syringae strains can localize and survive in organisms beyond higher plants, and thus reveals opportunities for studying their influence on P. syringae evolution.