Natively unfolded proteins: a point where biology waits for physics

The experimental material accumulated in the literature on the conformational behavior of intrinsically unstructured (natively unfolded) proteins was analyzed. Results of this analysis showed that these proteins do not possess uniform structural properties, as expected for members of a single thermodynamic entity. Rather, these proteins may be divided into two structurally different groups: intrinsic coils, and premolten globules. Proteins from the first group have hydrodynamic dimensions typical of random coils in poor solvent and do not possess any (or almost any) ordered secondary structure. Proteins from the second group are essentially more compact, exhibiting some amount of residual secondary structure, although they are still less dense than native or molten globule proteins. An important feature of the intrinsically unstructured proteins is that they undergo disorder-order transition during or prior to their biological function. In this respect, the Protein Quartet model, with function arising from four specific conformations (ordered forms, molten globules, premolten globules, and random coils) and transitions between any two of the states, is discussed.     

Structural disorder serves as a weak signal for intracellular protein degradation

Targeted turnover of proteins is a key element in the regulation of practically all basic cellular processes. The underlying physicochemical and/or sequential signals, however, are not fully understood. This issue is particularly pertinent in light of the recent recognition that intrinsically unstructured/disordered proteins, common in eukaryotic cells, are extremely susceptible to proteolytic degradation in vitro. The in vivo half-lives of proteins were determined recently in a high-throughput study encompassing the entire yeast proteome; here we examine whether these half-lives correlate with the presence of classical degradation motifs (PEST region, destruction-box, KEN-box, or the N-terminal residue) or with various physicochemical characteristics, such as the size of the protein, the degree of structural disorder, or the presence of low-complexity regions. Our principal finding is that, in general, the half-life of a protein does not depend on the presence of degradation signals within its sequence, even of ubiquitination sites, but correlates mainly with the length of its polypeptide chain and with various measures of structural disorder. Two distinct modes of involvement of disorder in degradation are proposed. Susceptibility to degradation of longer proteins, containing larger numbers of residues in conformational disorder, suggests an extensive function, whereby the effect of disorder can be ascribed to its mere physical presence. However, after normalization for protein length, the only signal that correlates with half-life is disorder, which indicates that it also acts in an intensive manner, that is, as a specific signal, perhaps in conjunction with the recognition of classical degradation motifs. The significance of correlation is rather low; thus protein degradation is not determined by a single characteristic, but is a multi-factorial process that shows large protein-to-protein variations. Protein disorder, nevertheless, plays a key signalling role in many cases.     

The N-terminal half of the peroxisomal cycling receptor Pex5p is a natively unfolded domain

Targeting of most newly synthesised peroxisomal matrix proteins to the organelle requires Pex5p, the so-called PTS1 receptor. According to current models of peroxisomal biogenesis, Pex5p interacts with these proteins in the cytosol, transports them to the peroxisomal membrane and catalyses their translocation across the membrane. Presently, our knowledge on the structural details behind the interaction of Pex5p with the cargo proteins is reasonably complete. In contrast, information regarding the structure of the Pex5p N-terminal half (a region containing its peroxisomal targeting domain) is still limited. We have recently observed that the Stokes radius of this Pex5p domain is anomalously large, suggesting that this portion of the protein is either a structured elongated domain or that it adopts a low compactness conformation. Here, we address this issue using a combination of biophysical and biochemical approaches. Our results indicate that the N-terminal half of Pex5p is best described as a natively unfolded pre-molten globule-like domain. The implications of these findings on the mechanism of protein import into the peroxisome are discussed.     

Dematin exhibits a natively unfolded core domain and an independently folded headpiece domain

Dematin is an actin‐binding protein originally identified in the junctional complex of the erythrocyte plasma membrane, and is present in many nonerythroid cells. Dematin headpiece knockout mice display a spherical red cell phenotype and develop a compensated anemia. Dematin has two domains: a 315‐residue, proline‐rich “core” domain and a 68‐residue carboxyl‐terminal villin‐type “headpiece” domain. Expression of full‐length dematin in E. coli as a GST recombinant protein results in truncation within a proline, glutamic acid, serine, threonine rich region (PEST). Therefore, we designed a mutant construct that replaces the PEST sequence. The modified dematin has high actin binding activity as determined by actin sedimentation assays. Negative stain electron microscopy demonstrates that the modified dematin also exhibits actin bundling activity like that of native dematin. Circular dichroism (CD) and NMR spectral analysis, however, show little secondary structure in the modified dematin. The lack of secondary structure is also observed in native dematin purified from human red blood cells. ¹⁵N‐HSQC NMR spectra of modified dematin indicate that the headpiece domain is fully folded whereas the core region is primarily unfolded. Our finding suggests that the core is natively unfolded and may serve as a scaffold to organize the components of the junctional complex.     

Structural memory of natively unfolded tau protein detected by small-angle X-ray scattering

Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) is a universal low-resolution method to study size and shape of globular proteins in solution but recent developments facilitate the quantitative characterization of the structure and structural transitions of metastable systems like partially or completely unfolded proteins. We present here a study of temperature induced transitions in tau, a natively unfolded protein involved in Alzheimer's disease. Previous studies on full length tau and several disease-related mutants provided information about the residual structure in different domains revealing a specific role and extended conformations of the so-called repeat domains, which are considered to be responsible for the formation of amyloid-like fibrils ("paired helical filaments"). Here, we employ SAXS to investigate the temperature dependent properties of tau. Slow heating/cooling of the full length protein from 10°C to 50°C did not lead to detectable changes in the overall size. Surprisingly, quick heating/cooling caused tau to adopt a significantly more compact conformation, which was stable over up to 3 h and represents a structural "memory" effect. This compaction is not observed for the shorter tau constructs containing largely the repeat domains. The structural and functional implications of the observed unusual behavior of tau under nonequilibrium conditions are discussed.     

Assembly and function of the Photosystem II manganese stabilizing protein: lessons from its natively unfolded behavior

The Photosystem II (PS II) manganese stabilizing protein (MSP) possesses characteristics, including thermostability, ascribed to the natively unfolded class of proteins (Lydakis-Simantiris et al. (1999) Biochemistry 38: 404–414). A site-directed mutant of MSP, C28A, C51A, which lacks the -S–S- bridge, also binds to PS II at wild-type levels and reconstitutes oxygen evolution activity [Betts et al. (1996) Biochim Biophys Acta 1274: 135–142], although the mutant protein is even more disordered in solution. Both WT and C28A, C51A MSP aggregate upon heating, but an examination of the effects of protein concentration and pH on heat-induced aggregation showed that each MSP species exhibited greater resistance to aggregation at a pH near their pI (5.2) than do either bovine serum albumin (BSA) or carbonic anhydrase, which were used as model water soluble proteins. Increases in pH above the pI of the MSPs and BSA enhanced their aggregation resistance, a behavior which can be predicted from their charge (MSP) or a combination of charge and stabilization by -S–S- bonds (BSA). In the case of aggregation resistance by MSP, this is likely to be an important factor in its ability to avoid unproductive self-association reactions in favor of formation of the protein–protein interactions that lead to formation of the functional oxygen evolving complex.     

Modeling the accessible conformations of the intrinsically unstructured transactivation domain of p53

Internuclear distances derived from paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) data were used to restrain molecular dynamics simulations of the intrinsically unstructured transactivation domain of the tumor suppressor protein, p53. About 1000 structures were simulated using ensemble averaging of replicate molecules to compensate for the inherent bias in the PRE-derived distances. Gyration radii measurements on these structures show that the p53 transactivation domain (p53TAD) is statistically predominantly in a partially collapsed state that is unlike the open structure that is found for p53TAD bound to either the E3 ubiquitin ligase, MDM2, or the 70 kDa subunit of replication protein A, RPA70. Contact regions that potentially mediate the collapse were identified and found to consist of mostly hydrophobic residues. The identified contact regions preferentially place the MDM2 and RPA70 binding regions in close proximity. We show that our simulations thoroughly sample the available range of conformations and that a fraction of the molecules are in an open state that would be competent for binding either MDM2 or RPA70. We also show that the Stokes radius estimated from the average gyration radius of the ensemble is in good agreement with the value determined using size exclusion chromatography. Finally, the presence of a persistent loop localized to a PXP motif was identified. Serine residues flanking the PXP motif become phosphorylated in response to DNA damage, and we postulate that this will perturb the equilibrium population to more open conformations.     

Computational analysis of folding and mutation properties of C5 domain of myosin binding protein C

Thermal folding molecular dynamics simulations of the domain C5 of Myosin binding protein C were performed using a native-centric model to study the role of three mutations related to Familial Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy. Mutation of Asn755 causes the largest shift of the folding temperature, and the residue is located in the CFGA' beta-sheet featuring the highest phi-values. The mutation thus appears to reduce the thermodynamic stability in agreement with experimental data. The mutations on Arg654 and Arg668, conversely, cause little change in the folding temperature and they reside in the low phi-value BDE beta-sheet, so that their pathological role cannot be related to impairment of the folding process but possibly to the binding with target molecules. As the typical signature of Domain C5 is the presence of a longer and destibilizing CD-loop with respect to the other Ig-like domains, we completed the work with a bioinformatic analysis of this loop showing a high density of negative charge and low hydrophobicity. This indicates the CD-loop as a natively unfolded sequence with a likely coupling between folding and ligand binding.     

Intrinsic structural disorder and sequence features of the cell cycle inhibitor p57Kip2.

The cell cycle inhibitor p57Kip2 induces cell cycle arrest by inhibiting the activity of cyclin-dependent kinases. p57, although active as a cyclin A-CDK2 inhibitor, is largely unfolded or intrinsically disordered as shown by circular dichroism and fluorescence spectra characteristic of an unfolded protein and a hydrodynamic radius consistent with an unfolded structure. In addition, the N-terminal domain of p57 is both functionally independent as a cyclin A-CDK2 inhibitor and unstructured, as demonstrated by circular dichroism and fluorescence spectra indicative of unfolded proteins, a lack of 1H chemical shift dispersion and a hydrodynamic radius consistent with a highly unfolded structure. The amino acid compositions of full-length p57 and the excised QT domain of p57 exhibit significant deviations from the average composition of globular proteins that are consistent with the observed intrinsic disorder. However, the amino acid composition of the CDK inhibition domain of p57 does not exhibit such a striking deviation from the average values observed for proteins, implying that a general low level of hydrophobicity, rather than depletion or enrichment in specific amino acids, contributes to the intrinsic disorder of the excised p57 CDK inhibition domain.     

Engineering the structural stability and functional properties of the GI domain into the intrinsically unfolded GII domain of the yeast linker histone Hho1p

Yeast Hho1p contains two domains, GI and GII, that are homologous to the single globular domain of the linker histone H1 (GH1). We showed previously that the isolated GI and GII domains have different structural stabilities and functional properties. GI, like GH1 and the related GH5, is stably folded at low ionic strength (10 mM sodium phosphate) and gives strong protection of chromatosome-length DNA ( approximately 166 bp) during micrococcal nuclease digestion of chromatin. GII is intrinsically unfolded in 10 mM sodium phosphate and gives weak chromatosome protection, but in 250 mM sodium phosphate has a structure very similar to that of GI as determined by NMR spectroscopy. We now show that the loop between helices II and III in GII is the cause of both its instability and its inability to confer strong chromatosome protection. A mutant GII, containing the loop of GI, termed GII-L, is stable in 10 mM sodium phosphate and is as effective as GI in chromatosome protection. Two GII mutants with selected mutations within the original loop were also slightly more stable than GII. In GII, two of the four basic residues conserved at the second DNA binding site ("site II") on the globular domain of canonical linker histones, and in GI, are absent. Introduction of the two "missing" site II basic residues into GII or GII-L destabilised the protein and led to decreased chromatosome protection relative to the protein without the basic residues. In general, the ability to confer chromatosome protection in vitro is closely related to structural stability (the relative population of structured and unstructured states). We have determined the structure of GII-L by NMR spectroscopy. GII-L is very similar to GII folded in 250 mM sodium phosphate, with the exception of the substituted loop region, which, as in GI, contains a single helical turn.     

Structure and dynamics at N- and C-terminal regions of intrinsically disordered human c-Myc PEST degron reveal a pH-induced transition

We investigated the structure and Brownian rotational motion of the PEST region (201-268) from human c-Myc oncoprotein, whose overexpression/dysregulation is associated with various types of cancer. The 77-residue PEST fragment revealed a large Stokes radius (~3.1 nm) and CD spectrum highlighting abundance of disordered structure. Changes in structure/dynamics at two specific sites in PEST degron were observed using time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy by labeling Cys⁹ near N-terminal with dansyl probe and inserting a Trp⁷⁰ near C-terminal (PEST M1). Trp in PEST M1 at pH 3 was inaccessible to quencher, showed hindered segmental motion and slow global rotation (~30 ns) in contrast to N-terminal where the dansyl probe was free, exposed with fast global rotation (~5 ns). Remarkably, this large monomeric structure at acidic pH was retained irrespective of ionic strength (0.03-0.25 M) and partially so in presence of 6 M Gdn.HCl. With gradual increase in pH, a structural transition (~pH 4.8) into a more exposed and freely rotating Trp was noticeable. Interestingly, the induced structure at C-terminal also influenced the dynamics of dansyl probe near N-terminal, which otherwise remained unstructured at pH > 5. FRET measurements confirmed a 11 Å decrease in distance between dansyl and indole at pH 4 compared to pH 9, coinciding with enhanced ANS binding and increase in strand/helix population in both PEST fragments. The protonation of glutamate/aspartate residues in C-terminal region of PEST is implicated in this disorder-order transition. This may have a bearing on the role of PEST in endocytic trafficking of eukaryotic proteins.     

Molecular recognition of structurally disordered Pro/Ala-rich sequences (PAS) by antibodies involves an Ala residue at the hot spot of the epitope

Pro/Ala-rich sequences (PAS) are polypeptides that were developed as a biological alternative to poly-ethylene glycol (PEG) to generate biopharmaceuticals with extended plasma half-life. Like PEG, PAS polypeptides are conformationally disordered and show high solubility in water. Devoid of any charged or prominent hydrophobic side chains, these biosynthetic polymers represent an extreme case of intrinsically disordered proteins. Despite lack of immunogenicity of PAS tags in numerous animal studies we now succeeded in generating monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) against three different PAS versions. To this end, mice were immunized with a PAS#1, P/A#1 or APSA 40mer peptide conjugated to keyhole limpet hemocyanin as highly immunogenic carrier protein. In each case, one MAb with high binding activity and specificity towards a particular PAS motif was obtained. The apparent affinity was strongly dependent on the avidity effect and most pronounced for the bivalent MAb when interacting with a long PAS repeat. X-ray structural analysis of four representative anti-PAS Fab fragments in complex with their cognate PAS epitope peptides revealed interactions dominated by hydrogen bond networks involving the peptide backbone as well as multiple Van der Waals contacts arising from intimate shape complementarity. Surprisingly, Ala, the L-amino acid with the smallest side chain, emerged as a crucial feature for epitope recognition, contributing specific contacts at the center of the paratope in several anti-PAS complexes. Apart from these insights into how antibodies can recognize feature-less peptides without secondary structure, the MAbs characterized in this study offer valuable reagents for the preclinical and clinical development of PASylated biologics.     

Pre-structured motifs in the natively unstructured preS1 surface antigen of hepatitis B virus

The preS1 surface antigen of hepatitis B virus (HBV) is known to play an important role in the initial attachment of HBV to hepatocytes. We have characterized structural features of the full-length preS1 using heteronuclear NMR methods and discovered that this 119-residue protein is inherently unstructured without a unique tertiary structure under a nondenaturing condition. Yet, combination of various NMR parameters shows that the preS1 contains "pre-structured" domains broadly covering its functional domains. The most prominent domain is formed by residues 27-45 and overlaps with the putative hepatocyte-binding domain (HBD) encompassing residues 21-47, within which two well-defined pre-structured motifs, formed by Pro(32)-Ala(36) and Pro(41)-Phe(45) are found. Additional, somewhat less prominent, pre-structured motifs are also formed by residues 11-18, 22-25, 37-40, and 46-50. Overall results suggest that the preS1 is a natively unstructured protein (NUP) whose N-terminal 50 residues, populated with multiple pre-structured motifs, contribute critically to hepatocyte binding.     

Direct characterization of the folded, unfolded and urea-denatured states of the C-terminal domain of the ribosomal protein L9

The stability of the isolated C-terminal domain of the ribosomal protein L9 (CTL9) is strongly dependent upon pH. Below pH 4.2, the folded and unfolded states are both populated significantly. Their interconversion is slow on the NMR chemical shift time-scale and separate, well-resolved resonances from each state are observed. This allows the hydrodynamic properties of both states to be studied under identical conditions by using pulse field gradient NMR experiments. Hydrodynamic radii of the folded, unfolded and urea denatured protein molecules at pD 3.8 have been derived. The acid-denatured protein has a significantly smaller hydrodynamic radius, 28.2A, compared to that of the urea-denatured protein, which is 33.6A at pD 3.8. Far-UV CD spectra show that there is more residual secondary structure retained in the acid-denatured ensemble than in the urea-denatured one. ANS binding experiments and analysis of the CD data show that this acid-denatured species is not a molten globule state. Diffusion measurements of CTL9 were conducted over the pD range from 2.1 to 7.0. The hydrodynamic radii of both the folded and the acid-unfolded protein start to increase below pD 4, with the radius of hydration of the acid-unfolded state increasing from 25.1A at pD 4.2 to 33.5A at pD 2.1. The hydrodynamic radius of the urea-denatured protein is much less sensitive to pH. The unfolded protein at pD 2.1, no urea, has almost the same hydrodynamic radius as the urea-denatured protein at pD 3.8. The CD spectra, however, show significant differences in residual secondary structure, and the acid-denatured state contains more structure.     

The effect of an ionic detergent on the natively unfolded beta-dystroglycan ectodomain and on its interaction with alpha-dystroglycan

Dystroglycan (DG) is an adhesion complex, expressed in a wide variety of tissues, formed by an extracellular and a transmembrane subunit, alpha-DG and beta-DG, respectively, interacting noncovalently. Recently, we have shown that the recombinant ectodomain of beta-DG, beta-DG(654-750), behaves as a natively unfolded protein, as it is able to bind the C-terminal domain of alpha-DG, while not displaying a defined structural organization. We monitored the effect of a commonly used denaturing agent, the anionic detergent sodium dodecylsulphate (SDS), on beta-DG(654-750) using a number of biophysical techniques. Very low concentrations of SDS (< or =2 mM) affect both tryptophan fluorescence and circular dichroism of beta-DG, and significantly perturb the interaction with the alpha-DG subunit as shown by solid-phase binding assays and fluorescence titrations in solution. This result confirms, as recently proposed for natively unfolded proteins, that beta-DG(654-750) exists in a native state, which is crucial to fulfill its biological function. Two-dimensional NMR analysis shows that SDS does not induce any evident conformational rearrangement within the ectodomain of beta-DG. Its first 70 amino acids, which show a lower degree of mobility, interact with the detergent, but this does not change the amount of secondary structure, whereas the highly flexible and mobile C-terminal region of beta-DG(654-750) remains largely unaffected, even at a very high SDS concentration (up to 50 mM). Our data indicate that SDS can be used as a useful tool for investigating natively unfolded proteins, and confirm that the beta-DG ectodomain is an interesting model system.     

Natively unfolded nucleic acid binding P8 domain of SeMV polyprotein 2a affects the novel ATPase activity of the preceding P10 domain

Open reading frame (ORF) 2a of Sesbania mosaic virus (SeMV) codes for polyprotein 2a (Membrane anchor-protease-VPg-P10-P8). The C-terminal domain of SeMV polyprotein 2a was cloned, expressed and purified in order to functionally characterize it. The protein of size 8 kDa (P8) domain, like viral protein genome linked (VPg), was found to be natively unfolded and could bind to nucleic acids. Interestingly, P10-P8 but not P8 showed a novel Mg²⁺ dependent ATPase activity that was inhibited in the presence of poly A. In the absence of P8, the ATPase activity of the protein of size 10 kDa (P10) domain was reduced suggesting that the natively unfolded P8 domain influenced the P10 ATPase.     

Operational definition of intrinsically unstructured protein sequences based on susceptibility to the 20S proteasome

Intrinsically unstructured proteins (IUPs), also known as natively unfolded proteins, lack well-defined secondary and tertiary structure under physiological conditions. In recent years, growing experimental and theoretical evidence has accumulated, indicating that many entire proteins and protein sequences are unstructured under physiological conditions, and that they play significant roles in diverse cellular processes. Bioinformatic algorithms have been developed to identify such sequences in proteins for which structural data are lacking, but still generate substantial numbers of false positives and negatives. We describe here a simple and reliable in vitro assay for identifying IUP sequences based on their susceptibility to 20S proteasomal degradation. We show that 20S proteasomes digest IUP sequences, under conditions in which native, and even molten globule states, are resistant. Furthermore, we show that protein-protein interactions can protect IUPs against 20S proteasomal action. Taken together, our results thus suggest that the 20S proteasome degradation assay provides a powerful system for operational definition of IUPs.     

The inactivating factor of glutamine synthetase,IF7, is a "natively unfolded" protein

Glutamine synthetase (GS) is the key enzyme responsible for the primary assimilation of ammonium in all living organisms, and it catalyses the synthesis of glutamine from glutamic acid, ATP, and ammonium. One of the recently discovered mechanisms of GS regulation involves protein-protein interactions with a small 65-residue-long protein named IF7. Here, we study the structure and stability of IF7 and its binding properties to GS, by using several biophysical techniques (fluorescence, circular dichroism, Fourier transform infrared and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopies, and gel filtration chromatography) which provide complementary structural information. The findings show that IF7 has a small amount of residual secondary structure, but lacks a well defined tertiary structure, and is not compact. Thus, all of the studies indicate that IF7 is a "natively unfolded" protein. The binding of IF7 to GS, its natural binding partner, occurs with an apparent dissociation constant of K(D) = 0.3 +/- 0.1 microM, as measured by fluorescence. We discuss the implications for the GS regulation mechanisms of IF7 being unfolded.