Hybrid DNA Extension and Reciprocal Exchanges: Alternative Issues of an Early Intermediate during Meiotic Recombination?

Large heterologies in gene b2 strongly increase the frequencies of reciprocal exchanges on their left border, towards the high conversion end. In a previous study, we observed that heterozygous point mutations located in the high conversion end (region F) stimulate the reciprocal exchanges instigated by the large heterology 138. We have defined some properties of this stimulation. The effect does not depend on the nature of the large heterology used. It is effective only with point mutations located on the left side of the large heterology. It does not depend on the number of heterozygosities accumulated in region F. It is not specific on the location of point mutations in region F: it decreases from region F (left end) to region E (middle part of b2). It is correlated with the mismatch correction efficiencies of the point mutations used. It is not observed in the absence of a large heterology. Point mutation heterozygosities which stimulate reciprocal exchanges also decrease the frequency of HDNA formation in gene b2. We propose a model in which reciprocal exchanges on the one hand and hybrid DNA formation on the other hand correspond to alternative processings of a common recombination intermediate.     

Effects of Holliday junction position on Xer-mediated recombination in vitro.

Site-specific recombination mediated by XerC and XerD functions in the segregation of circular replicons in Escherichia coli. A key feature of most models of recombination for the family of recombinases to which XerC and XerD belong is that a Holliday junction forms at the position of the first pair of recombinase-mediated strand exchanges and then branch migrates 6-8 bp to the position of the second pair of strand exchanges. We have tested this hypothesis for Xer recombination by studying the effects of junction position on XerC-mediated strand exchange in vitro. Recombination of synthetic Holliday junction substrates in which junction mobility was constrained to a region extending over or removed away from the normal cleavage and exchange point was analysed. All substrates undergo strand cleavage at the normal position. We infer that the Holliday junction need not be at this position during strand cleavage and exchange. With substrates in which the Holliday junction is constrained to a region away from the XerC-mediated cleavage point, strand exchange generates products with the predicted mispaired bases.     

Dissecting the resolution reaction of lambda integrase using suicide Holliday junction substrates.

A reciprocal strand exchange between two DNA helices generates the crossed-strand intermediate, or Holliday junction, which is common to many pathways of homologous and site-specific recombination. The Int family of recombinases are unique in their ability to both make and resolve Holliday junctions. Previous experiments utilizing 'synthetic' att site Holliday junctions to study the mechanisms associated with the cleavage, transfer and ligation of DNA strands have been confined to studying reciprocal strand exchanges (a pair of temporally overlapping strand cleavages). To circumvent this limitation, we have designed synthetic suicide Holliday junctions that make it possible to monitor individual DNA strand cleavage events. These substrates contain a pre-existing nick in the vicinity of the Int binding site; when Int introduces a second nick into these substrates, the 5'OH nucleophile required for ligation (in either the forward or reverse reaction) is lost by diffusion, thus trapping the covalent protein-DNA intermediate. The results indicate that resolution (involving two partner Ints) is stimulated by additional 'cross-core' Ints as a result of enhanced cleavage rates, and not as a result of enhanced co-ordination of cleavage. Several models for the role of the 'cross-core' Ints during resolution are discussed, as well as the usefulness of these substrates for studying additional aspects of the Holliday junction resolution reaction.     

The conversion gradient at HIS4 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. I. Heteroduplex rejection and restoration of Mendelian segregation.

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, some gene loci manifest gradients in the frequency of aberrant segregation in meiosis, with the high end of each gradient corresponding to a hotspot for DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). The slope of a gradient is reduced when mismatch repair functions fail to act upon heteroduplex DNA-aberrant segregation frequencies at the low end of the gradient are higher in the absence of mismatch repair. Two models for the role of mismatch repair functions in the generation of meiotic "conversion gradients" have been proposed. The heteroduplex rejection model suggests that recognition of mismatches by mismatch repair enzymes limits hybrid DNA flanking the site of a DSB. The restoration-conversion model proposes that mismatch repair does not affect the length of hybrid DNA, but instead increasingly favors restoration of Mendelian segregation over full conversion with increasing distance from the DSB site. In our experiment designed to distinguish between these two models, data for one subset of well repairable mismatches in the HIS4 gene failed to show restoration-type repair but did indicate reduction in the length of hybrid DNA, supporting the heteroduplex rejection model. However, another subset of data manifested restoration-type repair, indicating a relationship between Holliday junction resolution and mismatch repair. We also present evidence for the infrequent formation of symmetric hybrid DNA during meiotic DSB repair.     

Control of cross-over by single-strand DNA resection

Control of DNA cross-overs is necessary for meiotic recombination and genome integrity. The frequency of cross-overs is dependent on homology length and the conversion tract, but the mechanisms underlying the regulation of cross-overs remain unknown. We propose that 5'-end resection, a key intermediate in double-strand break repair, could determine the formation of cross-overs. Extensive DNA resection might favor gene conversion without cross-over by channeling recombination events through synthesis-dependent strand-annealing. In reactions with short regions of homology, resection beyond the homologous sequence would impede Holliday junction formation and, consequently, cross-over. Extensive DNA resection could be an effective mechanism to prevent reciprocal exchanges between dispersed DNA sequences, and thus contribute to the genome stability.     

Coordinated control of XerC and XerD catalytic activities during Holliday junction resolution

Site-specific recombinases XerC and XerD function in the segregation of circular bacterial replicons. In a recombining nucleoprotein complex containing two molecules each of XerC and XerD, coordinated reciprocal switches in recombinase activity ensure that only XerC or XerD is active at any one time. Mutated recombinases that carry sub?stitutions of a catalytic arginine residue stimulate cleavage and strand exchange mediated by the partner recombinase on DNA substrates that are normally recombined poorly by the partner. This is associated with a reciprocal impairment of the recombinase's own ability to initiate catalysis. The extent of this switch in catalysis is modulated by changes in recombination site sequence and is not a direct consequence of any catalytic defect. We propose that altered interactions between the mutated proteins and their wild-type partners lead to an increased level of an alternative Holliday junction intermediate that has a conformation appropriate for resolution by the partner recombinase. The results indicate how subtle changes in protein-DNA architecture at a Holliday junction can redirect recombination outcome.     

Intrachromosomal Recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae : Reciprocal Exchange in an Inverted Repeat and Associated Gene Conversion

Intrachromosomal gene conversion has not shown a strong association with reciprocal exchanges. However, reciprocal exchanges do occur between intrachromosomal repeats. To understand the relationship between reciprocal exchange and gene conversion in repeated sequences the recombination behavior of an inverted repeat was studied. We have found that in one orientation a single copy of the kanr gene of the bacterial transposon Tn903 flanked by part of the inverted repeats IS903 does not give G418 resistance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. A reciprocal exchange in the IS903 repeats inverts the kanr gene, which then gives G418 resistance in a single copy. Using this as a selection for intrachromosomal reciprocal exchange we have introduced multiple restriction site heterologies into the IS903 repeats and examined the crossover products for associated gene conversions. Approximately 50% of crossovers, both in mitosis and meiosis, were associated with a gene conversion. This suggests that these crossovers result from an intermediate that gives a gene conversion in 50% of the events, that is, both reciprocal exchange and gene conversion between repeated sequences have a common origin. The data are most consistent with a heteroduplex mismatch repair mechanism.     

Alterations in the directionality of lambda site-specific recombination catalyzed by mutant integrases in vivo.

Phage lambda integrative and excisive recombination normally proceeds by a pair of sequential strand exchanges. During the first exchange reaction, the "top" strand in each recombination site is cleaved, exchanged, and religated generating a Holliday junction intermediate. This intermediate DNA structure is resolved through a pair of reciprocal "bottom" strand exchanges, leading to recombinant products. The strict co-ordination of exchange reactions ensures religation between correct partner strands only. Here we show that the directionality of recombination is altered in vivo by two mutant integrases, Int-h (E174 K) and a double mutant Int-h/218 (E174 K/E218 K). This change in directionality leads to deletion instead of inversion on substrates that carry inverted attachment sites and, depending on the pair of target sites employed, requires the presence or absence of integration host factor. Neither Fis nor Xis is involved in deletion. Sequence analyses of deletion products reveal that the newly generated hybrid attachment site exhibits a reversed genetic polarity. We demonstrate that only one of two possible hybrid site configurations is generated and discuss two pathways leading to deletion. In the first, deletion results from a wrong alignment of the two recombination sites within the synaptic complex. In the second pathway, the unco-ordinated cleavage by the mutant integrases of all four DNA strands present in a conventional Holliday junction intermediate leads to two double-stranded breaks, whereby the subsequent rejoining between "wrong" partner strands appears restricted to only two strands.     

Mutations of the phage lambda attachment site alter the directionality of resolution of Holliday structures.

Integrative recombination of bacteriophage lambda occurs by two sequential, reciprocal strand exchanges at specific positions within the attachment sites. Both exchanges are promoted by the lambda Int protein; the first forms a Holliday structure, and the second resolves it to recombinant products. Recombination requires sequence homology within the 7 bp 'overlap' region that separates the two points of strand exchange. To see if homology promotes the second strand exchange, we constructed attachment site Holliday structures by annealing DNA strands and then assayed Int-promoted resolution. Holliday structures corresponding to strand exchange between sites with homologous overlap regions were efficiently resolved to give mixtures of recombinants and parents. Holliday structures corresponding to exchanges between heterologous sites fell into two classes. Members of the first class, in which heterology limited but did not completely prevent migration of the branchpoint within the overlap region, were resolved efficiently and preferentially to parental molecules. We propose that resolution to recombinants occurs only if homology allows branch migration from the first to the second exchange site. Members of the second class, in which heterology constrained the branchpoint within an Int binding site, were resolved poorly. We suggest that Holliday structures that have a branchpoint within an Int binding site are poor substrates for Int.     

Molecular Analysis of Recombination Events in Drosophila

The locations of crossover junctions and gene conversion tracts, isolated in the rosy gene of Drosophila melanogaster, were determined using DNA sequencing and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Frequent DNA sequence polymorphisms between the parental genes served as unselected genetic markers. All conversion tracts were continuous, and half of the reciprocal crossover events had conversion tracts at the crossover junction. These experiments have also identified the sequence polymorphisms responsible for altered gene expression in two naturally occurring rosy variants.     

Interplay between DNA replication, recombination and repair based on the structure of RecG helicase

Recent studies in Escherichia coli indicate that the interconversion of DNA replication fork and Holliday junction structures underpins chromosome duplication and helps secure faithful transmission of the genome from one generation to the next. It facilitates interplay between DNA replication, recombination and repair, and provides means to rescue replication forks stalled by lesions in or on the template DNA. Insight into how this interconversion may be catalysed has emerged from genetic, biochemical and structural studies of RecG protein, a member of superfamily 2 of DNA and RNA helicases. We describe how a single molecule of RecG might target a branched DNA structure and translocate a single duplex arm to drive branch migration of a Holliday junction, interconvert replication fork and Holliday junction structures and displace the invading strand from a D loop formed during recombination at a DNA end. We present genetic evidence suggesting how the latter activity may provide an efficient pathway for the repair of DNA double-strand breaks that avoids crossing over, thus facilitating chromosome segregation at cell division.     

The Effect of Attachment Site Mutations on Strand Exchange in Bacteriophage λ Site-Specific Recombination

Recombination of phage λ attachment sites occurs by sequential exchange of the DNA strands at two specific locations. The first exchange produces a Holliday structure, and the second resolves it to recombinant products. Heterology for base substitution mutations in the region between the two strand exchange points (the overlap region) reduces recombination; some mutations inhibit the accumulation of Holliday structures, others inhibit their resolution to recombinant products. To see if heterology also alters the location of the strand exchange points, we determined the segregation pattern of three single and one multiple base pair substitution mutations of the overlap region in crosses with wild type sites. The mutations are known to differ in the severity of their recombination defect and in the stage of strand exchange they affect. The three single mutations behaved similarly: each segregated into both products of recombination,, and the two products of a single crossover were frequently nonreciprocal in the overlap region. In contrast, the multiple mutation preferentially segregated into one of the two recombinant products, and the two products of a single crossover appeared to be fully reciprocal. The simplest explanation of the segregation pattern of the single mutations is that strand exchanges occur at the normal locations to produce recombinants with mismatched base pairs that are frequently repaired. The segregation pattern of the multiple mutation is consistent with the view that both strand exchanges usually occur to one side of the mutant site. We suggest that the segregation pattern of a particular mutation is determined by which stage of strand exchange it inhibits and by the severity of the inhibition.     

The effect of attachment site mutations on strand exchange in bacteriophage lambda site-specific recombination

Recombination of phage lambda attachment sites occurs by sequential exchange of the DNA strands at two specific locations. The first exchange produces a Holliday structure, and the second resolves it to recombinant products. Heterology for base substitution mutations in the region between the two strand exchange points (the overlap region) reduces recombination; some mutations inhibit the accumulation of Holliday structures, others inhibit their resolution to recombinant products. To see if heterology also alters the location of the strand exchange points, we determined the segregation pattern of three single and one multiple base pair substitution mutations of the overlap region in crosses with wild type sites. The mutations are known to differ in the severity of their recombination defect and in the stage of strand exchange they affect. The three single mutations behaved similarly: each segregated into both products of recombination, and the two products of a single crossover were frequently nonreciprocal in the overlap region. In contrast, the multiple mutation preferentially segregated into one of the two recombinant products, and the two products of a single crossover appeared to be fully reciprocal. The simplest explanation of the segregation pattern of the single mutations is that strand exchanges occur at the normal locations to produce recombinants with mismatched base pairs that are frequently repaired. The segregation pattern of the multiple mutation is consistent with the view that both strand exchanges usually occur to one side of the mutant site. We suggest that the segregation pattern of a particular mutation is determined by which stage of strand exchange it inhibits and by the severity of the inhibition.     

Suppression of intrachromosomal gene conversion in mammalian cells by small degrees of sequence divergence

Pairs of closely linked defective herpes simplex virus (HSV) thymidine kinase (tk) gene sequences exhibiting various nucleotide heterologies were introduced into the genome of mouse Ltk- cells. Recombination events were recovered by selecting for the correction of a 16-bp insertion mutation in one of the tk sequences. We had previously shown that when two tk sequences shared a region of 232 bp of homology, interruption of the homology by two single nucleotide heterologies placed 19 bp apart reduced recombination nearly 20-fold. We now report that either one of the nucleotide heterologies alone reduces recombination only about 2.5-fold, indicating that the original pair of single nucleotide heterologies acted synergistically to inhibit recombination. We tested a variety of pairs of single nucleotide heterologies and determined that they reduced recombination from 7- to 175-fold. Substrates potentially leading to G-G or C-C mispairs in presumptive heteroduplex DNA (hDNA) intermediates displayed a particularly low rate of recombination. Additional experiments suggested that increased sequence divergence causes a shortening of gene conversion tracts. Collectively, our results suggest that suppression of recombination between diverged sequences is mediated via processing of a mispaired hDNA intermediate.     

RuvAB-directed branch migration of individual Holliday junctions is impeded by sequence heterology

The Holliday junction, the key intermediate of recombination, is generated by strand exchange resulting in a covalent connection between two recombining DNA molecules. Translocation of a Holliday junction along DNA, or branch migration, progressively exchanges one DNA strand for another and determines the amount of information that is transferred between two recombining partners. In Escherichia coli, the RuvAB protein complex promotes rapid and unidirectional branch migration of Holliday junctions. We have studied translocation of Holliday junctions using a quantitative biochemical system together with a 'single-molecule' branch migration assay. We demonstrate that RuvAB translocates the junctions through identical DNA sequences in a processive manner with a broad distribution of individual branch migration rates. However, when the complex encounters short heterologous sequences, translocation of the Holliday junctions is impeded. We conclude that translocation of the junctions through a sequence heterology occurs with a probability of bypass being determined both by the length of the heterologous region and the lifetime of the stalled RuvAB complex.     

Recognition and manipulation of branched DNA by the RusA Holliday junction resolvase of Escherichia coli.

Homologous recombination is a fundamental cellular process that shapes and reshapes the genomes of all organisms and promotes repair of damaged DNA. A key step in this process is the resolution of Holliday junctions formed by homologous DNA pairing and strand exchange. In Escherichia coli , a Holliday junction is processed into recombinant products by the concerted activities of the RuvA and RuvB proteins, which together drive branch migration, and RuvC endonuclease, which resolves the structure. In the absence of RuvABC, recombination can be promoted by increasing the expression of the RusA endonuclease, a Holliday junction resolvase encoded by a cryptic prophage gene. Here, we describe the DNA binding properties of RusA. We found that RusA was highly selective for branched molecules and formed complexes with these structures even in the presence of a large excess of linear duplex DNA. However, it does bind weakly to linear duplex DNA. Under conditions where there was no detectable binding to duplex DNA, RusA formed a highly structured complex with a synthetic Holliday junction that was remarkably stable and insensitive to divalent metal ions. The duplex arms were found to adopt a specific alignment within this complex that approximated to a tetrahedral conformation of the junction.     

Mus81 and Yen1 promote reciprocal exchange during mitotic recombination to maintain genome integrity in budding yeast

Holliday junction (HJ) resolution is required for segregation of chromosomes and for formation of crossovers during homologous recombination. The identity of the resolvase(s) that functions in?vivo has yet to be established, although several proteins able to cut HJs in?vitro have been identified as candidates in yeasts and mammals. Using an assay to detect unselected products of mitotic recombination, we found a significant decrease in crossovers in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae mus81Δ mutant. Yen1 serves a backup function responsible for resolving intermediates in mus81Δ mutants, or when conversion tracts are short. In the absence of both Mus81 and Yen1, intermediates are not channeled exclusively to noncrossover recombinants, but instead are processed by Pol32-dependent break-induced replication (BIR). The channeling of recombination from reciprocal exchange to BIR results in greatly increased spontaneous loss of heterozygosity (LOH) and chromosome mis-segregation in the mus81Δ yen1Δ mutant, typical of the genomic instability found in tumor cells.     

Incorporation of large heterologies into heteroduplex DNA during double-strand-break repair in mouse cells

In this study, the formation and repair of large (>1 kb) insertion/deletion (I/D) heterologies during double-strand-break repair (DSBR) was investigated using a gene-targeting assay that permits efficient recovery of sequence insertion events at the haploid chromosomal immunoglobulin (Ig) mu-locus in mouse hybridoma cells. The results revealed that (i) large I/D heterologies were generated on one or both sides of the DSB and, in some cases, formed symmetrically in both homology regions; (ii) large I/D heterologies did not negatively affect the gene targeting frequency; and (iii) prior to DNA replication, the large I/D heterologies were rectified.     

Structural biochemistry of a bacterial checkpoint protein reveals diadenylate cyclase activity regulated by DNA recombination intermediates

To reveal mechanisms of DNA damage checkpoint initiation, we structurally and biochemically analyzed DisA, a protein that controls a Bacillus subtilis sporulation checkpoint in response to DNA double-strand breaks. We find that DisA forms a large octamer that consists of an array of an uncharacterized type of nucleotide-binding domain along with two DNA-binding regions related to the Holliday junction recognition protein RuvA. Remarkably, the nucleotide-binding domains possess diadenylate cyclase activity. The resulting cyclic diadenosine phosphate, c-di-AMP, is reminiscent but distinct from c-di-GMP, an emerging prokaryotic regulator of complex cellular processes. Diadenylate cyclase activity is unaffected by linear DNA or DNA ends but strongly suppressed by branched nucleic acids such as Holliday junctions. Our data indicate that DisA signals DNA structures that interfere with chromosome segregation via c-di-AMP. Identification of the diadenylate cyclase domain in other eubacterial and archaeal proteins implies a more general role for c-di-AMP in prokaryotes.