Calpains: an elaborate proteolytic system

Calpain is an intracellular Ca(2+)-dependent cysteine protease (EC 3.4.22.17; Clan CA, family C02). Recent expansion of sequence data across the species definitively shows that calpain has been present throughout evolution; calpains are found in almost all eukaryotes and some bacteria, but not in archaebacteria. Fifteen genes within the human genome encode a calpain-like protease domain. Interestingly, some human calpains, particularly those with non-classical domain structures, are very similar to calpain homologs identified in evolutionarily distant organisms. Three-dimensional structural analyses have helped to identify calpain's unique mechanism of activation; the calpain protease domain comprises two core domains that fuse to form a functional protease only when bound to Ca(2+)via well-conserved amino acids. This finding highlights the mechanistic characteristics shared by the numerous calpain homologs, despite the fact that they have divergent domain structures. In other words, calpains function through the same mechanism but are regulated independently. This article reviews the recent progress in calpain research, focusing on those studies that have helped to elucidate its mechanism of action. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Proteolysis 50 years after the discovery of lysosome.     

Changes in calcium dynamics following the reversal of the sodium-calcium exchanger have a key role in AMPA receptor-mediated neurodegeneration via calpain activation in hippocampal neurons

Proteolytic cleavage of the Na(+)/Ca(2+) exchanger (NCX) by calpains impairs calcium homeostasis, leading to a delayed calcium overload and excitotoxic cell death. However, it is not known whether reversal of the exchanger contributes to activate calpains and trigger neuronal death. We investigated the role of the reversal of the NCX in Ca(2+) dynamics, calpain activation and cell viability, in alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methylisoxazole-4-propionate (AMPA) receptor-stimulated hippocampal neurons. Selective overactivation of AMPA receptors caused the reversal of the NCX, which accounted for approximately 30% of the rise in intracellular free calcium concentration ([Ca(2+)](i)). The NCX reverse-mode inhibitor, 2-[2-[4-(4-nitrobenzyloxy)phenyl]ethyl]isothiourea (KB-R7943), partially inhibited the initial increase in [Ca(2+)](i), and prevented a delayed increase in [Ca(2+)](i). In parallel, overactivation of AMPA receptors strongly activated calpains and led to the proteolysis of NCX3. KB-R7943 prevented calpain activation, cleavage of NCX3 and was neuroprotective. Silencing of NCX3 reduced Ca(2+) uptake, calpain activation and was neuroprotective. Our data show for the first time that NCX reversal is an early event following AMPA receptor stimulation and is linked to the activation of calpains. Since calpain activation subsequently inactivates NCX, causing a secondary Ca(2+) entry, NCX may be viewed as a new suicide substrate operating in a Ca(2+)-dependent loop that triggers cell death and as a target for neuroprotection.     

Is calpain activity regulated by membranes and autolysis or by calcium and calpastatin?

Although the Ca(2+)-dependent proteinase (calpain) system has been found in every vertebrate cell that has been examined for its presence and has been detected in Drosophila and parasites, the physiological function(s) of this system remains unclear. Calpain activity has been associated with cleavages that alter regulation of various enzyme activities, with remodeling or disassembly of the cell cytoskeleton, and with cleavages of hormone receptors. The mechanism regulating activity of the calpain system in vivo also is unknown. It has been proposed that binding of the calpains to phospholipid in a cell membrane lowers the Ca2+ concentration, [Ca2+], required for the calpains to autolyze, and that autolysis converts an inactive proenzyme into an active protease. Recent studies, however, show that the calpains bind to specific proteins and not to phospholipids, and that binding to cell membranes does not affect the [Ca2+] required for autolysis. It seems likely that calpain activity is regulated by binding of Ca2+ to specific sites on the calpain molecule, with binding to each site eliciting a response (proteolytic activity, calpastatin binding, etc.) specific for that site. Regulation must also involve an, as yet, undiscovered mechanism that increases the affinity of the Ca(2+)-binding sites for Ca2+.     

Trigonella foenum graecum seed powder protects against histopathological abnormalities in tissues of diabetic rats

Premature visual impairment due to lens opacification is a debilitating characteristic of untreated diabetes. Lens opacification is primarily due to the insolubilization of crystallins, proteins essential for lens optical properties, and recent studies have suggested that a major cause of this insolubilization may be the unregulated proteolysis of crystallins by calpains. These are intracellular cysteine proteases whose activation requires the presence of calcium (Ca2+) and elevated levels of lens Ca2+ is a condition associated with both diabetic cataractogenesis and other forms of the disorder. A number of calpains have been identified in the lens, including calpain 2, calpain 10 and two isozymes of calpain 3: Lp82 and Lp85. The use of animal hereditary cataract models have suggested that calpain 2 and/or Lp82 may be the major calpains involved in murine cataractogenesis with contributions from calpain 10 and Lp85. However, calpain 2 appears to be the major calpain involved in murine diabetic cataractogenesis and the strongest candidate of the calpains for a role in human types of cataractogenesis. Here, we present an overview of recent evidence on which these observations are based with an emphasis on the ability of calpains to proteolyse lens crystallins and calpain structural features, which appear to be involved in the Ca2+-mediated activation of these enzymes.     

Stimulation of beta-amyloid precursor protein alpha-processing by phorbol ester involves calcium and calpain activation

Normal processing of Alzheimer's beta-amyloid precursor protein (APP) is markedly stimulated by phorbol esters, but the underlying mechanisms have yet to be fully understood. In this study, we observed that: (a) Phorbol 12,13-dibutyrate (PDBu)-stimulated APP secretion in cultured SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma and fibroblast cells was blocked by EGTA and calpain inhibitors in a concentration-dependent manner, but not by other protease inhibitors. (b) Secretion of fibronectin, another secretory protein tested for comparison, was enhanced by PDBu, but insensitive to calpain inhibitors. (c) PDBu stimulated intracellular calpain activity as measured by the hydrolysis of a fluorogenic calpain substrate. (d) PDBu also induced rapid proteolysis of two endogenous substrates of calpains, i.e., tau and microtubule-associated protein-2 (MAP-2) and the proteolysis was blocked by EGTA and calpain inhibitors. Taken together, these results suggest that stimulation of APP alpha-processing by PDBu is through a mechanism that involves the activation of Ca(2+) and, most notably, calpain. The implications of the findings are discussed in relation to the regulatory mechanism of APP alpha-processing.     

Domain II of m-calpain is a Ca(2+)-dependent cysteine protease

Calpain, a Ca(2+)-dependent cytosolic cysteine protease, proteolytically modulates specific substrates involved in Ca(2+)-mediated intracellular events, such as signal transduction, cell cycle, differentiation, and apoptosis. The 3D structure of m-calpain, in the absence of Ca(2+), revealed that the two subdomains (domains IIa and IIb) of the protease domain (II) have an 'open' conformation, probably due to interactions with other domains. Although the presence of an EF-hand structure was once predicted in the protease domain, no explicit Ca(2+)-binding structure was identified in the 3D structure. Therefore, it is predicted that if the protease domain is excised from the calpain molecule, it will have a Ca(2+)-independent protease activity. In this study, we have characterized a truncated human m-calpain that consists of only the protease domain. Unexpectedly, the proteolytic activity was Ca(2+)-dependent, very weak, and not effectively inhibited by calpastatin, a calpain inhibitor. Ca(2+)-dependent modification of the protease domain by the cysteine protease inhibitor, E-64c, was clearly observed as a SDS-PAGE migration change, indicating that the conformational changes of this domain are a result of Ca(2+) binding. These results suggest that the Ca(2+) binding to domain II, as well as to domains III, IV, and VI, is critical in the process of complete activation of calpain.     

The intriguing Ca2+ requirement of calpain activation

Mammalian ubiquitous micro- and m-calpains, as well as their Drosophila homologs, Calpain A and Calpain B, are Ca(2+)-activated cytoplasmic proteases that act by limited proteolysis of target proteins. Calpains are thought to be part of many cellular signaling pathways. These enzymes, however, require such high Ca(2+) concentration for half-maximal activation in vitro, [Ca(2+)](0.5), that hardly ever occurs in intact cells. This major dilemma has pervaded the literature on calpains for decades. In this paper several considerations are put forward that challenge the orthodox view and envisage mechanisms that may govern calpain action in vivo. The "unphysiologically" high Ca(2+) demand for activation may turn out to be an evolutionarily adjusted safety device.     

Crystal structure of calpain reveals the structural basis for Ca(2+)-dependent protease activity and a novel mode of enzyme activation

The combination of thiol protease activity and calmodulin-like EF-hands is a feature unique to the calpains. The regulatory mechanisms governing calpain activity are complex, and the nature of the Ca(2+)-induced switch between inactive and active forms has remained elusive in the absence of structural information. We describe here the 2.6 A crystal structure of m-calpain in the Ca(2+)-free form, which illustrates the structural basis for the inactivity of calpain in the absence of Ca(2+). It also reveals an unusual thiol protease fold, which is associated with Ca(2+)-binding domains through heterodimerization and a C(2)-like beta-sandwich domain. Strikingly, the structure shows that the catalytic triad is not assembled, indicating that Ca(2+)-binding must induce conformational changes that re-orient the protease domains to form a functional active site. The alpha-helical N-terminal anchor of the catalytic subunit does not occupy the active site but inhibits its assembly and regulates Ca(2+)-sensitivity through association with the regulatory subunit. This Ca(2+)-dependent activation mechanism is clearly distinct from those of classical proteases.     

Association of calpastatin with inactive calpain: a novel mechanism to control the activation of the protease?

It is generally accepted that the Ca(2+)-dependent interaction of calpain with calpastatin is the most relevant mechanism involved in the regulation of Ca(2+)-induced proteolysis. We now report that a calpain-calpastatin association can occur also in the absence of Ca(2+) or at very low Ca(2+) concentrations, reflecting the physiological conditions under which calpain retains its inactive conformational state. The calpastatin binding region is localized in the non-inhibitory L-domain containing the amino acid sequences encoded by exons 4-7. This calpastatin region recognizes a calpain sequence located near the end of the DII-domain. Interaction of calpain with calpastatins lacking these sequences becomes strictly Ca(2+)-dependent because, under these conditions, the transition to an active state of the protease is an obligatory requirement. The occurrence of the molecular association between Ca(2+)-free calpain and various recombinant calpastatin forms has been demonstrated by the following experimental results. Addition of calpastatin protected calpain from trypsin digestion. Calpain was coprecipitated when calpastatin was immunoprecipitated. The calpastatin molecular size increased following exposure to calpain. The two proteins comigrated in zymogram analysis. Furthermore, calpain-calpastatin interaction was perturbed by protein kinase C phosphorylation occurring at sites located at the exons involved in the association. At a functional level, calpain-calpastatin interaction at a physiological concentration of Ca(2+) represents a novel mechanism for the control of the amount of the active form of the protease potentially generated in response to an intracellular Ca(2+) influx.     

Action of calpain on the basic estrogen receptor molecule of porcine uterus

Basic estrogen receptor (ER) molecule (vero-ER) of the cytosol of porcine uterus was purified 1,200-fold after successive chromatographies on phenyl-Sepharose, hydroxylapatite, and DEAE-cellulose, followed by Sephadex G-150 gel filtration. The purified vero-ER was completely free from endogenous protease and ER-binding factor. The action of Ca2+-dependent cysteine proteinase (calpain) on vero-ER was studied by utilizing the purified receptor and calpains from porcine uterus (endogenous calpain), porcine kidney, and human erythrocytes. Proteolysis of vero-ER was followed by monitoring the disappearance of the binding capability of vero-ER with "8S" ER-forming factor. Vero-ER was proteolyzed by both the endogenous and the exogenous calpains in the presence of Ca2+. The calpains did not attack vero-ER in the absence of Ca2+. The results indicated the absolute requirement by calpain for Ca2+ for the limited hydrolysis of vero-ER. Uterine cytosol was shown to contain, in parallel with calpain, a protease which does not require Ca2+ for the limited proteolysis of vero-ER. The strongly hydrophobic domain of vero-ER, recently shown to be indispensable for the nuclear translocation of vero-ER (Murayama, A. & Fukai, F. (1983) FEBS Lett. 158, 255), was preferentially destroyed by both the Ca2+-requiring and -nonrequiring enzymes. It was assumed that calpain might intervene in the estrogen action by diminishing irreversibly the amount of the cytoplasmic ER capable of translocating into the nucleus.     

Evolutionary and physical linkage between calpains and penta-EF-hand Ca2+-binding proteins

The name calpain was historically given to a protease that is activated by Ca(2+) and whose primary structure contains a Ca(2+)-binding penta-EF-hand (PEF) as well as a calpain cysteine protease (CysPc) domain and a C2-domain-like (C2L) domain. In the human genome, CysPc domains are found in 15 genes, but only nine of them encode PEF domains. Fungi and budding yeasts have calpain-like sequences that lack the PEF domain, and each protein (designated PalB and Rim13, respectively) is orthologous to human calpain-7, indicating that the calpain-7 orthologs are evolutionarily more conserved than classical calpains possessing PEF domains. An N-terminal region of calpain-7 has a tandem repeat of microtubule-interacting and transport domains that interact with a subset of endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) III proteins. In addition to calpains, PEF domains are found in other Ca(2+)-binding proteins including ALG-2 that associates with ALIX (an ESCRT-III accessory protein) and TSG101 (an ESCRT-I subunit). Phylogenetic comparison of dissected domain structures of calpains and experimentally confirmed protein-protein interaction networks imply that there is an evolutionary and physical linkage between mammalian calpains and PEF proteins involving the ESCRT system.     

Calpains: targets of cataract prevention?

There is emerging evidence to suggest that the unregulated Ca(2+)-mediated proteolysis of essential lens proteins by calpains might be a major contributor to some forms of cataract in both animals and humans. Moreover, recently solved calpain structures have revealed molecular-level details of the activation mechanism used by these proteases, enabling the structure-based design of potent calpain inhibitors with the potential to act as anti-cataract agents. These agents offer the first real hope of an urgently needed alternative to the surgical treatment of at least some forms of cataract and relief from a life-depreciating condition on a global scale.     

The importance of conserved amino acid residues in p94 protease sub-domain IIb and the IS2 region for constitutive autolysis

p94/calpain 3, a skeletal muscle-specific member of calpain protease family, is characterized by apparent Ca(2+)-independence during exhaustive autolysis and concomitant proteolysis of non-self substrates. The purpose of our study was to comprehensively profile the structural basis of p94 enabling activation in the cytosol without an extra Ca(2+). Ca(2+)-dependent p94 mutants were screened using "p94-trapping", which is an application of yeast genetic reporter system called "proteinase-trapping". Several amino acids were revealed as critical for apparent Ca(2+)-independent p94 activity. These results highlight the importance of conserved amino acids in domain IIb as well as in the p94-specific IS2 region.     

Quantitation of tissue calpain activity after isolation by hydrophobic chromatography

A rapid and reliable method for quantitating tissue calpains (Ca2+-activated, neutral, thiol proteases) was developed using hydrophobic chromatography with phenyl-Sepharose. Calpains I and II isolated by this method are free of endogenous inhibitor(s) (calpastatin), activator(s), and nonspecific proteases. These calpains expose hydrophobic regions in the presence of Ca2+ and bind tightly to phenyl-Sepharose. Inactivation of bound calpain is prevented by the addition of leupeptin (20 microM). Calpains I and II bound initially by phenyl-Sepharose in a Ca2+-dependent manner are then eluted successively on the basis of their Ca2+-independent binding to phenyl-Sepharose. Because calpastatin may prevent binding of calpain to phenyl-Sepharose by forming a protease-inhibitor complex in the presence of Ca2+, preadsorbing the protease to a suspension of phenyl-Sepharose beads initially in the absence of Ca2+ separates most of the calpain present in tissue extracts from calpastatin. The isolated calpains obtained are assayed by casein digestion. This quantitation procedure is suitable for measuring calpain activity in various tissues and cells including erythrocytes.     

Hydrophobic association of calpains with subcellular organelles. Compartmentalization of calpains and the endogenous inhibitor calpastatin in tissues

Calpains I and II isolated from diverse tissues possess both Ca2+-independent, and Ca2+-dependent accessible hydrophobic regions. Possible subcellular organelle association of calpains involving these hydrophobic regions was studied. By homogenizing rat tissues directly in Ca2+ (50 microM), about 30-60% of the cytosolic calpain I and II activity reversibly associated with isolated subcellular fractions (microsomal greater than plasma membrane greater than nuclear). After binding to the particulate fraction, calpain II converted to a calpain I-like form exhibiting stronger Ca2+-independent binding to phenyl-Sepharose and a lower Ca2+ requirement for optimal activity. However, it retained its DEAE-cellulose chromatographic pattern, and precipitated with monospecific anti-calpain II antibodies. Although purified calpastatin (endogenous inhibitor) is known to form a Ca2+-dependent complex with calpains, it was not able to reverse the binding of calpains to the particulate fraction upon short incubation. It was, however, effective in blocking calpain binding when the isolated cytosolic fraction or a mixture of purified calpain and calpastatin was preincubated in the presence of Ca2+, and then added to the particulate fraction. Extraction of tissues under controlled conditions revealed that in fact calpains are already loosely associated with subcellular organelles even in the absence of Ca2+. This is the reason why in the crude homogenates with the addition of Ca2+, calpains strongly bind to the particulate fraction without interference by cytosolic calpastatin. Although calpastatin by complexing initially to calpain can prevent the association of this protease with subcellular organelles, it cannot dissociate calpains already bound to these subcellular fractions. By prior Ca2+-independent association with the hydrophobic proteins present in the subcellular fractions, calpains overcome the 3- to 30-fold inhibitory excess of calpastatin in tissues.     

Calpain activation by cooperative Ca2+ binding at two non-EF-hand sites

The active site residues in calpain are mis-aligned in the apo, Ca(2+)-free form. Alignment for catalysis requires binding of Ca2+ to two non-EF-hand sites, one in each of the core domains I and II. Using domain swap constructs between the protease cores of the mu and m isoforms (which have different Ca2+ requirements) and structural and biochemical characterization of site-directed mutants, we have deduced the order of Ca2+ binding and the basis of the cooperativity between the two sites. Ca2+ binds first to the partially preformed site in domain I. Knockout of this site through D106A substitution eliminates binding to this domain as shown by the crystal structure of D106A muI-II. However, at elevated Ca2+ concentrations this mutant still forms the double salt bridge that links the two Ca2+ sites and becomes nearly as active as muI-II. Elimination of the bridge in E333A muI-II has a more drastic effect on enzyme action, especially at low Ca2+ concentrations. Domain II Ca2+ binding appears essential, because Ca(2+)-coordinating side-chain mutants E302R and D333A have severely impaired muI-II activation and activity. The introduction of mutations into the whole heterodimeric enzyme that eliminate the salt bridge or Ca2+ binding to domain II produce similar phenotypes, suggesting that the protease core Ca2+ switch is crucial and cannot be overridden by Ca2+ binding to other domains.     

Activation of m-calpain is required for chromosome alignment on the metaphase plate during mitosis

Calpains form a superfamily of Ca(2+)-dependent intracellular cysteine proteases with various isoforms. Two isoforms, micro- and m-calpains, are ubiquitously expressed and known as conventional calpains. It has been previously shown that the mammalian calpains are activated during mitosis by transient increases in cytosolic Ca(2+) concentration. However, it is still unknown whether the activation of calpains contributes to particular events in mitosis. With the use of RNA interference (RNAi), we investigated the roles of calpains in mitosis. Cells reduced the levels of m-calpain, but not mu-calpain, arrested at prometaphase and failed to align their chromosomes at the spindle equator. Specific peptidyl calpain inhibitors also induced aberrant mitosis with chromosome misalignment. Although both m-calpain RNAi and calpain inhibitors affected neither the separation of centrosomes nor the assembly of bipolar spindles, Mad2 was detected on the kinetochores of the misaligned chromosomes, indicating that the prometaphase arrest induced by calpain inhibition is due to activation of the spindle assembly checkpoint. Furthermore, when calpain activity was inhibited in cells having monopolar spindles, chromosomes were clustered adjacent to the centrosome, suggesting that calpain activity is involved in a polar ejection force for metaphase alignment of chromosomes. Based on these findings, we propose that activation of m-calpain during mitosis is required for cells to establish the chromosome alignment by regulating some molecules that generate polar ejection force.     

SNARE protein degradation upon platelet activation: calpain cleaves SNAP-23

In order to better understand the molecular mechanisms of platelet granule secretion, we evaluated the effect of activation-induced degranulation on three functional platelet SNARE proteins, SNAP-23, VAMP-3, and syntaxin 4. Initial studies showed that SNAP-23 is lost upon SFLLRN-induced platelet activation. Experiments with permeabilized platelets demonstrated that proteolysis of SNAP-23 was Ca(2+)-dependent. Ca(2+)-dependent proteolysis of SNAP-23 was inhibited by the cell-permeable calpain inhibitors, calpeptin and E-64d, as well as by the naturally occurring calpain inhibitor, calpastatin. In addition, purified calpain cleaved SNAP-23 in permeabilized platelets in a dose-dependent manner. In intact platelets, calpeptin prevented SFLLRN-induced degradation of SNAP-23. In contrast, calpeptin did not prevent SFLLRN-induced degradation of VAMP-3 and syntaxin 4 did not undergo substantial proteolysis following platelet activation. Calpain-induced cleavage of SNAP-23 was a late event occurring between 2.5 and 5 min following exposure of permeabilized platelets to Ca(2+). Experiments evaluating platelet alpha-granule secretion demonstrated that incubation of permeabilized platelets with 10 microM Ca(2+) prior to exposure to ATP inhibited ATP-dependent alpha-granule secretion from permeabilized platelets. SNAP-23 was cleaved under these conditions. Incubation of permeabilized platelets with either calpeptin or calpastatin prevented Ca(2+)-mediated degradation of SNAP-23 and reversed Ca(2+)-mediated inhibition of ATP-dependent alpha-granule secretion. Thus, activation of calpain prior to secretion results in loss of SNAP-23 and inhibits alpha-granule secretion. These studies suggest a mechanism whereby calpain activation serves to localize platelet secretion to areas of thrombus formation.     

m-Calpain activation in vitro does not require autolysis or subunit dissociation

Calpains are Ca(2+)-dependent, intracellular cysteine proteases involved in many physiological functions. How calpains are activated in the cell is unknown because the average intracellular concentration of Ca(2+) is orders of magnitude lower than that needed for half-maximal activation of the enzyme in vitro. Two of the proposed mechanisms by which calpains can overcome this Ca(2+) concentration differential are autoproteolysis (autolysis) and subunit dissociation, both of which could release constraints on the core by breaking the link between the anchor helix and the small subunit to allow the active site to form. By measuring the rate of autolysis at different sites in calpain, we show that while the anchor helix is one of the first targets to be cut, this occurs in the same time-frame as several potentially inactivating cleavages in Domain III. Thus autolytic activation would overlap with inactivation. We also show that the small subunit does not dissociate from the large subunit, but is proteolyzed to a 40-45k heterodimer of Domains IV and VI. It is likely that this autolysis-generated heterodimer has previously been misidentified as the small subunit homodimer produced by subunit dissociation. We propose a model for m-calpain activation that does not involve either autolysis or subunit dissociation.