The strengths and limitations of using biolayer interferometry to monitor equilibrium titrations of biomolecules

Every method used to quantify biomolecular interactions has its own strengths and limitations. To quantify protein‐DNA binding affinities, nitrocellulose filter binding assays with ³²P‐labeled DNA quantify K_d values from 10^?12 to 10^?8 M but have several technical limitations. Here, we considered the suitability of biolayer interferometry (BLI), which monitors association and dissociation of a soluble macromolecule to an immobilized species; the ratio k_off/k_on determines K_d. However, for lactose repressor protein (LacI) and an engineered repressor protein (“LLhF”) binding immobilized DNA, complicated kinetic curves precluded this analysis. Thus, we determined whether the amplitude of the BLI signal at equilibrium related linearly to the fraction of protein bound to DNA. A key question was the effective concentration of immobilized DNA. Equilibrium titration experiments with DNA concentrations below K_d (equilibrium binding regime) must be analyzed differently than those with DNA near or above K_d (stoichiometric binding regime). For ForteBio streptavidin tips, the most frequent effective DNA concentration was ~2 × 10^?9 M. Although variation occurred among different lots of sensor tips, binding events with K_d ≥ 10^?8 M should reliably be in the equilibrium binding regime. We also observed effects from multi‐valent interactions: Tetrameric LacI bound two immobilized DNAs whereas dimeric LLhF did not. We next used BLI to quantify the amount of inducer sugars required to allosterically diminish protein‐DNA binding and to assess the affinity of fructose‐1‐kinase for the DNA‐LLhF complex. Overall, when experimental design corresponded with appropriate data interpretation, BLI was convenient and reliable for monitoring equilibrium titrations and thereby quantifying a variety of binding interactions.     

Interaction investigations of HipA binding to HipB dimer and HipB dimer + DNA complex: a molecular dynamics simulation study

We carried out molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations for a series of ternary and diplex models for the HipA protein, HipB dimer, and DNA molecule to address the mechanism of HipA sequestration and the binding order of events from apo HipB/HipA to 2HipA + HipB dimer + DNA complex. The results revealed that the combination of DNA with the HipB dimer is energetically favorable for the combination of HipB dimer with HipA protein. The binding of DNA to HipB dimer induces a long‐range allosteric communication from the HipB₂‐DNA interface to the HipA–HipB₂ interface, which involves the closeness of α1 helices of HipB dimer to HipA protein and formations of extra hydrogen bonds in the HipA–HipB₂ interface through the extension of α2/3 helices in the HipB dimer. These simulated results suggested that the DNA molecule, as a regulative media, modulates the HipB dimer conformation, consequently increasing the interactions of HipB dimer with the HipA proteins, which explains the mechanism of HipA sequestration reported by the previous experiment. Simultaneously, these simulations also explored that the thermodynamic binding order in a simulated physiological environment, that is, the HipB dimer first bind to DNA to form HipB dimer + DNA complex, then capturing strongly the HipA proteins to form a ternary complex, 2HipA + HipB dimer + DNA, for sequestrating HipA in the nucleoid. Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Different combinations of atomic interactions predict protein‐small molecule and protein‐DNA/RNA affinities with similar accuracy

Interactions between proteins and other molecules play essential roles in all biological processes. Although it is widely held that a protein's ligand specificity is determined primarily by its three‐dimensional structure, the general principles by which structure determines ligand binding remain poorly understood. Here we use statistical analyses of a large number of protein?ligand complexes with associated binding‐affinity measurements to quantitatively characterize how combinations of atomic interactions contribute to ligand affinity. We find that there are significant differences in how atomic interactions determine ligand affinity for proteins that bind small chemical ligands, those that bind DNA/RNA and those that interact with other proteins. Although protein‐small molecule and protein‐DNA/RNA binding affinities can be accurately predicted from structural data, models predicting one type of interaction perform poorly on the others. Additionally, the particular combinations of atomic interactions required to predict binding affinity differed between small‐molecule and DNA/RNA data sets, consistent with the conclusion that the structural bases determining ligand affinity differ among interaction types. In contrast to what we observed for small‐molecule and DNA/RNA interactions, no statistical models were capable of predicting protein?protein affinity with >60% correlation. We demonstrate the potential usefulness of protein‐DNA/RNA binding prediction as a possible tool for high‐throughput virtual screening to guide laboratory investigations, suggesting that quantitative characterization of diverse molecular interactions may have practical applications as well as fundamentally advancing our understanding of how molecular structure translates into function. Proteins 2015; 83:2100–2114. © 2015 The Authors. Proteins: Structure, Function, and Bioinformatics Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Lactoferrin Is the Major Deoxyribonuclease of Human Milk

Lactoferrin is the major iron-transferring protein of human barrier fluids such as blood and milk. It is a polyfunctional protein capable of binding DNA exposed on the surface of various cells. Electrophoretically homogenous lactoferrin was prepared by sequential chromatography of human milk proteins on DEAE-cellulose, heparin-Sepharose, and Sepharose containing immobilized anti-lactoferrin antibodies. By subsequent chromatography on Blue Sepharose the resulting lactoferrin was fractionated into several subfractions with different affinity for the sorbent, and this was associated with separation of additional lactoferrin peaks with DNase activity from the main peak. By various techniques, in particular, by in situ testing the DNase activity of lactoferrin in a DNA-containing gel after SDS-electrophoresis, hydrolysis of DNA was for the first time shown to be an intrinsic property of lactoferrin. The substrate specificity of lactoferrin in hydrolysis of DNA was different from specificities of known human DNases. Hydrolysis of DNA was activated by bivalent metal ions and also by ATP and NAD. Unlike the main fraction of lactoferrin with the highest affinity for Blue Sepharose, all protein subfractions with DNase activity were cytotoxic and suppressed growth of human and mouse tumor cell lines.     

R-state haemoglobin with low oxygen affinity: crystal structures of deoxy human and carbonmonoxy horse haemoglobin bound to the effector molecule L35

Although detailed crystal structures of haemoglobin (Hb) provide a clear understanding of the basic allosteric mechanism of the protein, and how this in turn controls oxygen affinity, recent experiments with artificial effector molecules have shown a far greater control of oxygen binding than with natural heterotropic effectors. Contrary to the established text-book view, these non-physiological compounds are able to reduce oxygen affinity very strongly without switching the protein to the T (tense) state. In an earlier paper we showed that bezafibrate (BZF) binds to a surface pocket on the alpha subunits of R state Hb, strongly reducing the oxygen affinity of this protein conformation. Here we report the crystallisation of Hb with L35, a related compound, and show that this binds to the central cavity of both R and T state Hb. The mechanism by which L35 reduces oxygen affinity is discussed, in relation to spectroscopic studies of effector binding.     

Identification of centromeric and telomeric DNA‐binding proteins in rice

Centromeres and telomeres are DNA/protein complexes and essential functional components of eukaryotic chromosomes. Previous studies have shown that rice centromeres and telomeres are occupied by CentO (rice centromere satellite DNA) satellite and G‐rich telomere repeats, respectively. However, the protein components are not fully understood. DNA‐binding proteins associated with centromeric or telomeric DNAs will most likely be important for the understanding of centromere and telomere structure and functions. To capture DNA‐specific binding proteins, affinity pull‐down technique was applied in this study to isolate rice centromeric and telomeric DNA‐binding proteins. Fifty‐five proteins were identified for their binding affinity to rice CentO repeat, and 80 proteins were identified for their binding to telomere repeat. One CentO‐binding protein, Os02g0288200, was demonstrated to bind to CentO specifically by in vitro assay. A conserved domain, DUF573 with unknown functions was identified in this protein, and proven to be responsible for the specific binding to CentO in vitro. Four proteins identified as telomere DNA‐binding proteins in this study were reported by different groups previously. These results demonstrate that DNA affinity pull‐down technique is effective in the isolation of sequence‐specific binding proteins and will be applicable in future studies of centromere and telomere proteins.     

On the molecular basis of the high affinity binding of basic amino acids to LAOBP,a periplasmic binding protein from Salmonella typhimurium

The rational designing of binding abilities in proteins requires an understanding of the relationship between structure and thermodynamics. However, our knowledge of the molecular origin of high‐affinity binding of ligands to proteins is still limited; such is the case for l ‐lysine–l ‐arginine–l ‐ornithine periplasmic binding protein (LAOBP), a periplasmic binding protein from Salmonella typhimurium that binds to l ‐arginine, l ‐lysine, and l ‐ornithine with nanomolar affinity and to l ‐histidine with micromolar affinity. Structural studies indicate that ligand binding induces a large conformational change in LAOBP. In this work, we studied the thermodynamics of l ‐histidine and l ‐arginine binding to LAOBP by isothermal titration calorimetry. For both ligands, the affinity is enthalpically driven, with a binding ΔCp of ~?300 cal mol^?1 K^?1, most of which arises from the burial of protein nonpolar surfaces that accompanies the conformational change. Osmotic stress measurements revealed that several water molecules become sequestered upon complex formation. In addition, LAOBP prefers positively charged ligands in their side chain. An energetic analysis shows that the protein acquires a thermodynamically equivalent state with both ligands. The 1000‐fold higher affinity of LAOBP for l ‐arginine as compared with l ‐histidine is mainly of enthalpic origin and can be ascribed to the formation of an extra pair of hydrogen bonds. Periplasmic binding proteins have evolved diverse energetic strategies for ligand recognition. STM4351, another arginine binding protein from Salmonella, shows an entropy‐driven micromolar affinity toward l ‐arginine. In contrast, our data show that LAOBP achieves nanomolar affinity for the same ligand through enthalpy optimization. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Cell‐free protein synthesis and purification of human dopamine D2 receptor long isoform

The human dopamine D2 receptor long isoform (D2L) has significant implications in neurological and neuropsychiatric disorders such as Parkinson's disease and schizophrenia. Detailed structural knowledge of this receptor is limited owing to its highly hydrophobic nature, which leads to protein aggregation and host toxicity when expressed in cellular systems. The newly emerging field of cell‐free protein expression presents numerous advantages to overcome these challenges. This system utilizes protein synthesis machinery and exogenous DNA to synthesize functional proteins outside of intact cells. This study utilizes two different cell‐free systems for the synthesis of human dopamine D2L receptor. These include the Escherichia coli lysate‐based system and the wheat‐germ lysate‐based system. The bacterial cell‐free method used pET 100/D‐TOPO vector to synthesize hexa‐histidine‐tagged D2L receptor using a dialysis bag system; the resulting protein was purified using nickel‐nitrilotriacetic acid affinity resin. The wheat germ system used pEU–glutathione‐S‐transferase (GST) vector to synthesize GST‐tagged D2L receptor using a bilayer translation method; the resulting protein was purified using a GST affinity resin. The presence and binding capacity of the synthesized D2L receptor was confirmed by immunoblotting and radioligand competition assays, respectively. Additionally, in‐gel protein sequencing via Nano LC‐MS/MS was used to confirm protein synthesis via the wheat germ system. The results showed both systems to synthesize microgram quantities of the receptor. Improved expression of this highly challenging protein can improve research and understanding of the human dopamine D2L receptor. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:601–608, 2013     

The hRad51 and RecA proteins show significant differences in cooperative binding to single-stranded DNA.

The human Rad51 protein (hRad51), like its bacterial homologue RecA, catalyzes genetic recombination between homologous single and double-stranded DNA substrates. Using IAsys biosensor technology, we have examined the critical first step in this process, the binding of hRad51 and RecA to ssDNA. We show that hRad51 binds cooperatively and with high affinity to an oligonucleotide substrate in both the absence and presence of nucleotide cofactors. In fact, both ATP and ATPgammaS have a slight inhibitory effect on hRad51 binding affinity. We show that this results from a decrease in the intrinsic affinity of a given monomer for ssDNA, which is counterbalanced by an increase in the cooperative assembly of protein onto DNA. In contrast, we show that the dramatic NTP-induced increase in ssDNA binding affinity of RecA is accounted for by a significant increase in cooperative filament assembly and not by an increase in the intrinsic DNA binding affinity of monomeric RecA. These results demonstrate that although the hRad51 and RecA proteins display many structural and functional similarities, they show profound inherent mechanistic differences.     

RNA/DNA hybrid binding affinity determines telomerase template-translocation efficiency

Telomerase synthesizes telomeric DNA repeats onto chromosome termini from an intrinsic RNA template. The processive synthesis of DNA repeats relies on a unique, yet poorly understood, mechanism whereby the telomerase RNA template translocates and realigns with the DNA primer after synthesizing each repeat. Here, we provide evidence that binding of the realigned RNA/DNA hybrid by the active site is an essential step for template translocation. Employing a template-free human telomerase system, we demonstrate that the telomerase active site directly binds to RNA/DNA hybrid substrates for DNA polymerization. In telomerase processivity mutants, the template-translocation efficiency correlates with the affinity for the RNA/DNA hybrid substrate. Furthermore, the active site is unoccupied during template translocation as a 5 bp extrinsic RNA/DNA hybrid effectively reduces the processivity of the template-containing telomerase. This suggests that strand separation and template realignment occur outside the active site, preceding the binding of realigned hybrid to the active site. Our results provide new insights into the ancient RNA/DNA hybrid binding ability of telomerase and its role in template translocation.     

NMR studies of an immunomodulatory benzodiazepine binding to its molecular target on the mitochondrial F1F0‐ATPase

Bz‐423 is an inhibitor of the mitochondrial F₁F₀‐ATPase, with therapeutic properties in murine models of immune diseases. Here, we study the binding of a water‐soluble Bz‐423 analog (5‐(3‐(aminomethyl)phenyl)‐7‐chloro‐ 1‐methyl‐3‐(naphthalen‐2‐ylmethyl)‐1H‐benzo][e][1,4]diazepin‐2(3H)‐one); (1) to its target subunit on the enzyme, the oligomycin sensitivity conferring protein (OSCP), by NMR spectroscopy using chemical shift perturbation and cross‐relaxation experiments. Titration experiments with constructs representing residues 1–120 or 1–145 of the OSCP reveals that (a) 1 binds to a region of the protein, at the minimum, comprising residues M51, L56, K65, V66, K75, K77, and N92, and (b) binding of 1 induces conformational changes in the OSCP. Control experiments employing a variant of 1 in which a key binding element on the small molecule was deleted; it had no perturbational effect on the spectra of the OSCP, which indicates that the observed changes with 1 represent specific binding interactions. Collectively, these data suggest that 1 might inhibit the enzyme through an allosteric mechanism where binding results in conformational changes that perturb the OSCP‐F₁ interface resulting in disrupted communication between the peripheral stalk and the F₁‐domain of the enzyme. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 29: 85–92, 2010. This article was originally published online as an accepted preprint. The “Published Online” date corresponds to the preprint version. You can request a copy of the preprint by emailing the Biopolymers editorial office at biopolymers@wiley.com     

Mechanical properties of BiP protein determined by nano‐rheology

Immunoglobulin Binding Protein (BiP) is a chaperone and molecular motor belonging to the Hsp70 family, involved in the regulation of important biological processes such as synthesis, folding and translocation of proteins in the Endoplasmic Reticulum. BiP has two highly conserved domains: the N‐terminal Nucleotide‐Binding Domain (NBD), and the C‐terminal Substrate‐Binding Domain (SBD), connected by a hydrophobic linker. ATP binds and it is hydrolyzed to ADP in the NBD, and BiP's extended polypeptide substrates bind in the SBD. Like many molecular motors, BiP function depends on both structural and catalytic properties that may contribute to its performance. One novel approach to study the mechanical properties of BiP considers exploring the changes in the viscoelastic behavior upon ligand binding, using a technique called nano‐rheology. This technique is essentially a traditional rheology experiment, in which an oscillatory force is directly applied to the protein under study, and the resulting average deformation is measured. Our results show that the folded state of the protein behaves like a viscoelastic material, getting softer when it binds nucleotides‐ ATP, ADP, and AMP‐PNP‐, but stiffer when binding HTFPAVL peptide substrate. Also, we observed that peptide binding dramatically increases the affinity for ADP, decreasing it dissociation constant (K_D) around 1000 times, demonstrating allosteric coupling between SBD and NBD domains.     

The 33 kDa protein can be removed without affecting the association of the 23 and 17 kDa proteins with the luminal side of PS II of spinach

An earlier study shows that a 30 min incubation of spinach PS II submembrane fragments at pH 6.3 in the presence of 10 microM HgCl(2) induces a 40% depletion of the 33 kDa protein without the apparent release of the 17 and 23 kDa proteins [Bernier, M., and Carpentier, R. (1995) FEBS Lett. 360, 251-254]. Here we report that the photosystem II 33 kDa extrinsic protein is fully removed by HgCl(2) added at micromolar and higher concentrations (0.25, 20, and 50 microM), with the 17 and 23 kDa extrinsic proteins and other intrinsic proteins remaining bound to the reaction center. The data presented here put in doubt the "regulatory cap" model of PS II, which follows the OEC-33 kDa-23 kDa-17 kDa binding order, as these results directly demonstrate that the 33 kDa protein can be removed without affecting the binding of the 23 and 17 kDa proteins to the intrinsic subunits of PS II. This suggests that each extrinsic protein may possess its own binding site on PS II. A possible mechanism for HgCl(2) upon the release of the 33 kDa protein is discussed.     

Molecular effects of copper on the reproductive system of mytilus galloprovincialis

This study aims to assess the effects induced by 24 hr exposure to a subtoxic copper concentration on the reproductive system (gonads, spermatozoa, and protamine‐like [PL] proteins) of Mytilus galloprovincialis. Inductively coupled plasma–mass spectrometry indicated accumulation of this metal in gonads, spermatozoa, and PL proteins of exposed mussels. Further, real‐time polymerase chain reaction analyses showed altered expression levels of mt10 and PL proteins genes in spermatozoa and gonads, respectively, of exposed mussels. Protamine‐like proteins, which represent the main basic component of sperm chromatin of this organism, showed a higher DNA binding affinity and a different DNA binding mode in exposed mussels. Moreover, an increased amount of NaCl was required for the release from sperm nuclei of PL‐III, the main PL protein component. Finally, PL proteins extracted from exposed mussels promoted DNA oxidative damage in the presence of H ₂O _2. These results demonstrate that the tolerable copper amount could also affect the properties of PL proteins and determine the negative effects on the reproductive system of this organism. These analyses could be useful to develop quick and efficient chromatin‐based genotoxicity tests for pollution biomonitoring programs.     

Influence of the N-terminal domain and divalent cations on self-association and DNA binding by the Saccharomyces cerevisiae TATA binding protein

The localization of a single tryptophan to the N-terminal domain and six tyrosines to the C-terminal domain of TBP allows intrinsic fluorescence to separately report on the structures and dynamics of the full-length TATA binding protein (TBP) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and its C-terminal DNA binding domain (TBPc) as a function of self-association and DNA binding. TBPc is more compact than the C-terminal domain within the full-length protein. Quenching of the intrinsic fluorescence by DNA and external dynamic quenchers shows that the observed tyrosine fluorescence is due to the four residues surrounding the "DNA binding saddle" of the C-terminal domain. TBP's N-terminal domain unfolds and changes its position relative to the C-terminal domain upon DNA binding. It partially shields the DNA binding saddle in octameric TBP, shifting upon dissociation to monomers to expose the saddle to DNA. Structure-energetic correlations were obtained by comparing the contribution that electrostatic interactions make to DNA binding by TBP and TBPc; DNA binding by TBPc is more hydrophobic than that by TBP, suggesting that the N-terminal domain either interacts with bound DNA directly or screens a part of the C-terminal domain, diminishing its electronegativity. The competition between divalent cations, K+, and DNA is not straightforward. Divalent cations strengthen binding of TBP to DNA and do so more strongly for TBPc. We suggest that divalent cations affect the structure of the bound DNA perhaps by stabilizing its distorted conformation in complexes with TBPc and TBP and that the N-terminal domain mimics the effects of divalent cations. These data support an autoinhibitory mechanism in which competition between the N-terminal domain and DNA for the saddle diminishes the DNA binding affinity of the full-length protein.