Bilateral cleft lip and nasal repair

SUMMARY: The bilateral cleft lip and nasal repair has remained a challenging endeavor. Techniques have evolved to address concerns over unsatisfactory features and stigmata of the surgery. The authors present an approach to this complex clinical problem that modifies traditional repairs described by Millard and Manchester. The senior author (H.S.B.) has developed this technique with over 25 years of surgical experience dealing with the bilateral cleft lip. This staged lip and nasal repair provides excellent nasal projection, lip function, and aesthetic outcomes. Lip repair is performed at 3 months of age. Columellar lengthening is performed at approximately 18 months of age. A key component of this repair focuses on reconstruction of the central tubercle. A triangular prolabial dry vermilion flap is augmented by lateral lip vermilion flaps that include the profundus muscle of the orbicularis oris. This minimizes lateral lip segment sacrifice and provides improved central vermilion fullness, which is often deficient in traditional repairs. The authors present the surgical technique and examples of their clinical results.     

Analysis of the lengthening effect of the muscle repair in functional cleft lip repair

In 14 patients undergoing functional cleft lip repair, changes in the lengths of the key lip segments were measured preoperatively, after the muscle layer was repaired, and after the skin was repaired using pieces of wire bent to follow the curves of the lip in three dimensions. The cleft side of the lip was shorter than the normal side in the vertical and horizontal dimensions. Freeing the muscle from its dermal insertions, splitting it, and advancing it into the medial side of the cleft lengthened the cleft side of the lip vertically and horizontally. The Z-plasty skin repair further lengthened the cleft side of the lip in the vertical dimension. The lengthening effect of the muscle repair appears to be the result of the loose skin redraping over the dissected muscle and further explains elimination of the orbicularis bulge and superior scar formation in the functional cleft lip repair.     

Experience with the functional cleft lip repair

The first 12 functional cleft lip repairs performed on unselected consecutive patients immediately following the completion of training by the author are presented. Previous reports on this cleft lip repair have shown excellent results but have always been based on patients operated on by the originator of the procedure. This report gives credence to the ease with which a cleft lip repair that gives reproducible good results can be taught and learned even by plastic surgeons with limited experience. It reviews the technical steps of the procedure, which emphasizes wide undermining and release of the orbicularis oris muscle on the lateral side of the cleft to allow redraping and lengthening of the lip skin, step-by-step layered closure of the mucosa, muscle, and skin, and further vertical lengthening of the lip with a Z-plasty skin closure. Three elements that are difficult to achieve or restore with cleft lip revision are evaluated: (1) achievement of a good skin scar, (2) maintenance of the alar-facial groove, and (3) achievement of adequate lip height without sacrificing horizontal lip length. Ten of the 12 patients had a satisfactory scar, 9 patients had a good alar-facial groove, and all patients had a normal-appearing horizontal lip length. Nine patients required secondary surgery; however, in six patients, this included correction of the nasal deformity that was not corrected at the time of cleft lip repair.     

Functional cleft lip repair: a sequential, layered closure with orbicularis muscle realignment

A lip repair based on anatomic and electric stimulation studies of the orbicularis muscle in unilateral cleft lip has previously been reported by one of the authors. Following some early modifications, this technique has been used on 125 primary lip repairs. The details of the present technique are described here. The advantages of the procedure, in addition to its functional reconstruction of the orbicularis muscle, are in its applicability to clefts of all widths and superior scar formation. The sequential nature of the procedure and freedom from commitment to a fixed, measured pattern at the outset makes the teaching of the method easier and the achievement of a pleasing result more predictable.     

Reconstruction of the superior labial sulcus in secondary bilateral cleft lip deformities: an inverted U-shaped flap.

A shallow buccal sulcus deformity following bilateral cleft lip repair is not rare. A variety of techniques are described for the secondary reconstruction of a deficient sulcus. Most of these are associated with a variable amount of contraction with subsequent obliteration of the sulcus. In this article, an inverted U-shaped flap is described for the secondary reconstruction of the deficient sublabial sulcus. In these patients, mobility of the upper lip was severely restricted, so orthodontic treatment was not possible. This technique was used in nine patients whose primary cleft lip repairs were performed in different institutions. The amount of re-adhesion or contraction was negligible, because a bare surface was not left behind and skin or mucosal grafts were not used. By advancing the lateral segments of the lip medially, projection of the upper lip was increased. The procedure resulted in adequate upper lip mobility for all patients, and sufficient sulcus was maintained during 1 to 6 years of follow-up. The patients experienced no difficulty with orthodontic appliances after this reconstruction.     

Development of the orbicularis oris muscle in normal and cleft lip and palate human fetuses using three-dimensional computer reconstruction

As part of an ongoing study of cleft lip and palate fetal morphology, normal and dysmorphic development of the human fetal orbicularis oris muscle was studied in a cross-sectional sample of 29 human fetuses (20 "normal" and 9 cleft lip and palate) ranging in age from 8 to 21 postmenstrual weeks. The specimens were embedded in celloidin and sectioned at 20 microns, and every tenth section was stained with hematoxylin and eosin. A computer reconstruction technique was applied to produce three-dimensional representations of the orbicularis oris muscle. The orbicularis oris muscle in the normal fetal sample with discernible lip fibers (N = 15) increased symmetrically in both fiber density and complexity from 12 to 21 weeks. Metrically, muscle volume and thickness growth curves were consistent with qualitative observations. In contrast, the unilateral cleft lip and palate fetal specimens with discernible lip fibers (N = 3) exhibited a 3.5-week delay in overall muscle development, asymmetrical fiber distribution, and abnormal fiber insertions. However, quantitatively, no significant (p greater than 0.05) differences were noted in orbicularis oris muscle thickness or volume between the normal and cleft lip and palate fetal specimens through 21 weeks. Findings suggest that orbicularis muscle deficiency, noted clinically in cleft lip and palate neonates, may be a result of perinatal functional dysmorphogenesis rather than congenital mesenchymal reduction or deficiency.     

Cleft lip, cleft palate, and velopharyngeal insufficiency

This article provides an introduction to the anatomical and clinical features of the primary deformities associated with unilateral cleft lip-cleft palate, bilateral cleft lip-cleft palate, and cleft palate. The diagnosis and management of secondary velopharyngeal insufficiency are discussed. The accompanying videos demonstrate the features of the cleft lip nasal deformities and reliable surgical techniques for unilateral cleft lip repair, bilateral cleft lip repair, and radical intravelar veloplasty.     

A model for fetal cleft lip repair in lambs.

Fetal wounds heal without inflammation and scar formation. This phenomenon may, in the future, be applicable to human cleft lip and palate repair. However, extensive experimental work must first be done to document the benefits of in utero repair. We developed a large animal model for creation and repair of a complete cleft lip and alveolus using fetal lambs. The cleft lip and alveolus deformity was created in eight 75-day-gestation fetuses (term = 145 days) and either repaired in three layers or left unrepaired. There were four sham-operated fetuses, and all animals were alive at harvest. Repaired, unrepaired, and control fetuses were harvested at 7, 14, 21, and 70 days following surgery. The unrepaired fetuses demonstrated a complete cleft lip and alveolus with an oronasal fistula. The maxilla was asymmetrical, with the greater segment deviated toward the cleft and with decreased anterior maxillary width. In contrast, repaired cleft lip and alveolus animals showed no scar, normal thickness of the lip, and a symmetrical maxilla. Histologic analysis of the repaired wounds showed evidence of tissue regeneration without scar formation. The results of this preliminary study indicate that the fetal lamb cleft lip and alveolus model is technically feasible with an excellent survival rate. Healing occurs without scar formation. In the repaired animals, the maxilla was symmetrical. This model will be used to document facial growth following in utero repair of a cleft lip and alveolus.     

Reconstruction of vermilion in unilateral and bilateral cleft lips

The white skin roll is a useful term to describe the cutaneo-vermilion border of the lip. The muco-vermilion border line parallels the white skin roll and is described as the red line. The lip vermilion should be constructed so that these lines are parallel and widest at the base of the philtral column. It is suggested that the triangular lateral lip vermilion flap be used in unilateral cleft lips. In bilateral cleft lips, a white skin roll vermilion-mucosal muscle flap is used for reconstruction of vermilion.     

A long-term, controlled-outcome analysis of in utero versus neonatal cleft lip repair using an ovine model.

Successful open repair of a cleft lip in utero has the advantage of scarless wound healing in the fetus. Unfortunately, no long-term outcome studies have been performed to evaluate the efficacy of these repairs. Moreover, no study to date has compared the long-term results of an in utero cleft lip repair to a similar, control-matched, newborn cleft repair. This study was performed to evaluate the 9-month outcome of in utero cleft lip surgery compared with an identical cleft lip repair performed on infant lambs. In utero epithelialized cleft lips were created through an open hysterotomy in sixteen 65-day-old fetal lambs (term = 140 days) using methods described by Longaker et al. Eight of 16 animals underwent subsequent in utero repair of these clefts at 90 days gestational age. The repair of the remaining eight animals was delayed until 1 week postpartum. At 9 months, the animals were analyzed for changes in lip contour and for the degree of scarring by hematoxylin and eosin and Masson's trichrome collagen staining. Two animals in each group died from preterm labor. Of the animals that survived to term, all repaired lips had some degree of abnormality postoperatively. One of six lips repaired in utero dehisced before delivery. Three of six neonatal repairs dehisced in the first postoperative month. In the remaining animals with intact lip repairs, the vertical lip height on the repaired side was an average of 9 to 12 mm shorter than the normal lip in both the in utero and neonatally repaired animals. Phenotypically, the postnatally repaired animals had more lip distortion and visible notching. Histologically, the in utero repair was scarless and the neonatal repairs had scar throughout the entire vertical height of the lip with an associated loss of hair in this region. Maxillary growth was also evaluated. There was no inhibition of maxillary growth in the animals that underwent in utero cleft lip repair. However, in the neonatal repair group, significant maxillary retrusion was evident. Compared with the cleft side of the maxilla, horizontal growth was decreased by 11 percent (p = 0.01). Compared with the intrauterine repair group, there was a 17-percent decrease in horizontal maxillary width (p = 0.01). Straight-line in utero repair of a cleft lip produces a better long-term result in terms of maxillary growth than a similar repair performed postnatally in the ovine model. There was no diminution in maxillary growth in the animals treated in utero. Histologically, in utero repair of clefts was indeed scarless. However, both lip repairs produced lips that were significantly shorter than their contralateral noncleft sides. This degree of lip shortening would require a secondary lip revision, thereby defeating the purpose of performing an intrauterine repair. Comparisons now need to be made between in utero and neonatal repairs using a Millard-type rotation advancement technique before intrauterine treatment can be considered to be more beneficial than our current treatment modalities.     

Primary correction of the unilateral cleft lip nose: a 15-year experience

This paper reviews a 15-year personal experience based on 400 unilateral cleft nasal deformities that were reconstructed using a method that repositions the alar cartilage by freeing it from the skin and lining and shifts it to a new position. The rotation-advancement lip procedure facilitates the exposure and approach to the nasal reconstruction. The nasal soft tissues are transected from the skeletal base, reshaped, repositioned, and secured by using temporary stent sutures that readapt the alar cartilage, skin, and lining. The nasal floor is closed and the ala base is positioned to match the normal side. Good subsequent growth with maintenance of the reconstruction has been noted in this series. The repair does not directly expose or suture the alar cartilage. Improvement in the cleft nasal deformity is noted in 80 percent of the cases. Twenty percent require additional techniques to achieve the desired symmetry. This method has been used by the author as his primary unilateral cleft nasal repair and has been taught to residents and fellows under his direction with good results. This technique eliminates the severe cleft nasal deformity seen in many secondary cases.     

Further refinements on the triangular flap closure of the cleft lip

Refinements in the triangular flap closure of the unilateral cleft lip are presented. Randall's mathematical interpretation of the Tennison repair has been extended by using a series of arcs to determine the crucial points which form the triangular flap. Using this easily taught method, an isosceles triangular flap can be plotted which will interdigitate into the noncleft side of the lip. Two symmetrical vertical distances on either side of the cleft are thus formed. This allows for a standardized repair which may be more readily taught than the rotation-advancement technique. In addition, flaps are created which are turned medically toward the cleft and are used to accentuate the philtral pout, close the nostril floor, and reinforce the lip repair, allowing closure of even extremely wide clefts in one stage. These refinements in using the triangular flap closure for the repair of the unilateral cleft lip are diagrammatically presented. We believe that these refinements enhance the results of this closure.     

Upper lip measurements at the time of surgery and follow-up after modified rotation-advancement flap repair in unilateral cleft lip patients

The purpose of this prospective study was to determine whether unilateral cleft lip repaired by the rotation-advancement flap will grow short on the repaired side. This study involved 56 patients with nonsyndromic unilateral cleft lip (31 with complete and 25 with incomplete cleft lip) who underwent a rotation-advancement flap repair by a single surgeon between 1989 and 1997. Eleven patients were lost to follow-up. Forty-five patients have been followed for a varying period of between 8 and 84 months (mean = 37 months). The upper lip was measured immediately after the lip repair and follow-up using calipers. The growth ratios of vertical, horizontal, and nostril sill dimensions were compared between the cleft side and the noncleft side of the same face. Statistical analysis was performed to compare the growths between the cleft and noncleft sides. There was not a significant difference in the growth ratios of vertical (Wilcoxon signed rank test, p = 0.85) and horizontal dimensions (Student's t test, p = 0.18) between the cleft and noncleft sides. There was, however, a statistically significant difference in the growth ratios of nostril sill width between the cleft and noncleft sides (Student's t test, p = 0.02). Our findings indicated that a repaired unilateral cleft retained the vertical and horizontal dimensions determined at the time of the initial repair.     

Lip pressure changes following lip repair in infants with unilateral clefts of the lip and palate

The present study was designed to quantitatively assess lip pressure changes following cleft lip repair in infants with unilateral cleft lip, alveolus, and palate. Lip pressure measurements were taken using an electronic transducer system developed especially for this study. Lip pressure was monitored from 3 months (preoperatively) through 2 years of age in cleft and normal control children. Findings from the present study confirm the hypothesis that lip repair in infants with unilateral cleft lip and palate significantly increases lip pressure and that increased lip pressure remains significantly higher than in normal control children for the 2-year duration of the study. Thus increased lip pressure when the palate is unrepaired has to be considered as a factor modulating subsequent craniofacial growth.     

Histologic, histochemical, and ultrastructural analysis of soft tissues from cleft and normal lips.

The cause of cleft lip remains speculative. The nature and extent of pathophysiologic changes in cleft lip muscle are controversial. This study was undertaken to better understand the developmental processes at work. There were two groups of patients. In group 1, 40 fresh tissue specimens were taken from 22 patients who were 2 to 5 months old-their age at the time of their primary cleft lip repair. In group 2, eight control specimens were collected from six children who were seen in the emergency department with lip lacerations. Fresh specimens fixed in neutral buffered formalin were evaluated by the use of hematoxylin and eosin with Luxol fast blue, Bielschowsky, and Masson trichrome stains. Fresh frozen tissue was histochemically assessed by the use of hematoxylin and eosin, modified Gomori trichrome, and adenosine triphosphatase. Ultrastructural analysis was performed on fine sections of glutaraldehyde-fixed tissue. Histologic examination revealed increased endomysial and perimysial collagen in cleft specimens with evidence of muscle-bundle size variation and nonneurogenic atrophy. Insignificant differences were observed between cleft-side and noncleft-side specimens when the means of 200 counts of neural-tissue bundles in the subdermis were compared (p = 0.093). Histochemical examination revealed no typical checkerboard pattern, but a preponderance of type 2 fiber was seen. By means of electron microscopy, increased numbers of subsarcolemmal mitochondria were found in cleft, noncleft, and control specimens. Increased absolute numbers of mitochondria and variations in size, shape, and crystal arrangement were identified. In conclusion, there is no evidence of deficient neural supply in the cleft lip. There is also no evidence of neurogenic muscle atrophy or a metabolic abnormality. There are characteristic myopathic changes. These, in concert with the observed interstitial fibrosis, may have far-reaching implications for growth and function.     

Assessment of bilateral cleft lip nose deformity: a comparison of results as judged by cleft surgeons and laypersons

Reconstruction of bilateral cleft lip nose deformity is difficult and the outcome is inconsistent. This study was conducted to evaluate the gross outcome and the difference in the assessment of nasal appearance as judged by two groups of raters, cleft surgeons and laypersons. Sixty-four patients with bilateral cleft lip were selected for review. The patients' ages ranged from 5 to 30 years. All patients had undergone primary cleft lip repair and secondary nasal reconstruction, and had been followed for at least 6 months. One image for each patient, which included a digitized frontal, lateral, and worm's-eye view, was projected for evaluation by the raters. The raters included five cleft surgeons and five laypersons. A rating scheme was used in which a score of 3 was given for a good, close to normal nasal appearance, 2 for an average result that needed minor revision, and 1 for a poor result that needed major reconstruction. The scores were averaged for each patient in each group and for each group as a whole. The final outcome was judged as good, fair, or poor on the basis of the mean score for each patient. Statistical analysis was performed. The mean score for all patients was 2.08 as assessed by the laypersons and 2.18 as assessed by the cleft surgeon group. There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups. Comparisons on rating scores among different raters revealed a fair agreement on the ratings within each of the two groups. The results were found to be good in 29.7 percent, fair in 64.1 percent, and poor in 6.3 percent of patients when evaluated by the surgeons. When rated by the laypersons, the nasal appearance was found to be good in 26.6 percent, fair in 60.9 percent, and poor in 12.5 percent of patients. This difference in distribution between the two groups was not statistically significant. When comparing the results given by the two groups of assessors, there was agreement on the nasal appearance in 65.6 percent of patients, and a difference in grading in the rest. For the patients who received different grading, the surgeons rated them one grade higher in 63.6 percent and one grade lower in 36.4 percent. There was no difference in grading between any of the evaluators that reflected a two-grade discrepancy in evaluation of results. This study shows that the surgical outcome of bilateral cleft lip nose deformity repair, at the authors' institution, is less than optimal. When assessing bilateral cleft lip nose appearance, the judgment of results by cleft surgeons was similar to that of the laypersons. However, different rating of results existed within each of the two groups, supporting the importance of clearly assessing patient/parent expectations and defining realistic surgical goals.     

Outpatient cleft lip repair

The emphasis on cost reduction and increased efficiency in health care delivery has prompted an increase in outpatient (ambulatory) surgical procedures. A retrospective review of the perioperative management of patients undergoing cleft lip repair at two urban tertiary pediatric hospitals was performed to assess the safety of outpatient cleft lip repair. The hospital database at Childrens Hospital Los Angeles was searched to find all patients who had been operated on for cleft lip repair during calendar years 1999 and 2000. Two groups were identified from Childrens Hospital Los Angeles: the outpatient cleft lip repair group (patients discharged the same day as the operation; n = 91) and the inpatient cleft lip repair group (n = 14). A data set was acquired from the Royal Children's Hospital in Melbourne, Australia, using the same criteria, for fiscal years 1998 to 2000 (n = 50). All patients from Royal Children's Hospital had operations as inpatients. Parameters considered for each group were age, sex, race, ethnicity, length of hospital stay, preexisting medical conditions or diagnoses, complications, and readmissions or presentation to the emergency department within 4 weeks of operation. The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles outpatient group had three readmissions that were considered to be complications of the operation. The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles inpatient group had one readmission attributable to a complication. The Royal Children's Hospital group also had one readmission for a complication. There was no significant difference in the complication rate of the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles outpatient group and the Royal Children's Hospital group (p > 0.05). There was also no significant difference in the complication rate of both of the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles groups compared with the Royal Children's Hospital group (p > 0.05). This study indicates that cleft lip repair performed in an outpatient setting may be a safe alternative to the inpatient operation. Certain preexisting medical conditions, however, may dictate the need for inpatient hospitalization after repair.     

Cleft palate repair by double opposing Z-plasty

In an attempt to improve speech results following palate repair while allowing adequate maxillary growth, a palatoplasty using two opposing Z-plasties of the soft palate, one of the oral and one of the nasal layers, has been used in 22 infants. Eight patients had unilateral cleft lip and palate, eight had bilateral cleft lip and palate, and six had cleft palate. The Z-plasties facilitate effective dissection and redirection of the palatal muscles to produce an overlapping muscle sling and lengthen the velum without using tissue from the hard palate, which permits hard palate closure without pushback or lateral relaxing incisions. Of the 20 children old enough for speech evaluation, 18 have no velopharyngeal insufficiency. Two have very mild velopharyngeal insufficiency. None has required a pharyngeal flap.     

Pathophysiology of cleft lip muscle

Although attention has been focused for decades on the correction of cleft lip deformities, our knowledge about the etiology of such deformities has remained presumptive. Sixty-six muscle biopsy specimens from cleft lip infants were obtained at the time of primary closure. Histochemical stains, histographic analysis, and electron microscopy were performed. A nonneurogenic muscle atrophy was seen that varied in severity, with muscle fibers near the cleft being the most atrophic and disorganized. Muscle fibers stained with the modified Gomori trichrome technique also demonstrated "ragged red" fibers typical of a mitochondrial myopathy. Electron microscopy confirmed large accumulations of mitochondria distorting the fibrils. These mitochondria also were increased in size and densely packed with cristae. This study thus demonstrates that the muscles in cleft lip deformities are not normal. Instead, they reflect either myopathy in the facial mesenchymal mitochondrion or at least a delay in maturation. We hypothesize that some of the morphologic deformities associated with cleft lip may cause a failure of mesenchymal reinforcement of the facial processes at a critical time in development.     

The short-lip deformity after triangular flap repair: a lengthening technique

A method for lengthening of the short lip after triangular-flap repair of the unilateral cleft lip is documented. This technique offers a minimal additional scar line and a maximum effect.