Studies of the Escherichia coli Trp repressor binding to its five operators and to variant operator sequences.

The Escherichia coli Trp repressor binds to promoters of very different sequence and intrinsic activity. Its mode of binding to trp operator DNA has been studied extensively yet remains highly controversial. In order to examine the selectivity of the protein for DNA, we have used electromobility shift assays (EMSAs) to study its binding to synthetic DNA containing the core sequences of each of its five operators and of operator variants. Our results for DNA containing sequences of two of the operators, trpEDCBA and aroH are similar to those of previous studies. Up to three bands of lower mobility than the free DNA are obtained which are assigned to complexes of stoichiometry 1 : 1, 2 : 1 and 3 : 1 Trp repressor dimer to DNA. The mtr and aroL operators have not been studied previously in vitro. For DNA containing these sequences, we observe predominantly one retarded band in EMSA with mobility corresponding to 2 : 1 complexes. We have also obtained retardation of DNA containing the trpR operator sequence, which has only been previously obtained with super-repressor Trp mutants. This gives bands with mobilities corresponding to 1 : 1 and 2 : 1 complexes. In contrast, DNA containing containing a symmetrized trpR operator sequence, trpRs, gives a single retarded band with mobility corresponding solely to a 1 : 1 protein dimer-DNA complex. Using trpR operator variants, we show that a change in a single base pair in the core 20 base pairs can alter the number of retarded DNA bands in EMSA and the length of the DNase I footprint observed. This shows that the binding of the second dimer is sequence selective. We propose that the broad selectivity of Trp repressor coupled to tandem 2 : 1 binding, which we have observed with all five operator sequences, enables the Trp repressor to bind to a limited number of sites with diverse sequences. This allows it to co-ordinately control promoters of different intrinsic strength. This mechanism may be of importance in a number of promoters that bind multiple effector molecules.     

Interaction of the Mnt repressor with 37-base pair synthetic operator DNA fragments. Importance of symmetric GC pairs

Mnt repressor is indirectly responsible for the maintenance of lysogeny of the phage P22. This repressor interacts with a 21-base pair operator DNA constituting within it a 17-base pair perfect 2-fold symmetric sequence whose bases make a direct contact with the protein. We have synthesized six 37-base pair DNAs consisting of 21 base pair natural operator and its modifications in which certain symmetrically situated GC base pairs were replaced systematically with ATs to understand their importance. The binding interaction studies of Mnt repressor to such natural and modified operator DNAs reported here indicate that the GCs close to the center of symmetry make major contacts with the protein whereas, GCs nearer to the periphery form weak contacts. Methylation protection experiments indicated that when the GCs near the center of symmetry were replaced with AT, the central GC became more accessible for dimethyl sulfate methylation with possible conformational change in DNA. The circular dichroism studies indicated that upon repressor binding conformational changes in DNA takes place with a possible increase in helicity of the repressor protein.     

Co-operative binding of two Trp repressor dimers to α- or β-centred trp operators

The α-centred trp operator binds one dimer of the Trp repressor, whereas the β-centred trp operator binds two dimers of the Trp repressor (Carey et al., 1991; Haran et al., 1992). The Trp repressor with a Tyr-Gly-7 substitution binds almost as well as the wild-type Trp repressor to the α-centred trp operator, but it does not bind to the β-centred trp operator. This confirms that Tyr-7 is involved in the interaction between Trp repressor dimers, as seen in the crystal structure (Lawson and Carey, 1993). Further experiments with a-centred trp operator variants showed that positions 1 of the a-centred trp operators play a crucial role in tetramerisation. The two innermost base pairs of the α-centred trp operator are not involved in contacts with the dimer of the Trp repressor binding to it. However, substitutions in these positions (T-A to G-T) effectively transform the α-centred trp operator into a β-centred trp operator, and thus encourage the binding of two Trp repressor dimers to this operator. Finally, we demonstrate, with suitable heterodimers, that one subunit of each dimer suffices to bind to a β-centred trp operator.     

An alkaline phosphatase protection assay to investigate trp repressor/operator interactions

We have used an alkaline phosphatase protection assay to investigate the interaction of the trp repressor with its operator sequence. The assay is based on the principle that the trp repressor will protect a terminally 5'-32P-labeled operator DNA fragment from attack by alkaline phosphatase. The optimal oligonucleotide for investigating the trp repressor/operator interaction extends two base pairs from each end of the genetically defined target sequence predicted by in vivo studies [Bass et al. (1987) Genes Dev. 1, 565-572]. The assay works well over a 10,000-fold range of protein/DNA affinity and is used to show that the corepressor, L-tryptophan, causes the liganded repressor to bind a 20 base pair trp operator duplex 6400 times more strongly than the unliganded aporepressor. The affinity of the trp repressor for operators containing symmetrical mutations was interpreted in terms of the trp repressor/operator crystal structure as follows: (1) Direct hydrogen bonds with the functional groups of G-9 of the trp operator and the side chain of Arg 69 of the trp repressor contribute to DNA-binding specificity. (2) G-6 of the trp operator is critical for DNA-binding specificity probably because of the two water-mediated hydrogen bonds between its functional groups and the N-terminus of the trp repressor's E-helix. (3) Sequence-dependent aspects of the trp operator's conformation help stabilize the trp repressor/operator complex.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Crystallographic analysis of Lac repressor bound to natural operator O1

Previous structures of Lac repressor bound to DNA used a fully symmetric "ideal" operator sequence that is missing the central G-C base-pair present in the three natural operator sequences. Here we have determined the X-ray crystal structure of a dimeric Lac repressor bound to a 22 base-pair DNA with the natural operator O1 sequence and the anti-inducer ONPF, at 4.0 A resolution. The natural operator is bent in the same way as the symmetric sequence, due to the binding of the hinge helices of the repressor to the minor groove at the central GCGG sequence of O1. Comparison of the structures of the repressor bound to the natural and symmetric operators shows very similar overall structures, with only slight rearrangements of the headpiece domains of the repressor. Analysis of crystals with iodinated DNA shows that the operator is uniquely positioned and allows for the sequence registration of the DNA relative to the repressor to be determined. The kink in the operator is centered between the left half-site and the central G-C base-pair of O1. Our results are most consistent with a previously proposed model in which, relative to the complex with the symmetric operator, the repressor accommodates binding to the natural operator sequence by shifting the position of the right headpiece by one base-pair step towards the center of O1.     

The DNA target of the trp repressor.

Unexpected features seen by high resolution X-ray crystallography at the interface of the trp repressor and the 'traditional' trp operator provoked the claim that the DNA fragment used in the crystal structure is not the true operator, and therefore that the crystal structure of the trp repressor-operator complex does not portray a specific interaction. An alternative sequence was proposed mainly on the basis of mutational studies and gel retardation analysis of short target duplexes (Staacke et al., 1990a,b). We have reexamined the sequence consensus in trpR-repressible promoters and analyzed the mutagenesis experiments of others including Staacke et al. (1990a) and found them fully consistent with the interactions of the traditional operator sequence seen in the crystal structure, and stereochemically inconsistent with the above referenced alternative model. Moreover, an in vitro trp repressor-DNA binding analysis, employing both novel DNA constructs devised to avoid previously encountered artifacts as well as full-length promoter sequences, indicates that the traditional operator used in the crystal structure is the preferred target of the trp repressor.     

The possible roles of residues 79 and 80 of the Trp repressor from Escherichia coli K-12 in trp operator recognition

We constructed mutants of the Trp repressor from Escherichia coli K-12 with all possible single amino acid exchanges at positions 79 and 80 (residues 1 and 2 of the recognition helix). We tested these mutants in vivo by measuring the repression of synthesis of β-galactosidase with symmetric variants of α- and β-centered trp operators, which replace the lac operator in a synthetic lac system. The Trp repressor carrying a substitution of isoleucine 79 by lysine, showed a marked specificity change with respect to base pair 7 of the α-centered trp operator. Gel retardation experiments confirmed this result. Trp repressor mutant IR79 specifically recognizes a trp operator variant with substitutions in positions 7 and 8. Another mutant, with glycine in position 79, exhibited loss of contact at base pair 7. We speculate that the side chain of Ile79 interacts with the AT base pairs 7 and 8 of the α-centered trp operator, possibly with the methyl groups of thymines. Replacement of thymine in position 7 or 8 by uracil confirms the involvement of the methyl group of thymine 8 in repressor binding. Several Trp repressor mutants in position 80 (i.e. AI80, AL80, AM80 and AP80) broaden the specificity of the Trp repressor for α-centered trp operator variants with exchanges in positions 3, 4 and 5.     

Probing the structure of gal operator-repressor complexes. Conformation change in DNA

The gal operon is regulated by binding of Gal repressor to two operator loci, OE and OI, which are separated by 114 base pairs (bp). We have probed the actual operator DNA segments with and without Gal repressor occupation by characterizing the regions protected by repressor from DNase I digestion and dimethyl sulfate methylation. The segments which are protected from DNase I digestion in both OE and OI are about 22 bp long and seem to include 2-3 extra bp on either side of a 16-bp similar sequence containing an approximate dyad symmetry, with a consensus half-symmetry sequence GTG(G/T)AA-C. Repressor occupation hinders the reactivity of the consensus guanines in the four half-symmetry sequences, as shown by retardation of methylation at the N-7 positions by dimethyl sulfate owing to repressor binding. The protected guanines are symmetrically located. Since a dimeric Gal repressor affects symmetrically located bases, it is consistent with the notion that each half-operator is occupied by a repressor subunit. Because the N-7 positions of methylation of guanines lie in the major grooves and the protected guanines are located at positions 1, 3, 8 and the rotational 1', 3', and 8' in the 16-bp dyad symmetry, we suggest that Gal repressor establishes direct contacts with bases at 1, 3, 1', and 3' through two major grooves lying on one face of an operator helix and prevents reactivity of the guanines at 8 and 8' of a third major groove on the opposite face by changing the DNA helical structure at this position. Contacts at other positions are also discussed.     

The role of the minor groove substituents in indirect readout of DNA sequence by 434 repressor

The sequence of non-contacted bases at the center of the 434 repressor binding site affects the strength of the repressor-DNA complex by influencing the structure and flexibility of DNA (Koudelka, G. B., and Carlson, P. (1992) Nature 355, 89-91). We synthesized 434 repressor binding sites that differ in their central sequence base composition to test the importance of minor groove substituents and/or the number of base pair hydrogen bonds between these base pairs on DNA structure and strength of the repressor-DNA complex. We show here that the number of base pair H-bonds between the central bases apparently has no role in determining the relative affinity of a DNA site for repressor. Instead we find that the affinity of DNA for repressor depends on the absence or presence the N2-NH(2) group on the purine bases at the binding site center. The N2-NH(2) group on bases at the center of the 434 binding site appears to destabilize 434 repressor-DNA complexes by decreasing the intimacy of the specific repressor-DNA contacts, while increasing the reliance on protein contacts to the DNA phosphate backbone. Thus, the presence of an N2-NH(2) group on the purines at the center of a binding site globally alters the precise conformation of the protein-DNA interface.     

Ligand-mediated conformational changes in Trp repressor protein of Escherichia coli probed through limited proteolysis and the use of specific antibodies

Trp repressor of Escherichia coli K-12 is a dimeric protein (monomer size, 108 amino acids) that acquires high affinity for certain operator targets in double-stranded DNA upon interaction with L-tryptophan. High titer antiserum directed against E. coli Trp repressor protein, elicited in rabbits, was monospecific toward native or denatured Trp repressor. Using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay to measure antigen-antibody reaction, we found that the binding of L-tryptophan to Trp repressor was associated with a marked decrease in antibody reactivity that presumably accompanied a conformational change in this protein to a state with strong affinity for trp operator-bearing DNA. We analyzed the pattern of cleavage of Trp repressor by chymotrypsin and trypsin and the effect of L-tryptophan on such hydrolytic cleavages. Chymotrypsin cleaved Trp repressor mainly between residues 71 and 72. In the presence of L-tryptophan this cleavage was slowed. The first-order rate constants for chymotryptic digestion of Trp repressor were 7.6 X 10(-2) and 4.6 X 10(-2) min-1 in the absence and presence of L-tryptophan, respectively. Tryptic digestion was more complex. Initial cleavage of Trp repressor occurred with approximately equal facility between residues 69-70 or 84-85. Subsequent tryptic hydrolyses led eventually to a major core fragment containing the first 54 amino acids of Trp repressor plus four other fragments from the carboxyl-terminal half of the protein. In the presence of L-tryptophan, cleavage by trypsin between residues 54-55 and 84-85 was retarded, even when a previous hydrolytic event elsewhere in the protein had occurred. Tryptophan had essentially no effect on the tryptic hydrolysis of peptide bond 97-98, but accelerated cleavage at peptide bond 69-70. The first-order rate constants for the first tryptic cleavage of Trp receptor were 1.55 X 10(-1) and 1.33 X 10(-1) min-1 in the absence and presence of ligand, respectively. Our results are compatible with a structural model wherein certain amino acid side chains and peptide bonds of Trp repressor (specifically, those of residues 69-85) lie on or near the surface of the protein. This region of Trp repressor has been predicted to contain the operator recognition site. The susceptibility to proteolytic attack of at least four peptide bonds in this area changes when the protein interacts with L-tryptophan.     

Interaction of the Bacillus subtilis phage phi 105 repressor DNA: a genetic analysis.

The Bacillus subtilis phage phi 105 repressor specifically recognizes a 14-bp operator sequence which does not exhibit 2-fold rotational symmetry. To facilitate a genetic analysis of this sequence-dependent DNA binding a B. subtilis strain was constructed in which mutations affecting the phi 105 repressor-operator interaction cause a selectable phenotype, chloramphenicol resistance. After in vivo mutagenesis, we isolated and mapped 22 different mutations in the repressor coding sequence, 15 of which are missense substitutions. These are exclusively located in the N-terminal part (positions 1-43) of the 144 residue long polypeptide. Two nonsense mutants, at positions 70 and 89, respectively, still show partial repressor activity. These data suggest that the phi 105 repressor consists of at least two independently folding structural domains, of which the N-terminal is involved in operator binding. Twelve missense mutations are clustered in a region extending from Gln-18 to Arg-37, which we propose to be the DNA-binding alpha-helix--beta-turn--alpha-helix motif, common to all lambda Cro-like repressors. The second ('recognition') helix shows significant homology with the corresponding sequence in Tn3 resolvase, and there is also a striking similarity between the phi 105 operator and the consensus sequence for a Tn3 res half-site. Based on these observations, and on the previously isolated phi 105 0c mutants, we tentatively assign some specific contacts between base pairs from the first half of a phi 105 operator site and amino acids from the repressor's 'recognition helix'.     

Mutants in position 69 of the Trp repressor ofEscherichia coli K12 with altered DNA-binding specificity

Structural analysis by X-ray crystallography has indicated that direct contact occurs between Arg69, the second residue of the first helix of the helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif of the Trp repressor, and guanine in position 9 of the α-centred consensustrp operator. We therefore replaced residue 69 of the Trp repressor with Gly, Ile, Leu or Gln and tested the resultant repressor mutants for their binding to synthetic symmetrical α-or β-centredtrp operator variants, in vivo and in vitro. We present genetic and biochemical evidence that Ile in position 69 of the Trp repressor interacts specifically with thymine in position 9 of the α-centredtrp operator. There are also interactions with other bases in positions 8 and 9 of the α-centredtrp operator. In vitro, the Trp repressor of mutant RI69 binds to the consensus α-centredtrp operator and a similartrp operator variant that carries a T in position 9. In vivo analysis of the interactions of Trp repressor mutant RI69 with symmetrical variants of the β-centredtrp operator shows a change in the specificity of binding to a β-centred symmetricaltrp operator variant with a gua-nine to thymine substitution in position 5, which corresponds to position 9 of the α-centredtrp operator.     

Three additional operators, Op21, Op68, and Op88, of bacteriophage P1. Evidence for control of the P1 dam methylase by Op68

The repressor of bacteriophage P1, encoded by the c1 gene, is responsible for maintaining the P1 prophage in the lysogenic state. Previously, 11 c1 repressor binding sites or operators scattered over the whole genome of P1 have been found. From sequence analysis an asymmetric, 17-base pair consensus sequence, ATTGCTCTAATAAATTT, was derived. Using a synthetic 15-base-long oligodeoxyribonucleotide as operator probe, we have identified three additional operators. We have mapped the operators at the positions 21,68, and 88 of the P1 genome and determined their sequence. These operators are controlled by c1 because corresponding P1 DNA fragments (i) require c1 repressor in vivo in order to be clonable in multicopy plasmids, (ii) exhibit a c1-repressible promoter activity, (iii) are retarded by c1 repressor protein during electrophoresis, and (iv) contain the 17-base pair consensus sequence with one mismatch base each. Furthermore, we suggest that expression of the DNA adenine methylase (dam) encoded by P1 is controlled via Op68.     

Operator DNA sequence variation enhances high affinity binding by hinge helix mutants of lactose repressor protein

The mechanism by which genetic regulatory proteins discern specific target DNA sequences remains a major area of inquiry. To explore in more detail the interplay between DNA and protein sequence, we have examined binding of variant lac operator DNA sequences to a series of mutant lactose repressor proteins (LacI). These proteins were altered in the C-terminus of the hinge region that links the N-terminal DNA binding and core sugar binding domains. Variant operators differed from the wild-type operator, O(1), in spacing and/or symmetry of the half-sites that contact the LacI N-terminal DNA binding domain. Binding of wild-type and mutant proteins was affected differentially by variations in operator sequence and symmetry. While the mutant series exhibits a 10(4)-fold range in binding affinity for O(1) operator, only a approximately 20-fold difference in affinity is observed for a completely symmetric operator, O(sym), used widely in studies of the LacI protein. Further, DNA sequence influenced allosteric response for these proteins. Binding of this LacI mutant series to other variant operator DNA sequences indicated the importance of symmetry-related bases, spacing, and the central base pair sequence in high affinity complex formation. Conformational flexibility in the DNA and other aspects of the structure influenced by the sequence may establish the binding environment for protein and determine both affinity and potential for allostery.     

Symmetric lac operator derivatives: effects of half-operator sequence and spacing on repressor affinity

We have analyzed lac repressor binding in vivo and in vitro to several symmetric lac operator sequences. Two features of the operator appear to be important for repressor binding: sequence, both of the operator and of its extended regions, and the spacing of the operator halves. Host mutations that alter DNA superhelical density (topA, gyrB) did not change the relative affinity of cloned symmetric operator sequences for repressor. Analysis by dimethylsulfate methylation and DNaseI digestion of repressor-operator complexes indicated that repressor makes symmetric contacts with the symmetric operator, in contrast to its contacts with the two halves of the natural operator.     

Chemical synthesis and biochemical reactivity of bacteriophage lambda PR promoter

By a combination of chemical and enzymatic methods, a 75 base pair DNA duplex containing the sequence of the lambda PR promoter including the OR1 and OR2 cI repressor binding sites was synthesized. The solid support phosphite triester procedure (Caruthers, M. H. et al., Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology XLVII, in press) was used for the synthesis of oligonucleotides comprising the sequence. We report here an adaptation of the method of DNA synthesis in test tubes. Assembly of the oligonucleotides involved the use of T4 polynucleotide kinase and T4 DNA ligase. We show that the synthetic DNA is recognized by RNA polymerase and cI repressor in a manner identical to the same control region contained on a restriction fragment isolated from bacteriophage lambda DNA. Our synthetic approach using chemically synthesized promoter variants is thus suitable for studies probing the function of promoters.     

Base substitution mutants of the lac operator: in vivo and in vitro affinities for lac repressor

16 single-site mutations and a 1-bp deletion in the lac operator have been cloned and examined with regard to repressor binding. A 13-bp, central ‘core’ operator sequence, bp 5–17 of the natural operator, was also synthesized and cloned. Repressor affinity was assessed in vivo by quantitating the level of β-galactosidase activity resulting from chromosomal operon derepression and in vitro by measuring the stability of repressor-operator complexes. Our results support the general conclusion that the repressor-operator interaction is asymmetric, particularly across the center of the operator sequence, with little or no specific contact at position 12. Some sequence changes in the right side of the operator markedly reduced repressor affinity, indicating that although binding to this half of the sequence has been suggested to be less important than the left half, it still significantly contributes to the binding affinity.     

Stereochemical effects of L-tryptophan and its analogues on trp repressor's affinity for operator-DNA

We have employed a filter binding assay to help study the mechanism by which bound L-tryptophan enables the Escherichia coli trp repressor to bind its operators. We have prepared variants of the trp repressor using structural analogues of the natural corepressor, L-tryptophan, and measured the affinity of these variants for a 20-base pair oligonucleotide duplex containing a symmetrical idealization of the trp operator from the E. coli trpEDCBA operon. By normalizing for each analogue's previously determined affinity for the trp aporepressor, we have estimated the extent to which each of the functional groups of bound L-tryptophan contributes to operator affinity. We discuss the likely role of these functional groups in the context of the crystal structures of the inactive, unliganded trp aporepressor, the liganded, active repressor, an inactive pseudorepressor (Pseudorepressors are formed by analogues of L-tryptophan that bind at the tryptophan-binding site but form near isomorphs of the repressor that have poor affinity for operator-DNA.) and the trp repressor/operator complex. We find that the alpha-amino group and an unsubstituted amino (-NH-) nitrogen of L-tryptophan's indole ring are essential for operator affinity. The former properly orients the corepressor and the latter interacts directly with the DNA. The alpha-carboxyl group, on the other hand, greatly enhances but is not essential for operator binding. The alpha-carboxylate's role, which is dependent on the corepressor's orientation in the binding pocket, is apparently to position the guanidinium group of Arg-84 for favorable contacts with the operator's sugar-phosphate backbone.     

Serine to cysteine mutations in trp repressor protein alter tryptophan and operator binding

The tryptophan repressor regulates expression of the aroH, trpEDCBA, and trpR operons in Escherichia coli. The protein contains no cysteine residues, and the presence of this reactive side chain would allow introduction of spectral probes to monitor binding reactions. Three mutant trp aporepressors, each with a point mutation from serine to cysteine, were produced at positions 67, 86, and 88 by oligonucleotide-directed site-specific mutagenesis. This single conservative substitution affected both tryptophan and operator DNA affinities in all three purified proteins. Cysteine substitution for serine at position 67 decreased tryptophan binding by approximately 6-fold and the operator DNA affinity by approximately 50-fold. The proximity of this amino acid to Gln-68 which is involved in binding to operator DNA (Otwinowski, Z., Schevitz, R. W., Zhang, R.-G., Lawson, C. L., Joachimiak, A., Marmorstein, R. Q., Luisi, B. F., and Sigler, P. B. (1988) Nature 335, 321-329) may account for this effect. Substitution at position 86 diminished tryptophan binding by approximately 4-fold and operator DNA binding by approximately 130-fold. The participation of Ser-86 in the hydrogen bond network required for operator binding (Otwinowski, Z., Schevitz, R. W., Zhang, R.-G., Lawson, C. L., Joachimiak, A., Marmorstein, R. Q., Luisi, B. F., and Sigler, P. B. (1988) Nature 335, 321-329) presumably accounts for the DNA binding effects. The diminished corepressor activity in these two mutants may derive from distortions of the binding region, as the tryptophan and DNA binding sites are intimately related. The mutation at position 88 altered tryptophan binding the most of the three mutants (approximately 18-fold) and operator binding least (approximately 12-fold). Ser-88 forms a hydrogen bond with the amino group of bound tryptophan (Schevitz, R. W., Otwinowski, Z., Joachimiak, A., Lawson, C. L., and Sigler, P. B. (1985) Nature 317, 782-786), and alteration of the geometry of the side chain would be anticipated to perturb the topology of the binding site. The diminished operator affinity may derive from improper alignment of the tryptophan ligand, crucial for high affinity operator binding (Otwinowski, Z., Schevitz, R. W., Zhang, R.-G., Lawson, C. L., Joachimiak, A., Marmorstein, R. Q., Luisi, B. F., and Sigler, P. B. (1988) Nature 335, 321-329).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)