Mechanistic investigations of low dose exposures to the genotoxic compounds bisphenol-A and rotenone

A complete hazard and risk assessment of any known genotoxin requires the evaluation of the mutagenic, clastogenic and aneugenic potential of the compound. In the case of aneugenic chemicals, mechanism of action (MOA) and quantitative responses may be investigated by studying their effects upon the fidelity of functioning of components of the cell cycle. These present studies have demonstrated that the plastics component bisphenol-A (BPA) and the natural pesticide rotenone induce micronuclei and modify the functioning of the microtubule organising centres (MTOCs) of the mitotic spindles of cultured mammalian cells in a dose-dependent manner. BPA and rotenone were used as model compounds in an investigation of dose response relationships for the hazard/risk assessment of aneugens. Thresholds of action for the induction of aneuploidy have been predicted for spindle poisons on the basis of the multiple targets, which may need disabling before a quantitative response can be detected. The cytokinesis blocked micronucleus assay (CBMA) methodology was utilised in the human lymphoblastoid cell lines AHH-1, MCL-5 and Chinese hamster V79 cell lines. A no observable effect level (NOEL) at 10.8 microg/ml BPA was observed for MN induction. Rotenone showed a small increase in MN induction with the first significant effect at 0.25 ng/ml in V79 cells but there was no significant effect in the metabolically competent cell line, MCL-5. For a mechanistic evaluation of the aneugenic effects of BPA and rotenone, fluorescently labelled antibodies were used to visualise microtubules (alpha-tubulin) and MTOCs (gamma-tubulin). The NOELs for tripolar mitotic spindle induction in V79 cells were 7 microg/ml for BPA and 80 pg/ml for rotenone (concentrations which produced similar changes to mitotic index (M.I.)). Interestingly there was close proximity to the NOEL of 10.8 microg/ml BPA for micronucleus (MN) induction in the human lymphoblastoid AHH-1 cell. Multiple MTOCs can therefore be predicted as a possible mechanism for MN induction. The similarity in concentration inducing tripolar mitosis, M.I. and MN changes suggests immunofluorescence analysis to be a useful dose setting assay with emphasis on the mechanism.     

More Accurate Dose-Response Estimation Using Monte-Carlo Uncertainty Analysis: The Data Cube Approach

The traditional q₁ ^* methodology for constructing upper confidence limits (UCLs) for the low-dose slopes of quantal dose-response functions has two limitations: (i) it is based on an asymptotic statistical result that has been shown via Monte Carlo simulation not to hold in practice for small, real bioassay experiments (Portier and Hoel, 1983); and (ii) it assumes that the multistage model (which represents cumulative hazard as a polynomial function of dose) is correct. This paper presents an uncertainty analysis approach for fitting dose-response functions to data that does not require specific parametric assumptions or depend on asymptotic results. It has the advantage that the resulting estimates of the dose-response function (and uncertainties about it) no longer depend on the validity of an assumed parametric family nor on the accuracy of the asymptotic approximation. The method derives posterior densities for the true response rates in the dose groups, rather than deriving posterior densities for model parameters, as in other Bayesian approaches (Sielken, 1991), or resampling the observed data points, as in the bootstrap and other resampling methods. It does so by conditioning constrained maximum-entropy priors on the observed data. Monte Carlo sampling of the posterior (constrained, conditioned) probability distributions generate values of response probabilities that might be observed if the experiment were repeated with very large sample sizes. A dose-response curve is fit to each such simulated dataset. If no parametric model has been specified, then a generalized representation (e.g., a power-series or orthonormal polynomial expansion) of the unknown dose-response function is fit to each simulated dataset using “model-free” methods. The simulation-based frequency distribution of all the dose-response curves fit to the simulated datasets yields a posterior distribution function for the low-dose slope of the dose-response curve. An upper confidence limit on the low-dose slope is obtained directly from this posterior distribution. This “Data Cube” procedure is illustrated with a real dataset for benzene, and is seen to produce more policy-relevant insights than does the traditional q₁ ^* methodology. For example, it shows how far apart are the 90%, 95%, and 99% limits and reveals how uncertainty about total and incremental risk vary with dose level (typically being dominated at low doses by uncertainty about the response of the control group, and being dominated at high doses by sampling variability). Strengths and limitations of the Data Cube approach are summarized, and potential decision-analytic applications to making better informed risk management decisions are briefly discussed.     

Combining multiple comparisons and modeling techniques in dose-response studies

The analysis of data from dose-response studies has long been divided according to two major strategies: multiple comparison procedures and model-based approaches. Model-based approaches assume a functional relationship between the response and the dose, taken as a quantitative factor, according to a prespecified parametric model. The fitted model is then used to estimate an adequate dose to achieve a desired response but the validity of its conclusions will highly depend on the correct choice of the a priori unknown dose-response model. Multiple comparison procedures regard the dose as a qualitative factor and make very few, if any, assumptions about the underlying dose-response model. The primary goal is often to identify the minimum effective dose that is statistically significant and produces a relevant biological effect. One approach is to evaluate the significance of contrasts between different dose levels, while preserving the family-wise error rate. Such procedures are relatively robust but inference is confined to the selection of the target dose among the dose levels under investigation. We describe a unified strategy to the analysis of data from dose-response studies which combines multiple comparison and modeling techniques. We assume the existence of several candidate parametric models and use multiple comparison techniques to choose the one most likely to represent the true underlying dose-response curve, while preserving the family-wise error rate. The selected model is then used to provide inference on adequate doses.     

Evaluation of the developmental effects on mice after prenatal, or pre- and postnatal exposure to 2,3-dimercaptopropane-1-sulfonic acid (DMPS)

The sodium salt of 2,3-dimercaptopropane-1-sulfonic acid (DMPS), a water soluble metal complexing agent, was administered to four groups of pregnant Swiss mice at 0, 70, 210, and 630 mg/kg/day by two dosing schedules: gestation day 14 until birth (prenatal exposure), and gestation day 14 until postnatal day 21 (pre- and postnatal section). Dams were allowed to deliver and the number of live and dead pups recorded. Each pup was sexed and weighed on days 0, 4, 14, and 21. Also, pinna detachment, incisor eruption and eye opening were monitored. No adverse effects on offspring survival or development were evident in either exposures at doses employed in this study. The "no observable effect level" (NOEL) for health hazard to the developing fetus or pup was 630 mg DMPS/kg/day. This dose is much higher than the amounts of DMPS usually administered in human heavy metal poisoning.     

The role of control groups in mutagenicity studies: matching biological and statistical relevance

The statistical test of the conventional hypothesis of "no treatment effect" is commonly used in the evaluation of mutagenicity experiments. Failing to reject the hypothesis often leads to the conclusion in favour of safety. The major drawback of this indirect approach is that what is controlled by a prespecified level alpha is the probability of erroneously concluding hazard (producer risk). However, the primary concern of safety assessment is the control of the consumer risk, i.e. limiting the probability of erroneously concluding that a product is safe. In order to restrict this risk, safety has to be formulated as the alternative, and hazard, i.e. the opposite, has to be formulated as the hypothesis. The direct safety approach is examined for the case when the corresponding threshold value is expressed either as a fraction of the population mean for the negative control, or as a fraction of the difference between the positive and negative controls.     

Reflections on the implications of thresholds of mutagenic activity for the labelling of chemicals by the European Union

During the course of the safety evaluation and regulatory control of chemicals it is important to distinguish between "potential hazard" and "actual risk" of exposure to toxins. In the case of DNA reactive chemicals, it has been prudent to assume that hazard is expressed as risk at low exposure concentrations. However, analysis of the dose-response relationships of both DNA reactive and non-DNA reactive genotoxins (e.g., aneugens) indicate that there are exposure concentrations below which protective mechanisms such as DNA repair activity and the presence of multiple targets may lead to the prediction of no risk until threshold concentrations are achieved. Current European Union management procedures for mutagenic chemicals are based predominantly upon hazard assessment rather than assessment of actual risk under likely exposure scenarios. As our knowledge of protective mechanisms increases, the time is now appropriate to undertake a re-evaluation of European Union criteria and to base the clarification mutagenic chemical more firmly upon the basis of actual risks to the human population and to the environment.     

Efficient design for estimation of median lethal dose and quantal dose-response curves

The results of quantal dose-response experiments are often summarized by an estimate of the "median lethal dose," denoted LD50, and many sequential designs have been proposed for efficient estimation of LD50. These designs strive to produce a sequence of trials at dose levels that get closer and closer to LD50. Consequently, they may not provide very good estimates of the overall shape of the dose-response curve. In this paper we propose guidelines for the design of experiments that estimate LD50 fairly efficiently and that also allow for efficient global estimation of the curve.     

Enhanced airway responses to substance P after repeated challenge in guinea pigs

We performed three consecutive dose-response curves to rapid intravenous infusions of substance P (SP) in anesthetized, mechanically ventilated guinea pigs. The dose of SP required to decrease pulmonary conductance to 50% of its base-line value (ED50GL) decreased 2.8-fold (P less than 0.002) and 3.3-fold (P less than 0.001) on the second and third dose-response curves, respectively, compared with the first. SP did not alter airway responses to intravenous histamine but did cause a significant (3.7-fold) decrease in ED50GL for dose-response curves to intravenous capsaicin, an agent that causes bronchoconstriction by release of endogenous tachykinins. The neutral metalloendopeptidase inhibitor thiorphan (0.5 mg) and the angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor captopril (1.7 mg) both caused a marked enhancement of airway responses to SP observed on the first dose-response curve but did not alter the enhancement of SP-induced airway responses produced by repeated SP challenge. The anticholinergic atropine (5 mg/kg iv), the antihistamine mepyramine (8 mg/kg iv), and the cyclooxygenase inhibitor indomethacin (30 mg/kg ip) had no effect on the first SP dose-response curve. Atropine and mepyramine did not prevent the enhancement of SP responses observed with repeated challenge, but after pretreatment with either indomethacin or acetylsalicylic acid, dose-response curves to SP were reproducible. Our results indicate that airway responses to intravenous SP are enhanced with repeated SP challenge and suggest that cyclooxygenase products of arachidonic acid metabolism are involved in the mediation of this phenomenon.     

Effect of GABA agonists on the neurotoxicity and anticonvulsant activity of benzodiazepines

Progabide (50 mg/kg, i.p.), a GABA receptor agonist, significantly decreases the median minimal neurotoxic dose (TD50) of clobazam, chlordiazepoxide, and diazepam; the receptor binding of these substances is highly enhanced by muscimol. Progabide has no significant effect on the TD50 of clonazepam and triazolam; the receptor bindings of these substances is either only slightly enhanced or not altered by muscimol. Progabide also significantly decreases the median antimaximal electroshock dose (MES ED50) of all the benzodiazepines tested. However, progabide has no effect on the median antipentylenetetrazol dose (PTZ ED50) of the benzodiazepines. Likewise, THIP (2.5 mg/kg, i.p.) significantly decreases the TD50 of chlordiazepoxide but not that of triazolam. THIP significantly decreases the MES ED50 of chlordiazepoxide and triazolam but has no effect on the PTZ ED50 of these two substances. The above data suggest that benzodiazepine receptors linked to GABA receptors contribute to the minimal neurotoxicity and anti-MES activity but not to the anti-PTZ activity of benzodiazepines.     

Statistical models for low dose exposure

Extrapolation of health risks from high to low doses has received a considerable amount of attention in carcinogenic risk assessment over decades. Fitting statistical dose-response models to experimental data collected at high doses and use of the fitted model for estimating effects at low doses lead to quite different risk predictions. Dissatisfaction with this procedure was formulated both by toxicologists who saw a deficit of biological knowledge in the models as well as by risk modelers who saw the need of mechanistically-based stochastic modeling. This contribution summarizes the present status of low dose modeling and the determination of the shape of dose-response curves. We will address the controversial issues of the appropriateness of threshold models, the estimation of no observed adverse effect levels (NOAEL), and their relevance for low dose modeling. We will distinguish between quantal dose-response models for tumor incidence and models of the more informative age/time dependent tumor incidence. The multistage model and the two-stage model of clonal expansion are considered as dose-response models accounting for biological mechanisms. Problems of the identifiability of mechanisms are addressed, the relation between administered dose and effective target dose is illustrated by examples, and the recently proposed Benchmark Dose concept for risk assessment is presented with its consequences for mechanistic modeling and statistical estimation.     

A reanalysis of thyroid neoplasms in the Israeli tinea capitis study accounting for dose uncertainties

In the 1940s and 1950s, children in Israel were treated for tinea capitis by irradiation to the scalp to induce epilation. Follow-up studies of these patients and of other radiation- exposed populations show an increased risk of malignant and benign thyroid tumors. Those analyses, however, assume that thyroid dose for individuals is estimated precisely without error. Failure to account for uncertainties in dosimetry may affect standard errors and bias dose-response estimates. For the Israeli tinea capitis study, we discuss sources of uncertainties and adjust dosimetry for uncertainties in the prediction of true dose from X-ray treatment parameters. We also account for missing ages at exposure for patients with multiple X-ray treatments, since only ages at first treatment are known, and for missing data on treatment center, which investigators use to define exposure. Our reanalysis of the dose response for thyroid cancer and benign thyroid tumors indicates that uncertainties in dosimetry have minimal effects on dose-response estimation and for inference on the modifying effects of age at first exposure, time since exposure, and other factors. Since the components of the dose uncertainties we describe are likely to be present in other epidemiological studies of patients treated with radiation, our analysis may provide a model for considering the potential role of these uncertainties.     

The effect of a synthetic anticholinergic agent, N-methyl hyoscine methyl sulfate, on the exocrine pancreatic secretion of the alert dog]

The inhibitory action of N-methyl hyoscine methyl sulphate (N-methyl scopolamine, an anticholinergic drug) has been studied on the exocrine pancreatic secretion stimulated by secretin + caerulein on the conscious dog provided with Thomas cannulae. The dose-response curve shows an "all or nothing" effect on protein secretion since 0.38 microgram/kg. The inhibition of water and bicarbonate secretion is only observed from 12 micrograms/kg. The inhibitory effect of this drug was much greater than that obtained with similar molar quantities of atropine and no central effect has been observed.     

Hormesis: changing view of the dose-response,a personal account of the history and current status

This paper provides a personal account of the history of the hormesis concept, and of the role of the dose response in toxicology and pharmacology. A careful evaluation of the toxicology and pharmacology literatures suggests that the biphasic dose response that characterizes hormesis may be much more widespread than is commonly recognized, and may come to rival our currently favored ideas about toxicological dose responses confined to the linear and threshold representations used in risk assessment. Although hormesis-like biphasic dose responses were already well-established in chemical and radiation toxicology by the early decades of the 20th century, they were all but expunged from mainstream toxicology in the 1930s. The reasons may be found in a complex set of unrelated problems of which difficulties in replication of low-dose stimulatory responses resulting from poor study designs, greater societal interest in high-dose effects, linking of the concept of hormesis to the practice of homeopathy, and perhaps most crucially a complete lack of strong leadership to advocate its acceptance in the right circles. I believe that if hormesis achieves widespread recognition as a valid and valuable interpretation of dose-response results, we would expect an increase in the breadth of evaluations of the dose-response relationship which could be of great value in hazard and risk assessment as well as in future approaches to drug development and/or chemotherapeutics.     

Application of the isobologram technique for the analysis of combined effects with respect to additivity as well as independence

Combined actions of two substances with similar effects are frequently expressed by pairs of doses that produce a fixed response, usually 50%, in so-called isobolograms (ED50 isobolograms). In addition to the dose scales in such graphs we propose the addition of effect scales, where possible, to indicate the effect at certain doses, e.g., the ED30. We further propose to construct isoboles for expected independent interaction, in addition to the additivity line, for which purpose a simple procedure is delineated. In practice, an independent isobole for 50% effect passes through the point formed by the ED30s of A and of B in ED50 isobolograms. Thus, the ED30s constitute the "zenith" of an independent isobole in ED50 isobolograms. It is shown that theoretical independent isoboles can either represent additive, overadditive, or underadditive interactions, depending on the steepness of the dose-response curves of the components. Hence, drugs with shallow dose-response curves exhibit overadditive independent effects, compounds with exponentially steep curves show additive independent interactions. Substances with very steep dose-response curves, producing lethal effects, exhibited marked underadditive effects which could be ascribed largely to an independent mechanism of action of the components. Hence, the inclusion of independent isoboles into conventional isobolograms provides new insights into the mechanisms of interactions and into the actions of the components. Interactions can thus be characterized better and more completely, and misinterpretations appear less likely than with conventional isoboles.     

Effects of an oriental herbal medicine, “Saiboku-to”, and its constituent herbs on Compound 48/80-induced histamine release from peritoneal mast cells in rats

Effects of a traditional oriental herbal medicine, "Saiboku-to" and its constituent herbs on Compound 48/80-induced histamine release from peritoneal mast cells in rats were investigated. Saiboku-to inhibited Compound 48/80-induced degranulation of and histamine release from the mast cells, suggesting that Saiboku-to not only possesses anti-histamine release effect from mast cells, but also contains active herbs with this effect. Significant inhibitions were found in 4 of 10 constituent herbs of Saiboku-to: Magnoliae Cortex, Perillae Herba, Bupleuri Radix and Hoelen. In the dose-response curves of the four herbs, the logarithmic linearity was observed for each herb, and 50% inhibitory concentration, the IC50 values, were calculated to be 56.8 microg/ml for Magnoliae Cortex, 175.8 microl/ml for Perillae Herba, 356.6 microg/ml for Bupleuri Radix, and 595.8 microg/ml for Hoelen. One mg/ml of Saiboku-to showing 75% inhibition of Compound 48/80-induced histamine release level from mast cells contains 88.5 microg of Magnoliae Cortex (it was estimated from the dose-response curve that this dose inhibits 62.68% of the Compound 48/80-induced histamine release level), 58.8 microg of Perillae Herba (21% inhibition), 205.9 microg of Bupleuri Radix (35.24% inhibition), and 147.1 microg of Hoelen (11.15% inhibition). From these results, it is suggested that the anti-histamine release effect of Saiboku-to, which contains 10 herbs, may be due mainly to the effect of Magnoliae Cortex and the synergism of the 3 other herbs.     

Comparison of cholin- and carboxylesterase enzyme inhibition and visible effects in the zebra fish embryo bioassay under short-term paraoxon-methyl exposure

The acute zebra fish embryo test (Danio rerio Hamilton-Buchanan, 1822) is an accepted bioassay to assess the toxicity of waste water that may be used for the replacement of testing with adult fish. It is also suggested for chemical hazard characterization and assessment, although only a few groups of substances have yet been studied. Specifically acting substances such as neurotoxic insecticides pose a potentially hazard for non-target fish. To establish whether the proposed zebra fish embryo test protocol and the inhibition of cholinesterases (acetylcholinesterase EC 3.1.1.7, propionylcholinesterase EC 3.1.1.8) and carboxylesterase (EC 3.1.1.1) enzymes can be used in a similar fashion for hazard characterization and risk assessment of chemicals and environmental samples, two types of experiments were conducted. Visual effects of exposure to the organophosphate metabolite paraoxon-methyl after 24 and 48 h in the zebra fish embryo test system were analysed with the use of an inverse microscope (rate of mortality, developmental disturbances, heart rate and others). The inhibition to cholinesterases and carboxylesterase was also measured. Enzyme inhibition as a biomarker of exposure was about 70 times more sensitive than the effects in the zebra fish embryo test with an IC₅₀ below 1.2 µmol compared with an EC₅₀ of 91 µmol. The dose-response relationships showed different curve characteristics with a linear increase of enzyme inhibition compared with a sigmoidal curve for the overt effects. Significant overt effects could only be seen at concentrations at which already 80% of the activities of the different esterases were inhibited.     

Eating nanomaterials: cruelty-free and safe? the EFSA guidance on risk assessment of nanomaterials in food and feed

Nanomaterials are increasingly being added to food handling and packaging materials, or directly, to human food and animal feed. To ensure the safety of such engineered nanomaterials (ENMs), in May 2011, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) published a guidance document on Risk assessment of the application of nanoscience and nanotechnologies in the food and feed chain. It states that risk assessment should be performed by following a step-wise procedure. Whenever human or animal exposure to nanomaterials is expected, the general hazard characterisation scheme requests information from in vitro genotoxicity, toxicokinetic and repeated dose 90-day oral toxicity studies in rodents. Numerous prevailing uncertainties with regard to nanomaterial characterisation and their hazard and risk assessment are addressed in the guidance document. This article discusses the impact of these knowledge gaps on meeting the goal of ensuring human safety. The EFSA's guidance on the risk assessment of ENMs in food and animal feed is taken as an example for discussion, from the point of view of animal welfare, on what level of uncertainty should be considered acceptable for human safety assessment of products with non-medical applications, and whether animal testing should be considered ethically acceptable for such products.     

Assessment of reproductive risks

In the regulatory process, the hazards posed by potentially toxic agents to the female and male reproductive systems and to developing young are evaluated by risk assessment procedures. In this paper, toxicity testing and the regulatory process are discussed, with emphasis on risk assessment. The suggested testing protocols of the Pesticide Assessment Guidelines (U.S. EPA) are presented as an example of testing that might be done to produce toxicity data for an agent. Protocols and end points that are utilized in testing for reproductive effects are described. Included are acute, subchronic, chronic, and short-term tests. The four components of reproductive risk assessment (hazard identification, dose-response assessment, exposure assessment, and risk characterization) are examined. Effects of dibromochloropropane on rabbit testicular parameters are used to demonstrate approaches that could be taken in doing a reproductive risk assessment. Research needs for screening methods, adequate dose-response testing, toxicokinetics, end point development, and extrapolation methods are identified. Finally, this paper discusses selected areas in which changes in reproductive risk assessment are anticipated, as well as the mechanism for influencing the nature and extent of those changes.     

Chromosome aberration induction in murine spermatocytes in joint exposure to radiation and sodium nitrite and nitrate]

In studying the combined effect of single and fractionated exposure to gamma/neutron radiation (12.5-50 cGy) and sodium nitrite (100 mg/kg) and chronic irradiation with a mixture of radiation (25 cGy) and sodium nitrite, nitrate (10-100 mg/l) the synergistic effect was observed in inducing reciprocal translocations in mouse spermatocytes. The dose-response function of the reciprocal translocations occurrence in Af mouse spermatocytes was nonlinear; there was a "plateau" within the dose range from 25 to 50 cGy.