Dynamics and histological characteristics of gonadal sex differentiation in pejerrey (Odontesthes bonariensis) at feminizing and masculinizing temperatures

This study evaluated the effects of different temperatures on the histological process of sex differentiation in the pejerrey Odontesthes bonariensis, a fish with marked temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD), at feminizing, neutral, and masculinizing temperatures. Fish reared at three temperatures (17 degrees C, 24 degrees C, and 29 degrees C) from hatching were sampled weekly until 11 weeks and their gonads were examined by histology. The percentages of females at 17 degrees C, 24 degrees C, and 29 degrees C were 100%, 73%, and 0%, respectively. Sex differentiation occurred earlier and at a smaller body size at higher temperatures in both sexes. The first signs of ovarian differentiation were observed at 4 and 7 weeks at 24 degrees C and 17 degrees C, respectively, and those of testicular differentiation at 4 and 7 weeks at 29 degrees C and 24 degrees C, respectively. Body or gonadal growth rates before sex differentiation were not proportional to temperature and showed no sexual dimorphism at 24 degrees C, where both sexes were present. Thus, differential growth rate is probably not a factor in TSD or histological sex differentiation in pejerrey. Blood vessels were formed before sex differentiation in both sexes and at all temperatures, and may be important for sex differentiation. No signs of intersexuality were found in any of the groups, and this characterizes pejerrey as the differentiated type of gonochorist even at feminizing and masculinizing temperatures. Ovaries were formed by the same histological processes at feminizing (17 degrees C) and neutral (24 degrees C) temperatures and without any pathological features such as germ cell degeneration. The process of testicular formation was generally similar at 24 degrees C and 29 degrees C, but some fish at 29 degrees C had widespread germ cell degeneration before sex differentiation. This suggests that pathological processes leading to germ cell death, such as heat-induced dysfunction of the supporting somatic cells, could be involved in masculinization of the genetic females at high temperatures.     

Cortisol-Induced Masculinization: Does Thermal Stress Affect Gonadal Fate in Pejerrey,a Teleost Fish with Temperature-Dependent Sex Determination?

Background

Gonadal fate in many reptiles, fish, and amphibians is modulated by the temperature experienced during a critical period early in life (temperature-dependent sex determination; TSD). Several molecular processes involved in TSD have been described but how the animals “sense” environmental temperature remains unknown. We examined whether the stress-related hormone cortisol mediates between temperature and sex differentiation of pejerrey, a gonochoristic teleost fish with marked TSD, and the possibility that it involves glucocorticoid receptor- and/or steroid biosynthesis-modulation.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Larvae maintained during the period of gonadal sex differentiation at a masculinizing temperature (29°C; 100% males) consistently had higher cortisol, 11-ketotestoterone (11-KT), and testosterone (T) titres than those at a feminizing temperature (17°C; 100% females). Cortisol-treated animals had elevated 11-KT and T, and showed a typical molecular signature of masculinization including amh upregulation, cyp19a1a downregulation, and higher incidence of gonadal apoptosis during sex differentiation. Administration of cortisol and a non-metabolizable glucocorticoid receptor (GR) agonist (Dexamethasone) to larvae at a “sexually neutral” temperature (24°C) caused significant increases in the proportion of males.

Conclusions/Significance

Our results suggest a role of cortisol in the masculinization of pejerrey and provide a possible link between stress and testicular differentiation in this gonochoristic TSD species. Cortisol role or roles during TSD of pejerrey seem(s) to involve both androgen biosynthesis- and GR-mediated processes. These findings and recent reports of cortisol effects on sex determination of sequential hermaphroditic fishes, TSD reptiles, and birds provide support to the notion that stress responses might be involved in various forms of environmental sex determination.     

Rainbow trout gonadal masculinization induced by inhibition of estrogen synthesis is more physiological than masculinization induced by androgen supplementation

The present study was designed to obtain new insights into fish gonadal sex differentiation by comparing the effects of two different masculinizing treatments on some candidate gene expression profiles. Masculinization was induced in rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss, genetic all-female populations using either an active fish androgen (11betaAnd, 11beta-hydroxyandrostenedione) or an aromatase inhibitor (ATD, 1,4,6-androstatriene-3,17-dione). The expression profiles of 100 candidate genes were obtained by real-time RT-PCR, and 46 profiles displayed a significant differential expression between control populations (males and females) and ATD/11betaAnd-treated populations. These expression profiles were grouped in four temporally correlated expression clusters. Among the common responses shared by the two masculinizing treatments, the inhibition of some early female differentiating genes (cyp19a1, foxl2a, fst, and fshb) appears to be crucial for effective masculinization, suggesting that these genes act together via a short regulation loop to maintain high sex-specific ovarian expression of cyp19a1. This simultaneous down-regulation of female-specific genes could be triggered by some testicular genes, such as dmrt1, nr0b1 (also known as dax1), and pdgfra, which are quickly up-regulated by the two masculinizing treatments. In contrast to 11betaAnd, ATD quickly restored the expression levels of steroidogenesis related genes (cyp11b2.1, cyp11b2.2, hsd3b1, cyp17a, star, and nr5a1) and some Sertoli cell markers (sox9a2 and amh) to the expression levels observed during control testicular differentiation. This demonstrates that these genes are probably not needed for active masculinization and that the inhibition of endogenous estrogen synthesis produces a much more complete and specific testicular pattern of gene expression than that observed following androgen-induced masculinization.     

Epigenetic control of cyp19a1a expression is critical for high temperature induced Nile tilapia masculinization

In fish species with temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) or genotypic sex determination plus temperature effects (GSD + TE), temperature can either affect sex differentiation or determine the sex. However, it is unknown if epigenetic control of cyp19a1a expression is critical for high temperature induced masculinization in the freshwater fish Nile tilapia. We analyzed the cyp19a1a DNA methylation levels in three age groups and found that they were lower in females than in males. At 8 months of age, males had DNA methylation levels of the cyp19a1a promoter that were almost twice as high as those of females. Exposure to high temperatures increased the cyp19a1a promoter DNA methylation levels from 30.87 ± 4.56% to 48.34 ± 0.92% (P = 0.035) in females and from 50.33 ± 7.38% to 51.66 ± 4.75% in males (P = 0.867). The increases in the cyp19a1a promoter DNA methylation levels were associated with the mRNA expression levels and might play a role in promoting gonadal differentiation in high temperature induced group females toward the male pathway. Western blot analysis revealed that the cyp19a1a protein expression levels in females significantly declined after high temperature treatment; only a slight decline was recorded in male fish. These results reveal that epigenetic control of cyp19a1a mRNA and protein expression is related to the environmental temperature and sex ratios in fish with TSD or GSD + TE.     

Aromatase plays a key role during normal and temperature-induced sex differentiation of tilapia Oreochromis niloticus.

In the tilapia Oreochromis niloticus, sex is determined genetically (GSD), by temperature (TSD) or by temperature/genotype interactions. Functional masculinization can be achieved by applying high rearing temperatures during a critical period of sex differentiation. Estrogens play an important role in female differentiation of non-mammalian vertebrates. The involvement of aromatase, was assessed during the natural (genetic all-females and all-males at 27 degrees C) and temperature-induced sex differentiation of tilapia (genetic all-females at 35 degrees C). Gonads were dissected between 486--702 degree x days. Aromatase gene expression was analyzed by virtual northern and semi-quantitative RT-PCR revealing a strong expression during normal ovarian differentiation concomitant with high levels (465 +/- 137 fg/g) of oestradiol-17 beta (E2-17 beta). This was encountered in gonads after the onset of ovarian differentiation (proliferation of both stromal and germ cells prior to ovarian meiosis). Genetic males exhibited lower levels of aromatase gene expression and E2-17 beta quantities (71 +/- 23 fg/ g). Aromatase enzyme activity in fry heads established a sexual dimorphism in the brain, with high activity in females (377.9 pmol/head/hr) and low activity in males (221.53 pmol/head/hr). Temperature induced the masculinization of genetic females to a different degree in each progeny, but in all cases repression of aromatase expression was encountered. Genetic males at 35 degrees C also exhibited a repression of aromatase expression. Aromatase brain activity decreased by nearly three-fold in the temperature-masculinized females with also a reduction observed in genetic males at 35 degrees C. This suggests that aromatase repression is required in the gonad (and perhaps in the brain) in order to drive differentiation towards testis development. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 59:265-276, 2001.     

Where does gonadal sex differentiation begin? Gradient of histological sex differentiation in the gonads of pejerrey,Odontesthes bonariensis (Pisces,Atherinidae)

This study investigated the possibility that the histological process of gonadal sex differentiation in pejerrey (Odontesthes bonariensis), a fish with marked temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD), occurs through a predictable gradient of differentiation as opposed to simultaneous or random differentiation throughout the gonad. For this purpose, fish reared at 17 degrees, 24 degrees, and 29 degrees C from hatching were sampled weekly for 11 weeks, fixed, and prepared for histological observation of serial cross-sections of the gonads. The thermal manipulation and sampling procedure ensured the availability of males and females at various degrees of gonadal sex differentiation. The location of the differentiated area(s) was estimated in the right and left gonads of 17 females and 14 males selected among the available specimens so as to represent increasing degrees of differentiation. The analysis revealed that sex differentiation followed a gradient from the anterior to posterior areas of the gonads regardless of sex. Furthermore, plotting of the degree of sex differentiation in the right gonad as a function of the degree of differentiation of the left gonad clearly showed that sex differentiation only begins in the right gonad when 10-30% of the length of the left gonad has already differentiated. The mean rostral edge of the differentiated areas in females was 9% and 10.8% for the left and right gonads, respectively, while for males these values were 7.3% and 7.0%, respectively. Thus, it was established that ovarian and testicular differentiation in pejerrey follow both a cephalocaudal and a left-to-right gradient. Possible explanations for this gradient and its relevance for TSD in pejerrey, that is, as a mechanism to prevent discrepant differentiation of male and female features within the same gonad, are discussed.     

Real-time PCR analysis of ovary- and brain-type aromatase gene expression during Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus) development

Two forms of cytochrome P450 aromatase, acting in both the brain and the ovary, have been implicated in controlling ovarian development in fish. To better understand the expression of these two enzymes during sexual differentiation in Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus), real-time PCR was used to quantify the mRNA levels of ovary- (cyp19a) and brain-type cytochrome P450 aromatase (cyp19b) genes in the gonad and brain during gonadal development. Both enzymes showed high levels of expression in both tissues in developmental stages prior to histologically detectable ovarian differentiation (38 mm fork length), with increased expression occurring slightly earlier in the brain than the gonad. Cyp19a showed a second peak of expression in later stages (> 48 mm) in the gonad, but not the brain. Cyp19b expression was generally higher in the brain than the gonad. These results suggest that sexual differentiation may begin in the brain prior to gonadal differentiation, supporting the idea that steroid hormone expression in the brain is a key determinant of phenotypic sex in fish. In an examination of sexually immature adults, cyp19a was highly expressed in female gonad while cyp19b was very highly expressed in the pituitary of both sexes. The ratio of cyp19a to cyp19b expression was much higher in ovaries than in testes in the adult fish, so this ratio was analyzed in the developing gonads of juvenile halibut in an attempt to infer their sex. This was only partially successful, with about half the fish in later developmental stages showing apparently sex-specific differences in aromatase expression.     

Time required for temperature-induced changes in gonadal aromatase activity and related gonadal structure in turtle embryos

Abstract. In the turtle Emys orbicularis , sexual differentiation of gonads is temperature-dependent. Oestrogens have been shown to be involved in this phenomenon and temperature has been expected to act, directly or indirectly, on regulation of synthesis or activity of cytochrome P-450 aromatase (P-450 arom). We have studied the effects of temperature shifts and of exposure at female- or male-producing temperatures for different times on gonadal aromatase activity and gonadal structure. In a first series of experiments, eggs were incubated at 25°C (masculinizing temperature) up to stage 18 and then exposed for 1 to 8 days at 35°C, a highly feminizing temperature. The response was exponential: aromatase activity increased clearly only after 4 day exposure at 35°C, then it was considerably enhanced. After 1 and 2 days at 35°C, the structure of gonads was not modified. With longer exposures at 35°C, gonads were progressively feminized: medullary epithelial cords disappeared, whereas an ovarian cortex was forming. In another type of experiment, eggs incubated at 30°C (feminizing temperature) until stage 19 were transferred at 25°C for 6 days. In embryos of these shifted eggs, gonadal aromatase activity was about ninefold lower than that in control embryos (maintained at 30°C). However, this activity did not fall to the level measured in embryos of the same stage incubated at 25°C from egg-laying and was about twofold higher than that measured at the time of transfer. Gonads exhibited a cortex anlage but the medulla was more voluminous than that of controls and epithelial cords were beginning to form within. Together these results show that changes in gonadal aromatase activity and in gonadal structure are correlated, and that temperature acts on regulation of P-450 arom synthesis. Amplification of this synthesis during the thermosensitive period at higher temperatures could reflect amplification of expression of the P-450 arom gene.     

Liver receptor homologue-1 (LRH-1) activates the promoter of brain aromatase (cyp19a2) in a teleost fish, the medaka, Oryzias latipes

The medaka, Oryzias latipes, like other fish, have two distinct aromatase genes, the ovarian (cyp19a1) and brain (cyp19a2) forms. We previously reported that Ad4BP/SF-1, a member of the NR5A subfamily, plays an important role in the regulation of cyp19a1 expression in medaka ovarian follicles during vitellogenesis. In the present study, we investigated whether liver receptor homologue-1 (LRH-1), another NR5A subfamily member, is involved in the regulation of cyp19a2 expression in the medaka brain. In situ hybridization analysis revealed that LRH-1 was expressed in the hypothalamus, where it colocalized with aromatase (cyp19a2). We then showed by transient transfection assays that LRH-1 was able to increase expression of a cyp19a2 reporter gene in various mammalian cell lines, and that mutation of a putative LRH-1 binding site within the cyp19a2 promoter abolished this effect. Taken together, these findings suggest that LRH-1 plays a role in regulating cyp19a2 expression in the medaka brain. This is the first to demonstrate in vitro the activation of brain aromatase by LRH-1 in the vertebrate brain.     

Sex determination in flatfishes: Mechanisms and environmental influences

Flounder of the genus Paralichthys exhibit a unique mode of sex determination where both low and high temperatures induce male-skewed sex ratios, while intermediate temperatures produce a 1:1 sex ratio. Male differentiation is thus easily induced in genetic females creating a combination of genetic (GSD) and environmental sex determination (ESD). Since male flounder become reproductively fit at substantially smaller body sizes than females, temperature or other environmental variables that elicit lower growth rates may also influence sex differentiation toward male development. This review covers our current knowledge of sex determination and differentiation in flatfishes including possible adaptive significance of ESD and involvement of factors such as aromatase (cyp19).     

Effects of short periods of warm water fluctuations on reproductive endocrine axis of the pejerrey (Odontesthes bonariensis) spawning

The aim of this study was to assess fluctuations in daily water temperature in Chascomús Lagoon during one year, and to evaluate whether the highest temperature recorded during pejerrey spawning season can produce an endocrine disruption on brain-pituitary-gonads axis. Fish were subjected to daily temperature fluctuations: 17 °C to 19 °C (reproductive control), 19 °C to 25 °C, and 19 °C to 27 °C. After 8 days, ten fish per treatment were sacrificed and gene expression of gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH-I, GnRH-II, GnRH-III), gonadotropin subunits-β (FSH-β, LH-β), glycoprotein hormone-α (GPH-α), gonadotropin receptors (FSH-R, LH-R), and gonadal aromatase (cyp19a1a) was analyzed. Also, plasma levels of sexual steroids and gonadal reproductive status were studied. Fish exposed to high temperature fluctuations quit spawning, presenting clear signs of gonadal regression. Fish recovered its spawning activity 11 weeks after heat treatment. At endocrine level, GnRH-I and FSH-β in both sexes, LH-β and GPH-α in males and FSH-R, LH-R and cyp19a1a in females decreased significantly in treated fish. Also, a strong reduction in plasma sex steroid levels was found for both sexes. This study demonstrated that pulses of warm water in natural environment during pejerrey spawning season can disrupt all levels of the reproductive axis, impairing reproduction.     

Aromatase activity in gonads of turtle embryos as a function of the incubation temperature of eggs

In embryos of the European pond turtle, sexual differentiation of gonads is temperature-dependent. Production of oestrogens appears to play a key role in this phenomenon. Gonadal aromatase activity was measured in embryos incubated at 25°C (masculinizing temperature) and at 30°C (feminizing temperature). At the beginning of the thermosensitive period, the aromatase activity was low at both temperatures but was somewhat higher at 30 than at 25°C. Afterwards, it remained low in differentiating testes at 25°C, whereas it increased in differentiating ovaries at 30°C to form a marked peak when germ cells underwent meiotic prophase. Eggs were shifted either from 25 to 30°C (highly feminizing) or from 30 to 35°C for 6 days at different stages of embryonic development. The 25–35°C shifts performed during the thermosensitive period strongly increased the aromatase activity but were ineffective after this period. The 30–35°C shifts increased the aromatase activity at all stages. Altogether, results indicate that, in differentiating gonads of turtle embryos, temperature acts on the regulation of synthesis (and therefore activity) of cytochrome P-450 aromatase (P-450-aro). The expression of the P-450-aro gene itself could be temperature-dependent. However, temperature could also act upon the expression of another gene involved in P-450-aro regulation.     

Temperature sex-reversal in amphibians and reptiles

The sexual differentiation of gonads has been shown to be temperature-sensitive in many species of amphibians and reptiles. In two close species of salamanders, Pleurodeles poireti and P. waltl, both displaying a ZZ/ZW mechanism of genotypic sex determination (GSD), the rearing of larvae at high temperatures (30 degrees-32 degrees C) produces opposite effects: ZZ genotypic males of Pleurodeles poireti become phenotypic females whereas ZW genotypic females of P. waltl become phenotypic males. Sex-reversal of these individuals has been irrefutably demonstrated through genetic, cytogenetic, enzymatic and immunological studies. In many turtles, both sexes differentiate only within a critical range of temperature: above this range, all the individuals become phenotypic females, whereas below it, 100% become phenotypic males. The inverse occurs in some crocodiles and lizards. In many species of these three orders of reptiles, females are obtained at low and high temperatures, and males at intermediate ones. Preliminary studies in turtles (Emys orbicularis) indicate that within the critical range of temperature, sexual phenotype conforms with GSD, but that above and below this range, GSD is overriden. Temperature shifts during larval development in salamanders and during embryonic development in reptiles allowed the determination of thermosensitive stages for gonadal differentiation. Estrogens synthesized in the gonads at these stages appear to be involved in their sexual differentiation, higher levels being produced at feminizing temperatures than at masculinizing ones. The phenomenon of temperature sensitivity of gonadal differentiation occurs in species showing a very early stage in the evolution of sex chromosomes. Its adaptive value, chiefly in reptiles, remains an open question.