Minigene reporter for identification and analysis of cis elements and trans factors affecting pre-mRNA splicing

All human genes contain a diverse array of cis-acting elements within introns and exons that are required for correct and efficient precursor messenger RNA (pre-mRNA) splicing. Recent computational analyses predict that most human exons contain elements required for splicing coinciding with an appreciation for the high frequency with which mutations that disruption pre-mRNA splicing cause disease. Minigenes provide a means to directly determine whether disease-causing mutations or single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) affect splicing efficiency. Minigenes have also been instrumental in investigations of alternative splicing to identify cis elements required for cell-specific splicing events, demonstrating regulation of individual splicing events by specific RNA binding proteins, and correlating binding of these splicing regulators with splicing regulation. Here we present a versatile minigene plasmid vector designed for rapid cloning and analysis of cis elements and trans-acting factors that influence splicing efficiency or regulate cell-specific splicing. Ubiquitous expression and unique restriction sites allow for straightforward replacement of a variety of gene segments to analyze the effects of nucleotide substitutions on splicing, to identify tissue-specific regulatory elements, or to determine responsiveness to coexpressed proteins or small molecules.     

The yeast RNA gene products are essential for mRNA splicing in vitro

The yeast rna mutations (rna2-rna11) are a set of temperature-sensitive mutations that result in the accumulation of intron-containing mRNA precursors at the restrictive temperature. We have used the yeast in vitro splicing system to investigate the role of products of the RNA genes in mRNA splicing. We have tested the heat lability of the in vitro mRNA splicing reaction in extracts isolated from mutant and wild-type cells. Extracts isolated from seven of the nine rna mutants demonstrated heat lability in this assay, while most wild-type extracts were stable under the conditions utilized. We have also demonstrated that heat inactivation usually results in the specific loss of an exchangeable component by showing that most combinations of heat-inactivated extracts from different mutants complement one another. In three cases (rna2, rna5, and rna11), the linkage of the in vitro defect to the rna mutations was ascertained by a combination of reversion, tetrad, and in vitro complementation analyses. Furthermore, each heat-inactivated extract was capable of complementation by at least one fraction of the wild-type splicing system. Thus many of the RNA genes are likely to code for products directly involved in and essential for mRNA splicing.     

Multiple functional domains of human U2 small nuclear RNA: strengthening conserved stem I can block splicing.

We showed previously that a branch site mutation in simian virus 40 early pre-mRNA that prevented small t antigen mRNA splicing could be efficiently suppressed by a compensatory mutation in a coexpressed U2 small nuclear (sn) RNA gene. We have now generated second-site mutations in this suppressor gene to investigate regions of U2 RNA required for function. A number of mutations in a putative stem at the 5' end of the molecule inhibited splicing, indicating that bases in this region are important for activity. However, several lines of evidence suggested that formation of the entire stem is not essential for splicing. Indeed, mutations that strengthen the stem actually inhibited splicing, and evidence that this prevents a required base-pairing interaction with U6 snRNA is presented. These results suggest that the relative stabilities of competing intra- and intermolecular base-pairing interactions play an important role in the splicing reaction. Mutations in a conserved single-stranded region immediately 3' to the branch site recognition sequence all inhibited splicing, indicating that this region is required for U2 function, although its exact role remains unknown. Finally, two mutations in the loop of stem IV at the 3' end of the molecule, which destroy the binding site of U2 sn ribonucleoprotein B", prevented small t splicing; this finding contrasts with previous studies which utilized different assay systems. Analysis of the accumulation and subcellular localization of all of the mutant RNAs showed that they were similar to those of the parental suppressor U2 RNA, indicating that the effects observed indeed reflect defects in splicing.     

Synthetic lethal mutations suggest interactions between U5 small nuclear RNA and four proteins required for the second step of splicing.

To investigate the function of the U5 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein (snRNP) in pre-mRNA splicing, we have screened for factors that genetically interact with Saccharomyces cerevisiae U5 snRNA. We isolated trans-acting mutations that exacerbate the phenotypes of conditional alleles of the U5 snRNA and named these genes SLU, for synergistically lethal with U5 snRNA. SLU1 and SLU2 are essential for the first catalytic step of splicing, while SLU7 and SLU4 (an allele of PRP17 [U. Vijayraghavan, M. Company, and J. Abelson, Genes Dev. 3:1206-1216, 1989]) are required only for the second step of splicing. Furthermore, slu4-1 and slu7-1 are lethal in combination with mutations in PRP16 and PRP18, which also function in the second step, but not with mutations in factors required for the first catalytic step, such as PRP8 and PRP4. We infer from these data that SLU4, SLU7, PRP18, PRP16, and the U5 snRNA interact functionally and that a major role of the U5 snRNP is to coordinate a set of factors that are required for the completion of the second catalytic step of splicing.     

RNA11 protein is associated with the yeast spliceosome and is localized in the periphery of the cell nucleus.

The yeast rna mutations (rna2 through rna10/11) are a set of temperature-sensitive mutations that result in the accumulation of pre-mRNAs at the nonpermissive temperature. Most of the yeast RNA gene products are involved in and essential for mRNA splicing in vitro, suggesting that they code for components of the splicing machinery. We tested this proposal by using an in vitro-synthesized RNA11 protein to complement the temperature-sensitive defect of the rna11 extract. During the in vitro complementation, the input RNA11 protein was associated with the 40S spliceosome and a 30S complex, suggesting that the RNA11 protein is indeed a component of the spliceosome. The formation of the RNA11-associated 30S complex did not require any exogenous RNA substrate, suggesting that this 30S particle is likely to be a preassembled complex involved in splicing. The RNA11-specific antibody inhibited the mRNA splicing in vitro, confirming the essential role of the RNA11 protein in mRNA splicing. Finally, using the anti-RNA11 antibody, we localized the RNA11 protein to the periphery of the yeast nucleus.     

Intron mutations that affect the splicing efficiency of the CYH2 gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Summary To define the extent of intervening sequences required for efficient splicing of the CYH2 gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, we have constructed a series of intron mutations. Artificial intron extensions of more than 300 bp of the natural intron lead to an inhibition of splicing where-as intron deletions lead to a drastic improvement of the splicing efficiency. It is shown that deletion of a 32 bp sequence element within the intron is responsible for this drastic improvement.     

Mutations in conserved intron sequences affect multiple steps in the yeast splicing pathway, particularly assembly of the spliceosome.

Yeast introns contain three highly conserved sequences which are known to be required for splicing of pre-mRNA. Using in vitro mutagenesis, we have synthesized seven point mutations at five different sites in these signals in the yeast actin intron. The mutant introns were then inserted into each of three constructs, which allowed us to assess the consequences both in vivo and in vitro. In virtually every case, we found the efficiency of splicing to be significantly depressed; mature mRNA levels in vivo ranged from 0 to 47% of wild-type. Surprisingly, the tightest mutations were not necessarily at the sites of nucleolytic cleavage and branch formation; these nucleotides are thus highly preferred, but are not absolutely necessary. Moreover, while particular nucleotides are specifically required for the final step in splicing, i.e. 3' cleavage and exon ligation, the predominant consequence of mutation within the conserved signals appears to be the inhibition of assembly of the splicing complex.     

The carboxy terminal WD domain of the pre-mRNA splicing factor Prp17p is critical for function

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Prp17p is required for the efficient completion of the second step of pre-mRNA splicing. The function and interacting factors for this protein have not been elucidated. We have performed a mutational analysis of yPrp17p to identify protein domains critical for function. A series of deletions were made throughout the region spanning the N-terminal 158 amino acids of the protein, which do not contain any identified structural motifs. The C-terminal portion (amino acids 160-455) contains a WD domain containing seven WD repeats. We determined that a minimal functional Prp17p consists of the WD domain and 40 amino acids N-terminal to it. We generated a three-dimensional model of the WD repeats in Prp17p based on the crystal structure of the beta-transducin WD domain. This model was used to identify potentially important amino acids for in vivo functional characterization. Through analysis of mutations in four different loops of Prp17p that lie between beta strands in the WD repeats, we have identified four amino acids, 235TETG238, that are critical for function. These amino acids are predicted to be surface exposed and may be involved in interactions that are important for splicing. Temperature-sensitive prp17 alleles with mutations of these four amino acids are defective for the second step of splicing and are synthetically lethal with a U5 snRNA loop I mutation, which is also required for the second step of splicing. These data reinforce the functional significance of this region within the WD domain of Prp17p in the second step of splicing.     

The translation initiation factor eIF4E regulates the sex-specific expression of the master switch gene Sxl in Drosophila melanogaster

In female fruit flies, Sex-lethal (Sxl) turns off the X chromosome dosage compensation system by a mechanism involving a combination of alternative splicing and translational repression of the male specific lethal-2 (msl-2) mRNA. A genetic screen identified the translation initiation factor eif4e as a gene that acts together with Sxl to repress expression of the Msl-2 protein. However, eif4e is not required for Sxl mediated repression of msl-2 mRNA translation. Instead, eif4e functions as a co-factor in Sxl-dependent female-specific alternative splicing of msl-2 and also Sxl pre-mRNAs. Like other factors required for Sxl regulation of splicing, eif4e shows maternal-effect female-lethal interactions with Sxl. This female lethality can be enhanced by mutations in other co-factors that promote female-specific splicing and is caused by a failure to properly activate the Sxl-positive autoregulatory feedback loop in early embryos. In this feedback loop Sxl proteins promote their own synthesis by directing the female-specific alternative splicing of Sxl-Pm pre-mRNAs. Analysis of pre-mRNA splicing when eif4e activity is compromised demonstrates that Sxl-dependent female-specific splicing of both Sxl-Pm and msl-2 pre-mRNAs requires eif4e activity. Consistent with a direct involvement in Sxl-dependent alternative splicing, eIF4E is associated with unspliced Sxl-Pm pre-mRNAs and is found in complexes that contain early acting splicing factors--the U1/U2 snRNP protein Sans-fils (Snf), the U1 snRNP protein U1-70k, U2AF38, U2AF50, and the Wilms' Tumor 1 Associated Protein Fl(2)d--that have been directly implicated in Sxl splicing regulation.     

Genetic Studies of the Prp17 Gene of Saccharomyces Cerevisiae: A Domain Essential for Function Maps to a Nonconserved Region of the Protein

The PRP17 gene product is required for the second step of pre-mRNA splicing reactions. The C-terminal half of this protein bears four repeat units with homology to the β transducin repeat. Missense mutations in three temperature-sensitive prp17 mutants map to a region in the N-terminal half of the protein. We have generated, in vitro, 11 missense alleles at the β transducin repeat units and find that only one affects function in vivo. A phenotypically silent missense allele at the fourth repeat unit enhances the slow-growing phenotype conferred by an allele at the third repeat, suggesting an interaction between these domains. Although many missense mutations in highly conserved amino acids lack phenotypic effects, deletion analysis suggests an essential role for these units. Only mutations in the N-terminal nonconserved domain of PRP17 are synthetically lethal in combination with mutations in PRP16 and PRP18, two other gene products required for the second splicing reaction. A mutually allele-specific interaction between prp17 and snr7, with mutations in U5 snRNA, was observed. We therefore suggest that the functional region of Prp17p that interacts with Prp18p, Prp16p, and U5 snRNA is in the N terminal region of the protein.     

The neurospora CYT-18 protein suppresses defects in the phage T4 td intron by stabilizing the catalytically active structure of the intron core.

The Neurospora CYT-18 protein, a tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase, which functions in splicing group I introns in mitochondria, promotes splicing of mutants of the distantly related bacteriophage T4 td intron. In an in vivo assay, wild-type CYT-18 protein expressed in E. coli suppressed mutations in the td intron's catalytic core. CYT-18-suppressible mutations were also suppressed by high Mg2+ or spermidine in vitro, suggesting they affect intron structure. Both the N- and C-terminal domains of CYT-18 are required for efficient splicing, but CYT-18 with a large C-terminal truncation retains some activity. Our results indicate that CYT-18 interacts with conserved structural features of group I introns, and they provide direct evidence that a protein promotes splicing by stabilizing the catalytically active structure of the intron RNA.     

AG-dependent 3'-splice sites are predisposed to aberrant splicing due to a mutation at the first nucleotide of an exon

In pre-mRNA splicing, a conserved AG/G at the 3'-splice site is recognized by U2AF(35). A disease-causing mutation abrogating the G nucleotide at the first position of an exon (E(+1)) causes exon skipping in GH1, FECH and EYA1, but not in LPL or HEXA. Knockdown of U2AF(35) enhanced exon skipping in GH1 and FECH. RNA-EMSA revealed that wild-type FECH requires U2AF(35) but wild-type LPL does not. A series of artificial mutations in the polypyrimidine tracts of GH1, FECH, EYA1, LPL and HEXA disclosed that a stretch of at least 10-15 pyrimidines is required to ensure normal splicing in the presence of a mutation at E(+1). Analysis of nine other disease-causing mutations at E(+1) detected five splicing mutations. Our studies suggest that a mutation at the AG-dependent 3'-splice site that requires U2AF(35) for spliceosome assembly causes exon skipping, whereas one at the AG-independent 3'-splice site that does not require U2AF(35) gives rise to normal splicing. The AG-dependence of the 3'-splice site that we analyzed in disease-causing mutations at E(+1) potentially helps identify yet unrecognized splicing mutations at E(+1).     

Pre-mRNA secondary structures influence exon recognition

The secondary structure of a pre-mRNA influences a number of processing steps including alternative splicing. Since most splicing regulatory proteins bind to single-stranded RNA, the sequestration of RNA into double strands could prevent their binding. Here, we analyzed the secondary structure context of experimentally determined splicing enhancer and silencer motifs in their natural pre-mRNA context. We found that these splicing motifs are significantly more single-stranded than controls. These findings were validated by transfection experiments, where the effect of enhancer or silencer motifs on exon skipping was much more pronounced in single-stranded conformation. We also found that the structural context of predicted splicing motifs is under selection, suggesting a general importance of secondary structures on splicing and adding another level of evolutionary constraints on pre-mRNAs. Our results explain the action of mutations that affect splicing and indicate that the structural context of splicing motifs is part of the mRNA splicing code.     

Sequence requirements in different steps of the pre-mRNA splicing reaction: analysis by the RNA modification-exclusion technique.

The stepwise assembly of splicing complexes and the subsequent splicing reaction were analyzed by the RNA modification-exclusion technique, which generates the equivalent of a complete set of point mutations in a single reaction. We found that although the sequences surrounding the 5' splice site, the branch point, and the 3' splice site, including the 3' AG, were required for presplicing complex formation, modified nucleotides at these positions were not completely excluded. The same sequences were required for splicing complex formation; however, modified nucleotides in these sequences were excluded to a much greater extent.