The Immune Tolerance Network at 10 years: tolerance research at the bedside

Immune tolerance-inducing therapies reprogramme immune cells to eliminate pathogenic immune responses while preserving protective immunity. The Immune Tolerance Network (ITN), sponsored by the US National Institutes of Health, was established in 1999 to evaluate new tolerance-inducing therapies and carry out mechanistic studies using a unique interactive approach in partnership with industry, academia and foundations. Ten years later, the ITN has carried out approximately 36 clinical trials and tolerance studies examining innovative tolerogenic approaches in the settings of allergy, autoimmune diseases and organ transplantation. ITN investigators have published more than 80 original research papers based on this work. This Timeline article summarizes the progress and challenges of clinical research in the ITN.     

Conventional immunosuppression and co-stimulation blockade

Organ transplantation has become an accepted and successful therapeutic intervention for many patients with end-stage organ disease. Current conventional immunosuppressive regimens achieve very good short-term allograft survival but long-term outcomes are less than adequate. Furthermore, non-specific immunosuppression has its attendant side-effects including increased risks of malignancy and infection as well as drug-specific sequellae. With recent advances in the field of immunology, promising new therapies have arisen that could potentially eliminate lifelong drug therapy and promote indefinite acceptance of the donor tissue. Identification of co-stimulatory signals essential for T-cell activation has provided exciting new possibilities for controlling the alloimmune response. The compatibility of these new agents with proven conventional therapeutics has yielded mixed results. When used in combination, their immunosuppressive properties appear synergistic. However, if the goal of therapy is sustained, specific T-cell hyporesponsiveness, many conventional agents antagonize the effects of co-stimulatory blockade in several immune tolerance models.     

HIV therapy in the post-eradication era

Over the past three years, most efforts of virologists and immunologists involved in the field of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) have been focussed on strategies aimed at eradicating the infection. So far, however, all the approaches have been unsuccessful. Indeed, even if the currently available potent antiretroviral regimens are able to induce a profound and durable suppression of viral replication, they have poor effect on a viral reservoir of latently infected CD4+ T lymphocytes that rapidly reactivate after treatment discontinuation. Different approaches, including combined (immune based and antiretroviral) therapies, are therefore under investigation. The goal is to achieve an equilibrium where virus-induced immune dysfunction is prevented by an effective anti HIV immune response.     

Modeling Rejection Immunity

ABSTRACT: Background Transplantation is often the only way to treat a number of diseases leading to organ failure. To overcome rejection towards the trans- planted organ (graft), immunosuppression therapies are used, which have considerable side-effects and expose patients to opportunistic infections. The development of a model to complement the physician's experience in speci- fying therapeutic regimens is therefore desirable. The present work proposes an Ordinary Differential Equations model ac- counting for immune cell proliferation in response to the sudden entry of graft antigens, through different activation mechanisms. The model consid- ers the effect of a single immunosuppressive medication (e.g. cyclosporine), subject to first-order linear kinetics and acting by modifying, in a saturable concentration-dependent fashion, the proliferation coefficient. The latter has been determined experimentally. All other model parameter values have been set so as to reproduce reported state variable time-courses, and to maintain consistency with one another and with the experimentally derived proliferation coefficient. Results The proposed model substantially simplifies the chain of events potentially leading to organ rejection. It is however able to simulate quanti- tatively the time course of graft-related antigen and competent immunore- active cell populations, showing the long-term alternative outcomes of rejec- tion, tolerance or tolerance at a reduced functional tissue mass. In particu- lar, the model shows that it may be difficult to attain tolerance at full tissue mass with acceptably low doses of a single immunosuppressant, in accord with clinical experience. Conclusions The introduced model is mathematically consistent with known physiology and can reproduce variations in immune status and allograft sur- vival after transplantation. The model can be adapted to represent different therapeutic schemes and may offer useful indications for the optimization of therapy protocols in the transplanted patient.     

Molecular therapies for systemic lupus erythematosus: clinical trials and future prospects

The prognosis of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus has greatly improved since treatment regimens combining corticosteroids and immunosuppressive medications have been widely adopted in therapeutic strategies given to these patients. Immune suppression is evidently efficient but also leads to higher susceptibility to infectious and malignant diseases. Toxic effects and sometimes unexpectedly dramatic complications of current therapies have been progressively reported. Identifying novel molecular targets therefore remains an important issue in the treatment of lupus. The aim of this review article is to highlight emerging pharmacological options and new therapeutic avenues for lupus with a particular focus on non-antibody molecular strategies.     

Antigen-specific tolerance strategies for the prevention and treatment of autoimmune disease

The development of safe and effective antigen-specific therapies is needed to treat patients with autoimmune diseases. These therapies must allow for the specific tolerization of self-reactive immune cells without altering host immunity to infectious insults. Experimental models and clinical trials for the treatment of autoimmune disease have identified putative mechanisms by which antigen-specific therapies induce tolerance. Although advances have been made in the development of efficient antigen-specific therapies, translating these therapies from bench to bedside has remained difficult. Here, we discuss the recent advances in our understanding of antigen-specific therapies for the treatment of autoimmune diseases.     

Therapies for allergic inflammation: refining strategies to induce tolerance

Current therapies for asthma and allergy are relatively safe and effective at controlling symptoms but do not change the chronic course of disease. There is no established method to prevent asthma and allergy, and major unmet needs in this area include the better control of the severe forms of these diseases and the developments of curative therapies. Two major therapeutic strategies for asthma and allergy are currently being developed, and I here discuss the advances and challenges for future therapeutic development in these two areas. The first approach, allergen-specific immunotherapy, aims to induce specific immune tolerance and has a long-term disease-modifying effect. The second approach is the use of biological immune response modifiers to decrease pathological immune responses. Combination strategies using both of these approaches may also provide a route for addressing the unmet clinical needs in allergic diseases.     

The liver: an organ of the immune system?

The liver stands in a unique position between the gastrointestinal tract and systemic venous system. Its constant exposure to food antigens, bacterial products and potential pathogens through the mesenteric circulation, requires the liver to maintain tolerogenic capabilities while preserving the means to mount effective immune responses. The liver has the unique ability amongst solid organs, to activate na?ve CD8+ T lymphocytes in an antigen-specific manner. However, this activation can be inefficient and lead to apoptosis. This phenomenon is believed to be involved in both, the development of oral tolerance and the induction of tolerance in liver allografts. The liver is the target of both autoimmune diseases and of chronic viral infections and its unique tolerogenic environment has frequently been suggested as a factor in the development of these diseases. A better grasp of the liver's unique immunological processes would lead to a better understanding of immune tolerance mechanisms and their role in the development of autoimmune diseases and chronic viral infections.     

Apoptotic cell-based therapies against transplant rejection: role of recipient’s dendritic cells

One of the ultimate goals in transplantation is to develop novel therapeutic methods for induction of donor-specific tolerance to reduce the side effects caused by the generalized immunosuppression associated to the currently used pharmacologic regimens. Interaction or phagocytosis of cells in early apoptosis exerts potent anti-inflammatory and immunosuppressive effects on antigen (Ag)-presenting cells (APC) like dendritic cells (DC) and macrophages. This observation led to the idea that apoptotic cell-based therapies could be employed to deliver donor-Ag in combination with regulatory signals to recipient’s APC as therapeutic approach to restrain the anti-donor response. This review describes the multiple mechanisms by which apoptotic cells down-modulate the immuno-stimulatory and pro-inflammatory functions of DC and macrophages, and the role of the interaction between apoptotic cells and APC in self-tolerance and in apoptotic cell-based therapies to prevent/treat allograft rejection and graft-versus-host disease in murine experimental systems and in humans. It also explores the role that in vivo-generated apoptotic cells could have in the beneficial effects of extracorporeal photopheresis, donor-specific transfusion, and tolerogenic DC-based therapies in transplantation.     

Taming lupus-a new understanding of pathogenesis is leading to clinical advances

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune disease that is characterized by the loss of tolerance to nuclear self antigens, the production of pathogenic autoantibodies and damage to multiple organ systems. Over the years, patients with SLE have been managed largely with empiric immunosuppressive therapies, which are associated with substantial toxicities and do not always provide adequate control of the disease. The development of targeted therapies that specifically address disease pathogenesis or progression has lagged, largely because of the complex and heterogeneous nature of the disease, as well as difficulties in designing uniform outcome measures for clinical trials. Recent advances that could improve the treatment of SLE include the identification of genetic variations that influence the risk of developing the disease, an enhanced understanding of innate and adaptive immune activation and regulation of tolerance, dissection of immune cell activation and inflammatory pathways and elucidation of mechanisms and markers of tissue damage. These discoveries, together with improvements in clinical trial design, form a platform from which to launch the development of a new generation of lupus therapies.     

Dendritic cells: emerging pharmacological targets of immunosuppressive drugs

Immunosuppressive drugs have revolutionized organ transplantation and improved the therapeutic management of autoimmune diseases. The development of immunosuppressive drugs and understanding of their action traditionally has been focused on lymphocytes, but recent evidence indicates that these agents interfere with immune responses at the earliest stage, targeting key functions of dendritic cells (DCs). Here, we review our present understanding of how classical and new immunosuppressive agents interfere with DC development and function. This knowledge might provide a rational basis for the selection of immunosuppressive drugs in different clinical settings and for the generation of tolerogenic DCs in the laboratory.     

Gram-Negative Enterobacteria Induce Tolerogenic Maturation in Dexamethasone Conditioned Dendritic Cells

Dendritic cells have been investigated in clinical trials, predominantly with the aim of stimulating immune responses against tumours or infectious diseases. Thus far, however, no clinical studies have taken advantage of their specific immunosuppressive potential. Tolerogenic DCs may represent a new therapeutic strategy for human immune-based diseases, such as Crohn’s disease, where the perturbations of the finely tuned balance between the immune system and the microflora result in disease. In the present report, we describe the generation of tolerogenic DCs from healthy donors and Crohn’s disease patients using clinical-grade reagents in combination with dexamethasone as immunosuppressive agent and characterize their response to maturation stimuli. Interestingly, we found out that dexamethasone-conditioned DCs keep their tolerogenic properties to Gram-negative bacteria. Other findings included in this study demonstrate that the combination of dexamethasone with a specific cytokine cocktail yielded clinical-grade DCs with the following characteristics: a semi-mature phenotype, a pronounced shift towards anti-inflammatory versus inflammatory cytokine production and low T-cell stimulatory properties. Importantly, in regard to their clinical application, the tolerogenic phenotype of DCs remained stable after the elimination of dexamethasone and after a second stimulation with LPS or bacteria. All these properties make this cell product suitable to be tested in clinical trials of inflammatory conditions including Crohn’s disease.     

Allergic contact dermatitis: how to re-induce tolerance?

Allergic contact dermatitis (ACD) is a skin inflammatory disease mediated by activation of CD8+ cytotoxic T cells specific for haptens in contact with the skin. CD4+ T cells behave as both regulatory and tolerogenic cells since they down-regulate the skin inflammation in patients with ACD (regulation) and prevent the development of eczema (tolerance) in normal individuals. Thus, ACD corresponds to a breakdown of immune tolerance to haptens in contact with the skin. Several regulatory CD4+ T cell subsets (Treg), especially CD4+CD25+ natural Treg cells, are involved in immunological tolerance and regulation to haptens through the production of the immunosuppressive cytokines IL-10 and TGF-beta. Ongoing strategies to re-induce immune tolerance to haptens in patients with eczema include improvement of existing methods of tolerance induction (oral tolerance, low dose tolerance, allergen-specific immunotherapy, UV-induced tolerance) as well as development of new drugs able to activate IL-10 producing Treg cells in vivo. Ongoing and future progress in this area will open up new avenues for treatment of eczema and more generally autoimmune and allergic diseases resulting from a breakdown of tolerance to autoantigens and allergens, respectively.     

Current and Future Immunomodulation Strategies to Restore Tolerance in Autoimmune Diseases

Autoimmune diseases reflect a breakdown in self-tolerance that results from defects in thymic deletion of potentially autoreactive T cells (central tolerance) and in T-cell intrinsic and extrinsic mechanisms that normally control potentially autoreactive T cells in the periphery (peripheral tolerance). The mechanisms leading to autoimmune diseases are multifactorial and depend on a complex combination of genetic, epigenetic, molecular, and cellular elements that result in pathogenic inflammatory responses in peripheral tissues driven by self-antigen-specific T cells. In this article, we describe the different checkpoints of tolerance that are defective in autoimmune diseases as well as specific events in the autoimmune response which represent therapeutic opportunities to restore long-term tolerance in autoimmune diseases. We present evidence for the role of different pathways in animal models and the therapeutic strategies targeting these pathways in clinical trials in autoimmune diseases.Autoimmune diseases are debilitating conditions that affect a large and growing portion of the population (∼3%–5% in the United States) (Jacobson et al. 1997). Autoimmune diseases take a devastating toll on affected families and have a considerable economic impact. Thus, improving the understanding of autoimmune diseases and developing novel therapies have been significant goals in public health. The development of autoimmune diseases reflects a loss of tolerance of the immune system for self-antigens. With the exception of a few rare monogenic diseases such as immune dysregulation, polyendocrinopathy, enteropathy, X-linked syndrome (IPEX), and autoimmune polyendocrinopathy-candidiasis-ectodermal dystrophy (APECED) syndrome, the development of autoimmunity is a complex and multifactorial process. This process usually involves genetic predispositions and poorly defined environmental factors that result in slight alterations in many different checkpoints, which in turn tilts the balance toward autoreactivity and away from immunoregulation. Although clearly there are key roles for B cells, antigen-presenting cells (APCs), and the innate immune response in the development and progression of autoimmune diseases, this article will focus on autoreactive T cells and potential targets of tolerogenic treatments (Fig. 1). In addition, we will discuss selected strategies currently available or being developed in the clinic as well as future opportunities to prevent and treat these diseases. Finally, current clinical strategies available as the standard of care for autoimmune diseases rely on immunosuppressive and anti-inflammatory treatments that curtail the pathological events, alleviate symptoms, and provide short-term relief in some patients. Thus, we will focus for the most part on immunotherapies aimed at reestablishing long-term tolerance.Open in a separate windowFigure 1.Development of the pathogenic autoimmune response and targets for immunotherapy. Autoreactive T cells that escape thymic negative selection are usually controlled by intrinsic (inhibitory receptors) and extrinsic (regulatory cell populations) mechanisms of tolerance in the periphery. In individuals genetically prone to autoimmunity, one or several of these checkpoints are defective, resulting in expansion of autoreactive T cells that cannot be controlled by Tregs (red, autoreactive effector T cells; green, Tregs; gray, polyclonal conventional T cells). Autoreactive T cells migrate to their targeted tissue where cytotoxic mechanisms and uncontrolled inflammation mediated by soluble mediators released by T cells and innate cells result in tissue damage. Various immunotherapeutic strategies target different steps in this process. (A) The ultimate goal of immunotherapy is to alter the balance of pathogenic versus regulatory T cells to restore tolerance, as detailed in Figure 2. (B) Anti-CD3 mAbs, antigen-specific therapies, and costimulation blockade alter the interactions between autoreactive T cells and antigen-presenting cells (APCs) and/or the signaling pathways resulting from productive T-cell receptor (TCR) ligation after presentation of cognate self-peptide/MHC (major histocompatibility complexes) in the presence of costimulatory signals, leading to deletion, anergy, immune deviation, or induction of Tregs. (C) Many strategies aim at boosting Tregs, either by concomitantly deleting Teff and promoting Tregs, and thus resetting the immune system to various degrees, such as antithymocyte globulin (ATG), rapamycin plus IL-2, and autologous hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT), or directly providing Tregs through cellular therapy. (D,E) Some therapies target populations of APCs, such as depletion of B cells by rituximab or the promotion of self-antigen presentation specifically by tolerogenic dendritic cells (DCs). (F) The migration of autoreactive T cells to their target tissue is being altered by inhibitors of leukocyte trafficking such as natalizumab and fingolimod. These drugs may further promote tolerance by keeping autoreactive T cells in the lymph nodes (LN) during immunosuppression, a prerequisite for efficient immunomodulation in some cases. (G) Anti-inflammatory therapies such as tumor necrosis factor (TNF) antagonists reduce tissue damage but also create an immunological environment more favorable to the induction of Tregs and restoration of tolerance.     

Induction of transplantation tolerance in non-human primate preclinical models

Short-term outcomes following organ transplantation have improved considerably since the availability of cyclosporine ushered in the modern era of immunosuppression. In spite of this, many of the current limitations to progress in the field are directly related to the existing practice of relatively non-specific immunosuppression. These include increased risks of opportunistic infection and cancer, and toxicity associated with long-term immunosuppressive drug exposure. In addition, long-term graft loss continues to result in part from a failure to adequately control the anti-donor immune response. The development of a safe and reliable means of inducing tolerance would ameliorate these issues and improve the lives of transplant recipients, yet given the improving clinical standard of care, the translation of new therapies has become appropriately more cautious and dependent on increasingly predictive preclinical models. While convenient and easy to use, rodent tolerance models have not to date been reliably capable of predicting a therapy's potential efficacy in humans. Non-human primates possess an immune system that more closely approximates that found in humans, and have served as a more rigorous preclinical testing ground for novel therapies. Prior to clinical adaptation therefore, tolerance regimens should be vetted in non-human primates to ensure that there is sufficient potential for efficacy to justify the risk of its application.     

Antibody-induced transplantation tolerance that is dependent on thymus-derived regulatory T cells

Targeting of the CD45RB isoform by mAb (anti-CD45RB) effectively induces donor-specific tolerance to allografts. The immunological mechanisms underlying the tolerant state remain unclear although some studies have suggested the involvement of regulatory T cells (T-regs). Although their generative pathway remains undefined, tolerance promoting T-regs induced by systemic anti-CD45RB treatment have been assumed to originate in the peripheral immune system. We demonstrate herein that separable effects on the peripheral and central immune compartments mediate graft survival induced by anti-CD45RB administration. In the absence of the thymus, anti-CD45RB therapy is not tolerogenic though it retains peripheral immunosuppressive activity. The thymus is required for anti-CD45RB to produce indefinite graft survival and donor-specific tolerance, and this effect is accomplished through thymic production of donor-specific T-regs. These data reveal for the first time an Ab-based tolerance regimen that relies on the central tolerance pathway.     

Mucosal modulation of immune responses to heat shock proteins in autoimmune arthritis

Induction of oral tolerance to antigens that are targets of self-reactive immune responses is an attractive approach to antigen-specific immune therapy of autoimmune diseases. Oral tolerization has indeed proven to be safe and effective in amelioration of autoimmune diseases in animal models. In humans, results have been somewhat controversial. The emphasis given to clinical outcome rather than to immunomodulation, and the difficulty in identifying appropriate candidate antigens contribute to the controversy. Heat shock proteins are promising targets for immune intervention. Immune reactivity to heat shock proteins has indeed been correlated with autoimmune arthritis in animal models, and abnormal immune responses to heat shock proteins have been described in human arthritis as well. Despite significant recent progress, little is known at a molecular level regarding the mechanisms which are responsible for a switch from autoimmunity to tolerance in humans. This is particularly true with respect to sequential analysis of several molecular and immunologic markers during both the course and treatment of disease. Novel approaches are currently under way to fill the gaps. We will briefly detail here the experience gained to date, and identify some of the avenues which future research will explore.     

Emerging mechanisms and applications of low-dose IL-2 therapy in autoimmunity

Interleukin 2 (IL-2) is a pleiotropic cytokine that elicits both immunogenic and tolerogenic immune response essential for homeostasis. Initial clinical application of IL-2 based therapy was hampered by its function on broad spectrum of cells expressing corresponding receptors, which exerts uncontrolled side effects in clinical trials. While recent progress on structural modification or adjusted regimen of IL-2, revolutionized the use of IL-2 in immunomodulation process that requires stringent selection of effector cells, such as promotion of T_REG cells for tolerance or invigoration of CD8⁺ T cells against infection and cancer. Low-dose IL-2 therapy is amongst these succuss and is proved to be a promising immunotherapy to treat a broad range of autoimmune and inflammatory diseases. This article will review major recent advances in fundamental research on IL-2 as well as significant progress made in clinical trials where patients received low-dose IL-2 therapy. This knowledge also helps design further optimized IL-2 therapies for a broader application in treating human disease.     

The effects of immunosuppression on regulatory CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells: impact on immunosuppression selection in transplantation

During immune response and T-cell activation, both effector T cells and regulatory T(T(reg)) cells are activated and regulated simultaneously by both positive and negative pathways. CD4(+)CD25(+) T(reg) cells play a critical role in immune tolerance to self antigens as well as to allografts in some transplant settings. Effective immunosuppressive regimens significantly reduced the incidence of acute allograft rejection in patients following organ transplantation. However, the impact of immunosuppressive treatment on the potential induction of transplant tolerance has not been well determined. In this review we summarize the effects of immunosuppressive reagents on CD4(+)CD25(+) T(reg) cells in order to bring attention to this issue, which may affect the choice of immunosuppressive regimen in the clinical setting.     

The enemy within: keeping self-reactive T cells at bay in the periphery

The remarkable capacity of the mammalian immune system to coordinate deadly attacks against numerous invading pathogens, yet turn a blind eye to self-tissues continues to fascinate immunologists. It has been clear for some time that immune cells capable of recognizing self-proteins exist in normal individuals without seemingly causing harm. The 'peripheral tolerance' mechanisms that keep these cells in check are the focus of intense research, not least because defects in these pathways might cause autoimmune diseases. In this review, new developments in our understanding of peripheral tolerance are discussed.