Artifacts accompanying digestion of chromatin with micrococcal nuclease

DNA in the micrococcal nuclease limit digest of chromatin is completely resistant to DNAse II. At least part of this resistance is not a property of the untreated chromatin, but is acquired in the course of digestion.     

Ion competition and micrococcal nuclease digestion studies of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA. Evidence for torus organization by circumferential DNA wrapping

Spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA structures have been studied by ion competition using a sedimentation assay and by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Competitor ions Mg2+, Ca2+ and putrescine2+ show specific ion effects; but all three appear to affect the DNA condensation-decondensation equilibrium caused by spermidine3+ in a qualitatively similar manner, suggesting the spermidine3+-DNA interaction is largely electrostatic. Our data show a hysteresis in condensation and decondensation transition directions. We interpret this in terms of a kinetic block in the condensation direction with decondensation representing the equilibrium state of the system. These results agree with results obtained from related systems using different measurement techniques. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA produces broad but discrete bands in gel electrophoresis experiments. At least two bands determined to be 760 +/- 87 bp and 1355 +/- 135 bp, possess the size ratio 1:1.8 +/- 0.4 consistent with their forming the monomer and dimer fragments of an arithmetic band series. We rationalize this result in terms of a localized micrococcal nuclease cleavage model of circumferentially-wrapped DNA toruses proposed previously by Marx, K.A. and Reynolds, T.C. (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (1982) 79, 6484-6488). The arithmetic series monomer band (760 +/- 87 bp), corresponding to wrapping B DNA once circumferentially about the torus, is in agreement with the electron microscopic measurements of hydrated calf thymus DNA torus circumferences presented by Marx, K.A. and Ruben, G.C. (Nucleic Acids Res. (1983) 11, 1839-1853).     

Digestion by micrococcal nuclease of mouse submandibular-salivary-gland chromatin.

Nucleic prepared from mouse submandibular salivary gland show marked fragility during isolation. Hwever, intact nuclei relatively free from cytoplasmic contamination were obtained by homogenization in buffers containing 0.88 M-sucrose, Ca2+, spermine, spermidine and the proteinase inhibitor aprotinin, followed by centrifugation through 2.2 M-sucrose. The kinetics of digestion by the micrococcal nuclease of chromatin in these nuclei are similar to those of chromatin from mouse liver nuclei. Base-pair size analysis of the solubilized DNA from both organs shows a stable high-molecular weight species of chromatin, which is further digested to mononucleosome and subnucleosome species. With extensive digestion the chromatin becomes insoluble. The mononucleosomes produced from salivary-gland chromatin after the inhibition of endogenous proteinase activity exhibit an s20,w value of 11S and contain histones H1, H2A, H2B, H3 and H4.     

Fractionation of trinucleotides from partial micrococcal nuclease digests of calf thymus DNA

The enzymic digest is first fractionated according to chain length by column chromatography on DEAE-Sephadex in 7 M urea at neutral pH. The trimer fraction is further resolved according to Gp content on DEAE-Sephadex in 50% MeOH and NH₄-formate buffers at pH 5.2. The three subgroups of trinucleotides containing 0, 1, and 2 Gp residues, respectively, are then separated according to Ap, Cp, and Tp content on DEAE-cellulose in 7 M urea and 0.1 M formic acid. Among the 23 trimers so obtained, sequence isomers such as TpGpAp and ApGpTp are resolved by partition chromatography on cellulose columns with 30% NH₄-sulfate at neutral pH.     

Ion competition and micrococcal nuclease digestion studies of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA: Evidence for torus organization by circumferential DNA wrapping

Spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA structures have been studied by ion competition using a sedimentation assay and by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Competitor ions Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺ and putrescine²⁺ show specific ion effects; but all three appear to affect the DNA condensation-decondensation equilibrium caused by spermidine³⁺ in a qualitatively similar manner, suggesting the spermidine³⁺-DNA interaction is largely electrostatic. Our data show a hysteresis in condensation and decondensation transition directions. We interpret this in terms of a kinetic block in the condensation direction with decondensation representing the equilibrium state of the system. These results agree with results obtained from related systems using different measurement techniques. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA produces broad but discrete bands in gel electrophoresis experiments. At least two bands determined to be 760 ± 87 bp and 1355 ± 135 bp, possess the size ratio 1:1.8 ± 0.4 consistent with their forming the monomer and dimer fragments of an arithmetic band series. We rationalize this result in terms of a localized micrococcal nuclease cleavage model of circumferentially-wrapped DNA toruses proposed previously by Marx, K.A. and Reynolds, T.C. (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (1982) 79, 6484–6488). The arithmetic series monomer band (760 ± 87 bp), corresponding to wrapping B̄ DNA once circumferentially about the torus, is in agreement with the electron microscopic measurements of hydrated calf thymus DNA torus circumferences presented by Marx, K.A. and Ruben, G.C. (Nucleic Acids Res. (1983) 11, 1839–1853).     

Distribution of H1 histone in chromatin digested by micrococcal nuclease.

The relative amount of H1 histone associated with isolated nucleosomes from calf thymus was determined as a function of the extent of DNA digestion by micrococcal nuclease. Generally the amount of H1 histone associated with mononucleosomes decreases with increasing digestion until 60% of the original H1 remains associated with DNA 150 base pirs or less in size. Coincidentally, H1 histone increases relative to the other histones in aggregated material that sediments through sucrose gradients to form a pellet. However, the level of H1 histone remains at control values for oligonucleosomes (dimer to hexamer) over the 30% digestion range studied. An increase in ionic strength to 0.3 M NaCl in the density gradient reveals a different pattern of H1 binding, whereby the amount of H1 reflects the average size of the DNA fragments with which it is associated. Although there is significant binding to nucleosomes per se, it appears that the major ionic involvement of H1 is with internucleosomal spacer DNA.     

Fractionation of chromatin of liver cell nuclei after mild micrococcal nuclease digestion

Mild micrococcal nuclease treatment of rat and mouse nuclei and fractionation were based on the method of Tata and Baker. Three chromatin fractions, S, P1, P2, were separated, and for each of these fractions the sensitivity to the DNase 1 action was determined. The relative content in these fractions of non-transcribed DNA sequences was established by hydridization with a mouse satellite DNA, and the relative content of transcribed DNA sequences--by hydridization with DNA synthesised on the total poly (A) mRNA. None of the fractions displayed the properties characteristic of active chromatin.     

Another potential artifact in the study of nucleosome phasing by chromatin digestion with micrococcal nuclease

We show that, contrary to expectations, restriction enzyme cleavage of chicken erythrocyte nucleosome core particle DNA generates a series of distinct subnucleosome fragments. These fragments do not result from bulk nucleosome phasing in vivo, but arise from micrococcal nuclease cleavages internal to the core particle, at roughly 10-base pair intervals and at AT-rich sequences. Those 145-base pair DNA fragments remaining intact are a biased population in which the guanine content can fluctuate by as much as 10%, with a 10-base pair period. We suggest that these same considerations, when applied to a unique DNA sequence, are the true explanation for several previous claims for nucleosome phasing.     

Heterogeneity of chromatin fragments produced by micrococcal nuclease action.

Digestion of calf thymus chromatin with micrococcal nuclease produces a mixture of apparently well defined nucleoprotein fragments which have been partially resolved by sedimentation on linear (5-20%) sucrose gradients. Sedimentation patterns reveal a predominant peak at the 11S position, three slower components, which have not previously been reported, at the 3.4S, 5.3S and 8.6S positions, and three faster components at the 17S, 22S and 26S positions. DNA isolated from the 3S to 12S region of gradients has been resolved on polyacrylamide gels into nine to ten discrete components ranging from 47 to 156 base pairs in length. A nearly identical pattern of small DNA products was obtained from chromatin digested in intact nuclei. These data suggest that chromatin contains either several types of subunits or predominently a single type of subunit which can be asymmetrically cleaved at any one of four or more sites.     

Superstructural differences between chromatin in nuclei and in solution are revealed by kinetics of micrococcal nuclease digestion.

Digestion of chromatin in nuclei by micrococcal nuclease, measured as the change in the concentration of monomer-length DNA with time, displays Michaelis-Menten kinetics. Redigestion of soluble chromatin prepared from nuclei by micrococcal nuclease treatment, however, is apparently first order in enzyme and independent of chromatin concentration. This qualitative difference results from an increase in the apparent second order rate constant, kcat/Km, for liberation of monomer DNA: the apparent Km for soluble chromatin is lower by close to 3 orders of magnitude than that for chromatin in nuclei, whereas kcat decreases by less than 1 order of magnitude. Neither the integrity of the nuclear membrane nor the presence of histone H1 contributes to the high Michaelis constant characteristic of chromatin in nuclei. Moreover, differences due to the buffers used for digestion and redigestion are minimal. Low catalytic efficiency is, however, correlated with the presence of higher order chromatin superstructure. Micrococcal nuclease added to soluble chromatin under nondigesting conditions at low ionic strength (I = 0.002) co-sediments with chromatin in sucrose gradients. In 0.15 M NaCl, added nuclease no longer sediments with chromatin and redigestion kinetics become first order in both enzyme and substrate. Kinetic analysis of this type may afford an assay for native, higher order structures in chromatin. Our results suggest that micrococcal nuclease binds to soluble chromatin through additional interactions not present in nuclei, which may be partly ionic in nature.     

Chromatin structure of the chicken lysozyme gene domain as determined by chromatin fractionation and micrococcal nuclease digestion

The chromatin structure encompassing the lysozyme gene domain in hen oviduct nuclei was studied by measuring the partitioning of coding and flanking sequences during chromatin fractionation and by analyzing the nucleosome repeat in response to micrococcal nuclease digestion. Following micrococcal nuclease digestion, nuclei were sedimented to obtain a chromatin fraction released during digestion (S1) and then lysed in tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane-(ethylenedinitrilo)tetraacetic acid-[ethylenebis(oxyethylenenitrilo)]tetraacetic acid and centrifuged again to yield a second solubilized chromatin fraction (S2) and a pelleted fraction (P2). By dot-blot hybridization with 14 specific probes, it is found that the fractionation procedure defines three classes of sequences within the lysozyme gene domain. The coding sequences, which partition with fraction P2, are flanked by class I flanking sequences, which partition with fractions S1 and P2 and which extend over 11 kilobases (kb) on the 5'side and probably over about 4 kb on the 3' side. The partitioning of class II flanking sequences, which are located distal of class I flanking sequences, is different from that of class I flanking sequences. Coding sequences lack a canonical nucleosome repeat, class I flanking sequences possess a disturbed nucleosome repeat, and class II flanking sequences generate an extended nucleosomal ladder. Coding and class I flanking sequences are more readily digested by micrococcal nuclease than class II flanking sequences and the inactive beta A-globin gene. In hen liver, where the lysozyme gene is inactive, coding and class I flanking sequences fractionate into fractions S2 and P2.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The effect of micrococcal nuclease digestion on nucleosome positioning data

Eukaryotic genomes are packed into chromatin, whose basic repeating unit is the nucleosome. Nucleosome positioning is a widely researched area. A common experimental procedure to determine nucleosome positions involves the use of micrococcal nuclease (MNase). Here, we show that the cutting preference of MNase in combination with size selection generates a sequence-dependent bias in the resulting fragments. This strongly affects nucleosome positioning data and especially sequence-dependent models for nucleosome positioning. As a consequence we see a need to re-evaluate whether the DNA sequence is a major determinant of nucleosome positioning in vivo. More generally, our results show that data generated after MNase digestion of chromatin requires a matched control experiment in order to determine nucleosome positions.     

DNase I site mapping and micrococcal nuclease digestion of pachytene chromatin reveal novel structural features

A comparison of the DNase I digestion products of the 32P-5'-end-labeled pachytene nucleosome core particles (containing histones H2A, TH2A, X2, H2B, TH2B, H3, and H4) and liver nucleosome core particles (containing somatic histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4) revealed that the cleavage sites that are 30, 40, and 110 nucleotides away from the 5'-end are significantly more accessible in the pachytene core particles than in the liver core particles. These cleavage sites correspond to the region wherein H2B interacts with the nucleosome core DNA. These results, therefore, suggest that the histone-DNA interaction at these sites in the pachytene core particles is weaker, possibly because of the presence of the histone variant TH2B interacting at similar topological positions in the nucleosome core as that of its somatic counterpart H2B. Such a loosened structure may also be maintained even in the native pachytene chromatin since micrococcal nuclease digestion of pachytene nuclei resulted in a higher ratio of subnucleosomes (SN4 + SN7) to mononucleosomes than that observed in liver chromatin.     

Effects of thyroid hormone administration on the susceptibility of rat liver chromatin to digestion with micrococcal nuclease

The accessibility of rat liver chromatin to digestion with micrococcal nuclease was investigated in normal, thyroidectomized and thyroid hormone-treated animals. A significant increase in digestibility of chromatin by micrococcal nuclease was produced by thyroid hormone treatment. The DNA in the soluble fraction analyzed by electrophoresis showed identical sizes in thyroidectomized and triiodothyronine-treated animals. However, DNA in the pellet obtained from thyroidectomized animals showed a relatively high concentration of polynucleosomes which were virtually undetectable in the pellet from thyroid hormone-treated animals. Analysis of proteins in the micrococcal nuclease solubilized fraction of chromatin revealed differences between thyroidectomized and thyroid hormone-treated animals. It is suggested that thyroid hormone causes changes in nucleoproteins which alter the structure of chromatin in such a way as to expose more DNA to nuclease attack and/or increases the solubility of released nucleosomes.     

Thermal denaturation of DNA in the chromatin fragments released by mild micrococcal nuclease digestion of HTC cell nuclei

In chromatin a minor fraction melts at a temperature lower than deproteinized DNA, which may be assigned to DNA destabilizing proteins. We attempted to localize the destabilized DNA in the various chromatin fragments separated by electrophoresis after a mild micrococcal nuclease digestion. The small released fragments are enriched in coding sequences. About 20% of the DNA extracted from the released nucleosomes are single-stranded, 60% of the DNA in these fragments are digested by nuclease S₁ after incubation at low temperature, which suggests that the DNA destabilizing proteins are present in the released nucleosomes. Hybridization studies have shown that 25% of the DNA in nucleosomes are specific of this class of fragments. DNA destabilizing proteins could be associated with the specific sequences.