Structural basis for the design and synthesis of selective HDAC inhibitors

Histone Deacetylases are considered promising targets for cancer epigenetic therapy, and small molecules able to modulate their biological function have recently gained an increasing interest as potential anticancer agents. In spite of their potential application in cancer therapy, most HDAC inhibitors unselectively bind the several HDAC isoforms, giving rise to different side-effects. In this context, we have traced out the structural elements responsible of selective binding for the therapeutically relevant different HDAC isoforms. The structural analysis has been carried out by molecular modeling, docking in the binding pockets of HDAC1–4 and HDAC6–8, 36 inhibitors presenting a well defined selectivity for the different isoforms. As quick proof of evidence, we have designed, synthesized and experimentally tested three selective ligands. The experimental data suggest that the obtained structural guidelines can be useful tools for the rational design of new potent inhibitors against selected HDAC isoforms.     

Synthesis and biological activity of cyclotetrapeptide analogues of the natural HDAC inhibitor FR235222

In the course of our ongoing efforts to discover new and more effective HDAC inhibitors useful for the development of promising anticancer candidates, we have recently undertaken a molecular modelling study on a small collection of FR235222 analogues, synthesized by us in the frame of a structure–activity relationship investigation, made in order to identify the key structural elements essential for the activity. Progress made in structure elucidation of HDAC active site, together with accurate docking calculations, provided new structural insights useful for a further refinement of the tetrapeptide scaffold which should assure an optimal interaction between the synthetic ligands and the biological target. Following the computer aided suggestions we synthesized six new cyclotetrapeptide analogues of the lead compound (3–8), bearing a carboxylic or an hydroxamic acid functionality as Zn binding moiety. Herein we describe their synthesis and their inhibition activity on different HDAC isoforms.     

Design and evaluation of 'Linkerless' hydroxamic acids as selective HDAC8 inhibitors

In this report, we describe new HDAC inhibitors designed to exploit a unique sub-pocket in the HDAC8 active site. These compounds were based on inspection of the available HDAC8 crystal structures bound to various inhibitors, which collectively show that the HDAC8 active site is unusually malleable and can accommodate inhibitor structures that are distinct from the canonical 'zinc binding group-linker-cap group' structures of SAHA, TSA, and similar HDAC inhibitors. Some inhibitors based on this new scaffold are >100-fold selective for HDAC8 over other class I and class II HDACs with IC(50) values <1microM against HDAC8. Furthermore, treatment of human cells with the inhibitors described here shows a unique pattern of hyperacetylated proteins compared with the broad-spectrum HDAC inhibitor TSA.     

The structural requirements of histone deacetylase inhibitors: SAHA analogs modified at the C5 position display dual HDAC6/8 selectivity

Histone deacetylase (HDAC) proteins have emerged as important targets for anti-cancer drugs, with four small molecules approved for use in the clinic. Suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (Vorinostat, SAHA) was the first FDA-approved HDAC inhibitor for cancer treatment. However, SAHA inhibits most of the eleven HDAC isoforms. To understand the structural requirements of HDAC inhibitor selectivity and develop isoform selective HDAC inhibitors, SAHA analogs modified in the linker at the C5 position were synthesized and tested for potency and selectivity. C5-modified SAHA analogs displayed dual selectivity to HDAC6 and HDAC8 over HDAC 1, 2, and 3, with only a modest reduction in potency. These findings are consistent with prior work showing that modification of the linker region of SAHA can alter isoform selectivity. The observed HDAC6/8 selectivity of C5-modified SAHA analogs provide guidance toward development of isoform selective HDAC inhibitors and more effective anti-cancer drugs.     

A spectrophotometric assay for histone deacetylase 8

Inhibitors for the classical protein deacetylase enzymes have been actively pursued to develop the next generation of cancer therapy. Developing a novel convenient assay platform for the classical enzyme-catalyzed reactions could thus facilitate the drug discovery process. Based on our previous studies demonstrating the functional mimicry of N(epsilon)-thioacetyl-lysine for N(epsilon)-acetyl-lysine in the reaction catalyzed by the classical enzyme histone deacetylase 8 (HDAC8) on a peptide template derived from the C terminus of the human p53 tumor suppressor protein, we have developed a spectrophotometric HDAC8 assay via quantifying thioacetate produced from the enzymatic dethioacetylation with Ellman's reagent 5,5'-dithiobis(2-nitrobenzoate). We further demonstrated that this novel assay was selective for HDAC8 versus HDAC1 and 2 and for other classical protein deacetylase enzymes present in the HeLa nuclear extracts, thus making it potentially suitable not only for screening HDAC8-selective inhibitors but also for selectively assessing HDAC8 activity under (patho)physiological conditions.     

Molecular modifications on carboxylic acid derivatives as potent histone deacetylase inhibitors: Activity and docking studies

In the light of known HDAC inhibitors, 33 carboxylic acid derivatives were tested to understand the structural requirements for HDAC inhibition activity. Several modifications were applied to develop the structure–activity relationships of carboxylic acid HDAC inhibitors. HDAC inhibition activities were investigated in vitro by using HeLa nuclear extract in a fluorimetric assay. Molecular docking was also carried out for the human HDAC8 enzyme in order to predict inhibition activity and the 3D poses of inhibitor–enzyme complexes. Of these compounds, caffeic acid derivatives such as chlorogenic acid and curcumin were found to be highly potent compared to sodium butyrate, which is a well-known HDAC inhibitor.     

Structural Basis for the Inhibition of Histone Deacetylase 8 (HDAC8), a Key Epigenetic Player in the Blood Fluke Schistosoma mansoni

The treatment of schistosomiasis, a disease caused by blood flukes parasites of the Schistosoma genus, depends on the intensive use of a single drug, praziquantel, which increases the likelihood of the development of drug-resistant parasite strains and renders the search for new drugs a strategic priority. Currently, inhibitors of human epigenetic enzymes are actively investigated as novel anti-cancer drugs and have the potential to be used as new anti-parasitic agents. Here, we report that Schistosoma mansoni histone deacetylase 8 (smHDAC8), the most expressed class I HDAC isotype in this organism, is a functional acetyl-L-lysine deacetylase that plays an important role in parasite infectivity. The crystal structure of smHDAC8 shows that this enzyme adopts a canonical α/β HDAC fold, with specific solvent exposed loops corresponding to insertions in the schistosome HDAC8 sequence. Importantly, structures of smHDAC8 in complex with generic HDAC inhibitors revealed specific structural changes in the smHDAC8 active site that cannot be accommodated by human HDACs. Using a structure-based approach, we identified several small-molecule inhibitors that build on these specificities. These molecules exhibit an inhibitory effect on smHDAC8 but show reduced affinity for human HDACs. Crucially, we show that a newly identified smHDAC8 inhibitor has the capacity to induce apoptosis and mortality in schistosomes. Taken together, our biological and structural findings define the framework for the rational design of small-molecule inhibitors specifically interfering with schistosome epigenetic mechanisms, and further support an anti-parasitic epigenome targeting strategy to treat neglected diseases caused by eukaryotic pathogens.     

2-Trifluoroacetylthiophene oxadiazoles as potent and selective class II human histone deacetylase inhibitors

Trifluoroacetylthiophene carboxamides have recently been reported to be class II HDAC inhibitors, with moderate selectivity. Exploration of replacements for the carboxamide with bioisosteric pentatomic heteroaromatic like 1,3,4-oxadiazoles, 1,2,4-oxadiazoles and 1,3-thiazoles, led to the discovery that 2-trifluoroacetylthiophene 1,3,4-oxadiazole derivatives are very potent low nanomolar HDAC4 inhibitors, highly selective over class I HDACs (HDAC 1 and 3), and moderately stable in HCT116 cell culture.     

Pimelic diphenylamide 106 is a slow, tight-binding inhibitor of class I histone deacetylases

Histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitors, including various benzamides and hydroxamates, are currently in clinical development for a broad range of human diseases, including cancer and neurodegenerative diseases. We recently reported the identification of a family of benzamide-type HDAC inhibitors that are relatively non-toxic compared with the hydroxamates. Members of this class of compounds have shown efficacy in cell-based and mouse models for the neurodegenerative diseases Friedreich ataxia and Huntington disease. Considerable differences in IC(50) values for the various HDAC enzymes have been reported for many of the HDAC inhibitors, leading to confusion as to the HDAC isotype specificities of these compounds. Here we show that a benzamide HDAC inhibitor, a pimelic diphenylamide (106), is a class I HDAC inhibitor, demonstrating no activity against class II HDACs. 106 is a slow, tight-binding inhibitor of HDACs 1, 2, and 3, although inhibition for these enzymes occurs through different mechanisms. Inhibitor 106 also has preference toward HDAC3 with K(i) of approximately 14 nm, 15 times lower than the K(i) for HDAC1. In comparison, the hydroxamate suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid does not discriminate between these enzymes and exhibits a fast-on/fast-off inhibitory mechanism. These observations may explain a paradox involving the relative activities of pimelic diphenylamides versus hydroxamates as gene activators.     

Optimization of biaryl Selective HDAC1&2 Inhibitors (SHI-1:2)

A class of biaryl benzamides was identified and optimized as selective HDAC1&2 inhibitors (SHI-1:2). These agents exhibit selectivity over class II HDACs 4-7, as well as class I HDACs 3 and 8; providing examples of selective HDAC inhibitors for the HDAC isoforms most closely associated with cancer. The hypothesis for the increased selectivity is the binding of a pendant aromatic group in the internal cavity of the HDAC1&2 enzymes. SAR development based on an initial lead led to a series of potent and selective inhibitors with reduced off-target activity and tumor growth inhibition activity in a HCT-116 xenograft model.     

Structural and functional analysis of the human HDAC4 catalytic domain reveals a regulatory structural zinc-binding domain

Histone deacetylases (HDACs) regulate chromatin status and gene expression, and their inhibition is of significant therapeutic interest. To date, no biological substrate for class IIa HDACs has been identified, and only low activity on acetylated lysines has been demonstrated. Here, we describe inhibitor-bound and inhibitor-free structures of the histone deacetylase-4 catalytic domain (HDAC4cd) and of an HDAC4cd active site mutant with enhanced enzymatic activity toward acetylated lysines. The structures presented, coupled with activity data, provide the molecular basis for the intrinsically low enzymatic activity of class IIa HDACs toward acetylated lysines and reveal active site features that may guide the design of class-specific inhibitors. In addition, these structures reveal a conformationally flexible structural zinc-binding domain conserved in all class IIa enzymes. Importantly, either the mutation of residues coordinating the structural zinc ion or the binding of a class IIa selective inhibitor prevented the association of HDAC4 with the N-CoR.HDAC3 repressor complex. Together, these data suggest a key role of the structural zinc-binding domain in the regulation of class IIa HDAC functions.     

Metabolism as a key to histone deacetylase inhibition

There is growing interest in the epigenetic mechanisms that are dysregulated in cancer and other human pathologies. Under this broad umbrella, modulators of histone deacetylase (HDAC) activity have gained interest as both cancer chemopreventive and therapeutic agents. Of the first generation, FDA-approved HDAC inhibitors to have progressed to clinical trials, vorinostat represents a "direct acting" compound with structural features suitable for docking into the HDAC pocket, whereas romidepsin can be considered a prodrug that undergoes reductive metabolism to generate the active intermediate (a zinc-binding thiol). It is now evident that other agents, including those in the human diet, can be converted by metabolism to intermediates that affect HDAC activity. Examples are cited of short-chain fatty acids, seleno-α-keto acids, small molecule thiols, mercapturic acid metabolites, indoles, and polyphenols. The findings are discussed in the context of putative endogenous HDAC inhibitors generated by intermediary metabolism (e.g. pyruvate), the yin-yang of HDAC inhibition versus HDAC activation, and the screening assays that might be most appropriate for discovery of novel HDAC inhibitors in the future.     

Two catalytic domains are required for protein deacetylation

Histone deacetylase (HDAC)-6 was recently identified as a dual substrate, possibly multisubstrate, deacetylase that can act both on acetylated histone tails and on alpha-tubulin acetylated on Lys40. HDAC-6 is unique among deacetylases in having two hdac domains, and we have used this enzyme as a useful model to dissect the structural requirements for the deacetylation reaction. In this report, we show that both hdac domains are required for the intact deacetylase activity of HDAC-6 in vitro and in vivo. The spatial arrangement of these two domains in HDAC-6 is essential and alteration of the linker region between the two domains severely affects the catalytic activity. Artificial chimeric HDACs, made by replacing the hdac domains in HDAC-6 with corresponding domains from other class II HDACs, show de novo deacetylase activity. Taken together, our results demonstrate for the first time that the spatial arrangement of hdac domains is critical for in vivo deacetylation reaction and may provide a useful model for the development of novel HDAC inhibitors.     

The discovery of novel HDAC3 inhibitors via virtual screening and in vitro bioassay

Histone deacetylase 3 (HDAC3) is a potential target for the treatment of human diseases such as cancers, diabetes, chronic inflammation and neurodegenerative diseases. Previously, we proposed a virtual screening (VS) pipeline named “Hypo1_FRED_SAHA-3” for the discovery of HDAC3 inhibitors (HDAC3Is) and had thoroughly validated it by theoretical calculations. In this study, we attempted to explore its practical utility in a large-scale VS campaign. To this end, we used the VS pipeline to hierarchically screen the Specs chemical library. In order to facilitate compound cherry-picking, we then developed a knowledge-based pose filter (PF) by using our in-house quantitative structure activity relationship- (QSAR-) modelling approach and coupled it with FRED and Autodock Vina. Afterward, we purchased and tested 11 diverse compounds for their HDAC3 inhibitory activity in vitro. The bioassay has identified compound 2 (Specs ID: AN-979/41971160) as a HDAC3I (IC₅₀?=?6.1?μM), which proved the efficacy of our workflow. As a medicinal chemistry study, we performed a follow-up substructure search and identified two more hit compounds of the same chemical type, i.e. 2–1 (AQ-390/42122119, IC₅₀?=?1.3?μM) and 2–2 (AN-329/43450111, IC₅₀?=?12.5?μM). Based on the chemical structures and activities, we have demonstrated the essential role of the capping group in maintaining the activity for this class of HDAC3Is. In addition, we tested the hit compounds for their in vitro activities on other HDACs, including HDAC1, HDAC2, HDAC8, HDAC4 and HDAC6. We have identified these compounds are HDAC1/2/3 selective inhibitors, of which compound 2 show the best selectivity profile. Taken together, the present study is an experimental validation and an update to our earlier VS strategy. The identified hits could be used as starting structures for the development of highly potent and selective HDAC3Is.     

Design of novel histone deacetylase inhibitors

Histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitors that target Class I and Class II HDACs are of synthetic and therapeutic interest and ongoing clinical studies indicate that they show great promise for the treatment of cancer. Moreover, Zolinza (vorinostat) was recently approved by the FDA for the treatment of the cutaneous manifestations of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma [Nat. Rev. Drug Disc. 2007, 6, 21]. As part of a broader effort to more fully explore the structure-activity relationships (SAR) of HDAC inhibitors, we sought to identify novel HDAC inhibitor structures through iterative design by utilizing low affinity ligands as synthetic starting points for SAR development. Novel and potent HDAC inhibitors have been identified using this approach and herein we report the optimization of the recognition elements of a novel series of malonyl-derived HDAC inhibitors.     

Structural insights into the Plasmodium falciparum histone deacetylase 1 (PfHDAC-1): A novel target for the development of antimalarial therapy

The histone deacetylase (HDAC) enzyme from Plasmodium falciparum has been identified as a novel target for the development of antimalarial therapy. A ligand-refined homology model of PfHDAC-1 was generated from the crystal structures of human HDAC8 and HDLP using a restraint guided optimization procedure involving the OPLS/GBSA potential setup. The model was extensively validated using protein structure checking tools. A predictive docking study was carried out using a set of known human HDAC inhibitors, which were shown to have in vitro antimalarial activity against the chloroquine sensitive D6 and resistant W2 strains of P. falciparum. Pose validation and score-based active/inactive separation studies provided independent validation of the geometric accuracy and the predictive ability of the generated model. Comparative analysis was carried out with the human HDACs to identify differences in the binding site topology and interacting residues, which might be utilized to develop selective PfHDAC-1 inhibitors.