Examining the influence of specificity ligands and ATP-competitive ligands on the overall effectiveness of bivalent kinase inhibitors

Background

Identifying selective kinase inhibitors remains a major challenge. The design of bivalent inhibitors provides a rational strategy for accessing potent and selective inhibitors. While bivalent kinase inhibitors have been successfully designed, no comprehensive assessment of affinity and selectivity for a series of bivalent inhibitors has been performed. Here, we present an evaluation of the structure activity relationship for bivalent kinase inhibitors targeting ABL1.

Methods

Various SNAPtag constructs bearing different specificity ligands were expressed in vitro. Bivalent inhibitor formation was accomplished by synthesizing individual ATP-competitive kinase inhibitors containing a SNAPtag targeting moiety, enabling the spontaneous self-assembly of the bivalent inhibitor. Assembled bivalent inhibitors were incubated with K562 lysates, and then subjected to affinity enrichment using various ATP-competitive inhibitors immobilized to sepharose beads. Resulting eluents were analyzed using Tandem Mass Tag (TMT) labeling and two-dimensional liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (2D–LC-MS/MS). Relative binding affinity of the bivalent inhibitor was determined by calculating the concentration at which 50% of a given kinase remained bound to the affinity matrix.

Results

The profiling of three parental ATP-competitive inhibitors and nine SNAPtag conjugates led to the identification of 349 kinase proteins. In all cases, the bivalent inhibitors exhibited enhanced binding affinity and selectivity for ABL1 when compared to the parental compound conjugated to SNAPtag alone. While the rank order of binding affinity could be predicted by considering the binding affinities of the individual specificity ligands, the resulting affinity of the assembled bivalent inhibitor was not predictable. The results from this study suggest that as the potency of the ATP-competitive ligand increases, the contribution of the specificity ligand towards the overall binding affinity of the bivalent inhibitor decreases. However, the affinity of the specificity components in its interaction with the target is essential for achieving selectivity.

Conclusion

Through comprehensive chemical proteomic profiling, this work provides the first insight into the influence of ATP-competitive and specificity ligands binding to their intended target on a proteome-wide scale. The resulting data suggest a subtle interplay between the ATP-competitive and specificity ligands that cannot be accounted for by considering the specificity or affinity of the individual components alone.

     

Bivalent inhibitors of the tyrosine kinases ABL and SRC: determinants of potency and selectivity

We recently reported a chemical genetic method for generating bivalent inhibitors of protein kinases. This method relies on the use of the DNA repair enzyme O(6)-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase (AGT) to display an ATP-competitive inhibitor and a ligand that targets a secondary binding domain. With this method potent and selective inhibitors of the tyrosine kinases SRC and ABL were identified. Here, we dissect the molecular determinants of the potency and selectivity of these bivalent ligands. Systematic analysis of ATP-competitive inhibitors with varying linker lengths revealed that SRC and ABL have differential sensitivities to ligand presentation. Generation of bivalent constructs that contain ligands with differential affinities for the ATP-binding sites and SH3 domains of SRC and ABL demonstrated the modular nature of inhibitors based on the AGT scaffold. Furthermore, these studies revealed that the interaction between the SH3 domain ligand and the kinase SH3 domain is the major selectivity determinant amongst closely-related tyrosine kinases. Finally, the potency of bivalent inhibitors against distinct phospho-isoforms of SRC was determined. Overall, these results provide insight into how individual ligands can be modified to provide more potent and selective bivalent inhibitors of protein kinases.     

Design, synthesis and in vitro evaluation of novel bivalent S-adenosylmethionine analogues

In optimal cases, bivalent ligands can bind with exceptionally high affinity to their protein targets. However, designing optimised linkers, that orient the two binding groups perfectly, is challenging, and yet crucial in both fragment-based ligand design and in the discovery of bisubstrate enzyme inhibitors. To further our understanding of linker design, a series of novel bivalent S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) analogues were designed with the aim of interacting with the MetJ dimer in a bivalent sense (1:1 ligand/MetJ dimer). A range of ligands was synthesised and analyzed for ability to promote binding of the Escherichia coli methionine repressor, MetJ, to its operator DNA. Binding of bivalent SAM analogues to the MetJ homodimer in the presence of operator DNA was evaluated by fluorescence anisotropy and the effect of linker length and structure was investigated. The most effective bivalent ligand identified had a flexible linker, and promoted the DNA-protein interaction at 21-times lower concentration than the corresponding monovalent control compound.     

Staurosporine tethered peptide ligands that target cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA): Optimization and selectivity profiling

We have recently developed a fragment based selection strategy for targeting kinases, where a small molecule warhead can be non-covalently tethered to a phage-displayed library of peptides. This approach was applied to the conversion of the promiscuous kinase inhibitor, staurosporine, into a potent bivalent ligand for cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA). Herein we report a systematic evaluation of this new bivalent ligand (BL); (a) Lineweaver–Burke analysis revealed that the BL, unlike substrate-based bivalent kinase inhibitors, displayed non-competitive inhibition with respect to the peptide substrate, suggesting an allosteric mechanism of action; (b) linker optimization of the BL, afforded one of the most potent, sub-nanomolar, inhibitors of PKA reported to date; (c) the BL was found to be modular, where attachment of active site targeted small molecule warheads in lieu of staurosporine could achieve similar gains in affinity; and (d) profiling studies of both the staurosporine derivative and the BL (amide isostere) against a panel of 90 kinases revealed almost unique enhancement in selectivity against PKA (>5-fold) compared to the starting staurosporine derivative. These combined results provide new insights for BL discovery, which has the potential to provide guidance toward the development of kinase selective reagents while uncovering new allosteric sites on kinases for therapeutic targeting.     

Engineered bivalent ligands to bias ErbB receptor-mediated signaling and phenotypes

The ErbB receptor family is dysregulated in many cancers, and its therapeutic manipulation by targeted antibodies and kinase inhibitors has resulted in effective chemotherapies. However, many malignancies remain refractory to current interventions. We describe a new approach that directs ErbB receptor interactions, resulting in biased signaling and phenotypes. Due to known receptor-ligand affinities and the necessity of ErbB receptors to dimerize to signal, bivalent ligands, formed by the synthetic linkage of two neuregulin-1β (NRG) moieties, two epidermal growth factor (EGF) moieties, or an EGF and a NRG moiety, can potentially drive homotypic receptor interactions and diminish formation of HER2-containing heterodimers, which are implicated in many malignancies and are a prevalent outcome of stimulation by native, monovalent EGF, or NRG. We demonstrate the therapeutic potential of this approach by showing that bivalent NRG (NN) can bias signaling in HER3-expressing cancer cells, resulting in some cases in decreased migration, inhibited proliferation, and increased apoptosis, whereas native NRG stimulation increased the malignant potential of the same cells. Hence, this new approach may have therapeutic relevance in ovarian, breast, lung, and other cancers in which HER3 has been implicated.     

A convenient procedure for the synthesis of nonsymmetrical bivalent selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors using polymer-supported reagents

A convenient synthesis of nonsymmetrical bivalent inhibitors of the serotonin transporter is described. The synthesis utilizes polymer-supported reagents that allow for rapid access to novel bivalent ligands without the need for isolation or purification of synthetic intermediates.     

Probing the topological tolerance of multimeric protein interactions: evaluation of an estrogen/synthetic ligand for FK506 binding protein conjugate

Bivalent small molecules composed of a targeting element and an element that recruits endogenous proteins have been shown to block protein-protein interactions in some systems. We have attempted to apply such an approach to disrupt the interaction of the estrogen receptor α with either its associated coactivators or its dimerization partner (i.e., another estrogen receptor). We show here that a conjugate capable of simultaneously binding both the estrogen receptor and a recruited protein (FK506 Binding Protein 12 kDa) is, however, incapable of disrupting the multimeric estrogen receptor dimer/coactivator complex both in vitro and in cell-based reporter gene assays. We postulate why it may not be possible to disrupt this particular protein-protein complex-as well as other systems having high topological tolerance-with such bivalent inhibitors.     

Bivalent inhibitors of protein kinases

Abstract

Protein kinases are key players in a large number of cellular signaling pathways. Dysregulated kinase activity has been implicated in a number of diseases, and members of this enzyme family are of therapeutic interest. However, due to the fact that most inhibitors interact with the highly conserved ATP-binding sites of kinases, it is a significant challenge to develop pharmacological agents that target only one of the greater than 500 kinases present in humans. A potential solution to this problem is the development of bisubstrate and bivalent kinase inhibitors, in which an active site-directed moiety is tethered to another ligand that targets a location outside of the ATP-binding cleft. Because kinase signaling specificity is modulated by regions outside of the ATP-binding site, strategies that exploit these interactions have the potential to provide reagents with high target selectivity. This review highlights examples of kinase interaction sites that can potentially be exploited by bisubstrate and bivalent inhibitors. Furthermore, an overview of efforts to target these interactions with bisubstrate and bivalent inhibitors is provided. Finally, several examples of the successful application of these reagents in a cellular setting are described.     

Transforming bivalent ligands into retractable enzyme inhibitors through polypeptide-protein interactions

The concept of bivalent polypeptides with controllable flexible linkers is demonstrated through the design of a new generation of 'antidote'-reversible inhibitors of thrombin. These molecules contain two binding moieties, each of which in isolation has only a moderate affinity of binding, which are linked together by a flexible peptide bridge. We show that activities of the potent bivalent inhibitors of thrombin can be reversed by the specific, but much weaker, binding of the linker moiety to protein 'antidotes'.     

Influence of synthetic peptide inhibitors on the thermal stability of thermitase, a serine proteinase from Thermoactinomyces vulgaris

The influence of chloromethyl ketones and methyl ketones of N-acylated peptides on the thermal denaturation of thermitase was investigated in the presence and the absence of calcium ions. The chloromethyl ketone derivatives are known to react irreversibly with the enzyme, whereas the corresponding methyl ketones are reversible inhibitors. Both groups of inhibitors offer a broad variety of affinity constants. The irreversible inhibition of thermitase causes a marked stabilization against thermal denaturation. On the other hand, the enzyme stability is not influenced by the binding of reversible inhibitors. The stabilizing effect of calcium ions is not dependent on the inhibitor binding. The importance of bivalent interaction (bridge formation) in the active site region of the enzyme for its thermal stability is discussed.     

Synthetic bivalent CD4-mimetic miniproteins show enhanced anti-HIV activity over the monovalent miniprotein

HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120 is displayed as a trimeric complex on the surface of virion and infected T-cells, making it a typical multivalent target. This paper describes the design and synthesis of bivalent CD4-mimetic miniproteins to target the conserved CD4-binding pockets in the trimeric gp120. Using miniprotein CD4M9 as the model inhibitor, we created bivalent inhibitors in which two CD4M9 moieties were tethered by a spacer of varied length and evaluated their anti-HIV activity using a cell culture assay. The synthetic bivalent miniproteins showed 5-21-fold enhancement in anti-HIV activity over the monovalent miniprotein. The activity enhancement is dependent on the length of the spacer. The study suggests that targeting the oligomeric gp120 complex by novel multivalent ligands offers a valuable strategy for developing highly specific and effective HIV entry inhibitors.     

Building homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer assays for characterization of bivalent inhibitors of an inhibitor of apoptosis protein target

XIAP (X-chromosome-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein) is a central apoptosis regulator that blocks cell death by inhibiting caspase-3, caspase-7, and caspase-9 via binding interactions with the XIAP BIR2 and BIR3 domains (where BIR is baculovirus IAP repeat). Smac protein, in its dimeric form, effectively antagonizes XIAP by concurrently targeting both its BIR2 and BIR3 domains. Here we describe the development of highly sensitive homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (HTRF) assays to measure binding affinities of potent bivalent peptidomimetic inhibitors of XIAP. Our results indicate that these assays can differentiate Smac-mimetic inhibitors with a wide range of binding affinities down to the picomolar range. Furthermore, we demonstrate the utility of these fluorescent tools for characterization of inhibitor off-rates, which as a crucial determinant of target engagement and cellular potency is another important parameter to guide optimization in a structure-based drug discovery effort. Our study also explores how increased inhibitor valency can lead to enhanced potency at multimeric proteins such as IAP.     

Peptidomimetic modification improves cell permeation of bivalent farnesyltransferase inhibitors

Bivalent enzyme inhibitors, in which a surface binding module is linked to an active site binding module through a spacer, are a robust approach for site-selectively delivering a minimally-sized agent to a protein surface to regulate its functions, such as protein–protein interactions (PPIs). Previous research revealed that these agents effectively disrupt the interaction between farnesyltransferase (FTase) and the C-terminal region of K-Ras4B protein. However, the whole cell activity of these peptide-based agents is limited due to their low membrane permeability. In this study, we tested a peptidomimetic modification of these bivalent agents using a previously developed inhibitor, FTI-249, and evaluated their cell permeability and biological activity in cells. Confocal cell imaging using fluorescently-labeled agents showed that the peptidomimetic 3-BODIPY penetrated cells, while the peptide-based 1-BODIPY did not. Cell-based evaluation demonstrated that peptidomimetic 3 at a concentration of 100 μM inhibited HDJ-2 processing in cells, indicating that this peptidomimetic modification improves cell permeability, thus leading to enhanced whole cell activity of the bivalent compounds.     

Bivalent inhibitor of the N-end rule pathway.

The N-end rule relates the in vivo half-life of a protein to the identity of its N-terminal residue. Ubr1p, the recognition (E3) component of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae N-end rule pathway, contains at least two substrate-binding sites. The type 1 site is specific for N-terminal basic residues Arg, Lys, and His. The type 2 site is specific for N-terminal bulky hydrophobic residues Phe, Leu, Trp, Tyr, and Ile. Previous work has shown that dipeptides bearing either type 1 or type 2 N-terminal residues act as weak but specific inhibitors of the N-end rule pathway. We took advantage of the two-site architecture of Ubr1p to explore the feasibility of bivalent N-end rule inhibitors, whose expected higher efficacy would result from higher affinity of the cooperative (bivalent) binding to Ubr1p. The inhibitor comprised mixed tetramers of beta-galactosidase that bore both N-terminal Arg (type 1 residue) and N-terminal Leu (type 2 residue) but that were resistant to proteolysis in vivo. Expression of these constructs in S. cerevisiae inhibited the N-end rule pathway much more strongly than the expression of otherwise identical beta-galactosidase tetramers whose N-terminal residues were exclusively Arg or exclusively Leu. In addition to demonstrating spatial proximity between the type 1 and type 2 substrate-binding sites of Ubr1p, these results provide a route to high affinity inhibitors of the N-end rule pathway.     

Bivalent SIRT1 inhibitors

In the current study, bivalent compounds 1–17 constructed by covalently linking the ?-amino group of lysine in a tripeptidic scaffold to a functionality via a linker were prepared and examined for their inhibitory potencies against SIRT1, a prototypical member of the β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (β-NAD⁺)-dependent sirtuin family of protein N^ε-acyl-lysine deacylases. A few of them were found to be stronger SIRT1 inhibitors than the N^?-acetyl-lysine-containing monovalent counterparts 18 and 19. As exemplified with compounds 6 and 18, a bivalent SIRT1 inhibitor could exhibit a greater degree of inhibitory selectivity among SIRT1/2/3 than the corresponding monovalent counterpart. This study has laid a foundation for the future development of superior bivalent inhibitors against the (patho)physiologically and therapeutically important sirtuin family of deacylase enzymes.     

Kinetic analysis of the binding of monomeric and dimeric ephrins to Eph receptors: correlation to function in a growth cone collapse assay

Eph receptors and ephrins play important roles in regulating cell migration and positioning during both normal and oncogenic tissue development. Using a surface plasma resonance (SPR) biosensor, we examined the binding kinetics of representative monomeric and dimeric ephrins to their corresponding Eph receptors and correlated the apparent binding affinity with their functional activity in a neuronal growth cone collapse assay. Our results indicate that the Eph receptor binding of dimeric ephrins, formed through fusion with disulfide-linked Fc fragments, is best described using a bivalent analyte model as a two-step process involving an initial monovalent 2:1 binding followed by a second bivalent 2:2 binding. The bivalent binding dramatically decreases the apparent dissociation rate constants with little effect on the initial association rate constants, resulting in a 30- to 6000-fold decrease in apparent equilibrium dissociation constants for the binding of dimeric ephrins to Eph receptors relative to their monomeric counterparts. Interestingly, the change was more prominent in the A-class ephrin/Eph interactions than in the B-class of ephrins to Eph receptors. The increase in apparent binding affinities correlated well with increased activation of Eph receptors and the resulting growth cone collapse. Our kinetic analysis and correlation of binding affinity with function helped us better understand the interactions between ephrins and Eph receptors and should be useful in the design of inhibitors that interfere with the interactions.     

Structure-function relationships of hirulog peptide interactions with thrombin.

Using hirudin as a model, a novel class of bivalent thrombin inhibitors has been designed and characterized (Maraganore et al. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 7095-7101). These peptides, designated 'hirulogs', interact with both thrombin's catalytic center and its anion-binding exosite for fibrinogen recognition. In order to investigate structure-activity relationships in hirulog peptides, a number of peptide and peptidomimetic derivatives with alterations in catalytic-site binding and anion-binding exosite binding moieties were prepared. Replacements or modifications in the catalytic site and exosite binding moieties were achieved with the consequences of maintaining or improving antithrombin activity. In addition to showing improved affinity for thrombin, some derivatives with Ki's in the sub-nanomolar range showed increased anticoagulant activities. These findings highlight the versatility of hirulog peptides in their bivalent interactions with thrombin.     

Towards the development of antimicrobial drugs acting by inhibition of pathogen attachment to host cells: a need for polyvalency

The development of inhibitors of microbial attachment to target cells has been proposed recently as a possible novel approach to antimicrobial chemoprophylaxis and treatment. In this paper an attempt is made to contend that such artificial inhibitors must be polyvalent, i.e. capable of binding to the pathogen or its target by multiple bonds.     

Novel class of bivalent glutathione S-transferase inhibitors

Exploiting the principle of bivalent binding, we have designed symmetrical, bifunctional inhibitors to simultaneously occupy both active sites of cytosolic glutathione S-transferase, with enhanced specificity for the P1-1 isoform. We have prepared two series of compounds that differ in their binding domains-the first is a series of bis-glutathione conjugates, and the second is a series of compounds each possessing two equivalents of Uniblue A, an analogue of Cibacron Blue. For each series, a monofunctional reference compound was also prepared to determine the relative advantage of the bivalent inhibitors. Within each series, the most potent inhibitors exhibited IC(50) values 2 orders of magnitude lower than the relevant reference compounds. Moreover, within the bis-glutathionyl series, a 10-fold increase in selectivity was achieved for GST P1-1 over the A1-1 isoform. Isothermal titration calorimetry with a representative bis-glutathione conjugate and a monofunctional reference compound indicates that the bivalent inhibitor exhibits the expected increase in intrinsic affinity and decrease in stoichiometry relative to the monofunctional compound, supporting the overall design strategy.     

Design and characterization of bivalent Smac-based peptides as antagonists of XIAP and development and validation of a fluorescence polarization assay for XIAP containing both BIR2 and BIR3 domains

XIAP (X-chromosome-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein) is an inhibitor of apoptosis by binding to and inhibition of caspase-3 and caspase-7 through its BIR2 domain and caspase-9 through its BIR3 domain. Smac (second mitochondria-derived activator of caspases) protein is an endogenous antagonist of XIAP. Smac forms a dimer and concurrently binds both the BIR2 and BIR3 domains in XIAP, functioning as a highly efficient and potent cellular inhibitor of XIAP. In this article, we have designed and synthesized a bivalent Smac-based ligand (Smac-1) and its fluorescent labeled analogue (Smac-1F) and characterized their interaction with different constructs of XIAP. Our study demonstrates that bivalent Smac-based ligands bind concurrently to both the BIR2 and BIR3 domains of XIAP and are more than 500 times more potent than the corresponding monovalent Smac-based ligands. Bivalent Smac-based ligands also function as much more potent antagonists of XIAP than do the corresponding monovalent Smac-based ligands in cell-free functional assays. Using Smac-1F and XIAP containing both BIR2 and BIR3 domains, we also developed and validated a new fluorescence polarization-based assay. Hence, our designed bivalent Smac-based peptides mimic the mode of dimeric Smac protein in their interaction with XIAP containing both BIR2 and BIR3 domains and achieve extremely high potency in binding and functional assays. Our study provides new insights into the mode of action of bivalent Smac ligands targeting XIAP and a basis for the design and development of cell-permeable, bivalent Smac mimetics.